Union of Concerned Scientists

How Does Uneconomic Coal Generation Impact the Grid? A Discussion with Regulators

On November 19th I had the privilege to sit on a panel of industry luminaries discussing an issue I’ve been researching for some time: Coal-fired power plants that operate uneconomically in wholesale markets.

Wholesale power markets all have rules in place that are designed to prevent power plants from running uneconomically. However, some power plant operators use those same market rules to bypass the market decision-making process through a process known as “self-committing.” Self-committing coal-fired power plants allow those plants to operate out of “merit-order” (from least cost to highest cost) and can result in serious market distortion and inflated consumer costs.

Here are some of my past blogs on the subject:

  • Presenting the results of a national analysis of the issue [link]
  • Discussion how self-committing coal can distort the market [link]
  • Laying out a few possible solutions to the problem [link]
  • Below is a video of my presentation which includes a crash course on uneconomic self-committing coal and includes the preliminary results of our latest and ongoing research on how it affects the MISO system.

See video of the panel conversation here.

My slides can be found here.

As Commissioner Freeman astutely pointed out, “this is a leadership issue.” With more commissioners now aware of the issue, I’m looking forward to seeing more state regulators taking a leadership role on self-committing coal-fired power plants.

Photo: PDTillman/Wikimedia Commons

More from Union of Concerned Scientists

Union of Concerned Scientists3 min readAmerican Government
Will the EPA Strengthen Ethylene Oxide Standards Without Outside Interference?
Industry is seeking to weaken EPA's proposed new rule regulating ethylene oxide emissions despite the science-based evidence of harm from long-term exposure.
Union of Concerned Scientists4 min read
Growing Shade Equity, One Tree at a Time
Community-engaged science is helping provide shade equity—equal access to the cooling benefits of tree cover—to residents of Los Angeles.
Union of Concerned Scientists3 min readAmerican Government
Show Me the (Agriculture Appropriations) Money
The agriculture appropriations bill that was recently signed into law is a mix of good and bad. We need to push Congress to do better in its funding for next year.

Related