Sunteți pe pagina 1din 35

APPENDIX C

EXAMPLE PROBLEMS

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

Includes example problems dealing with the following:

1. Cellular Cofferdam on Rock

2. Cellular Retaining Wall on Sand

3. Cellular Retaining Wall on Clay

C-1

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

Cellular Cofferdam on Rock

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 Cellular Cofferdam on Rock DESIGN DATA Dia of cell, D =

DESIGN DATA

Dia of cell,

D = 63.67' ; effective width, B = 53.06'

Guaranteed piling interlock strength, tg = 16,000 PLI

Cell Fill, Overburden and Berm Properties:

= 30°,tg = 16,000 PLI Cell Fill, Overburden and Berm Properties: tan = 0.577 110 pcf (moist)

tan

PLI Cell Fill, Overburden and Berm Properties: = 30°, tan = 0.577 110 pcf (moist) =

= 0.577

110 pcf (moist)=

=

= 72.5 pcf (submerged)

=

72.5 pcf (submerged)

PLI Cell Fill, Overburden and Berm Properties: = 30°, tan = 0.577 110 pcf (moist) =
PLI Cell Fill, Overburden and Berm Properties: = 30°, tan = 0.577 110 pcf (moist) =
PLI Cell Fill, Overburden and Berm Properties: = 30°, tan = 0.577 110 pcf (moist) =

C-2

Rock and Clay Seam Properties:

Rock and Clay Seam Properties: c = 750 psf Coefficient of Friction: Soil on rock, tan

c = 750 psf

Coefficient of Friction:

Soil on rock,

tan

Steel on steel at interlocks,

LOADING

Soil on rock, tan Steel on steel at interlocks, LOADING = 0.50 f = 0 .

= 0.50

f = 0.30

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

Service Condition - Water to top of cell; cell fill saturated to top of berm; berm saturated

1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 Service Condition - Water to top of cell; cell fill saturated to

C-3

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

SLIDING STABILITY

El 557 w/o Berm

W

H

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 SLIDING STABILITY El 557 w/o Berm W H C-4

C-4

El 557 w/Berm

El 557 w/Berm EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 Sliding resistance of berm on rock = 170.5(0.50)

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

Sliding resistance of berm on rock = 170.5(0.50) = 85.3 k

Passive resistance of berm, P R = l/2(6.09)(28) = 85.3 k

Passive failure of berm will occur concurrent w/sliding of entire berm on rock.

berm will occur concurrent w/sliding of entire berm on rock. El 542 w 1 w 2

El 542

w 1

w 2

w 3

w B

w R

v 1

v

2

P

a

p

W

W

H

See Page 2

84.6

"

 

55.8

107.7

107.7

See above

170.5

180.06 x 15 x 0.155

418.6

0.94 x 180.06

-169.3

1/2 x 3.56 x 180.06

-320.5

 
 

See Page 2

2.7

1/2 x 4.50 x 72

16l.O

 

347.4

k

  347.4 k
1/2 x 3.56 x 180.06 -320.5   See Page 2 2.7 1/2 x 4.50 x 72

C-5

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

OVERTURNING STABILITY

El 557

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 OVERTURNING STABILITY El 557 VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE C-6

VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 OVERTURNING STABILITY El 557 VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE C-6
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 OVERTURNING STABILITY El 557 VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE C-6

C-6

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL PLANE ON INBOARD CENTER LINE OF CELL SHEETING Point

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL PLANE ON INBOARD CENTER LINE OF CELL SHEETING Point of

VERTICAL PLANE ON

INBOARD

CENTER LINE OF CELL

SHEETING

Point of Fixity:

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL PLANE ON INBOARD CENTER LINE OF CELL SHEETING Point of

C-7

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

HORIZONTAL SHEAR RESISTANCE

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 HORIZONTAL SHEAR RESISTANCE Assume entire cell saturated. C = B tan

Assume entire cell saturated.

C = B tan

C = B tan = 30.5'

= 30.5'

a = H-c

= 26.5'

89 HORIZONTAL SHEAR RESISTANCE Assume entire cell saturated. C = B tan = 30.5' a =

C-8

INTERLOCK TENSION

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

INTERLOCK TENSION EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 C-9
INTERLOCK TENSION EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 C-9

C-9

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

HANSEN'S METHOD

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 HANSEN'S METHOD C-10

C-10

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 c-11

c-11

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

Summary

*

*

*

*

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 Summary * * * * 1 2 . 5 1 0

1 2.5

10

42

5.0

10.0

43

19.7

4,575

2,463

1.86

2 2.0

14

44

11.5

10.0

33

20.0

5,130

3,141

1.63

3 1.5

22

52

20.5

7.0

30

20.0

6,553

4,078

1.61

4 1.0

36

64

35.0

0.5

20

20.4

9,208

5,589

1.65

* Scaled value.

C-12

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

Cellular Retaining Wall on Sand

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 Cellular Retaining Wall on Sand DESIGN DATA Dia of cell, D

DESIGN DATA

Dia of cell, D = 52.52' ; effective width,

Guaranteed piling interlock strength, tg = 16,000 PLI

B = 43.99'

Cell Fill, Backfill, and Overburden Properties:

g = 1 6 , 0 0 0 P L I B = 4 3 .

C-13

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

Coefficient of Friction:

Soil on steel,

tan

29 Sept 89 Coefficient of Friction: Soil on steel, t a n = 0 . 4

= 0.40

Steel on steel at interlocks, f = 0.30

LOADING

Service Condition - Cell fill and backfill both saturated to el 500. Pool at el 480.

at interlocks, f = 0.30 LOADING Service Condition - Cell fill and backfill both saturated to

C-14

VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL PLAN ON CENTER LINE OF CELL Point
VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL PLAN ON CENTER LINE OF CELL Point

VERTICAL PLAN ON CENTER LINE OF CELL

Point of Fixity:

SHEAR RESISTANCE EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL PLAN ON CENTER LINE OF CELL Point of

OUTBOARD

SHEETING

SHEAR RESISTANCE EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL PLAN ON CENTER LINE OF CELL Point of

C-15

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 HORIZONTAL SHEAR RESISTANCE C-16

HORIZONTAL SHEAR RESISTANCE

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 HORIZONTAL SHEAR RESISTANCE C-16
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 HORIZONTAL SHEAR RESISTANCE C-16

C-16

INTERLOCK TENSION

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

INTERLOCK TENSION EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 PULLOUT RESISTANCE OF LAND FACE SHEETS C-17
INTERLOCK TENSION EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 PULLOUT RESISTANCE OF LAND FACE SHEETS C-17

PULLOUT RESISTANCE OF LAND FACE SHEETS

INTERLOCK TENSION EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 PULLOUT RESISTANCE OF LAND FACE SHEETS C-17

C-17

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

PENETRATION RESISTANCE OF OUTBOARD SHEETS

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 PENETRATION RESISTANCE OF OUTBOARD SHEETS BEARING CAPACITY @ TOE C-18
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 PENETRATION RESISTANCE OF OUTBOARD SHEETS BEARING CAPACITY @ TOE C-18

BEARING CAPACITY @ TOE

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 PENETRATION RESISTANCE OF OUTBOARD SHEETS BEARING CAPACITY @ TOE C-18

C-18

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE (Schroeder-Maitland)

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE (Schroeder-Maitland) C-19
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE (Schroeder-Maitland) C-19
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE (Schroeder-Maitland) C-19
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE (Schroeder-Maitland) C-19

C-19

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

HANSEN'S METHOD

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 HANSEN'S METHOD C-20
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 HANSEN'S METHOD C-20

C-20

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 (1) Approximate. C-21

(1) Approximate.

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 (1) Approximate. C-21

C-21

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

Summary

*

*

*

*

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 Summary * * * * 1 2.5 9.0 35.5 4.5 8.0

1 2.5

9.0

35.5

4.5

8.0

29

11.12

5,675

5,194

1.09

2 2.0

12.5

39.5

9.5

8.0

28

11.31

6,544

6,144

1.06

3 1.5

18.0

42.5

16.0

6.0

20

11.71

8,141

7,386

1.10

4 1.0

29.5

52.5

29.5

1.0

12

12.19

11,550

9,964

1.16

* Scaled value.

 
 

C-22

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 C-23
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 C-23

C-23

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 (1) Approximate. Summary * * * * 1 2.5 9.0 35.5

(1) Approximate.

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 (1) Approximate. Summary * * * * 1 2.5 9.0 35.5

Summary

*

*

*

*

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 (1) Approximate. Summary * * * * 1 2.5 9.0 35.5

1 2.5

9.0

35.5

4.5

8.0

29

13.90

4,946

3,470

1.42

2 2.0

12.5

39.5

9.5

8.0

28

13.86

4,115

2,553

1.61

3 1.5

18.0

42.5

16.0

6.0

20

13.57

3,841

1,810

2.12

4 1.0

29.5

52.5

29.5

1.0

12

13.27

5,889

2,625

2.24

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

Cellular Retaining Wall on Clay

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 Cellular Retaining Wall on Clay DESIGN DATA Dia of cell, D

DESIGN DATA

Dia of cell, D = 66.85' ; effective width, B = 58.57'

Guaranteed piling interlock strength, tg = 16,000 PLI

Cell Fill and Backfill Properties (sand and gravel)

58.57' Guaranteed piling interlock strength, tg = 16,000 PLI Cell Fill and Backfill Properties (sand and

C-25

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

Overburden Properties (medium stiff clay)

29 Sept 89 Overburden Properties (medium stiff clay) Coefficient of Friction: Soil on steel, tan =

Coefficient of Friction:

Soil on steel, tan

stiff clay) Coefficient of Friction: Soil on steel, tan = 0.40 Steel on steel at interlocks,

= 0.40

Steel on steel at interlocks, f = 0.30

LOADING

Service Condition - Cell fill and backfill both saturated to el 487. Pool at el 480.

at interlocks, f = 0.30 LOADING Service Condition - Cell fill and backfill both saturated to

C-26

VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 C-27
VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 C-27
VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 C-27

C-27

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

HORIZONTAL SHEAR RESISTANCE

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 HORIZONTAL SHEAR RESISTANCE C-28
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 HORIZONTAL SHEAR RESISTANCE C-28

C-28

INTERLOCK TENSION

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

INTERLOCK TENSION EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 PULLOUT RESISTANCE OF LAND FACE SHEETS C-29
INTERLOCK TENSION EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 PULLOUT RESISTANCE OF LAND FACE SHEETS C-29

PULLOUT RESISTANCE OF LAND FACE SHEETS

INTERLOCK TENSION EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 PULLOUT RESISTANCE OF LAND FACE SHEETS C-29

C-29

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

BEARING CAPACITY

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 BEARING CAPACITY C-30

C-30

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE (Schroeder-Maitland)

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE (Schroeder-Maitland) C-31
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE (Schroeder-Maitland) C-31
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 VERTICAL SHEAR RESISTANCE (Schroeder-Maitland) C-31

C-31

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

HANSEN’S METHOD

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 HANSEN’S METHOD C-32

C-32

Summary

Summary EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 45 7,084 3,459 2.05 60 3,920 2,488 1.58 70 2,985
Summary EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 45 7,084 3,459 2.05 60 3,920 2,488 1.58 70 2,985

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

Summary EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 45 7,084 3,459 2.05 60 3,920 2,488 1.58 70 2,985

45

7,084

3,459

2.05

60

3,920

2,488

1.58

70

2,985

1,992

1.50

75

2,645

1,777

1.49

80

2,352

1,567

1.50

85

2,095

1,362

1.54

C-33

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 C-34
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 C-34
EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 C-34

C-34

Summary

Summary EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 FS 45 4,828 1,653 2.92 70 1,316 493 2.67 85
Summary EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89 FS 45 4,828 1,653 2.92 70 1,316 493 2.67 85

EM 1110-2-2503 29 Sept 89

FS

45

4,828

1,653

2.92

70

1,316

493

2.67

85

1,431

757

1.89

C-35