Ad Analysis Group Grading Rubric STEP 4: THE REFLECTIO

a!" #indi$idual%:
Exemplary (A) Most proud moment Very clear explanation of most proud moment. Very thoughtful and honest explanation of ideas for changes. Very clear explanation of most & least effective techniques. Very thoughtful and honest explanation of challenge(s). Very thoughtful and honest explanation of lesson(s). Very thoughtful and honest selfassessment with grade. Very thoughtful and honest assessment of group members with appropriate grades. Responses on Google forms survey have been carefully edited for spelling and grammar errors; almost no errors are visible.

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
Excellent (B) Clear explanation of most proud moment. Proficient (C) Somewhat clear explanation of most proud moment. Needs Improvement Unclear explanation of most proud moment. Unsatisfactory Proud moment not addressed.

Suggestions for improvement

Thoughtful and honest explanation of ideas for changes. Clear explanation of most & least effective techniques.

Somewhat honest explanation of ideas for changes.

Unclear explanation of ideas for changes.

Ideas for changes not addressed.

Most and least effective techniques

Somewhat clear explanation of most & least effective techniques.

Unclear explanation of most & least effective techniques; one might be missing.

Most & least effective techniques not addressed.

Biggest challenge

Thoughtful and honest explanation of challenge(s).

Somewhat honest explanation of at one challenge.

Unclear explanation of challenge.

Challenges not addressed.

Lesson(s) learned

Thoughtful and honest explanation of lesson(s).

Somewhat honest explanation of at one lesson.

Unclear explanation of lesson.

Lessons not addressed.

Contributions of self with grade deserved Contributions of each group member with grade deserved

Thoughtful and honest selfassessment with grade. Thoughtful and honest assessment of group members with appropriate grades.

Somewhat honest selfassessment with vague grade.

Unclear selfassessment; missing a grade.

Self-assessment not addressed.

Somewhat honest assessment of group members with appropriate grades.

Unclear assessment of group members; missing grades or grades inappropriate.

Group members assessments not addressed.

Grammar/ Mechanics

Responses on Google forms survey have been carefully edited for spelling and grammar errors; only a few minor errors are visible.

Responses on Google forms survey need more editing for spelling and grammar errors; some significant errors are visible.

Responses on Google forms survey have not been carefully edited for spelling and grammar errors; parts of responses are unclear.

Responses on Google forms survey have not been carefully edited for spelling and grammar errors; responses are unreadable or incomplete. TOTAL: ____/15

(summative points)