Page 1

ASSA SINGH v MENTRI BESAR, JOHORE

[1969] 2 MLJ 30 Court: MYFC Judges: AZMI LP, ONG HOCK THYE CJ (MALAYA), SUFFIAN AND GILL FJJ AND RAJA AZLAN SHAH J Judgment Date: 17/3/1969

Cases referring to this case Annotations: All Cases Court: ALL COURTS Sort by: Judgment Date (Latest First) Treatment Case Name Citations Referred

Court

Date 8/6/2009

Signal

JAMALUDDIN BIN MO[2009] 4 MLJ 593; [2009] HD RADZI & ORS v MYFC MLJU 432 SIVAKUMAR A CHE HONG YEE v TIMBALAN MENTERI KE[2008] 7 MLJ 642; [2008] SELAMATAN DALAM MYHC MLJU 779 NEGERI, MALAYSIA & ORS KOK WAH KUAN v PUBLIC PROSECUTOR KERAJAAN NEGERI SELANGOR & ORS v SAGONG TASI & ORS [2007] 5 MLJ 174 MYCA

Followed

14/12/2007

Referred

12/6/2007

Referred

[2005] 6 MLJ 289; [2005] MLJU 347; [2005] 5 AMR MYCA 629; [2005] 4 CLJ 169

19/9/2005

Referred

MOHAMAD EZAM BIN MOHD NOR & ORS v [2003] 2 MLJ 364; [2003] MYHC MENTERIDALAM2 CLJ 459 NEGERI & ANOR KAM TECK SOON v TIMBALAN MENTERI [2003] 1 MLJ 321; [2003] DALAM NEGERI 1 AMR 721; [2003] 1 CLJ MALAYSIA & ORS AND 225 OTHER APPEALS MOHAMAD EZAM BIN [2002] 4 MLJ 449; [2002] MOHD NOOR v KETUA 4 AMR 4053; [2002] 4 MYFC POLIS NEGARA & OTHCLJ 309 ER APPEALS PUBLIC PROSECUTOR v SHARMA KUMARI [2000] 6 MLJ 254 MYHC

24/3/2003

Referred

15/11/2002

Referred

9/6/2002

Referred

4/10/2000

Page 2

Referred

DATUK SERI S SAMY VELLU v S NADARAJAH PP v PUNG CHEN CHOON

[2000] 4 MLJ 696

MYHC

22/9/2000

Followed

[1994] 1 MLJ 566

MYSC

17/1/1994

Followed

MOHAMED HABIBULLAH BIN MAHMOOD v [1992] 2 MLJ 793 FARIDAH BTE DATO TALIB TIMBALAN MENTERI HAL EHWAL DALAM [1991] 1 MLJ 350 NEGERI, MALAYSIA & ORS v LIAU NYUN FUI LIAU NYUN FUI v TIMBALAN MENTERI HAL EHWAL DALAM [1990] 2 MLJ 240 NEGERI, MALAYSIA & ORS TUN DATO HAJI MOHAMED SALLEH BIN ABAS v TAN SRI DATO [1988] 3 MLJ 149 ABDUL HAMID BIN OMAR & ORS GS DAVID v GOVERNMENT OF MALAYSIA & [1988] 1 MLJ 38 ORS TIMBALAN MENTERI HAL EHWAL DALAM NEGERI MALAYSIA & ORS v CHEOW SIONG CHIN

MYSC

15/12/1992

Referred

MYSC

12/10/1990

Referred

MYHC

18/12/1989

Followed

MYSC

22/7/1988

Referred

MYOCJ 15/6/1987

Referred

[1988] 1 MLJ 432

MYSC

15/5/1987

Referred

CHEOW SIONG CHIN v TIMBALAN MENTERI HAL EHWAL DALAM [1986] 2 MLJ 235 NEGERI, MALAYSIA & ORS YIT HON KIT v MINISTER OF HOME AFFAIRS, MALAYSIA & ANOR

MYOCJ 21/5/1986

Referred

[1988] 2 MLJ 638

MYOCJ 6/2/1986

Referred

RAMASAMY A/L SHANMUGAM v STATE GOVERNMENT OF [1986] 2 MLJ 188 PENANG & GOVERNMENT OF MALAYSIA

MYSC

20/1/1986

Page 3

Referred

PP v PARAM CUMARASWAMY

[1986] 1 MLJ 512

MYOCJ 3/1/1986

Referred

MAJLIS PERBANDARAN PULAU PIN[1979] 2 MLJ 127 ANG v BOEY SIEW THAN GOVERNMENT OF MALAYSIA & ORS v LOH WAI KONG LOH KOOI CHOON v GOVERNMENT OF MALAYSIA RE DATUK JAMES WONG KIM MIN; MINISTER OF HOME AFFAIRS, MALAYSIA & ORS [1979] 2 MLJ 33

MYFC

21/3/1979

Referred

MYFC

13/2/1979

Referred

[1977] 2 MLJ 187

MYFC

7/6/1977

Referred

[1976] 2 MLJ 245

MYFC

24/8/1976

Referred

ZAINAB BINTI OTHMAN v SUPERINTENDENT OF PRISON, PU[1975] 2 MLJ 221 LAU JEREJAK, PENANG RE DATUK JAMES WONG KIM MIN OSMAN BIN MAT ISA & ORS v SUPERINTENDENT OF PRISON, ALOR STAR & ANOR RAMLI BIN SALLEH v INSPECTOR YAHYA BIN HASHIM [1975] 2 MLJ 244

MYFC

14/6/1975

Referred

MYOCJ 19/4/1975

Referred

[1974] 1 MLJ 189

MYOCJ 27/4/1974

Referred

[1973] 1 MLJ 54

MYOCR 19/8/1972 J

Cases considered by this case Annotations: All CasesCourt: ALL COURTS Sort by: Judgment Date (Latest First) Treatment Case Name Citations AMINAH v SUPERINTENDENT OF PRISON, PENGKALAN CHEPA, KELANTAN SURINDER SINGH KANDA v GOVERNMENT OF THE FEDERATION OF MALAYA

Court

Date

Signal

Referred

[1968] 1 MLJ 92

MYOCJ 28/10/1967

Referred

[1962] MLJ 169

MYPC

2/4/1962

Page 4

Referred

CHIA KHIN SZE v MENTRI BESAR, SELANGOR KESHAVAN MADHAVA MENON v STATE OF BOMBAY

[1958] MLJ 105

MYOCJ 11/4/1958

Referred

[1951] SCR 228

Referred

LOCAL GOVERNMENT [1915] AC 120 BOARD v ARIDGE

EWCA

Referred

MUNGONI v ATTOR[1960] 2 WLR 389; [1960] NEY-GENERAL OF AC 336 NORTHERN RHODESIA STATE OF BOMBAY v SHIVBALAK [1965] 1 SCR 211 -

Referred

Catchwords & Digest

Preventive Detention -- Detention order -- Restricted Residence Enactment (FMS Cap 39) -- Detention under Restricted Residence Enactment (FMS Cap 39) -- Pre-Mederka law inconsistent with Constitution -Modification to make it consistent with Constitution -- Delegation of Minister's powers Constitutional Law -- Constitution -- Pre-Merdeka law -- Validity of inconsistent pre-Merdeka statute -Restricted Residence Enactment