Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Published by The Brechner Center for Freedom of Information College of Journalism and Communications University of Florida
September 2005
council meeting.
after a city
Federal officials argue against
disclosing hurricane records
The complaint asserted that Bennett,
councilman Fred Miller and former
Mayor Eloise Taylor were all present and
discussed government business in FORT MYERS – Attorneys for the the 2004 hurricanes.
violation of the state’s Sunshine Law. federal government are arguing that The federal government has filed a
The Sunshine Law prohibits records maintained by the Federal motion for summary judgment, requesting
government officials from meeting Emergency Management that U.S. District Court Judge
privately to discuss public business, but
it does allow social gatherings.
Agency are not of interest
to members of the public. ACCESS John. E. Steele rule in its favor.
Such a ruling would allow the
Investigators determined that the
three officials talked about numerous
This comes in response
to a lawsuit by three RECORDS hurricane records to remain
undisclosed.
subjects, including the weather and Gannett newspapers, The The newspapers have argued
baseball. Fort Myers News-Press, Florida Today the information is of public interest and
However, the investigation concluded and the Pensacola News-Journal, seeking citizens have a right to learn how the
that no city business was discussed at access to the records. government is spending its money.
the dinner gathering, and therefore, the The newspapers argued that the Additionally, they believe the files should
officials were not in violation of the records contain information related to be released in accordance with the federal
Sunshine Law. disaster assistance given in response to Freedom of Information Act.
ACCESS RECORDS CONTINUED
NYC officials release documents detailing Sept. 11
NEW YORK CITY – City officials The documents include about 15 Earlier this year, the state’s highest court
have released thousands of documents hours of audio recordings and more than ruled that some, but not all, of the records
maintained by the fire department 12,000 pages of transcribed firefighter should be made public.
regarding the September 11th terrorist testimony taken after the event. Records released previously suggest that
attacks after a three-year court battle. The newspaper sued under the federal some of the more than 340 firefighter
The New York Times filed the lawsuit, Freedom of Information Act after the city casualties could have been prevented with
which was supported by the relatives of refused to disclose the records it better communication among emergency
fallen firefighters. maintained as a part of its investigation. services groups.
SECRECY
Report concludes costs of secrecy skyrocketing
WASHINGTON – The federal Some of the increase in cost can likely The report attributes part of the increase
government classified more than 15.5 be attributed to the ability of federal in secrecy classifications to the increased
million documents during the last year, agency heads to classify information number of officials who have the power to
according to a report issued by the under vague labels such as “sensitive classify documents.
federal Information Security Oversight security information.” Since the 2001 terrorist attacks, President
Office. “I’ve seen information that was George W. Bush has given classification
The increasing secrecy, driven by classified that I’ve also seen published in power to the heads of the Environmental
fears of terrorism after the September third-grade textbooks,” said J. William Protection Agency, the Department of
2001 attacks, cost taxpayers an Leonard, who heads the Information Agriculture and the Department of Health
estimated $7.2 billion last year. Security Oversight Office. and Human Services.
BROADCASTING
Legislation would reinstate Fairness Doctrine
WASHINGTON – U.S. Rep. Maurice reasonable time to allow for conflicting that it restricted freedom of expression and
Hinchey (D-N.Y.) introduced a bill that perspectives to discuss issues of public led to less discussion of public issues.
would require broadcasters to devote air importance. Another provision in the bill seeks to
time to all sides of controversial issues. In 1987, the Federal Communications limit the number of stations that a media
The legislation, which would restore Commission repealed the Fairness entity can own in a single market.
the Fairness Doctrine as it was once Doctrine, which was initially intended to Hinchey sponsored similar legislation in
called, is pending in the House of promote the broadcasting of diverse 2004, but that bill never made it out of
Representatives. views. Opponents of the policy argued committee.
Hinchey’s bill, called the Media
Ownership Reform Act of 2005, mandates
that broadcast licensees provide CENSORSHIP
DECISIONS Judge rules Florida high school’s
ON FILE distribution policy unconstitutional
Copies of case opinions, Florida FORT MYERS – A Lee County high opinion that the school board policy used to
Attorney General opinions, or school student plans to appeal a federal prevent her pamphleteering was
legislation reported in any issue as court decision denying her claim that the unconstitutional because of a requirement
“on file” may be obtained upon Lee County School Board violated her that “no advertisement shall include
request from the Brechner Center for First Amendment rights by refusing to political, religious or organizational
allow her to distribute anti-abortion symbols.”
Freedom of Information, College of
literature. Because the court found that the nature
Journalism and Communications, The court ruled against Michelle of the literature could cause disruption, it
3208 Weimer Hall, P.O. Box 118400, Heinkel, who was denied permission in ruled against Heinkel’s First Amendment
University of Florida, Gainesville, April 2003 to circulate the pamphlets in claim.
FL 32611-8400, (352) 392-2273. her middle school. Her attorney plans to appeal to the U.S.
However, the federal court noted in its Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit.