85/95 Kristin Foster 5-5-14

UNC Center for Urban Education

Updated 2/20/2014
Appendix J

EDSE 328 329 Observation/Self Reflection Rubrics
(to be used by the Field Experience Instructors when observing Teacher Candidate lesson plans)

EDSE 328 329 Observation Rubric (Complete Lesson Plan-including the Lesson Preparation Form
and the Lesson Plan itself to be given to the field instructor at the time of the observation)
14 15 Points 9 13 Points Less than 9 points
The lesson was exemplary.
All of the elements of effective
instruction were evident.
Some of the elements of effective
instruction were evident.
12 Closure needs to be stronger
and more effective to see if
students learned the objectives
Few or none of the elements
of effective instruction were
evident. (The teacher
candidate was not prepared to
present the lesson.)
The teacher candidate tried new
strategies with students.
15 Creative and motivating
strategies
A specific teaching strategy(s) was
identified in the lesson plan and
utilized in the teaching.
The teacher candidate did not
use teaching strategies or was
unable to identify the strategy
used.
The lesson addressed all focus
areas identified at last observation.
The focus requirements were
addressed but the teacher
candidate needs more practice
OR
Not all focus requirements
identified in last observation were
addressed. 13
The focus areas from the last
observation were not
addressed.
The teacher candidate addressed all
student needs during the lesson.
15 Nicely done
The teacher candidate addressed
some of the student needs were
during the lesson.
The teacher candidate did not
attend to specific student
needs.
The teacher candidate effectively
communicated expectations/
outcomes and behavior standards
and followed through during the
lesson.
15
The teacher candidate was not
clear about expectations/
outcomes and behavior standards
OR communicated these elements
but did not follow through.
The teacher candidate did not
communicate expectations/
outcomes and behavior
standards. Behavior was not
addressed. Students were
unclear of expectations.
85/95 Kristin Foster 5-5-14



The teacher candidate reinforced/
encouraged learning efforts of all
students.
15
The teacher candidate provided
some reinforcement.
The teacher candidate did not
provide reinforcement/
encouragement of learning
efforts.


EDSE 328 329 Self Reflection Rubric (the self reflection form must be turned in to the field
experience instructor within one week of the observation)
5 Points 1 4 Points O Points
The reflection shows thought and
self-evaluation of the lesson
presentation. The identified focus
areas were reflected upon.
The focus areas identified for
refinement were not considered or
were not reflected upon in the
reflection.
The self- reflection was not
turned in.
0
14-15
points
Lesson plan is thorough and complete. Appropriate academic standard and/or
evidence outcome(s) align(s) with lesson focus. Instructional objective(s) is
specific and aligns with academic standard and is written in measureable form;
research-based instructional strategies are evident;
background knowledge and assessment of learner knowledge is clear, concise
and evident in lesson design; instructional grouping is identified in lesson plan
with detail; materials and resources match instructional objective(s), and
lesson closure includes summary of content and review of learning.
13-10
points
Lesson plan is complete. Appropriate academic standard is
identified, although, evidence outcome(s) does not align with lesson
focus. Instructional objective(s) is specific, although, not written
in measureable form; most instructional strategies are
researched-based; background knowledge and assessment of
learning knowledge is evident but needs more detail; materials and
resources match instructional objective(s), and lesson closure is
evident, although, lacks strong summary and review of learning.
85/95 Kristin Foster 5-5-14
9-10
points
Lesson plan is complete but lacks detail. Academic standard and
evidence outcomes dont align with lesson focus. Instructional
objective(s) is vague and not written in measureable form;
researched-based instructional strategies not evident; background
knowledge and/or assessment of learner understanding is weak;
materials and resources generally match instructional objective,
and lesson closure is weak.
Below 9
Points
Lesson plan incomplete; academic standards and evidence
outcome(s) missing, weak instructional objective(s); research-
based instructional strategies not evident, and closure is not
evident.