Appendix ii

Scoring Matrix for Seismic Variation Options

Available Marks
Client R.
Time
Cost

Weighting
60
40

Range
(Minor time impact 40-60, Medium time impact 20-40, Major time impact 0-20)
(Major cost impact 0-15, Medium cost impact 15-25, Low cost impact 25-40)

Marks for Time

Option

Score

Commentary

Option 1

15

Potential delay in receiving proposal from Contractor will result in delay to the works and likely delay to the
project completion date.

Option 2

60

Design and engineering works can immediately commence for critical areas.

Option 3

40

Slight delayed implementation is likely to increase the requirement for dismantling installed services to
provide access in congested areas.

Marks for Cost

Option

Score

Commentary

Option 1

20

Due to the uncertain nature and quantity of the work, the Contractor would likely price in the risk.

Option 2

10

Lack of final cost certainty and likelihood for dispute.

Option 3

35

Cost certainty for design and installation and competitive pricing due to known quantities.

Result
Option

Score

Rank

Option 1

35

Rank 3

Option 2

70

Rank 2

Option 3

75

Rank 1