Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
DGURNICK@LEWITTHACKMAN.COM
(818) 9 0 7 - 3 2 8 5
LAW CORPORATION
(818) 990-2120
TELECOPIER (818) 981-4764
ELEVENTH FLOOR
ENCINO. CALIFORNIA
91436-1865
16735-1
January 26,2015
vijaya@twitter.com
1355 Market St Ste 900
Dear Vijaya:
1.
Introduction.
As you know from prior communications, this law firm represents Brian Glicklich. Mr.
Glicklich serves as spokesperson for broadcaster Rush Limbaugh. Mr. Limbaugh is America's
most listened-to radio broadcaster, with an audience of 20 million people weekly over
approximately 600 radio stations nationwide. Mr. Glicklich is a private individual.
We are concerned that Mr. Glicklich has become the target of improper harassment by a
group ofTwitter users whose actions are violating Twitter Rules. The misconduct includes
perpetrators using Twitter to harass Mr. Glicklich and also advertisers. These actions include
threats, stalking, intimidation, misleading Twitter to improperly suspend Mr. Glicklich's
account, and use of Twitter's platform in other ways that violate Twitter's rules.
This letter asks Twitter to investigate the misconduct, enforce Twitter's rules with regard
to any accounts and perpetrators who are misusing Twitter, and protect Mr. Glicklich's account
from being improperly suspended.
2.
Background.
A group opposed to Rush Limbaugh has conducted a campaign in which they (1) tweet
outrageous false claims about Mr. Limbaugh, (2) tweet photos of CEOs and claim the CEOs
support the false claims, based solely on their companies sponsorship of Mr. Limbaugh's show,
and (3) send large volumes ofrude, unwanted spam tweets that disparage the reputation and
interfere with operations ofthe advertisers. This campaign involves harassment, disparagement
and intimidation.
The perpetrators recently expanded the campaign, to attack Mr. Glicklich, and escalated
with tactics that violateTwitter Rules, disparage Mr. Glicklich and indicatehe is in physical
caia
LEWITT, HACKMAN, SHAPIRO,
MARSHALL & HARLAN
A
LAW CORPORATION
danger. Mr. Glicklich has been targeted due to his defense against the attacks on Mr. Limbaugh
and advertisers. However, Mr. Glicklich is a private individual who is not in a position to
respond via radio broadcast and paid counter-advertising.
Mr. Glicklich's own use of Twitter has been attempts to expose the true size ofthe
#stoprush activism, identify the group's key members, expose the falsity of their claim to be
customers of sponsors, expose the falsity and unfairness of their actions, and respond with
corrections to their improper tweets. But the perpetrators responded to Mr. Glicklich's
participation on Twitter by using tactics that violate Twitter Rules, including organized, targeted
harassment and threats of physical harm directed against Mr. Glicklich. They are using Twitter to
disseminate photography that includes Mr. Glicklich's wife. They have brought Mr. Glicklich
and his family into their anti-Rush Limbaugh campaign.
The perpetrators are making the following specific false claims using Twitter, as elements of
an overall false narrative that Mr. Glicklich is a bad person, a criminal, a drug addict, a harasser,
a bully, and other pejorative characteristics:
a. They claim Mr. Glicklich committed a "federal crime;"
d. They claim his wife performed a sex act on a participant in the activist group;
e. They claim he is addicted to methamphetamines;
f. They claim he is the "filth of Limbaugh's sewer;"
g. They claim he performs sex acts on Rush Limbaugh;
h. They claim he hacked a bank account and caused the account to be overdrafted;
i.
Each of these claims is false. Each violates Twitter's rule against abuse, targeted abuse and
spam.
The harassing, bullying and stalking postings targeting Mr. Glicklich, include the
following:
*aw
LEWITT, HACKMAN, SHAPIRO,
MARSHALL & HARLAN
A
LAW CORPORATION
j. Stating that the person tweeting the message will make sure Mr. Glicklich will
regret ever posting using the #stoprushhash. This violates Twitter's rule against
violence and threats.
Stating Mr. Glicklich should "come after me, bitch... and you'll never forget it,
ever." This violates Twitter's rule against violence and threats.
o. Phoning Mr. Glicklich at home. This violates Twittier's rule against targeted
abuse and invasion of privacy.
p. Posting false claims about Mr. Glicklich repetitively, and referencing the
@Anonyops account controlled by individuals aligned with the group known as
Anonymous. This violates Twitter's spam policy, and organized harassment
policy.
q. The perpetrators induced @Anonyops to repeat a false claim to an estimated
320,000 or more accounts, which generated an outpouring of hateful and
threatening Tweets and emails against Mr. Glicklich. This violates the spam
policy and organized harassment policy.
The perpetrators took actions to mislead Twitter to believe incorrectly that Mr. Glicklich
violated Twitter's rules. The perpetrators' actions included:
r. Generating large numbers of false claims that Mr. Glicklich violated Twitter
Rules. The perpetrators claimed falsely that Mr. Glicklich harassed #stoprush
activists. This violates the spam policy and organized harassment policy.
s. Obtaining thousands of false followers ("Spam accounts") to follow Mr.
Glicklich's account, making it appear he violated Twitter's rule against
-3-
^uua-
LAW CORPORATION
his account. This violates the serial accounts and spam policy, and the organized
harassment policy.
t.
Registering numerous Twitter accounts for their own use, and then using these
Spam accounts to tweet and retweet false information; they do this to falsely
make the small group conducting the campaign appear larger. This violates
Twitter's rule against creating multiple accounts for disruptive or abusive
purposes.
u. Using software that calls the Twitter API to let participants easily send large
volumes oftweets. The software itself tells users to monitor the rate of sending
tweets to avoid being noticed by Twitter. This violates the spam policy, and
organized harassment policy, and the API terms.
These actions were taken partly to induce Twitter to suspend Mr. Glicklich's Twitter
account. The improper efforts succeeded in that at least 3 times in the past 2 weeks Twitter
suspended Mr. Glicklich's account. This preventing his efforts to respond to the perpetrators'
false allegations.
v. Posting photos of Rush Limbaugh sponsor CEOs alongside outrageous and false
claims about Mr. Limbaugh and charging that the CEO and their business
supports the false claims;
w. Threatening to continue or extend harassment of sponsors unless they stop
advertising on Mr. Limbaugh's show;
x. Using Twitter to encourage followers to harass advertisers, such as by buying and
returning products, to intimidate retailers to stop advertising on Mr. Limbaugh's
show;
eaui
LEWITT, HACKMAN, SHAPIRO,
MARSHALL & HARLAN
A
LAW CORPORATION
z. When sponsors block tweets from these perpetrators, they alert others in their
group to punish the business by harassing them more, using other Twitter
accounts.
Accompanying this letter are samples of tweets, evidencing each of the above forms of
misconduct, and a spreadsheet of key twitter accounts involved in these campaigns. Mr.
Glicklich advises that these tweets are representative only, and that he has collected and can
provide hundreds of additional tweets with similar characteristics.
3. Requests.
On behalf of Mr. Glicklich, we request that Twitter investigate these matters and on
confirming what is described, enforce Twitter's Rules by taking at least the following actions:
1. Protect Mr. Glicklich's account, @brianglicklich so that the activists are not able to have
it suspended by making false or organized complaints.
2. Delete the estimated 19,000+ Spam accounts that are following Mr. Glicklich.
3. Investigate and confirm the organized harassment and stalking, creation of Spam
accounts and use of the Twitter API to send spam tweets, using metadata available to
Twitter to identify and source these accounts.
4. Cancel accounts that are violating Twitter's rules.
5. Identify and cancel other falsified Twitter accounts that these groups have established,
including those "lying in wait" in the event their current accounts are suspended or
cancelled.
We urge Twitter to make a public statement of the actions taken, to discourage this
misconduct and misuse ofTwitter by users.
Mr. Glicklich and I are available to speak with you by phone to discuss these matters in more
detail.
4.
Conclusion.
ram Cj
LEWITT, HACKMAN, SHAPIRO,
MARSHALL & HARLAN
A LAW CORPORATION
intimidation. We request that Twitter enforce its rules against the organized violators who are
misusing Twitter. Please let me know the means by which you are doing so.
By:
-6-
David Gurnick
rXaw (//('<>
LEWITT, HACKMAN, SHAPIRO,
MARSHALL & HARLAN
A
LAW CORPORATION
lb.
$P julie sigwart
* Follow
jsigwart
FAVORITES
_ ..
fi-= -,
arm
v_
Hilt. BLDBS'^a
lc.
-7-
LAW CORPORATION
<e AdversAerialOne 5m
brianglickiich She's done it like six times now, by the way. I'm losing count.
1:53 PM -13 Jan 2015- Details
Hide conversation
Id.
4 Zaffod Beeblebrox
ZaffodB 15s
le.
Shawtwo
Shawtwo 1 h
If.
Mari
narisoLbeck Dec 13
lg.
LAW CORPORATION
lh.
Matt Osborne
2a.
-9-
JLaw uMce&
LEWITT, HACKMAN, SHAPIRO,
MARSHALL & HARLAN
A
LAW CORPORATION
| Matt Osborne
+ Follow
Osbornelnk
2b.
Alexis
AlexisDeWinter Dec 13
Gee I hope no one ever hacks Glicklich's emails. Can u imagine?? stoprush
2c.
|^
ConchUSMCGunny-thug
ConchGunny 12h
5 brianglickiich come after me bitch., and youll never forget it., ever.
*** Expand
2d.
2e.
40
rX<t(/t ( Y/fcai
LEWITT, HACKMAN, SHAPIRO,
MARSHALL & HARLAN
A
LAW CORPORATION
socallks 4m
brianglickiich Should you receive emails, I did NOT request anyone to write
you. I only posted FACTS on my FB wall. :) stoprush
4:04 PM - 14 Dec 2014 Details
2f.
BardOfEarth
BardOfEarth 6m
BardOfEarth "BardOfEarth 2h
.UnitePink Please post Glicklick # I'm a night owl HAPPY 2 call him back 2
A.M. #StopRush
Details
2g.
Anonymous
I^Di1^l4,.ll
3a.
from Twitterville.
4%
41-
^Law C//ccs
LEWITT, HACKMAN, SHAPIRO,
MARSHALL & HARLAN
A
LAW CORPORATION
AdversAerialOne
6h
3b.
KAT " kommonKat 39m
3c.
KittyLovesObama
@kittyFitz50
12
*am C;;><<:>
LEWITT, HACKMAN, SHAPIRO,
MARSHALL & HARLAN
A
LAW CORPORATION
Sam's opinion
SamanthaGoIded
Watson
@KKatarinaa_a
3d.
43-
swch
Logn
Happy Birthday ((StopRush. We are now 2 years old, help us celebrate by tweeting to sponsors
When you click a Ink. rl wis auto Iwm! without asking are you sure . !!l DO NOT TWEET TOO FAST !!!
Sporjoi
i
. .
Remember this? -
ItsNoFluke
.
..
limbaugh Says Pom KimStaivmg Good Way to Lose Weight hllp^/youtu.bo.'GeWIBOJIL1 ultsNcFluke
. - ; .1
.-,:.
".-.11
"..,
3,KMit--ln.
/.
,!.
.,
Oil .ill.omloaIA
Rush Lrnbajah ;cked about a woman raped while she was sleeping. Do you th*ik rape is funny? ItsNoFluko
Obamn On Sandra Fluke
h!1p//mm-la orpWGueSO
2 years ago. he had many paid advertisers. Now. It s PSAs, dead a- and Umbaogh shilmg Ns own companies filsnofuke stoprush
nl_.mba.jgri'i Legacy: How to Say You're Sorry When Youre Not ICpj'As.od'scWI I "StopRush nsNoFluke
RT Gproglegs Happy Birtiday (stoprush1 Thank you lor making the world a more decent place!! rtsNoFluko
/.
..
fltsNefluke that Rush receives ho marching orders hem tie Koch B-cthers >StcpRus*i
How rs advertising with drsoustng sexist Rush Umbaugh gorng wiln your female customers?
RT a tutt.ccr.tenti eitsfvoFluke eRushLimbaugh not orJy plants seeds of hate. He waters and lertitees them da-y.
RT OCoopsterO-t Hale shouldn't be celebrated or prof table. eiaNoRuke eslcoRush
Umtiaugh on Armed Forces Raao contributes to Mritary Rape http://ow.ry/u58aw ellsNoFruke pu sign lo remove hn ntlp7/ow.ryA>68j
4a.
M CMMorgan socallks 6h
RT &'kittyFitz50
Mr. Jason Robbins DraftKings CEO.
You could choose differently.
Why don't you?
#stoprush
44
StopRush.net
<u/aca C/if';
LEWITT, HACKMAN, SHAPIRO,
MARSHALL & HARLAN
A LAW CORPORATION
G3 CMMorgan retweeted
5h
of color
#stoprush
I
4\
11 9
v*
\
L
45-
LAW CORPORATION
stoprush
Expand
4b.
t-1 KittyFitzFerguson retweeted
Boop
^j^ Last chance @GEICO... Drop limbaugh for his Bigotry, Racism and
< demeaning women & children #stoprush pic.twitter.com/pYirjvrtTt
4c.
46
oitftY/ LWCCC4
LAW CORPORATION
Kate AKRNHSNC
26m
Kate AKRNHSNC
< 27m
4d.
| Elizabeth Figueroa
* Follow
IngenioMediaPR
13
4e.
-17
*a
LEWITT, HACKMAN, SHAPIRO,
MARSHALL & HARLAN
A
LAW CORPORATION
socallks 40s
stoprush Pis tweet to brianwcc Wholesale Cap Corp, many ads per day
during Rush on KTIE He blocked me. LOL