Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Prepared By:
Shantel Bishoff, OTS & Jaclyn Jerse, OTS
Touro University Nevada
School of Occupational Therapy
874 American Pacific Dr.
Henderson, NV 89014
Clinical Scenario:
Autism spectrum disorders (ASD) are a group of developmental disabilities that can cause
significant social, communication, and behavioral challenges (CDC, 2013). The Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that about 1 in 88 children have been identified
with an ASD (CDC, 2013). More people are being diagnosed than before but the reasons remain
unknown, but are in part likely due to increased awareness. The CDC revised the ASD prevalence
estimates from 1 in 150 children to 1 in 110 children (CDC, 2013). ASD is characterized, in
varying degrees, by problems in social interaction, verbal and nonverbal communication, and
repetitive behaviors (Autism Speaks, 2013). Children with ASD present unique challenges to the
classroom teacher and the childs inability to regulate his or her own behavior can often be the
biggest struggle (Koenig, Buckley-Reen, & Garg, 2012). To date, several organizations promote
and fund autism research however few have isolated specific intervention strategies to enhance
engagement in occupation. Additionally, because ASDs presentation in each child is so varied
with symptoms ranging from mild to severe, understanding the condition and finding the best
therapies [can be] difficult (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2011, p. 1).
It is important then that OT practitioners work collaboratively with individuals on the autism
Adapted from AOTA Evidence-Based Literature Review Project/7 CAT Worksheet.5-05
spectrum, their families, their teachers and other health professionals to, provide a range of
needed resources and services that support the individuals ability to participate fully in life,
(AOTA, 2010, p. 1). Exercise as an intervention has become increasingly popular in the United
States. The latest "Yoga in America" study released by Yoga Journal shows that 20.4 million
Americans currently practice yoga (Yoga Journal, 2012). Exercise based activity has many
benefits including stress reduction, increased flexibility and muscle tone, improved athletic
performance, increased respiration and energy, and maintenance of a balanced metabolism
(AOTA, 2013). Yoga is classified as a mindbody intervention by the National Center for
Complementary and Alternative Medicine and can be used as a complementary approach in
occupational therapy to enhance engagement in occupation (Koenig et al., 2012). Exercise based
strategies are used as an intervention strategy in the classroom in order to increase attention,
increase social skills, decrease maladaptive behavior, and increase functioning in children
diagnosed with ASD. This review looks at the evidence behind children with ASD participating in
exercise-based interventions to make positive behavioral changes.
mentioned previously, many children with ASD experience deficits within social and
communication skill realms that can interfere with engagement in daily life occupations and
interactions with family members, friends, and peers in a purposeful manner. Provided their
prevalent use already to aide in these areas, it is important to determine the effectiveness of
exercise-based interventions that will increase appropriate social behaviors which in turn will help
ensure that the profession is in compliance with evidence based practice by providing the most
effective treatments available.
If it is found that exercise based therapy can effectively improve social skills and communication,
children with autism who have been placed alternatively in school, may find themselves eligible
for increased inclusion in least restrictive environments. Furthermore, it is possible that improved
communication and social skills could help children be more self-sufficient and thus depend on
others and community programs less.
Studies suggest that physical activity in the form of something as simple to implement as jogging
may be efficacious in promoting academic achievement for students diagnosed with ASD
(Nicholson, Kehle, Bray & Heest, 2011, Level IV). Study results showed changes in
communication, language, play and joint attention when utilizing exercise-based interventions
(Radhakrishna, Nagarathna & Nagendra, 2010, Level II). Evidence suggests that specific yoga
programs help decrease maladaptive behaviors when used with children with ASD no matter how
severe the diagnosis (Rosenblatt, Gorantla, Torres, Yarmush, Rao, Park...Levine, 2011, Level III).
Several finding throughout this exhaustive literature review showed improvement of social
functioning in the physical activity participants, further presenting with higher results in the
PedsQL, reflecting exercise interventions to be effective (Tan, 2011, Level II).
Healthcare delivery and policy: Findings revealed increased percentages of observed academic
engagement for students participating in the physical activity interventions. It also appeared that
the increases in academic engagement correlated with the level of participation in the physical
activity such that the students who were more consistently running or walking subsequently
displayed greater involvement in the classroom. By providing a physical activity program that
meets regularly, it is possible to positively impact the lifestyle and independence of individuals,
especially for those with disabilities. Parents of each reviewed study all reported dramatic positive
impacts on their childrens lives as a result of the specific exercise-based interventions. An
increased sense of accomplishment and self-worth was also reported by the parent or guardian of
each individual child. Results suggested that a yog-based program may help to increase behavior
skills such as imitation, language, joint attention, communication, play, and alertness when used
with children with ASD (Radhakrishna, Nagarathna & Nagendra, 2010, Level II). Evidence
suggests that physical activity is capable of triggering the brains ability to change (Tan, 2011,
Level II) The evaluation of exercise-based interventions especially given its increased integration
into practice both clinically and within the health profession to treat a myriad of diagnoses and
symptoms is critical within evidence-based practice. As the need for scientifically based
educational interventions is outlined in the Individuals With Disabilities Education Improvement
Act of 2004, research addressing the effectiveness of intervention to guide evidence-based
Adapted from AOTA Evidence-Based Literature Review Project/7 CAT Worksheet.5-05
practice is pivotal.
Education and training of OT students: Although many of the interventions within the relevant
studies implemented assessments and outcome measures in which the individual effectuated the
measure, had to be certified or trained within the realm of the assessment pertinent to the study,
this was not the case for all reviewed literature. The clinical reasoning and creativity that is
already part of entry-level education would allow for an introduction of the concept of each
individual measure for a number of pertinent cases. Introduction to the concepts involved in many
of the interventions however would enhance entry-level education and add to the skill set of
entry-level practitioners. However, although many of the studies present as not needing further
certification to conduct and implement, distinct training to perform specific yoga interventions
would be useful to incorporate further knowledge and credibility while implementing yoga-based
interventions (Radhakrishna, Nagarathna & Nagendra, 2010, Level II).
Refinement, revision, and advancement of factual knowledge or theory: Additional research is
needed to better understand which specific physical activity interventions are most appropriate for
specific children in various settings. Randomized control trials should be conducted in order to
provide a higher level of evidence supporting the exercise-based interventions in order to further
solidify structured, beneficial interventions. Future research should examine the effectiveness of
the many programs already within research as well as new programs in relation to academic
outcomes, performance-based executive function tasks that assess attention and focus among
students with ASD as well as behavioral outcomes to see whether improved behavior affects
educational and occupational performance.
Overall, the evidence suggests mixed results and thus an inconclusive review. Despite effective
and partial effectiveness across several studies, the limitations found within the research
aggregate require the results be evaluated and applied on a preliminary, experimental basis.
Additional research is justified if not solely to either validate and close or refute and expand the
findings of this exhaustive review. Homogenous groups, increased sample sizes, and valid and
like outcome measures should be utilized in future studies to allow for the strongest and highest
level of evidence when complete. It should also be noted that the focused question utilized in the
making of this CAT encapsulated the spectrum of available exercise-based therapies. It would be
beneficial in future reviews to complete separate reviews regarding modified and non-modified
interventions. Once a techniques effectiveness has been determined, then and only then can it be
compared to and analyzed against another. While these studies provide a jumping off point,
further research is required to determine exercise-based interventions position as a therapeutic
intervention in the advancement of factual knowledge and theory of OT practice.
Review Process:
The following process was undertaken to thoroughly and effectively evaluate the literature:
-In consultation with the course instructor, the focused question was developed and chosen out of
Adapted from AOTA Evidence-Based Literature Review Project/7 CAT Worksheet.5-05
personal interest regarding the practice as well as specific interventions implemented in an effort
to target the ASD population.
-Search terms for applicable population, intervention, and outcome terms were developed and
later verified by course instructor.
-Search terms were used to exhaust databases in search of abstracts and full text articles that
contained each component.
-Abstracts that did not thoroughly identify inclusion of all components were further evaluated by
reading the article in full text to determine presence or absence of necessary components.
-Twenty articles were submitted as a result of comprehensive literature search. As per the
requirements of an Evidence-Based Literature Review, included articles had to be of evidence
level IV and above. Course instructor along with students confirmed determined level of evidence
when necessary.
-With assistance of course instructor, full-text articles of those identified in literature search were
obtained. The articles were read and reviewed in reference to focused question. Full-text articles
that did not meet identified population, intervention, and outcome were eliminated from further
analysis.
-From the twenty, five free standing articles were analyzed within a systematic review and were
thus, eliminated. High priority articles were then selected and reviewed based on level of evidence
and publication date in a peer reviewed journal for the years 1992 through 2014 in an effort to
provide a comprehensive review of the strongest and most recent evidence on the topic.
-Ten articles meeting population, intervention, and outcome standards as well as exclusionary
criteria were selected for Evidence Table and appraised for significance.
-Course instructor reviewed appraisal of articles and provided feedback regarding revisions and
article use approval for Critically Appraised Topic.
-Ten articles evaluated and approved were used to summarize key findings and clinical
significance in this Critically Appraised Topic.
Exclusion Criteria:
Studies that had outcome measures focused on something other than behavior; sample had
children not diagnosed with ASD; evidence prior to 2002; qualitative studies; adult and geriatric
Adapted from AOTA Evidence-Based Literature Review Project/7 CAT Worksheet.5-05
population
Search Strategies:
Categories
Patient/Client Population
Intervention
Outcomes
included articles, the course instructor helped ensure level of evidence of included articles was
indeed appropriate for appraisal.
-The students appraised ten articles determined to fit population, intervention and outcome
components while also meeting inclusion/exclusion criteria required to answer the focused
question in an Evidence Table. The Evidence Table was reviewed and critiqued by course
instructor.
-The students summarized the key findings and clinical significance of the reviewed articles from
the Evidence Table while referencing instructor feedback to complete the Critically Appraised
Topic.
Results of Search:
Summary of Study Designs of Articles Selected for Appraisal:
Level of
Evidence
Number of Articles
Selected
Randomized controlled-trial
II
III
IV
TOTAL:
The small sample size and cultural bias was a limitation to this study (Movahedi,
Bahrami, Marandi, Abedi, 2013, Level I).
Level II:
The sixteen week study prevented researchers from determining the long term effects
and would require further investigation (Koenig, Buckley-Reen & Garg, 2012, Level II).
Small sample size, negative behavior reduction did not reach statistical significance
(Magnusson, Cobham, McLeod, 2012, Level II)
The limitations of this study include the small sample size, small age range and single
gender of participants (all male) limit generalization. Second, even though an attempt
was made to obtain an equal size and type of ASDs in two groups of children with
ASDs, differences in cognitive abilities and gross motor skills were not evaluated and
might have influenced findings (Pan, 2010, Level II).
There is not a defined, representative sample of participants because there was no
information given on the control group, which decreases the internal validity. The
intervention was not clearly explained in the study. There were no psychometric
properties given for any of the three outcome measures so the reliability and validity of
these is unknown, which also decreases the internal validity. Because of the way the
participants were chosen, there could have been selection bias in the study. Bias could
have also been created because the ones implementing the intervention were the special
educators and parents who know the children well (Radhakrishna, Nagarathna &
Nagendra, 2010, Level II).
First, the current sample size is small thus must be considered a pilot study. Second, the
unequal treatment time between the experimental and control group may have
introduced certain bias to the nature of the results. Third, the confirmation of the ASD
diagnosis including the type and severity was not carried out (Tan, 2010, Level II).
Level III:
Main limitations included the small sample size consisting of eight children with
contrasting abilities. The use of more homogenous subgroups of children could
contribute to the heated debate about best treatment methods (Kok, Kong & BernardOpitz, 2002, Level III).
Limitations presented with this study was the lack of quantitative and qualitative data,
and evidence should be obtained with caution. There was no follow up with the
participants in the study so the long-term effects are unknown (Resenblatt et al., 2011,
Level III).
Levels IV and V
The small sample size, limited space to perform physical activities, and
influence/motivation to participate may have affected the study (Nicholson, Kehle, Bray,
Heest, 2011, Level IV).
Other
N/A
Kok, A. J., Kong, T. Y., & Bernard-opitz, V. (2002). A Comparison of the Effects of Structured
Play and Facilitated Play Approaches on Preschoolers with Autism A Case Study. Autism,
6(2), 181-196. doi: 10.1177/1362361302006002005
Magnusson, J. E., Cobham, C., & McLeod, R. (2012). Beneficial effects of clinical exercise
rehabilitation for children and adolescents with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Journal of
Exercise Physiology, 15(2), 71-79. Retrieved from
http://www.asep.org/asep/asep/JEPonlineApril2012Jane_Magnusson.pdf
Movahedi, A., Bahrami, F., Marandi, S. M., & Abedi, A. (2013). Improvement in social
dysfunction of children with autism spectrum disorder following long term Kata techniques
training. Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders, 7(9), 1054-1061. Retrieved from
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1750946713000834
Nicholson, H., Kehle, T. J., Bray, M. A., & Heest, J. V. (2011). The effects of antecedent physical
activity on the academic engagement of children with autism spectrum disorder. Psychology in
the Schools, 48(2), 198-213.
Pan, C.-Y. (2011). The efficacy of an aquatic program on physical fitness and aquatic skills in
children with and without autism spectrum disorders. Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders,
5(1), 657-665. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rasd.2010.08.001
Radhakrishna, S., Nagarathna, R., and Nagendra, H.R. (2010). Integrated approach to yoga
therapy and autism spectrum disorder. Journal of Ayurveda & Integrative Medicine, (1) 2,
120-124. doi: 10.4103/0975-9476.65089
Rosenblatt, L., Gorantla, S. Torres, J., Yarmush, R., Rao, S., Park, E.,Levine, J. (2011)
Relaxation response based yoga improves functioning in young children with autism: a pilot
study. Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, (11) 17, 1029-1035. DOI:
10.1089/acm.2010.0834
Tan, W. Z. B. (2011). Physical activity: its implication on attention span and quality of life in
children with Autism Spectrum Disorder. Retrieved from http://ro.ecu.edu.au/theses_hons/20/
Other References:
American Occupational Therapy Association. (2010). Autism statement. Retrieved from
http://www.aota.org/practitioners/official/statements/40880.aspx?ft=.pdf.
American Occupational Therapy Association. (2011). Occupational therapys role with autism.
Adapted from AOTA Evidence-Based Literature Review Project/7 CAT Worksheet.5-05