Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
DYSLEXIA
IN THE
FIE
Windy Clark, Gayla Lutz,
& Kara Zwolinski
Texas Educational
Diagnostician
Association
Conference
April 30, 2015
TODAYS OBJECTIVES
Analyze definitions and characteristics of Dyslexia, Specific
Learning Disability and Speech Impairment
Examine impaired cognitive processes associated with
Dyslexia, Specific Learning Disability, and Speech
Impairment
Reflect on the different pathways of dyslexia assessment
and identification
Reflect on General Learning Difficulty
MULTIDISCIPLINARY
TEAM
4/30/15
4/30/15
MULTIDISCIPLINARY TEAMS
Reading specialist/dyslexia specialist
Speech Language Pathologist
Administrator
Parents
STATE LAW
89.1040. Eligibility Criteria.
STATE LAW
The determination of dyslexia is made by a
multidisciplinary team composed of members
who are knowledgeable about the
Student being assessed;
Assessments used;
Meaning of the collected data;
The reading process;
Dyslexia and related disorders;
Dyslexia instruction;
District or charter school, state, and federal guidelines for
assessment
State Dyslexia Handbook, Revised 2014, p. 21, 76
4/30/15
MULTIDISCIPLINARY APPROACH TO
DYSLEXIA
Confusion on whether dyslexia falls under general
education or special education
DEFINITIONS/CHARACTERISTICS
DYSLEXIA, SPECIFIC LEARNING DISABILITY, SPEECH
IMPAIRMENT
DYSLEXIA
4/30/15
DYSLEXIA BASICS
SBOE passed the
revised handbook in
July, 2014
The Revised 2014
Handbook replaces all
previous Dyslexia
handbooks
SBOE-approved
procedures
School district
guidelines for written
procedures
p. 8
DEFINITIONS OF DYSLEXIA
(1) Dyslexia means a disorder of constitutional origin manifested
by a difficulty in learning to read, write, or spell, despite
conventional instruction, adequate intelligence, and sociocultural
opportunity.
(2) Related disorders include disorders similar to or related to
dyslexia such as developmental auditory imperceptions,
dysphasia, specific developmental dyslexia, developmental
dysgraphia, and developmental spelling disability.
Texas
Education
Code
38.003
p. 8
DEFINITIONS OF DYSLEXIA
Dyslexia is a specific learning disability that is neurological in origin.
It is characterized by difficulties with accurate and/or fluent word
recognition and by poor spelling and decoding abilities. These
difficulties typically result from a deficit in the phonological
component of language that is often unexpected in relation to other
cognitive abilities and the provision of effective classroom instruction.
Secondary consequences may include problems in reading
comprehension and reduced reading experience that can impede
growth of vocabulary and background knowledge.
International
Dyslexia
Association
4/30/15
Cognitive deficit(s) is
specific, not general or
pervasive
Cognitive
Weakness/Deficit
Consistent
Academic
Weakness/Deficit
p. 8
Strengths
(average or better overall
ability)
Academic deficit(s) is
unexpected because
overall cognitive ability is
at least average.
Cognitive deficit(s) is
specific, not general or
pervasive
Cognitive
Weakness/Deficit
Consistent
Reading words in
isolation, decoding
unfamiliar words, fluency
(rate/accuracy), spelling
SPECIFIC LEARNING
DISABILITY
4/30/15
4/30/15
4/30/15
Cognitive deficit(s) is
specific, not general
or pervasive
Basic Reading
Cognitive
Weakness/Deficit
Reading Comprehension
Reading Fluency
Written Expression
Math Calculation
Math Reasoning
Listening Comprehension
Oral Expression
Consistent
Learning
Disability
Reading
Oral
Language
Math
Written
Expression
Basic
Reading
Reading
Comprehension
Reading
Fluency
Math
Calculation
Math
Reasoning
Oral
Expression
Listening
Comprehension
Dyslexia
SPEECH IMPAIRMENT
4/30/15
SPEECH IMPAIRMENT
89.1040. Eligibility Criteria
SPEECH IMPAIRMENT
300.8 Child with a disability.
(c) (11) Speech or language impairment
means a communication disorder, such
as stuttering, impaired articulation, a
language impairment, or a voice
impairment, that adversely affects a
childs educational performance.
4/30/15
4/30/15
Goldsworthy, C. L. (2003)
4/30/15
DYSLEXIA
DIFFICULTIES IN THE
COGNITIVE PROCESSES
p. 20
Strengths
Academic deficit(s) is
unexpected because
overall cognitive ability is
at least average.
Cognitive deficit(s) is
specific, not general
or pervasive
Phonological Awareness
(history of remediation),
Rapid Naming,
Orthographic Processing
Consistent
UNEXPECTEDNESS
p. 8
Listening comprehension,
reading comprehension, verbal
expression, mathematics,
vocabulary, written expression,
handwriting, ability to learn in
the absence of print
Academic deficit(s) is
unexpected because
overall cognitive ability is
at least average.
Cognitive deficit(s) is
specific, not general
or pervasive
Phonological Awareness
(history of remediation),
Rapid Naming,
Orthographic Processing
Consistent
4/30/15
UNEXPECTEDNESS
p. 8
Listening comprehension,
reading comprehension, verbal
expression, mathematics,
vocabulary, written expression,
handwriting, ability to learn in
the absence of print
Academic deficit(s) is
unexpected because
overall cognitive ability is
at least average.
Cognitive deficit(s) is
specific, not general
or pervasive
Phonological Awareness
(history of remediation),
Rapid Naming,
Orthographic Processing
Consistent
The term Dyslexia does not apply to children who have learning difficulties that are primarily the result of visual, hearing, or
motor disabilities; of intellectual disability; of emotional disturbance, or of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage
Degree of Impairment
p. 8
Mild
Moderate
Severe
4/30/15
Cognitive deficit(s) is
specific, not general
or pervasive
Gc
Gf
Glr
Basic Reading
Gsm
Gv
Consistent
Gs
Reading Comprehension
Reading Fluency
Written Expression
Ga
Executive Function
Math Calculation
Math Reasoning
Listening Comprehension
Oral Expression
Academic deficit(s) is
unexpected because
overall cognitive ability is
at least average.
Cognitive deficit(s) is
specific, not general
or pervasive
Gc
Gf
Glr
Basic Reading
Gsm
Gv
Gs
Executive Function
Reading Comprehension
Reading Fluency
Written Expression
Ga
Consistent
Math Calculation
Math Reasoning
Listening Comprehension
Oral Expression
The term Specific Learning Disability may not apply to children who have learning difficulties that are primarily the result of a visual, hearing, or
motor disability; of intellectual disability; of emotional disturbance; of cultural factors; of environmental or economic disadvantage; or of limited
English proficiency
4/30/15
Basic
Reading
Auditory
Processing
(Ga)
Long-term
Retrieval
(Glr)
Phonetic
Coding (PC)
Naming
Facility (NA)
Visual
Processing
(Gv)
Orthographic
Processing
Visual
Memory
(VM)
Short-term
Memory
(Gsm)
Processing
Speed (Gs)
Working
Memory
(MW)
Perceptual
Speed (P)
Reading
Fluency
Long-term
Retrieval &
Storage (Glr)
Naming
Facility (NA)
Associative
Memory
(MA)
Visual
Processing
(Gv)
Processing
Speed (Gs)
Orthographic
Processing
Perceptual
Speed (P)
4/30/15
SPECIAL EDUCATION . . .
WHO SHOULD BE REFERRED?
Students who may display additional factors complicating
their dyslexia and will require more support than what is
available through the general education dyslexia program
OR
Students with severe dyslexia or related disorders who may
be unable to make a sufficient rate of academic progress
within any of the programs described in the procedures
related to dyslexia
SHOULD
4/30/15
p. 13-14
p. 16
MULTIPLE MEASURES OF
ASSESSMENT
Identify
strengths/weaknesses
without norms
Observations
Parent & teacher reports
Work samples
Compared to others
IQ tests
Achievement tests
Cognitive Tests
p. 19
Performance level of
taught curriculum
Teacher-made quiz
Benchmarks
Informal
Curriculumbased
Normreferenced
Criterionreferenced
In relation to specific tasks
STAAR
TPRI/Tejas LEE
4/30/15
p. 18
Page
22
Identification guideposts of
dyslexia in other languages may
differ
Decoding in transparent
languages may not be a strong
indicator of dyslexia as reading
rate
Page
18
4/30/15
ACADEMIC AREAS/COGNITIVE
PROCESSES
Page
20-21
Page
22
Page
23
4/30/15
GUIDANCE DOCUMENTS TO
INTERPRET DATA
4/30/15
CHARACTERISTICS OF GENERAL
LEARNING DIFFICULTY
Pattern is not consistent with SLD construct
Unexpected underachievement is not
present
Domain-specific cognitive weakness as a
primary contributing factor to poor
achievement not present
All performance are similar; expected
achievement
Flanagan, Ortiz, and Alfonso (2013). Proposed Characteristics of and Educational Foci for Individuals with Learning Difficulties that Vary in Type and Severity, in
Flanagan, Ortiz, & Alfonso, Essentials of Cross-Battery Assessment, Third Edition (pp. 267-270). Hoboken, NY: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
4/30/15
CHARACTERISTICS OF GENERAL
LEARNING DIFFICULTY
Scores appear to be within low to below
average
Flanagan, Ortiz, and Alfonso (2013). Proposed Characteristics of and Educational Foci for Individuals with Learning Difficulties that Vary in Type and Severity, in
Flanagan, Ortiz, & Alfonso, Essentials of Cross-Battery Assessment, Third Edition (pp. 267-270). Hoboken, NY: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Cognitive
deficits are
general
Cognitive
Weaknesses and
Deficits are general
Consistent
Academic
Weaknesses and
Deficits are general
SOMETHING TO PONDER
According to Kavale and colleagues (2005), About 14% of the
4/30/15
4/30/15
b)
CODE OF ETHICS
B. Responsibilities to Individuals
Undergoing Assessments
1. Diagnosticians are committed to
developing the highest educational
and quality of life potential of
individuals with exceptionalities
C. Professional Competency
4. Interpretation and Reporting of Results
g. Diagnosticians who have the responsibility for
making decisions about learners or policies based
upon test results have a thorough understanding of
applicable assessment procedures, educational
theory, methodology, and research.
ANY QUESTIONS?
4/30/15
THANK YOU!
Windy Clark
windy.clark@esc4.net
Gayla Lutz
gayla.lutz@esc4.net
Kara Zwolinski
kara.zwolinski@esc4.net
REFERENCES
Carson, L., Gillon, G., & Boustead, T. (2012). Classroom Phonological Awareness Instruction and Literacy
Outcomes In the First Year of School. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools,
doi:10.1044/0161-1461(2012/11-0061).
Farrall, M. L. (2012). Reading assessment: linking language, literacy, and cognition. Hoboken, New Jersey:
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Flanagan, Ortiz, and Alfonso (2013). Proposed Characteristics of and Educational Foci for Individuals with
Learning Difficulties that Vary in Type and Severity, in Flanagan, Ortiz, & Alfonso, Essentials of CrossBattery Assessment, Third Edition (pp. 267-270). Hoboken, NY: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Flanagan, Ortiz, and Alfonso (2013). Common Components of Alternative Research-Based Methods of SLD
Identification in Flanagan, Ortiz, & Alfonso, Essentials of Cross-Battery Assessment, Third Edition (p.240).
Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Goldsworthy, Candace L. Developmental Reading Disabilities: A Language Based Treatment Approach
Second Edition. Canada: Thomson Learning, Inc., 2003.
Rescorla, L. A. & Dale, P. S. (2013). Late talkers. Baltimore, Maryland: Paul H. Brookes Publishing Co.
Richards, Regina G. The Source for Dyslexia and Dysgraphia. East Moline, IL: LinguiSystems, Inc., 1999.
Texas Education Agency. (Revised 2014) The dyslexia handbook: Procedures concerning dyslexia and
related disorders. Austin, Texas.