eee Grose Kyanan~ §7 The Camp as the ‘Nomos of the Modern. 71 Wha hapened in the camps exe the jie com cepeof ime tepid poe sacar in wich ‘essen ok pce fea amply mind rm cosierion ‘Tac camp is mel the place tn whith he moe bole cmd Fran nas ves ex om cart ee we er he asa forthe tne Br hse who ome Sf He we wil bry flow an vere lit of ings. inscad of dling thd ofthc from the evens hat ten pace here il ae hac camp, wht its pelea star, hat sch evn coul ake place thre Tht Willd usw red the camp nota his fas ad a9 rod longing pr en eel but nome Synth hen mated moro he poli spate inwich wee il vng THnorans dob whether the Gt camps to appear wee the cangrde consents coe te Spas in baa 8962 che popular inet ofthe ely, he "once ES ito which de Eola herded he Boers owed he i or cntury, What nce ec thin Bork coma te “Foneeny linked wa clonal war iexended oan ate eudadon Thccampe se hr bor out of oiary ow ea 166 The Camp as Nome 67 les, s¢ o8€ mighe have supposed, fom « vansfomation and development of cima lw ue out ofa ate of exerpion and tour lve This i een enter ia de Nai Lage, eoncening tho origin ajuda egime we are wel foemed Ichasbeen toted thatthe pride bis forlerment wa not cmon la ce Schafer, protective cody), jr instation OF Pesan ogi tha the Nas jut sorties ced s+ ppetenatne police mesrute iol ate allowed individuals co beak int custody” independeny of any cximinalbebarion solely to avid danger othe enn of the ste. The origin of “Schtcfeainthe Prtian law of Jane 4 15 0n the se of ‘emegeny, which wat mended alo Geman wth the excep tin of Baar in. An even eater igi fr Schtsfcan be lected inthe Pron inwson the "poco of ena liber” (Goh der pels Pri) of ebrcy 130, which wee idly pple dorng che Bre Word War ac ding he disorder Jn Germany tat flowed the sgning ofthe peace wean. Ii imporant not to forge thar the Base concenation camps in {Germany were the work nto the Nan regime bat of the Sci Democratic gweament, which ineemed thousands of commnt- ‘sents in 923 onthe bai of Scary and alo crened the "Ronen fr Alinde a Conlon, which used msn Ester European refers and wich my, therefore, Be amined the Gt cmp for Jin his cecry Ceven if ia, ‘tow, oe an etermisation camp) "The jie foundation for Sebustafvas the prodamaton of sheet of ego of exception and the coresponding sspesion ‘ofthe ancl of he Geman tnsion tie pexanted perma Tertes, Anil 4 of the Weimar connieaton sea a flow: "The president of the Rich may, in heave of rave dsurbance cor hea o publi ecu and ord make the decions ney to esablsh pole secur fecsary wie dead ofthe armed Fees To the end he may provisionally suspend [ans Kft ecm the fandom coneined in aes 1485107, 18, {abc as4 and 153" Rom 1919 to 924, the Weimar government Ceara he sane of xption many tines, meine: prolonging,Bez sot The Camp at Beedgn it for up © five months (for example from September 1923 to February 1929). Tn this sense, when the Nas took power snd prochlmed the “dete fr the protection of the pool nd Sar (erndnang sum Slaton Vth wed Seat on obey sh oy, ‘nef suspending che srl ofthe consitstionconcersog peronalibecy th fcedom ofexpresionandef acenbly and he |nolbiy of te home and of posal and lephone pevcy hey ‘merely followed a practice conolidced by previous gotaren Yethere wasn mporan: noe No mieaion a all as made of te exprenion Aaouabmenetond( sate of exception) athe tot ‘ofthe deste, which va, fom the jriclpoine of view fans ply grounded in aie 4 ofthe conration then cea ‘hich withou a douke amounted eo + declrnion afte secs of exception Canis ign 17 1 22,04 and ofthe cont tation ofthe German Reich” the fist paragraph ted, ae ne pended unil further nove", The dece tsned de Bate orc unl the end ofthe The Reich, which hain hina been sey defined as» "Nigh of Se. Barholomev that lated sche Yan? (Drbischand Wieland, Sem p26. These fepon "has cee Be refered as an exer and rool tte of fe ‘al danger and ees 1 be sof with jel rae fle Nas inal Soil jar were so aware of the paula of the sition that hey defined bythe partonic expen aof wild exception” (eine goolien dasncimecasend). “Thioega ‘he suipesion of Fendementl ight,” wrtes Werner Spas us cloe to the regime “the decent beng a ate of wild exception for the sake of the enablichent of he Neon Secale St (quoted ibid, p36 7.2. The imporance of iconv ren bewen the se sf cpio snd the snc amp anne boreal foraconec undenendng ofthe nae ofthecan. The pre te? offedom ee aie in Sch only, pes tion auth spent ratings The nowy ht Steg now paced fom eae ot exception en which had Ben bed ad foci he os sun. Thee oe te pee wen ear The Camp a2 Nomet 169 of exgtion begins to bcoe the rae In he ap, the stare of {ction which was xedally a rmporey spenton ofthe ue of law on the bss of «fea stat of danger oe eee Pesmanentspaal rangement which a+ such neverckes ne ‘uins ouside the noomal order When Himmler decided were «8 "concentaon carp for polcsl pone” in Dacha ste trie of Hider lection as chanel ofthe Raich a Mand tn ‘he camp was immediely entre to the 88 and thenle Stata placed outside the rlesof peal nd prion iam wich, then and subsequent had no beating on i Dept the mele plltion of che ofen conraicory communique introns, ‘2d elerams thiough which the authorities bo athe Resch and ofthe indviusl Lander tok eer arp che workings of Sac ‘nfs rage a pose ser te decaf ebay hc cp aboot independence frm every ud contal od very rer nce othe coca jail order was constantly resin Ae, ‘erdingso the new noon ofthe Navona Secale ar ng vthom Cat Semi was in the font line, which Inne he ‘btimary apd immedace oars of lew in the Faheers command Schtchfhad, worms 90 need whatsoeres ef jd ooo tion in xing insitions ad laws being “an meine ce sf the Naina Sac revolton" (Orbach and Widen, Se sem p 27). Becaee of hihi i near m he camp wane located in sich peal space of exception Die he head oF the Gesapo, could dec, “Neither an ore nora lnsucion exis forte eign ofthe camps they wer a intl oe day ‘hey were chee [wen nice gerne, swe ne Tg dae (quoted iid, p30, Dacha a the other cmp dat mee nme added to ie (Sedvenhausen, Buchrwall, Lichtenberg) remained ces aye ia opeation—mhat raid wat the a of thee population (hich i ceran pcods, impala bervecn 1935 sed blast Jews began tobe depo dint 9.900 peopl Bain Geemany the camp a such had become «permanent rai, 273 The padi satu ofthe cmp as 2 space of exception ‘mastbe comiderd.Thecamp tape ofland placed out thewo The Comp Paradis norma juridical odes bat ti neve oe simpyan xen space Whatisexdedin he camp scordiago the esmoog Calsene ofthe eam exception (cape) tak oui inked through sown exchio, But what Bt of al alan ito the juridical onder isthe sate of exception ioe. nsf athe a of caceptin wills” ie inaugrates new jr ples pe dbgn in which che orm Becomes nding fron the rion The cam taste rac in whch the nate of ‘cexpton the poublyofdecling on which funds sveign fower~is ealzed ermal. The sovereign long lie Br fel athe didn che opr ofthe Weimar contiunon, deciding fn the exception onthe bats of recgniing given fc sia tin ange to able ayn eh inner arate ofthe ban tat characterizes his power, he now defo produc the sisi ara coneeqence fie econ on the exception, Thi shyin he cp che quai rif we local loge seedy dcingohble Gom the guaeris fc, sedi thie soe rer queon conening the lel 0 lepsy of what bap ened hte simply makes oes, Tecan a rdf aw and [sin bith she mtr base oe indingstabe "hannah Arend ocr oberved hain he comp, he principle shar suppor toa ele ad ha common see obtinatly relies to ami comes fly lig his ithe principle coding ‘© which ‘rething i poste” Only bce the camps con we a pace of exception in dhe sete we have eamined in ‘hich not only is bw comple upended ba ft and lw ae amply confused retin inthe camps ly ponte thi pict juidco pola arcrre of the campethe tw of ‘which precy wo rene a nable exception not understood, ‘he incredible things tht happeaed there remain comple una telighle Whoever entered thecamp movedina oa fining: Son beeen ouside and is, exception and ule, anil, in which he very concep of subjective ight nd ur prote tion ao Tooger made any enee What is ror, i the perm ‘tein the cp wa J ad lend ern deed of it Sight a chien Oy the November ews nd was sabquely The Comp Noma? n completely dentonaled a the ine of he Fl Seaton Inso- far ais inhabianes were supped of every pie tats and wholly reduced vo bac fife the emp was alo the mos able bopolical pace ever wo have ben sled, hich power con ons nothing but pore lie, without any mediation. Thi i wy ‘he camp isthe very puadige of polccl space a the point at which pics become bioplii dome acral eons fase wth the ten. The care question eo pose concerning he honors commited inthe camp therefore, nthe hypcrtcl one of how crimes of such atrocity could be commited spine ‘hasan beings. Irwould be motehone and above al, more ef ‘investigate carl the jidical rocedares and deployments af ‘oer by which human ngs could be so completely peed of ‘he hts and prerogatives that no act comed gun them ould apps any longer = rte (A hsp, ace, every ‘hing bad ely bese pone) 74 The bare lif ico which the camp inhibin were cane formed snot however, an extaplitl cetera fc shat le limit config recognising. Ii rates a hea in “which aw constantly pases oer ino fc ada ol ad in ‘which he oo planes become ndingathable Is impossible wo gasp the pei of ce National Soil concept of cen, vith i the pci vaguene and inconsistency cat char ic-if one frp tha the biel boda conten the new fandameetl politi eobjet is ctr» guaeinfs e exee ‘le the ieeieetion of cern binlogicl bod) ot a gueo ‘ar he idetieaon ofa cern jue alte applic but ‘ater the sit of sovereign plzaldecion that open he ‘rol laditincton of facta ve No one expres this pec nature of he new Fundamental biopoiacazgories more cle tha Shiite who in he esay ‘tae, Movement, Ppl” aptorimits the concept of ce, with which "he Naina Soca see could note, ad witha which is jar fe would not be pou” othe “geez and indeterminate cause that had penezted ever oteove im The Can os Prati seply into German ond European lation in she venti century Ie peneating insite the ie we, Senet obser, concep nek a “Food moa ora morn “public secuy and orders of dagen “case of nec” which refer nt to a ule bu to a stuton, rendered obsolete theison ofthat woud prot bealeco replete al css and all tuations and th judges oul hae to Umi chemuehes simply to appving. In moving ceainty and calealabilty ouside he jure rle, thee clases render all judi concept iadeterminace. "In ths ens” Schmit wes, ‘wich unvitingy Kallas cen, toe chee aro sly "admin fori coe. The ie appiion of ses beeen Sj snd Chay The ‘ey formed seme o condemn ut shh sad move (Se fie or th rm round fuel erin ad adhere {helen wich atthe eine il the oud be jae dependence Yee backache oad th Frail ‘pein ow wih wa eget see and opr Tong gs, nce why of comdension. (ip 4)-40 concept such the National Soca notion of ce (0 nde words of Schmit, of "gui of ook) functions at» gene Clase (analogous co “ae of danger” orto "good morale) that ows not er any stuntin of erect but nad edies ts nme coincidence office and law The Judge. the cl Servant orwhoeer dar has rekon wich ich potion a ong erin hil accovding to arle or sean of face. Binding imal solely vo hi own community of eae with the German people and the Fuhr such a petson moves in azonein which he Aisin beeen ifeand pai, beeen question oF fe end ‘qostons ofl has literal ne more meaning 75 Only fom thie pespecive doe the Non Sail he ‘oxytha pois the immedi nd ncinelly pet our flaw in he woed ofthe Faber soquie fl ignfnnc, Jur he word of the Fuhrer nota fcr sation thai hen ean The Camp a: Nomoi, PD me il bt thie ni ing sno de plants faa IS and Germ body cmon eg dando 1) ora et Oogelpcppeaion ea a at se ht ons le sn cof oes ens ‘ie he ef a td “head wvely ipl ahi cpr ben sui otha ean Nee ee byte Faber scaler wnlenosscepe cali Siovnoru fer Thole nds Sees Imani) deco eee poses ‘living nolope ein mse Be, isin andewond irvine Scns ae ‘Sean on ute ch ae pak ca bomen and oh hope dog on engin he ogo fogs does (Cp po) The Fey eting Fringes dclnin of he ereigy ns nso Ugh robo, Patina png) sry Sco, CF pwede hac ed ems ae main Bo oon sn may es He Site of oe song orale we es inden ols eho nnn a ee Catan thwo eh es Threat ong Sets he esos rn heme ofteinene econo ‘lyon (Sah pa) dng lee ‘itor comedy sng be tenn Gem ple pin er ey ee Scenic osha ing apollo pale econ’ tp), i aoe ke ‘etn conn empiri cece ah hecanp ith pera abla inp ey bern sl yl sd pa cnet oe ih cer nay debe em Wht Fon gure cmpofinmn ea essm4 The Campo Peaign individeal biological belonging to dhe Jesh acd) co which he ut apply the dsiminaton ofthe National Socialis rae: On ‘Reconary, every gesture, very eens the emp, om the mos ‘ordinary tothe moet cece enc the dson on bat lie ‘thick theGeemanbopolieal bodys made aoua.Thetepacation the Ji body ithe made production of the pecially ‘German body, uta producon ithe aplication ofthe 16, his is re, the exence of the amp costs in dhe maeiinaton ofthe rate of exeption and in dhe sbsequnt Creton of a space in which bee i and the jd enter ino theshol of inicio, then we mst adic char we Bnd tuber viraly in che presence of camp evry time sch 2 Strcrte created, independent ofthe kinds of cie dae ae omitted thee and whats is denominson and specie w- ography. The stadt in Bait which the alan pb 93 ronal herded alles Abacsnianigran before sending, them bck hi counuy, he wine yce-cing ck ia which the Vichy authorities greed che Je before coniging ther © the Gesmans the Kavarna fr Aadndr in Cots Slow in which the Wena governmea atered Jews efagee fiom the Ese orth sone dant in Pench iteasional i ors in which eget acing for refugee staus are deaina wl thon all equally be ump. nal sere, a aparently nace bu pace (for cramp he Hel Ards in Roissy) actualy de Timi espace in which the normal onder ie de ico suspended and in which whether or no aoc ate come depends not on lew buon the city aod ete sens fee police who rempo- tail ate sovereign (For camo, nthe four day during which Teele ca be el inthe sone date before the intervention of he dial author 177th lig the bh of the camp in ortie appears an coat tn cay sgl the pin epace of moder ile tis produced atthe pone a which the polit sytem ofthe modern nana, which wa founded on the functional ness The Compas Nomet ra bowen a deerminatlcleation (nd anda devine order (he Sa) aed medized by automat ule forthe insipcon of ie (ith othe maton entering ri, and te Sse Asides tase deed the cate ofthe natin logical lifes fone ofits proper racks. fhe sructre ofthe acon sae iin cher word defined by the ther elements Lind ede, ich he rupture of dhe old nem ie peadaced noe in the to pects tat consti ie aczrding wo Shit Goalzaon, Oran dee er, Onde), bt rater ache point sang the instipion of Bare fe ie ie hac thus becomes mason) within the on of them. Somshing can no longer function within the edad mechanisms tat regulate thie inscription, andthe camp i the tw hidden eegltrof che nein of lif in the oner—on rate, the ign ofthese nb artion withou being ‘ransormed inc lel machine Te sigan tha the camp ‘ppt oper with new ls on cent and he denon ination of ezen—aoe ony dhe Nuremberg ews on cnn in the eich bur ak the fs on denaionalaon promulgated by sles ll European sty, inlding France, becween 19s and 193. The saze of exception, which vat exetaly a emporaty ‘spenion ofthe uridne pala order, now becomes a nwa ‘table spt aangement inhabit by ee bse eta ore ad more can no longer be ized in cha ener. The growing lsocaion of bit bate if) and the oto tate ithe ew a of politics incu and what we ll cmp ith djuncson. To an order without oaacon (he ae of excxpin, in which is suspended) dee sow ererponde nelson without order (@be compas permanent space of xepion. The poll sre so loage odes forms of life an juridical ules n= deeinate ‘pace but instead cones a very enters dct alia: Hon ha excende cand int which very form fea evey ele can be virally taken, The camp at daca location the hidden max fhe pics in which we ate tl ving and iit ‘hissserte ofthe camp thi we mat an to ogee all ‘meamoephoes into the sone dente oa sports and certain ‘usin of our cs, The camp sth out, aspera clementze 96 The Campa Paradigm that has now added ie tomand so broken old iniy conpored ofthe tthe oaon (ir), snd ad From th pep he camp hae, ceri ee, eg. peared i a cea exnene form in he ear ofthe emer Ygovia. What happening thee by no eens a8 incseed heres hive ben guk odie «enon of the oll poked arene wcodog sw ele tod etc Srangutat wich omy ating rpetion of pcos at icten te contason of th Eopean sana Arie in the Forme: Yoga, her, an neurbl opie of the ld toma and deca of pputns and man ves lng Sir nor liner ef ight Hoce the deve imgorace of {inc ape ape If he Nace meer oop of cing he Final Solution by aking ons women pean, eben the punch hc red the ein of iin te ode cf {Reon eae wa sll-ifins profoundly enforced vee in openion. The pipe ha nw ened ico» prose of expand dscationIrebecaingncreingy impor rit seco, nde at pe ty ow cant io {lvoe new ad one ut plate dfs ofthe incr fin of ie ie te i. The amp, which i ow ec lodged thin the iy nrg, tbe mew bipal mome of ie ne. Brey imprest poll mening of he em ok sc apn ih hepa arn edn open hg ‘Frolov ines the por the danhte ma the EEE opctam desu beh i cna ie eon hn teat dee oad Eo pin in common see tin pel pce lan ppl Be epg te Sh pl he the ceding we (pol, pp pole odie Lato popula abd pple oe ‘tyes eit oth he ome eas a9 witay Folie ty inthe ian pogo the peoples je nde ‘bus ofthe lowes ds bon pop ne polio (Ppl) fea Englah wor "pope whi rs ke een eEtening il conse the no-one icon 0 The Gang es Nonor 7 ‘he ch and she nb In the esa Contino one dh witout ary tino, "Wedbe people ce Unie Se” Ye wen nc ivokes 2 “Gorement ofthe pepe bythe pel fo the (plein the Geysborg Aes the eran pct oppor he Fs epi wo anuher eople” ut how eal abi mas ‘en ding the Fech Reon (a ya pci the pte ick cin wee mae fo he pipe of poplar sverspn) ‘bow by he dace le led competion Bre png uner ‘ood a oh ede ds Ane ced the wry deen te ‘ord wa born ou of ompasia, andthe tm baa th eles Fermidrcne and wbuppvess—i pple Je males mispndir smtasTobepiee wis wont ey, Lpeapl ur maw teen ‘Sty ane othe es scien nd mor oer gare of te Reva ‘on ul pute" (On Ration p70) Bat inte chp fod ‘Rijahivin which demaay orth fat opal sei ce concept ‘eed due the larry the pup eno ented whe mp nmwnkr coadcaig fom mle pty ctostananoe Sih ifs nd constant sean apy aot be ime eer an unlial ier in bent and con othe once "peop in Weer police Irian we lpg wer Ine ot nay saber but ise onlaon beeen to pose paler on theone han, hfe Repl sa wake pola Wy aon he ocr he saben of the peoples» fgesny lpi of ely pd ened bodies or pom he oa ard Incafon sheet Besta anon te oer am con it aly bapa atone ete, he osteo negated snd sr ‘stl teen nd the ete, te pcr of ae or ‘amp-ofthe etc hopped nd ceded hse ‘gland compact rent ft the one’ en Sous ee ‘nywhere te my Finder pale concep nln th ‘apes dhe Umoncof Abad Pad ore. Dumont here ‘ean peopl ia pala eneepe ta diatera double monet {nd samples relation bereen oo execs, Buh ay a ‘heconsrto afte human pea opal body par eg Fendamenal vin and tin the concep’ wecan cy ie bacon pa tt me ve on ee teal poi. ‘sewoute bar li (pnp nd pole exisenes (Prop eaon sd indie 2¥and The pol” thus sale eePy The Camp Pea ‘dima sl ace whine ei wh at ein Ste hwo ich pron secon he ‘ritchie nded Hee cnn Saabeichigveuwenyemibescntdon pn poy ike pul ee ev sys day sad yt ae Gules bree iste pret ey deny Soma bw eccorinaly bred ant pet trv oxknon epg Seeded end Oem pone pla be Pop’ vet Eby cea king te lf and we enn ele oes tien sn iene anh epee nee Tino ethene tsp ore evosee ene TShclowe tc jecsnnd brane evel tone Su lonsAgehectonend Sewn tgnacterione popes e pope tapering tt of fen ey a can ol wor Sar es mo ‘ely ey cof da he see pe tod a ‘Socveri soe ec un ny ey. When oe sk ad Sr nar Mar edd ar ce” cap ch et wi bn tage von ely deed Se ee rey pl aa ‘Sreb on tt cay wen ie cen dey he meni igi pe und frp loc and ew og yy ay ope TAS ir fe fecle melee te Reel ‘opel fice win ial thn wl Be pombe rend ean {die pops ofthe iy fo canary inne vy Fo he upg ween tes pepl” wat erent a nde Wyn orci tucpereneeda na pcaynal aceon, fn Roe ie ied dea of be re mi cay ail ye dee ‘roan beeten ppd le exch i om i ‘Sheard naa jatar inthe Middle Ages te dsincon brea the ipl mma ante pls peopel t 8 pest ringer ats ad wade Baan with he Fech Heo hon noe bens the sl deposary of svelgny the pepe 8 (tmigmed ine an embursing psec, ae mir ad eclason ‘te inwenay as, ple mat feral he cof sisted copper pp plete comer cad The Camp a Nea 119 sp. fr the ft sine aan shaper intleie si Te he ‘mle eer ad xls neo enti oi co ‘ips bur ele poll ego al ennai anal {Sp dat sam odoin macen plies sal ave poll tnd even plaice). thse ou eg thing bt the impale nd mao enanps v0 recone the dvson ding the peopl, 1 emia ‘ately the people dat i exuded "Thas steps ing Sng zag diftene moda and hasonsRightand Le opeaia ‘ured ii coun wich uid in tpi ‘Sine at sah se bat which ha bee paral reed a all Indusied counti—ofprofuing nl ad wide people The steam with ewopment arf Ut te ‘coins wh the opal ca per pede undid people “The nmin of the Jee Neck Gemany angus iy silicic fit. A be pole te sto be eg So th aon oil body Ge meed hr every ation scl ol sell the Jer the repre pr eae ‘od als he vig tol of te pope ado be tc et oder secretes within ul but whe pro mo [ingle in ny wa Ard we mus the ener pie fhe Taal ug that vie Pegl aepeople i the ad ry wh sh the Germ Vll-rprnerine pr exclne of he Rl > ‘tole pall hody—soughe to line the Jere With he Fal Solon ich dik not by cane ile Gy and eb ho coul orb ipa) sm uty ana elope Ee. ‘eth poll ene fh We for he olen doin rer te pode the Gasman Vlas th pope hat aly overcame cig fal bopolial face (This hy che Nas ade so cistely ‘ted at a cing Jer and Gp thy wee sal ho ‘king for he tr ropa people) roping te Ren pee on the ign hen oes 1 gor old hy hat ner pale appre by he pce ‘coring hich“ Whee hare ae i tee wel avo Be = eopt=on ondon ha one imei 4 ta the pails ‘lds aver lan "Ware tora People ae il be tre "The fea tat wi ele to hae een overcame By cling the pele he Jews who pal thas podsvee 80 The Comp a Parag elf nem wansoiog te enite Geran people io «sce He enacted dean blob he a be inti ‘ued (ough th liana of te mena i and the eae othe dee. And in rn yer maou wy, dy ‘ncrcr cpt pj of cinaing the poor cae omg derlopnent ote educa eps aiscded ‘ut ao uansfounsche ene population of the Td Wold i be |e Ony » pois tat wil hve lene ote the finde ‘pale cae of the ein scout wile al op th ‘lation do pun end eth cl wn dvi the peopled Seeii ofhce § Threshold ‘Thee theses have emerged 2s provisional conclusions in the crs ofthis inguiy + Theorigina political ration ithe ban the stat of exception ‘zon of inditincio between outide ad nde, exclusion and ‘acho. 2. Thefundameotl ceo ovecign power isthe production of bare ie ax originry politcal clement and a tested of trian Bereen nature and elute, sé and bite 1 Today ic noe the cy but eather the camp that isthe fundamental biopic paradigm ofthe Wes “Te fis ofthese these cll int qusion every theory ofthe ‘contractual origin of ate power and, lon wih every ate 10 round politcal cram in meshing likes "belonging" sheet be founded on pop atioa, clio or any ore ‘eniy. The seond thes impli dha Were pols abi lis fom the very beginning nd hac every temp o fad oli iberes in tego the tien i chetfoe. i vain, “The thin hess, finally tons sais Highton te model by which scl scenes, cology aba studi, and chtecere today oe tying wo conaire ad orgnze che public space of the ‘wo ce without any dear vatenes that chek very center lies the same breif (een fi har been ened nd ered