Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Once or twice per day at school, Melissa will pick up an object from
her desk at throw it on the floor with an unknown level of force. This is a
critical behaviour to address as it puts the safety of Melissa, her
classmates and her teachers at risk of serious injury.
Leaving the classroom
Once or twice per day at school, Melissa will stand up and leave the
classroom to go to the library or playground. This behaviour has been
recognised as of higher priority than verbal aggression as Melissas
teacher has a duty of care over Melissa. Melissa could be putting herself in
danger when she is not in sight of school staff.
Verbal aggression
Four to five times per week at school, Melissa will threaten to kill
other children, tell Rosey she hates her, and growl threateningly
towards someone or no one. This behaviour warrants intervention because
as a consequence it may contribute to Melissa being perceived negatively
by others, deprived socially or being excluded from community settings
(Emerson & Fox, 2010).
The frequency of Melissas behaviours have been noted however for
a more in depth analysis of Melissas behaviour this FBA and PBSP would
benefit from knowing more about the dimensions of the behaviour and all
locations where the behaviours do and do not occur (Umbreit, 2007). The
more details known about Melissa will mean that the plan can be more
individualised to fit her needs (Crone & Horner, 2003). If I was directly
observing Melissa I would use the Functional Assessment Hypothesis
Formulation Protocol in Larson and Maag (1998) to assess each behaviour
in depth and write definitions that were more specific, observable and
measurable.
Setting Events and Antecedents
Self-regulation
The setting events include Melissas sense of competitiveness. The
antecedent is where Melissa is not seen as the best at something. She is
negatively reinforced for this behaviour as she does not have to admit to
her mistake, but also punished as her behaviour does not achieve the
intended outcome.
Tangible
The antecedent is where she has been denied access to a desired
activity. Her initial behaviour does not achieve the intended outcome but
may have been positively reinforced previously. In the second instance, it
is positively reinforced as she gets to keep the basketball.
Social attention
Cluster
Escape: Avoiding a non-preferred
Behaviour of Concern
Melissa said you cant make me!
task or activity
Self-regulation: To self-manage
lost
Melissa growled at teacher and
emotional over-arousal
floor
Melissa told the girls she hated
activity
Hypotheses
When Melissa is at school and asked to engage in a non-preferred
task or activity, she will verbally refuse to engage, throw an object on the
floor, leave the classroom and/or push the person making the request with
sufficient force in order to avoid participating in the non-preferred task or
activity.
When Melissa is not seen as the best at something, she will growl,
deny that she is not the best, threaten classmates and throw objects on
the floor in order to self-regulate her emotions.
When Melissa is denied access to a preferred activity, she will
display verbal aggression towards her teacher and/or classmates, kick
6
On the next page is a table of options consisting of the three mostreinforcing boxes that were checked for Melissa on her Reinforcement
Inventory. The blue shaded boxes indicate animal-related activities. Yellow
indicates reading-related activities and green indicates school-related
activities.
Much interest
A fair amount of
Eurovision
interest
Ice cream (vanilla,
Computer games
sweet)
Bicycle/bike riding
chocolate)
Cake
Video games
Watching TV (animal
Cookies
Visiting a place of
documentaries)
Watching movies
interest (city/museum)
Amusement park
Chess
Swimming
Zoo
Ping pong
Tennis
Science
Scrabble
Hiking
Physical Education
Singing
Competitive games
Math
Musical group
Animal puzzles
Vacation
Airplane ride
Earning money
teacher
Girl scouts, clubs
Having a pet
friends
Reading
Repairing or building
Looking at books
Listening to stories
Magazine subscription
Spelling
Attention in a group
Going to school
recorder
Not being nagged
Grades
Doing homework
Opportunity to select a
job
Stars on a chart
Money
Special badges
Exception from a
Accumulation of marbles
domestic activity
Plan the days activities
or chips
Points
Meeting chairperson
Numbers
Period with no
Theatre tickets
monitoring
Certificates
Antecedent Management Strategies
The implementation of antecedent management strategies are
important as research shows that behaviours of concern are more likely to
9
Differentiation
Rosey can make adjustments to non-preferred activities through
differentiating instruction, content, and process and product (Neitzel,
2010). When designing activities from the curriculum, Rosey can use the
REACH program to design lessons that correlate with Melissa and her
peers readiness level, interests, and preferred mode of learning
(Tomlinson, 2004; as cited in Rock, Gregg, Ellis, & Gable, 2008; Rock,
Gregg, Ellis, & Gable, 2008). Rosey can use the REACH program to help
her learn more about Melissa and how she perceives experiences and
events at school (Horner, Sugai, Todd, & Lewis-Palmer, 2000).
Modelling
10
Rosey can use other students as role models, sit Melissa next to a
good role model, and through video self-modelling where Melissa is seen
working on a non-preferred activity, acting appropriately and receiving a
good mark (Kansas Mental Health Positive Behavior Support, n.d.). A social
story could be made for Melissa based on the task analysis for her
replacement behaviour (Appendix D) or desired behaviour. This process
can be reinforced for Melissa through forward chaining where the
replacement behaviour is taught in its naturally occurring order.
Prompting
The use of prompts will enable Melissa to have an opportunity to
respond appropriately to a situation and receive reinforcement accordingly
for demonstrated the replacement or desired behaviour (Vardas, 2009).
Once Rosey has established an environment with clear expectations about
appropriate behaviours through the use of video modelling and social
stories, she can then prompt Melissa through visual and verbal prompts
(Kansas Mental Health Positive Behavior Support, n.d.). Timing prompts
can be an important antecedent, such as just prior to a non-preferred
activity her teacher could prompt Melissa about the appropriate response
for not wanting to participate (Neitzel, 2010; Vardas, 2009; Kansas Mental
Health Positive Behavior Support, n.d.).
11
Reinforcement protocols
Melissas short-term goal will be the first focus of reinforcement in
order for Melissa to still be able to escape from non-preferred activities.
Melissa will be able to avoid non-preferred activities through the use of
the break card (Appendix F) and use of the cool down box. Over time, the
time Melissa is allowed to spend on break will decrease therefore
increasing the incentive for Melissa to engage in a desired behaviour.
To reinforce Melissas desired behaviour, a classroom pet will be
introduced to increase the incentive for Melissa to be in the classroom and
used as a choice of reinforcement for her. An additional benefit of a
classroom pet is that they can enhance the socio-emotional development
of children (Friedmann, 2000; NIH, 2009; as cited in Meadan &
Jegatheesan, 2010). In addition to the class pet, Melissa will be given a
Puzzle Piece Reinforcement Chart similar to that in Appendix E (The
Communication Window, 2011).
If I was able to observe Melissa, I would record the average time she
spent participating in non-preferred activities. On the assumption that
Melissa participates in non-preferred activities once per day for ten
minutes, I would begin reinforcing her participation half way through this
time. When Melissa follows directions and completes non-preferred tasks
for five minutes she will receive a piece of a puzzle that makes an animal.
When the animal puzzle is complete, Melissa will be allowed 10 minutes of
free time. Initially, the puzzle will have two pieces but over time will
increase in number.
Melissa will be reinforced on a schedule of Differential
Reinforcement of Incompatible Behaviour (DRI) in order to substitute
leaving the classroom and displaying aggression for desired behaviours
(Schloss & Smith, 1998). Initially Melissa will be reinforced on a fixedinterval schedule and over time the intervals will increase by a few
minutes.
12
Skill development
A Competing Pathways Analysis (Appendix H) is used to connect the
FBA and PBSP in order to increase the efficiency, efficacy and relevance of
the PBSP (Crone & Horner, 2003). Melissas replacement behaviour is to
appropriately ask for a break and use the cool down box to select a
short-term activity to complete. This skill will be taught through the use of
the model-lead-test method whereby the teacher will use direct
instruction, modelling, demonstrations and prompts to encourage the
replacement behaviour (Horner, Sugai, Todd, & Lewis-Palmer, 2000). The
eight steps of the model-lead-test method can be seen in Appendix I for
the teacher to use with examples of classroom applications for Melissa
(UNC School of Education, n.d.).
Melissas desired alternative behaviour is for her to follow directions
and complete non-preferred activities at school. To achieve this goal,
Melissa needs to improve on her social and coping skills. This can be
achieved through mindfulness practice which can be learnt as a class and
provide an opportunity for Melissa to build relationships. Both social and
coping skills can be taught through social stories, which complements
Melissas love for reading. Research has found social stories to help
individuals identify the appropriate social cues and responses when
reacting to a situation (Schneider & Goldstein, 2010).
De-escalation strategies
13
14
Mediator/staff supports
The team involved in implementing this program will be all people
who directly work with Melissa, including Rosey, her mother and other
teachers, and the school counsellor. Additionally, a person with
behavioural expertise in conducting FBAs and implementing PBSPs. The
incorporation of administrative authorities can assist in supporting and
making recommendations about personnel, resources, time and more.
Finally, Melissa will be involved and informed about expectations, goals
and rewards, and given the chance to ask questions (Sugai, Lewis-Palmer,
& Hagan-Burke, 2000; Crone & Horner, 2003).
Challenges may arise in implementing the PBSP where the
strategies to implement are not contextually fit with Melissas team and
environment. Considerations need to be made in regards to the practical
constraints of time, resources, finances, skills, facilities, attitudes, and
beliefs (Crone & Horner, 2003). The contribution of Melissas team in both
planning and implementation is important so it fits suitably within the
school context (Horner, Sugai, Todd, & Lewis-Palmer, 2000).
Final comments
Difficulties may arise with the teacher not having time to monitor
Melissas behaviour and therefore self-monitoring, different prompts and
skills may need to be taught and used instead. Rosey should also be
cautious that she is not unintentionally rewarding problem behaviour
(Horner, Sugai, Todd, & Lewis-Palmer, 2000). Tools and techniques will
need to be added to plan for maintenance and generalisation.
Melissas team can access free workshops, information and
resources on the Positive Partnerships website which aims to support
school age students on the autism spectrum (Partnerships between
Education and the Autism Community, 2014). Additionally, the Kansas
Institute for Positive Behavior (sp) Support can be used for training in FBAs
and PBSPs (Kansas Institute for Positive Behavior Support, 2012b).
15
Word Count
FBA: 1163 words
PBSP: 1579 words
Total: 2742 words
References
Crone, D. A., & Horner, R. H. (2003). Designing a behavior support plan.
Building positive behavior support systems in schools: functional
behavioral assessment (pp. 55-69). New York, USA: Guilford Press.
Emerson, E., & Fox, P. (2010). Positive Goals for Positive Behavioural
Support: Interventions to Improve Quality of Life for People with Learning
Disabilities Whose Behaviour Challenges. Brighton, England, United
Kingdom: Pavilion Publishing.
Hewett, D. (1998). Commentary: managing incidents of challenging
behaviour - principles. Challenging behaviour: principles and practices
(pp. 67-87). London, England: David Fulton Publishers.
16
Horner, R. H., Sugai, G., Todd, A. W., & Lewis-Palmer, T. (2000). Elements
of Behavior Support Plans: A Technical Brief. Exceptionality: A Special
Education Journal, 8(3), 205-215.
Kansas Mental Health Positive Behavior Support. (n.d.). Examples of
Antecedent Interventions. Retrieved June 8th, 2015, from
<http://kmhpbs.org/sites/kmhpbs.org/files/awareness_supplements/buildin
g_pbs_plans_handout.pdf>
Kansas Institute for Positive Behavior Support. (n.d.b). Scatter Plot
Assessment Tool. Retrieved June 9th, 2015, from
<http://www.kipbs.org/new_kipbs/fsi/files/scatterplot-abc%20analysis.pdf>
Kansas Institute for Positive Behavior Support (2012). Funcitonal
Behavioral Assessment Interview Form. Retrieved June 9th, 2015, from
<http://www.kipbs.org/new_kipbs/fsi/files/Functional%20Assessment
%20Interview.pdf>
Kansas Institute for Positive Behavior Support. (2012b). Training Materials
from the Kansas Mental Health and Positive Behavior Support (KMHPBS)
Project. Retrieved June 10th from
<http://www.kipbs.org/kmhpbs/index.html>
Larson, P. J., & Maag, J. W. (1998). Applying Functional Assessment in
General Education Classrooms: Issues and Recommendations. Remedial
and Special Education, 19(6), 338-349.
Makin, P. J., & Hoyle, D. J. (1993). The Premack Principle: Professional
Engineers. Leadership & Organizational Development Journal, 14(1), 1621.
Meadan, H. & Jegatheesan, B. (2010). Classroom Pets and Young Children.
YC Young Children, 65(3), 70-77.
Neitzel, J. (2010). Antecedent-based interventions for children and youth
with autism spectrum disorders: Online training module. Chapel Hill, NC:
17
19
Appendix A
Appendix B
ABC Observation Data Sheet attached as separate document
20
Appendix C
When Im bored
I will
When Im frustrated
I will
Appendix D
Task analysis for feelings of frustration or boredom
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Stand up
Pick up break card
Walk to teacher
Give to teacher
Go to cool down box
Open box
Select activity
Complete activity in time limit
Return to lesson
Appendix E
21
Appendix F
Appendix G
22
Physical
Verbal
Leaving
Using
calm
Receiv
and
aggressio
aggressio
classroom
break
down
es
time
card
box
puzzle
piece
23
Appendix H
Appendix I
24
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
25
Example: Note home to Melissas mum about her progress using the new
skill, encouragement to use it at home.
26