Sunteți pe pagina 1din 4

Reviewers Guide

PART A:
SECTION I
Reviewers Name:
E-Mail:
Manuscript Number:
Title:

The linkage between Corporate Social Performance and the


Corporate Financial Performance in the ICT Multinational
Companies of Romania

Authors:
Date Sent To Reviewer:
Date Expected From Reviewer:

Waddock and Graves


26 martie 2015
10 aprilie 2015

PART B: Reviewer Only


SECTION II: Comments per Section of Manuscript

General comment:

Introduction:

Methodology:

Results:

Acest articol i propune s prezinte n linii mari, tendinele de


dezvoltare la nivel mondial ( ICT ), punnd accent pe pie ele n
cretere din Europa Central i de Est, Orientul Mijlociu, Asia de Est,
i n special din Romnia.
n nceputul articolului ne sunt prezentate principalele tendin e de
dezvoltare precum: inovaia n tehnologia mobil, acces dinamic de
la PC la telefoane mobile, convergena n furnizarea de servicii,
inovaie n dispozitivele personalizate, de consum bazate pe evolu ia
web, pieele emergente, pieele n curs de dezvoltare, ducnd astfel
la creterea concurenei n sectorul ICT.
Ceea ce ar putea impiedica dezvoltarea sectorului ICT ar fi
urmatoarele: schimbrile climatice, libertatea de exprimare, via a
privat i securitatea, dezvoltarea economic.

Se bazeaz pe o analiz a modificrilor pe termen scurt n pre urile


de vnzare , ca un proxy pentru performana firmei n urma unui
eveniment CSR.
Rezultatele au variat de la a prezenta o rela ie negativ ntre CSR i
performana firmei (neexistnd astfel nicio legatur), la o rela ie
pozitiv.

Acest studiu, a ncercat s raspund la ntrebarea dac performan a


social a unei companii este legat de performan a sa financiar, i
dac da, care este efectul acestui fenomen.

Discussion:

Waddock i Graves ( 1997) demonstreaz c ipotezele de cercetare


sunt validate de ctre modelul econometric construit pe o analiz de
regresie multivariat a indicelui social ( luat din baza de date KLD ) i
rezultatele financiare ale unui grup de 400 de companii din SUA.
Panoul de companii multinationale ICT din Romnia , reprezentat
statistic de indicatorii sociali i de contabilitate , par s aib o
structur ideologic i strategic diferit, comparativ cu e antionul de
companii americane analizate de Waddock i Graves.

SECTION II (Cont.)

Business for Social Responsibility (2008), The Contribution the ICT Industry
Can Make to Sustainable Development - A Materiality Assessment by the
Global eSustainability Initiative, April, p. 1-44
Frantzen, S (2012), CEEand MEA Regions: Understanding the Impact of
Technology Transition on Growth Opportunities in Emerging Markets, IDCs
47th Annual Industry Business Briefing
McWilliams, A., Siegel, D. and Wright, P. M. (2006). Corporate social
responsibility: Strategic Implications, Journal of Management Studies, 43:1
January, 1-18
PAC - Pierre Audoin Consultants (2011), Software and IT Services Industry
Bibliography/References: Verticals: Public Sector Worldwide - Sector Overview, Part 2: Poland, Portugal,
Romania, Russia, Slovakia, Spain, Switzerland, Turkey, UK, USA, p.14
Samson, D. and Popescu, L. (2010), Market Analysis: Romania IT Services
Market 2010-2014 Forecast and 2009 Vendor Shares, IDC #ES06S, Volume: 1,
p. 1
Waddock, S. and Graves, S. (1997). The corporate social performance
financial performance link. Strategic Management Journal, 18, 30319
Wood, D. (2010), Measuring Corporate Social Performance: A Review,
International Journal of Management Reviews, DOI: 10.1111/j.14682370.2009.00274.x

Others:

www.majorcompanies.ro
www.desprefirme.ro

Decision:

SECTION III - Please rate the following: (1 = Excellent) (2 = Good) (3 = Fair) (4 = poor)
Originality:
Contribution To The Field:
Technical Quality:
Clarity Of Presentation :
Depth Of Research:

1
2
1
2
2

SECTION IV - Recommendation: (Kindly Mark With An X)

Accept As Is:
Requires Minor Corrections:
Requires Moderate Revision:
Requires Major Revision:
Submit To Another Publication Such As:

Reject On Grounds Of (Please Be Specific):

SECTION V: Additional Comments


Asupra acestui studiu a putea face un comentariu general, iar acela ar fi, c
articolul a fost unul ct se poate de clar,i nu a fost nevoie s caut alte surse
din care s neleg ideea principal ce i-a propus articolul s ne-o ofere.