Explorați Cărți electronice
Categorii
Explorați Cărți audio
Categorii
Explorați Reviste
Categorii
Explorați Documente
Categorii
SERIE NOU
XIII
2015
PEUCE
SERIE NOU
XIII
STUDII I CERCETRI
DE ISTORIE I ARHEOLOGIE
TULCEA 2015
ISSN: 0258-8102
Adresa / Address:
Website:
http://www.revistapeuce.icemtl.ro/
Redactor ef / Editor-in-chief:
Cristian MICU
Sorin-Cristian AILINCI
Camelia KAIM
CU P RI NS / SU M MA R Y
Motto:
Cte pturi de prundi s-au aezat aici din viaa popoarelor din trecut? Istoria cea mai detaliat n-ar fi n stare s o
descrie cu acea acurate cu care vorbete mozaicul arheologic din aceste pturi. i cte de aceste ruine aflm pe
teritoriul ntreg locuit de Romni, care n cea mai mare parte-s nc necunoscute tiinei. S le dispreuim ca lucruri
fr de nici o valoare i s aruncm obiectele aflate n ele ntr-o parte? Sau s le adunm i s le conservm pentru
tiin? i numrul acestor ruine de pe teritoriile locuite de Romni e foarte mare i mai fiecare an descoper noi, cci
aici n aceast parte a Europei vandalismul popoarelor a fost aa de mare, nct chiar ruinele au fost acoperite de rn,
peste care cresc acum arbori seculari. nsemntatea lor pentru tiin e foarte mare. S ne nchipuim toate aceste ruine
dezgropate dup sistemul sus artat i am vede imense comori preioase scoase la iveal pentru tiin. Tot pmntul
Daciei ni s-ar nfia n goliciunea aceea, ce pare a ne insufla privirea lui de astzi. Atunci ne-ar apare fiecare obiect,
ce l-am scoate din mozaicul pturilor acestor ruine prundie, ca o scul mare, pentru a crei conservare am tremura i
ne-am da toat silina de a aduce cu tiina pozitiv n concordan i a-i da explicaia ce i se cuvine. N-am mai
mpinge-o din dispre cu piciorul, ci am sruta-o ca o rmi scump a unui trecut glorios al rii noastre. Toate
aceste lucruri le-am compara cu obiectele ntrebuinate de noi i n diferina lor am cuta s gsim progresul omenirii
i al nostru.
(Dionisie Olinescu, Convorbiri arheologice. Cu privire la romni, n Familia, XXV, 18/30 iunie 1889, p. 292)
Abstract: This study aims to put emphasis for the first time on a chapter in the long and
fascinating history of Cucuteni culture in Bucovina. This historic region that existed for 143 years (17751918), administered at first by the Habsburg Empire, followed by the Austrian-Hungarian Empire, draws
special interest. Here, in a small and remote Austrian province, remarkable finds surfaced, being part of
both Romanian and Austrian archaeology and of European historiographic landscape. The exceptional
value of the prehistoric sites and artefacts from Bucovina ascribed to Cucuteni civilization drew the
interest of Vienna authorities that, following the early practices, sent their best specialists to catalogue,
research and publish the finds. The catalysts were The Central Commission for the research and
conservation of the historical and artistic monuments/Zentralkommission fr Erforschung und
Erhaltung der Kunst-und historischen Denkmale and The Anthropology Society/Anthropologische
Gessellschaft, through their professionals and prestigious publications (Jahrbuch and
Mittheilungen).
The publication in Vienna in 1899 of the impressive monography Die sterreichisch-ungarische
Monarchie in Wort und Bild. Bukowina where Josef Szombathy published a documented chapter entitled
Muzeul Bucovinei, tefan cel Mare 33, 720003, Suceava, Romnia, niculicab@yahoo.com.
PEUCE, S.N. XIII, 2015, p. 7 - 44
Vorgeschichte, amply presenting the prehistoric finds in Bucovina, crowns researches of both Austrian
specialists and Romanian cultural figures in Bucovina over several years.
Karl A. Romstorfer, Raimund F. Kaindl and Josef Szombathy carried out meritorious work of
recovery and publication of the unearthed archaeological material, therefore we may consider them real
pioneers of Cucuteni culture research. Thanks to them and to some warm-hearted Romanian or Austrian
researchers born in Bucovina, of whom we selectively mention Dionisie Olinescu, Constantin Morariu,
Vasile Tomiuc, Vasile Arici, Emanuel de Costin, Otto Petrino, Josef von Gutter, Heinrich Klauser,
Cucuteni vestiges of impressively beautiful shapes and painted motifs were unearthed, drawn, restored
and exhibited in the museums of Vienna and Chernivtsi. The foundation of the two archaeological
societies in Bucovina Society of the Museum of Siret and the Romanian Archaeological Society of
Chernivtsi along with the set up in 1875 of Franz Joseph University of Chernivtsi (1875) and of the
Museum of the Country of Bucovina (1893) had a major impact not only on prehistoric research, but
also on the conservation, display and publication of the discovered archaeological materials. All these
data, synthetically presented in this study, are part of the pioneering phase of archaeology, the phase of
recovery of the first vestiges of Cucuteni culture in Bucovina. Although at that time (second half of the
19th century) their discoverers did not know its real name, the value of the information transmitted to
present times is extraordinary.
Rezumat: Studiul de fa i propune evidenierea, n premier, a unui fragment din
ndelungata i fascinanta istorie a culturii Cucuteni, din cuprinsul provinciei Bucovina. Acest spaiu
istoric, cu o existen de 143 de ani (1775-1918), administrat la nceputuri de Imperiul Habsburgic,
ulterior de cel Austro-Ungar, prezint un interes aparte; aici, ntr-o mic i ndeprtat provincie
austriac s-au fcut descoperiri remarcabile, care fac parte nu doar din istoria arheologiei romneti i
austriece, ci i din ansamblul peisajului istoriografic european. Valoarea excepional a siturilor i a
obiectelor preistorice din Bucovina, dovedite mai trziu ca aparinnd civilizaiei cucuteniene, a
suscitat interesul autoritilor vieneze, care, conform practicilor acelor timpuri, a trimis pe cei mai
buni specialiti s le repertorieze, s le cerceteze i s le publice. Factorii determinai au fost, firete,
cele dou instituii de anvergur din Viena: Comisia Central pentru cercetarea i conservarea
monumentelor istorice i de art / Zentralkommission fr Erforschung und Erhaltung der Kunstund historischen Denkmale i Societatea de Antropologie / Anthropologische Gessellschaft, att
prin specialiti, ct i prin prestigioasele lor publicaii (Jahrbuch i Mittheilungen). Totodat,
apariia la Viena, n anul 1899, a impresionantei monografii Die sterreichisch -ungarische
Monarchie in Wort und Bild. Bukowina, n care Josef Szombathy public un capitol documentat,
intitulat Vorgeschichte, n care sunt prezentate pe larg descoperirile preistorice din provincie,
reprezint ncununarea unor cercetri care au durat mai muli ani i la care au contribuit att
specialiti austrieci, ct i oameni de cultur romni din Bucovina.
Astfel, Karl A. Romstorfer, Raimund F. Kaindl i Josef Szombathy, au desfurat o activitate
meritorie, de recuperare i publicare a materialelor arheologice descoperite, ei putnd fi considerai
adevrai pionieri ai cercetrii culturii Cucuteni. Datorit lor, dar i unor inimoi cercettori romni
sau austrieci, unii nscui n Bucovina, dintre care amintim selectiv pe Dionisie Olinescu, Constantin
Morariu, Vasile Tomiuc, Vasile Arici, Emanuel de Costin, Otto Petrino, Josef von Gutter, Heinrich
Klauser, vestigiile cucuteniene, care i-au impresionat prin frumuseea formelor i a motivelor pictate,
au fost recuperate din adncul pmntului, desenate, restaurate i expuse n muzeele din Viena i
Cernui. n acelai timp, fondarea celor dou societi de arheologie din Bucovina: Societatea
Muzeului Siret i Societatea arheologic romn din Cernui, alturi de nfiinarea, n 1875, a
Universitii Francisco-Josefine din Cernui (1875) i a Muzeului rii Bucovinei (1893), a
avut un impact major n ceea ce privete nu doar cercetarea preistoriei, ci i a conservrii, expunerii i
publicrii materialelor arheologice descoperite. Toate aceste date, nfiate sintetic n intervenia de
fa, fac parte din etapa de pionierat a arheologiei, de recuperare a primelor vestigii aparinnd culturii
Cucuteni din cuprinsul Bucovinei, i, chiar dac la timpul acela (a doua jumtate a secolului al XIXlea) descoperitorii lor nu i-au cunoscut numele adevrat, valoarea informaiilor transmise pn la
noi, peste timp, este nepieritoare.
Keywords: Eneolithic, Cucuteni civilization, Bucovina, history of archaeology, Society of the
Museum of Siret, Romanian Archaeological Society of Chernivtsi, Museum of the Country of Bucovina.
Cuvinte cheie: eneolitic, civilizaia Cucuteni, Bucovina, istoria arheologiei, Societatea
Muzeului Siret, Societatea Arheologic Romn din Cernui, Muzeul rii Bucovinei.
10
Pl. I.
Personaliti ale arheologiei din Bucovina sec. al XIX-lea, al cror nume se leag de
cercetarea vestigiilor aparinnd culturii Cucuteni / Personalities of archeology in 19th
century Bucovina linked to the research of Cucuteni culture vestiges.
11
corespondeni. Acest lucru s-a ntmplat i n cazul Bucovinei, pentru care s-a
stabilit un numr de trei conservatori i cinci membri corespondeni, care aveau
drept atribuii identificarea, repertorierea i publicarea datelor referitoare la
diversele categorii de descoperiri, fie ele de monument (biserici, mnstiri, situri
arheologice, cimitire) sau mobile (vestigii arheologice de genul: ceramic, piese de
cupru, bronz, monede, tezaure, documente istorice .a.) 2. Cel dinti conservator al
Bucovinei, numit de Comisia Central n anul 1856, a fost Andreas Mikulicz, n ale
crui atribuii intrau repertorierea descoperirilor arheologice i identificarea siturilor
ce urmau a fi investigate 3.
Trecnd n revist etapa de pionierat a arheologiei din Bucovina, remarcm
activitatea unor reprezentani ai intelectualitii romneti, care au dorit nfiinarea
unor instituii de anvergur (naionale i nu numai), dedicate acumulrii, conservrii
i prezentrii artefactelor caracteristice diferitelor domenii ale tiinei din acea
vreme: arheologie, istorie, numismatic, art, tiinele naturii etc. 4 Astfel, amintim
pe: Aron Pumnul, Eudoxiu Hurmuzachi i George cavaler de Costin, care au
urmrit nfiinarea unei societi arheologice n Bucovina, care s adune toate
descoperirile arheologice, fie de la colecionari, fie de pe urma spturilor, obiectivul
principal fiind acela de a nfiina un Muzeu Naional al provinciei. Toate aceste idei,
care se fceau auzite prin vocea unor oameni importani, fie politici, fie de cultur,
i-au gsit o susinere complementar n msurile pozitive, culturale, ale Imperiului.
Astfel ne explicm faptul c n Bucovina au aprut cu uurin, n scurt timp,
societi arheologice i instituii specializate 5. De asemenea, cercetarea arheologic
din Bucovina a fost girat calitativ i instituional, prin nfiinarea Societii Muzeului
Siret (1870), a Universitii din Cernui (1875), a Societii arheologice romne din
Bucovina (1886), a Muzeului rii Bucovinei din Cernui (1893) i a Muzeului orenesc
Suceava (1900). n cadrul acestor organizaii i instituii i-au desfurat activitatea
personaliti marcante ale vieii culturale din provincie: Josef von Gutter, Dionisie
Olinescu, Constantin Morariu, Karl A. Romstorfer, Raimund F. Kaindl, Simion
Florea Marian, Iraclie Porumbescu, tefan Repta, Animpodist Dachevici, Josef
2
4
5
Denumirea i atribuiile celor trei seciuni n care erau organizai conservatorii, aa cum au
fost ele gndite de Comisia Central din Viena, erau: seciunea I-a, pentru monumentele
preistorice, antice i cele din timpul migraiilor, pe lng aceasta pentru monedele din toate
timpurile; seciunea a II-a, pentru monumentele medievale i contemporane, cu excepia
celor scrise; seciunea a III-a, pentru monumentele scrise medievale i contemporane.
Niculic 2009, 26-27; Niculic 2013, 532; Niculic 2013a, 489, 497-498. Listele cu membrii
corespondeni i conservatorii pentru Bucovina au fost periodic publicate n Mittheilungen
der Central-Commission, precum i n Jahrbuch des Bukowiner Landes-Museums (Cernui).
Niculic 2013, 517-533.
Costin 1865, 12; Emandi 1985, 19-20; Olaru 2002, 79; Jumar 2005, 86; Niculic 2009, 28-29.
12
Fleischer, Vasile Morariu, Victor Prelicz, Heinrich Klauser, Dimitrie Isopescu, Franz
A. Wickenhauser, Franz cavaler Des Loges i muli alii 6. Acum, mai ales n ultimul
sfert de veac al sec. al XIX-lea, multe dintre descoperirile preistorice din Bucovina
sunt prezentate n diverse publicaii ale vremii, fie ele din provincie, din
Transilvania, din Regat (Bucureti) sau din capitala Imperiului: Jahrbuch des
Bukowiner Landes-Museums / Anuarul Muzeului rii Bucovinei (Cernui), Gazeta
Bucovinei, Patria, Czernowitzer Zeitung, Czernowitzer Wochenblatt, (Cernui), Revista
politic (Suceava), Voina Naional i Buletinul Societii Geografice Romne (Bucureti),
Familia (Oradea), Amicul Familiei (Gherla), Tribuna (Sibiu), Mittheilungen i Jahrbuch
der Central-Commission i Mittheilungen der Anthropologischen Geselschaft 7.
n cadrul interveniei de fa ncercm s evideniem descoperirile aparinnd
civilizaiei cucuteniene din Bucovina, despre care trebuie spus c, la vremea respectiv
(a doua jumtate a sec. al XIX-lea), au strnit admiraia i interesul tiinific al tuturor
celor care au avut prilejul s intre n contact direct cu producia ceramic, despre care
s-a remarcat n epoc, c reprezint un nalt nivel artistic. Punctm mai puin
personalitile, ntruct aceasta s-a fcut deja, ntr-un context mai larg8.
Este, ntr-adevr, dificil de apreciat care sunt primele vestigii cucuteniene
descoperite pe cuprinsul provinciei Bucovina. Cu puin indulgen am putea
accepta c unele toporae de piatr lefuit, perforate i neperforate, descoperite
nainte de 1870 aparin acestei strlucite civilizaii. Aceste informaii interesante i
aparin arheologului amator, baronul Otto von Petrino (1834-1884), fost conservator al
Comisiei Centrale din Viena pentru seciunea I-a (1870-1879), care a avut i unele
preocupri de geologie9. n scrisorile trimise de el din Sadagura, la 26 mai 1870, ctre
Franz von Hauer, membru al comitetului de redacie al revistei Mittheilungen der
Anthropologischen Gesselschaft in Wien (revista Societii de Antropologie din Viena,
nfiinat n 1870), apar referine despre topoarele de piatr descoperite la Kisseleu
(astzi Kiseliv / rom. Chislu, raion Kicman / rom. Cozmeni, regiunea Cernui,
Ucraina), Mamornia (astzi n raionul Hera, reg. Cernui), Suceava i Cernui (n
7
8
9
Ignat 1969, 93-a104; Emandi 1985, 14-33; Niculic 2009, 17-115; Niculic 2013, 517-522;
Niculic 2013a, 490-491
Niculic 2009, 17-18; Niculic 2013, 520-521.
Niculic 2009, 27-115; Niculic 2013, 517-533; Niculic 2013a, 487-502; Niculic 2014, 495-508.
A publicat n Jahrbuch der geologischen Reichsanstalt, Viena (1868, 1875). Vezi Kaindl 1893, 7274; Kaindl 1896, 5 i nota 2; Sbiera 1904a, vol. III, 577; Niculic 2009, 27 i nota 47; Niculic
2013, 523-524; Niculic 2013a, 491.
13
Pl. II. Prima pagin a studiului Charta archeologica a Bucovinei / First page of the study Charta
archeologica a Bucovinei (Olinescu 1894).
10
11
14
Pl. III. Harta arheologic a Bucovinei, publicat la Bucureti de Dionisie Olinescu / Archeological
map of Bucovina, published in Bucharest by Dionisie Olinescu (Olinescu 1894a).
15
n acei ani, un rsunet local i central l are activitatea lui Josef Eduard Ritter
von Gutter (1809-1886), fost primar al Siretului (Pl. XI/2-3), militar de carier, arheolog
i numismat amator, pe care l putem considera a fi primul arheolog al Bucovinei12. Josef
von Gutter a avut iniiativa de a fonda, n anul 1870, Societatea Muzeului Siret, prima
societate arheologic din Bucovina; menirea ei era de a colecta diverse obiecte pentru
viitorul Muzeu al rii Bucovinei (acesta a fost deschis la 14 mai 1893, sub numele de
Muzeul rii Bucovinei din Cernui). Activitatea sa rodnic a determinat numirea lui
n calitate de conservator al Comisiei Centrale din Viena n perioada 1880-1885, pentru
seciunea I-a. Alturi de faptul c a redactat, n manuscris (din pcate acesta s-a
pierdut), o cronic istoric a oraului Siret, von Gutter este descoperitorul primelor
monumente arheologice, care, mai trziu, vor fi atribuite culturii amforelor sferice de pe
teritoriul Romniei (mormintele de inhumaie n cutie de piatr de pe Dealul Iancului
de la Grniceti, jud. Suceava) i al primelor depozite de bronzuri din Bucovina:
Prelipca i Priscreni (azi n reg. Cernui). Alturi de aceste importante descoperiri,
el a menionat, cu mult zel, diverse obiecte preistorice, inclusiv neolitice din
Bucovina, cu predilecie pe cele din zona oraului Siret, unde a activat n cea mai mare
parte. Astzi, n coleciile Muzeului Bucovinei din Suceava (secia Muzeul Siret), se mai
pstreaz o statuet antropomorf feminin, aparinnd culturii Cucuteni, descoperit
de Gutter n zona crmidriei Beill de la Siret, la 2 m adncime; aceasta reprezint
prima descoperire aparinnd culturii Cucuteni din Bucovina, care a fost publicat (Pl.
XI/1a-b)13. A publicat n presa cernuean: Czernowitzer Zeitung, Czernowitzer
Wochenblatt i n Mittheilungen der Central-Commission (Viena)14.
Dispariia lui Josef von Gutter n primvara anului 1886 a produs un gol n
cercetarea arheologic din Bucovina. Se punea problema att a continurii activitii
neobositului arheolog amator, ct i a salvrii coleciilor adunate cu trud ani n ir. n
acest context, n acelai an apare, la Cernui, Societatea Arheologic Romn, fondat de
12
13
14
Despre Josef von Gutter vezi: Prelicz 1886, 31-32; Revista politic, I, nr. 7, 15 august 1886,
9; Reli 1927, 10-13; Gassauer 1933; Andrieescu 1936, 163, 169; Ignat 1969, 94-95; Satco
2004, I, 468; Niculic 2009, 29-35; Prelicz 2011, 74-77, 128-131; Niculic 2013, 524-525;
Niculic 2013a, 491-492.
*** Notizen. 135, in Mittheilungen, X. Jahrgang, N.F., 1884, CCXXIV i fig. 7.
Notiele respective din Mittheilungen der Central-Commission reprezint rapoarte (informri)
sintetice, uor modificate fa de forma lor original, ntocmite pe baza rapoartelor i drilor
de seam ale lui Josef von Gutter (*** Notizen. 21. Vom Serether Museum-Verein, in
Mittheilungen, VI. Jahrgang, N.F. 1880, LXXVI; *** Notizen. 45. (Die Hnengrber von
Graniczestie), in Mittheilungen, VI. Jahrgang, N.F. 1880, LXXXV; *** Notizen. 49, in
Mittheilungen, VII. Jahrgang, N.F. 1881, LXXX; *** Notizen. 135, in Mittheilungen, X. Jahrgang,
N.F. 1884, CCXXIV i fig. 7; *** Notizen. 121, in Mittheilungen, XI. Jahrgang, N.F. 1885, CXVII
i fig. 8 de la p. CVXI).
16
un alt arheolog amator, de aceast dat romn, Dionisie Olinescu (1852-1924) (Pl. I/1).
Am avut prilejul, recent, s ne oprim pe larg asupra activitii lui Dionisie Olinescu i
a societii sale15. Datorit meritelor sale deosebite, rezultat deopotriv al cercetrii de
teren, dar, mai cu seam de cabinet, D. Olinescu a fost numit membru corespondent al
Societii Geografice Romne (1886) i membru corespondent al Comisiei Centrale din
Viena (1891). A avut o susinut activitate publicistic, pe teme de istorie, geografie,
numismatic, fiind prezent i cu intervenii numeroase n pres, n special n revistele
de la Sibiu (Tribuna), Gherla (Amicul Familiei), Oradea (Familia), n care a prezentat
reportaje i sinteze ale vieii culturale din Bucovina, fcnd cunoscute totodat
descoperirile arheologice din provincie. A mai colaborat la Voina Naional
(Bucureti), Jahrbuch des Bukowiner Landes-Museums, Junimea Literar i Gazeta Bucovinei
(Cernui), Buletinul Societii Geografice Romne (Bucureti)16. Cea mai important
oper a sa este legat de activitatea de repertoriere a descoperirilor arheologice din
Bucovina, concretizat n publicarea studiului intitulat Charta arheologica a Bucovinei17
(Pl. II), i a reprezentrii cartografice a descoperirilor arheologice de pe teritoriul
provinciei18 (Pl. III), unicat pentru arheologia romn a acelor vremuri. Att n textul
studiului, ct i pe hart, regsim numeroase informaii referitoare la distribuia i
poziionarea obiectivelor arheologice din Bucovina, multe dintre acestea, conform
descrierilor, aparinnd civilizaiei cucuteniene (statuete antropomorfe, topoare de
piatr, ceramic).
Pe Dionisie Olinescu l-au interesat, n mod firesc pentru acele timpuri,
manifestrile spirituale ale vieii omului preistoric, aa cum le nelegea el, ilustrate
prin intermediul ceramicii pictate i a reprezentrilor antropomorfe. El a rmas,
printre altele, impresionat de vestigiile arheologice descoperite nc din timpul
activitii lui Josef von Gutter, n zona Zamca a localitii Siret (astzi n jud. Suceava).
Astfel, ntr-un articol din Voina Naional (Bucureti, 1886)19, el considera c staiunea
de la Siret Zamca este una din cele mai interesante staiuni preistorice ale Bucovinei
i a ntregii Dacii, fiindc st n strns legtur cu celelalte pn acum descoperite
15
16
17
18
19
Morariu 1888-1891, 245-247, 304-305; Morariu 1893, 242-243, 304-309; Sbiera 1904, vol. III, 53;
Loghin 1926, 262; Predescu 1999, 614; Ignat 1978, 513-520; Vatamaniuc 1996, 17-32; Satco,
2004, vol. II, p. 151-152; Niculic 2008, p. 5; Niculic 2009, p. 73-115; Niculic, 2013, p. 525526; Niculic, 2013a, 492-493.
citm selectiv: Olinescu 1876, 442; Olinescu 1876a, 550; Olinescu 1884; Olinescu 1885, 186187; Olinescu 1885a, 190-191; Olinescu 1885b, 460, 462; Olinescu 1885c, 625; Olinescu 1886, 23; Olinescu 1886a, 37; Olinescu 1889, 271; Olinescu 1894, 64-94; Olinescu 1894a, 3-10.
Olinescu 1894, 64-94.
Olinescu 1894b.
Olinescu 1886, 2-3.
17
staiuni ale Daciei, cu Piscul-Crsani, Vdastra, din Romnia i Turda din Ardeal i
mrturie netears pentru nrudirea popoarelor preistorice din Bucovina cu celelalte
ri ale Daciei Vechi. Autorul descrie cu lux de amnunte descoperirile de pe Zamca:
la trei metri adncime, fuseser observate zone cu pmnt ars, cu cenu i crbuni, n
care s-au descoperit dou topoare de piatr, cuite de cremene, coarne ascuite, dini
de la animale antediluviene, oase de psri, unelte de cusut ca ace de os, fierstraie
din flcile petilor, unelte de estur cu greutatea statuii de lut rou i uscat numai la
soare i secar calcinat20. El remarc descoperirea cu totul deosebit, reprezentnd,
dup toate indiciile, o depunere ritual, aparinnd civilizaiei Cucuteni: dou oale
mari de lut rou i una mic ce erau decorate cu felurite semne geometrice i umplute
cu cenu de la oameni mori. Mai multe ulcele din lut rou, de o nlime de 7 cm i
de o lime de 6 cm le nconjurau la o deprtate de 25-36 cm, care erau pn la una
toate stricate; n ele se afla o mas neagr cleioas. Vasele acestea erau fcute numai cu
mna, fr roat i uscate la soare. Hrburi din aceste ulcele s-au scos pn acum pn
la o sut. ntre acestea se aflase i un idola mic fcut din lut rou, fr roat, numai cu
mna. E de 4 cm lung21. Capul lui e diform semnnd mai mult unei buhe i prul se
ascuete ntr-un triunghi; e fr mini i fr picioare i pntecele e format ca la o
femeie nsrcinat, avnd pe el un semicerc ntors spre sus. Pe cap i n cealalt parte a
corpului se afl guri, desigur pentru introducerea de ace, sivare, spre a fi purtat ca
amulet. Fr a intra n prea multe detalii, mai amintim c Olinescu vedea analogii
potrivite pentru frumoasa statuet de la Siret n descoperirile de la Vdastra, PisculCrsani i Turda, dintre care unele prezentau aceleai orificii ca piesa de la Siret. El
cosider c toate aceste reprezentri aparin unei zeiti feminine, o Venus, ce era
venerat de ctre popoarele Daciei, invocnd, totodat, similariti cu alte
descoperiri, mult mai ndeprtate, ca cele efectuate de H. Schliemann la TroiaHissarlik i Micene. D. Olinescu remarca faptul c statueta prezenta un corp de femeie
nsrcinat, indicndu-se astfel marea fecunditate a vieii, semnele de pe pntecele ei,
ca semicercul i triunghiul fiind socotite embleme religioase ale fecunditii
femeieti: idolul de la Zamca din Siret ne reprezint deci o Venus, care, dup
exteriorul ei i simbolurile ei religioase, arat mult senzualitate nedesfrnat a
populaiei de atunci22.
Fr a fora lucrurile, ne ntrebm dac am putea invoca anumite analogii
pentru descoperirea, credem remarcabil, de la Siret. Astfel, notm c la Ghelieti
(jud. Neam), au fost descoperite ase vase pictate, dispuse n cerc, n jurul unui alt vas
20
21
22
Olinescu 1886, 3.
n realitate nlimea statuetei este mai mare: 9 cm (pl. XI/1b).
Interesant ni se pare maniera de judecare istoric, cu privire globalizatoare, la toat
Dacia (Olinescu 1886, 3).
18
Pl. IV. Ceramic pictat aparinnd culturii Cucuteni, descoperit la ipeni / Painted ceramic
ascribed to Cucuteni culture, discovered at ipeni (Romstorfer 1893, fig. 29-31).
23
24
25
19
dintre marii arheologi ai Europei acelor timpuri: Josef Szombathy (1853-1943) (Pl. I/2).
Date biografice amnunite au fost deja publicate de Angelika Heinrich de la
Naturhistorisches Museum din Viena26, la fel i n ceea ce privete activitatea sa de
cercetare a vestigiilor arheologice ale Bucovinei 27, astfel c punctm doar cteva
momente importante. Josef Szombathy a studiat Polithenica la Viena, a avut
preocupri de botanic, paleontologie, mineralogie, petrografie (a participat la
cursurile marilor profesori Andreas Kornhuber i Ferdinand von Hochstetter,
devenind mai apoi asistentul acestuia din urm n 1874). Geologia i-a fost predat de
Eduard Suess, iar geografia fizic de Friedrich Simony. A participat i la celebrele
cercetri arheologice de la Hallstatt (Austria), coordonate de Ferdinand von
Hochstetter. La momentul sosirii sale n Bucovina, Szombathy acumulase deja o vast
experien de birou, teoretic, dar i una practic, ceea ce i adusese promovarea n
funcia de custode al coleciei de antropologie i preistorie a Muzeului de Istorie
Natural / Naturhistorisches Museum din Viena, precum i aceea de membru al
Societii de Antropologie din Viena (numit n 1879)28, societate care fusese fondat
puin mai devreme, n 187029.
ntr-un studiu din 2014 ne-am referit pe larg la prezena lui Josef Szombathy, n
cursul anilor 1893 i 1894, n Bucovina 30. Privitor la recunoaterile sale arheologice din
provincie menionm c exist doar patru mrturii documentare semnate personal 31.
Astfel, primele trei au fost publicate sub forma unor rapoarte de mici dimensiuni, n
anuarul Muzeului rii Bucovinei din Cernui / Jahrbuch des Bukowiner LandesMuseums, dup cum urmeaz: n 1894, nr. II Prhistorische Recognoscierungstour nach
der Bukowina im Jahre 1893, pag. 11-21; n 1895, nr. III Zweite Recognoscirungstour in die
Bukowina, pag. 20-24; n 1896, nr. IV Zweite Recognoscierungstour in die Bukowina, pag.
131-135, acesta din urm fiind de fapt o reluare a textului publicat n anul precedent.
Cea de a patra contribuie a lui Szombathy, reprezentnd o reuit sintez a
cercetrilor i a concepiilor sale istorice, privitoare la descoperirile strvechi din
Bucovina, dateaz din anul 1899, fiind publicat sub forma unui capitol dstinct, n
celebra lucrare monografic, de dimensiuni impresionante Die sterreichisch-ungarische
Monarchie in Wort und Bild. Bukowina (Viena, 1899). Acest capitol, intitulat de Josef
Szombathy sugestiv Vorgeschichte / Preistorie, rmne, pn astzi, un document unic
pentru descoperirile preistorice din zona noastr. Alturi de aceste izvoare
26
27
28
29
30
31
20
32
33
21
Pl. VI. Descoperiri cucuteniene din Bucovina: amforete, vase bitronconice, capac de tip coif
suedez, vas-binoclu. Ceramica pictat provine din cunoscuta aezare de la ipeni.
Unele topoare de silex aparin probabil civilizaiei Amforelor Sferice / Cucuteni finds in
Bucovina: small amphorae, biconical vessels, Swedish helmet lid, binocular-shaped vessel. The
painted ceramic was found in the famous settlement of ipeni. Certain flint axes are probably
specific to the civilization of the Spherical Amphorae (Szombathy 1899, 51).
22
Pl. VII. 1. Itinerariul lui Josef Szombathy n Bucovina, toamna anului 1893; 2, vase de tip
binoclu descoperite n aezarea cucutenian de la ipeni (Ucraina) / 1. Josef
Szombathys itinerary in Bucovina, in autumn 1893 (Niculic 2014, 507, fig. 5); 2.
binocular-shaped vessels found in the Cucutenian settlement of ipeni (Ukraine) (Much
1902, 120, fig. 1-4; Niculic 2011, 303, fig. 4).
34
35
23
Pl. VIII. Descoperiri aparinnd civilizaiei Cucuteni din aezarea de la ipeni (Ucraina):
plastic antropomorf, zoomorf, vase-binoclu, ceramic pictat i nepictat, msualtar cu patru picioare, ceramic de tip Cucuteni C, greuti, fusaiole, vrf de sgeat
de silex, diverse piese os / Finds belonging to the Cucuteni civilization in the settlement of
ipeni (Ukraine): anthropomorphic, zoomorphic plastic art, binocular-shaped vessels, painted
and not painted ceramic, small four legged altar table, Cucuteni C ceramic, weights, spindle
whorls, flint arrowheads, various bone items (Kaindl 1903a).
24
36
37
38
39
40
25
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
26
consistent prin mai multe localiti din Bucovina: tefanovka 48 (tefanovca, distr.
Coman la acea vreme n.n.), unde a studiat colecia de piese preistorice a lui Ioan
cavaler de Zotta; n cltoriile sale, efectuate cu trsura, a fost nsoit de Karl A.
Romstorfer la: Sadagora (Sadagura), Waslowce (Vslui, distr. Cernui pe atunci),
Kukzurmik (Cuciur Mic), Zastawna (Zastavna), Kadobestie (Cadobeti, distr.
Coman), Kriszczatec (Criciatec, distr. Coman) i Zwiniacze (Zviniace, distr.
Coman)49, din aceast ultim localitate i din colecia lui Ioan Zotta fiindu-i
prezentate numeroase piese neolitice50. La Kotzman (Coman) i-a fost prezentat un
vas de lut pictat provenind de la ipeni, asemntor cu altul gsit la Doroui pe
Nistru51. n ncheierea raportului dedicat cercetrilor din 1894, Szombathy noteaz c
vestigiile arheologice descoperite prezint un interes deseobit, provincia Bucovina
avnd o valoare etnografic deosebit, el spernd ca n viitorul apropiat s poat
detalia informaiile obinute52. Aceste detalieri nu au ntrziat s apar: contactul lui
Josef Szombathy cu antichitile Bucovinei a fost unul pozitiv, concretizat prin
apariia capitolului Vorgeschichte / Preistorie, din impresionanta monografie Die
sterreichisch-ungarische Monarchie in Wort und Bild. Bukowina (Viena, 1899)53. nsoit de
o frumoas ilustraie, realizat de artistul vienez Theodor von Ehrmanns (Pl. V/1; VI),
autorul a sintetizat aspectele privitoare la descoperirile preistorice cunoscute n acel
moment n Bucovina. Vizibil emoionat de succesul, ineditul i importana european
a spturilor de la ipeni, Szombathy le dedic acestora un spaiu amplu n economia
capitolului. Tocmai de aceea, cteva dintre vasele aparinnd culturii Cucuteni de la
ipeni (subliniem nc o dat c la momentul respectiv nu se cunotea acest termen),
au fost ilustrate n textul su (Pl. VI). Din text reiese ct de mult a dorit Szombathy s
neleag cele mai vechi urme de locuire uman din Bucovina, din aa-zisa perioad
primitiv, creia i aparineau unelte de piatr i oale de ceramic, alturi de
felurite unelte de os. El ia n consideraie importana aezrilor neolitice
descoperite n Bucovina, dintre care, pe primul loc, n opinia sa, l ocup locuinele
cercetate la ipeni pe malul Prutului. Szombathy remarc tehnica de construcie a
acestor locuine din timpurile strvechi, vorbind despre colibe mici neolitice, cu
pereii realizai din nuiele mpletite i mbrcate cu lut, cu acoperiul din paie sau
stuf, oferind i o surprinztoare analogie, aflat la ndemn: aa cum exist i astzi
la ar. De asemenea, el atrage atenia asupra unor descoperiri de excepie ca de
48
49
50
51
52
53
Pentru denumirile localitilor existente n acea vreme vezi i: Werenka 1895; Grigorovitza 1908.
Szombathy 1895, 21; Niculic 2014, 504.
Szombathy 1895, 21; Andrieescu 1936, 166; Niculic 2014, 504.
Szombathy 1895, 21-22; Andrieescu 1936, 166; Niculic 2014, 504.
Szombathy 1895, 24.
Szombathy 1899, 49-56.
27
exemplu: oalele uneori mai mari de jumtate de metru, castroane ntinse sau
adnci, precum i minunate stative duble (de fapt cunoscutele vase-binoclu).
Despre toate aceste el remarc: au fost lucrate manual, din lut foarte fin i c au fost
pictate cu maro nchis sau rou nchis, amintind spiralele i formele geometrice.
Ilustraia capitolului Vorgeschichte include i o frumoas statuet antropomorf (Pl.
V/1, dreapta jos)54.
Un alt personaj-cheie n dezvoltarea vieii culturale i tiinifice a Bucovinei, cu
implicaii majore n cercetrile arheologice din Bucovina a fost reputatul arhitect
austriac Karl A. Romstorfer (1854-1916) (Pl. I/3), istoric i arheolog deopotriv55.
Romstorfer a fost conservator pentru Bucovina al Comisiei centrale din Viena (seciunea
a II-a) ncepnd cu anul 1888 i membru corespondent strin al Academiei Romne (29
mai 1914). S-a remarcat i printr-o activitate publicistic meritorie, care a cuprins att
descoperirile eneolitice, ct i cele aparinnd epocii bronzului i fierului sau cele
medievale56.
Karl A. Romstorfer a participat la numeroase cercetri arheologice (spturi),
dar i la excursii de documentare (vezi mai sus cazul Szombathy) 57, n general
contribuia sa la dezvoltarea i diseminarea cunotinelor despre arheologie i despre
rezultatele cercetrilor din Bucovina, aparinnd pre- i protoistoriei Bucovinei fiind
puin cunoscute cercettorilor romni58. Alturi de multe alte iniiative, cum sunt
preocuprile privitoare la restaurarea monumentelor istorice medievale ale provinciei,
menionm contribuia sa decisiv la fondarea Muzeului rii Bucovinei din Cernui
(1893) i a Muzeului Orenesc Suceava (1900)59. Activitatea sa meritorie i-a adus i
poziia de secretar al Muzeului rii Bucovinei, n aceast calitate Karl A. Romstorfer
propunnd editarea periodicului Jahrbuch des Bukowiner Landes-Museums. n aceast
publicaie el a semnat rubrica Aus den Mittheilungen der k.k. Central-Commission fr
Erforschung und Erhaltung der Kunst und historischen Denkmale, n care a rezumat
54
55
56
57
58
59
28
rapoartele Comisiei Centrale din Viena, aprute n Mittheilungen i Jahrbuch der CentralCommission, menionnd, printre altele, descoperirile aparinnd culturii Cucuteni, de
la ipeni, Siret sau din alte localiti. A fost unul dintre colaboratorii apropiai ai lui
Josef Szombathy n timpul cercetrilor sale din Bucovina din anii 1893 i 1894,
participnd i la spturile din staiunile de la ipeni, Hliboca i Hlinia 60. Despre
descoperirile de la ipeni, Karl A. Romstorfer a publicat un succint raport n
Mittheilungen der Central-Commission61, intitulat sugestiv Gefsse aus Schipenitz / Vasele
de la ipeni. Aflm de aici c nvtorul din sat (Vasile Arici n.n.) a descoperit multe
vase interesante de lut, n momentul cnd a nceput lucrrile la grajdul din
gospodrie; el a spat o groap mai adnc pentru un stlp de lemn i a gsit un strat
de argil (lut) ars a crui margine nu a gsit-o, nici dup ce a mrit groapa la 2 m n
diametru. Sub acest strat au fost descoperite ulterior fragmente ceramice provenind de
la vase ntregibile. Profesorul Kolbenheyer i baronul Nicolae Musta (membru n
curatoriul Muzeului rii Bucovinei n.n.)62 au luat cteva oale i strchini. Este
descris interesantul decor pictat desenat cursiv cu pensula, cu grosimi diferite: linii
circulare care se ntretaie i se ncolcesc, la oale fiind pictat doar jumtatea
superioar (Pl. IV/1-2); de asemenea, aici s-a descoperit i un cuit de silex cu lungimea
de 9 cm, limea de 2 cm i grosimea de 0,5 cm63.
Raimund Friedrich Kaindl (1866-1930) (Pl. I/4), unul dintre marii profesori ai
Universitii din Cernui este bine cunoscut pentru studiile sale de etnografie i
istorie privitoare la Bucovina. A fost membru n curatoriul Muzeului rii Bucovinei
din Cernui, decan (1910, rector al Universitii din Cernui (1912-1913), membru
corespondent (1898) i conservator (1909) al Comisiei Centrale din Viena64. De
asemenea, Raimund Kaindl s-a remarcat prin pasiunea pentru arheologie, n special
pentru descoperirile preistorice de la ipeni. Kaindl este autorul uneia dintre
importantele lucrri de sintez referitoare la istoria Bucovinei: Geschichte der Bukowina
(Cernui, 1896), n care prezint, printre multe altele, descoperirile preistorice
cunoscute la acel moment n provincie. A avut o via deosebit de activ n peisajul
cultural, n general i cel arheologic, n special, participnd la spturile de la ipeni
alturi de Josef Szombathy i nvtorul Vasile Arici (1893), relund ulterior
60
61
62
63
64
29
65
66
67
68
69
70
Citm selectiv: Kaindl 1893; Kaindl 1894; Kaindl 1894a, 115-116; Kaindl 1896; Kaindl 1898,
236-237; Kaindl 1901, 47-48; Kaindl 1903, 82-84; Kaindl 1903a, 97-114; Kaindl 1904, 17-44;
Kaindl 1908, 144-150; Kaindl 1910.
Kaindl, 1896, 12.
Kaindl, 1896, 12.
Kaindl, 1896, 12.
Kaindl, 1903, 102-114.
Kaindl, 1903a, 102.
30
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
31
32
vasului se observa jar. Avnd n vedere observaiile generale, autorul are n vedere
existena unei locuine care a suferit un incendiu puternic 88. Interesant este observaia
lui Kaindl: n apropierea acestui loc care pstreaz urmele unui incendiu violent a
avut loc o srbtoare, cteva oale de mici dimensiuni, cu oase i cenu, gsite n
apropierea podelei de lut ars, ngropate n cas, conducnd spre ipoteza unei
ceremonii funerare. El mai arat c lng oala de mici dimensiuni, care coninea oase
arse, la 20-30 cm sub stratul de lut ars, au fost gsite: un vas-binoclu ntreg, patru
jumti de vas-binoclu, care nu se potrivesc unele cu altele, o jumtate de vasbinoclu, o oal de mici dimensiuni i un capac; sub toate aceste rmie a fost
descoperit o bucat de os puterd. Kaindl ajunge la urmtoarea concluzie: sub
podeaua de lut era o groap, n care au fost adunate toate obiectele sus menionate,
considernd c dei fragmentare, obiectele nu au fost aruncate, ci aezate cu grij n
groap. Aceste obiecte erau utilizate n cadrul unor obiceiuri, iar Kaindl, n virtutea
cunotinelor sale etnografice, menioneaz un obicei foarte interesant, cunoscut la
populaia huul din Bucovina: spargerea intenionat a unei oale, pentru a alunga
rul, n acest scop nefiind aleas oala cea mai bun 89. Concluzionnd, R. F. Kaindl
susine c este vorba despre un loc de nmormntare, ncercnd i o reconstituire a
scenariului funerar: defunctul era incinerat, cenua i resturile oaselor erau adunate
ntr-o oal, care era aezat lng celelalte anexe, ndeosbi lng numeroasele vasebinoclu, ntr-o groap puin adnc. Apoi, aceasta era acoperit cu buci de lut ars, se
mai aplica un strat consistent de lut i se aprindea focul, pentru a ine departe
animalele. Se pregtea mncare pentru ospul mortului. Acest lucru este dovedit de
mulimea vaselor, mari i mici (precum pahare pentru butur), care au fost
descoperite n partea sudic a aezrii (de la ipeni n.n.). Cutnd cteva analogii
pentru acest gen de descoperire, cu defunctul incinerat i acoperit cu lut galben,
Kaindl amintete cercetrile lui K. Hadaczek (cercetrile de la Zelechow i Niesuchow
din Galiia)90.
n ncheierea acestor rnduri consacrate profesorului Raimund F. Kaindl i
contribuiei sale la cunoaterea culturii Cucuteni din Bucovina, nu putem dect s
afirmm c avem n faa noastr unul dintre arheologii cu o puternic intuiie a
realitii din teren. Observaiile sale minuioase, ncercrile de reconstituire i
nelegere a construciilor, a utilizrii practice a inventarului arheologic, a destinaiei
rituale a unor complexe arheologice ni-l nfieaz pe profesorul Kaindl ca un
veritabil cercettor al preistoriei europene.
88
89
90
33
Pl. IX. 1-7. Ceramic descoperit n aezarea cucutenian de la ipeni (astzi n reg. Cernui,
Ucraina) / 1-2. Ceramic found in the Cucutenian site of ipeni (nowadays in the region of
Chernivtsi, Ukraine) (Kaindl 1904).
34
92
93
94
Wurzer 1911, 63-67; Satco, 2004, II, 579; Ungureanu 2006, 25; Ungureanu 2007, 77, 83, 88;
Niculic 2009, 38 i nota 96; Niculic 2011, 293-303; Niculic 2013, 531; Niculic 2013a, 496;
Fodor 2014, 418-420.
cf. ***, Mittheilungen, 1908, III. Folge, VII. Band, p. XV; Wurzer, 1911, 67.
Niculic 2011, 296 i nota 21.
***, Notizen. 57, in Mittheilungen, XVI. Jahrgang, N.F., 1890, 133; ***, Notizen. 40, in
Mittheilungen, XXVI. Jahrgang, N.F., 1900, 105; Much 1902, 120-121 i fig. 1-4)
35
provinciei. A absolvit Facultatea de Teologie din Cernui, ulterior devenind preot paroh
la Bdeui, Miliui i Rdui. Alturi de scrierile sale referitoare la istoria mnstirilor
Bucovinei, menionm c a luat parte, alturi de profesorul Heinrich Klauser, la unele
cercetri de teren din depresiunea Rdui, precum i la primele spturi din necropola
tumular de la Volov (jud. Suceava)95. Meritele sale au fost evideniate prin
nominalizarea, n anul 1898, ca membru corespondent al Comisiei Centrale96. Dei
activitatea sa n domeniul preistoriei este minimal, artm totui c a descoperit vestigii
preistorice n albia prului Sucevia, afluent de dreapta al Sucevei97. ntmplarea a fcut
ca numele preotului Vasile Tomiuc s fie legat de una dintre cele mai frumoase piese
specifice lumii eneolitice: sceptrul cruciform de la Bdeui, sincron cu sfritul fazei
Cucuteni A faza Cucuteni A-B, pstrat astzi n coleciile Muzeului Bucovinei din Suceava
(Pl. V/1, 2 a-b). Piesa a fost reprezentat grafic n cunoscutul studiu intitulat Vorgeschichte,
semnat de Josef Szombathy, din cadrul cunoscutei monografii Die sterreichisch-ungarische
Monarchie in Wort und Bild. Bukowina (1899), grafica fiind semnat de Theodor von
Ehrmanns (Pl. V/1)98.
Pl. XI. a-b. Reprezentare antropomorf feminin descoperit de Josef von Gutter la Siret; b. Foto S.
Igntescu, 2008 / a-b. Anthropomorphic feminine representation discovered by Josef von Gutter at
Siret (*** Notizen. 135, in Mittheilungen, X. Jahrgang, N.F., 1884, fig. 7); b. Photo by Sorin
Igntescu, 2008.
95
96
97
98
36
Pl. XII. 1. Placa de pe mormntul lui Josef von Gutter; 2. Monumentul funerar al cpitanului
Josef von Gutter, fost primar al Siretului, din cimitirul catolic de la Siret / 1. plate on Josef
von Gutters tomb; 2. funerary monument of captain Josef von Gutter, former mayor of the town
of Siret, in the catholic cemetery of Siret.
37
38
39
Bibliografie
Andrieescu, I. 1936, Cercetri i descoperiri arheologice n Bucovina, Cronica
Numismatic i Arheologic 12, 105, ianuarie-martie, 161-173.
Andrieescu, I. 1943, Bucovina i Basarabia n lumina arheologiei, Analecta 1, 3-33.
Boghian, D., Mihai, C. 1987, Le complexe de culte et le vase dcor ornithomorphe peint
dcouverts Buznea (dp. de Iai), n Petrescu-Dmbovia, M., Ursulescu, N.,
Monah, D., Chirica, V. (eds.), La civilisation de Cucuteni en contexte
europen, BMA 1, Iai, 313-324.
Costin, G. 1865, Anunu, Foaea Soietii pentru literatura i cultura romn n
Bucovina 1, nr. 6, 1 iunie, Cernui, 12.
Demciuc, V. M. 2006, Karl Adolf Romstorfer, restaurator al monumentelor istorice din
Bucovina, Crai Nou, Suceava, nr. 4286, miercuri, 18 octombrie 2006, 5.
Emandi, I. E. 1985, Muzeul de Istorie Suceava, Bucureti.
Fodor, L.-M. 2014, nvmntul gimnazial de stat n Cernuiul Habsburgic: evoluie i
importan, Analele Bucovinei 21, 2 (43), 411-431.
Gassauer, R. 1933, Briefe Gutters an Wickenhauser, Bukowiner Heimatbltter,
herausgegeben von A. Nibio, Radautz, Jahrgang I, Heft 2-3.
Grigorovitza, Em. 1908, Dicionarul geografic al Bucovinei, Bucureti.
Heinrich, A. 2003, Josef Szombathy (1853-1943), Mitteilungen der Anthropologischen
Gesellschaft in Wien 133, Viena, 1-45.
Ignat, M. 1969, Din istoricul cercetrilor arheologice din judeul Suceava, Studii i
Materiale. Istorie 1, 93-104.
Ignat, M. 1978, Dionisie Olinescu, Suceava 5, 513-520.
Ignat, M. 1978a, Necropola tumular de la Volov Dealul Burlei, Suceava 5, 107-140.
Ignat, M. 2006, Necropolele tumulare din zona Rdui n cadrul lumii traco-getice (sec. VIIV a.Ch.), Trgovite.
Jumar, D. 2005, Societi culturale academice romneti din Bucovina n perioada
interbelic, Iai.
Kaindl, R. F. 1893, Die Anthropologische Gesellschaft in Wien in ihrem Verhltnisse zur
Bukowina, Jahrbuch des Bukowiner Landes-Museums 1, Czernowitz, 72-74.
Kaindl, R. F. 1894, Der rumnische archologische Verein in der Bukowina, Czernowitz.
Kaindl, R. F. 1894a, Notizen. 77 (Bericht ber im August 1893 in der Bukowina
vorgenommene prhistorische Forschungen), Mittheilungen 20. Jahrgang,
N.F., 115-116.
Kaindl, R. F. 1896, Geschichte der Bukowina. Erster Abschnitt. Von den ltesten Zeiten bis
zu den Anfngen des Frstenthums Moldau (1342), Czernowitz.
40
Kaindl, R. F. 1898, Notizen. 119 (Funde in der Bukowina), Mittheilungen 24. Jahrgang,
N.F., 236-237.
Kaindl, R. F. 1901, Notizen. 17 (Archologische Unterschungen zu Wassilen und Panka in
der Bukowina), Mittheilungen, 27. Jahrgang, N.F., 47-48.
Kaindl, R. F. 1903, Bericht ber die Ausgrabungen der Hgelgrber von Unter-Horodnik und
Prdit (Bukowina), Mitteilungen der Anthropologischen Gesellschaft in
Wien 33, Viena, 82-84.
Kaindl, R. F. 1903a, Prhistorisches aus der Bukowina. Forschungen aus dem Grberfelde von
Unterhorodnik-Prdit und in der prhistorischen Ansiedlung von Szipenitz,
Jahrbuch der K. K. Zentralkommission fr Erforschung und Erhaltung
der Kunst- und historischen Denkmale 1, Viena, 97-114.
Kaindl, R. F. 1904, Prhistorisches aus der Bukowina. (Neue Forschungen in Szipenitz),
Jahrbuch der K. K. Zentralkommission fr Erforschung und Erhaltung
der Kunst- und historischen Denkmale 2, Viena, 17-44.
Kaindl, R. F. 1908, Neolitische Funde mit bemalter Keramik in Kozylowce (Ostgalizien),
Jahrbuch fr Altertumskunde 2, Viena, 144-150.
Kaindl, R. F. 1910, Beitrge zur Vorgeschichte und Ethnographie Osteuropas, Wien und
Braunschweig.
Klein, A. A. (1990/1991), Raimund Friedrich Kaindl, Leben und Werk (1866-1930), in
Kaindl-Archiv. Mitteilungen der Raimund Friedrich Kaindl Gesellschaft, Heft
8, Stuttgart, p. 37-42.
Loghin, C. 1926, Istoria literaturii romne din Bucovina. 1775-1918 (n legtur cu evoluia
cultural i politic), Cernui.
Mais, A. 1990/1991, Das Verhltins Raimund Friedrich Kaindls zur Volkskunde, n KaindlArchiv. Mitteilungen der Raimund Friedrich Kaindl Gesellschaft, Heft 8,
Stuttgart, 42-46.
Mihai, C., Boghian, D. 1985, Complexul cucutenian de cult descoperit la Buznea (com.
Trgu Frumos), MemAntiq 9-11 (1977-1979), 429-452.
Monah, D. 1997, Plastica antropomorf a culturii Cucuteni-Tripolie, BMA 3, Piatra-Neam.
Morariu, C. (1888-1891), Kulturhistorische und ethnographische Skizzen ber die Romnen
der Bucovina, 1 Theil, Resicza-Wien.
Morariu, C. 1893, Pri din istoria Romnilor bucovineni scrise n limb poporal, Cernui.
Much, M. 1902, Notizen. 24. (Steinzeitliche Keramik in der Bukowina), Mittheilungen der
K. K. Zentralkommission fr Erforschung und Erhaltung der Kunst- und
historischen Denkmale 28, Viena, 120-121.
Niculic, B. P. 2006, Karl Adolf Romstorfer, Crai Nou 4250, mari, 29 august 2006,
Suceava, 5.
41
42
Olinescu, D. 1886, Antichitile din Bucovina. I, Voina Naional 3, nr. 630, 13/25
septembrie, 2-3.
Olinescu, D. 1886a, Starea archeologic n Bucovina, Tribuna 3, 10, 14/26 ianuarie, 37.
Olinescu, D. 1889, Convorbiri archeologice. Cu privire la romni, Familia 25, 23, 4/16 iunie, 271.
Olinescu, D. 1894, Charta archeologica a Bucovinei, Buletinul Societii Geografice
Romne 15, 1-2, Bucureti, 64-94.
Olinescu, D. 1894a, Chrile Bucovinei, Buletinul Societii Geografice Romne 15, 3-4,
Bucureti, 3-10.
Pavljuk, O. M. 2000, Bukovina. Viznani postati. 1774-1918 (biografinij dovidnik),
ernivci.
Petrino, O. 1871, Steingerthe aus der Bukowina, Mitteilungen der Anthropologischen
Gesellschaft in Wien 1, Viena, 109-110.
Predescu, L. 1999, Enciclopedia Romniei. Cugetarea. Material romnesc. Oameni i
nfptuiri, ediie anastatic, Bucureti.
Prelicz, V. 1886, Geschichte der Stadt Sereth und ihre Alterthmer, Sereth.
Prelicz, V. 2011, Geschichte der Stadt Sereth und ihre Alterthmer / Istoria oraului Siret i
antichitile sale, ediie ngrijit de B.P. Niculic, traducere de I. Rosto,
Iai.
Reinecke, P. 1896, Skythische Alterthmer in der Bukowina, Jahrbuch des Bukowiner
Landes-Museums 4, Czernowitz, 40-45.
Reli, S. 1927, Oraul Siret n vremuri de demult. Din trecutul unei vechi capitale a Moldovei,
Cernui.
Romstorfer, K.A. 1889, Funde in der Bukowina, Mittheilungen der K.K.
Zentralkommission fr Erforschung und Erhaltung der Kunst- und
historischen Denkmale 15, Viena, 32-33.
Romstorfer, K. A. 1891, Sereth als Fundort archologiser Gegenstnde, Mittheilungen der
K. K. Zentralkommission fr Erforschung und Erhaltung der Kunst- und
historischen Denkmale 17, Viena, 80-83.
Romstorfer, K.A. 1893, Notizen. 135. (Gefe aus Schipenitz), Mittheilungen der K. K.
Zentralkommission fr Erforschung und Erhaltung der Kunst- und
historischen Denkmale 19, Viena, 243-244, 256-Abb. 29-31.
Romstorfer, K.A. 1893a, Aus den Mitteilungen der k. k. Central-Commission fr
Erforschung und Erhaltung der Kunst und historischen Denkmale, Jahrbuch
des Bukowiner Landes-Museums 1, Czernowitz, 45-71.
Romstorfer, K.A. 1894, Aus den Mitteilungen der k. k. Central-Commission fr Erforschung
und Erhaltung der Kunst und historischen Denkmale, Jahrbuch des
Bukowiner Landes-Museums 2, Czernowitz, 115-119.
Romstorfer, K.A. 1894a, Notizen. 2. (Neuere interessante Funde in der Bukowina,
43
44
During March 2014 a treasure consisting of twenty-two gold notched rings was
brought to the National Museum of Romanian History, where the objects are
currently kept in custody for evaluation and research.
The gold rings were discovered with a metal detector 1 on the slope of a hill,
on the outskirts of the city of Braov. Although all the items were placed together
(Fig. 3/1), at first only twenty-one of them were recovered, the last notched ring
being found a few days later. According to the finders explanations he came back in
search for other elements which could be useful for the context analysis. The items
were found at a depth of about 0.25 m, immediately underneath the vegetal layer, in
46
a close cluster (Fig. 3/1), with a few of them still fastened together (Fig. 3/2; see Cat.
Nos. 2-3, 8-11)2. The area was subject to a field walking in order to establish the
details of the find and determine the land features as well as the possible access
paths to this specific spot (Fig. 2/2)3.
LOCATION
From the geographical point of view, the treasure is located in the southern part
of the city of Braov, in the Prund-Schei neighbourhood (Fig. 2/1). The micro-region is
marked by a hill, Dealul Frasinului (maximum altitude 1016.4 m)4, on its western
slope, at the altitude 777.5 m, being the spot where the treasure was found (Fig. 2/2).
From the point of maximum altitude of the hill down to the valley the slope has a
mean inclination of 15, with several more abrupt areas with an inclination up to 335.
These days the area where the discovery took place is completely covered in woods,
but these are plantations of recent times. It should be also mentioned that the
stratigraphy consists in a thin vegetal layer immediately over the bedrock.
TYPOLOGY
Based on their shape and decoration, the items belong to the category of
notched rings, being representative for the so-called Brdu type, named after the
eponym hoard6.
The rings of this type are closely related to the notched rings, being also notched
but with a more varied decoration7. The notched bracelets and rings have in common
the rounded cross-section of the metal bar and the thinning of the ends, as well as the
almost integral decoration of the surface with narrow parallel notches. M. Rusu
determined three variants of notched bracelets: the Meseeni variant (the entire
surface, excepting the ends, is ornamented with equal vertical notches, and the
2
3
4
5
6
7
It should be mentioned that this find was preceded by a similar one, which took place a
month earlier, when another 4 gold notched rings, with a total weight of 7 g, were
discovered on the slope of an opposite hill (Fig. 2/1-2). These items, discovered also by Mr.
Fnel erban, are now preserved in the archaeological collection of the Braov County
Museum of History. Taking into consideration the fact that the small treasure which entered
the collections of the Braov Museum was the first to be found, it will be conventionally
considered here for reasons of clarity as Braov I, while the treasure which constitutes the
subject of this paper will be named Braov II.
The survey was carried out by Mihai Florea and Cristiana Ttaru on August 18 th 2014.
Direcia topografic militar, foaia L-35-088-A-a, 1982 (The Military Topographical
Department, sheet L-35-088-A-a, 1982).
The slopes were determined on the E-W direction.
Popescu 1956, 228.
Popescu 1956, 228, fig. 138/1-8.
47
bracelets bar has a round cross-section); the ona variant (with similar notches, except
on the interior face of the bracelet, so that the resulting cross-section of the metal bar is
in the shape of letter D); the Reca variant (the notches are oblique on the smooth
interior surface of the bracelet, and the cross-section of the metal bar is in the shape of
letter D). Most of the notched rings known so far are identical only of more reduced
size to the bracelets belonging to the Meseeni variant, and they are present (as is
also the case with the bracelets) in the Bronze D and Hallstatt A1 hoards and
treasures8. The Brdu type is represented by rings for which the vertical notches
alternate with triangular or oblique false torsions. They have a round shape and are
made of thin gold bar, decorated on the entire surface with the exception of the ends,
which are thin and pointed, close to each other or slightly overlapping9.
Fig. 1. The distribution of treasures and hoards containing gold notched rings of Brdu type
from Romania.
48
they are part of bronze hoards, which contain besides bronze tools, weapons and
ornaments, also representatives of this type (Brdu; Tuteu).
CHRONOLOGY
Based mainly on their association with the bronze objects in hoards, the gold
notched rings of Brdu type are considered to belong to the Early Iron Age, more
precisely to Hallstatt B1 (10th century BC), the Moigrad Tuteu hoarding horizon10.
ANALOGIES
As already mentioned, there are several finds in the intra-Carpathian area, both
treasures and hoards, which contain items belonging to the Brdu type (Fig. 1).
Apoldu de Sus (Miercurea Sibiului, Sibiu County). During 1843 eighteen gold
notched rings of Brdu type were found within the territorial limits of the village 11.
No other information regarding the find context is known. The rings, attached to each
other in form of a chain, are presently part of the collections of the National Museum
of Romanian History12. The find was dated to Hallstatt B1 (10th century BC), based on
the characteristics of the items. All the rings are open, thicker in the median area, with
undecorated and slightly overlapping pointed ends. The rings are decorated with
groups of circular notches, alternating with segments of oblique notches with various
orientations. The chain weighs 75.27 g and is approximately 34 cm long 13. The rings
are arranged in the chain in a relative order of size, with the biggest item at one end
and the smallest item (also seeming to be the only one fragmented) at the other end 14.
Some rings are slightly deformed but otherwise in good condition. From the point of
view of their decoration, the rings are present in several variants, having their body
divided in a number of segments varying from 3 to 9.
Bihor County (?). The bronze hoard found during the 19th century contained
socketed axes, saw blades, knives, hammers, spearheads, and money-rings15. Based on the
drawings of the bronze objects and also on the observation that the socketed axes have a
10
11
12
13
14
15
Prvan 1926, 308, is dating the hoard from Brdu to Bronze IV (1000-900 BC); Mller-Karpe
1959, 127; Petrescu-Dmbovia 1961, 106; Petrescu-Dmbovia 1977, 136-137; Popescu 1962, 410411 (changing his opinion expressed earlier (1956, 228), that these hoards belonged to Hallstatt
A); Rusu 1972, 36; Oan-Marghitu 2013, 224, Cat.No.35.1-35.5; A. Popescu 2013, 225.
Luca et alii 2003, 38; Mozsolics 1973, 200; A. Popescu 2013, 225.
MNIR Inv. No. 47586.
Mozsolics 1972, 200; Popescu 2013, 225.
It is not very clear if this arrangement is the original one or it was subject to ulterior
rearrangements.
Prvan 1926, 404 (inele-bani); V. Prvan based his discussion on the information provided by J.
Hampel, Bronzkor, III, inclusively on the plate CCXXVI which is published in Getica as Fig. 257.
49
much wider cutting edge than usual16, the hoard most probably belonged to Hallstatt B1.
The five items presented by V. Prvan in Fig. 257/22 and mentioned in the archaeological
literature as belonging to the category of notched rings17 consist of a bigger ring, with
overlapping ends, to which there are attached, through a thinner ring, also with
overlapping ends, 4 rings of similar size, apparently also with overlapping ends18.
Braov I (Braov County). The small treasure containing 4 gold notched rings,
allegedly of Brdu type, was found during the first months of 2014, in the southern
part of the city of Braov, on the slope of a hill, at a low depth. The notched rings are
small light items weighing together 7 g19.
Brdu (Bardocz; Tlioara; Covasna County). The bronze hoard from Brdu
(Tlioara)20 was found in 1858 and entered the collections of the Museum of Natural
History in Vienna during 1899. The hoard contained: 2 cauldrons; 6 axes (from which 2
socketed axes); 2 sickles; 1 sword fragment; 2 bronze rings; several bronze cake ingots;
25 gold rings. In the collections of the National Museum of Transylvanian History ClujNapoca entered: 1 sickle; 3 bracelets; 2 fragments possibly from a fishing hook; 1
decorated gold ring21. The hoard was dated to Hallstatt B1, the Moigrad Tuteu
hoarding horizon, based on the characteristics of the bronze objects22. Although in the
archaeological literature23 the rings are drawn mainly as separated items, they were
described as being 25 gold rings belonging to a decorative chain24. From the available
information, the ten rings which are presented in drawings and for which the weight is
known are small light items (most of them between 1.3 g and 3.2 g), some of them
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
50
complete and the others apparently in different states of fragmentation; four of the rings
are attached two by two, weighing together in one case 6.8 g and in the other case 3.2
g25. The decoration of the complete items varies from the point of view of the number of
segments dividing the body of the rings, from 3 to 7 segments.
Fig. 2. 1. The area of discovery showing the characteristics of the landscape; 2. The topographic
map of the area of discovery indicating the altimetric profile.
25
51
Fig. 3. 1. Photo taken at the moment of discovery; 2. The items immediately after their removal
from the ground (courtesy of Mr. Fnel erban).
52
The Orghidan Collection. Eleven gold notched rings with unknown provenance
entered the Orghidan collection26. They were described in the archaeological literature
as a part of a Hallstatt necklace consisting of 10 earrings and 1 ring, decorated with
notches, with various horizontal and oblique motifs, with analogies in the early
Hallstatt from Transylvania (Brdu, Apoldu de Sus, Tuteu). The diameter is given as
22.5 mm and their total weight as 43.02 g27. Most of the rings seem to be complete,
maybe with the exception of the eighth item from left to right, in the photo published
by the authors. It is not clear if the fourth item is not also in a fragmentary state. Also
from the photo it looks like at least half of the items have their body divided into 5
segments of decoration.
Tuteu (Bihor County). Although the hoard from Tuteu is probably the best
documented find containing gold notched rings of Brdu type, there are still a lot of
uncertainties arising from the conditions in which the discovery took place. In the
outskirts of the village of Tuteu, on the Bereteu valley, close to Marghita, near the
forest, a 10 years old boy found in September 1934 Bronze Age objects, which entered
the collections of the museum of the National House Oradea, after being sequestrated
by the gendarmerie because the gold was not declared in time28. In the earliest
publication of the hoard, F. Ardos presents it as consisting of: 6 bronze rings; 1 socketed
axe; 2 bronze buttons; 1 knife; 2 knives in the shape of a spear and with two cuttingedges; 1 half of a socketed axe; 2 knives with two cutting-edges; 5 gold rings; 1 small
clay vessel; 5 copper ingot fragments; fragments of clay vessels dated to the Bronze
Age29. The author was also drawing attention on the possibility that the hoard could
have contained initially more bronze and gold objects: when the gendarmerie from
Marghita took notice of the find, two months after the discovery, some items
disappeared and the already mentioned ones were confiscated by the Oradea police
from certain merchants30. In the same time exactly the fact that the objects were
sequestrated from several different merchants stands against ruling out the possibility
that originally they came from multiple sources31. It seems that later other objects from
that find were recovered since when the hoard was brought to the National Museum of
Antiquities their number was already increased. The hoard came to this institution in
26
27
28
29
30
31
53
two lots: 27 bronze objects and 5 gold rings32 in the spring of 1935, 16 bronze objects in
the fall of 1940; the second lot with the wrong indication of their find place as Terebe33.
A field research was conducted as early as 1936 by F. Ardos, as well as a small
excavation some years later by M. Petrescu-Dmbovia and C. Mateescu (November 13th
December 14th 1945). Although no other items were found, these researches allowed
several observations regarding the find context. The hoard was located approximately
600 m SW of the townships limit and 120 m N of the meander of the Sla rivulet, being
found on the southern slope, washed by water, of the Sla (Szlls) hill, in an area with
no prehistoric settlement known. It opened only towards E and S, with forest in the rest,
forming a secondary valley, closed towards W and SW, in comparison with the wider
and more open valley of the Bistra River. The hoard was at a depth of only 0.05 m, with
several objects scattered at the surface. The present number of objects, comprising the
gold rings, is 48. The information offered by the finders indicates that a big polished
black-brown clay vessel contained the bronze objects (in no particular order) together
with the small clay vessel containing the gold rings placed in a whitish powder. The
objects were: 1 axe with median wings; 11 socketed axes; 4 sickles; 1 knife; 4 saw-blades;
2 blade tips; 12 bracelets; 2 buttons; 5 fragments of raw bronze; 5 gold rings and 2
fragments of gold rings34. The five complete gold notched rings35 are open, with their
extremities slightly overlapping, thinned and pointed. All are decorated with parallel,
longitudinal and transversal incisions. The decoration is disposed in groups on the
entire surface of the objects, only the extremities being left without decoration36. Three of
the complete items from Tuteu have the length of the gold bar separated by their
decoration into 9 segments (2 rings), respectively 7 segments (1 ring), the other two
being decorated with simple circular notches on their entire surface, with the exception
of their ends37 (forming 3 segments of decoration). Their weight and maximum diameter
are38: 10.20 g with 55 mm; 7.20 g with 34 mm; 5.90 g with 33.2 mm; 3.05 g with 24.3 mm;
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
Most probably all the gold items: in the early publications (for example Popescu 1956, 229, Fig.
140/3) the 2 small rings made of fragments from notched rings and intertwined are presented as
attached through one of them to the biggest of the 5 complete notched rings. They are now
exhibited in the Treasure Room of the National Museum of Romanian History separated from
the biggest ring, as an individual item. It is not known when this separation took place.
Petrescu-Dmbovia 1961, 81.
Dumitrescu 1936, 225-234; Petrescu-Dmbovia 1961, 81-114, fig. 1-5; Petrescu-Dmbovia
1977, 136-137, fig. 329/1-12, 330/1-19, 331/1-17; rlea, Popescu 2013, 223, Cat. No. 35.
MNIR Inv. No. 8992-8996. The two fragments of notched rings attached to each other
received their own inventory number (Inv. No. 8997).
Dumitrescu 1936, 231.
Oan-Marghitu 2013, 224, Cat.No.35.1-35.5.
In the increasing order of their inventory number.
54
2.40 g with 21.2 mm; 1.20 g with the length of the two fragments together of 10 mm39. If
it is taken into account the fact that originally the two ring fragments were attached to
the biggest of the complete notched rings, the total weight of the resulting item would
have been 11.40 g.
DISCUSSION
Find context
It can be easily noticed from the presentation of the treasures and hoards
containing gold notched rings of Brdu type that many essential details concerning
their deposition (such as location, association with structures or land features,
association of items, state of preservation, integrity of the find, internal arrangement) are
lost. As a result, any comparison between these finds or between them and any new
find is bound to be marked by uncertainties. Keeping in mind this warning, we consider
that it could still be useful to determine if the few characteristics known for the
deposition of this type of rings are to be met also in the case of the treasure Braov II.
Location. The only finds which can offer more or less viable information regarding
the location are the hoard from Tuteu and the treasure Braov I. Both have in common
with each other and with the treasure Braov II the deposition of the items on the slope
of a hill, in areas with relatively difficult access, and in spots where no other structures
contemporary with them could be identified. In fact, the closest Hallstatt B1 find to our
treasure seems to be so far the treasure Braov I and vice versa. What differs is the
orientation of the slope, which faces W in the case of Braov II, E in the case of Braov I 40
and S in the case of Tuteu. Another common feature is that all three of them were
found very close to the surface (0.25 m for Braov II; 0.05 m for Tuteu).
Association of items. As it was already mentioned, the gold notched rings of
Brdu type from the intra-Carpathian area are either found in treasures containing
only this kind of items or in hoards in association with items of the same type and
with bronze objects. Unfortunately the conditions of discovery are in many cases
less clear than it could be wished, so any conclusion arising from this observation
with respect to a possible pattern in the association of items should be prudently left
open. Still, if the new found treasure is considered from this perspective, it seems to
join the same trend of treasuring gold items of the same type. This situation is rather
different to what happens during the timespan from Middle Bronze Age to Hallstatt
A in this area, when the trend seems to be towards associating in treasures gold
39
40
55
objects belonging to different categories and types and in the same time towards
maintaining a more or less clear separation between the deposition of gold items
and that of bronze items41.
Arrangement. There is not a lot of information regarding this aspect of the
deposition of the gold notched rings. In the case of the hoard from Tuteu the finders
described the gold rings as being placed in a small clay vessel, in a whitish powder,
next to the bronze objects, all of them being placed in a bigger clay vessel 42. For the
rest of the finds the information is even scarcer. In the case of the treasure Braov II
the close cluster of the gold objects could be as well the result of their placement as a
bulk directly in the ground or a sign that initially they were placed in a container
made of organic material (for example, leather bag or small wooden box) which has
not survived. As long as there is no kind of proof for any of these possibilities, it is
useless to speculate on this subject.
What is interesting to notice is that both in the Apoldu de Sus treasure and in
the Orghidan Collection treasure, the items are attached to each other so that the
result is a chain43. In a similar way were described in the archaeological literature the
notched rings from Brdu, as belonging initially to a decorative chain 44. The only
question that could arise is if this is the original form in which the rings were
treasured or the result of a later intervention. Still, as long as on one hand this
situation is repetitive in the case of the notched rings and on another hand similar
finds are known for hair-rings and rings (including the Bronze D Hallstatt A type
with lozenge-shaped cross-section)45, there is no strong reason to doubt that this was
the original arrangement.
The treasure Braov II contains both individual items and groupings of rings
attached to each another. At the moment of their arrival at the National Museum there
were 9 individual rings (Cat. Nos. 1, 4-7, 12-15), 6 rings attached two by two (Cat. Nos.
2/1-2; 8/1-2; 9/1-2), and 6 rings attached three in a row (Cat. Nos. 10/1-3; 11/1-3). More
difficult is to determine if the ring to which are attached two small rings made of
41
42
43
44
45
For a more complete view on this point see Popescu 1956; Popescu 1962; Rusu 1972 (with the
catalogue of gold finds for Bronze D Hallstatt A).
Petrescu-Dmbovia 1961, 81.
Luca et alii 2003, 38; Mozsolics 1973, 200; A. Popescu 2013, 225; Gramatopol, Theodorescu
1966, 66, Cat. No. 27 (O1/22), Pl. V/1.
Petrescu-Dmbovia 1977, 127.
Popescu 1956, 209, 227, Fig. 124, 139/8; Rusu 1972, 45 (Cat. No. 27), 46 (Cat. No. 30, 33, 37), 47
(Cat. No. 43), 50 (Cat. No. 69); Gramatopol, Theodorescu 1966, 66, Cat. No. 14, Pl. II/5
56
46
47
48
49
Mr. Fnel erban, in a personal communication, emphasized the fact that at the moment of the
discovery, when the rings were removed from the ground, more of them gave the impression
of being attached to each other and separating as a result of the movement. Taking this
description into consideration, we tried to determine, based on the present state of the items, if
this could really have happened. The visual analysis of the rings left us with the impression
that (with very few exceptions) the way their ends touch or overlap would have made
impossible a voluntary separation in the case of most of the items. In other words, in order to
allow a ring to slide from the attachment to another ring the ends must be intentionally drawn
apart. Thus, the conclusion which has been reached is that most probably at the moment of the
discovery most of the rings were literally hanging to each other (due to the conditions of their
deposition) rather than being really attached in one long chain.
The expression usually found in the archaeological literature regarding the treasure from
Apoldu de Sus is that it contained 18-20 rings (Mozsolics 1973, 200; Popescu 2013, 225). It
is unclear if the original number was higher than 18 or there is just an approximation
expressed at some point and perpetuated in the literature.
The 2 fragments of notched rings (Cat. Nos. 3.2-3) attached to a complete ring were not
counted.
For the uncertainty regarding the number of notched rings from Brdu see above at
Analogies.
57
50
This is with the exception of the happy (in its unhappiness) situation when modern tools
leaving specific traces were used to cut the gold instead of simply breaking it, as it happens
in some cases.
58
Characteristics
The characteristics of the gold notched rings from the treasure Braov II which
will be discussed further are their decoration, weight, dimensions, shape, technology,
decoration techniques, and metal composition. Where possible, their characteristics
will be compared to those of items belonging to other treasures or hoards.
Decoration. The most visible and in the same time recognisable feature of the
items discussed here is their decoration, which represents together with their shape
the main argument for including them in the larger category of the notched rings and
in the narrower group of the notched rings of Brdu type. As already briefly
discussed above, what is characteristic in the case of the notched rings of Brdu type
is the fact that the combination of notches divides the surface of the metal bar in
groups or segments of decoration. Based on this observation, an attempt was made to
determine how many variants could be obtained if the number of the decoration
segments is taken into consideration. It must be emphasized that these variants are
established only for the treasure Braov II, with no certainty that they will prove
themselves generally applicable and more as a probing in view of eventual future
research on this subject. The aim was to observe if any kind of relation can be
established between different characteristics of the same item (for example, decoration
and size, decoration and weight, or between these and the metal composition) or
between different items (for example, the existence of sets of rings with very similar
decoration, size, weight, or even gold composition).
Based on the number of decoration segments the rings from the treasure Braov
II were separated into three main variants: A the metal bar is divided into 5
segments (2 undecorated ends; 2 segments with parallel notches; 1 central segment
with more sophisticated decoration); B the metal bar is divided into 9 segments (2
undecorated ends; 2 segments with parallel notches; 2 segments with more
sophisticated decoration; 2 segments with parallel notches; 1 central segment with
more sophisticated decoration); C the metal bar is divided into 3 segments (2
undecorated ends; 1 more extended segment with parallel notches).
The problem which had to be confronted while establishing these variants was
that it soon became clear that the degree of variation in the decoration went beyond
merely separating it into a number of segments. The variation of the decoration itself,
which seems to be mainly the result of two factors the chosen pattern in which the
notches are combined and the decoration technique , intervenes in complicating the
situation. As a result, accepting the risk that any selection of this kind is open to
subjectivity, related variants were added to the main ones. Thus, the variant A has a
related variant A1, also with the decoration divided into 5 segments but with stylistic
59
differences, while the variant B has so far four related variants (B1-4) based on the
same criterion.
From the total of 22 complete items, there are: 8 rings of variant A; 1 ring of
related variant A1; 6 rings of variant B; 2 rings of related variant B1; 1 ring of related
variant B2; 1 ring of related variant B3; 1 ring of related variant B4; 2 rings of variant
C. In the case of the two fragmented rings it was impossible to determine the
original variant.
Variant A, containing rings with 5 decoration segments, is characterised by a
central decoration segment consisting of triangles created through the application of
parallel notches (for example, Cat. No. 1; Fig. 4.1). This segment is slightly bulging in
comparison with the rest of the gold bar, enhancing this way the effect of the
decoration.
The related variant A1, although based on 5 decoration segments, presents a
different decoration of the central segment, which is also more reduced in length than in
the case of variant A rings: simple oblique notches placed in pairs and forming a sort of
fir tree motif, running along the length of the gold bar (Cat. No. 10.3; Fig. 5/4).
Variant B, containing rings with 9 decoration segments, is characterised by 3
segments with more complicated decoration: 2 intermediary groups consisting of a
oblique notches placed in pairs perpendicular on the length of the gold bar; a central
group consisting, like in the case of variant A, of triangles created through the
application of parallel notches (for example, Cat. No. 2.2; Fig. 4/2). All the segments
with more sophisticated decoration are slightly bulging.
The related variant B1 has the central segment decorated in the same manner as
the main variant B. The difference appear in the manner of decorating the
intermediary segments, which in this case consist in a fir tree motif running along
the length of the gold bar towards the ends of the ring (Cat. Nos. 5-6; Fig. 4/5-6).
The related variant B2 is very similar to the related variant B1, but the fir tree
motif runs this time along the gold bar toward the central segment of the ring (Cat.
No. 7; Fig. 5/1).
The related variant B3 has all 3 segments decorated with triangles consisting of
parallel notches (Cat. No. 10.2; Fig. 5/4).
The related variant B4 has a decoration similar to that characteristic to variant B,
with the main difference that the segments with more sophisticated decoration are not put
in evidence also through the bulging of the gold bar in those areas (Cat. No. 11.1; Fig. 5/5).
Variant C is characterised by simple parallel notches on the entire surface of the
gold bar, with the exception of the ends (for example, Cat. No. 11.2; Fig. 5/5).
The two fragmented items have preserved each only one end and a part of the
decoration with parallel notches, so it was impossible to determine to which variant
60
they belonged initially. As it was noticed on one hand that in general the length of the
ends is proportional with the general length of the bar the bigger the item the longer
the undecorated part of the ends and on the other hand that the length of the end is
reduced in the case of both fragmentary items, it is possible to have belonged to small
light rings (Cat. Nos. 3.2-3; Fig. 4/3).
Every other characteristic which will be discussed further is taken into
consideration also in connection with the variants based on the decorative features of
the items, in order to observe if any kind of pattern emerges.
Weight. The determination of the weight in the case of the gold notched rings is
in general hampered by two difficulties: their reduced weight necessitates a very
sensitive balance and their deposition attached in the form of chains makes it
practically impossible to determine the weight of individual items 51.
Cat. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
Item No.
1.
2.1.
2.2.
3.1.
3.2-3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.1.
8.2.
9.1.
9.2.
10.1.
10.2.
10.3.
11.1.
11.2.
11.3.
12.
13.
14.
15.
Variant
A
A
B
B
X
A
B1
B1
B2
A
A
B
B
B
B3
A1
B4
C
A
B
A
A
C
Total weight
7.91
13.97
13.97
7.33
7.33
6.99
6.32
6.14
5.61
13.29
13.29
11.80
11.80
13.94
13.94
13.94
13.77
13.77
13.77
3.50
2.01
3.18
5.25
Weight/item
7.91
9.73
4.24
5.36
1.97
6.99
6.32
6.14
5.61
8.34
4.95
6.22
5.58
4.97
5.53
3.45
5.29
2.17
6.31
3.50
2.01
3.18
5.25
Table 1. The weight of the gold notched rings from the treasure Braov II.
51
There are in this situation the chains from Apoldu de Sus and the Orghidan Collection, as
well as the rings attached two by two from Brdu.
61
All the items from the analysed treasure were weighed for greater precision with
a balance used for numismatic finds. The weighing was repeated for each item in order
to ensure the accuracy of the results, which are presented in Table 1 and Graph 1.
In the case of the rings attached by two or three, fortunately it was possible to
temporary detach the items without causing them any damage, with the specific
purpose of weighing them. The rings forming small chains received each a label with
their catalogue number, were photographed before detaching them, and after being
weighed were carefully replaced in exactly the same order as before, using the
photographs as a safety backup. Thus, for these groups of rings there are presented in
Table 1 both their total weight and the weight of the individual items. The same
procedure was applied in the case of the ring having attached the pendant (Cat. No.
3), with the observation that the separation was possible only between the complete
ring and the pendant consisting of two small fragments bent in shape of rings. The
pendant itself was weighed as one item (see in Table 1 Item No. 3.2-3), as it was
very clear that any attempt to detach the two fragments would have been dangerous
for their integrity.
Weight
2g
3g
4g
5g
6g
7g
8g
9g
10 g
Table 2. Weight / number of items.
Number of items
1
2
3
3
6
5
1
1
1
Leaving aside the two fragmentary rings, which are as expected the lightest
item (1.97 g), the weights of the rings cover quite a large range of values. The
lightest item is only 2.01 g (Cat. No. 13) and the heaviest is 9.73 g (Cat. No. 2). The first
impression left by the weight values is that there is no true cluster, with results that
can be described as rather scattered between these extremes. Still, it can be noticed
that half of the items (11) have weights situated between 5 and 7 g, with another
significant number of items (6) with weights between 3 and 5 g (Table 2). The number
of very light as well as heavy items is comparatively reduced. There are 3 items
(counting also the pendant) weighing less than 3 g and 3 items weighing more than
7 g, although a derogation could prove to be necessary in the case of one ring (Cat.
No. 3). In its case appears the same question expressed above regarding the ring from
62
Tuteu which had initially attached a similar combination of two fragmentary rings: if
the weight of the items should be considered separately, or they should be seen as one
item. In other words the problem to be solved is if and how the weight of this type of
rings mattered for their owners. If the pendant functioned as some sort of weight
supplement, it would be normal to consider the items as one. In that case the weight
of the ring Cat. No. 3 would become 7.33 g, sending it in another category.
From these results it can be inferred at least in the case of the treasure Braov II
some sort of preference for items of medium weight, situated especially between 5 and 7
g. That this is not a general trend can be seen when this situation is compared to what
happens in the case of other associations of items. Unfortunately, the only terms of
direct comparison are offered by the hoard from Tuteu and partially by the hoard from
Brdu. The five complete rings from Tuteu, when analysed from the perspective of
their weight, leave the impression of representing a selection of almost all the possible
weight values: 2.40 g; 3.05 g; 5.90 g; 7.20 g; 10.20 g. To this the weight of 1.20 g of the two
fragmentary rings forming the pendant could be added. The individual rings from
Brdu are far more clustered but in the same time far lighter: 1 ring with less than 2 g; 3
rings between 2 and 3 g; 2 rings between 3 and 4 g. The other finds, Apoldu de Sus,
Braov I and Orghidan Collection, provided until now only access to their total weight52.
So at this moment, from the weight perspective, the composition of the treasure Braov
II looks closer to that of the Tuteu hoard than to that of the Brdu hoard.
In this situation, the question was if a comparison of the mean values of the
rings weights could prove itself more expressive (Table 3).
Find
Apoldu de Sus
Braov I
Braov II
Brdu
Orghidan Collection
Tuteu
Number of items
18
4
22/23
1053
11
5/6
Table 3. The total weight and the mean weight (weight/ring) for the finds with gold notched
rings.
52
53
As already mentioned, the rings from Apoldu de Sus and the Orghidan Collection are
attached to each other; the rings from the treasure Braov I are not yet published.
There were taken into account only the 10 items with published weights. It should also be
kept in mind that some of the items, now apparently fragmented, may have been originally
heavier (but not a lot heavier, if the weight of the complete items can be used as an
indicator).
63
As it can be noticed, the mean values of weight vary considerably from find to
find. Still, some sort of pairing seems to emerge if these values are compared. First,
there are finds containing only small light items, as is the case with Braov I treasure
and possibly the Brdu hoard. Secondly, there are finds that could be described as
containing mainly medium weight rings (also in general with similar dimensions), the
chains from Apoldu de Sus and from the Orghidan Collection. Thirdly, there are the
finds from Braov II and Tuteu which contain rings varying more visibly in weight
and size, the presence of bigger heavier items offering an increase of the mean value
of the finds weight.
What was observed in the case of the treasure discussed here is that although
the weights of the individual rings vary considerably not the same thing happens to
the total weight of the rings attached to each other. With one exception, the two rings
under the Cat. No. 9, weighing together 11.80 g, they all cluster between 13.29 g and
13.97 g (Cat. Nos. 2, 8, 10-11). Still, at the present moment it is impossible to say if this
situation reflects an intention or is simply a coincidence.
Graph 1. The weight of the gold notched rings from the treasure Braov II in view of their
decoration variant.
64
variant A are some of the lightest items. Also the ring belonging to the related variant
A1 (Cat. No. 10.3) is a very light item (3.45 g). From this point of view, the rings
belonging to variant B and related variants B1-4 have the most consistent behaviour,
with weights between 3.50 and 6.32 g. The two rings belonging to variant C are quite
separated by their weight, since one item (Cat. No. 11.2) weighs 2.17 g and the other
(Cat. No. 15) weighs 5.25 g. In the same time, very interesting seem to be the two rings
belonging to the variant B1 (Cat. Nos. 5-6), which have very similar weights, 6.32 and
6.14 g. Except for them, it is difficult to determine clearly any pairings or clusters.
Dimensions and shape. These two characteristics of the rings will be discussed
together, as they are directly related to each other.
From the point of view of their shape, the rings of Brdu type were described
in the archaeological literature as items with a round or rounded shape, made of metal
bar thicker in the middle and thinning progressively towards the ends, which are
open and pointed54. During the process of measuring the rings from the Braov II
treasure, the items were conventionally placed on the working surface in the same
position they are usually presented in the photos or drawings, with their ends up and
the thicker part of the gold bar down (see photo below). Then, in order to establish
their size and in the same time to determine how round they really are, two diameters
were measured on the interior of each item and two diameters were measured on the
exterior of each item, both vertically and horizontally. For the dimensions of the gold
bar itself, again two diameters were measured, in each case on the thinnest point
(which proved to be at the end) and on the thickest point (which proved to be in the
middle, on the central segment of decoration).
The dimensions of the rings cover quite a large range, as it can be seen in Table
4. Still, as in the case of their weight, the rings belonging to variant A have the
tendency to be bigger than the rings belonging to the other variants.
The comparison between the lengths of the vertical and horizontal diameters of
the analysed rings proved that none of the measured items is perfectly round in
shape. The variation of the relation between the vertical and horizontal diameters
results in two shapes: ovoid or egg-shaped (when D1 is longer than D2) and oval
(when D1 is shorter than D2). The next step was to see if the shape is up to some point
connected to the rings variant (Table 4).
The rings of type A adopt both the ovoid and the oval shape. From the total of 8
rings belonging to this variant, 3 have ovoid shape. It is possible that another ring of
this type (Cat. No. 8.1) belonged initially to this group, its present oval shape being
probably created by the ulterior accentuated overlapping of the ends. The other 5
54
Dumitrescu 1936, 231; Rusu 1972, 36, Pl. III/2; A. Popescu 2013, 225.
65
items have a slightly oval shape. The ring belonging to the related variant A1 has an
ovoid shape.
Interior diameters:
d1 on the vertical
d2 on the horizontal
Exterior diameters:
D1 on the vertical
D2 on the horizontal
Metal bar diameters:
d min: on the thinnest
part (the end)
- d max: on the thickest
part (the middle)
In the group of the 6 items of variant B 4 rings have an oval shape. To them the
3 rings belonging to related variants B2-4, all with an oval shape, can be added. The
other 2 items have a very slight ovoid shape, being almost round (Cat. No. 9.1-2). Still,
the most clear ovoid shape for the variant B and related variants is found in the case of
the 2 rings belonging to related variant B1.
The 2 rings belonging to variant C have both an oval shape.
The attempt to determine the relation between the diameter of the rings (in this
case D1) and their weight gave in general the expected results (Graph 2), with the
greatest part of the rings of variant A offering higher values than the other rings. The
rings of variant B and related variants create a more convincing cluster, having values
closer to each other than it is the case with the variant A rings. Where the graph is
really expressive is in showing better the distinctive behaviour of the two rings of
related variant B1, which are on one hand brought by the relation diameter-weight in
the area occupied by the variant A items and on another hand again very close to each
other. At this point these are two items which begin to behave as a pair. This is not the
case with the two rings of variant C, which are kept quite apart from each other both
by their weight and their dimensions. Instead, another possible pair could be formed
by 2 rings belonging to variant B which have very close dimensions, similar shape,
and also close weights (Cat. Nos. 9.1-2).
66
Variant
A
A
B
B
A
B1
B1
B2
A
A
B
B
B
B3
A1
B4
C
A
B
A
A
C
Shape
ovoid
ovoid
oval
oval
ovoid
ovoid
ovoid
oval
oval
oval
ovoid
ovoid
oval
oval
ovoid
oval
oval
oval
oval
oval
oval
oval
d1 (mm)
36.40
26.66
20.27
24.77
31.98
32.70
32.91
22.7
26.01
24.54
23.18
23.67
21.72
25.52
23.17
25.93
14.92
25.12
14.40
18.87
19.13
31.37
d2 (mm)
35.26
25.71
21.60
25.79
30.37
30.30
30.76
24.39
27.61
25.90
22.86
23.00
22.75
26.51
24.04
28.77
16.63
25.76
18.98
21.83
22.73
31.63
D1 (mm)
42.26
32.28
24.37
30.05
36.28
38.01
37.60
27.63
32.04
28.42
28.80
28.48
27.16
29.70
27.40
31.17
18.68
31.70
20.51
22.27
23.21
35.52
D2 (mm)
40.22
31.64
26.64
31.05
35.25
34.91
35.91
29.55
33.16
30.53
27.81
27.83
27.72
30.83
27.14
32.84
20.11
32.06
23.87
24.71
26.27
35.58
Table 4. The diameters of the notched rings from the Braov II treasure.
It was interesting to notice that a direct relation diameter weight should not
be taken for granted, in the sense that the heaviest item is not necessarily the biggest
and vice versa (see for example Cat. Nos. 1 and 2.1): the general thickness of the metal
bar clearly plays a role in reaching a certain weight in the case of each ring. In the
same time it could be just a coincidence but it should be mentioned that in the case of
the variant A the ovoid shape is associated with the heaviest items (Cat. Nos. 1, 2.1, 4,
and possibly also 8.1 before its modification).
Technology. The gold notched rings of Brdu type were rarely more extensively
approached in the archaeological literature from the perspective of their technology of
fabrication. One remark on this subject regarded the entire category of notched items,
being presumed that both the notched bracelets and the notched rings were cast using
the lost wax technique, since the perfectly uniform notches cannot be obtained through
mechanical torsion55. The mechanical torsion can be excluded from the start as a method
55
67
for producing rings of Brdu type, as long as the more complicated segments would
have been impossible to be obtained through torsion. The question remaining is if the
rings of this type were indeed cast using the lost wax technique.
Graph 2. The weight diameter relation for the notched rings from the treasure Braov II.
The visual analysis of the rings cannot offer a lot of information, since the items
are relatively small and the notches creating the pattern are tiny. Still, the impression
left by them is the one noticed by M. Rusu before, that the notches look in general
perfectly uniform, and even more, in the special case of the rings of Brdu type, the
segments with more sophisticated decoration would have been difficult to be worked
directly on the metal bar with the necessary degree of precision. But the opportunity
of analysing the items under a microscope brought a different perspective on the
technology implicated in the creation of this type of rings.
In the case of some of the rings, especially Cat. No. 4, an observation was made
which could cast a light on the method used by the goldsmith in order to obtain the gold
bar. At the end of the item, on the interior surface, it can be noticed a line running along
the gold bar (Fig. 7/5). A similar line could be observed on another category of metal
objects, this time made of copper and belonging to an earlier chronological framework,
the rings with flat-hammered out-turned or rolled ends (senringe). In their case the
metal was poured into a groove and resulted in thin, elongated bars56. The results of the
investigations indicated sand casting, but stone moulds could not be completely
excluded. The cross-section of the rough cast bar was then reworked to become rounder,
56
68
the ends of the bar were flattened and curled more or less into loops, then the bar was
bent into a ring shape. Most items were found in an annealed state, which would
suggest that the final deformation was hot working. But the amount of deformation for
bending the ring was determined as being comparatively low, so that also cold
deformation would have left only few traces like slip lines if any. In any case, extensive
hot working can be excluded57 in the case of the senringe. The most characteristic
aspect of this method is the resulting concave aspect of the interior side of the ring,
indicating cooling shrinkage which affected the surface of the initial metal bar. This
characteristic is a direct result of using open moulds58. Thus, subsequent interventions
were required, the margins of the concave area being hammered inwards, in an attempt
to diminish the concavity. Still, the grooves remained very often plainly visible, even in
the case of ulterior smoothing, the initial groove being transformed into a fine forging
seam but without completely disappearing.
It is very possible that this method was used in the case of the gold rings. The
advantage is that it is a much simpler method, requiring most probably less time and
skill than the lost wax technique, and creating no loss of metal. The thin metal bar
would have been poured in a simple open mould and then reworked to cover the
shrinkage of the metal on the surface left in contact with the colder air, and to obtain
the round cross-section. If this method was indeed used, one remaining question is if
the decoration was created at that point or after the bending of the metal bar in shape
of a ring. This probably depends on the tool kit the goldsmith had at his disposal, but
it is interesting to notice that several items display a certain degree of flattening on the
sides (see for example Fig. 8/3), which could indicate the turning of the bar from one
side to the other and some pressure applied on it. This would be rather consistent
with placing the bar on a harder surface in order to intervene with a tool for
decoration, than with placing an already shaped ring on a support and decorating it in
this manner. Anyway, the fact that the decoration goes all around the metal bar would
have made the last approach more difficult. Another method which would allow the
intervention could have implied the use of a vice or a material like resin, for example,
to fix the ring in place during decoration.
In any case, the details observed when the decoration itself was analysed come
to confirm the use of another method than the lost wax technique. At least all the signs
indicate the application of the decoration after the gold bar was cast. This aspect will
be briefly discussed below.
57
58
69
Decoration techniques. The analysis through the microscope of the 22 complete items
and the 2 fragmentary items indicates that all of them were decorated using most
probably a specialised tool kit, with very fine tools. The fine parallel scratches left behind
by the tools and observed in all the cases seem consistent with the application of the
decoration on an already cast metal bar (for example, Fig. 6/4-5; 7/1; 8/1). The fact that the
scratches are considered left by the tools used for decoration and not in the process of
removing the soil after the discovery of the items is sustained by the fact that the mineral
depositions from the earth superimpose the scratches (Fig. 6/4, 6; 9/6).
Another possible argument resides in the fact that the microscope showed that
the pattern is far from perfect: the notches are rarely equal in depth and width, and
similarly the spaces left between them are unequal on their entire surface (see for
example Fig. 6/5-6; 7/2; 8/1, 3; 11/5). Even more, several errors noticed in the
application of the pattern, errors which normally would have been either avoided or
corrected in time if the pattern was originally made on wax. In several cases it is
visible that the tool slid resulting in an unwanted prolongation of the notch, most
noticeably in the case of Cat. No. 13 (Fig. 11/4). On another ring there is a clear error in
applying the parallel notches (Cat. No. 6; Fig. 8/3). The most frequent mistake seems
to be the unintentional crossing of another element of the pattern. In the case of some
of the rings (for example, Cat. Nos. 1, 3.1) it can be seen how the tool used to create a
notch was pushed too much and crossed another notch (Fig. 6/4; 7/1).
There seem to be two main methods of obtaining the notches, used to create the
parallel notches and respectively the notches forming the most complicated pattern. The
parallel notches were most probably created by a repeated intervention on parallel lines
across the surface. As a result, in a number of cases a prominent ridge was left behind
indicating the limit of each of the (seemingly) two interventions for each individual notch
(Fig. 6/5; 8/2). In some other cases, the parallel notches could have been created by a single
intervention (Fig. 9/1). The fact that each intervention in its turn looks as the sum of
several very fine long lines applied with a similar pressure combined with the presence of
the central prominent ridge left behind in some cases makes it possible that the goldsmith
used an indented tool rather than a fine pointed one (Fig. 10/3).
The notches which form the more sophisticated pattern were more probably
applied with a sharp pointed tool, sometimes in one move (Fig. 7/6) and sometimes
prolonging the notch through a series of interventions with the same tool (Fig. 9/3-4).
Although the range of techniques and resulting notches is rather limited the use
of the microscope offered the opportunity of sometimes noticing different approaches
to similar or almost identical patterns. Even the errors seem in some cases specific for
a ring or group of rings. These observations raised the question if through a more
detailed research it could not be possible to determine different hands, in other
70
words rings coming from the hands of different goldsmiths or at least from different
workshops / traditions of decoration. One of the most interesting examples prove to
be the two rings belonging to the variant B1, which are made similar to each other and
distinctive from the rest not only by their dimensions, weight and pattern, but also by
the way that pattern was applied. The technique used is in the same time similar for
the both rings (even the slight errors, like the unequal space left between notches) and
different from that used for other rings, leaving the strong impression that both rings
were made and finished by the same person (Fig. 7/6; 8/1-3 see in comparison with
details for rings belonging to other variants).
An aspect open to misinterpretation on a visual analysis and cleared by the
microscope analysis was the apparent wearing out of some of the rings. The first
impression was that those items suffered from prolonged use which led to the polishing
and partial removal of the decoration in some areas. This interpretation would not have
been normally challenged, but the problem was that the affected areas were in contrast
with any type of use which could be advanced for this type of rings. The worn out
areas were mostly located towards the ends of the rings, on the notched segments, and
on the lateral parts of the metal bar, more frequently only on one side. If the rings were
used as ornaments, either as hair-rings, earrings, fingerings, or parts of a chain, the most
polished areas should have been on the interior and/or on the ends. Still, as there is no
certainty regarding the real ways of use for this category of finds, it was considered
useful to investigate also this situation under the microscope, in the hope of obtaining
more information. The result came as a surprise, since the weak representation of the
decoration in the analysed areas seems to have nothing to do with any kind of extensive
use, being instead a result of the decoration technique. In other words, in the case of
several rings the goldsmith took far less pain to obtain a notch of equal depth on the
entire circumference of the bar. The result is that in general the central part of a notch
is far more visible than its ends which are almost disappearing (Fig. 6/7; 7/2; 8/4-5;
10/5; 11/5). What it is still unclear is if this was the result of a recherch effect, of the lack
of experience or work in a hurry, or simply laziness.
The use of a microscope to analyse in more detail the rings from Braov II
treasure proved to be a real asset to the research. It is the aim of our team to continue to
analyse the photos in order to refine and better understand the results obtained so far.
Metal analysis. The notched rings from Braov II treasure were analysed through
the XRF technique, using a portable spectrometer Innov-X Systems Alpha Series, with
W anticathode tube; SiPIN diode; Peltier cooling effect; work parameters 40 kV
tension, 35 A intensity, acquisition time 30.
The results for the 22 complete rings are presented in Graph 3, the symbols
indicating the variant to which they belong. All the analysed items are made of native
71
gold (electrum), containing different percentages of silver. The gold in the natural
alloy ranges from 81.22% to 94.25%. Trace elements were also determined: Cu (only in
the spectra 0.001%); Fe (0.001% 1.45%); Ni (only in the spectra 0.001%); Sn (for 2
items: Cat. No. 1 0.28%; Cat. No. 8 1.27%).
The presence of tin in some of the items and the high percentages of gold in the
natural alloy in general could indicate the use of secondary sources (placer gold). Still,
a degree of prudence is necessary, given the fact that the analyses were conducted on
unprepared surfaces and it was observed that in the case of gold artefacts silver and
especially copper are often lost from the surface (the so-called surface enrichment)59.
Graph 3. The metal composition (Au-Ag) of the gold notched rings from the treasure Braov II.
The analysis of the metal composition in relation with the rings decoration
variant reveals a trend: the rings belonging to variant B and related variants B2-4 are
characterised by higher percentages of gold in the natural alloy than most of the rings
belonging to variant A. The two rings of variant C have values which bring them
closer to the variant B than to the variant A as a whole. Again very interesting are the
two rings of B1 variant, which present both the lowest purity of gold, being very close
to each other in the graph and in the same time separated from the other items. This
characteristic and those discussed before give these two rings the appearance of
behaving like a pair of items.
59
72
Although the trend in the use of gold is present in the graph the resulting
clusters are not as clear as to allow a definite conclusion on this subject. The
connection between metal composition and variant of the rings is not strong enough
to be considered mutually dependent. In other words, it cannot be considered a sign
that a specific gold composition was especially searched for when a ring of a specific
variant was made. A more natural explanation could be that the rings representing
different decoration patterns and techniques were the product of various workshops
which would have had most probably access to different sources of gold. Even if they
were made in the same workshop this does not necessarily stand against using
different sources of gold. The clearest connection remains so far that between the two
rings of B1 variant, which seem to have been produced from the same charge of gold
and by the same goldsmith.
Function
The subject of the function of the gold notched rings of Brdu type was briefly
discussed quite often in the Romanian archaeological literature, without being reached a
clear conclusion. An interesting point is that from the oldest publications of this
category of finds on an interpretation as possible pre-monetary signs was almost always
present. V. Prvan describes the 25 gold open rings from Brdu as maybe coins60, and
the rings from Bihor County as money-rings61. Some years later, discussing the hoard
from Tuteu, F. Ardos considers that the finding place was a bronze workshop, and the
gold rings were the payment for the objects made by the craftsman. Because money did
not exist during those times, the gold rings, or in some areas even gold ingots used
also as jewellery, served as money in the exchange62. More prudent, V. Dumitrescu cites
V. Prvan with his opinion on the function of the rings from Tuteu, without
developing the idea or expressing his acceptance of it63. D. Popescu affirms that in
general the notched rings are considered as ring money, but considers that they could
have played also the role of hair-rings64, followed by M. Gramatopol and
R. Theodorescu in their discussion on the chain from the Orghidan Collection65.
The other line was the one just mentioned, of considering these rings as
ornaments for the body. How were exactly worn was more difficult to establish, as
they are often described as too small to be worn as bracelets 66, but in the same time too
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
73
big to be interpreted without doubts as hair-rings. Being open rings their use as
fingerings was sometimes clearly rejected67. Their interpretation as hair-rings is most
frequent, as already noticed, followed by attributing to them a function as earrings, or
the use of the more general term of headdress ornaments, especially in those cases
when the rings seemed to form pairs68.
Their context, the fact that the gold notched rings of Brdu type are usually
found in treasures and hoards, does not offer unfortunately a lot of information
regarding the way they were used. Neither can this information be extracted very easy
from their association, their number or their characteristics.
The analysis of the gold notched rings from the Braov II treasure does not seem,
at least at this point of the research, to support their function as pre-monetary signs;
their variation in weight, dimensions, decoration, and even metal composition does not
look consistent with such a use. This lack of standardisation could be of course only
apparent due to the fact that from the statistical point of view the analysed items are far
from being representative, so this question must be left open for now.
No traces of use were determined so far that could throw a light on the way
these rings could have been worn. The only criteria that can be taken into
consideration are those related to their characteristics. As it was already noticed in
the archaeological literature, they are too small to be worn as bracelets (even by
children) and it is clear that a great number of them are too big to be worn as
fingerings. The hypothesis that they were used as headdress ornaments seems to be
the safest one. Of course, at this point the analysis of the rings can only prove that
they could have been used in a certain way, not that they were really used that way.
The characteristics of the rings make it possible for them to be used as hair-rings or
more probably as ornaments attached to a headdress made of cloth. Also a little
experiment showed that they would have been very wearable and beautiful earrings
(Fig. 11/6). There is not any very clear sign that they could have been habitually
used in pairs or sets of more than two, but also nothing is against this possibility.
Our analysed lot seems to contain both unique items and pairs (Cat. Nos. 5-6 and
possibly Cat. Nos. 9.1-2). A more careful research on this subject could bring more
possible sets or, on the contrary, could infirm the present impression. Anyway, the
search for similarity could prove to be a trap, because there is no certainty that even
in the case of sets the symmetry would have been either important or necessary.
Taking the example of their use as earrings, there is nothing to say that they could
not have been worn only as a single item (for one ear), or in numbers greater than
two (more than one earring for one ear), or even in the case of two earrings a
67
68
74
different model for each ear. Even more, the arrangement in which the rings of this
type are often found, as chains, could suggest that they were worn at least in some
occasions or by some individuals as such, maybe hanging around the neck or waist,
or attached to the clothes or headdresses69.
The only clear thing at this point is that there is not enough information to
determine how they were used or even if there was a standard of use. It is our hope
that future researches on the subject of the gold notched rings of Brdu type will
bring more useful information.
CATALOGUE
1. Ring (Fig. 4/1).
Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant A.
Weight: 7.91 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 36.40 mm; d2: 35.26 mm; D1: 42.26 mm; D2: 40.22 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 1.09 mm; d max: 3.43 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends slightly
overlapping. The decoration divides the gold bar into 5 segments: undecorated ends; 2
intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the
bars length; 1 central segment more sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel
incisions, forming triangles of various sizes. The central segment is further more pointed
out by the bar slightly bulging in that area. The ring has an ovoid shape.
Preservation: Good.
2. Two rings attached to each other (Fig. 4/2). Total weight: 13.97 g.
2.1. Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant A.
Weight: 9.73 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 26.66 mm; d2: 25.71 mm; D1: 32.28 mm; D2: 31.64 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 0.95 mm; d max: 3.46 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends with
accentuated overlapping. The decoration divides the gold bar into 5 segments: undecorated
ends; 2 intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the
bars length; 1 central segment more sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel
incisions, forming triangles of various sizes. The central segment is further more pointed out by
the bar slightly bulging in that area. The ring has an ovoid shape.
Preservation: Good.
69
A find which could shed a light on more unusual uses of rings, this time hair-rings, is
known from the Middle Bronze Age necropolis from Cndeti (Monteoru Ia phase): the
deceased was wearing a neck-ring like a diadem, placed on the forehead, to which was
attached a chain made of bronze hair-rings which surrounded the face, reaching the
mandible (Florescu, Florescu 1983, 115).
75
76
undecorated ends of the notched rings seems to vary proportionally with their size, the smaller
length of this undecorated end could indicate that the original ring was also rather small.
Preservation: Fragment.
Fig. 4. 1. Cat. No. 1; 2. Cat. No. 2; 3. Cat. No. 3; 4. Cat. No. 4; 5. Cat. No. 5; 6. Cat. No. 6.
3.3. Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant uncertain.
Weight: 1.97 g (total weight of the two ring fragments)
77
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 4.24 mm; d2: 2.92 mm; D1: 7.04 mm; D2: 5.61 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 1.01 mm; d max: 1.74
Description: Fragment of gold bar from a notched ring bent in order to create a very small ring.
The resulted ring has an oblong shape, with close ends. Given the fact that the fragment used
from the original ring represents one of that items ends, the present ring has one tapering end,
undecorated, and one cut or more probably broken end, decorated with circular parallel
incisions, perpendicular on the gold bar. The bar has circular cross-section. As more details of
the original rings decoration cannot be determined, it is impossible to draw conclusions
regarding its variant. Similar to the ring discussed above (cat. no. 3.3), the smaller length of the
undecorated end could indicate that the original ring was also rather small.
Preservation: Fragment.
4. Ring (Fig. 4/4).
Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant A.
Weight: 6.99 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 31.98 mm; d2: 30.37 mm; D1: 36.28 mm; D2: 35.25 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 0.95 mm; d max: 3.07 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends slightly
overlapping. The decoration divides the gold bar into 5 segments: undecorated ends; 2
intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars
length; 1 central segment more sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel incisions,
forming triangles of various sizes. The central segment is further more pointed out by the bar
slightly bulging in that area. The ring has an ovoid shape.
Preservation: Good.
5. Ring (Fig. 4/5).
Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant B1.
Weight: 6.32 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 32.70 mm; d2: 30.30 mm; D1: 38.01 mm; D2: 34.91 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 0.87 mm; d max: 3.05 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends barely
overlapping and a little distanced from each other. The decoration is divided into 9 segments:
undecorated ends; 2 intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions,
perpendicular on the bars length; 2 intermediary segments decorated with oblique incisions
forming a fir tree pattern parallel on the bars length (the tip of each tree pointing towards
the end to which is closer to); 2 intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel
incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 1 central segment more sophisticatedly decorated
with groupings of parallel incisions, forming triangles of various sizes. From the three segments
with more complex decoration, the main one is slightly bulging in comparison with the rest of
the gold bar. The ring has an ovoid shape.
Preservation: Good.
78
79
slightly bulging in that area. The ring has an oval shape, due also to the fact that the ends were
made to overlap much more than in the case of other rings belonging to this variant.
Preservation: Good, the decoration is very visible.
Fig. 5. 1. Cat. No. 7; 2. Cat. No. 8; 3. Cat. No. 9; 4. Cat. No. 10; 5. Cat. No. 11; 6. Cat. No. 12.
8.2. Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant A.
Weight: 4.95 g
80
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 24.54 mm; d2: 25.90 mm; D1: 28.42 mm; D2: 30.53 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 1.20 mm; d max: 2.89 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends close to each
other. The decoration divides the gold bar into 5 segments: undecorated ends; 2 intermediary
segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 1 central
segment more sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel incisions, forming triangles
of various sizes. The central segment is further more pointed out by the bar slightly bulging in
that area. The ring has a slightly oval shape.
Preservation: Good.
9. Two rings attached to each other (Fig. 5/3). Total weight: 11.80 g.
9.1. Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant B.
Weight: 6.22 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 23.18 mm; d2: 22.86 mm; D1: 28.80 mm; D2: 27.81 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 1.20 mm; d max: 3.16 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends slightly
overlapping. The decoration is divided into 9 segments: undecorated ends; 2 intermediary segments
decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 2 intermediary segments
decorated with oblique incisions forming a fir tree pattern perpendicular on the bars length; 2
intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 1
central segment more sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel incisions, forming
triangles of various sizes. All three segments with more complex decoration are slightly bulging in
comparison with the rest of the gold bar. The ring has an oval shape.
Preservation: Good.
9.2. Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant B.
Weight: 5.58 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 23.67 mm; d2: 23.00 mm; D1: 28.48 mm; D2: 27.83 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 0.99 mm; d max: 2.95 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends slightly
overlapping. The decoration is divided into 9 segments: undecorated ends; 2 intermediary segments
decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 2 intermediary segments
decorated with oblique incisions forming a fir tree pattern perpendicular on the bars length; 2
intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 1
central segment more sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel incisions, forming
triangles of various sizes. All three segments with more complex decoration are slightly bulging in
comparison with the rest of the gold bar. The ring has an oval shape.
Preservation: Good.
10. Three rings attached to each other, in the succession cat. nos. 10.2, 10.3, 10.1 (Fig. 5/4). Total
weight: 13.95 g.
10.1. Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant B.
Weight: 4.97 g
81
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 21.72 mm; d2: 22.75 mm; D1: 27.16 mm; D2: 27.72 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 0.94 mm; d max: 2.70 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends slightly
overlapping. The decoration is divided into 9 segments: undecorated ends; 2 intermediary segments
decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 2 intermediary segments
decorated with oblique incisions forming a fir tree pattern perpendicular on the bars length; 2
intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 1
central segment more sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel incisions, forming
triangles of various sizes. All three segments with more complex decoration are slightly bulging in
comparison with the rest of the gold bar. The ring has an oval shape.
Preservation: Good.
10.2. Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant B3.
Weight: 5.53 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 25.52 mm; d2: 26.51 mm; D1: 29.70 mm; D2: 30.83 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 1.02 mm; d max: 2.85 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends close to each other.
The decoration is divided into 9 segments: undecorated ends; 2 intermediary segments decorated
with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 2 intermediary segments more
sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel incisions, forming triangles of various sizes; 2
intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 1
central segment more sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel incisions, forming
triangles of various sizes. All three segments with more complex decoration are slightly bulging in
comparison with the rest of the gold bar. The ring has an oval shape.
Preservation: Good.
10.3. Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant A1.
Weight: 3.45 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 23.17 mm; d2: 24.04 mm; D1: 27.40 mm; D2: 27.14 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 1.06; d max: 2.48 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends close to each
other. The decoration divides the gold bar into 5 segments: undecorated ends; 2 intermediary
segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 1 limited
central segment decorated with a fir tree pattern, parallel with the bars length, running on one
side of the ring to the right, and on the other side to the left. The ring has a slightly ovoid shape.
Preservation: Good.
11. Three rings attached to each other, in the succession cat. nos. 11.2, 11.1, 11.3 (Fig. 5/5). Total
weight: 13.77 g.
11.1. Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant B4.
Weight: 5.29 g.
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 25.93 mm; d2: 28.77 mm; D1: 31.17 mm; D2: 32.84 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 1.02 mm; d max: 2.90 mm
82
Fig. 6. 1. Cat. No. 13; 2. Cat. No. 14; 3. Cat. No. 15; 4. Detail (Cat. No. 1); 5-6. Details (Cat. No.
2.2); 7. Detail (Cat. No. 3).
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering overlapping ends.
The decoration is divided into 9 segments: undecorated ends; 2 intermediary segments
decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 2 intermediary
segments decorated with oblique incisions forming a fir tree pattern perpendicular on the
bars length; 2 intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular
on the bars length; 1 central segment more sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel
83
incisions, forming triangles of various sizes. In fact it is very similar to the variant B rings,
except for the fact that the segments with more complex decoration are not so visibly marked
through the bulging of the gold bar. The ring has an oval shape.
Preservation: Good.
11.2. Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant C.
Weight: 2.17 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 14.92 mm; d2: 16.63 mm; D1: 18.68 mm; D2: 20.11 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 0.97 mm; d max: 2.20 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering overlapping ends. The
decoration is divided into 3 segments: undecorated ends; 1 extended central segment decorated with
circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the gold bar. The ring has an oval shape.
Preservation: Good.
11.3. Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant A.
Weight: 6.31 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 25.12 mm; d2: 25.76 mm; D1: 31.70 mm; D2: 32.06 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 1.22 mm; d max: 3.27 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends slightly
overlapping. The decoration divides the gold bar into 5 segments: undecorated ends; 2
intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars
length; 1 central segment more sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel incisions,
forming triangles of various sizes. The central segment is further more pointed out by the bar
slightly bulging in that area. The ring has a very slight oval shape.
Preservation: Good.
12. Ring (Fig. 5/6).
Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant B.
Weight: 3.50 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 14.40 mm; d2: 18.98 mm; D1: 20.51 mm; D2: 23.87 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 1.04 mm; d max: 2.66 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends slightly
overlapping. The decoration is divided into 9 segments: undecorated ends; 2 intermediary
segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 2
intermediary segments decorated with oblique incisions forming a fir tree pattern
perpendicular on the bars length; 2 intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel
incisions, perpendicular on the bars length; 1 central segment more sophisticatedly decorated
with groupings of parallel incisions, forming triangles of various sizes. All three segments with
more complex decoration are slightly bulging in comparison with the rest of the gold bar. The
ring has an oval shape and it is comparatively small.
Preservation: Good.
84
Fig. 7. 1-2. Details (Cat. No. 3); 3. Detail (Cat. Nos. 3.2-3); 4-5. Details (Cat. No. 4); 6. Detail
(Cat. No. 5).
85
Fig. 8. 1-2. Details (Cat. No. 5); 3-4. Details (Cat. No. 6); 5-6. Details (Cat. No. 7)
13. Ring (Fig. 6/1).
Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant A.
Weight: 2.01 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 18.87 mm; d2: 21.83 mm; D1: 22.27 mm; D2: 24.71 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 1.07; d max: 1.96 mm
86
Fig. 9. 1. Detail (Cat. No. 7); 2-3. Details (Cat. No. 8.1); 4-5. Details (Cat. No. 8.2); 6. Detail (Cat.
No. 9.1).
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends slightly
overlapping, but distanced from each other. The decoration divides the gold bar into 5
segments: undecorated ends; 2 intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions,
perpendicular on the bars length; 1 central segment more sophisticatedly decorated with
87
groupings of parallel incisions, forming triangles of various sizes. The central segment is further
more pointed out by the bar slightly bulging in that area. The ring has an oval shape. It is very
small and the bar is very thin.
Preservation: Good.
Fig. 10. 1-2. Details (Cat. No. 9.1); 3-4. Details (Cat. No. 9.2); 5. Detail (Cat. No. 10.2); 6. Detail
(Cat. No. 10.3).
14. Ring (Fig. 6/2)
Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant A.
Weight: 3.18 g
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 19.13 mm; d2: 22.73 mm; D1: 23.21 mm; D2: 26.27 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 1.08 mm; d max: 2.16 mm
88
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends slightly
overlapping. The decoration divides the gold bar into 5 segments: undecorated ends; 2
intermediary segments decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the bars
length; 1 central segment more sophisticatedly decorated with groupings of parallel incisions,
forming triangles of various sizes. The central segment is further more pointed out by the bar
slightly bulging in that area. The ring has an oval shape. It is small and the bar is very thin.
Preservation: Good, but one of the ends is twisted.
Fig. 11. 1. Detail (Cat. No. 11.1); 2. Detail (Cat. No. 11.2); 3. Detail (Cat. No. 11.3); 4. Detail (Cat.
No. 14); 5. Detail (Cat. No. 13); 6. Possible use of the notched rings as earrings.
15. Ring (Fig. 6/3).
Type: Notched ring of Brdu type, variant C.
Weight: 5.25 g
89
Dimensions: Diameters: d1: 31.37 mm; d2: 31.63 mm; D1: 35.52 mm; D2: 35.58 mm; Cross-section
diameters: d min: 0.95 mm; d max: 2.22 mm
Description: Ring made of gold bar with circular cross-section and tapering ends, slightly
overlapping. The decoration is divided into 3 segments: undecorated ends; 1 extended central
segment decorated with circular parallel incisions, perpendicular on the gold bar. The ring has
an oval shape.
Preservation: Good.
Bibliography
Ardos, F. 1936, Date arheologice privitoare la Oradea i judeul Bihor, Familia 3, 4, 61-76
Butler, J.J. 2002, Ingots and Insights: Reflections on Rings and Ribs, in Bartelheim, M.,
Pernicka, E., Krause, R. (Hrsg.), Die Anfnge der Metallurgie in der alten
Welt, Verlag Marie Leidorf, Freiberg, 229-243.
Cowell, M.R., Hook, D.R., 2010, The analysis of metal artefacts, in Johns, C., The Hoxne
Late Roman Treasure. Gold Jewellery and Silver Plate, The British Museum
Press, London, 175-183.
Dumitrescu, V. 1936, Le depot de la fin de lge du bronze dcouvert Tuteni, Dacia 5-6,
225-234.
Florescu, M., Florescu, A. 1983, Cercetrile arheologice de la Cndeti Coasta Banului,
com. Dumbrveni, jud. Vrancea, Materiale 15, 112-123.
Gramatopol, M., Theodorescu, R. 1966, Vechi podoabe de aur n coleciile Cabinetului
Numismatic al Academiei Republicii Socialiste Romnia, Studii i Cercetri de
Istoria Artei, Seria Arta plastic 13, 1, 63-95.
Junk, M. 2003, Material properties of copper alloys containing arsenic, antimony, and
bismuth. The material of Early Bronze Age ingot torques, Freiberg.
Luca, S.A., Pinter, Z.K., Georgescu, A. 2003, Repertoriul arheologic al judeului Sibiu.
Situri, monumente arheologice i istorice, Bibliotheca Septemcastrensis 3, Ed.
Economic, Sibiu.
Mozsolics, A. 1973, Bronze- und Goldfunde des Karpatenbeckens. Depotfund horizonte von
Forr und plyi, Budapest.
Mller-Karpe, H. 1959, Beitrge zur Chronologie der Urnenfelderzeit nrdlich und sdlich
der Alpen, Berlin.
Oan-Marghitu, R. 2013, Depozitul de la Tuteu, jud. Bihor, Cat. No. 35.1-35.5, in OanMarghitu, R. (ed.), Aurul i argintul antic al Romniei, Catalog de Expoziie,
Muzeul Naional de Istorie a Romniei, Bucureti, 224.
Prvan, V. 1926, Getica, Bucureti.
Petrescu-Dmbovia, M. 1961, Date noi cu privire la depozitul de bronzuri de la Tuteu (r.
Marghita, reg. Criana), ArhMold 1, 81-114.
90
Victor H. Baumann1*
Abstract: The find in Tulcea, close to the ancient settlement of Aegyssus, of a Dionysian basrelief fragment dated to the Roman period, enables the author to digress briefly into Dionysian
mythology. The bas-relief represents Dionysus as a child, symbolizing regeneration and renewal.
Given the few plastic representations of the Divine Child myth, this find contributes to better
understanding of the cult of Dionysus during the Roman period. The author deems the find one of a kind.
Despite clumsy artistic expression, the bas-relief synthesizes the most dramatic episode in the Dionysian
myth the rebirth, the victory on death, the new beginning, the cyclical renewal of the world.
Rezumat: Descoperirea unui fragment de relief dionisiac, de epoc roman, n Tulcea, n
apropierea vechiului ora Aegyssus, i d posibilitatea autorului s fac o scurt incursiune n mitologia
lui Dionysos, divinitate unic, att n plan cultual, ct i cultural, n general. Fiind vorba de o
reprezentare plastic a lui Dionysos copil, relieful votiv capt o importan aparte, datorat cultului
Copilului Divin care semnifica regenerarea i rennoirea, in extenso, a lumii, anunndu-i un nou
nceput. n acelai timp, datorit numrului redus al reprezentrilor plastice ale mitului referitoare la
copilria lui Dionysos, aceast descoperire contribuie la o mai bun nelegere a felului n care zeul
continua s fie vzut n plin epoc roman. Autorul consider c, dincolo de unele stngcii, vizibile n
execuia artistic a reliefului, suntem n faa unui unicat al plasticii dionisiace, artistul reuind s
realizeze o sintez plastic a celui mai dramatic moment al mitului dionisiac, al renaterii, al victoriei
asupra morii, al noului nceput, al rennoirii ciclice a lumii.
Keywords: Tulcea, Dionysus, myth, Silenus, nymphae, satyr, Hermes, Ariadne.
Cuvinte cheie: Tulcea, Dionysos, mit, silen, nimfe, satir, Hermes, Ariadna.
92
Victor H. BAUMANN
Fig. 1. Planul oraului Tulcea cu locul descoperirii reliefului dionisiac (II), la cca. 1 km SE de
cetatea Aegyssus (I) / Layout of Tulcea with the place of discovery of the Dionysian bas-relief
(II), approx. 1 km SE of Aegyssus settlement (I).
Fragmentul de relief votiv a pstrat o mare parte din imaginea copilului Dionysos,
sculptat n ni, n basorelief, ncadrat de chenare late i fronton triunghiular2, sugernd
faada unui templu, sau mai degrab a unui monument funerar.
Piesa descoperit la Tulcea se ncadreaz printre reliefurile de cult, definite de
Radu Florescu icoane populare, specifice zonei balcano-anatoliene3. Este sculptat n
calcar cretacic de Bachioi, fragmentul pstrndu-se n urmtoarele dimensiuni:
H max.= 33 cm; h minim = 19,5 cm; g = 15 cm. Lime pstrat: sus = 18,5 cm; max.=
26 cm; jos = 14 cm. H Dionysos = 23 cm. Fronton: h = 5 cm; L = 23 cm. Frontonul este
decorat cu dou ramuri de mslin, unite printr-un fruct n zona central a
triunghiului. n chenarul din stnga este sculptat un vrej masiv de vi-de-vie, cu
frunze i ciorchini de struguri (rezervat: o frunz i un ciorchine). Baza frontonului,
respectiv cornia, mai groas dect prile laterale ale acestuia, se aseamn mai mult
cu linourile aflate deasupra intrrilor n mausoleele greco-romane.
2
3
Piesa se pstreaz n colecia Muzeului de Istorie i Arheologie din Tulcea, nr. inv. 45.222.
Florescu 1980, 134.
93
94
Victor H. BAUMANN
8
9
10
95
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
96
Victor H. BAUMANN
limbaj plastic, derivat din simbolistica ciclului vieii 19, atribuind motivelor
ornamentale valori sacre, apotropaice.
2.0. Din epocile greco-elenistic i roman a ajuns pn la noi un numr
relativ mic de reprezentri plastice, referitoare la copilria zeului 20. n acest sens,
am ales cteva dintre cele mai reprezentative. Naterea lui Dionysos: pe o pictur
din epoca clasic greac, aflat n Museo Archeologico Nazionale di Napoli 21 (Fig. 3);
pe un basorelief din aceeai epoc, aflat n Muzeul Vatican22 (Fig. 4); pe un vas
grecesc din sec. al V-lea a.Chr., aflat n Muzeul Louvre, din Paris23 (Fig. 5); i un
detaliu mozaic din Nea Paphos (Cipru SV) Casa lui Aion24 (Fig. 6). Copilria:
Dionysos cu Sylen, Hermes i Pan, pictur din villa roman Boscoreale Muzeul din
Napoli 25; Dionysos clare pe panter detaliu mozaic din Djemila (Algeria)26 (Fig.
7); pruncul Dionysos alptat de doic pe muntele Nysa fresc din Villa Farnestina
(Italia)27 (Fig. 9); mbierea copilului Dionysos pe muntele Nysa Nea Paphos
(Cipru SV) Casa lui Aion, mozaic28 (Fig. 8); Hermes n brae cu pruncul Dionysos
(sculptur greac din sec. al IV-lea a.Chr., aflat n muzeul din Olimpia Grecia)29
(Fig. 11/1); Satyr purtnd n spinare pe Dionysos copil ( sculptur roman din Villa
Albani, Roma )30 (Fig. 11/2); detaliu cu Dionysos copil pictur mural din villa
rustica de la Balca (Pannonia) 31 (Fig. 10). Menionm ns c n iconografia
reprezentrilor plastice, care, n general, iustreaz naterea i pruncia divinitii,
exceptnd cele dou piese din catalogul lui Gasparri (vezi nota 19), apropiate
temetic, nu am ntlnit analogii pentru piesa de la Tulcea.
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
97
Fig. 3. Naterea lui Dionysos (Muzeul din Napoli, Italia) / Birth of Dionysus (Museum of Naples),
Italy (http://www.truthbeknown.com/dionysus.html).
Fig.
4.
Naterea
lui
Dionysos
din
coapsa
lui
Zeus.
Basorelief
antic,
din epoca clasic (Muzeul Vatican) / Birth of Dionysus from the thigh of Zeus. Ancient basrelief antic, classic age (Vatican Museum) (www.cosmovision.com Dionysos: les mythes).
32
33
34
Vezi, n acest sens: Dragomir 1962, 421-430; Irimia 1966, 22-29, nr. 12-16; Scorpan 1967,
passim; Covacef 1973, 111-116; Covacef 1998, 163-167; Alexandrescu-Vianu 2000, 128-131, pl.
173-177(a-d); Covacef 2013, 18-23.
Scorpan 1967, 34-35, fig. 6a i 6b. Cele trei vase de tip oinophoros, aflate n apropierea cetii
Troesmis sunt decorate cu personaje din cortegiul lui Dionysos, care-l acompaniaz pe
acesta. Cf. tirbulescu 2003,19.
Florescu 1980, 135.
98
Victor H. BAUMANN
frumoasele i interesantele reliefuri votive de la Fgrau Nou (jud. Tulcea), din sec.
II-III p.Chr.35 Reliefurile votive mici i mijlocii i aediculae-le, n care figura central a
compoziiei este cea a divinitii, sunt cele mai rspndite monumente dionysiace de
pe teritoriul Dobrogei36. Acestora li se adaug teracotele37, hermele i efigiile cu
caracter decorativ-simbolic38. Mtile greco-romane, reduse ca numr, aparin n
totalitate tradiiei bacchice, fiind reprezentri ale lui Dionysos-Bacchus, tnr i
matur39, dar niciodat copil.
Fig. 5. Dionysos renscut, pictur roie pe fond negru, ceramic attic, sec. al V-lea a.Chr.
(Muzeul Luvru) / Dionysus reborn, red on black painting, Attic ceramic, 5 th c. BC (Louvre
Museum) (www.histoire-fr.com: Les Dieux grecqs files. Mythologie grecque. I. La Gense, II,
Les Olympiens, no. 13).
35
36
37
38
39
99
Fig. 6. Naterea lui Dionysos (Nea Paphos, Cipru SV, Casa lui Aion, detaliu mozaic) / Birth of
Dionysus (Nea Paphos, Cyprus SW, House of Aion, mosaic detail) (Welch 1998, 360, fig.138;
http://romeartlover.tripod.com/Paphos2.html).
2.1 Numrul redus al reprezentrilor plastice ale mitului despre copilria lui
Dionysos, n general, i de pe teritoriul Dobrogei, n special, pune n valoare relieful
votiv de la Tulcea, ntruct acesta nu prezint asemnri conceptuale cu niciuna dintre
piesele cunoscute, care redau scene de la naterile lui Dionysos, datorate lui Zeus i
altor diviniti, sau prezint aspecte din copilria fericit a divinitii, pe muntele
40
41
42
100
Victor H. BAUMANN
Fig. 7. Dionysos copil, clare pe panter, cu nimf i satir, detaliu din mozaicul din Djemila
(Algeria) / Child Dionysus riding a panther, with nymph and satyr, detail in the mosaic of
Djemila (Algeria) (Blanchard 1980, 170, fig. 1).
Fig. 8. mbierea copilului Dionysos (Nea Paphos, Cipru SV, Casa lui Aion, detaliu mozaic) /
Bathing of child Dionysus (Nea Paphos, Cyprus SW, House of Aion, mosaic detail) (Welch 1998,
360, fig. 138; http://romeartlover.tripod.com/Paphos2.html).
101
n acest sens, vezi cultul ErouluiCavaler, unde, la fel ca i n cazul lui Herakles (Hercules la
omani) simbolul acceptat de greci era obinerea nemuririi prin suferin (Kernbach 1989,
219221), ceea ce era valabil i pentru alte diviniti, precum Dionysos, concepii
eschatologice care au strbtut veacurile pn la victoria cretinismului, i nu numai, fiind
asimilate de asceza cretin ncepnd din sec. IV a.Chr.
102
Victor H. BAUMANN
44
45
46
103
Fig. 11. 1. Hermes n brae cu pruncul Dionysos (sculptur greac din sec. al IV-lea a.Chr.),
Muzeul din Olimpia; 2. Satyr purtnd n spinare pe Dionysos copil (sculptur roman din
sec. II p.Chr.,Villa Albani, Roma) / Hermes holding infant Dionysus (Greek sculpture, 4th c.
BC), Museum of Olimpia; 2. Satyr carrying child Dionysus on his back (Roman sculpture, 2nd c.
AD, Villa Albani, Rome) (Alpatov 1962; Ajootian 2000).
104
Victor H. BAUMANN
Fig. 11. 1. Bacchus-copil. Figurin din lut ars din Tomis (?), MINA-Constana; 2. Teracot,
colecia Canarache, MINA-Constana; 3. Satyr n brae cu Bacchus-copil, vas de bronz,
sec. II p.Chr., Callatis / Child Bacchus. Burnt clay figurine from Tomis (?), MINA-Constana;
2. Terracotta, Canarache collection, MINA-Constana; 3. Satyr holding child Bacchus, bronze
vessel, 2nd c. AD, Callatis (Irimia 1966; Scorpan 1967).
105
106
Victor H. BAUMANN
ISACCEANOVIODUNUM.
ARTEFACTE DIN MATERII DURE ANIMALE DESCOPERITE N 2014
Corneliu Beldiman
Aurel-Daniel Stnic
Diana-Maria Sztancs
Abstract: Isaccea, Tulcea County (Noviodunum) -osseous materials discovered during 2014
archaeological campaign. The archaeological researches carried out in 2014 in various sectors of IsacceaFortress site (Noviodunum), Tulcea County (NOV) recovered several osseous materials artefacts. Their
study continues the systematic analysis of this type of artefacts discovered at Noviodunum, which started
in 2013. Such artefacts already form here a rich collection, gathered during the past six decades of
archaeological excavations.
The dispersion of discoveries in various sectors of the site does not allow us to formulate some
detailed conclusions. We need to take into account the existence of some workshops where osseous
materials artefacts (especially those made of red deer antler) were manufactured during the Roman period
and Middle Ages (the 2nd3rd centuries AD; 13th century). These items were probably used in composite
artefacts such as: tools, weapons, clothing accessories, furniture accessories, various wooden artefacts,
weapons etc. The raw materials discovered in various stages of manufacture (blanks, unfinished; raw
material etc.) are proofs in this respect.
This analysis aims at extensively highlighting the latest discoveries and the related primary data.
The data in the catalogue and tables 1-2 provide all significant information regarding the artefacts,
according to the current methodology in the field.
In order to achieve the objectives of the study, optical means of observation were used (optical
microscope, zoom 10 40; digital microscope, zoom 10 400); complete sets of images at various
scales were taken (microscopic including), thus initiating an image data base of artefacts discovered at
Noviodunum. The catalogue includes artefacts coded NOV/2014_1 and numbered from 1 to 9, classified
from typologically.
Chronological and cultural data related to the studied artefacts were provided by the author of the
researches (A. D. Stnic) and were correlated (wherever possible) with the observations regarding the
typological and technological specifics. The data are preliminary and can be revised.
Each artefact was studied according to a standard protocol comprising several levels and
components in order to register the data in an extensive/exhaustive manner (see the catalogue).
The typological categories that form the assemblage are presented according to Beldiman 2007
Typology List: Weapons: Tools: bone needles (2); Weapons: bone arrowhead (1); Accessories: red deer
Universitatea Cretin Dimitrie Cantemir, Facultatea de Istorie, Splaiul Unirii Nr. 176,
Sector 4, 040042 Bucureti.
Institutul de Cercetri Eco-Muzeale Gavril Simion, Str. Progresului Nr. 32, 820009 Tulcea.
coala Central, Str. Icoanei Nr. 3-5, Sector 2, 020451 Bucureti.
PEUCE, S.N. XIII, 2015, p. 107 - 136
108
antler perforated plate (1); Hafts: handle made of red deer antler (1); decorated bone plate (1); belt buckle
made of red deer antler (1); Technical pieces Raw material, waste: red deer antler tine (1); red deer
antler tine, distal end (1).
Regarding the raw materials, red deer antler is present in 5 items while bone was used for
manufacturing 4 items.
According to the data made available by the authors of the research as well as according to the
data obtained during the typological and technological analysis, the chronology of the artefacts is the
following: Roman period (2nd 3rd centuries 4 items); the Middle Ages (13th century 5 items).
The processing methods of the raw materials include simple procedures such as: fracture,
chopping, scraping, abrasion, sawing, cutting with knives, as well as more complex technological
procedures like: perforation, engraving in order to decorate the piece and finishing it etc. Axe, knife and
saw were the tools used for this purpose. The manufacture of the artefacts was specialised, involving the
existence of some workshops inside or outside the site (trade could be alternative source).
The analysis of the assemblage provides the new typological, technological, cultural and
chronological benchmarks for the complex and extensive approach of the cultural manifestations at
Noviodunum during the Roman period and the Middle Ages.
Rezumat: Cercetrile arheologice din anul 2014 de la Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea au avut
caracter preventiv i s-au desfurat n sectorul afectat de lucrrile de construire a vitorului sediul al
Poliiei de Frontier, Sector Isaccea (TPF). Campania arheologic 2014 de la Noviodunum a prilejuit i
recuperarea unui lot de artefacte aparinnd industriei materiilor dure animale. n marea lor majoritate,
piesele provin din complexe: S1/C11, S1/C12, S2/C3B, S3/C3 dou piese, S13/C15 = gropi databile n
sec. al XIII-lea; S6/C3 dou piese = groap databil n sec. II-III p.Chr.; o pies passim. Studiul lor
continu analiza sistematic a acestui gen de materiale (nceput n 2013), care formeaz deja o colecie
bogat, alctuit pe parcursul a ase decenii de spturi arheologice.
Efectivul total include 9 piese. Scopul analizei de fa este acela de a introduce n circuitul
tiinific descoperirile cele mai recente, cu datele primare n form extensiv. Repertoriul ofer toate aceste
date semnificative relative la artefacte, tratate conform reperelor metodologiei actuale a domeniului.
Analiza a recurs, n mod sistematic, la mijloace optice de observare (microscop optic, mriri 10 40;
microscop digital, mriri 10 400); au fost realizate seturi complete de fotografii la diverse scri,
inclusiv cu ajutorul microscopului, iniiindu-se baza de imagini a repertoriului artefactelor din sit (Fig.
1-20). Catalogul include piesele avnd indicativul provizoriu NOV/2014, piesele fiind numerotate de la 1
la 9 (exemplu: NOV/2014_1), ordonate pe criterii tipologice. Atribuirile cultural-cronologice ale
materialelor studiate preiau ncadrrile propuse de autorii cercetrilor (epoca roman i medio-bizantin),
corelate, acolo unde a fost posibil, cu observaiile asupra specificului aspectelor tipologice i tehnologice.
Ele sunt preliminare, putnd comporta unele revizuiri.
Piesele se pstreaz n coleciile Muzeului de Istorie i Arheologie din cadrul Institutului de
Cercetri Eco-Muzeale "Gavril Simion", Tulcea,. Fiecare artefact a fost tratat dup un protocol
standard, cu mai multe paliere i componente, viznd nregistrarea extensiv/exhaustiv a datelor; pentru
detalii a se vedea catalogul.
Categoriile tipologice reprezentate sunt, n conformitate cu lista tipologic Beldiman 2007: I Unelte:
ace de cusut de os (N = 2); II Arme: vrf de sgeat de os (N = 1); III Accesorii: cataram de corn de cerb (N
= 1); plcu de os (N = 1); plcu de corn de cerb (N = 1); IV Elemente receptoare: mner de corn de cerb
109
(N = 1); V Diverse: Materii prime Corn de cerb (N = 1); Deeuri de corn de cerb (N = 1); efectiv total N =
9. Materiile prime, eboele, piesele rebutate, deeurile indic procesarea local probabil a MDA n ateliere n
care se produceau (i) artefacte IMDA (os i corn de cerb). n privina materiilor prime, predomin cornul de
cerb (5 piese), n timp ce osul este reprezentat prin 4 piese (oase lungi i plate de mamifere de talie mare).
Potrivit datelor furnizate de autorii cercetrilor, dar i n urma analizei datelor tipologice i tehnologice,
ncadrarea cronologic probabil se refer la: epoca roman circa sec. II-III p.Chr. (4 piese: ace de os 2,
nchiztoare pentru pung de piele, cataram); evul mediu sec. al XIII-lea (5 piese).
Piesele IMDA studiate furnizeaz necesare repere tipologice, tehnologice i cultural-cronologice
pentru abordarea complex i extensiv a manifestrilor civilizaiei i culturii comunitilor de la
Noviodunum (respectiv, IMDA) din epoca roman i evul mediu.
Keywords: ancient technology, bone and antler artefacts, decorated artefacts, IsacceaNoviodunum, Middle Ages, Roman period.
Cuvinte cheie: artefacte decorate, epoca roman, evul mediu, industria materiilor dure animale,
Isaccea-Noviodunum, tehnologie antic.
CONTEXTUL
Spturile arheologice din anul 2014 de la IsacceaCetatea Noviodunum, jud.
Tulcea (NOV) au avut caracter preventiv i s-au desfurat n sectorul afectat de
lucrrile pentru Construire sediu sector Poliie de Frontier Isaccea (TPF) 1. Investiia
construirii viitorului sediu al Poliiei de Frontier, Sector Isaccea a afectat o suprafa
de 6000 mp dintr-un teren situat n zona de protecie al sitului arheologic
Noviodunum2. Cercetarea arheologic s-a realizat n dou etape, n funcie de
finanarea asigurat de reprezentantul beneficiarului3. Astfel, n perioada 5 mai - 30
iunie a fost investigat o suprafa de 3000 mp, fiind nregistrat un numr de 164
complexe arheologice. A doua etap a cercetrilor arheologice preventive s-a
desfurat n perioada 15 30 septembrie, fiind investigate, ntre seciunile S14-S17,
110 complexe.
Topoleanu, Stnic 2013; Topoleanu, Stnic 2014; Topoleanu, Stnic 2015a; Topoleanu,
Stnic 2015b (cu bibliografia).
Prima delimitare a sitului arheologic Cetatea Noviodunum, realizat de Victor H. Baumann
n anul 1997, pe baza datelor avute la dispoziie n acel moment, nu a cuprins i terenul
afectat de aceast investiie. Cercetrile de teren realizate n cadrul programului de
cercetare Noviodunum 2000, NAP (Noviodunum Archaeological Project) i Noviodunum
2020 au adus noi date i informaii, referitoare la potenialul arheologic al unor terenuri
situate n vecintatea sitului delimitat.
Avnd n vedere suprafaa mare ce urma a fi cercetat arheologic s-a optat pentru
mprirea acesteia n 18 seciuni, orientate N-S, desprite de martori stratigrafici ce aveau o
lime de 1,00 m. Seciunile au lungimea cuprins ntre 54 m (S 1) i 74 m (S 17).
110
111
5
6
Beldiman, Sztancs 2013; Beldiman et alii 2013; Beldiman, Sztancs 2014; Beldiman, Sztancs
2015; Beldiman et alii 2014; Sztancs et alii 2014.
Beldiman 2007; Sztancs 2011.
Topoleanu, Stnic 2013; Topoleanu, Stnic 2014; Topoleanu, Stnic 2015a; Topoleanu,
Stnic 2015b; http://www.noviodunum.ro.
Beldiman et alii 2011; Beldiman, Sztancs 2007a; Beldiman, Sztancs 2007b; Beldiman, Sztancs 2010;
Beldiman et alii 2010. A se vedea i Nuu, Stanc, Paraschiv 2014; Nuu, Stanc, Stan 2014.
112
Descoperirile databile n evul mediu (sec. XIIIXIV) au fcut rareori obiectul unor
abordri extensive8. Contribuiile generate de analiza loturilor IMDA de la
Noviodunum pot oferi reperele metodologice i repertorial/tipologice actuale pentru
abordarea acestui gen de manifestri ale culturii materiale n spaiul istro-pontic i
regiunile nvecinate.
Piesele sunt inedite i se pstreaz n coleciile Institutului de Cercetri EcoMuzeale, Tulcea, Muzeul de Istorie i Arheologie. Fiecare artefact a fost tratat dup un
protocol standard, cu mai multe paliere i componente, viznd nregistrarea
extensiv/exhaustiv a datelor a se vedea repertoriul. Se vizeaz aspecte precum:
materiile prime; starea de conservare (piese ntregi, fragmentare/fragmente); tipologia;
morfologia; morfometria; urmele de fabricare; urmele de utilizare; formularea
ipotezelor relative la rolul funcional. Fia standard pune la dispoziie datele despre
artefact n urmtoarea structur: Indicativ Tip Cod tipologic Categorie (unelte,
arme, podoabe, materii prime, accesorii etc.) Instituie deintoare/Colecie Numr
de inventar Context Apartenen cultural Fig. Materie prim Stare de
conservare (ntreg, fragmentar, fragment) Descriere (morfologie, date tehnice
privind fabricarea, urme de utilizare, rol funcional prezumat etc.) Dimensiuni (mm)
Bibliografia/Inedit9.
TIPOLOGIE, MATERII PRIME, ASPECTE TEHNOLOGICE I ECONOMICE
Categoriile tipologice reprezentate sunt, n conformitate cu lista tipologic
Beldiman 200710: I Unelte: ace de cusut de os (N = 2); II Arme: vrf de sgeat de os (N =
1); III Accesorii: cataram de corn de cerb (N = 1); plcu de os (N = 1); plcu de corn
de cerb (N = 1); IV Elemente receptoare: mner de corn de cerb (N = 1); V Diverse:
Materii prime Corn de cerb (N = 1); Deeuri de corn de cerb (N = 1); efectiv total N = 9.
Materiile prime, eboele, piesele rebutate, deeurile indic procesarea local
probabil a MDA n ateliere n care se produceau (i) artefacte IMDA (os i corn de cerb).
n privina materiilor prime, predomin cornul de cerb (5 piese), n timp ce osul
este reprezentat prin 4 piese (oase lungi i plate de mamifere de talie mare).
Potrivit datelor furnizate de autorii cercetrilor, dar i n urma analizei datelor
tipologice i tehnologice, ncadrarea cronologic probabil se refer la: epoca roman
circa sec. II-III p.Chr. (4 piese: ace de os 2, nchiztoare pentru pung de piele,
cataram); evul mediu sec. al XIII-lea (5 piese) (tabelele nr. 1-2).
Modalitile de procesare a materiilor prime includ procedee simple, precum
fracturarea, cioplirea, despicarea, raclajul axial, abraziunea, tierea transversal cu
8
9
10
113
114
115
Fig. 1. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_1 / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress). 2014
excavation campaign. Osseous material artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages). NOV/2014_1.
116
Fig. 2. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_1. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous material artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_1.
NOV/2014_3
Vrf de sgeat de os Ebo NOV 2014 TPF S2-3 Complex 3B Sud cript
Fr nr. inv. (provizoriu) Datare probabil: evul mediu (sec. al XIII-lea) Fig. 5-6
Stare de conservare: pies fragmentar lipsete extremitatea distal, fracturat
n vechime; starea de conservare a suprafeelor este foarte bun.
Materie prim: fragment diafizar de os lung, probabil de vit humerus?;
metapod? (Bos taurus).
Descriere: ebo de vrf de sgeat de os; fasonat aproape integral; pstreaz la
partea proximal/extremitatea proximal o poriune a suprafeei medulare (cavitatea
medular). Seciuni ovale i circulare faetate. Form general tronconic alungit.
Extremitatea proximal este concav asimetric (de debitaj). La partea proximal se
observ dou planuri de fractur simetrice. Debitaj realizat probabil prin percuie
117
Fig. 3. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_2. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous material artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_2.
NOV/2014_4
Plcu perforat de corn de cerb NOV 2014 TPF S6 Caroul 7 Complex 1
Nr. inv. 50499 Datare probabil: epoca roman (sec. II-III P.CHR.) Fig. 7-8
Stare de conservare: pies ntreag; starea de conservare a suprafeelor este
bun; urme de coroziune slab uniform distribuite pe suprafeele piesei.
Materie prim: corn de cerb, fragment (compacta) de raz sau de ax.
Descriere: plcu perforat de corn de cerb; probabil nchiztoare de pung de
piele?; form general pentagonal neregulat (sau rectangular cu o extremitate
118
119
120
Fig. 4. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_2. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous material artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_2.
NOV/2014_6
Plcu decorativ gravat de os NOV 2014 TPF S1 Carourile 10-11 Complex 11
Nr. inv. 50506 Datare probabil: evul mediu (sec. al XIII-lea) Fig. 12-13
Stare de conservare: pies fragmentar fracturat n vechime la extremitatea
distal dup gravare; extremitatea proximal a fost modelat prin tiere transversal,
dup gravare; starea de conservare a suprafeelor este foarte bun.
Materie prim: fragment probabil de os plat (corp costal) (compacta) provenind
de la un erbivor de talie mare nedeterminabil vit? (Bos taurus).
121
122
Fig. 5. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_3. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous material artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_3.
Fig. 6. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_3. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_3.
123
Fig. 7. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_4. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_4.
Fig. 8. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_4. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_4.
124
Fig. 9. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_5. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_5.
Fig. 10. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_5. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_5.
125
Fig. 11. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_5. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_5.
Fig. 12. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_6. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_6.
126
Fig. 13. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_6. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_6.
NOV/2014_7
Cataram de corn de cerb NOV 2014 TPF S3 Complex 3 (11)
Nr. inv. 50494 Datare probabil: epoca roman (sec. II-III p.Chr.) Fig. 14-16
Stare de conservare: pies fragmentar lipsete partea distal (bucla),
fracturat recent; starea de conservare a suprafeelor este foarte bun.
Materie prim: corn de cerb, fragment (compacta) de ax de mari dimensiuni.
Descriere: cataram de corn de cerb (pies de centur) masiv, modelat
grosier, nefinisat. Form general trapezoidal, cu marginile concave, extremitatea
127
128
Fig. 14. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_7. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_7.
Fig. 15. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_7. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_7.
NOV/2014_8
Corn de cerb Materie prim NOV 2014 TPF S1 Carourile 10-11 Complex 12 Fr
nr. inv. (provizoriu) Datare probabil: evul mediu (sec. al XIII-lea) Fig. 17-18
129
Fig. 16. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_7. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_7.
Materie prim: corn de cerb, ax drept, exemplar adult de talie mare; ax lepdat;
fragment bazal de ax cu medalion, rozet, raza 1 i baza razei 2.
Descriere: materie prim constituit de baza axului i raza 1, detaat prin
percuie direct/cioplire; extremitatea distal a razei 1 detaat prin acelai procedeu
tehnic, aplicat pe faa anterioar; urme de impact se conserv i pe faa posterioar i
pe cea lateral; detaare prin fracturare; Urme de percuie direct/cioplire, percuie
direct/fracturare la nivelul rozetei, detandu-se cca 2/3 ale circumferinei; percuie
direct/cioplire la nivelul bazei razei 2 pentru detaare prin fracturare; pe ax se
observ urme de cioplire pe faa median i pe faa posterioar, oblice, ample,
130
Fig. 17. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_8. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_8.
NOV/2014_9
Corn de cerb Deeu NOV 2014 TPF Passim Fr nr. inv. (provizoriu)
Datare probabil: evul mediu (sec. al XIII-lea) Fig. 19-20
Stare de conservare: pies ntreag; starea de conservare a suprafeelor este
foarte bun.
Materie prim: corn de cerb, raz, segment distal.
131
Fig. 18. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_8. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_8.
LISTA ABREVIERILOR
Ad. Adncimea; C Caroul; CD Calibrul distal; Diam diametrul; Dist
Distana; ED Extremitatea distal; EP Extremitatea proximal; Ext Exterior; FI
Faa inferioar; FS Faa superioar; Gros Grosimea; IMDA Industria materiilor
dure animale; Int Interior; Inv. Inventar; L Lungimea; L tot Lungimea total;
L Limea; Max Maxim; MD Marginea stng; MD Marginea dreapt; N
Numr; N tot Numr total; NOV Noviodunum; PD Partea distal; Perf
132
Fig. 19. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_9. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_9.
Fig. 20. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca roman
evul mediu). NOV/2014_9. / Isaccea-Noviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress).
2014 excavation campaign. Osseous materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages).
NOV/2014_9.
133
Tabel nr. 1. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca
roman evul mediu). Repertoriu tipologie, datare, context. / Table 1 IsacceaNoviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress). 2014 excavation campaign. Osseous
materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages). Repertory typology, datation, context.
Indicativ/Tip
Epoc/Datare/Cultur
Context
NOV 2014_1
Ac de cusut de os
NOV 2014_2
Ac de cusut de os Ebo
NOV 2014_3
Vrf de sgeat de os
Ebo
NOV 2014_4
Plcu perforat de corn
de cerb
NOV 2014_5
Mner de cuit de corn de
cerb
NOV 2014_6
Plcu decorativ gravat
de os
NOV 2014_7
Cataram de corn de cerb
NOV 2014_8
Corn de cerb Materie
prim
NOV 2014_9
Corn de cerb Deeu
134
Tabel nr. 2. Isaccea-Noviodunum, jud. Tulcea. Punct: Cetate. Campania 2014. IMDA (epoca
roman evul mediu). Repartiia artefactelor pe seciuni i complexe. / Table 2 IsacceaNoviodunum, Tulcea County. Site: Cetate (Fortress). 2014 excavation campaign. Osseous
materials artefacts (Roman period Middle Ages). Distribution of artefacts in excavated sections
and arcghaeological complexes.
Seciune
S1
Complex
C11
Datare
Sec. XIII
C12
S2
3B
Sec. XIII
S3
C3
Sec. XIII
C3
Sec. II-III
C3
Sec. II-III
C1
Sec. XIII
S13
15
Sec. II-III
Passim
Sec. XIII
S6
Artefact
NOV 2014_6
Plcu
decorativ
gravat de os
NOV 2014_8
Corn de cerb
Materie prim
NOV 2014_3
Vrf de sgeat de os
Ebo
NOV 2014_5
Mner de cuit de
corn de cerb
NOV 2014_7
Cataram de corn de
cerb
NOV 2014_1
Ac de cusut de os
NOV 2014_4
Plcu perforat de
corn de cerb
NOV 2014_2
Ac de cusut de os
Ebo
NOV 2014_9
Corn de cerb Deeu
135
Bibliografie
Beldiman, C., Sztancs, D.-M. 2014, Isaccea, jud. Tulcea [Noviodunum], Punct: Cetate,
Sector: Sud-Est. Industria materiilor dure animale descoperit n campaniile 2012 i
2013, CCAR. Campania 2013, 94-97.
Beldiman, C. 2007, Industria materiilor dure animale n preistoria Romniei. Resurse
naturale, comuniti umane i tehnologie din paleoliticul superior pn n neoliticul
timpuriu, Asociaia Romn de Arheologie, Studii de Preistorie
Supplementum 2, Bucureti, 2007.
Beldiman, C., Elefterescu, D., Sztancs, D.-M. 2010, Ostrov-Durostorum. Industria
materiilor dure animale, CCAR. Campania 2009, 132-136.
Beldiman, C., Rusu-Bolinde, V., Achim, I. A., Sztancs, D.-M. 2011, Aspects of ancient
economy at Histria: bone/antler anvils and iron sickles, Angelescu M. V., Achim
I., Bltc A., Rusu-Bolinde V., Bottez V. (ds.), Antiquitas Istro-Pontica.
Mlanges darchologie et dhistoire ancienne offerts Alexandru Suceveanu,
Institut dArchologie Vasile Prvan de lAcademie Roumaine, Facult
dHistoire de lUniversit de Bucarest, Cluj-Napoca, 421-436.
Beldiman, C., Stnic, Sztancs, D.-M. 2014, Isaccea-Noviodunum. Artefacte din materii
dure animale descoperite n 2012 i 2013, Peuce, S.N. 12, 233-268.
Beldiman, C., Sztancs, D.-M. 2007a, Histria. Sectorul Basilica extra muros. Industria
materiilor dure animale, CCAR. Campania 2006, 202-205.
Beldiman, C., Sztancs, D.-M. 2007b, Capidava. Industria materiilor dure animale, CCAR.
Campania 2006, 108-112.
Beldiman, C., Sztancs, D.-M. 2010, Capidava. Industria materiilor dure animale, CCAR.
Campania 2009, 48-50.
Beldiman, C., Sztancs, D.-M. 2013, Isaccea, jud. Tulcea [Noviodunum], Punct: Cetate,
Sector: Sud-Est. Industria materiilor dure animale descoperit n campaniile 20092012, CCAR. Campania 2012, 74-75.
Beldiman, C., Sztancs, D.-M. 2015, Isaccea, jud. Tulcea [Noviodunum], Punct: Cetate,
Sector: Sud-Est. Industria materiilor dure animale descoperit n campania 2014,
CCAR. Campania 2014, 210-216.
Beldiman. C., Stnic, A.-D., Sztancs, D.-M. 2013, Noviodunum. Data about the bone and
antler artefacts, Annales dUniversit Valahia Trgovite, Section
dArchologie et dHistoire 15, 1, 37-53.
Nuu, G., Stanc, S. M., Paraschiv, D. 2014, Niculiel. A Roman Rural Settlement in NorthEast Moesia Inferior. Archaeological & Archaeozoological Research, Archaeologica
et Anthropologica II, Parthenon Verlag, Kaiserslautern und Mehlingen.
136
Nuu, G., Stanc, S., Stan, D. A. 2014, Carved Bone and Antler from Northern Dobruja in
Archaelogical and Archaeozoological Context, Ed. Universitii Alexandru Ioan
Cuza, Iai.
Rusu, A. A., Mrginean, Fl. 2004, Prelucrarea osului i cornului n Transilvania medieval
(nceput de abordare tematic), Arheologia Medieval 5, 113-158.
Sztancs, D.-M. 2011, Industria materiilor dure animale n neo-eneoliticul din Transilvania.
Repertoriu, tipologie, studiu paleotehnologic, date privind paleoeconomia. Baze de
date, tez de doctorat, Universitatea Lucian Blaga" Sibiu, 2011 (nepublicat).
Sztancs, D.-M., Beldiman, C., Stnic, A.-D. 2014, Artefacte din materii dure animale
descoperite la Noviodunum, Comunicare prezentat la Sesiunea Internaional
de Comunicri tiinifice Arheologia Mileniului I p.Chr., Muzeul Judeean
de Istorie i Arheologie Prahova, Ploieti, 28-30 august 2014.
Topoleanu, F. Stnic, A.-D. 2013, Isaccea, jud. Tulcea [Noviodunum], Punct: Cetate,
Sector: Sud-Est, CCAR. Campania 2012, 70-74.
Topoleanu, F., Stnic, A.-D. 2014, Isaccea, jud. Tulcea [Noviodunum], Pun