Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Justin Merritt
Ms. Sobotka
LD Debate: Civil Disobedience
30 November 2015
Affirmative Constructive
I.
Introduction
a. Peace is more important than all justice; and peace was not made for the
sake of justice, but justice for the sake of peace. Martin Luther
b. Resolution: Civil Disobedience in a democracy is justified.
c. Key Terms: (Marriam-Webster Online Dictionary)
i. Civil Disobedience: the refusal to comply with certain laws or to
pay taxes and fines, as a peaceful form of political protest.
ii. Civil Liberties: the state of being subject only to laws established
for the good of the community, especially with regard to freedom
of action and speech; individual rights protected by law from
unjust governmental or other interference.
iii. Democracy: a system of government by the whole population or all
the eligible members of a state, typically through elected
II.
representatives.
Case
a. Value: Justice
i. Defined: the quality of being fair and reasonable
ii. Importance: Civil disobedience in a democracy distinguishes
justice in the face of injustice; thereby establishing utmost vitality
to the decision of non-violent actions.
b. Criterion: Protect/ advocate for the rights of individuals through nonviolent, peaceful actions against the government to achieve justice for all
of humanity.
9.
beaten Riders.
f. 328 people are arrested before they finish.
g. By November, Attorney General Robert Kennedy
and the Interstate Commerce Commission intervene
to force integration.
h. In just a few months the Freedom Riders had
integrated interstate travel.
12. Birmingham, Alabama 1963
a. Selective buying boycott was pressuring local
businesses for equal access to jobs
b. Sit-ins hit Birmingham libraries and restaurants.
c. Kneel-ins disrupted services in all-white churches.
d. Demonstrations continued in violation of a court
order barring further protest, resulting in hundreds
of arrests, including that of King.
e. In a radical escalation of the conflict, over 1,000
young African-Americans, teenagers and even
III.
Conclusion:
a. Summary:
i. Closing: I have shown you that Mohandas Gandhi utilized
effective acts of civil disobedience against unjust actions of Indias
government, in which civil liberties were violated, and leaders of
the Civil Rights Movement, such as Martin Luther King, Jr.,
utilized methods of civil disobedience against the government in
the face of turmoil to achieve justice, and the first amendment
II.
Clarification questions
a. Can you define democracy?
b. When you mentioned specific countries that failed when exercising civil
disobedience, werent those countries that were non-democratic?
Set up argument
a. Can you tell me what the First Amendment of the Constitution guarantees
for all citizens?
b. How do you justify the freedom of speech and freedom to assembly in
regards to civil disobedience? In other words, are citizens only exercising
their civil liberties granted to them by the U.S. Constitution when
engaging in acts of civil disobedience?
Negative Rebuttal
Affirmative Rebuttal (3 Minutes)
I.
II.
Reference List
BRIA 16 3 b Bringing Down an Empire: Gandhi and Civil Disobedience - Constitutional
Rights Foundation. (n.d.). Retrieved November 28, 2015, from http://www.crfusa.org/bill-of-rights-in-action/bria-16-3-b-bringing-down-an-empire-gandhi-andcivil-disobedience
Locke, J. (1689). The Second Treatise of Civil Government. Awnsham Churchill.
Gandhis first act of civil disobedience. (n.d.). Retrieved November 28, 2015, from
http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/gandhis-first-act-of-civil-disobedience
Zunes, S., & Laird, J. (2010). Movements and Campaigns. Nonviolent Conflict, Retrieved
from https://www.nonviolent-conflict.org/index.php/movements-andcampaigns/movements-and-campaigns-summaries?
sobi2Task=sobi2Details&catid=17&sobi2Id=22