Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
PROGRESS REPORT
NOVEMBER DECEMBER 2015
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................................................................. iv
LIST OF FIGURES ............................................................................................................................................ v
ABBREVIATIONS ........................................................................................................................................... vi
Background ................................................................................................................................................... 1
Methodology................................................................................................................................................. 1
Poor Record Keeping..................................................................................................................................... 2
MINIMUM EXPENSES OF POLITICAL PARTIES ............................................................................................... 2
Assessment of Minimum Expenses by Party ............................................................................................ 4
Increase in Party Expenses............................................................................................................................ 7
Minimum Amounts Spent by District........................................................................................................ 8
Expenses of Presidential Candidates in November and December ........................................................ 10
Observed Expenditure Variations ............................................................................................................... 14
CAMPAIGN ADMINISTRATION EXPENSES ............................................................................................... 16
TRANSPORT EXPENSES ................................................................................................................................ 18
Analysis of Transport Expenditure Trends .............................................................................................. 19
Expenditure on Event/Rally/Consultative Meetings Expenses ............................................................... 20
Analysis of Expenditure on Campaign Rallies ......................................................................................... 21
Expenditure on Campaign Materials ...................................................................................................... 22
Analysis of Campaign Materials Expenditure ......................................................................................... 23
Electronic and Print Media Expenses...................................................................................................... 24
Expenses on Journalists by Presidential Candidate (Nov & Dec) ............................................................ 25
Analysis of Expenditure on Media .......................................................................................................... 26
Expenses on Handout Materials ............................................................................................................. 27
Analysis of Expenditure on Handout Materials ...................................................................................... 31
Donations, Fundraising/Vote Buying & Misuse of State Resources ....................................................... 33
Nexus between Voter Tourism, Voter Hospitality and Voter Bribery .................................................... 37
Misuse of Government Resources .......................................................................................................... 38
RECOMMENDATIONS ................................................................................................................................. 42
APPENDIX I .................................................................................................................................................. 43
APPENDIX II ................................................................................................................................................. 45
APPENDIX III ................................................................................................................................................ 47
APPENDIX IV ................................................................................................................................................ 48
iii
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: Amount Spent by All Parties & Candidates per Month (Nov-Dec) ................................................. 2
Table 2: Minimum Expenses by Party & Party Members (November & December 2015) ........................... 5
Table 3: Total Amount Spent by Candidates/Parties per District (Nov-Dec) ................................................ 8
Table 4: Amount Spent by Presidential Candidates in November & December ........................................ 10
Table 5: Average Campaign Admin Expenses for Nov-Dec per Parliamentary Candidate ......................... 16
Table 6: Expenses on Means of Transport Used to Arrive at Rally/Event (Nov-Dec) ................................. 18
Table 7: Event/Rally/Consultative Meetings Expenses for Nov-Dec (%) .................................................... 20
Table 8: Campaign Materials Expenses for November & December.......................................................... 22
Table 9: Electronic and Print Media Expenses for November & December ............................................... 24
Table 10: Handout Materials Expenses in November & December ........................................................... 27
Table 11: Examples of Materials Handed Out During Campaigns .............................................................. 32
Table 12: Donations & Fundraising/Vote Buying for November-December .............................................. 33
Table 13: Examples of Donations During Campaigns ................................................................................. 34
Table 14: Examples of Misuse of State Resources ...................................................................................... 40
Table 15: NRM Party Minimum Expenses by November 2015 ................................................................... 43
Table 16: SUMMARY of NRM Party Minimum Expenses by November 2015 ............................................ 45
Table 17: FDC Party Minimum Expenses by November 2015..................................................................... 47
Table 18: Amama Mbabazi Minimum Expenses in WestNile ..................................................................... 48
iv
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Amount Spent by All Parties & Candidates per Month (Nov-Dec) ................................................ 3
Figure 2: Minimum Expenses by Party & Party Members (November & December 2015) ......................... 5
Figure 3: % Change in Expenses by Party & Party Members (November & December) .............................. 6
Figure 4: Total Amount Spent by Candidates/Parties per District (Nov-Dec)............................................... 9
Figure 5: % Increase in Amount Spent by Candidates/Parties per District ................................................. 10
Figure 6: Amount Spent by Presidential Candidates in November & December ....................................... 11
Figure 7: % Change in Expenses by Presidential Candidates in November & December ........................... 15
Figure 8: Campaign Administration Expenses for November and December ............................................ 17
Figure 9: Percentage Change in Administration Expenses for November and December ......................... 18
Figure 10: Use of Means of Transport Used to Arrive at Rally/Event (November & Dec) .......................... 19
Figure 11: % Change in Expenses on Means of Transport Used (Nov-Dec) ................................................ 20
Figure 12: Event/Rally/Consultative Meetings Expenses for Nov-Dec (%) ................................................. 21
Figure 13: Event/Rally/Consultative Meetings Expenses for Nov-Dec (%) ................................................. 22
Figure 14: Campaign Materials Expenses for November & December ...................................................... 23
Figure 16: Overall Campaign Materials Expenses (Nov-Dec)...................................................................... 24
Figure 17: Electronic and Print Media Expenses for November & December ............................................ 25
Figure 18: % Change in Electronic and Print Media Expenses for November & December ....................... 27
Figure 19: Handout Materials Expenses in November & December .......................................................... 28
Figure 20: % Increase in Expenses on Handout Materials in November & December ............................... 31
Figure 21: Donations & Fundraising/Vote Buying forNovember-December .............................................. 33
Figure 22: SUMMARY of NRM Party Minimum Expenses by November 2015 ........................................... 46
ABBREVIATIONS
ACCOB
ACCU
ACFIM
CEON
CEPDA
CODI
DGF
DP
Democratic Party
FABIO
FDC
KICK
MACCO
MIRAC
MONARLIP
NRM
NDI
NTF
NUAC
RAC
SMS
TAACC
TAC
TIU
UGX
Uganda Shillings
UPC
WACSOF
vi
Background
Monitoring the expenditure of candidates for presidential and Member of Parliament races
during the pre-election period is one of the many aspects that civil society is observing in the preelection period. Alliance for Campaign Finance Monitoring (ACFIM) is the specialized body of civil
society organisations that are conducting this initiative as an extended study to come up with
credible estimates of how much political parties and individual candidates spend on election
campaigns; document how money is used in campaign and the extent to which it influences
election outcomes. The study further interrogates how budget funds are used or misused in
election campaigns. Access to credible information about use of money in election campaigns in
Uganda is critical to developing national interventions that will among other things equalize the
conditions for political competition. Reforms in electoral and political financing will benefit
tremendously from information collected and shared by ACFIM.
We leverage the presence of 65 locally recruited campaign finance monitors that are using their
familiarity with the local context and situational awareness to gather data. This data is analysed
and to show the extent to which money influences political campaigns and election outcomes.
The data is collected from 16 districts namely: Kampala, Luweero, Masaka, Jinja, Iganga, Kabale,
Kanungu, Bushenyi, Kabarole, Hoima, Arua, Nwoya, Lira, Apac, Katakwi and Moroto. As ACFIM
we strongly believe that unregulated use of money in election campaigns is one of the main
causes of commercialization of politics, a problem that will require Ugandans from all walks of
life to take action to reduce it.
Methodology
The 16 districts covered under the scope of ACFIM comprise a total of 74 constituencies
representing 14.4% of the whole country. The data reported does provide an indication of
emerging trends that give a clear indication of happenings and changes in voting behavior in
major geographical regions. ACFIM monitors use scientific tools to collect data on campaign
expenses of political parties and candidates, voter bribery and misuse of government
administrative resources for campaigns at constituency level. Filled campaign expenses tools are
submitted to district supervisors who keep moving from constituency to constituency for data
quality assurance. There is a team of experts at ACFIM secretariat that frequently carries out data
quality control checks across the 16 districts. Collected data is entered into a web-based
database. During the reporting period, monitors submit data on campaign events and
incidents/happenings they have observed directly and indirectly. Critical incidences are
transmitted to supervisors in real time by the use of phone calls or Short Message Service text
messaging.
1
Key Findings
Poor Record Keeping
Political parties and candidates participating in the campaigns for the 2016 general elections are
poor at keeping record of expenditure incurred on campaign trail. ACFIM Researchers report that
the campaign finance management systems of participating political parties and candidates are
by and large rudimentary. The absence of legal requirement for disclosure of campaign income
and expenditure makes harder the task of capturing and verifying all data collected. The
information presented by ACFIM in this report should be understood in terms of credible
minimums of campaign expenditure.
The minimum amount of money observed to have been spent by parties and their flag bearers in
the observed districts was UGX 49.6 billion in November and 88.1 billion in December
representing an increase of 77% over the two months. This increase is largely attributed to the
commencement of member or parliament campaigns having been nominated on the 3 rd and 4th
of December 2015. Nomination days for members of parliament were characterized with
profligate expenditure as candidates were eager to announce their presence or arrival on the
political scene. ACFIM observers reported use of motorcades, bodabodas cyclists, entertainers;
and provided transport refund, food and drinks for supporters that accompanied them to
nomination and attended the nomination rallies.
Table 1: Amount Spent by All Parties & Candidates per Month (Nov-Dec)
Month
AMOUNT SPENT
% OF TOTAL
November
49,625,169,000
36.0
December
88,063,034,700
64.0
137,688,203,700
100.0
TOTAL
% CHANGE
1.77
49,625,169,000
November
December
88,063,034,700
Caption: Bodaboda cyclists hired by a number of candidates to add pomp to their processions
on nomination day.
Caption: Nomination day for Member of Parliament candidates in Luweero district: Above left is a state
of the art platform build by independent candidate Patricia Magara of Katikamu South constituency.
Caption: The coaches, minibuses and wagons that escorted MP candidate Salongo Alfred Muwanga that
on nominmtion day in Luwero District. Nominations were awash with the pomp that money could buy.
Table 2: Minimum Expenses by Party & Party Members (November & December 2015)
PARTY
NRM
INDEPENDENTS
FDC
GO FORWARD
DP
UPC
OTHERS
TOTAL
NOVEMBER
44,413,292,000
2,327,800,000
1,293,965,000
849,120,000
429,480,000
184,342,000
127,170,000
49,625,169,000
DECEMBER
76,589,135,000
8,529,394,000
1,612,253,000
649,785,700
224,383,000
228,257,000
229,827,000
88,063,034,700
% of TOTAL
87.9
7.9
2.1
1.1
0.5
0.3
0.3
100.0
% Change
+72
+266
+25
-23
-48
+24
+81
+77
Figure 2: Minimum Expenses by Party & Party Members (November & December 2015)
70,000,000,000
60,000,000,000
50,000,000,000
40,000,000,000
30,000,000,000
20,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
0
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER
PARTY
Observable
Minimum Cost
Expense Category
Per village to reactivate NRM village
1 structures
15,000,000,000
19,000,000,000
20,000,000,000
6,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
30,000,000,000
TOTAL
100,000,000,000
Expense Category
1
3
4
Contribution to TDA
Fuel on Campaign Trail @ 900,000
10
11
12
200,000,000
210,000,000
50,000,000
54,000,000
TOTAL
120,000,000
42,000,000
20,000,000
15,000,000
801,000,000
1,512,000,000
The graphic representation below shows that the minimum expenses that were incurred by the NRM
party in five months (May October 2015) before nominations for presidential candidates, is over 66
times more than what the strongest opposition party FDC has spent in seven month (May December
2015).
Figure 3: Comparison between NRM Party and FDC Party Spending
100,000,000,000
80,000,000,000
60,000,000,000
40,000,000,000
20,000,000,000
0
NRM (May - Oct. 2015
Figure 4: % Change in Expenses by Party & Party Members (November & December)
% INCREASE/DECREASE
250
200
150
100
50
(50)
(100)
PARTY/ PRESSURE GROUP
NOVEMBER
13,609,018,000
8,874,592,000
4,417,323,100
3,320,783,000
3,296,972,800
2,975,282,000
2,283,512,000
2,130,552,200
1,675,587,000
DECEMBER
22,859,128,000
14,599,592,500
8,491,767,000
6,153,370,900
6,241,036,000
5,593,768,000
4,263,801,000
3,721,684,000
2,322,366,200
8
% of Total
26.5
17.0
9.4
6.9
6.9
6.2
4.8
4.3
2.9
% Change
68.0
64.5
92.2
85.3
89.3
88.0
86.7
74.7
38.6
MOROTO
KABALE
APAC
HOIMA
KABAROLE
KANUNGU
NWOYA
TOTAL
1,524,316,200
1,281,064,900
1,113,817,200
826,031,600
807,675,000
780,340,000
708,302,000
49,625,169,000
2,841,009,000
2,575,309,000
2,125,504,200
1,259,060,000
1,890,503,400
1,997,027,500
1,128,108,000
88,063,034,700
3.2
2.8
2.4
1.5
2.0
2.0
1.3
100.0
86.4
101.0
90.8
52.4
134.1
155.9
59.3
77.5
25,000,000,000
20,000,000,000
15,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
5,000,000,000
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER
DISTRICTS
Variation in Expenditure
All districts witnessed an increase in the expenditure by candidates/parties from the months of
November and December at an overall rate of 77.5%. The highest increase in expenditure was
observed in the district of Kanungu with 156% increase, followed by Kabarole (134%) and Kabale
(101%). The least increment in expenditure was in the districts of Lira (39%), Hoima (52%), Nwoya
(59%) and Luweero (65%).
9
% INCREASE
140.0
120.0
100.0
80.0
60.0
40.0
20.0
-
DISTRICTS
NOVEMBER
4,897,716,000
849,123,000
129,556,500
31,402,000
14,532,000
10
DECEMBER
22,252,640,000
498,237,000
847,103,000
64,330,000
19,779,000
% of
Total
91.61
4.55
3.30
0.32
0.12
% CHANGE
+354
-41
+554
+105
+36
Mabirizi Joseph
Maureen Faith Kyalya
TOTAL
11,571,000
3,709,500
5,937,610,000
14,915,000
1,983,000
23,698,987,000
0.09
0.02
100.00
25,000,000,000
A
M 20,000,000,000
O
U
N 15,000,000,000
T
S 10,000,000,000
P
E
5,000,000,000
N
T
-
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER
CANDIDATES
11
+29
-47
+299
Caption: Branded chopper used in November to rally voters to turn up for candidate Yoweri
Museveni campaign rallies.
Caption: (ABOVE) FDC presidential candidate Kizza Besigye invested significantly in branding the
mobile campaign platform and the public address system that moves with it. BELOW: The NRM
party branded vehicle that carries the sound system and entertainers as party of the candidate
Yoweri Musevenis advance party.
12
ACFIM Observers have christened him: The Money Man. He is retired Leut. Gen. Henry Tumukunde. He
was handing over UGX 20million to an association of vendors in Entebbe Market in December. He has
been leading the advance party of candidate Yoweri Museveni. Observers in Arua reported that he handed
out UGX 50,000 to 400 voters who claimed to have converted from FDC they met him at White Castle
Hotel in Arua.
13
Caption: The drinks served on to attendees on Candidate Museveni Rallies This particular consignment
was in observed in Usuk, Katakwi district.
14
600
500
400
300
200
100
(100)
Yoweri
Kaguta
Museveni
Amama
Mbabazi
Abed
Bwanika
PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATES
15
Mabirizi
Joseph
Maureen
Faith Kyalya
November
1,545,000
237,000
310,000
166,000
37,000
36,000
2,331,000
16
December
2,275,000
498,000
453,000
324,000
54,000
159,000
3,763,000
% of
Total
63
12
13
8
1
3
100
% Increase or
Decrease
+47
+110
+46
+95
+46
+342
+61
500,000
November
1,000,000
1,500,000
2,000,000
2,500,000
The month of December 2015 saw an increase in administration expenses observed across the
74 constituencies under ACFIM study scope. The biggest increase was on Computer/Internet at
342%, followed by expenses on Drivers at 110%, followed by expenses on Security at 95%.
17
Figure 10: Percentage Change in Administration Expenses for November and December
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
TRANSPORT EXPENSES
The most common means of transport used to arrive at campaign events/rallies in November
and December was buses (28.0%), followed by cars (17.8%), Boda-bodas (16.1%), coasters
(11.1%) and Van/Taxi/Matatu (10.7%), Pick-ups (3.4%). Helicopters were the least means of
transportation (1.8%)
TOTAL % USE
28.0
17.8
11.1
10.7
16.1
6.5
3.4
18
Helicopter
Other Transport Means
TOTAL
1.8
4.7
100.0
+174
+267
+150
Figure 11: Use of Means of Transport Used to Arrive at Rally/Event (November & Dec)
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
30.0
PERCENTAGE
19
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
%
Expenses
44.2
30.8
10.6
4.0
3.6
1.9
% CHANGE
(Nov-Dec)
828
801
258
-20
163
57
Soda
Tents
Security
Water
Alcohol
Chairs
Venue
Ambulance
TOTAL MINIMUMS
52,551,300
106,424,000
51,696,000
124,335,000
24,934,000
75,624,000
39,867,000
22,661,000
10,276,114,300
0.5
1.0
0.5
1.2
0.2
0.7
0.4
0.2
100.0
152
116
189
338
121
155
155
447
471
E
X
P
E
N
S
E
S
Ambulance
Venue
Chairs
Alcohol
Water
Security
Tents
Soda
Musicians/Entertainment
Food
Public Address
Transport refunds to Event Attendees
Cash to Voters & Agents
Donation by candidate
0
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
PERCENTAGE
by Cash to Voters & Agents at 801%, Ambulances at 447% and Water at 338%. The least
increments were in Musicians/Entertainment at 57%, Tents (116%) and Alcohol (121%).
Chairs
Alcohol
Water
Security
Tents
Soda
Musicians/Entertainment
Food
Public Address
Transport refunds to Event Attendees
Cash to Voters & Agents
Donation by candidate
0
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
PERCENTAGE INCREASE
NOVEMBER
2,103,984,000
240,000,000
125,441,400
DECEMBER
9,182,020,000
1,981,955,000
512,931,500
22
PERCETAGE
73.61
14.49
4.16
CHANGE
336
726
309
Caps
Badges
Posters
Others
Billboards
Banners
Bandanas
Branded Kitenges
Wrist Bands
TOTAL MINIMUM
108,070,000
31,000,000
26,047,000
12,768,000
6,600,000
6,090,000
5,250,000
3,000,000
525,000
2,668,775,400
698,938,000
25,110,000
92,787,500
69,175,000
15,300,000
9,095,000
34,877,000
40,562,500
965,000
12,663,716,500
5.26
0.37
0.78
0.53
0.14
0.10
0.26
0.28
0.01
100.00
547
-19
256
442
132
49
564
1252
84
375
10,000,000,000
8,000,000,000
6,000,000,000
4,000,000,000
2,000,000,000
-
NOVEMBER
CAMPAIGN MATERIALS
DECEMBER
then Bandanas at 564%. The least increase was in Banners at 49%, Wrist Bands at 84% and
Billboards at 132%.
C
A
M
P
A
I
G
N
M
A
T
E
R
I
A
L
S
Branded Kitenges
Banners
Others
Badges
Fliers
T-Shirts
0
20
40
60
80
PERCENTAGE
November
55,340,000
39,962,000
32,370,000
29,237,000
4,707,000
24
December
271,819,000
141,172,000
96,743,000
118,477,000
15,002,000
% of Total
40
22
16
18
2
% Change
391
253
199
305
219
SMS Blasts
Robbo calls
TOTAL MINIMUMS
3,635,000
1,250,000
166,501,000
7,140,000
3,250,000
653,603,000
1
1
100
96
160
293
Figure 5: Electronic and Print Media Expenses for November & December
1%
1%
18%
Talk Shows
40%
Radio Adverts/Jingles
Print media
Facilitation for Journalists
DJ Mentions
16%
SMS Blasts
Robbo calls
22%
25
250000000
200000000
150000000
100000000
December
50000000
0
November
December
26
Figure 19: % Change in Electronic and Print Media Expenses for November & December
PERCENTAGE CHANGE
500
400
300
200
100
0
Different materials were handed out to voters by campaign agents of political candidates during
campaigns in the months of November and December. These included Hoes (21.1%), Food
(21.1%), Sugar (20.0%), Sauce Pans (15.7%), Seeds (8.6%), Salt (8.3%) and others (5.2%).
Table 12: Handout Materials Expenses in November & December
Material Items
Hoes
Food
Sugar
Sauce pans
NOVEMBER
14,238,000
14,045,000
13,665,400
12,015,000
Handout Materials
DECEMBER
TOTAL
35,238,000
49,476,000
35,637,000
49,682,000
33,405,400
47,070,800
24,865,000
36,880,000
27
PERCENT
21.1
21.1
20.0
15.7
% CHANGE
147
154
144
107
Salt
Seeds
Others
TOTAL
4,308,400
1,600,000
4,580,000
64,451,800
15,084,000
18,702,000
7,600,000
170,531,400
19,392,400
20,302,000
12,180,000
234,983,200
8.3
8.6
5.2
100.0
250
1069
66
165
50,000,000
40,000,000
30,000,000
DECEMBER
20,000,000
NOVEMBER
10,000,000
Hoes
Food
Sugar
Saurce
pans
Salt
Seeds
Others
28
Caption: Boxes of Mukwano soap source pans and other items awaiting distribution to supporters of
incumbent Katikamu North MP Abraham Byandaala in Luweero district.
29
Caption: Plastic chairs and NASECO maize seeds donated by incumbent Member of Parliament
for Bukoto Central in Masaka District and incumbent Vice President Edward Kiwanuka Sekandi.
Caption: Mama Kit donated by incumbent Member of Parliament for Jinja Municipality East Constituency
30
247
Hoes
254
Food
244
1169
Sugar
Saurce pans
Salt
207
Seeds
Others
350
31
IGANGA
JINJA
KABALE
KANUNGU
KAMPALA
KATAKWI
LUWEERO
MASAKA
MOROTO
MWOYA
LIRA
Parish/Village
Western Ward B, Akere
Atik Owang
Nicu
Bushenyi Town
Katungu
Nyagabo
Lunju
Nyamundeija
Nsale/Nawansega
Bukoyo, Busu Village
Butamila/Buyengo
Nyakabungo
Kabale Municipality
Rugyeyo
Kambuga
Kawempe 2
Nakivubo
Alogook,Wera
Agodingod,Okeriso
Lusanja/Bwaliba
Date
9/24/2015
10/9/2015
10/21/2015
11/20/2015
10/27/2015
10/23/2015
10/12/2015
10/25/2015
11/26/2015
10/8/2015
10/23/2015
10/25/2015
10/4/2015
10/22/2015
10/21/2015
10/25/2015
10/24/2015
9/23/2015
9/15/2015
11/24/2015
Event
Consultative Meeting
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Consultative Meeting
Campaign Meeting
Campaign Meeting
Campaign Meeting
Campaign Meeting
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Meeting
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Meeting
Party
UPC
UPC
NRM
Go Forward
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
FDC
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
FDC
NRM
NRM
NRM
Handout/Donation
Cash
Cash
Cash
Food
Movit Products
Boxes of Soap
Dozens of Plates
Jericans of Kwete
Hoes & Cash
Borehole maintenance
Iron Sheets
Salt Sachets
Bars of Soap
Cash
Cash
Sugar
Loaves of Bread
Pipes & Sockets
Plates
Tarpaulins
Total Estimate
1,200,000
1,150,000
100,000
3,004,000
6,290,000
380000
250000
30000
12,500,000
200,000
1,500,000
167,500
603,000
200,000
900,000
64,000
51,000
132,000
30,000
105000
Bwaliba/Lusanja
Kirumba, Kirumba
Kyabakuza, Kyabakuza B
Mogoth, Kisop & Atedeoi
Acherer, Arengekeju
Alero/Panyabono
Ireda West, Ireda Shamba
11/24/2015
10/22/2015
10/22/2015
10/23/2015
10/20/2015
9/22/2015
9/19/2015
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Meeting
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Meeting
Campaign Rally
NRM
NRM
DP
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
320,000
210,000
1,100,000
1,000,000
65,000
450,000
100,000
32
Candidates were observed donating and fundraising on different occasions in November and
December. Churches were the main recipients of the donations (66%), followed by schools at 8%.
Other donations or fundraisings occurred in women groups (4%), mosques (3%) and youth groups
(2%). Other donations accounted for 17% of the expenses on Donations, Fundraising/Vote
Buying.
Table 14: Donations & Fundraising/Vote Buying for November-December
Donations & Fundraising / Vote Buying
November
December
Total
148,420,000
297,110,000
445,530,000
15,490,000
39,640,000
55,130,000
8,740,000
14,822,500
23,562,500
6,100,000
14,600,000
20,700,000
3,632,000
8,790,000
12,422,000
54,350,800
60,924,000
115,274,800
236,732,800
435,886,500
672,619,300
Item
Churches
Schools
Women Groups
Mosques
Youth Groups
Others
TOTAL
PERCENT
66
8
4
3
2
17
100
% CHANGE
100
156
70
139
142
12
84
300,000,000
250,000,000
200,000,000
150,000,000
100,000,000
50,000,000
Churches
November
Schools
Women
Groups
Mosques
GROUP DONATED TO
December
33
Youth
Groups
Others
Parish/Village
Awiri, Awiri
Ayumi London
ARUA
Kenya, Club Village
Okollo Trading Centre
BUSHENYI Ryeishe, Kitabi
Kibaare
HOIMA
Kidoma, Nyabunyira
Kyamukenda
IGANGA
Bulowoza
Buwabe
JINJA
Mafumbira/Wairaka
Nabitambala
KABALE
Central Ward
Rutengye, Kazooha
KABAROLE Bazaar, Public Library
KANUNGU Bugongi
Katete
KATAKWI Northern Ward,Katanga
Ongongoja, Akwamor
LUWEERO Wobulenzi
Kasana Kisaawe
MASAKA
Kyabakuza A
Kamuzinda, Bukunda
Kimanya, Kigamba
NWOYA
Date
9/7/2015
9/23/2015
12/11/2015
12/15/2015
12/14/2015
10/22/2015
10/26/2015
10/10/2015
9/20/2015
9/16/2015
9/22/2015
9/24/2015
10/25/2015
10/24/2015
10/2/2015
10/21/2015
10/20/2015
9/20/2015
10/10/2015
11/23/2015
11/9/2015
9/20/2015
11/1/2015
10/23/2015
Organization
Church
St. Peters Catholic Church
Fundraising
Appreciation of Supporters
Kitabi Women Group
Bwooma Women Group
Tugende Omumaiso
Kitana Catholic Church
Kasolo Women Group
Community
Pregnant Women
Farmers
All Saints Church
Kashambya Parents P. S
Njara Church Of Uganda
Namunye Mosque
Kirima Community S S
St Steven Catholic Church
Akwamor Village
Kwagalana Women Group
Healthy Centre 5
Kyabakuza Catholic Parish
Teachers Day
St Lucia
34
Party
UPC
NRM
Go Forward
Independent
Independent
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
FDC
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
Independent
NRM
DP
DP
NRM
NRM
Donation
Cement
Cement
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Mama Kits
Maize Seeds
Cash
Cash
Cash
Cash
Bursaries
Cash
Iron Sheets
Iron Sheets
Cash
Cash
Beddings
Desks
Ambulance, Basins
& Boreholes
Total Estimate
2,250,000
40 Bags
1,000,000
300,000
100,000
1,500,000
400,000
300,000
300,000
1,000,000
100 Kits
14,000,000
100,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
10,000,000
3,640,000
2,000,000
2,500,000
1,000,000
880,000
2,000,000
102,200,000
Caption:
These are some of
the photographs
depicting voter
tourism as
observed by
ACFIM Research
Assistants in Jinja
(above) and Arua
(below) during
the months of
November and
December 2015.
35
Caption: Candidate Yoweri Museveni has 12 yellow buses on campaign trail. ACFIM observers have
reported that these buses have been used to transport voters to campaign events of the NRM
presidential candidate a clear example of voter tourism. Voter tourism is prevalent.
36
Caption: Food being prepared at a campaign event in Bukalasa for supporters of independent
candidate Patricia Magara one of the contestants in the race for Katikamu South Member of
Parliament Luweero District.
Voter Bribery
Reports submitted by ACFIM Research Assistants/Observers show that voter bribery remained
prevalent in all 16 districts with all candidates across political parties, political groups and
independents being suspects of complicity. The Presidential Elections Act (as amended) 2005
[section 64] and Parliamentary Elections Act (as amended) 2005 [section 68] , define voter bribery as
an act where political candidates offer money or gifts to another person to either directly or indirectly
37
influence someone to vote or not to vote in a particular way. Based on this premise ACFIM members
argue that offering donations in cash or kind, handout materials, cash, voter tourism or generosity
that manifests in what ACFIM calls voter hospitality are all intended to influence voters to vote for
the particular candidates that have provided the inducements. This should be understood as forms
of voter bribery and must be condemned without qualification. Relevant government institutions
and should investigate and sanction political candidates and their agents that engage in these
practices.
Section 27 of the Presidential Elections Act (as amended) 2005 makes it illegal for any candidate to
use government resources for the purpose of campaigning for election. ACFIM observers reported
mainly incidents of misuse of government vehicles to transport voters to campaign rallies/events. On
the 9th of November 2015 a number of government vehicles were used on candidate Musevenis rally
held at Kasana Play Ground. Some of the vehicle registration plates observed in action at the rally
include: UG2183C, UG 0178H, UG1427W, UG 0187D, UG 2688D, UG 2183C, UG 2043C, UG 2405C.
UG 1832S, UG1768C. Observers in Katikamu report that on the same day government vehicle number
UG 2708R was used to transport supporters to Kasana playground.
Caption: Office of the President van was observed being used to ferry people to attend the NRM
flag bearers rally in Jinja district. This is in breach of the legal provisions against use of government
resources for campaigns.
38
Similarly on December 3rd 2015 dependent candidate for Katikamu South Member of Parliament
Patricia Magara was observed using a bus with government number plates to ferry campaign
attendees from different sub counties to her nomination rally in Bulakasa.
Caption: Bus used by independent candidate Katikamu South, Luweero District, Patricia Magara to
transport attendees to her first rally at Bukalasa after being successfully nominated in Luweero.
ACFIM observers report that the bus had been picking campaign event attendees from Wobulenzi,
Bombo, Nyimbwa and other villages to Bukalasa all day. Patricia is a daughter to the late bush war
veteran Sam Magara. Here the bus was pictured at the venue of her nomination rally at Bukalasa.
This is blatant misuse of government resources for campaigns a violation of section 27 (1) of the
Presidential Elections Act 2005.
39
Parish/Village
Kashasha, Ndeego
Nyaruhanga, Ntaranga
KATAKWI Omodoi,Atirir
LUWEERO Luweero TC/Kasana
Zirobwe
Bukalasa
MASAKA Kyantale, Kyanamukaka
Kyantale, Kyanamukaka
Kamuzinda,Bulegeya
IGANGA
Bulubandi Central 'B'
KATAKWI Omodoi, Atirir
LIRA
Omot
Date
10/17/2015
10/14/2015
10/19/2015
11/9/2015
12/3/2015
12/3/2015
9/14/2015
9/14/2015
10/22/2015
12/3/2015
10/19/2015
11/3/2015
40
Party
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
Independent
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
NRM
Event
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Consultative Meeting
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Consultative Meeting
Consultative Meeting
Campaign Meeting
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Campaign Rally
Caption: The campaign trail of candidate Kizza Besigye has been characterized with images like
this where citizens donate money towards his campaign expenses. ACFIM observers in Bushenyi
District reported that on Sunday the 20th of December 2015, candidate Kizza Besigye (pictured
above) attended mass at St Kagwa Parish church and later a service at All Saints Church where
Christians in both churches made total cash contributions of UGX 1.2million for FDC presidential
candidate.
41
RECOMMENDATIONS
1. Relevant government institutions namely the Electoral Commission, the Police and
Inspectorate of Government should consider investigating further the breaches in
electoral laws on voter bribery and misuse of government resources for campaigns that
have been exposed in this report. Once brought to the attention the office of the Director
Public Prosecutions, prosecutors must take the cases seriously and bring them to court
expeditiously.
2. Government through the ministry of justice and constitutional affairs should consider
amending legal provisions on voter bribery in the Presidential Elections Act 2005 and
Parliamentary Elections Act 2005 to strengthen punishments against voter bribery. In
addition voter bribery should be redefined to include all actions that are aimed at
inducing or influencing citizens to vote for particular candidates as revealed in this report.
Practices like donations, handout materials, cash handouts, voter-tourism and voterhospitality among others are clearly given to induce/bribe voters. These should be
qualified as acts of voter bribery. Candidates convicted of voter bribery should be banned
from contesting any elections for at least five years. Uganda needs a specific law to
regulate campaign financing.
3. Ugandans from all walks of life including religious leaders, cultural leaders, the academia,
civil society organisations, faith based organisations and the media among others should
take collective action to curb commercialization of politics. Specifically we need to change
people perceptions on vote buying/selling and encourage a culture where citizens stop
demanding for inducements from political candidates. The practice of ordinary citizens
making donations towards political candidates during campaigns should be strongly
encouraged.
42
APPENDIX I
Table 17: NRM Party Minimum Expenses by November 2015
OBSERVABLE
MINIMUM COST
EXPENSE
1
15,000,000,000
2nd Delegates Conference to elect Party Flag Bearer October 30-November 2nd
20,000,000,000
6,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
30,000,000,000
Outdoor Advertising
19,000,000,000
a) Bill Boards
1,274,100,000
b) Posters
1,706,400,000
c) Banners
214,550,000
Media Advertising
a) Newspapers
132,370,000
b) Radio
439,962,000
c) Television
829,200,000
Yellow T-Shirts
15,806,630,000
10
Other Expenses
Allowances for Journalists on Campaign Trail
42,000,000
7,000,000
140,000,000
5,000,000
28,800,000
7,350,000
Tents
2,400,000
Plastic Chairs
4,000,000
6,000,000
20,000,000
1,200,000
12,000,000
43
24,960,000
4,000,000,000
24,000,000
72,000,000
Allowance for 500 SFC men and women 20,000 per day for 30 days
Facilitation for at least 40 Journalists on 6 regional press conferences in Lango, W.Nile,
Gulu, Karamoja, Kapchorwa and Soroti: 500,000/= per person
TOTAL MINIMUM
300,000,000
120,000,000
125,219,922,000
44
APPENDIX II
Table 18: SUMMARY of NRM Party Minimum Expenses by November 2015
OBSERVABLE
MINIMUM COST
EXPENSE
Party Primary Elections
2nd Delegates Conference to elect Party Flag Bearer October 30-November
2nd
Delegates Conference that confirmed Pres. Sole candidates and amending
the constitution to make SC position appointive
30,000,000,000
Yellow T-Shirts
15,806,630,000
15,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
20,000,000,000
19,000,000,000
6,000,000,000
4,000,000,000
Outdoor Advertising
3,195,050,000
Media Advertising
1,401,532,000
Other Expenses
816,710,000
TOTAL MINIMUM
125,219,922,000
45
MAJOR EXPENSES
10,000,000,000
20,000,000,000
30,000,000,000
46
APPENDIX III
Table 19: FDC Party Minimum Expenses by November 2015
MINIMUM TOTAL
EXPENDITURE
EXPENSE
1 Party Delegates Conference at UMA
2
200,000,000
210,000,000
3 Contribution to TDA
50,000,000
30,000,000
5 Posters
120,000,000
379,240,000
164,245,000
21,000,000
20,900,000
10,000,000
10
801,000,000
290,480,000
TOTAL
1,293,965,000
47
APPENDIX IV
Table 20: Amama Mbabazi Minimum Expenses in WestNile
48