Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
The law further provided that the voters of the city would be classified as
belonging to either the 1st or the 2nd district, depending on their place of
residence.
o The constituents of each district would elect a Representative and 8 members of
the Sangguniang Panglungsod.
Mar. 13, 2007 COMELEC promulgated en banc Resolution No. 7837 implementing RA
9371.
Mar. 27, 2007 Rogelio BAGABUYO filed the present petition against the COMELEC,
on the ground that RA 9371 cannot be implemented without the conduct of a plebiscite,
which he says is indispensable for the division or conversion of a LGU.
o He asked that the COMELEC be stopped from implementing RA 9371 and
Resolution No. 7837 and for Cagayan de Oro to be reverted to a single district.
Apr. 10, 2008 Bagabuyo amended his petition to implead the Executive Secretary, the
Budget and Management Secretary, the Chair of the Commission on Audit, the Mayor
and Members of the Sangguniang Panglungsod of Cagayan de Oro, and the Cagayan
de Oro Board of Canvassers.
May 14, 2007 The National and Local Elections pushed through in accordance with RA
9371 and Resolution No. 7837, the SC not having issued a TRO.
o
ISSUES (HELD)
1) W/N Bagabuyo violated the hierarchy of courts doctrine when he filed the petition directly with
the SC (NO)
2) Does RA 9371 involve the division or conversion of a LGU, or does it only provide for
legislative reapportionment? (LEGISLATIVE REAPPORTIONMENT)
3) W/N RA 9371 violates the equality of representation doctrine (NO)
RATIO
1) CASE AT BAR IS AN EXCEPTION TO THE HIERARCHY OF COURTS DOCTRINE
The hierarchy of courts doctrine serves to declog court dockets and focus the SCs time
on matters within its exclusive jurisdiction.
Therefore, when SC has concurrent jurisdiction with a lower court over a proceeding,
recourse must first be made to the lower court; unless there are special and important
reasons for the direct invocation of the SCs jurisdiction, clearly and especially set out in
the petition.
Among these special and important circumstances include petitions for certiorari,
prohibition, and mandamus against lawmakers when the validity of their enactments is
assailed.
o CASE AT BAR: Bagabuyos petition assails a legislative enactment. The nature
of the issues raised also suffices as reason for considering it an exception to the
rule.
o Additionally, the petition also assails a resolution of the COMELEC en banc,
which requires a Rule 65 petition before the SC per ROC 64.
2) RA 9371 IS A LEGISLATIVE APPORTIONMENT MEASURE
CONSTITUTIONAL CONCEPTS DISTINGUISHED
o Bagabuyo: The implementation of RA 9371 requires a plebiscite since it involves
the division of an LGU.
o OSG: RA 9371 merely increases the representation of Cagayan de Oro in the
House of Representatives pursuant to Art. VI, 5 of the 1987 Constitution. It
o
o
RA 9371 simply creates a new legislative district out of the former lone district for
purposes of representation in the House of Representatives. No plebiscite is
therefore necessary.
The creation of additional Sangguniang Panglungsod seats by virtue of
COMELEC Resolution No. 7837 as a consequence of the creation of the two
new districts is not new but is based on an earlier law - RA 6636 which laid
down the apportionment of seats in the Sangguniang Panglungsod of every city.
The resolution simply follows the provisions of said law.
Furthermore, the resolution does not divide the LGU or create a new one. It
merely enhances voter representation by giving greater weight to each vote, both
in Congress and in the Sangguniang Panglungsod. From 12 councilors and one
representative for 500,000 people, CdO now has 2 House representatives, one
for each group of 250,000 people, and 8 councilors for each same group.