Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
CHAPTER-I
INTROCUCTION
1.1 GENERAL
Shares, bonds and real estate are the main asset types available in
the capital market. Real estate is usually negatively correlated to shares,
what makes it attractive for the purpose of risk diversification. On the
other hand, bonds and real estate goes along in their volatility. One
difference between these assets is that property is unique and its data on
price transactions is not computed on a daily basis; on the contrary, it is
very difficult to gather data on prices of similar properties. Shares and
bonds have in this respect identical characteristics and it is easy for
investors to assess their performance at high accuracy levels.
In the real estate market the situation is not as simple as that.
Investors are never sure about the value of a certain property if they were
about to sell or rent it. Property valuation methods are needed for
estimating the most probable value of a property on the market. The
accuracy of valuations is tested when an estimated value equals or
approximates the purchase price, which, in this case, represents the
investment cost.
The need for standardizing and clarifying the meaning and use of
this concept has risen at a point where investors, managers and
supervising authorities in the real estate market look for more reliable
information about the situation in the market.
Theories on macroeconomics, finance and valuation cannot be
viewed separately when examining the valuation concept and its
determinants. As the valuation can be used as a benchmark to
performance, or as determinants of property value or even as an
indicator
of
bubbles
in
the
property
market,
macroeconomic
determinants, and financial theories for the general financial market and
for the specific property market cannot be overlooked.
1.2 UNDRESSING THE OVERALL CONCEPT
Property values keep changing over time. The value of a real estate
is attached to the interest behind the objective of its valuation. The
assessment of a property is based, however, on four basic conditions:
need, limited supply, right of disposal and transferable assets in the
market. Once values change, yields are prone to follow its movements,
but in opposite direction. To better understand its relation, it is
important to see how yields relate to property values.
2. Income-related value
Income value is related to an investors expectancies regarding
future inflows of capital into his/her investment and it should, thus, be
regarded separately for each investment (individual nature).
Sometimes, the income value of the subject property is said to have
a built-in long-run intrinsic value, which implies stable returns over
time. It is also said that a market-adapted income value exists, which
assumes it possesses parameters that reflect the market. In other words,
it is regarded as a form of market value, but estimated out of a return
calculation model.
3. Cost-related value
The cost value is calculated in special circumstances, where:
Market is inexistent for special properties
In an insurance context
In countries where the property market is not functional
Even if the cost value concept is of little extent applied in the
Indian market, one should not ignore its existence in certain contexts. It
is important to notice that a number of other value concepts exist in the
Buying real estate directly results in profits (or losses) through two
avenues: revenue from rent and appreciation of the real estate's value.
Rental money comes from land already developed into residential or
commercial real estate. Appreciation can come from either developing
raw land or from the appreciation of the area around the land you own,
for instance the appreciation of real estate in some American cities due to
gentrification in the early 21st century.
1.5 PROPERTY
It means any interest in property; movable or immovable.
Immovable property means any land, building or part of a building
together with machinery, plant and other permanent fixtures.
1.6 LAND APPURTENANT TO BUILDING
Where there are building regulations, the land allowed under such
regulations for the enjoyment of the existing building shall be the
appurtenant land.
from
any
kind
of
encumbrance
as
to
the
transfer
of
title/occupancy/use.
1.8 LEASE HOLD LAND
A parcel of land is said to be lease-hold when the right of
enjoyment and possession is vested in a person other than the owner for
a definite period of time in consideration for a fixed sum of rent known as
lease (ground) rent. The owner of the land is known "Lessor" and the
person holding the lease title is known as "Lessee". Apart from the period
of lease and the rate of lease rent, the lease agreement may stipulate
other restrictive covenants such as use of land, sharing of unearned
profit, conversion of title into free hold, renewal of lease, resumption of
lease and right to sale / transfer of land. Long term leases having term of
99 years and above are considered leases in perpetuity.
construction,
the
quality
of
construction
materials,
climatic
10
11
12
valuation date. The terms "Market Value" and "Fair Market Value" are
synonyms except the word "Fair" introduces an element of a hypothetical
market. The expression "if sold" does not contemplate actual sales or
actual state of market. The expression "Open Market" does not
contemplate a purely hypothetical market exempt from restriction
imposed by law. The fair market value excludes sentimental value
advertisement, brokerage, stamp-duty, commission etc. for affecting the
sale transaction.
1.18 POTENTIAL VALUE
This is the inherent value in the property which is realised when
the property is developed in its most advantageous manner. For example,
land on outskirts of a town possesses building potential. Similarly, an
under-developed property possesses value which can be realised by fully
developing the property.
1.19 GUIDELINE VALUE
The value adopted for stamp duty is based on the land / building
rates fixed by the local authorities for the purpose of stamp duty charges.
1.20 SALVAGE VALUE
13
14
15
figures shown therein have to be followed for determining the cost. If the
assessee has produced less vouchers for some of the materials, the same
is estimated and added at the market rates. Similarly, the quantum of
labour payment is assessed and if the assessee has maintained proper
account, the total cost is worked out on the basis of detailed produced by
him. We rarely come across such cases where the assessee submits
complete technical accounting along with justification statements of
materials and labour. Such cases appear where the assessee is a
professional builder or has taken huge loans and payments made
through financial institutions. In such instances, the VOs should be
more vigilant in pointing out the items and specifications which may
have got escaped from the assessee's submission of facts. Such items can
be valued and added separately. However this method yields to a near to
perfect valuation, if the accounts are correctly maintained.
16
specification of the building (ii) the cost of materials and labour. The first
one is covered by the plinth area rate and the second one cost index.
I.
CPWD has approved Cost Indices for many years. These places should be
within hundred kilometer radius (preferably, within fifty kilometer) of the
concerned place.
II.
Work out the Cost Indices of required time for each place
III.
For each time average out the Cost Indices of all places nearest to
the place under consideration and adopt this figure as Cost Index of the
place that time.
IV.
As further check work out the current Cost Index of the place after
17
trial and error method. For past Cost Indices, take average of Cost
Indices of those places only whose average current Cost Indices
correspond nearest to current Cost Index of place.
V.
a)
Work out the current Cost Index of the place under consideration
based on prevailing market rates of materials and labour and that of the
other nearest places based on CPWD approved Cost Indices of those
places. Work out Cost Index differential factor of the place under
consideration with reference to the nearest places.
b)
18
c)
uniformity may be adopted for working out the Weighted Cost Index:1.22.3 LAND AND BUILDING METHOD
As the name indicates, in this method the value of land is added to
the value of structure to arrive at the fair market value of the property.
The method is generally adopted in the following situations:(a) In the case of self occupied property.
(b) In the case of property partly self occupied (i.e. more than 60%) and
balance tenanted.
(c) In the case where it is not possible to obtain fair and maintainable
rent.
(d) In case where there is no direct evidence of rent such as schools and
hospitals etc.
(e) In the case where the property is not fully developed, or the return
from the property is not commercial.
19
20
CHAPTER - II
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
2.1 GENERAL
Review of related literature is an essential part of research work. It
enables the investigator to know about the related studies and their
conclusion. This gives an idea for the present investigator to do her work.
Sometimes, even the research problem is selected from the studies
reviewed. The review helps the investigator to acquire a thorough
knowledge about the present problem and helps in the development of
research procedures.
Therefore, the present investigation went through the earlier
studies made in her field of research and they are presented in the
succeeding paragraphs.
21
22
technology S curve starts below the one of its precursor. The financial
criteria may disapprove the investment of the technology based on a
small discernible market. However, the new products may accumulate its
popularity with an accelerating rate. Therefore, sticking to NPV which
does not tell the potential of a new technology may obstruct firms
technology competitiveness development.
Like Reichert et al (1989) employed survey methods to assess
changes in property values before and after a Los Angeles Superfund
hazardous
waste
site
was
closed.
Notably,
the
survey
results
23
24
number
of
new
products
introduced
and
the
performance
25
26
NPV valuation rejected the R&D project but Real Options approved it.
Besides suggesting the value of flexibility, his study also proposed Real
Option models should be adopted in public policy and R&D investment
management. Li and Johnson (2002) build Real Option calculation based
on technology switching costs and the nature of competition.
2.3 SUMMARY
This chapter explains the details of review of literature were
explained. The next chapter furnishes with the review of literature are
explained.
27
CHAPTER - III
RULES FOR FIXING CAPITAL VALUE
3.1 INTRODUCTION
No.AC/NTC/1310/2011-12 dated 20.03.2012. In exercise of the
powers conferred by clause of sub section (1B) of section 154 of the
Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act (Act No.Bom. III of 1888), and of all
other powers enabling him in this behalf, the Commissioner, after having
obtained the approval of the Standing Committee, as required under the
said sub-section (1B), hereby makes the following rules to provide for the
factors and categories of users of buildings or lands and the weightage by
multiplication to be assigned to various such factors and categories for
the purpose of fixing the capital value of building and lands in Brihan
Mumbai, namely:1.
28
2. Definitions In these rules, unless the context otherwise requires:(a) Act means the Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act (Bom. III of
1888);
(b) flat means a separate part or portion of a building used or intended
to be used for residence, or office, or show room, or shop, or go down,
or for carrying on any industry, or business, or business, or profession,
or vocation;
(c) Hoarding includes boards used to display advertisements, erected on
poles, on the around or on a building;
(d) land appurtenant to a building means open spaces on all sides of a
building required to kept open in accordance with the relevant provisions
of the development control regulations for Greater Bombay, 1991 or any
such regulations, for the time being in force; 1
(e) Luxurious RCC building includes a RCC building having a
swimming pool, whether in use or not, and also any one or more of the
following amenities or facilities, namely;i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
Gymnasium
Club house
Jogging track
Health club
29
v.
vi.
vii.
with in a building
Open land includes land not built upon or land being built upon,
viii.
ix.
the Act;
Relative rate of base value means the rate of open land, or rate of
land
plus
residential
building,
office,
shop,
commercial
or
x.
xi.
xii.
Reckoner;
Schedule means a schedule to these rules;
Section means a section of the Act;
Star hotel means hotel classified as a star hotel with a specific
number of starts assigned there to by the Ministry of Tourism,
xiii.
Government of India;
Storage tank includes a tank, whether underground or on any
floor of a building, used for the storage of commodities, except the
xiv.
such
tower,
transmission
tower,
cellular
antenna,
xv.
30
xvi.
xvii.
xviii.
xix.
31
xx.
weightage
by
xxi.
schedule B.
The weightage by multiplication to be assigned to a building on
account of the age there of : - The weightage by multiplication to be
assigned to a building on account of age factor, for the building as
shown
in
column
of
schedule
and
the
weightage
by
xxii.
32
xxiii.
Area of hoarding or tower for the purpose of fixing capital value: Area of hoarding or tower for the purpose of fixing capital value
there of shall mean, in the case of a hoarding the area of the
square of the extremities of the poles on which the hoarding is
erected plus the area of the hoarding and in the case of a tower the
area covered by the extremities of the foundation of the tower. Built
up area of a flat or a building;
The total built-up area of a flat shall be reckoned by including the area
33
(xiii) watchman cabin (3) The built up area of any of the following items
shall not be reckoned while computing the built up area of a building or
part there of namely:- (i) lift room above ropmost storey, (ii) lift well, (iii)
stair case and passage there to including staircase room, (iv) chimney
and elevated tank, (v) meter room, (vi) pump room, (vii) underground and
overhead water tank, (viii) septic tank, (ix) flower bed and (x) loft in
residential flat.
4. Where only the carpet area of a flat or building is available on the
record of the Corporation and the total built up area there of computed
in the manner as aforesaid in sub rule (1), or as the case may be sub
rule (2) is not available on such record then the total built up area of the
flat or as the case may be of a building shall be arrived at in the following
manner namely: Built up area = 1.2 x carpet area as available on the record of the
Corporation + the built up area of the items specified in sub rule (1) or as
the case may be sub rule (2), unless already reckoned in such carpet
area.
11. fixation of capital value of a flat or building or part thereof
(1) while fixing the capital value of a flat the capital value of any one or
34
more of the relevant items specified in sub rule (1) of rule 10, as fixed in
accordance with the provisions of rules 14, 15, or sub rule (1) of rule 16,
as the case may be shall be added to the capital value of the flat.
(2) While fixing the capital value of a building or part there of the capital
value of any of the one or more of the relevant items specified in sub rule
(2) of rule 10 as fixed in accordance with the provisions of sub rule (2) or,
as the case may be, (3) of rule 416, shall be added to the capital value of
the building or part thereof.
12. Fixation of capital value of a building where there are tenants:The capital value of a building or part thereof which is occupied by
a tenant shall be fixed at 75% of the capital value of such building or
part thereof; fixed in accordance with the provisions of sub rule (1) or, as
the case may be sub-rule (2) of rule 11.Explanation for the removal of
doubts it is hereby declared that the provisions of this rule shall not
apply to a building or part thereof it,
1.
2.
landlord
35
36
37
38
contained in sub rules (1) and (2) where a cessed building is or being
demolished or has collapsed the land beneath the building or portion of
the building which is demolished or collapsed shall be deemed to be open
land and the capital value thereof shall be fixed as open land and
assigning there to a weightage by multiplication of 0.30 of the base value
of open land.
18. The capital value of storage tank. The capital value of storage tank
shall be fixed in the following manner namely: - (1) storage tank above
the ground level.
(a) land at the rate of open land in the Ready Reckoner and weightage
by multiplication to be assigned there to shall be 1.25,
(b) storage tank capacity of storage tank in litres multiplied by the rate
of Rs.40 per litre, with weightage by multiplication to be assigned thereto
on account of age factor as in schedule C.
(c) total capital value of a storage tank = total of items (a) and (b).
(2) storage tank below the ground level.
(a) land at the rate of open land in the Ready Reckoner and weightage by
multiplication to be assigned thereto shall be 1.25,
39
(b) storage tank capacity of storage tank in litres multiplied by the rate
of Rs.50 per litre, with weightage by multiplication to be assigned thereto
on account of age factor as in schedule C,
(c) total capital value of a storage tank = total of items (a) and (b).
19. Capital value of amenities of luxurious RCC building not to be
separately fixed again where the capital value of a luxurious RCC
building is fixed under these rules then no capital value of the amenities
specified in the definition of the expression luxurious RCC building shall
be separately fixed for the purpose of levy of property tax.
20. Valuation of open land capable of utilizing more than 1 floor space
index (F.S.I.) or transfer of development right (T.D.R.) as the Ready
Reckoner provides for the rate of base value of open land with 1 floor
space index open land which is capable of utilizing more than 1 floor
space index or any transfer of developed right shall be valued at an
increased rate in proportion to the higher floor space index or transfer of
development right proposed to be utilized and approved under the
building plan submitted to the Corporation for approval.
40
21. Capital value of open land or building or part thereof capital value of
open land or building shall be fixed under the provisions of the Act and
these rules in the following manner namely:(1) Capital value (CV) of open land Rate of base value (BV) of a open
land according to Ready Reckoner X weightage by multiplication as per
user category (UC) (part I of schedule A) X permissible or approved floor
space index (FSI) X area of land (AL). CV=BVxUCxFSIxAL (2) Capital
value (CV) of a building Relative rate of base value (BV) of a building
according to Ready Reckoner X weightage by multiplication as per user
category (UC) (Parts II, III, or as the case may be, IV of schedule A) X
weightage by multiplication as per the nature and type of building (NTB)
(schedule B) X weightage by multiplication on account of floor factors
(FF) for RCC building with lift (schedule D) X built up area (BA) CV = BV
x UC x NTB x AF x FF x BA examples:- Some examples based and worked
out on the formulae as aforesaid are shown in the Appendix.
22. Non application of Guidelines of stamp duty valuation.
Notwithstanding anything contained in the Important Guidelines of
Stamp Duty Valuation as specified in the Ready Reckoner the provisions
made in these rules shall have primacy over those guidelines and none of
41
those guidelines shall apply for fixing capital value under the Act and
these rules.
42
entry 0.10 7 land of stadium where tickets are sold for entry 1.008 land
of petrol pump/service station/LPG, CNG station/kerosene station 1.259
open air electric substation 1.25 10 open land non residential:- (a)
Commercial 1.25 (b) Industrial 1.10 11 open land residential 1.00 12
open land under reservation:- 9(a) partial impermissibility 0.10 7 land of
stadium where tickes are sold for entry 1.00 8 land of petrol
pump/service station/LPG, CNG station / kerosene station 1.25 9 open
air electric substation 1.25 10 open land non residential:Part II
User
Residential buildings
categories
of
residential
buildings
and
corresponding
43
6. Car parking
society used by its members) 1.00 9. Co-operative credit society 1.00 10.
Coaching class 1.00
12. Department
or
company
1.20
25.Mall
1.25
26.Mangal
44
conditioned) 1.20
convention hall/party hall, etc. (non air conditioned) 1.10 28. Multiplex
1.25 29.Non-banking financial institutions 1.20 30.Nursery, kids corner,
playgroup0.70 31. Nursing home 1.00 32. Office 1.00 33. Open air
theatre stage and other structure 0.30 34. Passenger terminal at airport
1.10 35. Private health club, gymnasium 1.00 34.passenger terminal at
airport 1.10 35.private health club gymnasium 1.00 47. Tires of seats
for specter in a stadium where no tickets are sold 0.06 48. Tower 1.00
49. Unstarred hotel 1.00 12 50. Weighbridge 1.00
categories
of
industrial
buildings
and
corresponding
45
46
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
more
more
more
more
more
than
than
than
than
than
30
35
40
45
50
years
years
years
years
years
up to 35
up to 40
up to 45
up to 50
0.70 14
years
years
years
years
0.82
0.79
0.76
0.73
(2) (3)
Basement used for car parking 0.70
Basement used for other than car parking 1.00
Lower ground floor 1.00
Upper ground floor 1.00
Ground floor 1.00
From 1st to 4th floor 1.00
From 5th to 10th floor 1.05
From 11th to 20th floor 1.10
From 21st to 30th floor 1.15
From 31st to 50th floor 1.20
From 51st to 75th floor 1.25
From 76th to 100th floor 1.30
Above 100th floor 1.35
47
Weightage
Relative rate of base value Rs,80,600 not applicable category
residential 1.00 nature building RCC building other Age of building 6
years 0.97 floor number 12 1.10built up area 80sq applicable.
CV=BVxUCxNTBxAFxFFxBA
=80600x1.00x1.00x0.97x1.10x80
C.V. = Rs.68,80,016
(2) RESIDENTIAL FLAT IN A BUILDING WITHOUT LIFT
Weightage
Relative rate of base value Rs.80,600 not applicable
User category Residential 1.00
Nature and type of building RCC building other than luxurious RCC
building 1.00
Age of building 6 years 0.97
Floor number 2 not applicable
CV=BVxUCxNTBxAFxFFxBA
48
=80600x1.00x1.00x0.97x80
C.V.=Rs.62,54,560
(3) OPEN LAND IN ISLAND CITY
Weightage
Rate of base value Rs.36,400 not applicable
User category Residential 1.00
Nature and Type of building not applicable not applicable
Age of building not applicable not applicable
F.S.I. Factor 1.33 1.33
Land area 80sq mtr not applicable
CV=BVXUCXFSIXLA
=36400X1.00X1.33X80
C.V.=Rs,38,72,960
(4) OPEN LAND WHERE RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PLAN WITH HIGHER
F.S.I HAS BEEN APPROVED
49
Weightage
Rate of base value Rs.36,400 not applicable
User category open land (Resi) 1.00
Nature and type of building applicable not applicable
Age of building not applicable
F.S.I. Factor 2.50
Land Area 80sq.mtr.not applicable
CV= BV X UC X FSI X LA
= 36400 X 1.00 X 2.50 X 80
C.V.=Rs.72,80,000
(5) OPEN LAND IN SUBURBAN AREA
weightage
Rate of base value Rs.33,200/- not applicable
User category residential 1.00
Nature and type of building not applicable
50
51
CHAPTER - IV
METHODOLOGY
4.1 GENERAL
In the present chapter, variables used in this study, formulation of
the objectives and hypotheses to be used in this study and also the
sample used in this study, distribution of the sample, statistical
techniques used in this study, and all other related aspects are presented
here.
4.2 METHODOLOGY:
52
4.4 SCOPE
The scope of this research will initiate and enhance the common
awareness, understanding and implementation of school building
valuation in rural areas in India. It will focus to improve school building
valuation in rural areas, and not for the valuation for the assets as a
whole. This research is the first phase in developing school building
valuation in rural areas guidelines in India that can be evolved in the
53
Descriptive analysis
Differential analysis
54
CHAPTER V
RESULT AND DISCUSSION
5.1 GENERAL
55
25
20
35
19
23
2013
Rate in lakhs
2014
20
26
33
18
22
2015
22
27
32
19
20
26
24
35
25
21
56
Year
Mean
Std. Deviation
2012
2013
2014
2015
24.40
23.80
24.00
26.20
6.39
5.93
5.43
5.26
Std. Error
Mean
2.86
2.65
2.43
2.35
t
8.542
8.970
9.881
11.131
df
4
4
4
4
Sig.
.001
.001
.001
.000
T-distribution result will reflect the difference between the two samples. Here the
answers given by both Financial years and different zone are same except. From this test
we can conclude both zone and years had the same level of awareness with respect to
cost.
Table 4.2 Significance analysis
ANOVA
Source of
Variation
Rows
SS
df
MS
456.8
114.2
Columns
18
Error
76
12
6
6.3333
33
Total
550.8
19
F
18.031
58
0.9473
68
P-value
F crit
0.00518
3.259167
0.044815
3.490295
57
58
59
5.3 SUMMARY
This chapter explains the details of result and discussion were
explained. The next chapter deals with summary of findings and
conclusions are clearly explained.
60
CHAPTER VI
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS
6.1 CONCLUSION
The findings of the present study lead to the following concluding
remarks. It is inferred that there is a significant difference in zone wise
school building rate in lakhs.
Based on the findings of this research, there are numbers of
research that can be ignited in the future. Firstly, the study on the plant
and machinery fundamental structure for practices can be conducted in
the future. The fundamental structure can be replicated from Chapter 2
of this research and be tested in the Malaysian market on their
suitability to be applied. The following list contains the most common
errors that the author has detected in the more than one thousand he
has had access to his capacity as business consult or trapped in a
speculative bubble is to not enter it to never buy what seem to be
extensions even if advised to do so by certain.
61
6.5 SUMMARY
This chapter explains the details of summary of findings and
conclusions were explained.
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
Rao.
Books for valuation of properties by Er.S.Mohan, lecturer, civil
engg.
5.
6.
dept.,
Annamalai University
and
Er.Perumal
Kabilan,
7.
8.
62
9.
APPENDIX
Zone
: Tirupathi SRO
: Thilak Road
SURVEY NO
GUIDELINE VALUE
GUIDELINE VALUE
(IN METRIC)
CLASSIFICATION
74/1
300/Sq.Ft
3230/Sq.Mt
74/2A
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
74/2B
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
74/3A1
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
74/3A2
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
74/3B
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
74/4
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
63
SURVEY NO
GUIDELINE VALUE
GUIDELINE VALUE
(IN METRIC)
CLASSIFICATION
76/1
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
76/2A
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
76/2B1
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
76/2B2
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
76/3
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
76/4
1300000/Acre
3212500/Hect.
PHOTO VIEWS OF
SCHOOL BUILDING
64
65
66