Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
171Anactrelatingtorestrictionsontheuseofelectroniccigarettes
JamesSargent,ProfessorofPediatrics,DartmouthMedicalSchool:Hesaidthatecigarettesare
completelyunregulated,theyhavenotbeenFDAapprove.SenatorCollamorepointedoutthat
ecigaretteshavetheoptionforvaryingdegreesofnicotine,unlikecigarettes.Sargentsaidthat
whenyoucomparethenumberofpeoplewhoeitherusecigarettesorecigarettes,thesmokers
aregoodatvaryingtheamountofnicotinetheytakein.Forexample,asmokercouldtakea
longerinhaleonacigaretteandtakeinmorenicotineandthesamethinggoesforecigarettes.
Hesaidtherearemanywaysthatsmokerscanregulatetheirnicotineintake.SenatorLyons
askedaboutwheretheauthorityforregulationcomesfrom,andSargentsaiditisacongressional
decision.
AdamTredwell,President,VermontVapor:Theywerethesecondcompanytodevelopvape
liquid.Theyhavebeeninbusinesssince2009.
AsfarasheknowsnobusinessinVermonthasaskedforavaporban.Hedoesntknowwhy
afterecigaretteshavebeeninVTforsolongthatthishasnowstartedbeingperceivedasa
problem.Hesaidthatmostpeoplewhouseecigarettesareusingthemtoquitsmoking.Hehada
studyreferencedinhistestimonythatshowedthat20%ofpeopleinastudywhohadno
intentionofquittingsmokingdidquitoncetheyweregivenanecigarettes.
Tredwellalsosaidthatifthisbillispasseditwillsendthemessagetoteensthatifyouban
ecigarettesthanitsendsthemessagethatsmokingisbetterthanecigarettesandtheymightas
wellsmoke.Hesaidstudiesshowthatyoutharelikelytoexperimentwithecigarettes.Buthe
saidtherewasastudyreferencedinhistestimonythatshowedaverysmallnumberofthosewho
experimentedwiththemwhobecameregularusers.
AndrewMacLean,Lobbyist,MMR:Hesaidunlikethetraditionaltobaccomarket,itisnotas
dominatedbylargecompanies.Hesaidthislegislationhastobeviewedfromtheindustrys
perspective,inregardstotaxationontheproduction.
Hesaidtheideaoftheproductoftheforadultsisawaytoregulatenicotineinalessharmful
waythansmoking.
HesaidEnglandproducedastudyfromtheCancerResearchofEnglandanditsaid39%of
peoplewhoweretryingtoquitsmokingusedecigarettes.Hesaidinthisstudyitstatedinthe
numberofpeoplewhodontsmokecigarettes,veryfewpeopleuseecigarettes.
HeshowedthesurveyfromVermontVapethattheyconducted,andithad88adultecigarette
users,andoutofthosepeopleonly3haddualuse.Heclaimsitisalargesurvey,butitseemsthe
committeedidntagree.HesaidfromR.J.Reynoldsperspectivetheysupportthetryingtokeep
themawayfromteens,buttheydonotsupportthepublicban.
SenatorCollamoresproposedamendment:line12oftheamendmentstatestheproductsbe
providedinalockedcontaineronthesalescontainerorinthecustomerareaofthestore.
RebeccaRyan,AmericanLungAssociation:Shesaidshedoesntthinkthisamendmentchanges
currentstatute.Shesaidthepointistogettheproductsoutofsightofchildren.Fromwhatshes
seenthelockedcontainersarenotverybig,andcouldeasilyfitbehindacounter.Shedoesnt
supportthisamendment.SenatorLyonswouldsupporttheproposal.
CommitteeDiscussion:Thecommitteedecidedtoincludetheamendment.SenatorCollamore
opposestheentirebill.Thereasonisthatheopposestheworkplacerestrictions.SenatorLyons
andPollinaareinsupportofthebill.SenatorPollinasaidhebelievesthatecigarettesdohelp
peoplequitsmoking,buthebelievestherestrictionsinthebillallowpeopletodosoandthatthe
publicusenormalizesthebehavior,whichtheydontwant.SenatorLyonssaidthereisno
regulationinthedevelopmentofwhatisinthevapor.Shesupportstheworkplacepieceofthe
bill.SenatorAyersuggestedthattheygoovertestimonyandvoteonthebilltomorrow.