Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
preschool
Imelda
rate of stunting
children
through
T Angeles,
ABSTRACT
hematological
Werner
J Schultink,
Paul
Matulessi,
Rainer
Gross,
Chwang
physical
on growth
and
preschool
children
both
C, whereas
anism
a control
food
were
and
(P
of iron
vitamin
Nutr
supplementation
as well
group
group.
school
<
0.01).
<
in the treatment
increase
in the control
the
on linear
growth
were larger
The positive
was
not
caused
Subjects
The
Iron supplementation,
anemia,
growth
rate,
anemia
reduced
and
decreased
problems
among
1 , 2).
Anemia
capacity
and
learning
(6).
Decreased
growth
is associated
with
achievement
(2-5).
in infancy
compared
with
rate
in
increased
are
two
children
A child
risks
protracted
peers
having
children
who
in
(WFA)
HFA
(8).
in developing
lack
is highly
countries.
Stunting
ifleft
untreated
(11,
which
has
in children
can
usually
after
of nutrients
Stunting
implies
that
lead
to a low
The
area
study
a childs
from
time,
an early
no catching
age
occurrence
ofanemia
among
J C/in Nutr
preschool
1993:58:339-42.
and
reduced
children.
Printed
growth
Aukett
and
in USA.
al
to in-
itself.
and
study
reduced
investigated
significantly
status,
improve
ofanemic
pre-
WFA.
out
that
109000
in Jakarta.
covered
and
a population
group
comprised
no stable jobs).
was
Indonesia,
at two
neighborhoods
with
density
sub-
a total
of 38000/
poor.
process
sequentially
and then as anemic.
identified
children,
aged 2The selection
criteria
were
to define
anemia
(2). All subjects
records
at the health centers,
which
were identified
contained
only
data on WFA.
From
the health
centers
list 2 16 children
were
selected
who met the anthropometrical
criteria.
All 2 16 children
to the health
their
a low
tration
center
hemoglobin
hemoglobin
was measured.
at the
request
concentration
ofhealth
could
concentration,
Finally.
center
be analyzed.
serum
84 children
met
femtin
staff
so
For those
concen-
the hematological
criteria.
The parents
of 80 children
gave written
consent
for
their childrens
participation
in the study.
Stool samples
of the
subjects
were examined
for the presence
of parasitic
infections
(ascariasis
and trichuriasis).
Children
with parasites
received
antreatment
(14) before
starting
iron
are often
(3)
1993 American
From
of
Indonesia,
the SEAMEO-TROPMED
Jakarta,
Indonesia
Center
Jakarta
and
Gesellschaft
Zusammenarbeit,
Eschborn,
Germany.
2 Address
reprint requests to WJ Schultink,
3852, 10038 Jakarta.
Indonesia.
Received
November
20. 1992.
Accepted
for publication
March 18, 1993.
be possible
rate
et
of iron
present
would
this
morbidity,
of anemia
the
mech-
supplementation,
genetic
onward,
up may
the
In theory,
as follows:
WFA Z score between
-2 and -3. hemoglobin
concentration
between
80 and 1 10 g/L, and serum
ferritin
< 12 g/
L. The upper
limits
of the hematological
measures
are usual
tihelminthic
communities
develops
some
will
in many
carried
of
the
with
reduced
effect
as hematological
a low
offices
study
have
that
12).
associated
was
health
km2. The
(25-30%
came
iron
developing
risk and
performance
prevalent
(10).
.4,ii
A chronic
(stunting),
potential
physical
study
district
values
used
from existing
develbetter
in
morbidity
(7). Growth
rate
in children
is associated
growth,
impaired
immune
capacities
anemic
disadvantages
growth
preschool
Asia,
elusive.
and methods
The selection
5 y. as low WFA
be assessed
by measuring
weight,
height,
and age, and can be
classified
by combining
the measurements
to form the indicators
weight-for-height
(WFH),
height-for-age
(HFA),
and weight-forage
with
direct
prevalences
in Southeast
children
population
iron-deficient
scholastic
rate
high
improves
supple-
influencing
However,
to decreased
or to the
the
iron
of positively
rate.
be due
iron
developing
countries
with decreased
physical
status
intake,
effect
growth
remains
growth,
nutrition-related
countries
may
supplementation
Therefore,
growth
physical
(P
Indonesia
opmental
food
dual
and
whether
Iron-deficiency
been
in growth
Considering
1993:58:339-42.
and
the
status
ofiron-enhanced
creased
Introduction
system,
have
0.001).
Height
and
Increases
in height
KEY WORDS
major
may
hematologic
that iron
children.
(P
values
supplementation
preschoolers,
mentation
increase
double
height,
by increased
food intake,
but seems to be influenced
by decreased
morbidity.
Iron supplementation
may be a relatively
inexpensive
way to help decrease
the high prevalence
of stunting.
Am
C/in
et al ( 1 3) reported
growth
in anemic
growth
Z score
height-for-age
0.001)
than
20 mg
Sastroamidjojo
hemoglobin
and serum
femtin
concentrations
Only the treatment
group showed
a significant
in all hematological
of all children
increased
effect
37) received
of 2 mo. Supplement
allocation
was
and finish of the study,
body weight,
intake.
and
determined.
increase
weight
(n
Soemilah
and
Society
for Clinical
Nutrition
at the University
f#{252}rTechnische
SEAMEO/GTZ,
P0 Box
339
group
and
340
so as to remove
and
helminthiasis
hematological
dom
to a treatment
None
of the
ferrous
dered
The
group
(ii
children
diseases.
The treatment
for a period
status.
prepared
Daily
supplement
locations,
between
closely
from
a control
(n
acute
supervised
daily
iron
Farma,
Jakarta,
health
height,
workers
packages.
finish
of the
and
food
2-mo
intake
by using
perature
or more
the
incidence
hemoglobin,
mean
weighing
Germany).
(16).
intake
3 alternate
was
by using generic
Energy
intakes
determined
(one
day
platform-
SECA,
were
by using
of sex and
by the
24-h
recall
the
days
of data
collected
Electronics
Ltd.
age
method
on
over
collection)
size.
food-
Japan).
by radioimmunoassay
kit (Ramco
Laboratories,
analysis
carried
Serum
procedure
Houston).
out at the
University
was
via venipuncture
out
by
between-subjects
subject
factor.
the differences
factor
and
time
by using unpaired
were not normally
differences
within
matched-pairs
were tested
signed-rank
test, and
by using the Mann-Whitney
transformation
groups
the
failed
tested
to give
de-
Pathol-
and
10.5
MANOVA
re-
Chicago)
C) as a
as a within-
interaction
groups
were
(P
<
0.05),
further
I tests, respectively.
as for serum
ferritin,
by
using
Wilcoxons
differences
between
test (20), because
a normal
children
and
group.
Four
and
groups
to treat
19 female)
of the
were,
period
male
subjects
and
1 8 female)
selected
an Islamic
holiday
on
relatives
outside
Jakarta.
control
mo.
in the control
a 2-mo
37 (19
Review
At the end
80 subjects
which
Mean
their
parents
(SD)
age in
respectively,
37.4
9.5
Results
Stool
and
with
examination
showed
before
that
70.3%
of the
parasites
(no
56.5%
the
start
ofthe
children
significant
of the
children
supplementation
in the treatment
group
in the control
group
were
difference
by chi-square
infected
test). At
WBCs
absence
ofall children
were
ofserious
infectious
have influenced
the serum
After
the supplementation
the
group
(Table
within
diseases
ferritin
concentration.
period
the mean
(P
group
for hemoglobin
ferritin
(P = 0.001)
control
were
the normal
that might
values
of
the
0.001),
MCV (P = 0.02),
higher
than the values
for
1 ), whereas
there
was
no significant
difference
ofWFA,
in the variables,
the before-after
differences
for the treatment
group
were significantly
greater
than those for the control
group
for hemoglobin
(P = 0.00 1 ), serum
femtin
(P = 0.02), MCV (P
=
0.02),
change
the
height
(P - 0.00
in WFH
Z score
ment
group
dicate
anemia.
were
HFA Z score
control
group
1 ), and
in the
change
in the treatment
After supplementation
TABLE
1
Hematological
above
(P
the cutoff
Within-group
increases
point
0.00 1 ). The
higher
than
was
group
(P = 0.02).
all hernatological
values
of the
concentrations
in body
values
before
distribution.
groups
a logTo
and after
weight
treatthat
and
in-
height
2 mo supplementation*
Before
Iron
vs after)
and paired
distributed,
were
was
investigated
When
values
ferritin
of Clinical
using
(before
control
Department
of Indonesia.
peated-measures
design
of SPSS/PC+
(19) with treatment
(iron
and vitamin
in the
the
39 (20 male
group
Ethical
Jakarta.
over
groups
used.
between
concentration,
MCV,
and WBCs
counter
(Sysmex
CC-l 80: TOA
Kobe.
subjects
treatment
and serum
Hamburg,
0. 1 cm
designed
to identify
portion
by using the Indonesian
Hemoglobin
by electronic
analyses
were carried
ogy, Medical
Faculty,
arithmic
0900
Medical
Data
alpha:
for effects
between
food models
were calculated
and 1 1 30.
determined
termined
mercial
an electronic,
to the nearest
to correct
3 d ofdata
collection.
Blood samples
(3 mL)
0830
were
770
measured
data
days
composition
plementation
tern-
of the indicators
WFA,
HFA,
and WFH
by using the National
Center
for Health
Statistics
reference
growth
Food
(body
diarrhea
(four
and recorded
Z scores
a microtoise.
were calculated
(NCHS)
(SECA
was
of fever
of sup-
or the district
health
worker.
without
clothing
between
0. 1 kg by using
scale
Height
duration
period
infections
(1 5), and
per 24 h) were checked
(ITA.)
weighed
model
and
37 #{176}C),
respiratory
loose, watery
stools
>
iron-treatment
was
by the
period
supplements
set included
in the
period
ofoccult
plementation,
approved
of Indonesia,
supplementation
their anemia.
The final data
period
Furthermore,
the entire
was
University
iron
between
test
researchers
blind
the
Over
received
iron-treated
and 37.2
volume
(MCV),
and serum
ferritin
concentration.
cell counts
(WBCs)
were carried
out to determine
infections.
2-mo
at central
was super-
corpuscular
White
blood
presence
ofthe
group
Indonesia).
ofthe
recorded.
to determine
proposal
of the
dropped
out after
took them to visit
supplementation
were
collected
one
was double
research
ofhelminthiasis
the chi-square
+ vitamin
(n = 39)
Hemoglobin
Serum ferritin
MCV (ft.)
Vitamin
C (n =
Hemoglobin
Serum ferritin
MCV (if.)
*
After
Difference
C
(gIL)
(tg/L)
37)
(gIL)
(ig/L)
SD. MCV,
mean
102
6.2
78.2
103
7.1
77.6
corpuscular
9
1.7
7.2
1 12
15.0
82.5
8
2.5
7.0
104
10.0
77.9
9t
lO.2t
5.4
10
8.8
4.0
I
10.9
9.2
1
2.9
0.3
l0t
9.5j
4.9
12
10.7
8.0
volume.
t Significantly
greater than the related value ofthe vitamin C group:
=
0.001, P < 0.02.
Significant
difference
between
start and finish of supplementation
period, P = 0.001 (within-group
change).
tP
were
and
supplements
which
iron
in prevalence
of enrollment,
Committee
supplements
C alone.
containing
The
40).
infectious
as 8 1 mg hydrated
of 20 mg vitamin
to the supplement
ofthe
samples
group
obvious,
by PT Kimia
by district
coded
supplement
At the start and
blood
at the time
ingestion
by subjects
took
place
meals
from 0900 to 1 1 30 h, and
Allocation
weight.
at ran-
with 20 mg vitamin
same period
oftime,
supplements
appearance
(supplements
vised
growth
were
of 2 mo of 30 mg elemental
received
daily
was of similar
(ITA.).
of both
assigned
received
sulfate.
combined
form.
During
the
AL
as a confounder
suffered
group
ET
80 subjects
40) and
ANGELES
GROWTH
TABLE 2
Weight, height, and Z scores
after 2 mo supplementation*
AND
IRON
STATUS
OF
During
of anthropometric
Before
indicators
before
After
and
both
This
+ vitamin
10.6
86.2
-2.53
-2.33
1.48
10.6
86.6
-2.54
-2.18
-1.56
1.2
6.5
0.42
0.83
0.55
11.1 1.4
88.9 5.9
-2.37 0.49
-1.96 0.73
1.57 0.50
1.3
6.9
0.34
0.96
0.60
1 1.2 1.5
88.1 6.9
-2.33 0.54
-2.10 0.92
-1.36 0.68
0.50.5t
2.7 l.Stt
0.17 0.33
0.37 0.4ltt
-0.06
0.46
0.6
1.5
0.21
0.07
0.21
Significantly
P
were
higher
significant
in the
than
the related
in both
treatment
groups
group
was
scores
significantly
ofWFA
period.
Energy
450 1 1045
(Table
2.7
whereas
and
intake
WFH
at the
kJ/d
significant
in the
increased
start
for the
changes
Episodes
control
group
respectively,
before
the
vitamin
vitamin
during
iron-treated
start
of the
whereas
period
and
No
data
was
4 1 1 3 1 187
groups.
and
were
diarrhea
more
group
in the
frequently,
(Table
3).
about
the same
in both
for fever,
respiratory
available
on
was
reflected
morbidity
study.
height
this
weight
of
may
be
gain
in a higher
was
WFA
group
received
infection
control
more
on growth
unlikely
resulted
group.
the
with parasites.
treatment,
at the end
treatment
given
there would
have
in the control
start
in the control
were infected
antihelminthic
to have
in an increase
Before
children
was made
influences
in HFA
in the
ences
ofthe
of the
group
than
The children
but no recheck
supplementation
before
supplementation
been especially
negative
group.
happened
However,
such
considering
the
in both groups.
supplementation
influ-
sufficient
on growth
of
anemic
children
have been reported
elsewhere
(3. 1 3). The children in those studies
had initial
HFA Z scores
of -0. 14 (3) and
I .66 ( 1 3), which
does not classify
them
as being stunted,
and
an effect
of the supplementation
and control
groups
were
respectively.
There
were no
infections,
The
the WFA
period
group
to which
study.
comparable
increases
in weight
The enhancing
effects of iron
the supplementation
group
of the illnesses
was
and 1 . I d, respectively,
diarrhea.
increase
extent
rise
Z score
HFA
Z score
are
the
in this
and
fact that
period.
If the worm
had been ineffective,
end
of the two
respiratory
and
height
while
for parasite
0.001)
C-only
occurred
1 .7, 2.5, and 3.0 times
than
in the iron-supplemented
duration
1 .5, 3.5,
infections,
(P
of the supplementation
in either
of fever,
2). The
1.5 cm
Average
groups:
of the iron
group
in the treatment
in both groups
0.81
0.36
0.23
0.5lII
group
was 1.5 1.8 cm (P = 0.001).
the Z scores
of WFA
and HFA
in-
the increase
in the control
In the iron-treated
group
creased
value
The
and
for growing
children.
influenced
by the de-
change
in height
in the treatment
group
was
than the height
change
in the control
group,
supplementation
0.02.
only.
weight
underweight
Two studies
of iron
as opposed
among
Thai
supplementation
to the
children
children
in the
did not show
on growth,
but
this
may
be
amount
of supplemented
iron or to differences
(22, 23). Normally,
a child 37 mo of age with
a height similar
to the median
ofthe
NCHS
reference
(16) would
need to grow
1.4 cm in 2 mo to remain
equal
to the median.
An average
increase
in height ofthe
treatment
group
in the present study
was 2.6
dicating
a marked
cm. or 1 86%
acceleration.
of the median
growth
rate, inIn a study in which
daily food
supplements
were
provided
to stunted
children
for a period
of 90 d (24), HFA
-2.34
found
growth
preschool
changed
from
to -2.24.
which
reflects
a smaller
increase
than the one
in this study. Effects offood
supplementation
on physical
are reported
to be most effective
when children
are aged
<
Indonesian
Z scores
study,
in which
no food
were distributed
and all children
to note that the treatment
group
in linear
growth.
study,
energy
present
intake
was
supplements
sufficient
drens
actual
weight
according
to WHO
daily
intake
recommendations
of 397 kJ/kg
(95 kcal/kg)
(9). Treating
anemia
is
reported
to increase
appetite
in adults
(27). However,
the treat-
Discussion
Both
Indonesia
milieu
and growth
are considered
of multiple
vestigate
and
anemia
and
conditions,
the effect
physical
growth
children.
The iron dosage,
ganization
(WHO)
The
substantial
supplementation
cantly
larger
C-only
group.
of iron
the
are
health
aim
supplementation
variables
ofanernic,
which
was
recommendations
increases
than
retardation
public
in line
in hematological
highly
prevalent
in
problems.
In this
of this
study
was
on the blood
underweight,
to invalues
preschool
with World
Health
Or(2), proved
to be effective.
values
over
TABLE
3
Episodes
of fever. respiratory
infections,
and diarrhea
supplementation
period in the two groups
the 2-mo
period
of the iron-treated
group
were signifithe small changes
that occurred
in the vitamin
Iron
Type
of morbidity
(n
vitamin
39)
during
the
Vitamin
C
(n = 37)
%
Fever
Respiratory
Diarrhea*
*
Defined
7.7
10.3
5.1
infections
as four or more
loose,
watery
13.5
27.0
16.2
stools
per 24 h.
II
groups
the
be expected
positively
(2 1), but
to a significant
group
in WFH
t Significant
difference
between start and finish of supplementation
period (within-group
change) tP < 0.0 1 , P < 0.05.
:j: Significantly
higher than the related value of the vitamin C group,
P= 0.001.
group,
in both
leading
0.6t
period
be estimated
SD.
treatment
cannot
similar
(n = 39)
Weight(kg)
Height (cm)
Weight-for-age
Height-for-age
Weight-for-height
Vitamin
C (n = 37)
Weight (kg)
Height (cm)
Weight-for-age
Height-for-age
Weight-for-height
the supplementation
worming
Difference
341
groups
increased
as would
increase
may have been
true
Iron
CHILDREN
342
ment
group
did
plementation
growth
rate
food
increased
energy
suggests
that
in the
treatment
group
was
During
the
diseases
in the treatment
ofinfectious
rate
iron
have
This
intake.
control
not
period.
group.
This
intake
the
may
have
caused
period
group
the
study
indicate
that
role in overcoming
iron
suplinear
incidence
less than
increased
in the treatment
group.
Furthermore
the
on oxidative
processes
may have stimulated
The results
of this
may play an important
the
by higher
the
was
influenced
ET
increased
not
supplementation
after
ANGELES
in the
growth
direct
action
of
growth
rate.
supplementation
both growth
retar-
dation
and anemia
in preschool
children.
It is recommended,
therefore.
that consideration
be given to providing
iron supplementation
women,
but
on effective
would
need
cost
supplementation
to be conducted.
ofiron
treatment
example,
is relatively
treatment
for one
Traditionally,
it is believed
between
micronutrients
tamin
A (30). Furthermore,
that
stunting
because
was
not
infectious
leads
to growth
this
WFA
cost
may
the
the
is caused
is too limited
effects
of mibut also zinc.
the interaction
indicator
2 1.
to growth
retar-
this study
increased
did confirm
morbidity,
that
which
and
1990.
20.
of malnutrition
contribute
in children,
and
about
for
one between
iron and viworking
group
concluded
also
It is necessary
malnutrition,
study,
$0.18.
or HFA
be considered,
(28, 29) and
an appropriate
depression
indicator,
knowledge
low
as the
a WHO
(3 1 ). However,
may cause
indirectly
to stunting.
beliefs
about
chronic
appropriate
Increased
such
diseases
dation
of children
lack of micronutrients
1 mo
energy.
This assumption
taking
into account
the
cronutrients.
Not only should
iron
which
is reported
to enhance
growth
children
that the
In the present
for
that
preschool
to note
may
therefore
to reconsider
the
the use of stunting
selection
of suitable
role of micronutrients
lead
existing
as an
treatment.
is vital
in
#{163}3
aspect.
22.
23.
24.
References
25.
26.
27.
1986:61:849-57.
4. Dallman
Nutr
response.
Am J Clin
28.
1987:46:324-9.
5. Soemantri
AG, Pollitt E, Insun Kim. Iron deficiency
anemia and
educational
achievement.
Am J Clin Nutr 1985:42:1221-8.
6. LozoffB, Jimenez
E, WolfAW.
Long-term
developmental
outcome
ofinfants
with iron deficiency.
N EngI I Med 199 1:325:687-94.
7. Pollitt
E. Malnutrition
and infection
in the classroom.
Paris:
UNESCO,
1990.
8. World Health Organization.
Measuring
change in nutritional
status.
Geneva:
WHO, 1983.
9. World Health Organization.
Energy and protein requirements.
Report of a joint FAO/WHO/UNU
Expert Consultation.
Geneva:
WHO, 1985 (Technical
report series 724.)
Snedecor
GW, Cochran
WG. Statistical
methods.
7th ed. Ames, IA:
Iowa State University
Press, I 980.
Stephenson
LS. Crompton
DWT,
Latham
MC, Schulpen
TWJ,
Nesheim
MC, Jansen AAJ. Relationships
between Ascaris infection
and growth of malnourished
preschool
children
in Kenya. Am J
Clin Nutr 1980:33:1 165-72.
GershoffSN,
McGandy
RB, Nondasuta
A, Tantiwongse
P. Nutrition
studies in Thailand:
effects of calories,
nutrient
supplements,
and
health interventions
on growth of preschool
Thai village children.
Am J Clin Nutr 1988:48:1214-8.
Migasena
P. Thurnham
DI, Jintakanon
K, Pongpaew
P. Anemia
in Thai children:
the effect of iron supplement
on haemoglobin
and
growth. Southeast
Asian J Trop Med Public Health 1972:3:255-61.
Husaini MA, Karyadi
L, Husaini YK, Karyadi
D, Pollitt E. Developmental
effects ofshort-term
supplementary
feeding in nutritionally
at-risk Indonesian
infants. Am J Clin Nutr 199 1:54:799-804.
Lutter CK. Mora JO, Habicht
JP, Rasmussen
KM. Robson
DS,
Herrera
MG. Age-specific
responsiveness
of weight and length to
nutritional
supplementation.
Am J Clin Nutr 1990:51:359-64.
Walker SP. Powell CA. Grantham-McGregor
SM, Himes JH, Chang
SM. Nutritional
supplementation,
and growth
of stunted
children:
the Jamaica
study. Am J Clin Nutr 199 1:54:642-8.
Basta SS, Soekirman
MS. Karyadi D, Scrimshaw
NS. Iron deficiency
anemia and the productivity
ofadult
males in Indonesia.
Am J Clin
Nutr 1979:32:916-25.
Golden
MHN, Golden
BE. Effect of zinc supplementation
on the
dietary intake. rate ofweight gain, and energy cost oftissue deposition
in children
recovering
from severe malnutrition.
Am J Clin Nutr
1981:34:900-8.
29.
Walravens
PA, Krebs NF, Hambridge
KM. Linear growth of low
income preschool
children
receiving a zinc supplement.
Am J Clin
Nutr
30.
1983:38:195-201.
by a lack ofprotein
and/or
and should
be reviewed,
low.
child
501.
groups
such as pregnant
Therefore,
further
study
systems
for
It is important
AL