Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
CME609
Research Methodology
By
Prof. Okechukwu Ugweje
2016LectureGuide
Federal University of Technology, Minna
Research Methodology
Research Methodology
Module 1
A. Research Concepts
Expertise is earned not given
Prof. Okey Ugweje
Research Methodology
What is Research? - 1
The word research is composed of two syllables, re
and search.
Re = a prefix- meaning again, anew or over again
search = a verb- meaning to examine closely and
carefully, to test and try, or to probe
Definition of Research?
What is Research? - 2
What is Research? - 3
What is Research? - 4
What is Research? - 5
What is Research? - 6
No Problem!
No Research!!
10
11
Unanswered question
Unsolved question
Concern
Query
Statement of inquiry
12
Purpose of Research
How?
What?
Who?
Where?
Why?
Prof. Okey Ugweje
When?
13
Purpose of Research
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
Research Characteristics - 1
Research is a process of
collecting,
analyzing and
interpreting information to answer questions
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
22
Research Characteristics - 2
23
Controlled,
Rigorous,
Systematic,
Valid and verifiable,
Empirical, and
Critical
24
Research Characteristics - 3
Research Characteristics - 3
1. Controlled:
3. Systematic:
2. Rigorous:
25
Research Characteristics - 4
Criteria
Analysis and
discussion
Conclusion
Referencing
Communication
27
Poor Research
Methodology
6. Critical:
26
5. Empirical:
Relevance is unclear,
Little or no evaluation,
Research questions missing,
impractical or unfocused
Little appreciation of research design
No justification of choice
Not linked to the literature
Unclear findings, unrelated to research
question,
Little or no attempt to discuss in relation
to literature review
Some conclusions but not linked to
research questions
Implications and limitations of results
not addressed
Plagiarism through omission of
inadequate referencing
Difficult to follow, Many spelling and
grammar mistake
Good Research
Sharply focused
Related to academic debate
Critical evaluation of relevance, up-to-date
literature,
Linked to focused feasible research
questions
Cohesive design,
Excellent review of research design options,
Linked to the literature
Clear findings discussed in an analytical
manner that generates new knowledge and
insight,
Linked to the literature
Conclusions clearly linked to research
questions
Attention given to implications and
limitations
All sources cited in the text and full
bibliographic details listed at the end
28
29
Research Methodology
30
Research Methods - 1
Research can be classified according to the perspectives:
1. Purpose of the research (why do it) the reason why
it was conducted
32
Research Methods - 2
Research Methods - 3
Classification of Research by Purpose
Basis of
Classification
Outcome of
research
Purpose of
research
Process of research
Comments
Explanatory,
Correlational
Structured,
Unstructured
Logic of research
33
Research Methods - 4
34
Research Methods - 5
35
36
Common Type
of Data
Experimental
Quantitative
Causal-Comparative Quantitative
Historical
Quantitative or
Qualitative
Developmental
Quantitative
Correlational
Quantitative
Case Study
Qualitative
Grounded Theory
Qualitative
Ethnography
Qualitative
Action Research
Quantitative and
Qualitative
Stage of
Problem
Evaluation
Evaluation
Description
Categories of
Theory
Testing or Revising
Testing or Revising
Testing or Revising
Description
Description
Exploration
Exploration
Description
Applied
Exploration
Building or Revising
Testing
Building or Revising
Building
Building
Building or Revising
38
39
40
41
Other Examples
What type of packaging for a box of chocolates do
consumers prefer?
What information do consumers want shown on food
labels?
Which car advertisements on television do men and
women of different ages prefer?
How many students study accounting in China
compared with students in Australia?
How do commuters travel to work in capital cities?
42
Note:
Descriptive and historical research provide a picture of
events that are currently happening or have occurred in
the past
Researchers often want to go beyond mere description
and begin discussing the relationship that certain
events might have to one another.
The most likely type of research to answer the
relationship among variables or events is called
correlational research.
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
Example:
Nancy Burton and Lyle Jones (1982) examined trends
in achievement levels of African American versus White
children.
They examined high school graduation rates between
these 2 ethnic groups who were born before 1913,
between 1913 and 1922, between 1923 and 1932, etc.
They also examined a variety of historical indicators in
more recent groups of African American and White
children.
One of their conclusions is that differences in
achievements between these groups are decreasing.
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
Experimental
Non-experimental
1. Causalcomparative
2. Descriptive
3. Correlational
4. Historical
64
Basic Research
Pure, fundamental
research
Discovery of new
knowledge; theoretical
in nature
Has no immediate
application
Takes many years for
the results of basic
research to find some
practical utility
Prof. Okey Ugweje
Quantitative Research - 1
Applied Research
Central purpose to solve
an immediate problem
Improved products or
processes
has immediate
application
Infers beyond the group
or situation studied
Interpretation of results
relies upon Basic
research
65
Quantitative Research - 2
Amounts
Frequencies
Degrees
Values
Intensity
Uses statistics for greater precision and objectivity
Based on the deductive reasoning
66
Quantitative Research - 3
67
68
Qualitative Research
69
Quantitative
Numerical, measurable
Explanation, prediction
Test theories
Known variables
Large sample
Standardized instruments
Deductive
Clearly stated questions
Rational hypotheses
Extraneous variable
controls
Statistical analyses
Prof. Okey Ugweje
Qualitative
Generally non-numerical
Explanation, description
Build theories
Unknown variables
Small sample
Observations, interviews
Inductive
In-depth descriptions of
situations
Interpretive and
descriptive
Qualitative
Action research
Case studies
Grounded theory
Ethnography
Differentiate between data
gathering & data analysis!
Difference with
Quantitative research
respect to:
Approach to
Structured/rigid/predetermined
enquiry
methodology
Main purpose of To quantify extent of variation in a
investigation
phenomenon, situation, issue, etc.
71
Qualitative research
Unstructured/flexible/op
en methodology
To describe variation in
a phenomenon,
situation, issue, etc.
Emphasis on
description of variables
Sample size
Fewer cases
70
Research Methodology
Nature of
findings
Quantitative research
Qualitative research
Research Objectives
73
74
Research Objectives - 1
Research Objectives - 2
75
76
Research Objectives - 3
Research Objectives - 4
77
Research Objectives - 5
78
Research Objectives - 6
79
80
Research Methodology
Research Process - 1
The research process deals with the ways and
strategies used by researchers to understand the
world around us.
The research process is similar to undertaking a
journey.
For a research journey there are two important
decisions to make1. What you want to find out about or what
research questions (problems) you want to
find answers to;
2. How to go about finding their answers.
Research Process
81
Research Process - 2
82
Research Process - 3
P = research-worthy Problem
L = valid peer-reviewed Literature
D = Data available
83
84
Research Process - 4
Research Process - 5
85
86
Research Methodology
Research Methodology
B. Research Methodology
or Methods
Research Methodology
87
88
Research Methodology - 1
Research Methodology - 2
May be regarded as the science of studying how
research is done scientifically
Is the study of various steps that are generally
adopted by a researcher in studying his/her
research problem along with the logic behind them
Should have a sound theoretical basis, conceptual
89
90
Research Methodology
Research Methodology - 3
A research methodology consist of phases, subphases, which will guide the researchers in their
choice of the methods, techniques, procedures, tools,
etc., appropriate at each stage of the research and
also help to plan, manage, control and evaluate the
progress of research
Research Methods
91
92
Research Methods
Research Method/Design:
Specific Methods, Techniques, or Procedures
used to conduct research or collect and analyze
data
Specific techniques, tools or procedures applied
to achieve a given objective
Research methods in engineering include
mathematical analysis, simulation,
measurements (data gathering), experimentation,
development of algorithm, software development,
comparative analysis, etc.
Prof. Okey Ugweje
93
Research Methodology
94
95
96
Methodology
Methods
If the subject into which you
If the subject into which
conduct a research is a scientific you conduct a research is
subject or topic
a scientific subject or topic
then research methodology
then the research
pertaining to the scientific
methods include the
topic involves the steps
experiments, tests,
regarding how to go about
study of various other
conducting the research, the
results of different
tools of research, advanced
experiments performed
techniques that can be used in
in relation to the topic
the conduct of the
or the subject and the
experiments, etc.
like
Prof. Okey Ugweje
97
98
Depends on
Research Questions/Problems
Research Aims/Goals/Objectives
Researcher Beliefs and Values
Researcher Skills
Time and Funding
99
100
Descriptive Questions
Difference Questions
Purpose:
Seeks to describe phenomena or characteristics of a
particular group of subjects being studied
Answers the question what is
Asking questions of the research participants
Testing or measuring their performance
Survey research
Qualitative research
Purpose:
Seeks to make comparisons between or within
groups of interest
Often associated with experimental research
Is there a difference between the control group
and the experimental group?
Treatment vs. control
Pre-test vs. post-test comparisons
Comparison of one group to another on the basis of
existing characteristics
Non-experimental research
101
102
Research Methodology
Relationship Questions
Purpose
To investigate the degree to which two or more
variables co-vary or are associated with each other
Module 2
Steps in Conducting
Research
103
104
Some Definitions
Research Skills
1-2
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
105
Research Methodology
106
1. Selecting and
Defining a Problem
107
108
109
4. Newness / Relevance
5. Manageability
Expertise, time, resources
Free from personal bias
6. Feasibility
Time constraints
Ethical constraints
Organizational support
Availability of equipment
7. After graduation employment possibilities
Answer
1. Personal interest / Passion, Curiosity
Most important
2. Importance / Contribution to the field
3. Significance
Theoretical value
Practical value
Timeliness
External review
Federal University of Technology, Minna
110
1-2
111
1-2
112
1-2
1-2
114
115
116
Getting Started
118
Problem Formulation
119
120
Problem Formulation
121
122
123
124
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
125
Research Methodology
Formulating a hypothesis
Developing the research plan
Collecting and analyzing the data
Interpreting results and forming conclusions
126
2. Describing the
Methodology of Research
127
128
Research Methodology
Collecting Data
This step involves conducting the study as per the
designed procedure (manipulating the experimental
variables in the case of an experimental method),
administering instruments for measuring variables
and/or gathering information through observation.
It also involves tabulating the data thus collected for
the purpose of analysis.
3. Collecting Data
129
130
Stage in the
Process
Determine
data collection
method and
forms
131
Typical Questions
Can existing data be used to advantage?
What is to be measured? How?
What is the source of the data?
Can objective answers be obtained by asking people?
How should people be questioned?
Should the questionnaires be administered in person, over
the phone, or through the mail?
Should electronic or mechanical means be used to make the
observations?
Should structure or unstructured items be used to collect the
data?
Should the purpose of the study be made known to the
respondents?
Should rating scales be used in the questionnaire?
Federal University of Technology, Minna
132
Research Methodology
Typical Questions
Who is the target population?
Is a list of population elements available?
Is a sample necessary?
Is a probability sample desirable?
How large should the sample be?
How should the sample be selected?
Who will gather the data?
How much supervision is needed?
What operational procedures will be
followed?
What methods will be used to ensure the
quality of the data collected?
Federal University of Technology, Minna
133
134
135
136
Research Methodology
Research Plan - 1
138
Research Plan - 2
139
140
Research Plan - 3
Research Plan - 4
141
142
Clarity of scope
What are you trying to achieve in the research?
1. Mind Map
2. Drill Down
Access to supervisor
3. Gantt Charts
Funding
4. Risk Analysis
Publishable quality
Prof. Okey Ugweje
143
144
Mind Map - 1
Mind Mapping - 2
145
Mind Map - 3
146
Mind Mapping - 4
Mind maps are tools which help you think and learn
147
148
Mind Mapping - 5
Mind Mapping - 6
149
project
risks
How is it happening ?
(methodology)
impact
Challenges
for me
Prof. Okey Ugweje
the future
150
Drill Down - 1
project
151
152
Drill Down - 2
Drill Down - 3
153
Drill Down - 4
154
Drill Down - 5
155
156
Involve a bank
insider
Use press and
financial
knowledge
Get away
Dig tunnel
Assignment
You are required to plan and organise a conference
at FUT Minna
Drill down the different tasks which must be achieved
for a successful event
157
158
Gantt Chart - 1
Gantt Chart - 2
159
160
Gantt Chart - 3
Gantt Chart - 4
You can use Gantt Chart to:
Lay out your research tasks to be completed
Show when these tasks should be carried out
Assist the allocation of resources is necessary
Work out the critical path for a task that must be
complete at a particular date
Identify relationships between research tasks
Estimate time for each task such as
Completing chapters
Conducting experiment or programming
Allocate time for meetings, information gathering
161
Projects Risks
162
Tunnel collapses
Develop response
163
164
Behind Schedule ?
165
Research Methodology
166
Module 3
Literature Review
167
1-2
168
169
170
Undertaking a LR requires:
1. identification of a topic of interest,
2. searching and retrieving the appropriate literature,
3. analyzing and synthesizing the findings, and
4. writing a report
Reviewing the literature involves:
searching,
collecting,
prioritising,
reading with a purpose and seeking out key issues and
themes, and
then presenting and discussing these critically.
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
Narrative or traditional
This type of review critiques/summarizes the
literature and draws conclusions about the topic in
question
The literature must be relevant studies and
knowledge that address the subject area
It is typically selective in the material it uses,
although the criteria for selecting specific sources
for review are not always apparent to the reader
It is useful in gathering together a volume of
literature in a specific subject area and summarizing
and synthesizing it
181
182
Systematic review
Systematic reviews use a more rigorous and welldefined approach to reviewing the literature in a
specific subject area
It is used to answer well-focused questions about a
problem
It detail the time frame and methods used to
evaluate and synthesize findings of the question
183
184
185
186
Meta-analysis
Meta-analysis is the process of taking a large body
of quantitative findings and conducting statistical
analysis in order to integrate those findings and
enhance understanding
It is seen as a form of systematic review which is
largely a statistical technique
It involves taking the findings from several studies
on the same subject and analyzing them using
standardized statistical procedures
This helps to draw conclusions and detect patterns
and relationships between findings
Meta-synthesis
Meta-synthesis is the non-statistical technique used
to integrate, evaluate and interpret the findings of
multiple qualitative research studies
Unlike meta-analysis, where the ultimate intention is
to reduce findings, meta-synthesis involves
analyzing and synthesizing key elements in each
study, with the aim of transforming individual
findings into new conceptualizations and
interpretations
187
188
Knowledge Continuum of LR - 1
Knowledge Continuum of LR - 2
Unconscious Incompetence:
being unaware of something, its relationship to other
things, and how it can be used in conjunction with
other things
Conscious Incompetence:
becoming aware that one does not know what can
be known
Conscious Competence:
beginning to surmise, envisage and hypothesise the
nature of something, its relationship to other things,
how it can be used, but not yet being able to use it as
intended
Unconscious Incompetence
Conscious Incompetence
Conscious Competence
Unconscious Competence
Levels of competency when completing a conceptual task ([2], [3], [4]
189
190
Knowledge Continuum of LR - 3
Knowledge Continuum of LR - 4
Unconscious Competence:
achieving expert level of knowledge of something
and its relationship to other things, how it can be
used, can conceptualise it as newly understood
events, and being able to utilise it, and understand
the general interrelationship and interaction
potentials between that thing and other things
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
198
199
200
201
Reports
Conference Proceedings
Records
Magazine
Archives
Letters
Interviews
2.
Internet
Data bases
202
203
204
205
206
208
209
Topic: _________________________________
Source
#2
Source
#3
Source
#4
210
Source
#K
Idea A
Idea B
In your new sources, you may find new ideas that you
need to add to your list at the left
--Idea J
Source
#1
Etc.
Federal University of Technology, Minna
211
212
213
214
Flowchart demonstrating the alignment of a general problem and research question, and
reconceptualising them in greater detail as properly aligned subproblems and research
questions [5]
215
2. Concept matrix
Used to present a concept-centric rather than an
author-centric LR
Ensures that LR is essentially a qualitative content
analysis of available published literature
Is a study of the research with the aim of collecting
information about its structure, process and
relationships
Thereby increasing familiarity of research object
and establishing the credibility of the project
Considers previous research, attempting to link it
with the study currently planned
Prof. Okey Ugweje
216
Matrix Method
Matrix Method
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
Networked
World
Innovation
Readiness
Evaluation
Institutional
Development
Digital
Inclusiveness
Community
Development
E-Strategies
E-Schools
Access to ICT
Services
E-Learning
References
E-Education
Policy
Concepts
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Atypicalconceptmatrixshowingwhichconceptsarediscussedinreferencesfora
literaturereviewoneReadiness[6]
Prof. Okey Ugweje
225
Access to ICT
Services
E-Schools
E-Strategies
Community
Development
Digital
Inclusiveness
Institutional
Development
Innovation
Readiness
Evaluation
Networked
World
Economic
Development
1
3
1
2
2
5
1
3
1
3
3
1
2
1
2
3
3
1
1
E-Learning
E-Education
Policy
References
Total relevant
concept per
source
Concepts
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
226
A typical concept matrix with an added row indicating the total number of sources per
concept as well as the total number of relevant concepts per source that focuses on eReadiness [6]
Prof. Okey Ugweje
227
228
Bar graph showing the number of sources per concept on the concept matrix
for a literature review that focuses on e-Readiness [6]
Prof. Okey Ugweje
229
230
Compare:
Try to find the similarities among literatures
Explain how each article is similar to the others.
Contrast:
Try to find the differences among literatures
Explain how each article differ to the others
Criticize:
Put your own opinion on what is written in the
literatures
Criticize the strength and weakness of the research
Synthesize:
Combine several literatures into an idea
Summarize:
Restate the article with your own words in a concise
way
231
232
Case One
The student was a doctoral candidate and could not
determine when to stop his literature review and
ended with a literature review of 180 pages. When
his supervisor requested that the student cut this
down, the response was You tell me what to cut
out. The student belonged to the conscious
incompetence branch of the competency quadrant.
This student should never have been accepted for a
doctoral study.
Case Two
another doctoral candidate who argued that he was using
grounded theory to inductively generate a new theoretical
framework from collected data because he could not find
enough literature to review on his topic. The supervisor
agreed that the grounded theory approach could be
appropriate if the research theme falls within an emerging
field of knowledge generation. Surprisingly, produced 100.
The supervisor then pointed out that the grounded theory
approach would be inappropriate because the student had
found more than enough theoretical literature to review. The
supervisor argued that the student should not use grounded
theory and that he should reduce the theory to at least 45
pages.
233
234
Case Three
The business student started a proposal and was
advised to use headings. He used some headings
and when advised to list a specific heading argued
that he would slot it into the introduction. The
students supervisor eventually could not make out
head or tail of the unsystematic literature review
that was presented.
235
236
Research Methodology
Referencing / Citation
237
238
Why do we Reference?
Citation:
Shows your credibility as a researcher
Gives proper credit to other authors and
researchers
Protects you from accusations of plagiarism
Federal University of
Technology, Minna
239
240
When do we Reference?
References List - 1
241
242
References List - 2
Reference/Citation Styles
243
244
1. In Text Citation
Cite references in numerical order beginning with
the main text, not the preliminary pages.
Once you number the reference, use the same
number in all subsequent citations.
245
246
Multiple References
Separate citation numbers with commas [3], [5]
To cite more than one source at a time:
Preferred
[1], [3], [5]
[1]-[5]
Acceptable
[1, 5, 7]
[1-5]
247
248
2. Reference List:
List of all sources at the end of the work
List references in the order they were cited (numerical
order, starting with [1]), not alphabetical order.
Align bracketed numbers and flush left, forming their
own column that hangs out beyond the body of the
references
This is called a hanging indent (examples later)
Allow space such that reference bodies remain
aligned when bracketed numbers increase to double
and (if necessary) triple digits.
249
250
251
252
Abbreviations
Either spell out the entire name of each periodical,
or use accepted abbreviations. Either way, be
consistent.
Abbreviations are: vol., no., p. (1 page only), pp.
(range of pages), Jan., Feb., Mar. (optional), Apr.
(optional), Jun. (optional), Jul. (optional), Aug.,
Sept., Oct., Nov., Dec.
Punctuation
Place punctuation inside quotation marks.
E.g, Periodicals.
253
254
Books
Journals
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
example of a chapter
Prof. Okey Ugweje
255
256
Conference Proceedings
[8]
[6]
[7]
257
[9]
258
Course materials
Manuals
[10] Bell Telephone Laboratories Technical Staff,
Transmission System for Communications, Bell
Telephone Laboratories, 1995.
[11] Motorola Semiconductor Data Manual, Motorola
Semiconductor Products, Inc., Phoenix, AZ, 2007.
259
[12]
[13]
260
Catalogs
Patents
Unpublished Sources
Standards
[15] T. I. Wein, private communication, Sept. 2005.
[18] IEEE Criteria for Class IE Electric Systems, IEEE
Standard 308, 1969.
261
262
E- Sources (IEEE)
[19]
264
Examples
265
Research Methodology
266
Module 4
Statement of the Problem
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
275
276
277
278
279
280
Formulate Objectives
281
Example:
1- To determine the effect of customer expectation on
customer satisfaction
2- To find out the effect of service quality on customer
satisfaction
3- To identify how word of mouth communication impact
on customer satisfaction
Formulate Objectives
Research Objective
To identify organizations
objectives for introducing
retirement schemes.
To describe the consequences
of early recruitment for
employees
To explore the effects of early
retirement for the organization
282
'to determine',
'to ascertain' and 'to examine,
to measure,
to explore.
Examine your objectives to ascertain the feasibility of
achieving them in the light of the time, resources and
technical expertise at your disposal.
283
284
Double-Check
285
Interest,
Magnitude,
Measurement of concepts,
Level of expertise,
Relevance,
Availability of data,
Ethical issues.
286
287
288
289
290
A fact or observation
Incorrect: The United States has many homeless
people
Correct: Because the homeless population is still
widespread in the United States, Congress,
organizations, and individuals must do more to
improve the problem
291
A generalization
Incorrect: Men take all the good jobs and get paid
more
Correct: Recent research shows that men are still
earning a significant amount more than women in
the same positions; therefore, employers and the
government must do more to narrow this gap.
292
An exaggeration
Incorrect: Fad diets are extremely unhealthy
A question
Incorrect: Is it right for the media to portray
women the way they do?
293
294
Vague or general
Incorrect: Jane Austen was a good author.
Correct: Jane Austen was one of the greatest
authors of all time because of her unique use of
characterization and plots detailing significant
social issues.
An announcement
Incorrect: This essay talks about how legalizing
marijuana is incorrect.
295
296
297
298
2. Persuasive
A persuasive statement makes a claim based on
opinion, evaluation, or interpretation about a topic
and proves this claim with specific evidence
If you have been asked to argue a point or choose
a side on an issue, this is likely the type of research
you will use.
4. The Essay:
Contains essays topic point, and three supporting
reasons
3. Expository
An expository (explanatory) research explains
something to the audience
Prof. Okey Ugweje
299
Example:
To reduce the number of highway fatalities
[topic and point], our country needs
[purpose=persuasive] to enforce the national
law that designates twenty-one as the legal
minimum age to drink, set up check points on
major holidays, and take away licenses from
convicted drunk drivers [three reasons].
Prof. Okey Ugweje
300
301
Delimitations
302
Delimitations
303
Examples include
Number and kinds of subjects
Treatment conditions
Tests, measures, instruments used
Type of equipment
Location, environmental setting
Type of training (time and duration)
Number of iterations of programs
304
Limitations
Limitations
Examples include
Sampling problems (representativeness of subjects)
Uncontrolled factors and extraneous variables
Faulty research design and techniques
Reliability and validity of measuring instruments
Compromises to internal/external validity
305
Assumptions
306
Assumptions
307
308
Research Methodology
Research Variables
A variable is a characteristic, trait, or attribute of a
person or thing that can be classified or measured
Attitude
Gender
Heart rate
Voltage, Current, Bit Error Rate
Variable - the condition or characteristic which in a
given study may have more than one value
Quantitative measured numerically
Discrete or Continuous
Qualitative categorical in nature
Prof. Okey Ugweje
310
1. A Flash of Brilliance
Warnings:
Warnings:
This may be too incremental
311
312
4. The Apprentice
Re-implement or re-do
Identify an improvement, algorithm, proof, etc.
You have now discovered a topic
Warnings:
You may be without a topic for a long time
It may not be a topic worthy of a M.S./PhD thesis
Prof. Okey Ugweje
313
6. Idea From A
314
Warnings:
You can read a lot of papers and not find a
connection
Or realize someone has done it already!
Warnings:
May be hard to tie into a thesis
May not have enough impact
Federal University of Technology, Minna
5. 5 papers = Thesis
Warnings:
Dont work on something you find boring, badlymotivated,
Several students may be working on the
same/related problem
315
316
Research Methodology
Examples of
Problem Statements
http://cnx.org/content/m17223/latest/
317
318
319
320
321
323
322
324
Research Methodology
Assignment
Download an IEEE journal paper on software
programming or development. Using this paper,
answer the following questions:
Module 5
1.
2.
3.
4.
Research Proposal
326
Thisisthetruth!
Prof. Okey Ugweje
1-2
327
1-2
328
A Research Proposal
Source:PlanningandwritingyourResearchProposal,byCaroline
Malthus,Te Puna Ako LearningCentre
Prof. Okey Ugweje
329
330
331
332
Research Proposals - 1
Research Proposals - 2
333
Research Proposals - 3
A good research proposal is based on scientific
facts and on the art of clear communication
Writing a formal research proposal should be started
by the time one has decided on the topic for the study
After you have gotten the ideas, then state the
problem in writing
Design steps to solve the problems methodology
Use all related theories, methods, techniques
334
Research Proposals - 4
335
336
Research Proposals - 5
Standard Requirements
337
Title
Research question
Aim and objectives
Rationale and context
Methodology/Methods
Plan of work
Resources / Support
Ethical Issues, if any
Reference list
Appendices
Title: ____________________________
Abstract
1. Introduction
2. Statement of the Problem
3. Objectives
4. Motivation
5. Justification
6. Methodology
7. Contribution of Research
8. Outline of Thesis
338
339
340
Abstract
Examples
Pulse, Echos, and Goo
vs
The Applicability of Ultrasound in Determining Mechanical
Properties of Materials
Which one is good or bad?
A Comparison of Extended Surfaces
vs.
Enhancing Convective Heat Transfer using triangular and
cylindrical Extended Surfaces
Which one is good or bad?
Prof. Okey Ugweje
341
Abstract
342
Introduction
Content of Abstract
Contains essential information only it is brief!
Covers research highlights
Gives the research problem and/or main objective
of the research
Indicates the methodology /methods used
Gives an idea of the proposed findings and
conclusions
343
344
Introduction
345
346
347
348
Motivation
Limited in scope
Related to a question or sub-questions
349
350
Justification
Methodology - 1
351
352
Methodology - 2
Methodology - 3
Description of process
Proposal should include the details of all processes
to be adopted in the study
How exposures, outcome variables are going to be
measured should be described in detail
A brief description of how the data will be collected
and processed
What statistical tests of significance would be used?
Study design
Study population / Sampling specifications
Sample size needed
Instrumentation
Specific procedures
Algorithm, flowchart, .
353
354
Contribution of Research
Methodology - 4
Time Frame & Work Schedule
The proposal should include the sequence of tasks
to be performed, the anticipated length of time
required for its completion
355
356
Outline of Thesis
Results
357
358
359
360
References
361
Citing:
Shows your credibility as a researcher
Gives proper credit to authors and researchers
Protects you from accusations of plagiarism
Please use applicable approved citation/referencing
style
Any scientific proposal without citation and
references is unacceptable
Your proposal will be REJECTED if it lacks proper
and approved citation and referencing
Prof. Okey Ugweje
362
363
364
Example of a Figure
365
366
Example of a Table
367
368
369
370
Sample Outline
Sample Outline
371
372
Sample Outline
Sample Outline
373
Sample Outline
374
Sample Outline
375
376
377
378
379
380
Source:PlanningandwritingyourResearchProposal,byCaroline
Malthus,Te Puna Ako LearningCentre
Prof. Okey Ugweje
381
Research Methodology
382
Plagiarism - 1
FinallyAvoid Plagiarism
Humans are natural copiers
Paraphrase!!!
383
384
Plagiarism - 2
Plagiarism - 3
Among other things, plagiarism refers to taking
others work and representing it as if it were your
own
385
Plagiarism - 4
386
Plagiarism - 5
To avoid plagiarism:
1. Document every source for information that is not
general knowledgethis includes facts and ideas
2. Cite every time a fact or idea is used unless it is clear
that one citation is referring to a group of facts/ideas
3. If you quote material, put quotation marks around the
quoted stuff and include a page number within the
citation
4. It is alright to paraphrase material, but you still have
to cite from where the paraphrased material came
5. When in doubt, cite the source
Lineage of Ideas:
Original sources of research are all the proof we
have for some facts. Without the paper trail of
academic thought:
People could pass off incorrect ideas as facts
We would have to keep re-proving theories
Contexts that generated facts and ideas get lost
Research becomes highly inefficient as it
becomes incredibly difficult to find full
information on a topic.
387
388
Research Methodology
Congratulations!YourProposalhasbeen
accepted!!Nowwakeupanddoit!!!
Module 6
Research Report
If research was not written up, did it
really occur?
Prof.OkeyUgweje
FederalUniversityofTechnology,Minna
389
Research Reports - 1
390
Research Reports - 2
391
392
Research Reports - 3
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
Technical Report
Popular Report
401
Interim Report
402
Summary Report
403
404
406
407
408
4. You will not be able to write the final report out first time
Reports may be rewritten a number of times before it
reaches completion
Plan for at least 2 iteration of your research report
Do not be discouraged when the first draft is not perfect.
Prof. Okey Ugweje
409
410
411
412
413
Middle:
Describe how activity was performed and what was
found
End:
Summarize - tell what it means
Did you meet goals, recommendations, difficulties,
414
Beginning:
Discuss the activity and why activity is important provide context
7. Methodology
8. Results and Discussion
9. Conclusions
10. Reference List
11. Appendices
416
Front Pages
Abstract
Intro
Narrow to focus
of report
Results
Discussion
Broaden again,
relate back to beginning
Conclusions
417
Title page
Signature Page
Declarations
Letter of Transmittal
Dedications
Acknowledgement
Abstract / Executive Summary
Table of Contents
List of Figures
List of Tables
Glossary/Acronyms
Abstract
418
419
Copyright:
Thiel 2009 Minna
Federal
UniversityDavid
of Technology,
Copyright:
Thiel 2009 Minna
Federal
UniversityDavid
of Technology,
Copyright:
Thiel 2009 Minna
Federal
UniversityDavid
of Technology,
Copyright:
Thiel 2009 Minna
Federal
UniversityDavid
of Technology,
Copyright:
Thiel 2009 Minna
Federal
UniversityDavid
of Technology,
Copyright:
Thiel 2009 Minna
Federal
UniversityDavid
of Technology,
426
Introduction
Federal
Copyright:
UniversityDavid
of Technology,
Thiel 2009 Minna
428
The Body
Literature Review
What do we know.
Methodology
Source of data
Be critical if appropriate.
429
Methodology
430
Methodology
Information needs
Research design
Research strategy
Methods
Sample
Procedure
Analysis
432
Results
Discussion
Assesses and comments on research results
Explanation for Results
Discuss the implications of your results in light of your
research objectives.
Comments on unexpected results, offering hypothesis
for them
Comparison to literature
Your research should build on existing knowledge so
refer back to the literature review
Does your research confirm previous studies? Deviate
from them?
Common error: Discussing your own findings without
any reference to existing knowledge.
433
434
Discussion
435
436
Appendices
437
438
Key Weaknesses
439
Federal
Copyright:
UniversityDavid
of Technology,
Thiel 2009 Minna
DOS
Use personal-opinion
expressions
Delete them
10
Creating Equations
Federal
Copyright:
UniversityDavid
of Technology,
Thiel 2009 Minna
Research Methodology
Federal
Copyright:
UniversityDavid
of Technology,
Thiel 2009 Minna
Thesis/Dissertation
Thedistinguishingmarkofgraduateresearch
isanoriginalcontributiontoknowledge
443
444
What is Thesis? - 1
What is Thesis? - 2
445
What is Thesis? - 3
Federal University of
Technology, Minna
446
What is Thesis? - 4
447
448
What is Thesis? - 5
What is Thesis? - 6
A Thesis is an argument
An exposition of an original piece of research
The product of an apprenticeship
Probably the largest (most self-indulgent) piece of
work youll ever do
Something that could be published:
E.g. at least one paper in a scholarly journal
but you will probably never publish the whole thesis
449
What is Thesis? - 7
450
451
452
453
454
Thesis Structure - 1
Thesis Structure - 2
455
456
Thesis Structure - 3
Thesis Structure - 4
457
Thesis Structure - 5
Front Pages
Abstract
First Chapter
Introduction
Thesis Body
Background/Literature Review/Fundamentals
Several
Methodology
Chapters
Data Presentation & Interpretation
Experiment/Simulation
Discussion of Results
Last Chapter
Summary and Conclusions
References
Appendices
Body
End
458
Beginning
AThesis
459
460
Front Pages
Title page
Signature Page
Declarations
Dedications
Acknowledgement
Abstract
Table of Contents
List of Figures
List of Tables
Acronyms
461
462
463
464
Chapter 1: INTRODUCTION
Chapter 1 of your thesis should be the expanded
version of your proposal containing the following
1.1 Introduction
1.2. Statement of the Problem
1.3. Motivation
1.4. Justification
1.5. Methodology
1.6. Contribution of Research
1.7. Outline of Thesis
465
Chapters 3, 4, 5, .
466
467
468
Visual Design
A reports visual design can make or break its
communication success
Visual Design includes:
Use of graphs and other graphics
Use of white space
469
470
Graphics:
Should be used to illustrate specific points
Should be incorporated in a way that is natural to
reports content/context
Should be explained fully in text using references
such as Fig. 1 shows
Should be cited if taken from a source
Graphics a caveat
Graphics do not speak for themselves!
For this reason, textual information should come
before graphics.
General layout should focus readers on key
information
Use white space to guide readers attention
Created through use of headings, subheadings,
and visuals
471
472
473
References/Bibliography
474
Appendices
Appendices
Derivations
Programs
Simulations
Interview transcripts
Questionnaires
Screen dump
Printouts, and previous reports
475
476
Research Methodology
Module 7
2. A journal article
3. A conference paper
Oral Research
Presentation
477
478
LearningObjectives
Explain presentation
State the features of a good presentation
Identify the elements of presentation
Itemize the tips and techniques for great
presentations
479
480
WhyGiveAPresentation?
Instruct
Lecture
Discussion
Brainstorming
Role Play
Exercises
Inform
Persuade
Educate
481
482
483
Location?
Time constraints?
Audience?
Format?
484
Build Rapport
Open Your Presentation
Present Main Points
Conclude Your Presentation
485
Number of Slides
As few as possible
Content
Contains info that people need
Structure
486
487
488
489
If persuasive
490
C
A
0 scans
128 scans
Rh123
Rh123 retention
(mean % of Fafter/Fbefore)
100
80
60
40
20
0
CMXRos
Rh123
-
0 scans
128 scans
D
100
80
60
40
20
0
Rh123 + CMXRos
491
Rh123
492
C
100
80
60
40
20
0
Rh123
-
D
1 00
80
60
40
20
0
Rh1 23 + CM XRos
Rh1 23
493
494
495
496
Rh123 retention
(mean % of Fafter/Fbefore)
100
80
60
40
20
0
Rh123
-
100
80
60
40
20
0
497
498
Decoration
Rh123
499
500
Presentation Style
Body Language
Posture
Gesture
Mannerism
Position
Enthusiasm
Vocal qualities
Projection
Body Language - 1
Projection
Modulation
Use of Text
Speed of speech and
presentation
Clarity of presentation
Use of pointing Devices
501
Body Language - 2
502
Body Language - 3
503
504
Posture
Stand upright
not hunched
505
Gestures
Mannerisms
506
507
508
Position
Enthusiasm
509
Voice Projection
510
Voice Modulation
Vocal qualities
Volume (Loudness)
indicate uncertainties
511
512
Clarity of Expression
Use of Notes
Dont read from prepared text
513
514
Speed of Speech
Dont
talk
too
slowly
515
516
Visual Aids
Speed of Presentation
517
518
Nerves
Habits
Deep breathing!
Questions
519
520
521
522
523
524
Conclusions
Research Methodology
Module 8
Publishing Your
Research
Publish or Perish
-- an old saying in the academic circles
525
526
1. Sharing Knowledge
Research costs money and those who supply the
money must get something of value in return
2. Knowledge Increase
Knowledge is the only commodity in the world that
actually increases in value and extent only when
shared. Your duty is to increase knowledge.
Through research the totality of the human body of
knowledge increases.
Human knowledge belongs to all humanity, it must be
shared and made available publicly.
527
528
Research Methodology
Journal
529
530
Journal Papers - 1
Each discipline has a number of journals where the
research findings may be published. Two categories:
1. Peer reviewed
2. Non- peer-reviewed
A peer-reviewed journal is one in which the articles
submitted for publication are reviewed by a panel of
experts peers who read and evaluate the suitability
of publication of the material
Only peer-reviewed publications are of significance
as scientific research publication
531
532
Research Methods
Journal Papers - 2
A journal should have predictable and suitable
sections with the right headings and content
organized in a logical and predictable order
Most journals do dictate or recommend a particular
structure
There are formats explicitly or implicitly for each
journal and for many types of research reporting
533
Conference Proceedings
534
Conferences Proceedings - 1
Conferences Proceedings - 2
535
536
Conferences Proceedings - 3
Conferences Proceedings - 4
537
References
[1] M. Punch, Politics and Ethics in Qualitative Research. In Denzin, N & Y
Lincoln (editors): The Handbook of Qualitative Research. CA, Sage, 1994
[2] W. S. Howell, The empathic communicator. University of Minnesota:
Wadsworth Publishing Company. 1982
[3] K-L. Thomson and R. V. Solms, Towards an Information Security
Competence Maturity Model, in Computer Fraud & Security, May 2006
[4] K-L. Thomson, R. von Solms and L. Louw, Cultivating an Organizational
Information Security Culture, in Computer Fraud & Security, October 2006.
[5] R. Klopper, The Case for Cyber Forensic Linguistics. Alternation Vol. 16,
No. 1, pp. 261-294, 2009
[6] R. Klopper and S. Lubbe, Using Matrix Analysis to Achieve Traction,
Coherence, Progression and Closure in Problem-Solution Oriented
Research Alternation Special Edition 4, 403 419, 2011
539
538