Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
9LÍNWDZQDLÍNWDeNL)LEH6¿[1
9LÍNHGU VDH7=XL{WºN NHU yWPQ eN)DPMD SDZ\D =D\ QD_NDU1 WDHGU y6[eN)D$Í
9H&9UyV)D+H&
LE6ÙDV
_ NWf QD VXLE'D WDf QD =.Qf yN+ =XL{WHºNU eN Sº=DH\ LE6ÙDV
QDPN $HÍU
96½\ yQ\ W.Q 9U
eHJDHQD V·E +\ QD_ QDLÍNHGUZ eUNP yNDQ $Í
9H& LN QD yN MDHQ =DH+DN =LGZ L{H\)U LQH\ 9HODFQD
NUHWyJHOLFUDFLUW%DHEfS½FLOW'ºPFHO9HVW7DLSyO.DL)HN'ºPy7HNPX{UD.D+H\H&_
L{H\)HULE6ÙDVeNL)$£LE6ÙDVLNQD
eNMQVd6\EDG,ZVW<V£DQ,L+HVHELE[\)DLQH\9PDUeNE£uUVU1DS¤+H\L&ODP_E£uL)=DEHOH&WDUVDUPºP
S½7HP3Df%ÐDHUUPH'<WXHOLGL&_E£uU%D[D\
y&D)¾eNL)JÀSLGH\fWD+HOÆUwNUD=DN_eNVd6\EDG,E£uHNeNLGQJÀSL)EOL&ODP_JÀSL)eUNP
eNGD LN&Xf L&O QD_ L{H\)UZ QD_ P+D68Q<Z QD_ +IDg NHU eNLGQ P+DLEH×3DUH1U PD'<HP P+D68Q< EÍ Z 6L{
f%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD_ WDUSU ',HU ',HU U<DP LPhH)6Q Z Q<DFDUDO LVHON6HQU PD'<HP E¿DfLO Z U<DPLO LELO\Q
LELO\QJ<DODL~ZJ½+Q4f%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD_$<DNÔLVHK )DLO+DfHK¾DHMQZ$L~HMQf%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD_$<DNÔLVHK )DLO
SDLQf%<OÔ%ÔNUHOD_$<DNÔLVHK )DLO9HODEDWDVf%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD_yVfVDH7$<DNÔLVHK )DLO$HQNUDVD\LQNSGDº7Z
f%<OÔ%ÔNUHOD_$<DNÔLVHK )DLOL3LMN<DOZQ<DFDUDOO<f%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD_WDUSU+IDgNHUeNLGQLPh)LEH×3DUH1U
PD'<HPyNDQeNSXNuUy7HN$<DP,EDUPHWDeNL)M,Ef%<OÔ%ÔNUHOD_WHEyVf$<DP,ED
SXUw[QDLNPL+ODQDLN},E
L&OWDMDQDyQfWDUSUyVf$<DP,EDy7HN',HU',HUU<DPLPhH)6QZQ<DFDUDOLVHON6HQUPD'<HPE¿DfLOZ
U<DPLO LPLO\QLPLO\Q S½MDLW f%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD eEd yVf VNO S½MDLWU yEcHF 7DNDU MQ< SDVDSDLV E¿DfLO Z
U<DPLO.DG<E<Zf%<OÔ%ÔNUHOD_
JÀS)D y6[ QD +HWf E£uU LU\<DNÔ6Q ÐS ÐS ÐS yKD ) NL )LQh LGV NDf $E J½<DPD yÐDLU ef 'UHQU
9MLENDL+Q,yWDHNyNÆQDHODyU"
ZH\OeNQDLÍNE£u_
yWDUE£uyWDyGL.yJ½)ÔLELO%DU$E$<DNÔLVHK )yNDH\QÔLVHK VFD VE¿Df$<DU<DPS½HVV
ZH\OWD+HOeN)DyN2WXNy6DQ_FDUE£uLQMLQMyG6LQH\JºENUH&
9HPLUNDQE£u MDLQV9PDHGUyG6QDePQeNL)yPL6Q9LEÉDUNHUH&y=)DLNQDeHNEDHUyPH*UhSULGH\
=D\^eHUDHS¿Q`
MDºPDQE£u 9HUyPH*UhSULGH\=DZ\D)De=XHJ9UQWXQN,"9PDHGUyG6ePQeNL)yPL6Q9LEÉDUNHUH&
y=)DLNQDeNGPVDJHUUQ,HFLGH\=D\^VDEÔHPLUQ`
fL\DQE£u yWDHGUPHWD9PDHGUyG6$W)Dh¤WLN&X QDNUHWSDUHOZWDUDeNL)yPL6Q9LEÉDUNHUH&=DU
eNLGNLGH\LKP]XLNH\LGHO$SULGNLGH\+cDVPXULJyELUH\9HV^fQÔLNhHE)U`
EDdODHG6,E£u ZH\OyWDUDyWD%DONHUfMDLQVy=9PDHGUyG6.XEfJU,EyPH*UhSUEDVDJHUUQ,HFLGH\
=DZ\DUPHWDyPL6QRWU,UyNDQfVDPº7<yQf9U9Í LKPfEDSDHEyND7Dy7HN"WHEWDUDeNL)LUVD\L}dyPL6Q
9LEÉDUNHUH&=DUeNLGNLGH\yUÐuHUH )UhL&Ë+D5+DL]XLNH\LGHO$Q<LGNLGH\%c<D%c<D+D¶D+D¶DNUHW
NUHWJUw&DJOy%5D+cDVPXULJy7HNÆUwNHUePQLNPDQX[Sº=¡yELUH\9HV^f%<OX6QyPL6Q`
Keyword: Billions of Deterministic Processes
eEDUP8OS½VHt9VD=DN
JD'DUGDL5yQfLN¡JD'DPDQX[Q\
9fQÐDfHQUZGDL5yQfVXWUDd9fQÐDfQZPDQX[Q\JD'D
y%5DUJDH\S6P9H&LN¡y%5DPDQX[Q\
LQh)HQUJDH\ZS6P9H&VXWUDdLQh)QZPDQX[Q\y%5D
e%DHEGDL5
EDS6P
HNPDSNDLI'HUhSVd+DU)DQHOE<DSDU)DyNPQ+HEeNEDUy%HEG<D.LQÅF\%\DE+UNHPU
yILUEOLINLNQD_LN&X DQ,ZV0Dº)yODNMQZEDUEDUeNfUNHPUyILUEO%XONHU=DH&Q_$º7DgWDUDLE6ÙDVHN
PDSNDLI'HUP+DhSVd+DUK¾<NUH&Q_y=PQ
y*D5DULKHPLE6ÙDVeNL)$£LE6ÙDVLN¡y*D5DULKPEHOLN&XQDf
%8WÔyS½HWLE6ÙDVeNL)$£LE6ÙDVLN¡%8WÔyS½WÔEHOLN&XQDf
fhLQNHºQLE6ÙDVeNL)$£LE6ÙDVLN¡fhLQNºQEHOLN&XQDf
nL{H\)HULE6ÙDVZeNL)$£LE6ÙDVVXWUDdL{H\)UEHOZLN&XQDfCreator does not exist
eEDUWXffEOyNDQU<D6QDOPDQX[LNQD¶DULE6ÙDHVUVDH7nQD¶DULE6ÙDVHNLOH\y3OHEQEHOPHQ
+\_LOH\y3OD)DLNU<D6QDLOL)UFUPV,PDEWDHNfS½ND6NUHEQD_eyWDyGL.$<DHSHOUVDH7$HUHUWXOQDU
yFH\ZyE6,yILUEOP8ODUVDH7NODUWXOQDZPHQ+\$HQNyE6,=XL{V´PWeHTEDHUPDNDO3HOUVDH7о<HELUU
WXOQD+H\yJOQD
$HQHNy%HEEDQDy%HESXQ:SXQ:eNL)9ªEDN<9hL5H\=D\efEHOy=9UG6)DLE6ÙDHVUPWL{H\)HULE6ÙDVZ
eNL)$£LE6ÙDVeN)X9')XLF¡DNUDyWDG8HU7DN$£LE6ÙDVND+DHNEHOWD+Dy=PQMDQDUS½H\DMQPHQNHUQD
yWPLQ9EDUPDQX[HNMDQDHQDUS½H\DMQZyED'NHUQD_PDQX[WD+HON,%DHEEX-HE$£LE6ÙDVND+DHNEHO"LQHP¢U
SH\ )HOD9HJLEHEFQDNHUG<D.
yFDH.UVDPHQffQ3DfQDf)eNL)P+D68Q<9H&Where did the Space come from?_
yVfP+D68HQ<UPH'<S½D\fQ3DfQDf)VPWXO<EÍ Z6L{9H&Where did the energy and matter come from?
Did they evolve from nothingness?_
LELO\QLELO\QJ<DODL~ZJ½+Q49H&Did they evolve too?_
LPLO\QLPLO\QS½MDLW9H&Did they Really evolve blindly and randomly?_
S½HW<NS½MDLWUPH'<9EDULELFUNHPUNDODU3uOhSS½MDLW9H&_
LELF'UHQULPLO\QLPLO\QNDODU3uOhLG6V<Z3OP8O9H&Did they also evolve?_
LEDQ,UDe.QSº=¡Z68Q<y7HNLN&XV¼LËNUHWV4P+\LQ_
LEDQ,UDe.QSº=¡ZLQºM,EEÍy7HNVDPDQ<eNL)M,EZV¼LËNUHWV4P+\LQ_
LEDQ,UDLN&XL3LMN<DOZQ<DFDUDOO<9LEÉDUNHUH&QWhere did the laws come from? Did they evolve?_
NDº=NDU1 V8HU S½FLOW eNL) =XL{ (a) Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its existence; (b) The
Universe began to exist; (c) Therefore, the Universe has a cause of its existence.
Keyword: Billions of Deterministic Processes
LEJE<Dd W® $QX=D\, ef Q<DFDUDO P+DLEH6ÙU eNL) ÆUw 9H&_ ef W® 9LEÉDHUU 9J Sº=¡ EÍEDG, QDLÍN
GDº6LQNUD P+DLE6ÙHN LFUÍÓD\, EHO LE6ÙDV NUHWQ_ LÐH3Q +LNd .XE yMDU LGH\ QD +HOZ EHOH&Q y= y=H+WX
P+DLEH6ÙUÆUw9H&yVH+WX P+DLEH6ÙUEDL+Uy7HNP+DLE6ÙHNV¼LËNUD+H\H&_e.DHQLÐH3Q+LNdeNL)V·DEQD
Cause L+HVHE L{H\)HUU S½LW $tXLO LQHºG6 NHUH&Q_ $HQHN +\W EOHW SDHUQ NDU1 &D5DZ LN&X LN&X *)QD
*)HWSDHU_+c<D+\WSDHU_LN¡ WDULNyNDQREDLQNS½PD19H&"9ULEJE<Ddy=yNDQNDU1&D5Df*H)H&
WDUfEDS½PD1LN"WD&D5DS½N»LWHWy=H+WX yE6,U%DJ*)QDUyS&HQfNDU17DHNyVfL%hSH\ )y7HNLEJE<Dd
eU yS&HQZ NDU1 7DNDU V·DEQDf yE6,_ NDU1 L+HVHE yN+ $<DNÔLVHK )Z 'HU LQHW SDHUQ LN¡ yV)D NW)XNu
VH¡D[MQN Z =XL{V´PW +HE" LEJE<Dd $º7 +H& P+DLEH×3DU1 What exploded and what triggered the Big-
Bang_yNDQUNPLQ\¡1&D5DfyNDQLN&X LEH×3DLUW+H\FDLULGHNLEL&¤%DHE&L5H\SH5SXQUD\eNLW+H\
LELO\QLELO\QJ<DODL~ZJ½+Q4RWU,+Z\DUV·DEQDNW)XNu"yNQZN,%DHEfEDefP+DLE6ÙV´S½VDU1NUHOD
eEde.QZNUH&"
LEJE<DdeUSUM,EV¼LËNUHWNH\NLELO\QE&UODJDHWQDLÍNUDL{H\)UHN$OVJK
EHOVPDHODFQDNHU
7DHNQ_L{H\)U=LG)DfPy×SVKDfHPQ6Qy7HNÑD',Q+\yVH4HVP\
S½VteNGPf$ED¡U_
LEDQ+H&LEDQ,HGUf9LEɻWV,LPWeNL))XO_LEDQLQHMy7HNy=PQLN&XNUHWSDHUQDyWPLQ9EDULN&X
V¼LËZNUHWSDHUQD_LEDQ,UDef)XOHNE<E+DUNHUV¼LËULN&X yPNDLQMPHNREDLQN%DHEE<D.<DNHUQPD_
V¼LË &D5D f%<OX6QZ LN¡ eNGPf $ED¡U_ LN&X eN)D y7HN f%<OX6Q ÆUw +HW +HE_ y=.DHQ LN&Xf QDf yV.DHQ
f%<OX6HQUS½6¢f9HVQD_VXWUDd9HJV¼LËSHUf%<OX6Q_f%<OX6QEDy=yNDQW®%XOEDVLINS½PDL1W+Z\DU
VDH7LN¡ L{H\)HUU$LÍW® ED$QLÍHW®UZyNDQV´SºNQDf_=LGZLN&X QDLÍNf%<OX6QW®HNL{H\)HUULENÀS
W®L+HVHELE6ÙDVNHUQy=)DVLW<f+DV<NU
S¼L7E,UyJDOHW®UPHWDeNL)S½LWLÌWVHW<UVDH7f%<OX6QWH®UWXOQD9UUD1,eLOMDHE7EXL5UVDH7FcDHGU
EXL5UWXOQDS½D\VPDQ_9My7HNLPLO\QLPLO\QE&U9HJS¼L7E,U9NDU=DL&O9MZLINWDfUH\yJH&_
yN+S¼L7E,UyJDOW®HN$Ñ,NDUNUHOWDHNSU,4DP8ON%DHES½PD1yG.DHQDZV·E_LN¡yN+LN$<DP,EDUPWS½D1,
y7HNÆUwNHULPLO\QLPLO\QS½MDLW+H\PDQX[Sº=¡ f%<OX6HQULVQDLUZSU,4DP8ON%DHEyG.DHWSDUHE"WDZ
9EDU E¿Df Z U<DP f%<OX6HQU y4H LN&X JHE[N $LW VDPDQ< U<DP QPXQDU hSU L%L NHU hSVd+DU K¾<
NUH&Qy=HODyPD)WH7<UWXOQD\LN&XfQD_
=LGZS½7PM,ENHEyND7D\ZN,%DHEf%<OÔ%ÔNHUH&WDUyNDQVGXUe.QSº=¡ZLEDQ,HGU+DHWyQfW7DLS
'HUyQZ\D=DNy=$<DP,EDUPHWDeNL)M,Ey7HNNDHUD+ÍH4S&D5Df9SQD9SLQf%<OÔ%Ô NUHWNUHWPDQXH[
eHVyIHNH&WDUSUZ+DMDHUDS½6¢ y7HN=D\_y=PQS½7PM,EyNDQÔ LOHtUL&O"yV.DHQDy7HNSXdLOtZÍ,LOt
NHEyNQZN,%DHEf%<OÔ%ÔNUHOD"S½HW<NL)S½MDLWUSXdLOtZÍ,LOteNVDH7QDLN9HJSHUf%<OÔ%ÔNHUH&"
RMLEN FDL+GD S8U1 Z Ed6LEÍDHUU MQ<f LN SXdLOt Z Í,LOt f%<OÔ%Ô NHUH&" PDQX[ Z SÆHGU $HND[ yNQ Z
N,%DHEf%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD"S½D1,UEd6LEÍDHUUMQ<WDHGUPH'<yNQZN,%DHEÆ{DQX ZLK¶DQX f%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD"eHN
$SHUUS½LW9Nº[1fEDyNQZN,%DHEf%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD"U{FODFHOUMQ<$LWV840L6UDhSL6UDyNQZN,%DHE
f%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD"U{fEDyNQZN,%DHEf%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD"S½7PM,HEULNyNDQ3LVO9H&"WDULINSHUUM,E
yNDQÔL)" S½D1,HGU S½H\DMHQf LN .DG< f%<OÔ%Ô NHUH& QDLN hOÔH)D)D" .DHG<U S½H\DMHQf LN PX. V+ KDfHMLÐ%
LVHÐP f%<OÔ%Ô NHUH& QDLN hOÔH)D)D" yG.DU S½H\DMHQf LN F4u f%<OÔ%Ô NHUH& QDLN LESU,W)D" 6ÙDVS½6ÙDHVU
S½H\DMHQfLNQDVDU£¾ f%<OÔ%Ô NHUH&QDLNLESU,W)D"yNQfED6ÙDVS½6ÙDHVUGUNDU+HOD"y6DQDUMQ<fLNNº1
f%<OÔ%Ô NHUH&QDLNhOÔH)D)D"$VDUEÍ 6U,Uy7HNyEUNHUyGZ\DUMQ<fLNSD\X S7ZPXQDLOf%<OÔ%Ô NHUH&
QDLN LESU,W)D" fW<DLG fW<DLG fW<DLG eUNP +DMDHUD UwW®S8º1 S½H6¢U hU yGZ\D LEDQ,HGU SH4 eNGPf
$V·E
yV½3NDGDSDLQy7HNyNDQUNPLQ\L¡WO<&D5DfLPLO\QLPLO\Q'UHQUU{PDdHVUJ5DEXLPDQM,EM¡ZN,)
SWtV+hLG3OP8O6V<fW<DLGE¿DfLOZU<DPLOf%<OÔ%ÔNHUH&Z+ÔPDfJVPDQXH[ULE6ÙDHVUE+UyGH.
VLW<f$EDN+HW+\
QDLÍNUD EHO 7DHNQLEDQ QDLN JKeU J<DS
S8U1NUH&_9LP LN¡ ef E{HE<U VDH7eNGPf eNPW Qf_
LEDQPDQXH[US½FLOWLE6ÙDHVULN&X LN&X J<DSS8U1NUHWSDHU_WHES½HW<NL)REDLQN9LEÉDHUUPD'<HPLN&X
$MDQDW7<y=PQhHQ0DLFW+\yWPLQ9EDU$HQNQWXQQWXQJ<DHSUZV¼LË+\_=WE5LEDQ,WcDUNDH&LN¡
WWfJ<DSyE6,WHE=DUDLQHMHGUHNV,PDES½H6¢UJLUPH'<9EUD.HWFD\WDHGUN7D9ODGD_VW<EOHW
LNLEDQLN¡QDLÍNHGULE6ÙDHVUJ<DSZS8U1NUH&_
Keyword: Billions of Deterministic Processes
efP+DLE6Ù)DÆ'XfE¿DfZU<DP$<DNÔLVHKH )U3OD3O+HO$HQNfH% )LELO\QLELO\QE&U'HULQº'DLUW%DHE
DeterministicallyUDQNUDUN7DQD_y=PQV¼LËUÆUwy7HNLPLO\QLPLO\QE&U'HUeSº=¡ eNL)S½D1,ZyEcHF
7DHNLQ_VXWUDd.XEyMDULGH\fEOD=D\y=P¼WX<eNL)'½wEVW<_$QXUxS%DHEP+DLEH6ÙUÆUwy7HNLELO\QLELO\Q
E&U'HU LELO\QLELO\Q J½+Q4LQM LQM $H4 VXHED' EDOHNU PHWD*XUH& eNL) eQDLºM"LEH×3DLUW +H\
SDLº)NOHODFDLULGHN&L5H\SH5SXQUD\eNLW+H\y&D)y&D)EORWU,NHULQMLQM$H468HQ<y*DUDÆUwNHU
QDLN"Z+Ô PDfJVeyNDQÔ LEDQyNQZN,ePQ6L{EHO*XUH&y=eNGPf7DPH&QDVXWUDd.XEyMDULGH\f
LE[\L)HNeNL)LK)DULPLQLÐNS½HVVEODy=HWSDHU_LN&XU<DPS½HVVZ7DNHWSDHU_=DH+DNyNDQUNPLQ\¡1
&D5DfLELO\QLELO\QE&U'HU$HQNS½HVVLQº'DLUW%DHEUDQNUDU9HG2LNyNDQV·DEQD9H&"
LEDQ,UDEHOQODf33ºPNUDUMQ<QDLNLEH6[
eNL)SLUHEH6UGUNDU_$º7Dgy=yNDQSLUHEH6ODf33ºP
NUHWSDHUQD_9My7HNLPLO\QLPLO\QE&U9HJeNL)LEH6[SLUHEH6
QDLNODf33ºPNHUH&_WDUPDHQ
LE[\L)LK)DULPLQLÐN_U<DP+HOy=yNDQSLUHEH6y=yNDQVP\ODf33ºPNUDUN7D_
9My7HNNH\NG6N9JSº=¡ZLEDQ,HGU DNA-eUJIQS½1DO,V´SHºNyWPQyNDQ'DU1DL&OQD_LN¡ 9M
DNA-eU$W<¡ ML)OJIQS½1DO,ZM,HEU9HUDLN&X WH7<UhSUL%LNHULE[\L)HN$HQHNfE¿DfZU<DP
f%<OX6HQU3OD3OEHOyPHQLQHWSDUH&QQD_
PDQXH[ULEL%¤fL \yNQZN,%DHEf%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD" DNA E¼LUVDH7fL \E¼LUV´SºNfEDN,"$W<¡ SLUÉDU
y=DNA W7<E+QNDU,eNL)FDONL+HVHENDMNHU_S½HW<NPDQXH[UDNAQDLNfhLQN$º7DgNDHUDVDH7NDHUD
LPOyQf_VLW<feeNLEV0\WDf=LG+\yVH4HLQ:VH GH+eL)eNL)LK)DULPLQLÐNLE[\_yEDEDNDOD$£
Q<DFDHUUSH4ef'UHQUfhLQNZLK)DULPLQLÐNLVHON6QVLW<f+DV<NU_VELN&XfE¿DfZU<DP+HOef
$VD'DU1fhLQNÔHQVEMD\7DNDUN7DQD_PDQXH[UL3tDULS½H )Uy4HZeNf=XL{S½H=DM<_
Æ'X WDfQ\VELN&XfE¿DfZU<DP+HOPDH-PH'<PDQXH[UyS)y7HNPDL
&DJOy%5DfW<DLGUEDFD$7ED
PDL
&DJO y%5D fW<DLGU yS) y7HN PDQXH[U EDFD yEU +H\ 9VDU N7D WD LN¡ +H& QD_ $º7Dg S½HVVHODU
yS&HQ eNL) ÑDW LQ\L¡W6L{ NDMNUDUV·DEQDfyE6,_3HOf%<OX6Q W® =LG VW<Z+\yVH4HyV)DHN
E¿DfZU<DPS½HVVEOD)DeNGPf$H=2L{N_f%<OX6QPHQ+\QDLÍNHGULGHNEXHPUDd+H\fy'H\=DH&
yN+ LN N.HQD ÆHQH&Q y= 9P JDH& +IDg NHU MDP 'HUH&" NFX JDH& LOFX" $<DHSO JDH& NcDIDO" NuP5D JDH&
MD¶XUD" -Dh JDH& ODh" SDQ JDH& 'DQ" P8OD JDH& NOD" QD WDU PDHQ eHOD VEf LK)DULPLQLÐN S½HVV_ 9U
LK)DULPLQLÐNS½HVHVLQ\L¡W6L{US½6¢9VD)DfÑD%DLEN_
M,EMJHWU LGHNZ V840%DHE G¼LË LGHO WDHGU 6DU,LUN JIHQU PH'< eN)D fhLQ3LºPL) O4< NUD =D\_ VELN&Xf
E¿DfZU<DP+HOG,º*LGQ'HUeffhLQ3LºPL)EMD\7DNDUN7DQD_LN&XLN&XS½D1,UyOHMUPD7D\eNHJD&DyN6
yNQ ZN,%DHE f%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD y=.DHQ $Q<DQ< S½D1,HGU yQfSÆSDL.HGUL6d ZLM+ED yNQZ N,%DHEf%<OÔ%Ô
NUHODLMUDH3UJOD$HWDO¶DyNQeNfSÆSDL.UJDH\eNDL'NNDODUfEDyNQZN,%DHEf%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD
S½HW<NL)S½D1,UMHQ0USUJ½<DMX\DLOyEH5ZIDy7HNÆUwNHUWDHGUJLWS½N»LWM,EQ=DSQS½1DO,ZEXLPDU
LGHNV840%DHEG¼LËLGHOZPHQ+HEy=QWDUDyNDQÑDW6L{DUDSLUFDLOWeEdyNDQQDyNDQ%DHEy)¾LQdS½Dª
eHODHNÆ'XfE¿DfZU<DPEHOLE6ÙDVNUD)DfyNQMDLQE¿DfEHOPHQ+\
E<LW{P yNV &D5D S¼L7E,U S½HW<NL) MDLWU PH'< =LG VP,4D FDODHQD +\ WD+HO yG.D =DHE y= QDU,HGU WXOQD\
SXUw[UDhFWD\yE6,eEdyVfVDH7yE6,6L{6DO,ZVD+V,_ePQLNyE6,hFWDUQDU,UDZSXUw[HGUWXOQD\NP
6L{6DO,ZVD+V,_LE[\)DHNLK)DULPLQLÐNPHQ+\QD"f%<OX6QW® eLE[H\N,EHO"U<DPf%<OX6QZQDU,
SXUwH[UPH'<LK)DULPLQLÐN<DLORE[P<P8ON9FU1NHUQDLN
S¼L7E,HWM,EMJHWUf%<OX6HQUSDVDSDLV.DG<E<Zf%<OÔ%ÔNHUH&$Q<DQ<J½H+y=PQM,EM¡yQfyWPLQ9EDU
yNDQ .DG<E<ZyQf VXWUDd×SËWf yG.D =DH& y=M,EMJgZ .DG<E<eHN $SHUUVDH7$tDLt%DHEML5W_
LE[\)DHNeN)DVXSLUNÀSQDEHOPHQ+\QD"Q<DFDUDO.DG<HE<UPH'<LEL%¤L%)DLPQZLPQDHUOyNQZN,%DHE
f%<OÔ%Ô NUHOD"yNDQSDJHOZLNLE6ÙDVNUHEy=LPLO\QLPLO\Q3OP8OZ6V<hLGeNL)E,My7HNf%<OÔ%Ô
NHUH&" WD&D5D S½7P E,Mf ED 9VHOD yND7D y7HN" yNDQ JD'DZ LN LE6ÙDV NUHE y= LWOJD& y7HN WDOJD&
f%<OÔ%Ô NHUH&*DVy7HNE)JD&f%<OX6HQU9HODHN$<DHSOZNcDIDHOUPH'<yNDQV´SºN9H&LN"9H.U
VDH7WUPXHMUfEDN,V´SºN=LGZGXH)DHWfSDLQ9H&yV½3Q<DFDUDOLVHON6HQUPD'<HPeHODf%<OÔ%Ô NUD
LN9HG2V·E"
Keyword: Billions of Deterministic Processes
S½7PW: *L5U
NDLUJHUULSWD7DNHOP+DLEH6ÙUNDLUJHUUZy=LSWD7DNHWf+HEeN7DyNEHOH&"E<LW{PyNVLN7DNHW
SDHUQD_LW,\W:QDLÍNUDy=f%<OX6QWH® LE6ÙDVNHUyVfW® LGH\fyWDWDHGUef=XL{HNV+HMf'UD6D\,
NUD=D\_f%<OX6QW® $QX=D\,S½7PM,EQDLNyNDQLSWDPDWD&D5Dff%<OÔ%Ô "NHUH&QDLÍNUDefVW<
HN
V+HMfyPHQLQHWSDUHOL{H\)HUUy4HeNfVW<
yPHQLQHWSDUH&QQDyNQ
QDLÍNHGU 9HUNL) =XL{ S¼L7E,HW LEL%¤ LMLQHVU y=H+WX 9ODGD9ODGD NDLUJU 9H& yVH+WX Q<DFDUDO
EÍJXHODUZ 9ODGD9ODGD NDLUJU 7DNHW +HE_
*XPHN%DºFX\DLOP¼W$EÍÓD'UD+\_efy=eNL)LQLËVP\*XHPUSUPDQX[Ñ\dL{\%DHESXQ:SXQ:yFWQSD\yV)D
LN yNDQf VdHNW E+Q NHU QD" ÑS¢HNZ U+V<P\ LN&X eN)D VdHNW EHOf PHQ +\_ %DºFX\DLO P¼W $EÍÓD\ G8U
G8UDH¡ULVQDLUZN,%DHEyG.DV·E_N,%DHEyFDH.USOHNeNMD\JDy7HN9HUNMD\JD\=DZ\DV·E_N7DEDD
eEdLEL%¤*)QDfEDN,%DHEV0U1UD.DV·E
eNL)L6ÆPDH\UySH)PDH\UyS)HN'UD=DNS½7PP+DLE6Ù_eU9HJZyNDQP+DLE6Ù9H&LNQDyNMDHQ7DND
$EÍÓD\N.HQDLNÑHS¢ZNÀSQDNUHWSDHUy=PDNH\NÎ\DUyVL )LP)DUMD\JDUEDL+HULE6DOeNh\DDU3uO
LW,\ P+DLE6Ù $HS4DNUH&" =DUD fHWDPH'< PDH\U$£NDUyS) y7HN yELUH\ 9HODLNW LW,\ P+DLEH6Ù SGDºSQ
NHUH& WDHGU NDH& e.Q S½7P P+DLE6Ù eNL) W7<_ yVf WH7<U hSU L%L NHU yN+ =LG 9HUD $HQN yE6,
h\DDU3uO W¼W,\ eNL) P+DLE6Ù $QXPDQ NHU yVf $QXPDQ $EH6H[ %XO ED VLIN y= yNDQL) +HW SDHU LN¡
$H=2L{NEDE¿Df+HEyNQ"NDU1ef$QXPDQyWDeNL)WH7<UhSUL%LNHU_
EDÍE MJHWU LN&X LN&X LE[\VLIN%DHE E<D.<DNUD=D\QDy=PQMDVÔL)VÔ_WHE =DUD MDVÔL)VÔ eL5H\y=HWFD\
WDHGUN7D9ODGD_'UD=DNeNMQ.XQ,eN+DMDUMQPDQX[HN+W<DNUHOD_ef+W<DUMDVÔL)VÔ N,%DHENUD
V·E"EDÍEMJHWyVf.XQ,HNE5HMDUeNEDUPD+W<DNUDV·E_WD+HOfLNMDVÔL)VÔ +H\=DHE"WD&D5DP¼W
PDQX[HGUM,LEWNUDZyWD$V·ES½FLOWLQ\HPy=)DNUD+\yV)D+H&eN'UH1U4LWS8U1MDVÔL)VÔ Q\_9U
.XQ,HN=LGLFL+{WNUDQD=D\yVH4HfEDN,+HE"eUNP9HUD$HQNLE[\9H&_
V<DU9fM<DNLQh)HQUeNL)hL{ The most beautiful system of the sun, planets, and comets, could only
proceed from the counsel and dominion on an intelligent and powerful Being.
V<DU¬<DQÔLVVE<DNQEHOQ It is true, that a little philosophy inclineth man’s mind to atheism, but depth in
philosophy bringeth men’s minds about to religion; for while the mind of man looketh upon second causes
scattered, it may sometimes rest in them, and go no further; but when it beholdeth the chain of them
confederate, and linked together, it must needs fly to Providence and Deity.
$<DNÔLVHK )DLO ODf3 3ºPNUDUE<DSDHU UMDU ySQÔHUDMQDHPU eN E¼L)6 P<DH7HPL)L6\DQ EHOQ This now tells
123
how precise the Creator’s aim must have been, namely to an accuracy of one part in 1010 . This is an
extraordinary figure. One could not possibly even write the number down in full in the ordinary denary
notation: it would be 1 followed by 10123 successive 0’s. Even if we were to write a 0 on each separate proton
and on each separate neutron in the entire universe- and we could throw in all the other particles for good
measure- we should fall far short of writing down the figure needed.
LE.<DW yM<DLWHºED NDºO V<DJDQ EHOQ An [dogmatic] atheist is someone who is certain that God does not
exist, someone who has compelling evidence against the existence of God. I know of no such compelling
evidence. Because God can be relegated to remote times and places and to ultimate causes, we would have to
know a great deal more about the universe than we do now to be sure that no such God exists.
LE.<DWGDº6LQNVH{L)VyS¿H)DZ$<DLUÐ)OZV·EW:L{H\)HULE6ÙDV,L&HOQ_=XHJ=XHJLN&X %DEÔEDG,P+DPDQE
L{H\)HUU y&cD\D hSOL² NUDU GDE, NHUH&Q_ WcDHGU PH'< VEDf LP7<DEDG, +Z\DU V·DEQD LQÅF\ $HQN NP_
eH4HLN¡eNMQVW<EDG,+Z\Df=H7Ì
MHQ0US8HºEyND7DZL&ODPLNQDP¼WX<USUfEDyND7D\=DHEDLE[\GXL)e.QSº=¡ZU+V<S8º1fUH\yJH&_M,LEW
ZP¼WPDQXH[UPH'<y=LN&X eN)DSDº7N<9H&'UD=DN XyV)DVEDfeNEDHN<Ñ,NDUNUHWED'<_JL1HWU
VP,NUH1UVD+DH=<SDº7N<)De%DHELO.Dy=HWSDHU
M,LEWPDQX[ P¼WPDQX[M5EÍX
=DUDLE6ÙDVNHUP¼WX<USUM5EÍ&D5D9ULN&Xf$EL6Ë7DHNQDWDHGUy4HX-eUPDQ+HE68Q<eEDUX-eU
PDQVP,NU1eELVH\LGH\LO.D=D\
M,LEWPDQX[ P¼WPDQX[
efLE6ÙDV$QX=D\,VP,NU1LN¡ y+DOÔKÔ NHUQDP¼WX<UVDH7VDH7 X-eUPDQ68Q<+H\=DZ\DLNV·E"6L{U
LQW<WDV8$QXVDHUyNDQLN&XUf'¯dVEDLEQD6QDfÆ'XeN$EÍÓDy7HN$Q<$EÍÓD\UxSD¡LUW+\_3HOM5EÍ
QD+\RMEVDHUUxSD¡LUW+HODLN¡ X-eUN,+HE" X yWDyNDQEÍ QDy=yV)DZRMEVDHUUxSD¡LUW+HE_ X
WD+HOyND7D\=DHE"yNDQQDyNDQ$EÍÓD\y7HN=DHELQÅF\_
Keyword: Billions of Deterministic Processes
L{H\)UHN eL5H\ =DZ\DU MQ< QDLÍNUD $W<¡ y=2L{N eNL) S½6¢HN yN26HO +DZ\D NHU LGHW FD\_ 'UD =DN
eNMQ LEDQ, $MDQD eN MD\JDHW y=H\ eNL) yPL6Q yG.HW ySHOQ_ .XE ÑD%DLEN%DHEf LEDQ,U PHQ GXL)
UwW®S8º1S½H6¢UhG\+HEyPL6QL)U9LEɺWDyNyPL6QL)N,%DHENDMNHU_QDLÍNUDLEDHQUyGD+D\
LGH\QD¶DUS½6¢HNy=)DyE6,UwW®S8º1yEPDOXPQDf
NHULGHWFD\_LEDHQUEDL+HUyNDQS½H6¢ QD=DZ\DPDHQ
LN¡LEDQHNfSHUD4%DHEJKL+HVHEyPHQyQZ\D
'UD=DNeNMQLEDQ,eNL)fH )LOHM )yUDE)ZeNL)yPL6QRWU,NUHOQ_eEDUyUDE))D=LGLEDQ,y7HN
VUDVLUyNDQVD+D=<QDLQH\ZyPL6HQUNDº=S½1DO,yPD)DPXL)%DHEE<D.<DNUHWV4P+\WD+HOfLNLEDQ,U$LÍW®
QDf
+H\=DHE"WD+HOfLNyUDE)ZyPL6HQUhSULEDQ,U+ÍH4S+DZ\D+H\=DHE"WDLN¡ yPDH)ZQDyNDQ
eNL)yPL6HQUNDº=S½1DO,REDLQN%DHEE<D.<DNUHWSDUDPDHQefQ\y=yVfyPL6HQUyNDQyPNDUyQf
QDLÍNUD9UZEHOQL3LMN<DOO<LGH\y=.DHQVELN&X E<D.<DNUDV·EyV.DHQL{H\)UeNL)$LWLU{6±_
e.DHQZLEDHQUZMULGH\S½6¢HNeL5H\=DZ\DUS½E1WD_S½7PW:3DfQDf))XOLGH\fQ3DfQDf)HNE<D.<DNUD
$V·E_ LW,\W: L3LMN<DO O<f ED N,%DHE f%<OÔ%Ô " NUHOD yV S½H6¢ y=HWZ WDUD f&XN Q\_ WD&D5D
SGDº7LEDHQUyNDQV8HN O*Q QDNHU efP+DLE6ÙHNE<D.<D NUHWSDUHOf LN L{H\)UQDf
+H\ =DHE" WDUD
y=)DEX-HWFD\QDyV)D+H&e)DEUdL{H\)U7DNDUfVX×SË9ODPW_L{H\)Uy7HN7DNHOLWLQfyWDL3LMN<DO
ZQ<DFDUDOO<y7HNÆUwNHUVELN&X V¼LËNHUH&Q_3HOL{H\)HUUV¼ËO<LGH\WDUfV¼LËHNE<D.<DNUHWSDUDU
PH'<$ÑD%DLENLN&XyWDyGL.QD_E<DSDU)DhOÔH)D+HOfEUdQDLÍNHGUeNL)SH\ )L&O
yN+yN+9EDULQHMHGUVD¡®QDLGH\9HEHJUVXHUEHO7DHNQLEDQ',HU',HUeNLGQVNOS½H6¢UhU.cXHM
yEUNUHEf_
=LGZ$V·EW7DLS=XL{U.<DLWHU'HUyQZ\D=DNy=N7DL)VW<_LN¡ SLUWDHSULE[\+H&=DUD
ePQN7DEHOQWDUDyWD9UyVVP\yEcHF7DNHEQQDQ<DFDUE5fyEULVNWDfQD3HOWDUDN,%DHEMDQHEQ
y=LEDQVLW<VLW<VNOS½H6¢UhU.cXHMyEUNHUH&LEDQ=LGE<º7+\WD+HON,+HEePQZyWD+HWSDHU
y= LEDQf eNVP\ L{H\)UHN 9LEÉDU NHU y3HOH& WD+HO" $WeE QDLÍNUD LN¡ fU<D6QDO LE6ÙDV LQH\f
S¼L7E,UEXNy7HNLFUWHU
LEGD\LQH&Q
eNMQE5LEDQ,ZWcDUM,E6D\=DMDQHWV4PWDefP+DLEH6ÙU$MDQDWH7<US½D\68Q<%DHJUND&DNDL&ef
$EÍÓD\ LQHMHN QDLÍN y*D[1D yGZ\DU yFH\ E5 fU<D6QDLOL) 9U LW,\L) yQf Atheism is the Maximum
irrationality possible_
LELO\QLELO\QJ½H+UPH'<eNPDS¼L7E,HWS½DH1UV¼LËLQH\$HQHNL{H\)HUUG4WDHNZVPDHODFQDNHU7DHNQ_
VPV<D+H&LQHMHGULE6ÙDVLQH\yN+V+HMVd6\S½ND6NHUQDefVPDHODFQDLN¡WDHGULGHNfEXHPUDd+Z\DU
N7D_ L{H\)U +\W FD\LQ WDf $Q<DQ< J½H+ S½DH1U V¼LË +\LQ LN¡ LE[\L) E¿Df Z U<DP +HO $Q<DQ< J½H+Z
U<DPLOS½D1ZhLGMJgV¼LË+Z\DUN7D_WD&D5DefP+DLEH6ÙUPHWD9HUDNWHODP+DLE6Ù y=9H&yNMDHQ
3HO$Q<DQ<P+DLEH6ÙZyWDS½D17DNHWSDHU_9PUDy=P+DLE6Ù LQH\%DEL&yVL)+\WL{H\)HUUNDH&eNL)4u
LE GXUPHWD
LQh)Q Z 9fQÐDfQ =7D{HP JLWV8 Z 9HSL4NWDEDG W® 9LEÉDU NUHOZ PDQEWDU hSU yVHODU $EGDQ
WcDHGUM,E6D\yGH.y=HWSDHUQLQ_PDQX[WcDHGU9LEÉDHUUVX3Oy%DJNUHOZWcDUDLQHMUDfyNDQVX3Oy%DJ
NHU y=HW SDHUQLQ P¼WX<U SU LN&Xf $EL6Ë QD 7DNHO LQh)Q Z 9fQÐDfHQU NDH& JLWV8 Z 9HSL4NWDEDG
WH®U 9U yNDQf P8O< yQf WcDHGU 9LEÉDU PDQEWDU yNDQ hSNDU ED $SNDHU 9VH& LN QD yV)DZ WcDUD 9U
yNDQNDHOf MDQHWSDUHEQ QDePQZ yWD+HWSDUHWDy=9HSL4NWDEDGW® 9LEÉDHUU SHUULGQfS¼L7E,)D
yNDQNDUH1'¯dV+H\yJOyVH4H9HSL4NWDEDGWH®UN,P8O<7DNHWD"eeNFUPLW{ZfU<D6QDOVW<_
LN¡ ePQ=LG+\y=WcDUD$Q<yNDQKDfHPQ6Qy7HNVELN&X MDQHWSDUH&QEDyNDQeNLGQMDQHEQWD+HOf
yNEOWcDHGU$EGDQÑDº7NEHOPHQ+\_
9JDP,NDOf=LGyNDQeNRGEG8LºESDHNS¼L7E,)D'¯dV+H\=D\yVH4HDQLEDQ9LEÉDU%DOP GQ<D\
$Q<D\fW<DLGUN,P8O<7DNHE"WDUSUZLNfyPfOZf )DUHQ)LQH\EVDV·E9W0,\ÑMQE£uED£EHGUVDH7
LNyG.DNUDV·EWD+HON,HVU96D\yQ6D\PDQX[&X)ÔH&"VEfLNWD+HOy)H´SDUDOPDQXH[UGº6QLNeW)Df
Q<DHUD PDQXH[U VDH7 WD+HO SÆSDL.HGU SDº7N< yND7D\ PDQXH[U eNL) VXG8US½VDU, Z yQDEO L%6Q 7DND)D
$H=2L{N+HEyNQ"VXWUDdePQ=LG+\y=S¼L7E,)D'¯dV+H\yJHOZePQeNMQ9H&QL=LQ9EDHUDS¼L7E,HN
LUyÐDUNUHWV4P+HEQWD+HOfyNEOVELN&X =7D=7%DHE$º7E+PHQ+\_eVEE<DSDHU$HQHNf+\W9J
LS&QDy%HEEDLWNJ½Í%DHELN&XeN)DEHOEVHEQWDHWZLN¡9PDUN7DUyNDQfSLUEºWQ+H&QD_
Keyword: Billions of Deterministic Processes
LE6ÙDV QDPN -u)ÔHN eL5H\ =DZ\DU MQ< $HQHNf eNL) yN26HOU 96½\ yQZ\D ÆUw NHUH&Q_ WDHGU %D[D\ yV)D
+H&ZH\O9PUDELOQDy=9PUDL{H\)HULE6ÙDVNLUQDEDQDL{H\)HULE6ÙDVNLU9LÍNUD=DEHOWDU
VDPHQ9PUDÆ'XeN)DQD
V8FNhSVºJELVH\LGf_
LE6ÙDVQDPN-u)ÔHNeL5H\=DZ\DUeNL)yPD4PyN26OWXf
N, ELOV_y=QL{H\)U LQH\QDLÍNHGU LQMÑ yNDQLF¡D%DEQDf yQfWDHGULF¡D%DEQD V´S8º19LÍNHGUhSU
LQº%U6,O_WDUDÆ'X eNL)QD
+DHWNHULQH\yULK9H&_9LÍNUDLN&X EODUVDH7VDH7WDUDyVfQD
yNWDHGU
9LÍNHGUN7DUV´PX.%DHJ&cXH5PDUHE_$º7Dg9LÍNUD=LGEHON
QDLÍNUDVDH7VDH7EOHEQDN
9PDU
eN QDLÍN E£uHN eNEDU LMHV NHUL&ODP 9&D ef S¼L7E,HW =LG yNDQf 9LÍN QD 7DNHWD yVH4H WXf
L{H\)HULE6ÙDVNULWVLNQD_E£u+c<D
EDQD
yNDQMEDELGHWSDHULQ
9LÍNWD V·EW: eNL) Q<DFDUDO L3QLPQ<DQ_ $HоLO\DU 9LGEDV,HGU PH'< QDLN eNL) VP,4D FDODHQD +H\L&O
=DUDN.HQDfS½FLOW'HºPUy&cD\DSD\LQ_VP,4D\yG.DyJH&WDUDZQDLNL{H\)HULE6ÙDV,_WD&D5DZeNL)L6ÆHN
'HºPUyNDQy&cD\D&D5DfE5NUDUSU=LGLMHVNUD+\efP+DLEH6ÙUyNDQL{H\)U7DNHWSDHULNQD_9PDU
'DU1DyV+c<D
V8FNMEDEfyGHE_
L{H\)HULE6ÙDVNLUQDED9LÍNHGU=XL{$Sº=Dª
EHOyN+LN¡ FXSFDS7DNHWSDHUQDEUbLEL%¤%DHEWDU
QDLE6ÙDVHNMDLÐ3DfNUDUfyFËDNHU_S½N»WSH4L{H\)HUU$QLÍHW®UÑSH4yN+=XL{WºNhSÍÓDSQNUDUVDH7
VDH7WDUNDH&yV)DeN)DSHML)%LE6ÙDV+H\=D\_yVH4HLN¡EDHºKQ$ES½w3WDU*DH5ZEºWDHE_
S½HW<HNfeNL)LQLËE\VSº=¡9LÍN7DNDUSUQDLÍN+\_3HOEDHºKQ$ES½w3ÑD%DLEN%DHEfQDLÍNHGU*DH5
EºWDHEy=H+WX WDUDfLE6ÙDVSLUEºWQNUH&Q_'UD=DNeNL)yND´SDLQHWeN6WMQyODNeNVDH7y=DJLGHOQ_
G6E&UFDNLUNUDUSUScDFMQ$E<D+LWLGHOQ_y=ScDFMQ$E<D+LWLGHOQWDHGUHNfLN¡ $E<D+LWUNDU1
Gº6DHW+HE_e.QefScDFMQyODN=LGhOÔH)DLGHNEDLNScFDQE¯fMQHNyNQWDUDFDNLUNUH&Q
WDUNDU1
Gº6DHWEHOWD+HOLQÅF\+DV<NUÆQDHEScDFMQyODNN,NDUH1LE6ÙDVSLUEºWQNUHOQyV)DWDHGUHNfE<D.<D
NUHW +HE_ WDUD =LG E<D.<D NUHW E<º7 +\ yVH4H WDHGUVDPHQ LN&X S7 y.DOD 9H& N 9LÍNHGU LEM\,
Keyword: Billions of Deterministic Processes
eUNP eNL) WXOQDHN N,HVU VDH7 N,HVU WXOQD EOD =DHE yN MDHQ =DH+DN WDU PDHQ WDUD
L{H\)UHNZ LEDHQU PH'< $¡º%X{ NHU LQH\H&Q WDf =LG +\ WD+HO WDHGU *DH5f LN¡ L{H\)HUU $QLÍW®
REDLQN%DHES½PD1NUDUGDL\W®y7HN=DH&_yG.D=DNWDUDNWG8UeHJDHWV4P+\
QDLÍNHGUeNL)=XL{The Argument from Evil: (1) Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is
not omnipotent. (2) Is he able, but not willing? Then he is malevolent. (3) Is he both able and willing? Then
whence cometh evil? (4) Is he neither able nor willing? Then why call him God? (Epicurus)
S½6¢+H&WDUDL{H\)HUULEH6[1HODZfL%OyND7Dy7HNySHOQyV)DWDHGUHN9HJE<D.<DNUHW+HE_$Q<7D\
e%DHE'HULQH\LN&XS½PD1NUDHNGº6Q6DHÍE¼DNDU=XL{EHO_ePQZyWD+HWSDHUy=%DOZP GL{H\)HUUf
V¼LË_yVH4HLN¡ ef=XL{UyNDQfP8O<7DNH&QD_$HQHN%DO
ZP G
6±GXL)HN9HSL4NZEHO7DHNQ_
$º7Dg %DO
U $QXSLÍÓLWf +H& PH GU hSLÍÓLW eEd LESU,W)DZ VW<_ hGD+U1ÑUxS EOD =D\ eNL) FDNu =.Q
VDºMHQU +DHW 7DHN W.Q yV)D %DO
$7F eNf FDNu =.Q .XLQU +DHW 7DHN W.Q yV)D +H\ =D\ P G
_ %DO Z
P GHN=7D{HP9HODZ$cD'DHUUVDH7ZWXOQDNUD+\_WD&D5DThe Argument from Evil
=XL{UeNL)SDOÔ)D
=XL{Z9H&_y=PQ (1) God does exist; (2) Gratuitous evils are incompatible with God; (3) Therefore, there
are no gratuitous evils.
L{H\)HU LE6ÙDV y=H+WX 9LÍNHGU W® yVH+WX QDLÍNUD =LG ef WH®U hSU 9ÍÓD UD.HW QD SDHUQ yVH4H ef
LEWHºNUyNDQfy6[yQf_3HO9LÍNUDfLN¡ F85D¡ LEM\,L+HVHEy7HN=DHE_$ND)<S½PD1&D5DPDQX[yNDQÔ GX:H.
eNL) Q<DFDUDO W®HN SLUW<DJ NUHE" =XL{EDG, PDQX[ yMHQÆHQ yNQf ED eWE5 -cXLN LQHW =DHE" QDLÍNUD LN
yNDQVXLSLU\UW® $3DUNUHWySHUH&_L{H\)HULE6ÙDHVUeNPDLENÀSW® +H&QDL{H\)HULE6ÙDVe&D5D
9VHO$Q<yNDQW® GcD5NUDHQDZ$V·E_efVX×SËV,PDEWD$HQHNy=QEX-HWfFD\QD_WHE+c<DLENÀS
eNL)W®9H&9UyV)D+H&PDQX[HN$PUW®$ºMQNUHW+HEQDLÍNUDLN$PUW®$ºMHQU3ºPXOD9LEÉDUNUHW
SDUHE"LEWHºNU9OÔL)HP)$EVDQNHÀSQDLÍNHGUMQ<eL)eNL)3OÔLVL3HN6Qy)Ð+HWSDHU
9LÍNHGU yNDQ WD5DÕ5D yQf y=H+WX WDUD VXLE'DMQN $EÍÓDHQ 9H&_ REDLQN%DHE S½PDL1W LENÀS yNDQ W®
9LEÉDUQD+Z\DSº=¡ L{H\)HUUÑSH4WDHGULQMÑ=XL{HNfWDUD=H7ÌEHOPHQNHU_yN+WDHWLPWySD[1
NUHOWDHNfEOHW+HE9UN,%DHES½PD1yG.DHOLWLQL{H\)HULE6ÙDVNUHEQeEdyNQ_eH4HZLN¡ EDHºKQ
QDLÍNHGU*DH5f7DNH&_
Keyword: Billions of Deterministic Processes
ÕPPP...9LPyWDeWLGQ'HUÆHQeHVL&L{H\)HULE6ÙDVLQ&NfeNL)$£LE6ÙDVWXf9EDUeVEN,9EOWDEO
EOL&V"9LPE£uUS½6¢ Z=XL{JXHODUyWPQyNDQSDOÔ)D=XL{V´PWMEDELGHWSDLULQ_Gº6Q6DHÍULN&X S½FLOW=XL{
LGH\Z WDHN EcDH) 9QHW SDUODP QD_ $º7Dg 9PDU E£u EOHW FDfH& WXf =Df ELOV QD yNQ L{H\)HU LE6ÙDV
yNDQ%DHEf$£LE6ÙDV+HWSDHUQD_WDUNDU1+H&efLE6ÙDVyE6LN&XUwW®S8º1WH7<UhSUL%LNHUGcDL5H\9H&
y=HODPDQX[yNDQ%DHEf$Ñ,NDUNUHWSDHUQD_LE6ÙDVPDHQf$£LE6ÙDVQ\_$HQHNfLE[\)DLQH\yV%DHE%DHE
QD_
E£u9UZEHO Believing in Creator is the Greatest Rational Wager Ever!
Because there is absolutely nothing to lose in this Case!
S½H6¢DUSºE
E£uHN LMHV NUODP LMhV L+ GX L.½ÐDQ PXVLOP L6.HGU yWD 9EDU 9ODGD9ODGD L{H\)U WD+HO yNDQÔ
L{H\)HUPDQX[LE6ÙDVNUHE"
E£u 9PDUeH+QfH )LOHM )
S½H6¢ LN&X)D%<DEDF<DNDy.H\EHOWXfyWDyGL.eNMQyEDNDU+fUH\yJL&Vef
P+DLEH6ÙUL{H\)U y7HN 7DNHONWHOD L{H\)U 7DND hLFgEHO WXfPHQ NLUV" ef eNLEd6 6WD±,HW yWDU ef
fH )LOHM )
S½6¢ 9VHO yNDQ S½6¢f QD_ yWDU ef S½6¢ ÆHQ JJ½DHPU PXTuVXTu yODNMQZ LPL)LPL) +DLV LGH\ +\W
EOHEhLQPHQ+\L6´SD,ZPDQXH[UPD-DPDL-yNDQeN)DS½MDLW+HE
9PDHNEHOL&V%DON7D$Q<NDhHNy=Q
PHQU%XHOZefQQÔS½6¢ LMHVNLUVQDMDLWVH*UNWHODP+DVLFE7DHNyU"eNL)yGH6UNWHODyS½LVHK )
7DHN"NWHODS½'DQP¡,7DHN"eNL)fhLQ%DLºVL)UNWHODL%LV7DHN"… "… "eN)DN7DV0U1UD.LE yV)D
+H& EDÍEWDU Q,LUH. U<D6QDLOL) LGH\f9PDHGU LEFDU NUHW +HE_ WD&D5D $Q< yNDQ S7Z y.DOD yQf LN¡_ WHE
yWDU VH G+ 7DNHO eNDL'N L{H\)HUZ LE6ÙDV NUHW SDLUV yVH4H 9EDU LN¡ L{H\)HUUS½N»W Vd.<D eEd WDUD
eHN$SUy7HNÑW¡ LNQDeUNP$HQNML)OS½6¢ FHO9VHE9UyWDHNfEDyNDQÔ L{H\)UV¼LËNHUH&yV)D
N,%DHEMDQLE"WD&D5DJD&SDODM,EM¡UL{H\)U"S¼L7E,UL{H\)U"FH UL{H\)U"V8Hº=UL{H\)U"Q<DFDUDOO<
U
L{H\)U"SDLQUL{H\)U"EDWDHVUL{H\)U"… "… "QDLÍNHGUyWDWD+HOyNDQL{H\)Uf7DNHEQDy=H+WX WDUD
L{H\)HULE6ÙDVNHUQDfLW+DVSº=DHODFQDNUHOyG.D=D\y=LQHGQSH4NH\N+DMDUE&U9HJy7HNf=XL{EDG,Z
$=XL{EDG,GXL)J½wSVPD¡UDO%DHEFHO9VH&_3HO9My7HNNH\N+DMDUE&U9HJPDQX[$ED$=XL{EDG,L&O
ef 'UHQU E{HE<U yNDQ L%L yQf_ hGD+U1ÑUxS EOD =D\ $TDHPU yUMU 3ºPXOD 9LEÉDHUU NH\N +DMDU E&U
9HJf y=.DHQ eNL) J½wS eNDL'N L{H\)HUU 'DU1DHN S½W<D.<DQ NHUH& yV.DHQ $Q< eNL) J½wS ef eNLEd6
6WD±,HWZeNDL'NL{H\)HULE6ÙDVNHUEDWDUV·DEQDUN7DEHOeNMQL{H\)UV´S8º1P+DLEH6ÙUMQ<=H7Ì+HO
eNDL'NL{H\)UyNQGUNDUyV)DyWDHNfE<D.<DNUHW+HE_WD&D5DeNDL'NL{H\)HUUy4HLN¡ GXºEOJK
fVXZ
FHO 9VHE =DUD eNDL'N L{H\)HUU V·DEQDU N7D EHO WDHGU S½7HP L{H\)HUU S½N»W Vd.<D LQLÅFW +Z\DU SUf
yNEO L{H\)U 9H& LN yQf
LEWHºN QDPD hLFg_ 'UD =DN ef P+DLEH6ÙU eN +DMDU L{H\)U 'HU LQH\ K. KLN V
OLMN LGH\ ED N´SX)DHUU N,HEDºK yIHO VEDfHN QDf
NHU LGHOQ WDUSU LWLQ N,%DHE LQLÅFW +HEQ y=9U yNDQ
L{H\)UQDf"eNDL'NL{H\)HUUy4HQDLÍNUDfLN¡ P+DLESHGSH5=DHEQNDU1WDUDNWHODL{H\)UHNOLMN
LGH\QDf
NHUyGHEQyV)DWDUDLQHMUDfMDHQQQDQ<DFDUQDNUwN%XHO%DHO=LGeNMQL{H\)UEDLNUH\=D\
WD+HOLN¡WDHGU.EU9H&$WeEyG.D=DH&y=eNDL'NL{H\)U
eNL)$.1H=DJ<eEdyVfVDH7$(EDLQN
E{E<_
eEDUWXfEOL{H\)Uf=LGVELN&XV¼LËNHU7DHNWD+HOL{H\)UHN9EDUyNV¼LËNHUH&"
E£u EHO $W<¡ UwW®S8º1 WHE JWDQXJLWN eNL) S½6¢_ 9PDU hH6< LN¡ L{H\)HUU V¼LË LQH\ Q\_ yWDU P8O S½6¢
$QX=D\,9LPÆ'X L{H\)HULE6ÙDVeNL)$£LE6ÙDVLNQDyV)DyG.DHQDUfyFËDNUL&_ZH\OQDLÍNUDZLN¡ FD VZ
$<DNÔLVHK )
eLE6ÙDVNHUe.QyN+=LGS½6¢ NHUFD VZ$<DNÔLVHK )yNV¼LËNHUH&"eUhULNWDUDLGHW
SDUHE"QDLÍNHGUy=.DHQ'DHS'DHSFD VZ$<DNÔLVHK )eUhSU9ÍÓDUD.HW+\yV.DHQefLE6ÙE½´PDHUQDL5
Q4 E<D.<DU MQ< eNPD L{H\)HU LE6ÙDV LN yE6, y=2L{N Q\" fQ3DfQDf) V¼LËU LN&X LN&X LE[H\U EDÍEV´PW
E<D.<DU MQ< LEDQ 9H&_ LEDQ e.DHQ VD+D=<NDU, eNL) )XO L+HVHE NDM NUHE_ WD&D5D E<DSDU)D e%DHEZ LF¡D
NUHW SDLUV N Ñ\dL{\%DHE PDQX[ V¼LË +H\ Q<DFDUDO EÍ LGH\ N´SX)DU Z yUDEH)U PHWD LN&X LK)DULPLQLÐN
Keyword: Billions of Deterministic Processes
S½HVVUZEDLQH\H&.Ñ\dL{\%DHEL{H\)UV¼LË+H\PDQX[V+LELO\QLELO\QLK)DULPLQLÐNS½HVVUV¼LËNHUH&_
N
=LGVW<+\WD+HO.
VW<+HEQDyNQ"Ñ\dL{\%DHEPDQXH[UPHWDEXLPDQS½D1,V¼LË+H\=LGLN&X NUHWSDHU
WD+HO eNf =XL{ $QX=D\, Ñ\dL{\%DHE L{H\)U V¼LË +H\ PDQXH[U yFH\ $yQN yE6, LN&X NUHW SDUHE QD yNQ"
QDLÍNHGULE6ÙDV$QX=D\,PDQX[=LGÑ\·X+HWSDHUWD+HOL{H\)HUUfEDÑ\·X+HWVPV<DyND7D\"
9&DL{H\)HULE6ÙDHVUS½6¢9VH&fEDyNQ"PDQX[LN9HEJLGH\L{H\)HULE6ÙDVNHU"
E£uU hU 9HU y+cDGO eW41'HUWD+HO N, ENEN NUODP"L{H\)U&D5DLELO\QLELO\QE&U 'HU LELO\Q
LELO\QS½HVVLQº'DLUW%DHEUDQNUDUV·DEQDeW)Df4,1y=WDLF¡DUZEDL+HU_Æ'XfFD V$<DNÔLVHK )ZyEDED
NDOD $£ Q<DFDUDO O< LGH\ ef $VD'DU1 Z LE×P\NU L3QLPQ<DQHN E<D.<D NUD =D\ QD_ e MQ<f $HQHN L{H\)HU
LE6ÙDV NHU Because it is Logical, Rational, and Most Likely the TRUTH_ yN+ yN+ 9HEJ LGH\Z L{H\)HU
LE6ÙDVNUHWSDHU=DUDe%DHELF¡DNHUQD_
9&D VELN&XHWf =LG L{H\)HUU SUP +DHWU y&cD\D
7DHN WD+HO LEDQ,UD 9EDU N, NUHE" WcDUD LN EHV EHV
9tXHOUPD7DFcX[HE"WcDHGUJHE[1D\ED'DUV¼LË+HEQD"
E£u LN&X)D UDJDLQW ÑHU ePQ 9MLE N7D yN EHO yU" LEDQ,HGU NDM NUHW VPV<D +HE yNQ" PHQ NU
PDfH{DV3Ô)Ô yND´SDLQ y7HN LN&X fHON)¾LQ~ 9fH)P EDLQH\ eNL) fhLQ%DLºVL)U O<DHE SDIDHQD +HOD_ eEDU &D
L64N Z O<DE y)NÔLQL6\DQUD LN eHOD LQH\ EHV EHV 9tXO FcX[HE" WDUD =¡SDLW E<E+DU NUHW SDUHE QD yNQ"
=¡SDLW.XHOWDHGUNDº=S½1DO,fEDMDQHWSDUHEQDyNQ"=¡SDLWUhSUPDfH{DV3Ô)Ô yND´SDLQU+DHWUy&cD\D
9H&
EHOyNDQNDMLN9)ÔHN7DNHE"e)DNDHUDNDHUDU<D6QDLOL)UV,PDEWD$7EDL{H\)UHNe5DHQDUeNL)&XWDZ+HW
SDHU_WHEJ<DLOLOZLQh)QOXfSDÍU9±XVVDODPS½PX.HGULN¡ yNDQVPV<D+\LQyN+yN+$=DLFW%DHELEDQ
LE[\NJHE[1DUPH'<L{H\)UHNy)HQeHQMJDL.FXLUPDºNDN7DEDDEHOQ_
PHQNUefS¼L7E,UEXHNeNMQ9LÍNZeNMQQDLÍNLEDQ,&D5D9UyNDQPDQX[yQf_WDUDh%H\fQWXQLN&X
9LEÉDUNUHOQ_yVH4HWDHGUS½LWL{\DyNPQ+HWSDHU"
E£uEHOZH\OQDLÍNLEDQ,UNDH&E<DSDUL)eNL)$<DNÔLVHKH )UUwU+V<
hHQ0DFQNUD+HEeEdWDUMQ<LWLQ
FD V Z $<DNÔLVHK )HN 'Q<EDGZ MDQDHW SDHUQ G<D)ÔVÔ $O $SULGHN 9LÍN LEDQ, L{H\)HUU P+DQ V¼LËU eNL)
UwU+V<hHQ0DFQNUHWySHUH&QLE'D\$W<¡ ÑD%DLEN%DHEfPDQLVNS½6DL¡ $QX%ENUHEQeEdL{H\)Uy7HNWDU
S½LWGDQZ96DNUHWSDHUQ_WcDUNDH&SXHUDE<DSDU)DfL{H\)HUUVDH7eNL)f )DHULÐd+DfK$<DLVNyJPÔVÔZ
+HWSDHU
9&DL{H\)Uy7HN7DNHOVXQDLP%8LPN´SyUDJ9SGfW<DLGHWy=+DMDU+DMDUPDQX[PDUD=DH&WDUE<D.<DN,"
E£uUMEDEZH\OS½7PW:eUyNDQVGXU9PDUMDQDyQf_LW,\W:WXf9LPeLE[H\S½6¢ NUDUyN"9PUDfED
WDHGU U4D NUHW SDUL& QD yNQ" yWDU9PDUf ED LQÅF\WD yND7D\ y= yNDQ PX+8HºW WXf9LPZ yWD WDHGU PHWD
G8º%DJD
+HWSDLUW¼W,\W:efS½H6¢UhUySHW+HOKDfHPQ6QSLUEºWQNUHW+HE_$º7Dgy)H´SDUDOMJgy7HN
MDQDV·EQ\_Æ'Xfy)H´SDUDOL%hSH\ )y7HNVELN&X LEFDUQDNHUf)DUQDOL%hSH\ )y7HNZyWD%DEHW+HE
WDfQD_WHEeNL)hGD+U1yGZ\Dy=HWSDHU_PHQNU]DNDUeNEDVDHWWXfyPD)DPXL)%DO%DHEfEDVNUL&V_+IDg
NHUyNDQeNRGEG8LºESDNeHVELÍUyODNHODHNWXHOLQH\LJH\S¼L7E,ULEL%¤6+Uy=PQ)UH )DLQhf\ºNLVKLQ
OQS<DLUVyUDPy)DLNZfW<DLGHWyUH.LGOWXfeLE[H\LN&XfMDLQVQD_WXf+\WPHQNUL&Vy=WDUDPHU%8W
+H\yJH&yWDU+\WNUw1DZ+H&efy%HEy=eHNyWDELÍUyODNMQWDUSU9EDUWDHGUhSUfePQP+DLESG
yQHPeHODeEDULE[\)Dy%HEG<D.
yVLGHQUPHWDE£uHN9PDUy6[S½6¢9&DL{H\)HULE6ÙDVHNLNKJÔP<DL)NEODy=HWSDHU"
E£uUyVDMDVD¦)DMEDE$V·EWD+HWfSDHUQDePQyE9TOÔN7DyNEHOH&"eNL)LE6ÙDVHNW.QfKJÔP<DL)N
EOD=DHE=.QyVfLE[H\UhSUeNDL'N=XL{V´PW$SÔ6QÔ 7DNDVH®ZyN+eNL)HNVW<ZEDLNHODHNLPH7<EHO
LE6ÙDVNUHE_y=PQ'HºPLE6ÙDHVUy4HKJÔP<DL)MHPUS½6¢ 9VHWSDHU_LN¡ L{H\)HULE6ÙDHVUy4HLE[\L)V´S8º1
Keyword: Billions of Deterministic Processes
9ODGD_ WDU NDU1 +H& L{H\)HU LE6ÙDHVU LENÀS yNDQ U<D6QDO $SÔ6QÔf y=H+WX PDQXH[U +DHW yQf yVH+WX ef
LE6ÙDVHNyNDQ%DHEfKJÔP<DL)NEODy=HWSDHUQD_9LÍNQDLÍNLQLºEH6H[$HQHNfKJÔP<DL)NLE[\)DLQH\yV%DHE
%DHEQQD_WDUDPHQNHUQLE6ÙDVPDHQfKJÔP<DL)N=DUDL{H\)HULE6ÙDVHNKJÔP<DL)NEHOWDUDe.QZPDH\UySH)f
UH\yJH&_EUbL{H\)HULE6ÙDVQDNUDPDHQLQHMHNyMDUNHU$LQÅF\WDULGHNyIHOyGZ\D_eNMQ=XL{EDG,PDQX[
yMHQÆHQLQHMHNN.HQDFUPWP$LQÅF\WDULGHNyIHOLGHWSDHUQQD_9UeNDUH1L{H\)HULE6ÙDVQDNUD)Df
fU<D6QDLOL)ZKJÔP<DL)MHPUPH'<SH5NDU1e.DHQ=XL{UyFH\9HEJEDEDLWNNDMNHUyE6,_WDUDfQ3DfQDf)
)DfP×S<DQHN $Ñ,NDU NHU VELN&XU 3OD3O Wg41Dg yG.HW FD\_ 9U WDg4L1N 3OD3O QD yG.HW ySH\ LF¡D
%DEQDUyKDHPfQHNQ<DHUDy7HNQ<DHUDWUEDLQH\y3HO_yVNDUH1WDUDPHQULEUwH+HOZL{H\)UHN$Ñ,NDUNHU
VDPL\NLN&X 6DL¡ ODH%U96D\SDLº7ELE[H\UPH'<L{H\)HUULENÀS.cXHMyE5D\_y=PQeNL)REDLQN9LEÉDHUU
VDH7VDH7WDUD+\WPHQNHUeEDUEXL-L{H\)HUU.DZ\Dy6[WDUSU9EDU+WD6D9EDULENÀSL{H\)HUUV£DQ
QDLÍNUDeSº=¡ÑW¡ yNDQW® GcD5NUDHWV4P+\LQ_ef$ÑLÍÓNU$EÍÓDe5DHWWDUDLEDHQUy.DOHVPD7DyJcDMD
ÆUwNHUH&Q_$º7DgLEDQHNL{H\)HUULENÀSW®
L+HVHES½LWLÌWNUHWhHISH5yOHJH&Q_LN¡WDUDy=)DEX-HW
FD\QD yV)D+H& LEDQ LQHMy=PQLENÀSL{H\)U
Q\ yWPLQ9EDULEDQ,UD L{H\)ULQH\ NDMZNHU QDÆ'X
L{H\6QLQH\NDMNHU_WD&D5DREDLQN9LEÉDU=WyE6,+HE=WyE6,NPÔHS¿~+HE=WyE6,h\DDU3uO+HE
yV)DWWyE6,L{H\)HUU$LÍHW®US½LWfLGNÔ LQHºG6NUHE$QLÍHW®ULGHNQ\3HOS½HW<NL)h\DDU3uO9LEÉDU
L{H\)HUU$LÍHW®UVDJHUeHNNL)P8O<EDQK¾SNDU1S½HW<NL)9LEÉDUeHNNL)W7<E+QNHU_efP+DLEH6ÙWH7<U
SLUPD1=WyE6,+HEyV)DWWyE6,eNMQÑDWVDUS½LWfLGNÔ LQHºG6NUHE$<DNÔLVHKH )ULGHNQ\WD&D5D
EDº)¾DUDHVON,EOHOQ9U NASNational Academy of ScienceseUJHE[NUDfEDN,LE6ÙDVNUHOQWDHWy=
LNVÔVX =D\9HVQDyV)DeW4H1LQÅF\EX-HWSDUL&V_LEDQ,ZJHE[NHGUPH'<QDLÍNWDUS½E1WDyEH5H&P8OW:
FDHºFU VDH7 LEDQ,HGU V*º[ Z LW{ $L%WD y7HN_ $º7Dg J<DLOLOZU VPVDPL\N VP\ y7HN_ Æ'X WDf Q\
KDUhfQEDG REDLEN%DHEVW< L+HVHES½LWLÌW+Z\DU9HJf $HQHNQDLÍN+H\+DWSD 'XH\EHV 9H&Q=DH+DN
=XL{LGH\yNDQLN&XHNQDf
NHULGHOfyWD9US½N»WSH4fQDf+H\=D\QDWDfQD_yG.LOQD9LPS½7HPf=XL{
LGH\9fQÐDfQZLQh)QHN=7D{HPJD'DZy%5DEDLQH\LGH\L&WDfEHOLNWXfS½N»WSH4fWcDHGUJD'DZy%5D
EHOLE6ÙDVNUDÆUwNHUL&V"yEÕDE<D)DH&2OyND7DNDU
eNL)LE6ÙDVHNW.Qf$£LE6ÙDVEOD=DHE=.QWDUÑSH4yNDQ=XL{fGcD5NUDHQDV·E+HEQD_L{H\)HULE6ÙDV
LN&X)DEXLPD\LE6ÙDHVUPW_e)D$HQN)DhSOL²UZE<DSDU_L{H\)HUU$LÍW® SU,4DP8ON%DHES½PD1NUDV·EQD
+HOZWDUÑSH4$HQNyMDUDHOD=XL{9H&_VEHFH\E5=XL{+H&efLE6ÙE½´PD
Z+Ô +c<D9LPeSº=¡ =DEHOL&WDUVELN&XfLN¡ E¿DfZU<DPf%<OX6HQU3OD3O_eUPH'<yNDQUNPEXLPD
NDMNHULQ9Uf%<OX6HQU3OD3O+Z\DHW9PDUyNDQN7D\PDfZNUHWSDULEQDLN¡
Z\DZE£uUePQGcDW%DtD-DL5UN,MEDEyGEEX-HWSDUL&QDWDUyE6,U%DJN7DEDDf9PDUPD7DZNDHQU
hSULGH\FHOyJH&yN+LNe=DDy7HNU4DNUHWSDUHEQ"
VLW<fLN Believing in Creator is not a blind Belief?
VLW<fLN The Greatest Rational Wager Ever?
VLW<fLN Nothing to lose?
VLW<fLN The Ball is in Atheists’ Court?
UD\+DQahumanb@yahoo.com