Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
l~ ~ "'~~
m ,~~~ l!l<f ~~~ ~tf I Appendi
~cq I Minority Representation ~ l!l~
<ll~ ~'«~
l!l~~ <f~ ~~ ~ ~ I
~~ ~~l~, ~t~~ ~ ~1!ffiI. ~~l1l1l
l!l~'1
Club <mlf \!j<!l ~ ~ ~o{.' l!l~ ~ ~
White Paper-l!l1f~~1(.'11t1"l1«i~ l!l~~ ~ ~
Constitution ~l~ l!l~ ~ l!l~~ l'f~ I cJI~
<lt~~I~~~~~
~~I
Horrabin-l!l1l'Atlas of Current Affairs ~
~1~1 l!l1f~~'QI<f~~~ l!t${~
v;~~fiI~ ~ ~r.~I~~~m ~ I
0WWI1f ~ l!l<f~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~
~<::5 Clfllt-C1J~, C1J~~ ~l'1<qlvl ~ ~ I 15~
~ ~~~N'91 elf ~~ ~Mt1f1 ~911l', l!l~ ~ <l~~
~~') 'ttl I ,,~~~ C<ftOf ~~1 0f1 ~ til
~~G1~ ~~ ~t1lffiT I 'IIl~••..
~ ~ 1f5 ~ ~.
~~I~l~"'~~~ ~ ~ ~
~<::51 ~ ~9f~~, ;s~')O{ ~ ~ ~ ~~
~t'lt~ Cl~ ~~ ~'l!l~ ~~T I ~1 <f~ 9f
~ ~ ~ ~, ~~ f.{fi"5<::5 ~ ~~ ~ ~
~~, ~~ ~ ~~ ~t~ lllltt{~ R I <::51 ~ 6~
"
<lJ<l~nt
m ifI
~'if;:ttJi 9ft<{ R I ~
I cjj M~filf<r;~~~
~ <l~~ ~~
~
Qf ~~~
lffiTI
•
~ ~~J c<rt~ C'ltft"fl: ~-fll ~ l!l<f~ ~l~
15l~'hI1 l!l~ ~"Itf.W!ffl ~ ~~J ~~ ~ I
!fir ~ «1fir-~~m
Nlli (M Pi, ~~ J ~
~r:oW~~1 R~'~,~~,~ ~ ~I ~-9tfm
I5R'f C1J~l 15l~ "Pl1l'J f~: ~~~~ ~.
~~tllf ~. ~ ~ ~iWf, ~-illf.ill'.!(-t'llf mr. ~AA·'$
~~~I
~~, ~fUctf1ll1 J1t~, ~~, ~~~
o!I'f~-~~ ~~. " ~. ~. "J. ($, ,,~ ~'It-mr, ~ ..m. ~ (.fI,
'1l'Plll,ti!
O;PO:ii Co!i'l, )~", ,~tiltlf ~Ii~, ~~ ~~~.~ ~~~til( ~ ~Jtfif I
~f~t~ IS ~~t.".t~~f! ';l~
~~~~;r ~<f, \!l<f~~~t'l <f"~~C~~ c<r f<l~~ ~'1I.!l~ c<rC'I~~ ~il~fu.~~ (tautological) I I.!t<f
~;r c;r~trn<!l"
C9f)<f<ft'1~~J~
~f\§ R~~ "~~'$f ~ ~~~ 'I~i{ I.!t-R~~l11
'Im 'S ~~1 ~<fJ~Rg, Pfi~
~fWs~~f;re ~~ C~<!l"~~~ ~~'1fu ~~9ftlff;;r ~ '!It~~fi{<f ~~'1~t~ ~~~ c<Iltif '$f~~~ ~~"$~
~~'tJ ~t~ C~~<!l"
c~-~;r ~~Q: '1t~ i.!l<!l" U 0i1 I.!l<f~'6nr.'1f"Jfi<fi~t<ftt~
~~ R~~~fa; '6lr.if<\ll11
\!l~
~;r ~q il1 ~'S ~~M<f ~~t'1 C'1~Sl~a,~ r. t I ~ '6rt~~t<f~~~r.~~~f% C5r.<f
~~ ~f<l~r.~ ~<f<fC~tlf
~~r~~ ~9f1~Jt;r~<f
~~ ~N~ 'S ~~ ~9J?~M ertSfClfM C'I ~~ '6{t~t~~ If\<w~r.~t~~~mf%! 9f"Jfifflr.~
~~~ ~'e~1 ~ ~~, i.!l<f~
<ftilr;~ 'I~07~~ ~9f;{ tUDl-physics-l.!t~R~~~fa; ~~~ f.l~~"$'1 14~~~ cml:~
\!l<fl"t~~~<f~r;il~C'$'fl~<f
'S i{tfs~i!)J ~t~r;'t~ ~t~il1 ~lf~, f<ti~~111''Itf<f<f<fi
(universal) if~, 'It~@<f (statis-
~t;r'I-f<l:oo~~ <f~'I ~~;r C~ ;r~, f<Rd <f~J~~S ~~ ~ I (ufu.~ C~~(1j~t~l C<ll<f~
'PJt<f~ Rr;~-t <\l~r;\§'1tr;~,
~'Jli'1~~ c~a, ill ~ilt~t~~J~ ~<ll~ ~~~fa'lr;\§ ~ J1~i{ fwr;~ ~'lf~ I ~,'1~~1 ~'ltr.<f~ ~tr.lf~ <\lt~~ I
'1ftl~r;'1 I ~~r;~~ ~il c~;r ~ilfit~~ ~9ft~ ~~"$~ ~ '6l~t<f~~'It~~<\l ~iI~ . ~~I.!l<\l N<\l c~r.<f ~t9fil
C~il~ ~~ ~tm 'tt'1r;~tr;<!l"~
~t~~ Rr;~~~~ I ~ <\lt~'1
~r;~wt~~r.~ I '6l~ ~~~iG 'S '6lr.-t~- ie1fu;lf\t~
if1 c<r\!l<f,N;r ~1\!l<fl"Nif \!l~ W~f)~a, W~'1~t\§<f ~~ ~~R~ 'Olt~~t~ ~r.:;e, f<f~ I.!l~~Rr.<fI"~ '6lt'S~m~tt~
'1~~~ ~~tr;il~ ~ <f"4ir;;r~~ ~t~<ll~r;;r~ <fvrt ~l \!l~il I.!l<p~~ ~"t~~
DXf,~l'1~~ ~~r.~ C~C<f~tR<ll~1
~~ I C~R<!l" '1~~~ i.!l~"t~<f "~'l~'1 'e ~","~ ~ ~'".(~W~~ 'Ol~il<fi~tRC'I-s-t,~~ ~ts (Sit .<p'r.~\!lClf
;rI I ~~til c~ltt~ ~9\filro~l:<Ii, ~~l:<Ii, ~tlf 001 Cll~ ~ ~i{~ I C<tiS3tR<fi
~ f~ 9lfitCl~il~ 'lc<f.f~1
~t~ctt~ Cl~l <nl:~ D1~ ;rI I
<Ii<J."f D"Ilft~l:<Ii~D"f .' ~~ ~m~~t~ ~l<firn <fl~~ ~t~J I ~l:"l~i{l:~fu~
~tl:;r~ flf~ I <tltt"'~ ~~m 9\~~~~~~ ~~ ~ ~~ 'l~'1l''1 Clif"frnf~ ~tOf~ C<lW~<IiDt~ ~ llJt" ~<Ii
~~-t~ ~W~i!, f<tl~ ~~ ,'l"~ ~t~D~rn c~~tR<tl <liti'f I cq{#{ ~~1ljJ C<fit~~ Mf~~ ~'t~ ~t~t~<tl" ~l:~ m~
~f%D~'" <Titt"'~~Jtfilf%<tl~~101tl1iI ~~ <litl:"'~ ~l!tlftit I ~ ~l:"l~~l:i{~ 1Ut" ~ C<fitifl ~M~ c.n~<fi t,s9\"l~
~t~ \.!l<tl~~1~~, ~~ C~l:<Ii~~Wl:~~ ntl:<liI C~iS3tRfl1 C<Tii{
C~ i!t~ fi{~J 9\rn~~i{ift"'~tt<li <!f~ <ll:"fC'ill:iIRl:~ ~~
\.!l~ ~fitii;l:<tl R~ll~tCl ~"tU f~~~iI I ~W~ <liti'f". ~ <Ti~ I ~~til ~~~ 'i{ttil, nf%'€ \!>l~<Tirn(fi~ ifl \.!l'<t~
(order) Cw-t~ Pt~tt'l~~ \!>If<l'f''f~~~f.r, (fitt~~ ~~i{-C~~J 9\~1% t,sm~i{ <Ii~~ I <tlJt"l~"'pt ~ f~
~~~"'<tl" ~ 9\~t<l~~~ (reversible) I \St~l:iI ~"tl:~~ ~i{~~ ~ R~9\l:~ t,s~1ljJ 9\ftl<li~, ~~ \!>lRg~~
f<1~~iSft~~, w-f<Ti'ltl:9j~, ~i!~~Wl:i!~ ~t~ C'!~ ~9ft~ ill <fi~ CCl~". ~ ~~ ~~till:<fi ~Jtfil~~ ~t~tl1i
t,s~ R~~ift"f I ~iS3~-9\f~<tl~ <fit"f \.!l<tl~il~-~'l~ , I.!ll:<!i
RwtW'1 ~f<lDt~ ~t~ ~rn f<tl" Cl"fl ~~ T 9\wt(.
w-ft<fi~~t~<tl" t,s9j~ <mt ~~J \.!l<Ti~ wm ~~ <lit"l~~n:~~ ~~~ 'l~~ ~rn Cl'(3'~JR~;'''f il~ I 'l~J
~f<I~~ ~~~ ~t9\ill <fit~ I ~~~~~~ ~u~t9\~ , ~~~-t ~l:~ ~~i{ ~ ,~"t-tJ"f, ~~l:~~, fffc~ C<fit~ ~~~
c<littill ~<U~ ~~ ~f.rr;<fi~ ~tifl CiI~ ~tt~ <Ii'l:~ ~ <tl"~1~~ ~~i{ ~~ ~rn ~~ ~Cl~l C~l:<tl"~t~ ~~~
~&~ClJt<fl\!>l~~Cl ~~ <tl~1Q«:~ 9\tt~ I 'I ~~1~~ ~~, i!rn ~t~ ~<l~1 CQj"t~~~ ~Cl~ R~~'1 <fi~t~
f<ll:-.r~'lt~fui<li \!>lf~~~ ~i{ ~ ~~t~~ ~~'lt~J, \!>l(t~ <fiM c;y~tti{ ~l:~t~ 9\~tCl~-n~ I ~~
wt~ ~~ CCl~'l·~ <tll:~i{fi{ I \!>l~{-fil~~ ~t~ro ~ ~ ~~ \.!l'ili{ \.!l<1l~ ~\!J~ ~~l:~ ~t~ 'ltmJ ~~ ~
Mf~ ~ ~iI~~~ f5~~l!i 9\t~ ilt, \.!l~ <fi~~ ~f;r ~ t, ~l:'iIt'<l~tl:<lfu~ <fl~1 ~ I c;y-~~~ ~"f entropy I
~l:~iI I ~~ 'ilt"Wt~ 'ilil 'l~'1l''1 ~<l~'1 Cll:"'~ C~ ~ Opy~ ~-tw ~t~J1 \.!l~iI ~'<t ~, \!l:~ Clftu~ Cl"fl ~
~-9\t~'€ ~~~~ ~ C~ il~iI~~ ~l:~, \.!l'ilil <ft ,,~ entropy~ ~l~\!'i{J ~~t~ ~~ ~'(3' <tll:~' Thermody-
~'1l' ~fffi~~iI~ \.!l~'l'il(iI 9\tE~l m ifll iSft"t"ll mw ics.!l11 I!f~~ R~~ ~'ltt~ ~-C<tll:il1 ~~<Ii '<lu;rt~c-t~
9\tf~ 'ltWl 'ltWi ~'<l~ ~~l:~l ~ Dl:"'~, ~ttw~ ~~ entropy~ ~~ I \.!l~R~l:1l~ t,s9\~ f;1';§~ <tl'l:~ ~"'l ~~
~w"'t~, f<fi~ 9\U~fil<IirnC~-'<l~"f ~<tlM c;y ~ Rr~<fI1, ~ ~ttill ~ f~J{<Tit~ ?i'U1 ~~~ ~~J ~ c'ilttU~ t,s9\~
'(j'~ ~rn ~ C<fit~ 9\fil~ c;r~ I ~5[,#{ Cl"fl:Cli{~ ~~'" C'lt;1 9\~~~, \.!l~~ ~~t;1 ~<l~ I t,s'(3' ~"l1
f<m~, ~l:<t c<flt~ ~1 \!>It'iltl:W~1"f ~~ ~ oor, ~ ~ ~f%~~ iI~ ~i!t;1 <l~ ~~i{<fit~ \!>l'l.9\~'iIt'l.~~R<Ii
~"I~l:~ I \!>l"'~ C~ ~t; ~t~ \.!l<filftl!i'lt~ C~ ~ <lcSi{~t~1 R~~ I
~~ I ~~~~~ f<roWtC~ ~~<fi~~ c<fitl:ifl~~ ~~,~i11~~ \!>l~~~~ "f~ C<nfllii<li~i{~ ~ I ~~
c~t<li ~~ il~ ~,c;y ~·C<fit~ C<fit&~l:"'~i{l:~i{ . l:9f 9f1ffl:<l'1l''1~<Ii C~ f<1~<Ii, ~~ ~r~ tt@l:<t'lt'l
]
<rtful ~~m 9tc~, ~~~ fS~tQ~~ ~~1 ~~ ~~~ ~ ~<f.a'f9{f~\! ~~'f <l'C~"l Cl{ ~~ ~~: c~li1·~r~w
I.!l<fi<lt~c~ ~~~~1l: ~Q"I~ ~, '5l<l~t1l:9t~<l~i1 C~t ~ l.!l<l~~tfW~ <fitC"I l.!l<lifil~1l: ~9{~ ~~ <llf~~1 9{~<lti1
~"1 ~"1 ~C"I'e, ~t~1l: 'f~~ ~~C\5 ~~ I.!lC<fi<lrot ~~t~"l ~t~t~1 ~9{C~ <lf9\! ~tf~~~~c~ ~f<I~C'f~ ~tfil
~~ OUI ~t~t~ ~ ~ 'f~ ~~ ~<l~-~~$C~ ~~ ~t1 ~~t~m CVf"11 ~t~t~l <lC"IiI~~l{ 'f1 f<ti\~~ '5ltfVf~tfilc~
~tC"lt<fi 9tt~tc~ \!t~tM ~l~ ~<lC~1l: 1~-<fi~~ "~1~~"l ~~~ ~C~J~ 'ft~~<fi ~~~iI~ <lJf'6'f<lc-tc~~ ~
~fW~ ~ 'f~ ~~ Dt~~ <fi~1~tf~ 9ttt1f , ~C"l <f.C~, ~t~ f<l<l1rn I.!l<lic.ll<Ti~iI
~@<Ii~ ~1~1 ~ftI~tc~ I
~~C~ I.!l~~t'(j> ~~tt't1l: ~~ <fi1l:1
~~<fi I ~ ~ <lltf~~~MC<ll ~f~~tf'f<f 'f~~C9{ ~~'1 <fi~~~
~t~1l: ~t~ <fit~oftc~~ Clf~ ~rn~ I.!l~~I.!l<fi'f~~. ~'" l( O{C~,\!C<l I.!l~~f"l Iftt~iI ~tf\!~ 11l:t<fit~O{)c\!~~"l I.!l<li<litt"l
~11.!l<fi~ ~~.'f'Sf~ ~f9t\! ~ ift~ I C1f 'f~~ il1l:iltfr ~~1 ~"l <l~~1 <l4ill <ll~1~~~tc~,'!~iI
'l-Clff.1-fil"l"l ~t~t1l: ~CtfJ
9t~~1l: ~9{~~ ~~~ I ~t~t1l: xtt~ftI<fi xtfu. ~~ ~f~ ~J Qjtf~c~ 9{tt1f <I~~l ~~~iI <li~ I ~t~t"l ~ 'f<fi"l
~fit<fi 'f~~J<fiiftm 'f~~ ~lil-~J~~~ <fi~~ I ~t<1rn tf~ fflT<fi~1~C~, ~t~ttVf~ ~t5t~ <l'J<l~t~9{~tC"lt5i11<fifuwl
1W~1.!l~9{'ft~~ "It~ <l'C1l:,~~il~ 9{~<ltftl<fi~<lm ~ 'tfil<ltt~~ 'I<Ii"! ~~1 c.ll<fi~ 'IR9ffu ~~ <liC~, ~Qjil(uf'6'~~
~~~ C<fitil1l:t~~ 'f~~CiI~ ~<lt~~~ ~t9til <Ii~C"!iI~ (~tt<l f.\~~<liftlC'!<lttfJ~~, C'f~ 'I~C~ c~t~~~ f<1<1t~~t~
~~ 1l:~ <1lfim Kekrops iIt~<fi 1.!l<fi~iI9J..W~~ ~ ~ ~~tc~~ ~t5lil ~tQt~ <IJ<l~~'e ~~ ~~~C~ I ~1r98 ~ii;tt<w
~<lil<lit"l 9{~ffl '5lt~~ ~~<lt1l: ~tCVfxt C\til I fillrf~<ltfir'Sf1 . B. Lyall 'Itt~<l ~~~ Report of the Land Revenue
~~~ ~1 filcil'f, ~<1t~~~ ~"Ii1 <liC1l:iI<lfQ'l~1~~ tlement of the Kangra District ~C~ <lC"l"l"The change
~51il fiM~\!l~ '5l~~~ 9tf~'\5 ~Jt~c~ ~t~rn The D~ community of wives to separation is going on,
Civilisation ~~ ( a~ ,.~ ) CVf~~~t~iI Cl{ ~Q{C~ til polyandry will disappear, though it probably exists
c~~ ~"I, ~ 111'{S ~t~C"I1l:<lW?lC~~f~~ I.!l<l~
iI~ 'e a greater extent than is admitted" I ~~t~ ~1 c~t~~
<l~ f~~ m~I €iCil1l:1~"Ii1 ~ ~-~ ~~ mt~ ~C\! <lJfu-.~'\5~fu ~~C~~ I.!l~~ I.!l<f'~ <l~~~ ~~'1
IftQ~ ~C1l:"l,\!~~C~ '5l<lttf C~-fiI"IiI 5M~ I C~ ~t~\! ~~C<l, ~fff'e I.!l~~Q{t1l:<li~1~~u1 ~<ft~ ~~1 ~ \!t~l
<liJt9ft~<fi~<ltc~ ~m"l~~ <lMm ~<firn <liC~I 1 ~~1 ~~<l\!: '5lCil<liC<I~<lJt9f<liI "lrota'! 'Itc~c~ ~ ~rm
~O.
~ ~lr~0 ~t~ J. B. Fraser 9f~ ~~t"lt~~ . <R1I'i!it<f'i!iro~ I!ft'tl1t~ I1fu~ ~1l1 ~ I ilrnt~tl11t
~ct ~~if ~<f~ ~~~ Journal of a tour through ir1f <I~ 9J.~-~~~~I!f~ \5(t~<fit"lI!frn f'i!it1ftfti! ~~tt~ I
11l<li
the Snowy Ranges of the Himalaya Mountains ~9f K. M. Panikkar Journal of the Royal Anthropo-
~ ~~ ~~ C~t1~51\!~fif~t~ ~J<fl ~9f~J<fiW!~ bgical Institute (XLVII-~l -<.~~)-~11 ~<lI~ ~~ ~m
~'1~~ ~im~ Asiatic Annual Register 9ffui~~ T. ~~i{ ell ~~1f ~~t~1t1 \!1 ~~1f ~~~ ~<ft~ ~t~ ~ ~<f
:Jftt~ "Narrative of a Journey to the Diamond ~ <ti~~ 9fttll ~<l~ ~t~1f1 <f~<fl \5(t~<f ~f'5te1T~ ~~'f
Sumbhulpoor" ~<ft~ C"It~if Cll <ft"l~~ ~"It~ '4( ~~1fit9f CI1N~l~~ I
C~R ~<ft~\!l ~t"l~~ ~t~ ~~~l ~tt~ ill-~~ \5(tt~fil<lltit
'5!til'f ~tf~1f ~t~ '5!fiI<ft~tI1~~~ e'5tt~f<t<fm
~~"I <f1 ~ ~t"l ~ro~ ~~t1l1 ~~ ~~ ~~ ~ 9ft'€~1~t~ I Bureau of Ethnology1f if<f~ <ftfii~ Pf<f1ftct
~~~~~im~ R. V. Russel ~t~~ Tribes and Castes Dr. J. Murdoch f"lN~~if ell Repulse Bayt'i!i e~tif «fiR
Central Provinces of India ~t~ M~~~if ell ~~ ~ ~~ ~~1f ~t$fJ® ~f~~~ ~~~1 ~t~; I!ft~J<P il~ 9J?lf
~~ 9f~~ ill C~tT;~t~tl11l~<lt~ ~~ ~~~ i!t~t1f1 ~ 1w~t~ ~~t~fil~ ~~~l ~~"a: ~~t"lll ~1 ~~'e> ~
~\! ~9f51\!~~ (~~ ~'E;, 8~lr ~~) I ~t'€~"Itl1it ( 8~~ ~~ ) I '5ftt~fil<fitll~'e1f-9ffi6~ I!ft~ ~i{.f~T; ~t~ <ft~
llt~ ell C<fitif~~ 9f~<ltt1l1l ~<ll~ ~~~ ~<ft~ 'm I ~t~ttl1l1 ~t$fJ C<lltifilt1l1 ll~ ~~~ e'5tt~f~t{ '5liJ1C<fiji{
C~tT;~~~t~ C'I~ f<t<lt~t~ ~ ~t~t1f ~tT; ~tm1f1 C'lttiJj~C"ItC<H
~~\!) ~~<ft~~t~ \!t<f~t~tt~ ~~l ~1ll ~~ I ~~
~~<ft1f'Jfi~l ~~ ~ (Journal of the Asiatic Soo ~ ~Jfu. llfW~t~ ~t51t~ ~~ ~t~l ~~t"l e~ji{ l!t~t1f -ttRg CI1lSm
Bengal vol. LXXII, part III, pp 88, 90) I ~~ ~ "111 ~<f ~ I!f't~t<fl ~~~t1f Dta;t~<ft1f~1ItD1ff<f~\f~1tfN<ft11
~$fitt"l1l ~iJ1 ~lW't llt~t~ ~~ta; e51t~ C~til <f~ <f1~ ~ ~~t$f <fl~l ~~ I \!l<f~ ®t"ltt<f~ <fit~~~ ~ ~t<fll
~~i! Cl11il-~U<f~1f
~mt1t 'Jfi~~l'5l9f'f<flftl~l llt~ I ~~o~ DIm f<l~~<ll1lift~; ~<fi' ~~11 '5l~9f~~\! \5(iJ1 ~ \!t~~
I!f<f'tf-t\! Ethnographic Notes in Southern I_ ~ ~~<fPl <fi~ I ~~tllt~ ~~1fl I!ft~X\: ~~~ I!ftfti{~~11f
E. Thurston ~tt~<f~N~tt~if ell CDl1furti{.
Dt~\f1f ~t$jJ ~ ~~ (Tenth Census of the United States, vol vii~
9f1f<f~~t~~ ~~~ ~ti!ttI11f,f.\<fiT;~ti'l~t\f1f Ul<f~~~ ~ ~~Ir) I '5ft~~ \5(tt~~~i\t\f1l ~$fJ \5(t~~~ ~~ C'lfu
~<\Pl <fitit; ~~ «fiR <f~~~~ itt~ ill ~~, i!~ ~~ ~,,~ti.t111l~~ 9J:?~ '5ft9f'Jfil~t"ltt<fi1l ~~~J1~~~ '5ltil<fle~~;
~'1 \!t~tt<fi"~lItm~ I!t~ 1l~ <fifil~ <ft~ <fi~ ( ) o~ ~'Iol1 ~<l1li! ~~~ ~~"I ~wt~ ~~~J1 ~: a:t~ 9ft~t'i!it~I
Qlt~ -t'i!it~~ c-t~tt~ (~~9~~:~:) ~~~iVi ~9f ~1l ~~~ '5lt~~~'l 9f1f~it ~ti! ~~~ ~~i! -I <ft'5t,l1ttilit
~tllm ~~t~ C"It~if ~ ~J~ ~tm ~W~ ~~t1 ~ ~1l1l ~i'l~'5t'l <f~1f ~~ ~~~ <fJ<f~t1t~~ ~fil~l
~ ilti\t" f<t<l~ <fitit ~<f~ I!tt~J~ ifl~ ll~~~ ~11!f. (Bureau of Ethnology1l ~~11-t <ftm ~<f1l'l, -<'9~,
9fttit I f~~ f<f ~ f~ 9J.w~ C<fi~~~ ~iJ1 ~t~1f clIt )'~) I
,
f.I~ 't<l 1.~ l~~ c~t~~t~ Relief ~~ CW~~ I .,
~~ 9f~ 9ffil~ ~~ ~ ~t~H:',Dtf.~<f ~ ••
~c. ~(.<{~ ';ttfu<{i~'
8
c~~t'e \!l<tiffl~ 9f~ Cif~I ~t~t<f'e C<lxt ~
~t~ ~~~ ~<lt~ c9fl~a;~ C<ltif~OO~ttif~ ~~ I iI1t .~ C\tM~t~, 1.~t\tt<1l1~ ~=~e,~rn+~ ~~ I
'ent~ if~~ ~t~ fir~ <tlllt~, "fiI~rn s- \!l~ OO~ (physical Body) '<3 ift~<lirn(Mental Body ~(te, We
\!l<fi~1\tt~~ Tariff '5tf'i<f1 ~tm~ m~<lt~~~ if1 t" ~~A ~11:=~
Soul) ~~~1 ~e,<fit~-I.(l<1~ <11~t~~r;~rn
~Pr C'l~~R~~~~
~if~~ ~<t<t~9f~~('invisible, boundless, all-
C~<ft 1fl"3.~ ~ca;if I ~lttfu~ ~t~ ~~ ~ ,
t I C<lt~~ ~t~1 ~fD~ I" a;~ ~~~ <rot ~~, etrating') Universal Principle-!lll, <lJf'e"-~txt~<fi~"<\\"
~~! c<\t~~~! \!l~if~ ~tif, ~<1~ ~ c<R Tariff ~R q ~~lCf ~ ~a;1 '*
ll~<lt~~»t1~~~tt<f ~<l~\S:. ~Oft\S~:-~'S1,')¢l'
s- CDt~ ~t~ ~~ oo~tt~~ C'5\!i~Dca; c~a; I ~' filf.I~
\!la;\!l<f ~'6'1 ~tl:~ ~~ I <1'ica;,"\!l~ \!i~~ f.lfil~,T ~~m ~'<3 cwM~tfi, l~rn~ ~ CWt~~~t~ ~~~
CJt~if DCa;c~ ~~ <1a;t~, "cwt~t~ ~ Q{t~ • ~ (~~) fctifM~ ~1 ('There is existence after death') ;
<1tf~ ~t~~ m~ f.I~~ I ~t9fM ~~ \!l~te{ ~~ ~ rq~~ 9f~ \!it~tllC\t<1f<fi~ ltt"3.~f<fi~ ~t~~ ~~ C9fxttl) f<t;~
\!i~ ~t~R CWt~if f~ f' s- ~ti{~~ ~ ~ ~cm~~~~l
'This existence is effected by re-birth-strictly speaking
Ci{~, f<f <1"lt<1if~~ <f~ 9ft~fWtif ~ I a;t~ ~~
by palingenesis, within one of the five realms mentioned
~fDt~ ~2-c~, "~t9fM \!l <rnt~ ~tt~ ~~ ~~if Cif_-U above'.
CW't~fiI~t~ s- ~I:a;~~ mJt~<lJ ~~~ 15l~
~~e, C\t<1t"ltt<fi
C\t<1
~~-CW<lxt~~ ~'1,
~rn't1~~, ~tift~ I" <1t"lS- \!l~ m~C~~ f<rt~~j~Ic."'l ~~ ~Jt~tt~ ~~ ~t~-~t~<l xtm ~~'1,
G-lI ~~ G- f.I~~ ~lttt~ <1ta;~"l~ I S-Jll
~llf~ ~"?l<fit~tt~if~~ ~-~~~~ ~11 ~'1,
~ti{~a;t~ ~t~ \!l~~if <1'¥ ~~~ ~t~ ',c~~ I f~f.{ ~llf~ C~ta;tt. C9f'lCftl)
~~-C~~~ ~'1,
~t~ C~~if I ~~til1 C~~ \!l~~~ C<lt~1~t~ ~ ~ ~llf~ 9f~t~tt~ f\!i~r~~t"l{-9fM<l -t~"?l~~'1 ~ I
~t~'e ~t~~ ~t~ <\\"~1
~~t'Sif ifl, ~~<1t\t~'e ~ I Ia1 Five in number, Sari putt a , are the fates which may be-
\!l~ lft~<f ~i{I:<\\" \!l<\\"ntif~tcfa; a;~ Ver l af~er death; namely these: passage into the hell world,
anunal kingdom. the realm of shades, the world of men
<l>too~a;if, ~~ ~~ ~ ~tt~ f~ 1 a;;5 ~PIlI
the abodes of the gogs-M. N. I, p. 73.
~ ~, "cDt~ ~~ c<fi"f, i\'(~,~ I f<lt\titr~ta;1
~~<fi1I 7il~'1~~t~, ~ ~W ~~~ ~Wift~ '<3 ~~-
f<t;f'
<fi1lt<1
~ ~'\!i ~ft1~1 ~~9\1l <ffi1~t~~ ~, \!l~ ~\!i1l
c~t~l C~<fi c~tQ{t~I.(l~ 9f,¥71~I ~;r I.(l~~ti{- ~
~9ff.l~\t1I~9ft\txt ~~iI)'[ ,
~. "'N ama-rupa together with consciousness' constitute the individual ( ~ )
~
C~,
~H 9ffil~
~-~
1'bere n 0 ••
t~1{" ,~n~
l!l~ ~~ ~t~~1 ~'lt~lI ~t~i <f1l~: f.i~. .
tion.
Such and such the fresh weal or woe I underwent.
. . I
..rT my life's endmg. Departmg, once more, came
~9f ~~ l!l~ C(f~~t~i1 Clf~t~lI ~~i ~\!: '!itO).ffi~ ~~~'I "as no ••
~~t1I ~~cf~~Q1~m\§l(qt~l "~\!"il Cl'Q1Tt'l\5l1
~9f ~5OfI Cl'l:1I( . e again elsewhere. In such wise I remembered the
~~ ~9f~ \!~l:\!), ~9f ~'l1J\511f~~ m\§Jt~ ~fi1i1 f~ teristics and particulars of my vaned . lots 10 previOus
. .
~ C'f<ll:Q1t~
~ll2t~t9f~l:Q1t~ <11~~t<f <f1 ~Q1tl:~l1 iS~ _~.r~R~tl,\,I, p. 38.
<f~ (~w~ "~~11~ <f"lJt~1I~ ~9f~ \§~ f9f\!iJ~~1 ~t~~~ 'l1~~ 1.Q~9f ,~~~' ~~~1 ~~CVf<t ~~ 'lllC~ l.!l~~Q{$ ~
<f1 ~w~t~ ~~~.,pt( ~OO'lT<f' ) o
~
*
I
<ll ~
~ ~!1fll~
~ ~
~~
(~~~1
~«i ~
) ~, ~f.!'l~<!I91~
'<l~§tf'l<fi ~
'~-e"""
:Ij~~ 'lIIttt I
hieindividual m9f) ~Ciif iSfLiif~${ f~ ~~ t1t~'1 <fC~-~
~«i ~ '&<!Qf
mfil<fi i!1 ~. m~ ~~
dl ~ .!If\!i~ ~ ~ ~llC~ ~l\' ~${ ~fll<vl l1t~'1<flC~-<fl~ <t~~~t~ ~, <fl~i{
'l~~-Of course the extreme in the direction of untainted ha •
~, ~~il ~t<t'1~, <fl~ ~~~t~ ~ 1*
as is s~id to ~e found within the heavens, we easily agree with,
c.ase, thiS much IS clear, that if there are heavens, according to the la"
tlOn, there must also be states of the opposite extreme, designated
·~ ~~~~
~'*
~'tt'l, Oi~ ~1~~
~'ttlI 9flI~m'l1 ~<e"ti.W'l1 <!<:'I\~
~'l/1 ~"9j~<!/1\i;~f\!i~~ ~
~~ dl<!~
~<:,
~qf.I-<!tD"9\f\!i Nc$ 8~
whatever form we choose to picture these states. (p 112)
~
~~ti~
dh~ i{f1lMetempsychosis-'5l~~the 'C1f ~~ 'fIlS'5l~, ~~ ~tt<t 9,i~ '5l<lJ~" f<f;~tt<t?
of the soul after death into some other body ~~. 9fi:lf<l~~~, f<luf9l~~~, ~~\! ~. ~~\! ~~ I
meta = change, and empsychosis = an animating 9f1l T ~tWt~f~~t~\! ~ I f~~ ~'Jfi <.!lr<Rtt~~ ~ il1
~~ 1.~Df<t~~i{lCft1i;'c~t"l' (constant and immuta . 9f ~ror1~, ~ ~'9i ~~'! ~t~ i{~"l{ ~~-'5ltm
1ftf.lti;~i{1,~~i{ ~t~n1 ~ti! 'It is an utterly and , ~, f<tU9f.'5lt<tnt~"t ~-~'5t~ ~ ~ I ~ ~~-
foolish idea'-~~i{ ~~t~ ~t'!l '5lf1lttWil:
C"Itt~t'€il:'!{1\1l1 f'-~i{ffW <f't"t~~ i{<ti{<t~, i{<ti{<t~ I
,
~~ut~ ~~-~~ (our real essence)-~~ '5l~~ ~~~1 ~l'1 ~~ ~~t~~~: ~: I
~:~~ 1J~0{1ffO{: <rm~~~ ~t~t~f5 II
~t'!lt9f~~, ~~ invisible, boundless, all-pervading -¥, ~1~1~1r18
f<I~tro ~i6>~tlCflt~~..-~ ~~ ~m~lCf(the adapta'
~~, <.!l~
~ i{<t~'flt-( CI!t~J~~<t:)'!t~nt ~~ f~ !
specific purposes, by the body (i{t~9f ) of the uni tlfO{tif~
~~ 't<l~31~1(<!t~l~~: ,
consciousness )-,!~i{ Metempsychosis ~~ 9J?tlt~c~ i{<ti{<t~"ll. ~~:~: ~~t~tt<t~ 9fil:~i{: '5lt~~<t,
~~t~1~ ~~tl! 9ft~ i{1I ~ ~ cw~1~~ ~~ -iS~~ ~ W;'Jfi~ ~, ~llil: i{<ti{<l ~t'flt~ ~ f<f;!
~~~ i{t~-i{~"l{ - ~~tt<f P alingenesis ~"II ~ ~<lrn'~~1'·~~ 'the indestructive germ from which
(Palin=again and genesis = birth). Palin-genesiScd the new individual arises each time.'·
J
tltf.i<li'aj~a new birth, the development of an individual ~~tt~ i3:~~ ~t-.t~ ~i{f~i{~iSf <l"Il~~~t~ I
in which it repeats that of its ancestors. ~ ~~ 'aj ~~~;rt~~~~t~ AA ~N'~O{f~0{,-~~1,'II') 0
~~lft~'tJt<f ~<tt~nl ~~~ '5lt~m ~ ~?\~~ <f'tf1 ~ ~~~: ~f9l ~.:-~R1t ~ m~ (m ~~) I ~
? ~lli:, ~9\_, OS ~ ~qft~AA~~,~9\~ OS ~~ filf'li~,~o$ 9\"ll~'J.-~~
l{llfl~1 ~O{OO9\f\3 ~~ ~W~l~~ -~~, ~1~1~l1' ~ 'Permanent Atoms' ~ ~ I
<tJ~ ~~ I!t'iC~~<tJ'6"~~m ~~il ~<t~ As regards Reincarnation, it is probably a mistake to
e that the same individual whom we know in bodily
~tt~ I ~ ~~ ~~C~ ~t<tt~ ~~ ~~~ ISVRl ~~ I l1\.
is likely to appear again, at some future date. There
~~ I!t'i~, ~a'IT;~~ ~ ~~-'5li{tfff <lita; ~~C~ ~/ .
1be exceptions, but as a rule that seems unlikely to happen.
~~c~c~I 9J?Cll~ ~'l(t~~ - il<ti{<t~'l(, ~tllt~c~~ ~ 1fbat may happen, however, is that some other portion of
~tf<1I§t<t,~~t~ ijp~ 'e ~~rn~~~ I die larger self becomes incarnate; and if so, it would be likely
to feela strong affinity, though often in a vague and puzzled
Palingenesisl!ll l!tt1rtfft~1!'I -.1, with some other portion which had been embodied pre-
(!j~ C<IPaliJ1genesis-l~CW<l <lt~t~ ~~cm tioUsly. And, again if this second incarnate portion happened
~~t~~ f~ <tC'ii{C<t~ISC~~'2Jt~~Jfif~ ~\1C\~<ttlfr
wtaf toincludesome part of what had gone to make the previous
individual,then there might not only be a sense of affinity,
~~c~~~9ft~ ~Wxfil ~~~tc~ (!j<l~C#\tt~i{~t'e~frntl{1 bat some kind of reminiscence, some memory of places and
wxf~f<t~'e~~t~ ~~~ I rroundings which had previously been familiar.
Even Hume, through 'excessively empirical' as
hauer calls him, says in his sceptical treatise on 1nm
•• * * * •• *
that this system is the only one of its kind to which phi How large a subliminal self may be, one does not know;
butone can imagine that in some cases it is very large, so that
can pay heed. It is also, according to Schopenba
itcontains the potentiality for the incarnation not only of a
postulate of Practical Reason. p. 108
lIICCession
of ordinary individuals, but of really great men. It
~~ ~'i~t~ a;~ ~~ Making of Man ~ ~ wouldbe a mistake to suppose that Dante and Tennyson were
~'l(t~ll<tttWll~tC'itDil1~ft1mif, 'i!t~~ ~Cil~~ (!j~ Palin reincarnations of Virgil, but one might, though presumptiously,
~t~tll'e ~~~fvi'i! I ~ ~MiSt~ "l~~'iil, We are e
imaginethat all three were incarnations of one great subliminal
lelf,which was able to manifest itself in different portions,
us larger than we know * * that each of us is bavinga certain family likeness, though without any necessary
partial incarnation of a larger self ~~~ '5jt~m W bodilyconsanguinity or inheritance in the ordinary sense.
-The Making of Man. PP. 1'70, 172
(!j~ f<t~t1;~ll#\~{.\!)~~~ 1!t<{)t1C\~I c~ti{ (!j~ larger
sciousness (~t~ ~~) ~~~~ ~~~~ 9J,t~ ~~ ~lJrn~MiS~ 'i;grC<I~tt<l ~~C~~ ~~~il ~ft1ta;il ~tm~
~t~~<{)t1C\~ft1~tNa; I iSt~ca;~ cw~t~· ~~ca; ~~a't._ ~~ Pa]ingenesis(!j~ ~~~ ~~ ~<1#\t~~~ i{~ f~ !
~ #\~~ (individualised consciousness) ~ ~~lft~ ~ ~. ~~
#\~C" ~~~ ~~"l-~~~
'5jf~\!) #\~~ #\\~t1l~ ~ ~t~1l1cw~~t@, ~~ ~ #\\~t~ (Round of rebirths)
~~~ <I~~~~~ ~ ~~~ ~t<tt~ ~f<t ~R~ti\~ ~tij'
I ~R ffiR~~ <tMmt~il-
~ft1a; I ~fi1a; 'e C1;R#\ti{C<t<ff<t~~- C'l1#\t~-U~~ Through not understanding, through not penetrating the
'i!t~tll I!tW~ ~t1l'l 1* noble truths . 0 Bhikkhus , we have wondered round this
longjourney-you and 1-(from the beginingless infinity
*~~ill'1fit<l'Jl.,~ Group Soul ~~ elf ~~ iS~ ~~. ~
the past).-~for~t~ ~-~o
~~;rt~l1\~t9f ~~tN<Kl1~ ~~tlT<1
<1tG'fol,
~~ ~ ~~ ~.<rt~1t ~~ <1if~ <I~ 9\~~-
·Whatever there may be, hretheren! of thin ~ ! fu~Pi ~t~~ ~ ~~ ( ~~t<l'if)
and not created, the hightest of them is the destructiota
I~ 'f~fi{ ! l1\~ ~t1lt~ '~ffp{' ~~-'5[~ I ~
circle of Sansara" ( ~~Jft~oi1F) -~~~11 R~t~, II, p. 34.
~lJt~ I ~ ~ '<{1t
~f~~ ~t<1 ~' I ~,~ ~~1
QI~ ~~ ~f;{ ~t* ~~f'f" 1lt~~9f~ •
~~ f.Pl~M~~-C\!t1lt1t~<1'($ (9f~~) ~( ~~tt~,
getting out of the circle of rebirths, out of sansara
~ • ~~t~'-c<A !
supreme goal of all sanctity I ~ ~~tt~~-E ~t~~~ ~'C~ ~~t~~ ~~~ ~~~-~ ~t1lt~ ~
is in a position to determine whether he shall be
or not I Qf c,,~~ ~~1 ~~1l1t ~~~ ~ Jft'fi{
• ~1t~1R~~1
"'~ ~ ~ 'f.r<l<lt't~~~~~' '1!l;r9f~tPrR~'t~'-
<1i~C<1,
~~ ~~m ~~~ ~~C~ 9f1fit<1(has the po ~m~1
making a future birth impossible.) I <tit~'1,
~~9f~,", ~~ '~e.'
There is the possibility of protecting ourselves AA 'R~t~ ~~'-~tt'11t R<fl1~, ~l~ 9\~iStlft~,
inscrutable essence, against a repetition of these pr '~~~' <1t~-~c1l1 ~~~ ~~~ ~~c~ ~t~~~ I
future time, that is in a new existence.
~~, f.liif~ ~t~~ R<fil1~~"IJ-
AA Jp 9fC~1tC¥\lf9f~r~ ~t'1 <1iftlt~,~f.I~ t~('''{'1' ~~~f.Rt9f~~J\t~;; ~fi{31fu 9ff9~1-~9flf
~ fil"ft~1 ~~ 9ftfu<1~- ~~~, ~~'Jli~, ~ro~R<1il1~f~-
"Rebirth is exhausted, lived out the holy life,
what was to do ; no more is this world for me". or, lUI
1S9t~ ~~~ ~~ f~ ~~9f~~'1~-~~<t~,t~
said in another passage: '(unshakable is my deliverance AA ~~~, ~R ~~ <1itll-a,~t<1i
~a, ~~ <1if~1
is the last birth, there is no more becoming anew."
on 9f~~ ~'5l~ ~
~0{1~tf5, 'Wl~~'3('5fi5B~~,~~~ ~~9)~~,
R?f,~' ~~~1,~"Pf ~ ~~t~~ I ~~*~t~ '5l~<11
~1t~~ ~'f-
-~ ~t'tjo{ ~~1~~ ~~t'tjo{
~~~ ~~",'J( R:~~ ~~~tc~,~~~ ~~f9f'!
~ 1.S~5~ 9ff9~1~'ll.lfuI
<1i~~~~<1Pt~ ~~~tt~-~t1t C<1it~f<li\ ~<1fit~ ~~-~ f!f.{ ~cm1t ~fu.~~~~R <fi~~1 <I~tl! 9\~~-
~fllrn-It is finished-Consummation est. ~ Cll ~~~ 1.S9fN~, Cl{0 Offu ~~~ ~~ I
~'5ttfilil ~~~ ~t~l ~tfi{ QfO\.~1c<fitf9t~ ~~ II
~~ ~t~ ~t~l ~~ ~~ 0I
~f.Il1\~ ~omt ~~~ ~tt~~, ~~~ 9ff~I'"I~
~~ ~~~ ~tf~ <1l~ C1l ~9f<f~ ~~ n -~f9f~~,-o
'~~t~fiR.' <ltftI '~t'ft~' ~(~~~tt1t lIt~ 1~~t~ ~ ~~ ~:~ Of!! <1l~~ tttm1 ~11ft~ ~~ Ofll-~t~ ~<fit;Q'l~
~(t~ AA ~<l"J!.'O" -~n~t1t l1\~xnl)~~
'5l~ lr{~1tI ~-~t~~
'It'll' ~""l~ ~t~ ~~ ~ C~lf ~~ I ~.. ~:.. ~t1lrn
~ c<l ~fu1I~tmtll~9f~,t~1 1l~9J..~~1 f5 1.tiOr~ ~J-l{lIf: 'e ~: ~~ ~tfi{ ~~-~~ ~~~ m iSt9f~
lffl~ ~ll'lt~~~ ~~~ ~fil '3lt'5fi't~-'3(t'l1i'l ~'if,')~
,ion of my equanimity)
~9(i1\t~ ~~ "'9\1't/ ~il1, CI!~f~ ~ •..
'~t~ 9ft9('( <111>J,'tJ)~~
~~ ~t~ 'e OOC~~'!i{~~-I!it~tt'$\1 iI1,_~1<lifil~ ( ~~ ) ,
~~1 wc::el
1!it~~Rs[fllj- ( 1{~1{fi{~~ )-1{R ~ ~ fi{f.{ fil~tt't~ C'!t~C'\~?f~, ~CVf<l ~i:!i ~t~ ~<I~
<lifij~ 9f'tut ;n , 'tude) i!l~ ~ ~4'iI~ftl~tt~iI-
~~ ~tt~ D cwWl1 5 ~1 D ~I!:
~i§,~ I qd ~~~ C6 c<{If~~C<ttlf~ ~ ~f.IC01 f5 9t~t<ltf~, ~~~~ ~
)'jt)'jt"lt~~ ~~t~,~11!11~~ ~l{ ~'t~ Il ~ 'Ifo\f~~f~1 f\§ 9(lli~tf\§' ~~~ cD c<tW~~c<ttwf'! ~ ~f.\1i{); ~
,
~~i!l~ f~~~~, AA 9J..~?ft?f~~- ,
",~PI\§; ~ 9(~tiltf\§, ~~f~~fili\§1 f~ 9(~t"lt~ I ~~~~
C5~~ ~tlff\§, ~ ~f.\ootfl! 9(~~t~, ~~t~f)'j'!1 f5 9(~~tf\§,
~uP ,UP 9ft9t 9(~~ ~~ ~t~~tl!'\ ~~ -
f~-~~J, 81')81~
'1~I)~
f ~~,~
~~~~~.
* :J ~~~
~ .is
~A!);;r~~ 4/ ~ ~
.J
A ~ :! ~ :w.~ <tl
;=:r .•
~ .t; ~
-+
41
w <iP..!J(;f>~.t; ~4/i
~~
~ ,~ <'I ~ ~ ~ 1i 'r;
AI ~
~ A91~~~~j _ :!ll ..!J
~
* - ~~
~~~~~.
SQt
r;
~ <a
~
• ~
ft
:il
(;f> AI
A91
- 2!.
~
A9I
M~i
~~~
~
-+!tS1
!:!~
~
,.uV'
:tP ~
';A1)
S)~~~- ~
~~
~ ~ <'I ~ ~
~ ,.(91 ~ ~
~ f1 I~-+ -+~ ""
~ ~
~
~-+
>Qj
t~A"
~ tt ~
:;i>(;f>§J.
~
jJ
Ho 9ffit6~ \qj5~~ IS ~tfi1lftt"~ '<l't<1r ~t\
~,
~~()~Ci! C<ll~·~<fil·~tm ~'e \.£l<fi~<fJt9f<lliSfc<f ~ 'ljf~~~ ~~ I
\!A'!, flf<lJ-Iff~I51--tt"ll ~Cil<fi ~~
f<fi~ <ft~f<fi~ ~~-\!l~
~r"il~1
15~~ ~ <fi~i{1-
f~~tC~il-iit~lf~
~~~f1r~<ll ~Ji 9ft~~l ~~ ~rnt~ ~ ~~ ~ ~<fC~~ -l~Riitlf C<lfvrf.-51~i{C<fi
\!l~il'(3<qt,~ <fiftt~l ~t~tc~,
C~ ~~~ C<f~ ~~ ~ijCi! ill 9ftfifm-~ ~~ Jf~ ~~~"I9Jt~t~~~'·\!l~ 1{~iW1 ~fi{ ~~C" "~1{toTr<f~~~~"-~
~R ~lJ-IJ:c~ 9f~ ~~C"Iill ~~c~t~\.£l~ ~~<1~ Jf~~ ~fiI 9f~r~ ~Cil<fi <fi~i{1-~-t~ 9f~1)~ ~f1{~1 C<ffffw
fuftc~il ~t~R<li ~tc"l~ ~~<fN~~ ~~N~ \St~, ~ _J 9ft~-iif~tclf~ ~C~<l~ ~()i{1 ~i{tmc~ ~~~~ ~~~
clfm ~~J C~il ~~t~ ~t<1~~C~~ C<fitil~Ci=!~.~t~ ~J~t~C~J~ ~~~~1 "1115 <fifitc~ 9ftc~' ~c<1 ~ ~tfVr~c<fi
'~~mi <fi~tsl <f~~1 ~~ <fiffi"l~ ~ ~~t~~<fJ 9ft"lil 'fl1 (ll~, <ffir~, f<l1t~<fi) ~11{~1 Cff<l <f~1 c<fiil!-c<R
~~9f~ PT~C~ ~i!il 9J.~C<fi 9ft~~1 ~~t~~if~~ ~Ci{ ~ ~-~tt~~ ~c-tt1lt"lJ 9J.~t'l-<fif<{~
<fc'Jl>tC"lfc-t~
~t"lRf~ <fi~~1 ~ T
ltlftil~ ~~t~"I, ~~ ~~~'($ ~ <f"l1 ~fil W'6>~'6"1ItO{ ~ lItRtC<fi{-C<fN<f ~~ <It<flJ~C~<l1lfi, ~ ~A-~"I, ~9f
il~ I \.£l~m ~t(!f C~<li f1r~(~if~ ~-c!ttf~-tl';f.f'! ~11 <fcf~t~ f<l~~-~1.'(3 ~~tffl~C<fi ~t~~1 ('<fif<l" <f~i{1 C<!lilT
~~R~ ~~ ~ <f4'if1 ~fif~l <fi~<fJc-t~ <fi~~tc~ I ~ <l1"itrm<f~ ~t1{~1 ~~c!t~C1{ <fR i{tt1{ ~~ <tin, ! ~
t1l~9f ~<fm 9f~C"I ll~t<lif<ff<fi<fi~Ci!if-i.!l~ ~lft :ljfi!: ~~-~~tc~ ~~~ C<ffff<li~~Clf~ ~~1 ~OY, ~ftt, 1{f~~~
m~ 1{Cil tstW~ ~~ I ~C<f 1{~t~~~ ~t<1J iit~~l <fi~~t. ~~Ci!~ R:C~" ~tt~-~~ 1{M~~ ~~~:c~~"~1~"J-
filc<f-t ~~<!ltc~ ~~~tt~if ~~tClf~ 9f~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~hll <filf1f9f'(3<fC"Iil i{t~-<fMC" ~ i{t~ I <rMnm
C1{ttS~ <fi~il ~~ ill' ~~r<1"1t9f \.£l<f~~~-f<f"ltc9f ~~1 ~~ 1{tffl~ 1l~C~ ~~-~tcil-1{tffl~ 1{f~~~ ~~" R~~
~~~ ~:~~r\! iit~~ C"I~;ft~" ~~<lJt9jf f<l~ ~ ~\! ~~~tc~-\!l~ ~iJJ~ <f~f<ti" <ff<{- f~ ~fii i{'i{-~~
f.l:~C~ <f"l1 ~ c;r~ <fif<l~ ~tc~ ~t1{~l l1l1{if \.£l<fi~jf1f\ iI'i{-f~R <fif<ll ~t~ ~1of~ <fM~ 9ftftt-<fif<l ~t\! ~~"I
~1f-~~C~ ~-9ffif~Jt~ofr ~~ ~~~~ c-tt<fi film ~ ~~il1-~~"t ~~c"t 5MC<f ~-~C<fi ~~ 5f~<ft~ ~~
':'~ 1{~7fF) ~~l ~~ I ~~lf-~~J ~if;fm ~-tt~ l8f 'ltiS '<1iijC"l~ 5~c<1 i{1-~-mc~ ~il <tin,m ~ ~t~C"I~
~t~ <fit<fJ·~~ilC<fi~~<fitt"l~ ~ ~~ftt\! <fiftf~j~tN~ , lfilt~ ~l-<f~-iltc1{ ilt~ ~~~ ~c"t ~t<fi1~ ~-~ ~~
~~"?f <fit~ c~rPr~1 fr~~c~ 9ftc"?f.,I ~~tm
ig~~~
1;;C<f
~~1
~"?f~m, iS~~
M<fC<fi-m~t~<fi
M<f '5f~~ =
~~
f'it<tC<fi,~~. <fi~~K~_
.
fii'l?f
\e.
=
.,J
<!l1!~~~t't~.~t-t'll~ <.!I~C<!t2lti!)J'f~t<liQ9(~ 1!Q"l~Wft\! \!~t~ ~'f1
~~tt~ <.!I~~ i!)'If~~~l"'~t<li~ ~~~t~ ~~~t'lf <.!I<\~
'1!~"fi!)
~~t~ /<:5t<\t~~
sitory and critical summary ~'If~ ~~~tt~ I 1!~1i!)'If"!t~ ~t~tt'lf~
,,~O\t~, <.!I~ 1!Q"l~~1 IS ~~Q~"'tcommentary ~t~tt'\f~ f~~ 159(~tr.:~
ttfJlt~<!l<\~C<\'lft~t~t'tJ~~~t~ t2lr.:<l"l
<1'ftl<lt~
~~~ 1!~~~1 ~ftlt~ I
$t~~ ~f~~1 ~~t~ ~t-\1~, i!)~~~,\ ~~t"l~Q ~ Ilt"fi!) t'I~1 ~t~
<1 ~~)j~ 1.~~f5i!)~~~t~"l f<1i~~t-II'<l~0\1-~9f1fJt~ <.!I9ftfJ~ W~ ~~t~
~ O\t~I ~"l~~ IS ~~t~ ~~~t~ I!il~<\tt'lf~ <.!I~-9(~~t~"t
~~~'\ ~~t~~ foI~·
P I.!l'lt~<lf-t~~t~~ <l'ijIS 'l~t~t~ ~\'<3" 1l~"lD~ D~<ir <.!I~,<.!I~~t"!~
.~ ~~\5 I ~ \5l~~tlffi!)foIf.,t~ '1!~ Il~t"tt~~~~~1 f>f~~ I \5i(~%\i!)
~~ ~~t<li~ 9J~t~Jt~ <.!I<1'1S
')~O ~~~t~ ~9(~Wt~1 ~~ 'l~~ 'l~~
m~ i" "It is a summary, expository and critical of all the
sixteen padas of the sutras. A clear idea of the entire sutra
teaching will, it is hoped, be got from it even without going
through the annotations and their translation." I <.!I~
~~~~f't<ft~
m1 $r.:~~Clll~<l~f%i!)~~~t~ I
I!~~'\ 1f~t"l~t2l~t"i!):~t5t1fJ "t~~~ "tt~~~ <:5WlJ~ ~~~'\ <1'fit~tt~~I
r.~ 'l<f"l~"l ~t~, ~tt~ ~tt~ ~ ~-~~Q ~tlfJ f\§f.{ f.{t~~ 4~ <ft~~1
I\~~tr.:~~
I ~~i!i~ t2lWi!) ~Jt~J~ '1!'4r.:~~~t5ttfJflft~~ ~l:~J ~"l~'\
~iW51f~tr~: I ~i!)<.!1<\ \S~~<!'\ W"lC~~ <.!I~m9(~~~ ~t9ffiS' '<f~1
~ 01111
~~ <.!I~'l~~~l:'tQ<.!Ii!)
~'\ 'l~-s ~~~~ ~<:5tt<l~15~~ '<ffitCi!) 5t~ I
JI"9\t'lf<f~~t"t~ 'If'lf~~~Mt<f ~ft ~H'\-~t"'tl\'l~i!) <fftll:i!)Ol, i!)l:<l9(~C<f~
9ft'll'~l:i!iQ~~~wt~ ~~l:t1 ~~i!); \5lt~1ct'fit, ~r.:~Qf~l\ 'l~~~l:'\ <.!If<l~l:~
~C"lt~~ ~~l:<l~I ~tQtlli"'t\5l~<ltt'lf~~tt~ ~~ f~~ f~~ ~~ "lN~
~., I ~~t<li '~<1'~'\' "l'i\f context \5lt~ ~Pl~l;§~~tt~, Ill>9\t'lf<f
~Q\<\1
~~ Il~~t~ ')\~I') ~<li~,~~~'\' "tr.:'i\f~~~<lt'lf ~f~~tt~~ section <.!I<l~
0
,'(r )'{~'Il~9(~3(>;ji
e<f<\'1\!l~ ~~~, f'!iR ~-~~~-f'!iR ~~ unit ~C~,
unique I
~9\f.r~c"\f~ ~tc"It5~1 ~f~t"l C'If~1llt~, ~~~1 <!l~ 1\~'IfT;"tC<f~
~9(~
~ 't~ f't~"It<f, C'If<\t"lt<f, ~'S!t9\~Cejt<ti IS ~"'t~ 'i\"t~ ,,~t'5~ I
• ~"'tc,,~ f'5O\~ ~~-~~:, IS ~'51 I 3(t>;jif~~f-lt~1 C"lt,,: I \!l~
<::!)'1:
~.,t,,~ ~9\c~~ ~/<::!)11~~ I ~t~t~1 ~t~tC<f 3(>;ji\"t"l~, f~f~ ~ 3(>;jiC"ItC<f~
'I'll'll" (Presiding Deity)-~t1ilt'51t~ ~'-~l:IJt'll''\ ~~, ~~~C'i\~ 1\t'5,
"I~ ~~ ~~t"ltt" ~t~tC'If~~~9 3(>;ji~ ~~, ~~t~1 ~<\'ll.'6' ~<r~t~ f~~"t"l
~~ ~f~~' ~t~~"~fU C'If~9ftt'5~9\~ 'f~"\f~ '''<\''11' "t~ ~f~~,-3(>;jiC<\~
~~ ~'<\f~ I ~~tc~~ "<\t"l f<\T;"\f~:-~r'6'
I ~t~ \!l" ~~t~ W'6i ~tc~-
~~t~ O\t~ <Qi~r~J~' <Qi~W'6'~ ~~<lit~~1 C'If<\ll~ ~C~ 9\~ ~~ ·~U~~
~ 'fil~~~ ~~~1 ~ 3(>;jiC"ltc~~9\~'5 ~~, <!l"<\~
3(>;jitC'S~~'<\~~ 9\1il~ C1j~
Ciltc<li
~<\~to\ ~t~~'3(>;jiC"lt~t-t'i\1\~f~, C;~C;~'t3(>;jiC"Itt~'t9\~t: 9\~t<\t~1
~~~-<!l<\~~t1iJt~lC~ 3(>;jit~~~\5 9f~3(>;ji-m9\
9\~1\9\t~ ~f<\~ ~o\ I
~ ~"!~ ~ <fit"!
9\~: ~¢~ 'lr1i 1-'lJ~<\i, ~l\!ol<,
I
~o~ ~fil5~
f~~ (~<\J$~)-'!lt<f~~ "tf1r~ ~~~ I (f"t. fil. ~..-t~
f~<\1'-~tR I!It~ <.!l<f<\111
~C~ C't~ <f~"1t1fI ~t~ ~'l~tJl1
~1 ~filf~ ; ~t <.!l"~ 'i~cl ~~~ I "bMc~fli c'!t~t~ 1!IIDw1"~
I <.!lclltC'l' (l't~ ~J~
~tt"ll C"lc<;fC~ <f~~t~c.,t~ <.!l~~c~ ~
'!lltt51~flfc"~ "c~,,~ <f~~1 <IN CIf'Sl1 IS~ ft~J C~ll"J '!llt~tlf.
~~ll~l I \!l~ <.!l<fi~ ~~~ ~tc"11~c~l, ~ ~c'" ~51~ ~mi<fi~l ~
if"! Cll"''lt~ I!I<\~~c~7;<:e11 <.!l<f~c~ <fi'~ ~ ~ltl ,~., ~~t~f~ ~7;1I~I
<liIf'l.~rei1l1, ~~f~ ~.,1 "f<\~t~7;a;1 <.!l~I!Itc51 Cifc~f~ <I'CIt
.,11 ~1<fl <.!l~C'tc~~ f1rc,,~ ,,~~t~C"1t~ C'l-t ll~~ ~l~ I ••~
~~.,t~.,~tit ~i\f~ ~c~·-
Q! 'i1i~a;tait~ ~ Ra;'PPtt~t
~~9ftt'if
~~fttril ~ ~ f<til~-R~
~~I
~~t~ll .
~f~~tl:fJ \!l <\{9\ij5~ 159\~t5tT I \!l~~ ~~~ $~91~ <1'Q(t-e c<l~~
~~ I f<1'~ 9(tI5M~ ~t\5,{~~<i1 ~t'$<f~ \ Qlt~~ f\!lf'l c~fiI 'If ~~1f~
~~~~f<\~~~ \!l<{i~ C'Il~o{ <\~ ~~<\tIf <t't~'1 \!l<\~ Cl{C~~ C'<R'Itt~t'ln
~~t~t'l~~~ ~~~~ ~~ <1'tciif~t"lt, ~t~ ~t~ l:fwtl f\!lf"i-s ~~tfo{<f 9f%~
"niS <{it~t~O{I lltt~~ <\{'1t~ ~ ~~\S f<f'% f~fo{ fo{\!lt~~ <\1fe;5t~
lpltt~tD"t~ <ft1\o{\ ~T.'1~~C"l '5l~(Qf~f'l C'l <{iot1
~tft~\S <{it~~O{'1~t~ I
<\~t'lt~"'I1, <\;ij"ltO{'111t~~~ '1t~~J~ ~t'lt~t<\ \S 5t't'l~1\!lt~ ~tl:fJ
~<:;~t~<\Wf~ ~~~l:ft~ ~t~ \!l <\~t~~\S ~~~ I ell <u<\~t~ \!l '5l<l~ '1~<l
C'lf<\~~ 9\tl5'6 f"w~~<1' \!l<\~~t~31tl5~1'5l<\~ ~'I\t'l <t't~0{ell C"l~<f 9fnr:<1'~
~rou '1~, 9\t~<\5~ C"I~t<1'~~",1 \ 9\tI5M~ f5f<1'~1jl\!lt~ ~t~ f~~ ~f<\t'lf~
~J <H~~ c-l~' \!l~ \!l<ft$~1 'S '1t~"H ~n Active Anthologyt\5'S
~~<\T
l' '1~t~t9f <\O'lt\!lC*~ <l{9\~5t1l f~fo{ ~~ f~~ <{if<lt';f~~~ ~fi
'lt~('\<{it~t~o{~t~ 5~fo{<\5t~~f<l~ <\~<\t~<\tlf~ ~f\5' <(i~~t~f"le ~~
lfll~t~ 9\i!?t"l C5tt~ 9\i!?t<\ 9\tI5C'9~ ~f.I~ 'I'mi ~~~ ~%<\tlf-ell
~t~ C9f~tt~~ ~f\5 foIt~ ~~ ~l) <{i~t<:!1I
~~<\tCIfC'l<{itt"l C"Itt'l' fO{~~1t"l.t<t'
i!l~~%<\tt"'f~<{if<l<:!t~
C'It~t'3.~ melopeia, phanopeia, logopeia, ~t~
~'11 \!lt9.9fC~~t'l ~~ C<!9\t~'9 ~t~' C*~'1 dichten-conden$are ~t"I'e
~<\% ~1 ~t"l~ \!l<1'~<{if<\\!i1 ~~ '11\ \!lt~ti!?1,fti~ f"'t~ ~~ <\~ ~~t';f~
'll!f\'~~~~t<1', <{i~~t~ \!lt~ ~f~'ll 0i1 ~"I\S, 'f<lDt~<{itt"l~9ft'l\i l:ft~OiIS
~t1\ttlf~ <1'f<l~t~f"l ~9\~t~ ('if0{, <5l~~tt~t5<f, l:f~tl{~ ~tf~, 'll~ <{i'l~J:'1~
9(~~ ~~t '$ <5ltlf,,(r;<{i <lif<\\!lt~ ~\!i<{itliJ <\t"l' ClSt<\C"lWt c~~t ~~ C"It~O{,
~~O{9\t~'6 ...~~t~l \!l~<f blah <\t~' ~~t~' C'If'lI
~<\~ ~~ 'ii:<fl~~t~ <5lW<{iWI'S ot~\!l 9\tt~-~~f"l~ f'l' <!t~
<\~~tt~~ ~ '1'1 \!l<\~iSJ.t<{it~~ <11<\t~~ <\1<5lt~t~"1.f<1' ~~ 9f~1l 18'6' ~ ?
...
~t"6tt(J G'\t~...t~1 ~~ \!l<{i1S<f~~ <5l'5J~iit~-l!\~'ll~~ j <{i~G\, ~~ ell ~t~
~f~~1~<{if<l~1,\!It ii~, ~t~ ~~I ~ <5lt'lf"1'IS-<\tf<f<{i~t"'f~cQ\t<1'~~cf ~\!l~ ,
tt~ ~f<\~t~ ~'1, f~~~ -s ~~fiI~ \!l<1'~,<5lf\i3~~t,'\~ 'e f~ filt"l' '1~<l1
9ft~t'9~ ~"IJ'§3t., CllllO{'CDR<f ideographic '5l~t~~ ~<l ~tt~
<ftfil~~~~~ <f~t';f~ ~~~t<f 1jt~l{T <1't~, C\!lllM9\~ ~t~ C<f~ ~~Oi-
~~<{i c~t~t~<f ~t~~ \StT.<\c'l~ ~~~~<{it"l <{it~' Oit5~ ~~t~
.,
>
~. •.••
- ~'. _ :-- •••••
- ---:-----:::-; •••~ •• 1 r :- •• ~.~- -;:~-~ • p • __ • _
- -...... .
8') ) ~'I!I•• 9ffi61 ~')~
1\~~ c~tf\t<ll~1~~f\ i\1, ~~t~ ~~f\ Clli\ ~~~~ ~~~ ~\!-l\t~ \ (..~ ..•~
~ ~tl\ ~ftlt~ ~t~~ ~~t~ f'!fo\ ~~t~tt9\'~ i\t"l~tt~ ~to\\ ~~-~~tt~
1!"1 ~'"". 1<~1'"~'"" "J;l\~'i1'< ~. r"" r,,~,,"" ~1''''''
"I\fu
lli I ~,t>l ~ ol1 "" •••• 1\1 ~111 lrt"l•• ,>\1n< t'fW\1 f,,~"
..-it
~
~; ","'>1'
'l:"" """"
"11«-"'''
'l:'" "i1,,1<'\11 .,," :;;".....
<OI~~" ~
r"~"'" ~1ffil
~ ••• "r"ll <lfil'o I
c~~tfelg~t~
11t1\G'j-~'~ l\~>09\t'"
~l\tt ~~ ~f~~~1 'Ilf.lt~ ~~~tf~r~tl.{
~~t~~~ ~~f\ \ f\!fo\ f.I~tfil~ti\l ~~tf\~, IS ~t9\\~~1 '1.M~~~~ ~
~ >\1'1.<1" ,-'I.\ "''' O\WI< l'i"," r" 'IfoICm< •• ~""'1< "'"'" :;;<iI'I,,"
.<1 'IV'i .I!
~
,_< 011'601 >:\1". r.'l11" ~"" ••1~ 1<\'l1 ~ •• rfl
~t'i>{qtfo1~tt(,<2\l\ Dtf\ ~1 \ c'If"O\HI'lfttt 1\t~t~~~~:f\W~ ~1I~tl\ ~~t~t1
~~c~t~ 111~~~~~O\ ~f9\t\! f\tf'l\t"'~ I f1\f\tO\·O\'l\t~ c~tO\~. l\1\tt ~f~~1~
'It~~J~ ~f~lj ft~tf\~ .:~~ l\ft~ lIt~t~, ~~t~t~ 1\t"O\~1
~~~~ ~~J
~t~1~ 1li.~<\~t~ ~tSl<ll~~tt, ft\5tf\~ ~~ ~t",~-"If you feel like that,
for God's sake go back to England and do something."
~~ ~~ <\9\'~~liillf\ liiMt\5 ~~ C'lf~~lf\ "O\1-1\t~t~1 "l{t\Wl fliifilt1
'I1tf11tf\~,
'e ~tfl\t1 fort"6g ~f~tf\~ 0\1, ~t~t~~ lI"'9ftol"O\tt <\tf~~ 1i.l~-{it
('ItC'l~ ~~ I ~\ilI"1< <01''11~J1fi; "I1fiI11 ~". ~""1 ot1C'ill >Jml~
~~~111"'9ft"lft~~1\t~ <:et~,~<\"~i1O\tf~t~"O\~ ~'S'\\tt~f\J~ "lft~ ~tO\t~t~
'f.It~~ ~t"O\~~t.1 '1$1 f"lft1
f\tf'\tf\~, 'e ~t~tt"lf~~1l1fi\~t~<\t~~tttli 1\tOl.t~1
.t'l\~~tf.l ~t~~tf\O\ ,
9\'~tfGl'! 1i.~<\~ c"'t~ ~t~1 i\t~~-~~ ~t~ f.tl\~ <\1 ~~tt.
9\'~t~<;; ~ftlt\! 9\'tf~ttt~ I f<;;f~ l!\~<\~ (,'lft~tO\~f\t",~-~~<:!1-~~~
oo.tO\, ~~t~ ~t~~t~ ~~ ~1\0\ ~~~ f<\t~<:!t~ l\t'Jlit~9\'t~t<\AA
.t~T 1I~~ <:!t~tt. '-f\J<\~ forc~"I {itt'S 9\'tfiIt<\0l.' .t~J~ 'e ~t<\J-
~ttf\t5Ol.~~~~.'S <\f1It~,~'\\tGli\ ~<;;1~f~~1 1li.6t~f\f~ ~~t~ <\tll ~fit\5'$
9\'tfilt<\~\ f'l\<\l\O\, '$tt~ ~~<:!' ~f<\~ ~",~gj~ l!\ <\t~'rt~~ 1W~ ~\!~
'l.~r.•• '''il :;;$"
9\'tfilt4'\ l!\~
I .1'11" "'~
c~t.tO\ <\m 9\'t~'$f~ -utt ~t
'-~ '\If'". ~111
(,l\<\~~~~l:\1 9\'t'$'\\1 I
:;;,.1' «'lilt""
m
~~1 1I~'$ ~f<\~1 ~~tt~ ~lt'it .~f\ \ (,<:g~O\l\t'\\t~ ~~ 'C\~9\it~ 1\tl:\J
~t'C\ito\~mt 1\tO\t~t~\5t~ f~f\, 'lff~~ lI1\ttGl .f'C\<:!t~~6f\~' f.~(,<:g~~.
'11111<~r.'G1I"till ~~ .••_" "r•• o\t1iI<f1'l~om"'" ot1C<! 'fWli"
~t.~ <mI<:!t1i.t~~ttt. <\~ 9\'>'5'tt\5 ~~m ~1f<llf\'e ~t~~ ~'l\J f\t~
~~f\ (.'\{~ ~ \ ~t<\ ~'C\i~~ ~~ ~~ttf~f\ \ ~f.f5t~~ ~~
~ "'" ~'1 ~~I' ~ ,,<I<~ f61'<~" ""'" ~ '\fu<O
~'l\tf\~~~, 1I1\tl ~~t~ ~t"'t~ ~~f\ ~t~iS'\ c~"'~t~~ 1I~\!, fil~ ~
""''''" ~<Ol' 'iii", ~•••.••
-0I"i'l 'IiIl ~f<."r~-
\tf,,~ '14.4
•
~~mf~.,
I \ti~~ ~ilfii ~Jt~i5t~ ~t~~, ~*,-~\tin ~~"I ~~ Whom even grief neglects, but on a tomb
She mumbles (which has now become this room)
I!t~h1'<l't~J f~., i5t'6't~ ~~~1,~ 9f~\tit~~~~ ~~~~~ I ~f~ Her groping moan of pain.
I!t~~ f<l~~ ~t"l f~., I ~t"l~t~ ~~~{ <l't<lJC~<l~~'l~~ ~ Pain 1 Can lie be that wily ghost who creeps
<l'~~il~" I From corner to corner 1- Then he leaps
With pinch, thud, grip and yell j recoils and weeps
~~ ~~tC'1 9f~~ ~<ltil~
Waiting to leap again.
~~ e<l'~t<l' {f~~l 9ft~t.,~, ~f.{ ~~<l'tG'\<l'tC<lJ~~ Oh the dull mirror! Never will it hold
~~m~"I; ~t~~ ~fu~ <f~~~ ''If<t''1~~1
~C~1 9f~t~f5~~ ~1 A ~ew reflection, less deformed and old 1
15f~~ ~<l"1~~I "lft~ ~~ ~'t~'18 ~t., ~ ~f\!)~fo;ift., ~I Roll up the long scroll, far too long unrolled.
~~ ~~~ "Ii I I!t~h1' ~~tff f~., ~'W- f<l~-t1f~:~~~'lt<ltlf I ~ Throw down the toppling stone.
People move out, move in, all far away.
c"1m~~t~-f.f~ ~~t~l ~~tt"lto"'t~ ~til~t~ ~ ~~t\! 'l.f~ ~Jtt~fiI.
Is there a difference between night and day?
~~ ~51 ~~\! ~~." l!1~t~ <l't<{J~'~~f~ o"ltil ""til ~'t~~~~ ~
In which direction move the hours 1 But, stay!
~~ I ~t~t~ l.f1f<fi~~tt"11<fif<1\!)1,
~t~~ ~tt'1~ M~\! I • Who groaned 1 Ah, me ! Who groaned 1
\ti~'1il~il '<ff<{~
'<ft<lJ~'<ftt-t ~t~t~t~ ~~~~ 15f~~.,"I11 ~
f~tfD~ <fiPf~1~~~ttllj~ "l~9ft~ ~~t.,~ <fif'r~ ~<l1'ii"tt~~t~\! .-ro.
~~ ~'<ftt"t~ ~1~ ~t"lt~l ~t"1il ~~~ I ~ f<l~c~~t~t ~~~ f~9f f'l~
~~m~tt~ I I!t~t~ ~c~ ~~tt\!) ~<l~~ <l'~t'<f ~<l'tG'\~tfft~ Clf~~ U I
~cm~
\tit~, ~~I:l~~tt., W ~~~n "lft~~ fo;~ll~ ~ ~~ <firo-~t$~
~'<ftllj<l'~~tt~"I ,
;rt"l~l ~t~ ~'ltC<l~'l~ ~~t.,~ '<f~ f~'ltt'1 ~~t"l I I!t~ 11~
~tfit~51 ~~lf~<l~~, ''If<ll1~~t~ilI 1t~ l.f~o{~~ <l'Pf'5l ~t'til ~
'1f~~l 9ft~., \!)~O{ ~~ ~~~ "llift.,~ ~~<fi~, ~~~1 ~~., elf ~'<f~l ~
O{l~~~1~~~\!) ~~t\! .,t~., I '<fh1''l,I!t~t~ <l'f<l~ll!t~t~ ~~tf"<fi '<ff~
51~'t~~~ ~~t\ti ~<l't~ ~~:l I ~f~~tt~ f<lDtc~~tt'<f ~t~t~ e~ .•~-
lft"1~ 15f~'i~ <l'filt~ ~ ~~51C'<f '1~0{ "~~~to{" <1"11~'I' ~Q
~t~ l.ft~~ ~~O{~~~til~"I I ~~~ f.I'l'il-~f5, ~~M\ti 15f~ '1T1I1~
l:St~1,'ltlft~'l-e<ltlf~J ~'ltt<151-~tO{t~t~ ~~t~ f<f~~ O{~I I!t~t~ fDW~
~~, ~tN~ ~ '-5i~~~ 'It'<ltt\ti ~t~ I I!t~HI <t'R~1 ~~ ~~t~
~'<ft"t I \tit~ ~~t~ 1ftffJ ~~ ~llii ~'e"'I:lIl.ft~l 'ltlft~'t~: 9fn-~t'<f ~
<l't~; ~t"lilf Clf~0{11 ~~ ~~ f~fO{I!t~t~ 1~<l~ ~51~ <fif<l~'f~'l~c~'111
\ti'\,. ~~ f~~l 'l~ s ~f.I <l'f<l; <fit~'1~t~t~ ~~~f~ 'l~J, ~<lt \!t~t~ ~.t1
15f<l'9f~ ~ ~<l5l<ltO{I c<l'ttill~<f~ <l'Pf\tin<fif<l~~til~ ~ 'l"1..9lfi1l~
0\1I ~,~'l, ~f"~1;-~~ ~t~ Bitter Sanctuary <l'f<l\ti$ ~t"lt~11.• fflo
"t~~ ~~~'<f$! ; ~~ e'l~ ~~ttii ~ ~ <fi~l~f5~ ~ I ~~ <ff.f:5t~ ~
I!t~~ ~~tt~~ ~~., I ~~ <l'f<l~~~ ~t5l1ljlfJnMR~ I Bitter Sane-
tuary~ ~tt'1 e~t5l-tlfJ1 ~ffi~~~ ~<l'~ <fi~\!1~< ~ <l'~1~~ ,
The Sickroom
A wrinkled hag beyond the reach of gloom,
,
On Rising Early
In the legend of Troy where was 1,
Rising early and walking in the garden
1 was, in the person of . Ajax the son' of Telamo n. A n d Od ysseus cheated
B~fore the s1;mhas properly climbed the hill
me .of the pnze
. of dead AchIlles' arms. For he subo m ed T rO)an ' .
captives to
HIS r~ys gi,lding the roof, not yet tbe grass '
testify that It was he who of us all had done their city the most harm. Angered
That IS whIte with dew still,
by this, I drove Troy's whole forces single-handed from the field • B u t h e covert Iy
And not enough breeze to eddy a puff 0f disposed slaughtered sheep in the place of the dead men that 1had strewn behind
, the meadows a thick m'ISt 1ymg
And out in , smoke
yet me and so fastened on me the name of madman.
And nothmg anywhere-ill or noticeable- In the legend of Robin Hood and his Merry Men, where was 11
Thanks indeed for that. I would prefer to be written down for the Sheriff of Nottingham, Robin's
But was there ever a day with wit enough enemy. But the natural truth is that I played the part of jolly Friar Tuck. 1
To be always early, to draw the smoke up straight took and gave great buffets. I was the gross fool of the greenwood.
Even at three o'clock of an afternoon In the legend of Jesus and his companions where was 11
~I was not Jesus himself, I was not John the Baptist, nor Pontius Pilate,
To spare dullness or sweat 1 '
nor Judas Iscariot, nor even Peter. I was Lazarus sickening again in old age
Indeed, many such days I remember •
long after the Crucifixion, and knowing that this time I could not cheat death.
That were dew-white and gracious to the last
In the legend of Tobit, where was I 1
That ruled out meal-times, yet had no more h~nger I was not old Tobit himself, nor his kinsman Raguel, nor Sarah, Raguel's
Than was felt by rising a half-hour before breakfast daughter, nor the angel Raphael, nor the devil Asmodaeus. I was Tobias, in the
Nor more fatigue, Where was it then I wandered'
sight of the towers of Ecbatana, with the gall, heart and liver of the fish in a pouch
A stranger to my yesterdays, with steps
by my side.
V ntaught by the sage past 1
~<rt~ C~:£l~ ~ dl~ ~~~ 9\~t~ ~flltfl ~C!, ~ ~~1 ~~~ ~l,l
ell ~~~ ~<I'\ar<li11'l ~f<f, Cll"<:!t~t~ ~~ <l't"l$~ "~~11 ~11'lt<e~"~
<fitll~ ~tll ~~fl ~~tM\5 ~~l,(t~, ~~ ~\51 Q{ $~t<fit~ ~<fiW't~ ~~'S
~l,(~-\!l~ "'t~<fi!i; ~\iJ~\iJ l2t<fitf"l~ ~f,,~1 ~~$t~ 9(t~t~~ 'f\5~ ~
l5lt<l'llcj<fiftl~t~fl, ffl ~t~tt~~ ~~~11 t!\\§~ ~ (.ll ~'i\'11 <\f~t"l~ ~l,( I
~t<1l ~'i\t\§ ~~~-l!l~ ~~ "llJliltl!t'i\J ~tf,,<:§t~ t!\~ $~ I ~Q\D~~tt\§ ~ot-
~N~~~"l "l\iJt~ l2t~~ ilt~\§ ~<I'S I c~ll:~~ ~"9f'{(t\§J 1Itil ~l,( ~~11'l
<fi~\!i1~f5~ Cl!il ~<et"3l~ 9\t~~ ~'i\ I ftl~~lInl ~~ ~tst~ ~~tt\!i ilt~ I
'i\~~ c,~t~~ c,,~~~~t\§ ell mf.i1l1 ~~tt<l' ~w'1 <fi~~1 ~M'l,(ttfi \!it~-e
1ilf'"l~l ~l,(t~ R)'jo;f-~~ttl"'t~ 9\f~~ ~""ttf~1I ~tlJ I ~Wr~~~~r~~
<fit~l-l'j~lll t!\<fi!i;l2tlltO\-~l,(~ ~tltil\iJ~ -tlt~1 ; ~~i\t~~ ~<fitt"t <\t\iJtt~
Cl(il"'~t~~ \5{~~~'11 ~~tf.l<f <fim\§ ~~~~ ~\iJl ~~~ ~i!?~~1 \5ltt~,
<l'f~l ~~tt<f ~9!~ R:x.ttt)'j~ W!1 c<\t~\5 lI~~<ett~ ~cj ",fill,(1 c:!~f.I
lI~t~ <fitt~J ~x.ttfl'\~ <l'fit~t~ I <et~t\§ ~'lt~ '1tt'i\ ~t1; dl<l'~ ~t~
dl<l'!i;~~t"l~ ~~-C"!t<e1 lOf'i\t\!illc~~ f~o;f-~t~t~l~ ~~~ ~C!,~I 1J!:'i\~ ~
~'i\ <fi~ ~ <l'~ t!\ ~~~ 9\~ ~tcj <eftl~ 'i\~~ <l'ftl~il, ~Q\tf9f'~ 9f'~
~!i; ~~ I ~~~t~ <fit"J·)'jtf~H
1>J..cf<;!il,( t!\~ ~~9!"iit~~\5 9f'tfl\' dl~ ~l,(~
~"'~ 9\f« I ~~t~ $t~~ ~-~fD<l't~ ~pt~ CDt!l\'t."lt~1,l1C'IIt"! Qf~ m
il~-In December, In Moonlight, The Spider, An Old Road,
\$~ ~~
The Last Leaf, The Dead Bird, The Flood, The Burnt Leaves
~~8~ ) ~-~st >!)~t
~ ~.~~ ~ ~~~ 9ftUl; f'1'~ e'lt~ 'ltfVf~t~ '<{~~ ~ ~~~ ~ f<l~~'1 <!l~t\! <ffit'! <ftt'lJ~ ~~-~'l ~ '6fiI~
soclahst, fem1Dlst~ humanist ~ <!It'lJlI~lltc~ ~~ ~ fil1l.~~~ <llt'1' e'1'~<!lfi~l ; '<l1;ift~'<rt~-<2\~~\! .• wml ~ ~ "S -mi<ft
i,s~m~ I ~~Wl~ <!If<r~~'1 5~C'! <It,,t~ ~t~ ~m ~ .•fftt C'lt~~ ~ ~"Itoil~ D~~ %~"l~~ ~~~ ~lli i,s~~tt~ I ~tll[~fil~~'~~m
~~fi1~ ~-~~"l~1 ~ ~~"f~ ~~~-~m!l1 f.lm ~if ~1 ~ jI'~l\t"~ ~fu<f~"t~ ~t~ ~t1lt~ ~t1I31~ 9f~~N'! ~~t"l~, e~ ~~~
IS ~~tf<l'1' "ili9f G'jt~ <lifilm ~tc~; f'1'~ \!l~ <lt~G'jt~~'lt~l1 l1lfl fWlll <ff'f \!l~ clI(t'1'-~tQ\1~1\t~ <!lfu~tt~if, 'lt~1 <ftC{J~f.it\! ~
~tf.l ~C5~ ~ 't'e>~,-<!l~ Cll RC~~ ~t~R~\!it~ ~nfC~I(~ ~CiS~~ ~~~tt~ 5t~ ~<ltif~ ~~ ~:t~ C~~~~ C<l"f~tt~tlf,~~~~ <$lt~ ~
11~ ~tiS~m ~M1,ltC~if \!l'1'Q/1 'l"l~ 'lt~J! t;!C'l ~Wffllf~ ~ ~ ~tt~ ~~1 ~~1,!~ ~~<l, \!l ~tlI(l ,,~1 ~~t~ if~ I
i,s9(111~ ~"l~tt~~ ~t~~J ~~ ~~t~ lI~t~t<lC'1' f~f.{ ~~ ~tr~C'! ~.
~tf.{ ~l[~ ~~1,ltt~if I \!it'S R~~"if1fJ Nt~ '1'film e<lit~t~ e~tQ/t'S ~
e ~~\51-<lt~"lJ C"f~ f"flltt~ I \!l~ ~<lt~<l'51 ~~1l1 €~t~ 'fn1 ~
5fi~~fc'l~ lllfT'~~t~ f~c~~ ~lflltc~c~ <!l~~ ~~fil'S' <!l~~ ~~1If I ..:
q~~1-<l~"ln ~~ <!l~~ c~lI(<lt~~ ~lItif lIc~t~t'l'S f~l~ ~tll1! ~qcm
- The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam
~ 'e 'li"1~~ ~t~~-<!ltC"l \!l"ili~ ~~'4 <!l~ '1't"t<!lt~~ ~t"ll "'l~11
-By Sir M. Iqbal (Oxford University Press).
<lim"! <ft~'1, e'ltlf~i, <tIH llCif <!lfil1,l~if CllR~~lI fVf~ Nm ~~~
~~C"l'S ~~ <UFtUlC<f ~~-~~lIto{-~lI~l-ll~~ \!lClftll(~ l"l~ ~tlf1
The Mystical Life-By Roger Bastide (Jonathan Cape ).
~~ "ll~ ~>:f1~~~1I ~~C<li\1 I An Examination of the Mystic Tendencies of Islam
. 'l~9jit~ ~~ ~<m~~<!f~~nl ~mi ~~t~ i§3t~Ql <!l~ ~~~, orm·~~ in the Light of the Quran and Traditions-By Prof.
~~-~:t~~ ~~ ~t~m ~fiI5i Ql "f~
'<ffol~,e~ ~lIt'1 ~'it<i>t~m 1Itt~~ ~~~ I M. M. Zuhuruddin Ahmad Andheri (Bombay).
~~~~~'1 <lti\fJt~tlfJttll~ "~tQ/~ *Dt~"lI 9j~~fil<!lt~ 9fm~~t~~ ~ ••• The Transformation of Nature in Art-By A. K.
~:~ ~t~'ll'1 ~lftift;!~ 9(it~wf~~ ~Tilf1fJ; f<1'~ ~~11~~~~ <!l1W~ Coomerswamy (Harvard University Press).
9fit-~~H( c<ftto'1G'jtf"l~~~~~ ~~~:~~ ~7J9(~~~ I em~if 'ltNn", ~
~t9\t~ D~lIm~t~ C~1"iftfJ~~tt<t ~otc~t~ <Ii~l ~t~, \!l<f, 'l<l tr~
~1Itt~~ 1I~fi{;i[,C<lm <l~~ ~~ Cll~~ 6tt1lJ ~R ~CO{l ~~m~~
lIt~tlf~~)jt'f <!If<lll~t~ll'!tC'ltlf ~31'\!~ ~~~1 Clf~ fiflltc~ I <fR~ ~~~f ~(;" 1ltl!i \!l<!l~ ~"l ~~(;~, \!l'~~ \!l<!l~'e if1 f(~ ~<l ~t~t~ fWtllI
~Qtll i,s9\tt~ ~'1$ ~~ <l~, \!i~~ \!it~ ~f\5<!ltl,\~~~t~ ~t~ ~~i\f~ 1ltl!i1
~~-e~'ttll 5~~~M~ ~~t~ ~flf~\!i~ ~~ I <!It'lJ~RC\! <fQ/t'"'ift~f.{l(~~
<iitl1~~tl1~1 ~~tG'j~ \!l~ ~~"I C~lI~~t~'l\!~ ~W~ \!l~ <ft<lJ~tf.l i,smmt'tJ 'S i,s~~t~ I ~~~ i,s~t~ ~~ ~t'1't~ c~tl1 ~l,\, f<!l~ 'If<!t\!t~ 'll'f~~~'1
~1,l1 ~~t<t I 1j~'l ~"t~~ f<l15~ 'l~tt~ I 11~~1 'e ~~ ...
"Itt~~ <ft"S (~~ \!l<l.t~~Mt~
~<l~~ rn'1' ~ e~~ ~~tc~ 5tfil9(ttlI(~ e~Tilft1fJ'"NC<f ~~ Ql f•• <ltG'j~-ll~t<!lrn \!l<l'-\!l ~t~ <!l~ e~~.c~t~t~ <!l~ I ~t~ <l~~rQj~ \!l~
<f~ ot~t<l ~~1 ~tf<l<f I ~l'S 9(il~lI elf "ili9f<ff<l \!l<!ltt<lJe ~t1 1jllttG'jt~l <f'll~, 'Olt5~ ~t~J<f <l~~tf.i~ ~'4 1j~tt"lt5if1 'l~<t, i,sfD\5'e
~Mmt~if, ~t~t~e ~"lifl f<l~"l I c2t~t1l~ ~t1jt~ C1{~lN"l \!l'1' 6ttlU if1l:- C<ltlf~l,\, f<!l~ C1l~~~ i,s~~ ~1'§ Cif~ I ~~t~~ <It'l~"t~~ ~~ <f~t&l'l-
~~ .• tt"lH~C\ C1It~'li"1t.;'t- ~tlft~'l~~ ~tmll ~~ ~if-mlft"!'\ f<l~ ~~ '1..~<l,~~~ ~t<lt'" ~1 ~~
~t~J<f <l~\!l~ ~1fJtlf1 ~~tt~ ~Q/<!l~lltt"lt5,,1 M~<l I \!i~ ~ ,,~ I
~~ c~ ~il 'ltO! '1:Qf ~ <rot
C'il ~~, '1:Qf ~~ <rof;
~tt~ ~ Rtl,\ ~tt"lt6if1 ~<ftQj \!l~ c<lill~<!lt1l~~51ijt~ I ~tqi~
Clit~ ~"l'f1I ~ $fI~ ",,'il
"ffiT 1- 9f~ ~ ~~<m~ ~to2t~t~~J~ ~ClfJ \!l'1'~<!l~ ~~<ft~ ~~if ~Qj I f<'lS~
IftciI1! 'llltm llt~ ~1, \5!~ <>tuf ~, \!l~ ~1 C"f~~ C~~ tf~~ ~wf'!~ ~<f ~~1jf~~1j1, \!l~ ~t~J ,,1 ~
~ ~'lt\ ~~ ~ 9ft~mnl <lt5t"l~, ,,1 ~ ~r~Rw~t~ ~<l~, if1 ~~ ~f~<ltt1f~ ~31'~11 ~rQ/~~
~t'Wl lfl~ \$I '{<ffit~ ~~ fu><t, ~tfGt'1' ~~<l'{t", ~ \!l~ lI~t'5tC<l~ e<1lt" <!lttfJ.'1't~'1 ~ ~7J9(g if~ I
~ ~ ~~ (irtQf (~ iii 9ft~ lWtl
\!l~ -e~~<!lJ <If't<f~~~tt~~ ~(~~\5 if~, ~-'l~lI IS ~,,~t~t~'lt<!l
~'il iSm~ ~ C'il~ m~-
'" em ~ Qft~ ClfttQf ~~ ~'tt$ ~till
~~~ ~~ .,~,,(c~~ ~tf~~ C'I<\" <f~t"tif1 .,~ I \!l~ e<!l~~G'jt'1' f.I~,
~o
,
,~8~] ~.-",m~ ~t
[
Cl!~R' ~t~o;\51, ~~ tlf'f ,~~ c;\51lR' ~J~~\! ~fi;JlJ ~C1~ ~"t'\-
~~~~, 9fIfIfM~ lffittc!i~ \~Jt'SJt~ ~Q'j~ ~~1 ~'.{I ~~ il~ ~
<ettC~Q'l~ ~I)~ lIff'6i ~t~ c~tut ~CQt'1~\5 <1~I I:!tt<lf ~;;~ ~
~"I~, ~"l1 <\1~"'J ~~ ~C~C'l ~O{ ~~fi{~ 'l.'eJ~ ~l:'f ~
i1\.,1ft"l 'l'eJ\5~ ~i~\!1 ~t9fo; 'l~'l' '-5\t1/~-lj'eJ~ lfttill <t'lltt-s ~
~~tQ'j~t~ ~~ 'et~~ ~~~ ~fl:! ~~t~ ~1I)cQ'j I
~Ci\~ ~tfill i5t: ~~<\tc"'~ ~f'!l9ft~ ~i\ ~~-
~c~tt9f 15{~1If ~~ C~C<If~il \S f~~ ~C~ ~~~ ~
DC"( ~t~f~Q'j I ~~ ~(~~1 ~~~ m, ~.,~
'If-f0{ ~C\5 ~~(~
The truth is that the religious and scientific processes, though invol-
ing different methods, are indentical in their final aim, Both aim at reaching
IS ~<1t'lf~ 9f'lfN~~~ttil~ ?f6~ 't ~
~ttft~t'\ ~<11\5I Pl~'" 1If1!t<WtCI! :he most real and to both the way to pure objectivety lies through what may
<lflltOO~~~ ~ttft~C't~ <fitt~ ~~ C~ <1'lfCQ'j,15{~(~ ~Q'j <\~~, ~l ~ be called the purification of experience.
<1t~~, <1t~~ ~~i\ '<{$I,I5{tlf-f<1t1f
~'" fi~tM~l£.l f<lf~ C~ ~I5JI!1 ~~ Ql~
~~ ~~<1JIS~15{{9f~~~ <fi'~.,t~ ~W ~f\B~\!tt~ ~fo; c~9t Pl:et'>t
c<l'til ~~~ fD~~t~ ~~ 9ftt~ il1 I I:!t~ ~C~ ~ CQ/C~~. Aliotta1/ ~
<fic~c~.,-as a natural fact, significant of the ~or~ally observa-
~~S1 Idealistic Reaction against Science <ett~f~", I ~C~1/ 1It~'t
ble behaviour of reality and experience as slgmficant of the
~~ ~t\!ful;~1~~ ~~~,I!C<1 f\i;:j ~ f<tw~ ~9f 'tt~'\~t~~'" ~ ~ 1k9flt
inner ]Jature of reality I ~~IS~ ~~ C~ I5{f'e~~t~ l..~\!)o; 1lt0\~<fi'
'l~~\Bt., ~t~C\ <fi~C~~O{~'.l' I
~~to{ c~~'t11
~r.il1/ ~f5 ~~t~~ ~~t~'.{ ~
IS~<l' ~~.,1 't~~ ~c." fq~'hlS~ ~~ C\!~o; 15{~t1l~ I5{t~ftl<f~t1f~'$ ,
~ (Jft~'-s 9f~1 IS ~9f~t~~t1/ ~m 9fN<1'J~"" f<fi~ (<fit;; 9ftf('l ~ ~t~9fl iSt: ~~<\t'" <\t"'t~-
. Th 't'fic and the religious processes are in a sense parallel to
~~o; CQ/c~ f<1f~:{~~ fo; I f<t~il 'l"'~ I5{t~tClf1/~tt~ ~lIf'lf~t9f ~i{ e sClen I , h' d'ff
each other. Both are really descriptions of the same worl~ wI,th t IS I ~r-
~*I:,~~til~ ~fD~ ~m~I f<fi~ ~~t~~ fllf'fjitQ 'R~tt~1/ ~t!Jf ~
ence only- that in the scientific process the ego's st~nd pOint ~s necessa~ly
~~ttlf~ 'l~~ f~1 ISCiRt ~9f~1 ~~t~ 'ltfil~ ~'" I ~t~'\ ~~0{1""~ ~'Sm . h 'the religious process the ego Integrates ItS competing
exclUSive w ereas In , . k' d f
~~o; ~~
~~~1 ~~~
~t~ ~
IS mechanistic
C;;~ I '-5{t1f~1<ett~ ~t~t~'.{ ~.,f<t~...,.~~~~
lItilt\Bt<fC<l'~'\ <fi't~~ I
~~
"'t'e ~\!~ ~rn~ ~t~.,1,
I ~t1f~1 I5{t~Jtf~<fi Pl~tt~ ~'l1 <fi'ftlt~ f~~~1 C~C~ ~~
r.. tendenci:S and develops a single inclusive attitude resulting In a In 0 syn-
thetic transfiguration
~~ synthetic
of his experiences.
transfiguration~ ~'" 'tc1f~ ~ <fi'ot1
- ~<I~ ~~-
rrc~ f"'tt~~, o;~il o;~il <f"'<fi~1, o;~o; N'S~1!3 ~\!~ <fi'~& il1; I5{t~ttlfl ~W~ iS1: ~~.,t'" <\~to\ Psychology of ReligionC<1'-f<lclIf~'!l: 0\<\ ~-
~C~J ~t~1 \SC'lft""'~~<1~ ~tt~ \!t~l ~riS~~., ~'t'l
9fc~ ~~~ f<t~ttol~~ f<I§tCo;~ Analytical Psychologyt<\' 15{~'1.9f"lC<15il1
<fiC~o;I A careful
'>t"'~ Clf~C~o{,~.,~ ~fD 1S~lSf<fi7$l<1Jt~Jl <fi~~" ~t~C~<1tt-«1/ ~I:!tll~ 1m I study 'of the nature and purpose of these re~lIy complementar!
ISCIf~ '>t~~ ~Cil~, ~t~tt'lf1/ "!tf~1f ~t~ ~}j'mCo;~ I C<l' ~tf\! ~~'lrt~ that both of them are dIrected to the pun-
processes s h ow S . _1< t,
~1\t'1 <I'~C\!<\J~ C<{I5{t~~t'S ~<1~tfol<l' ~C\! 9ftrn, <ett~tt\f1/'S ~'lf 15{~ ~~ fication of experience in their respectIve spheres-I5{'<\tl:, <\Ml<fi IS
C}j ~'lf~ ~t!Jf C\!t1ftt\f~ ~tl1fil<fi'\!~ f<t~tc.,~ '>t~f1Ii\ CO\(, filG'J~~, Qf ~Rg~<fi' <lJ~~t~ I l..c~t'(j>·~9ftCl.{i5t: ~~<ltG'J9f~'Jlit,.,<fi' ~t., <.!l<\~f<l~1f
~tf\!~ 9fC1Jli"~ fl)~ <If~<\t~ I5{f\!f~'iji ...,.fu. ~t<fi1~<1 I ~~ttlf~ fR1 ~\'ilt<lf ~~~'.{ <fit~C~" I i5t: ~<f<\tt"'1/ ~~~~ 'et~, l5{'>ttlf9ftf'S'!lJ ClfC~
<1~ ~C~c~ I 15{~1)~C\!)J<f 'fJfu.~~ <fi'-e<1J~"l ~~\Btc~ fD~1 <fi'~1-~~
C<{.,~~ CIf'Sll ~t<l' il1 C<lftil? C~ <I~~f"l 9fC~ ~1f$l ~ ~"I <fi11f1
~
~
~~fi1C\! "lf~ fl)~t1/ ~t9f <1~t;; I ~<fi~ ~1/c'l~ ~t9f il'.l', C<ft~'t
C<1~, C<fitl1lt'S
<fi1f-f<fi~ ~tc~-~~~~~
<1'e'<lJC<l'~~, ~t'S <I",f~il1 I
I5{tf1ll'~~ I C"l~<fiClf1/Pl~ 't
=1 ~C~ ~~ I iSt: ~~<1t"t <\C"'C~o; ~ <\;ti1l1o;l}j"'~t., ~~tt~ ~~.,t~
~ / Q'\\!~~{tl:, Constant
ixperience
Appeal
~t~ lIt11 ~~
of Nature, History, Reason
<1'1/1~~t~ <fi;ti<\1 I I5lt~~ f<\'l!tlj ~~
<fi;tiqJIS~~}jlltC~IS ~CtfJllClfJ"3l~'1 <fi~C'" 1f"lf ~'.{ ~1 I C<ft~tc'l1/ <nt~Jt'.l'
1St.~~<1ti\ <fi<::ebl~.,$<fi f<fi'~"l..,t1l!t~~t~ ~t1lt~ ~5t1/ <fi~<\t1/'Jli1f'!l1Cil~ I
~~ 1f~'if\f ~<fi'<1tC"l~
1ft\! ~~"l~ ~ IS ~\!t~ ~C!Jf ~;ti1ft~ f<1~ f~ ~~Q'\t1(}j\Bl~l ~~C~ ~tfil ~1 f<tc'lfliil<\~ 9f~ffi \!t1t c~tt~ ~tfil <$~
C<fit;; ~~f1/<l' f"Cllt~ c;;~ I <fi'WI~'" ~IS-The birth of Islam is the
<\cfO\t1/
~~(., <fi'ft1t\!9ftft11
birth of the inductive intellect, ~~~ c<l't1ttt'l I5{t~ constant
Bastide~~ <1~~tfO{~~~~1 ~~ ~ \!tt\! mystical "5lf'e~tt<\'
appeals to Reason, History, Nature and Experience I ~~ ~
f<l~tt;;~ f>t~ cC!fC<l'''If~1 ~~t~-·the book is planned to be one of
C~<fi' '~~o; ~}j.,t1{ ~;t~ ~<1f"l~J~~ concrete, finite ~<I~ objective
t{Ciltst'l, ~f~~tt~~ flf<fi' CC!fC<fi' C\!~fi{ '>t~~"'1:!1, '-5{~\!t1t f1f~ ~
pure science' I <1"'1 <\~"'J c~ ~~t~'.{ ~~tto;1/ ~..t~~., ~<1~t~ <f
...
[
9tqj~ I ~~f.r<f 9!~f! ~<ftfll'<f ~'<ftt~~, ~t~ ~l:~TC<ftil~ ~ f5i§~fqj 9t~~1 '<f~C~ ~t<1 f.lt~t'<f ~tll (Jlt'lO{1), ~~~ ~~ ~
~iIf ~~ C~'<f~ f~5t~ '<f~l15t"1"Ii-~llt~ f<l5t~ ~~ I Bas f<lt"l~ ~tm~iI I <tt~iS... ~tC'<f subsconcious ~t'l~ ~ ~ m
C~~'!l'l"l~ '<fl:~~iI ~ ~ilt~"l'<f 9tqj~ ~"l1 5t"I I ~ ~~ ~t'S~ O{i.{ I iI.:
'!l~"'~ ~~W~ '<ft~ ~~ - ~~O{ Masson-Oursel\!l~ Cornparati ~l ~i:j Mysticism \!l<t~ f<I~ttil~ 1\l:~J9tqjf~ ~Jltt~ ~(t~ methodo-
Philosophy I ~~til, '~"l~R, C'l~ 'S ~O\f. ( C"!~'<fC~'6' ~ ~l q logically, 9!N''fJ <I'llI ~9!"Cf~'\~tll <>IN"CfJ I5Itt~' '61~ ~ '1tt'e-
9tt('<fJ~~ ~i.{f~t~ <H~O{"Ii) fil1!~~ ~'lil~~~ '6Itt"l~~ '<f~ • transcend "Oneself and the world, and then, if the transcendent
f.I~MfQj~Plqjtt~ ~9t~~ ~~m~- ... is found, to apprehend it with a triumphant intuition, ~lll~
~tt1l fiI"! 9f~ I '!lt~O{~t~O{ '6IW<I'~'l~ ~~n'f<l' f.lt~~ 'S ,flllm ~1{1
Indeed in all Mysticism, there is an indentical psychological experience
••.I am almost inclined to make this experience consist of a certain inward '!If\!~1{ '<f~0{ O{l? ~~ C~ intuition~~ ~t~T~ ~t~~ ~ll, \!l~~ ~~
sentiment in which there are two distinct elements: on the one hand a sense ~t'i ~f.I ~ 15I~~'(ji '!ltO{iIf <>Ito{
~ '<f~t~IS~<t't"l ~ I ~t~ '!lt~t~ ~O{~ll
of depersonalization, or annihilation of the self, which being emptied of its Mysticism-!ll1 f<ttllf~"lft~ '!l~~~ O{~,iSt: ~~"'ltt'i~ <;!;tllt~synthetic
normal thoughts and emotions causes the mystic to feel that he is living a tranwguration of experience~ I ~~ '!If<;!;~\!)n1 ~t~tQlTI~~~~ 'S 9tftl·
life quite different from his usual one. On the other hand he does ~ • 'l~o{~ quality ~5t~ '<f~<1t~~~~1 '6It~~ c;O{~-'<ft~'1~"t"l~ 1{tti{~
cause of this lose himself in an utter void: other emotions and thoughts rise
Mysticism\!l~ '!lf~~1"'l~ 9tc~ ~ll O{j,~1 '!l~~ '<f~<lt~~~ ~t~0{1'<f~~
within him. But he does not feel them to be his own: they seem foreign
to him and he submits to them passively. .
~~ I ~t<t ~~W~~ ~t~1{1'f~tt~t<l~ ~ Mysticism.!l~ <lofil1 9tt~ 151~~
\!l~ ~lS ~t~t~ ~wf~ ~~~ ~~~t~ '6ItC'it5O{t~9tl:~ "lt~iS...~~ ~~'t1 ~m~,~~~~<11~~ ~iI synthesis, transformation~~ quality
C~ fil~~ '!lFs~~t~ ~~1l ~~ti.{ O{Rt~'<ft~~t~'<f~ ~~ ~t'<fl:"!'S 9tfi't! l!ltt~1 'lJt9f'<f,'!lt~l ~~~ <;!;tt"'l~~~~l,{ I fiI~<f l!lf~1 <lJ'6'<I'~1 11('6',
'6I<I~ti.{
c~~fgj ~~ lltll I C'<f<l"!
~~1IfC<litO{ '!l~~t~ <;!;t~tll
'!lt~~ c"If,€l,{l
~tlll ~~ <t>f<I\!)1 ~C"! ~CiI
~i.{~ O{~W~O{, \ ~Wt~~ ~qj "l{~, ~O{ttll~-~c~t~~~qj lS9t.• ~ilf~ I C'<fti\
The crises and raptures which are part of mystical experience are
not constantly recurring factor of Mysticism but something that is merely ~'i 2.~c;O{~
~~ ~t~J; ~t'<f~tt~ ~tlS f~fil~ I
ephemeral. Its very essence is that it is a method of life and knowledge, iSt: ~~t~"l{t~~ ~t~ '!ltl{ IS folli~~~~~ '!If<;!;~1~~ '!If<;!;~~1O{~,
an attempt by man to conquer man, and an effort towards negation as well
\!l'<f~'!lf~l I f\!)fil'!It'1'<ff"lfO{
,~t~ <It"!'6It~t~ C~<;!;t~\!)<ll:~~
Ql~'lfJ~~
as towards liberation. Finally, it is an heroic attempt to transcend oneself
and the world, and then, if the transcendent is found, to apprehend it with a ISD~t~ f9t~to{~tt~ cllt~ I ~~ <I~~tfolt~f~fO{C~~~~~t~~ ~'<R "Cft~~O{
~t~~<l~, &t., t"lft"ll1'!lt~/l1 ~~~ fui.{ I <1ft~t~~3l1'lfiC't~
( ~, ~'I ) ~~ ~"l,
triumphant intuition.
~~t~~~ ~t~, \!lM~til'!ltth ~"'~~ I
I talicised ~~~M~ ~f~ 9tnl:'<f~ ~~ '!lt~('1 '<f~f~- ~~l!: "It is in imitation ( ~f\!i ) of the angelic ( (~ ) works of art ( fio1~lf.1) that
~'<flS ~9tt~, ~~9!~ ~<lO{-lltl!it~ ~<I~~O{~ \s9!tl, C"t~ ~~ ~<lill:'<f'6If~- any work of art (f"m) is accomplished (~fil~) here: for exa~ple, ~ clay
~~ '<f~t~ \s9!tll I <I~CiS~effort towards negation as well as elephant, a brazen object, a garment, a gold object, and a mule-chanot are works
towards liberation iSt: ~<f<ltt"!~ purification of experience-\!l~ of art.' A work of art ( f"m ) indeed, is accomplished in him who comprehends
'<fllt1"'3l~'1'<fftllllClfllI ~~~ <I~~t"l~ C~ f<\~tcil~ '!l~ftl'(ji ~"I, f<ti~<tl this. For these (angelic) works of art (fimif.l, viz., the metrical si1p~ te~ts). are
an integration of the self (~~~~f\!i) j and by them the sacrificer likeWIse 1I1te-
'R~O{~ <I~ IS9!qj~ c~t'<f ~~~ ~"!, \!l~o{C'<fto{ '<ft{l CiI~I Instros-
grates himself ( ~1'm'\'ll'l~,¥~ ) in the mode of rythm ( ~Nll ). .
pection ~ 9f~Nf<\~tCi\~IS~9ffilfu~ 9!qjf~ ~<t'lIf1'!lt~"t"l ~'lt~ ~W{,
~<I~ Experimental Psychology~'S ~lIf~mtot <lJ~~ ~~, ~t?, ~U '!It''l.l-~~''ff~l!lt~ iSt: ~'<f<ltt-e(~purification of experience ~'<f~
9tt'Sm~tl Woodworth\!l~ Contemporary Schools of Psychologyt'S I <l~ I '61~~<\f'l~, ~~~~ ~<I~ C~R1fJ-5btt~~~Tfu~ ~'<f~ ~1 ~<ltf~~
Woodworth ~tC'<f Existential School ~~t~, ~C~~ ~~ <;!;t'l ~li!2 I ~i\t~t"t~ '<f"ltf<l~IS~'f <1f<I'~~ ~." ~<li~<;!;"tt~ ~wf6t<t' C~C~
'<f~ C"If~l:"I~C<lt<\l1 m<l ~ Introspection\!l~ C"If~~fgj
~i1 <t'~l ~'&~, '!It"lf~<t't{l-~~ 9t~f~ I ~~tco{~ c~tl!i ~fqj~
~"*~~
~n;
~t~tt1fJ
~9ft1
\!lt~t~O{I ~il '<f~fVfO{ ~~ '6Iti\ifRlt~ ~'i'<f-\!l~<;!;t~~<\~'h
C~RtiJ<;!~ 'R~tll
~<I'~1<I~9t~ I ~tt~'S ~~ imi ta tion of Na ture\!l~ ~~ \!l"Cf~~'<ft~ '1'f'S~1
-~'<f ~tl~~ f<l5t~ - f~~ll ~~ I Mysticism~IS ~t~ <l"ll ~, ~tllt~ I i5t: ~~~~"l{t~~ <1~~1f~ Meister Eckhart O{tt1{ C'l\<U~~ ~~
, «
[ '.1"8') ] ~-1I\~5l.I
~rtc"ltfD~ ~l,l~, f\5Ff f~C"lo{1JI<fi~0{~~~~ i.cm-c1~ ~~rt\5 c~~ I @~ \!l 'l"~'S ~~ i{'l.I-'1j~tlft~t~ 1lClO ~~~ ~ II\mttt\~,
~~'tJ IJI~ C~~~~/~ ~tO{~~~t>f fu>rt<fitc"t ~~f'l~, f~~"'ll ~~"'l~ ~ ~ "'"tll f01I ~tf~J '11 'f"t'tOl~ Oltt1l '\~tc~ Cl\ C1l<fi"'~ C<fitOl~<{ ~, '!1
ili1 ~'1 <fiC~ ~tc~~ <fi"lt~~ '€ N~ ~~~'1 .~~, ~t~~ .~,~~ c«~ -s ~t'1 ~1 Cl{ llt~t~~' llt01 \5t~ i!lfW\5tf51'f ~tlA~, \51 i\~tll c~
5tw~"l1 f~~'l1 <fitw fif~ I t1l~~ 5tw~"l1 1JI<l~ f"'ICil~1fC~JC<fifO{~lf ~ C~~~ "tfto{t ~ ~~1 ~tlfJtN<fi\5t~ ~\5 '5tft~ lltt<fi\S"II I \!i1,ffl lltOl
1JI"l~5t~~1t '€ llfij~~~ C~iIf~\5tMt~~ 1lC~'S fl!Q'jll~ ~t(~J ~; l{~~ Jjt~\5J <11'lfllftOl:~~o{ ~f<\l ~~~t~-\!I"~<fi lIf~"lt'" Cil~t<fi~ 'fll,
Eric Gill c!t1t Ol~ <l~ Art~ \!l~~ <fi~ <It''1C~ I ~rtOl~~ ~~il'~ ~~fu<fi ~~ ~<fi 9ft~<fi~1{t~, - ffl ~ttlf~ lItlfJ clit51·~ C~llOl <fit~ ~f~tl
~G'1)1JI't~~JtCOl1t
~~\5t\5'S ~~ fD~~Ni~ ~I'f-f I f5lt~ <ttll ~~ ~'lfi~ '5l~~, "lJ(~-c~tt~ ~tc~ ~WI1 ~'l~ I <l'f.,~~ti5~
<l~to{ ~~1t Lipps ~lff~1t <l~-IJI"1t~~ ~·tc\fi1 ~fil5~ ~ ~ \!I~ P1tl,ltc51~~~to{ <fit~'1 ~t1{tt'lf~ ~'ltOl~ Fl~'9\511 ~t~ ~t~ ~:t~
tt~l ~tcOlOl ~ ~<fit"1<fit~ ~tO{<f~~t~~ ~~~~t'S fq'¢t~ ~t1tO{ ~ 111_ '61~ttl'f~ ~ ~~o1 C<fit~t~, ~ ~~G'1\51f~.,Ol1 '1"11 ~~t~ ~~J~, f~~
empathy f<e:{IftWWt ~ ~~~t'1 ~ts ~~~ ~0l11 ~~tc9f~ C~~ '61t~~~ tli1<lto{~ <1~\~ '€ <\~f~1\ ~"tt"t1t ~"lOltl ~~~t'l1 ~<lOl-~~1
~t~~tll IJI~ ll~J\~lI lItOlt<ett't~ ~-t<\~ ~c~ ~c~t~ I Mari tainlJl1t Art ~ ~tOl<fi 1I~i!lf, ~t01~ ~~il ~il, CJj 'l"~1 "l{\<fit~011 <fit~ lltt<fii~~ ill I
and Scholasticism <l~~ IJI~ ~Jjc~ 9ffi15t~1t 9f~~<l~ t>f~1! ~~Clt •• ~~~~ ~51~ \!l~ ~<lfDi!lJ'€ ~t9f<fiI!~ ~ 1lt~Clf~ ~t~ ll~t~~ ~~'S
<fi~f~ I ~~tc9f-fqt"t~::!l'tt'fI '5lti!lf<fitilNeo-Thomsim~"1t ~1{C"lt'51ct= t1l<fi~t~ ~1{0l ~Wil ~c~ ~t~t~, ~W~ -C\S1l~ ~t~f"t~ '€ ~lI"t{ ~Cll
<fi~'1 C<lt~~lI IJI~ ~ ~~ttO{~ Art, Science, PhilosphYIJl1t lIt~J ~fl~ ~~"'9f~~ 9f~"9\c~~ <fitt~ ~t~t<lT <fit~ ~t"1t~ 1JI<l~ ~"!t~ I '5ltc~ ~f'6i~
Fl<ltCI'f~tO{~ C~Q\-~~<lt~ ~i!lf Fl~ I .~ <tJf'6'~ ~ ~~~ f~"!, \!itC\5 t1'It~Jt<fi~~<lJ~~ ~~tt"t~ ~<l<fit"t ~"I-
~tll~ <l'6i'tJ IJI~C~ ~tcs '€ Fl~Ol ~,~~ Cll Transformation '61ttli<fit"!<1J~~ '1jt~ <lJ~ ~~"9\"t/~t~ ~'f<\t~, ISt~ <llfC..,~tl1fO{~ ~1{t~
~tflflS ~1I C~~ ~~fOlt~~ 1JI<l~~t~~ 1lCOlt~t<l~t"1 <fit1t ~tcllt5Ol1 <fi~t'l.• ~~~1 ~t~ ~tl,lttlitOl~ "t~ IJI~~ C~ ~t~ttlio{ oWt~t1t (5g1 I 1JI<fi
C5tc~ ~t<l I C<fi<l"lIS~ 0l1l,-~1{0l c~~-t>fqjf~t\5, C\511~~ Fl~e <fiott~, ~ti!lf<fitll ~t~t~~ ~C~~ lltlfT <tJ~~ P1<fitllf ~if, C~ ~~~~
fD~~~, purification' of experience 011~til C<fitO{~<fit~ Jjt\5B~ ~~Jl ~~t~f~t\5 <til1 5t"! economic, <\t~"It~ ~~O\flS<fi ~til <:et~~~511 ~
t>ft'S1I1
~ 011I 1JI<l~
IJI~ purifica tion~1t ~t~OltlI ~ffi~
\S ~~"'t"1t ~\!R C1lCilOl1I
~tll~o{ I ~9f<fi~C'19ft{<fiJ ~<fit"l'S 9fqjf~t\5 C<fitO{~t{<fiJ COl~I ~~\!: \!it~ ~til ~~ ll~t~ "tt~ ~~tlfJ ~t1 ~~,~, IJI~~C1l~ ~~lfJ\!itt<fi
~tlft~ C5tc~ ~t1t~\5: ~~1 9f~~ 011I ~tt~1 <ltf'¥C~C\!itt"!C1l1~<fi\5t~,~t~ I f.,~g iSott'Iftt01,~5Ol1-~~tl! <11~~51~tO{
~ ~M~<;;1~~<\~tOlOl'f, CJf<f~ 'it" f~ IJI~ ~t't~~ ~t~T C1l1~<fi\51 c~~t~
If-til ~~ C'lfiti!l~ ~tl1fOl<fi'~t~~ ~C~ '€U>, <{tt<fi\!l'l" <fi~ <\"l15t"! ~tt\'f~,"ll
(precious) I '61t~<fi ~tf~~J ~tO{<fi~~tlI \!lIS<fi~01IJI~~ l'filill1lCOl~', ~t~
~t"<fi~t~ <fit~'1 lJI~tcO{~C1ltll, f<1l'~<fiM~~Ci5~<\\Si<\Jf<lell\lf~<\ 'f"t to{~
~~~ I CJjP1lfC~ ~t~1 <till 5til ~ ~"tt~ ~t~J~ \S ~<ltO{~ ~t~ ~t~-
An Essay on Philosophical Method-By R. G. Colling-
fu~t'lf~ IJI"~ ~~tOl <fi~'1 ~t~ ~tlf\~ 1'~~\511 .I.~~tO{~ ~<fitt"t ~-it~
wood. (Oxford: Clarendon Press)
(symbol) ~<\~~1I, ~t~ fq~.,~ ~t'll'C"lJ \~ '1ft'"!~<fi~t-s ~~ ~tc<lo{
~~~Ol 'If''t1;0l~Jjt~ ~ "t~<lt~ ~~ <fiM~~Ci5~(Collingwood) ~ I'f1'ItOl~~<fi ~J<t~t~ ~t~01 I
Oltll~tcI'f~ <fitc~l"tc~~ ~~tO{l OlllI <l~~ "M~~ ~~c~ "l"115til C~c9f"ttl'ftit <fiM~~tl5~ 1lt~J C~ C~~~ ~ ~t" ~H 11~ Cil~~ ~~J, IJI~~
I'ft"ttii<fi~tll\1 ~~t~'€ ~~ ~f\5~~ '€ ~<et<l ~f;{<fi~1~~~c~'-'5lW c~to{ ~t5J <\~~tf.1C\5 ~fO{ ~~,,~ <\~C~ ~1N ~ Cl'ff~m~ I ~t~
<l~~~ <fi~1 ~t<fi ~t~ 011~t~, (Speculum Mentis) c"'9f~'1t1{ Cll~CJj1t"it1t ~'e<\J ~~ ~ I'f-R ~~~~ ~~~\5~tf~J C~llo{~<\tOl~ ~f~~\!tl ~f\!$'!
~t~'1 9f~~ llt~J'e ~t<fi~ i!lftcO{Ol
I ~t~<fi ~f~J 1JI<l~\'fllf~-Jl <lell ~f~ "lJ~~ ~tf~~J~ ~11~~'\ <fi~t\!i ~O{, \!l<\~C1I ~~\!tl
~~tn ~~~~ f~Ff ~~iltll C1l~Jj1t \!l<fi~tll51t~ <ltilC~Ol,~t1{tCI'f1t~51 ~ ~<\tOl~ <lJt9f<fi\51
<{\5 C<llill
~~1 ~t~, \!i\!~ 'l~\51 ~~ ~ ~, ~ ffi'S
I'ft"t/~<fi<l1 ~t~~Jt<fi~ ~<l ~tllt~ IJI "lII1 lItO{<fi~tG'1~il ~t<l I ~~~ ~1\1 ~~t~ ~~t>f foI(lI ~t\!i 5tlI ''It'"i ~~ <\~ili~ \!it~ ~~~1{t0{
5C"lClfC<fitOl ~~ c~t~ IJI~Jj~ IJII! ~ ~~~<fi "'ll\5t"tt~ C"lt<fi111ft'!} ~"t~ I ~t~ ~~tlfJ\51 <l11'~~\5t~ ~ 'f-ft., C.,~, ~~<fi <\J~~trn1
<111'f-t"tOl~""~ OltcllOlfOl
I ~W ~'" 1'f"t"01<t1 }jtfu\5~ ~~~t., ~lf~ '"<fito{
t1'It~t~., CO{~, 'If-R ~~Il ~'~ ~~, ~~ ~ ~~il~ 1.~<f '61t~~
~8.
<ffG'\~~~ f~l,{ f<I\Stt~ ~f't~~ ~trt~ I 8tm I!\ <!tm"t~ f~
~~~il1-~~~~n ~~~rn ~ ~t9\oitQ Clf ~~"t Cl{t~~, 1\'If'l f.l"5~\!i1-f<1'i!$ C}j R"5~~t€ ~t~~R~ (hypothetical), ~Ol;
9jfiD~ }j~~~ \!it~ <1'tt~ e~t~~~J ~t'l I (assumptions) clllt~ I!\~mi ~AA~ '5lt~~, I!\~~ ~:fll~ (axiom) ""~~
I!\ }j1l~ <1'Q\~f<l~ ~ ~O{~ ~fe; ~<1i ~~t~ 9ftt~ ClI~Q/1 ~fil~~ ~t~ \!it~ ~f~ I ~t~ C"l\f'l~tt~ '5l~~1 e~1t~~, 'f'i3 (data) <t1 ~t~~~ 'lt~
~~tO\\ il~ I ~t~ ~~'S f~R ~il<1'~l f1ft~ (6gl <ft~~il, f<1'~ C}j~ ~t1I }j'll'.\iRti5~, f~'% I!\t~t\l\'S '5lt1l~ ~ 1!\~':Ilf~\!)tt~ 'l~~ '5lf~l!\i~
I!\<\~ ~ ~~t~Q ~tf.:QIWil1<\lQ~ c~t~ ~t~ ~~il 'l'6't~n~ <1'll/1~ ~~t\S 9ftt~ R I ~\!):f'l~ 15l~'ll0\<f'ClI~t~ f~ c~~t~, f<1''%fjj~~
clllt<f "ll\!i:f}jt~\!lt~1 ~t~ il1-1!\t'lfit\l\\9 ~ttil~ 9ffi'\f~ \!l9f~t<\~~, ~rt~tfi'1'
c'4t'1' lItt~ , .
f<I~t"l~ 9fqif~~ 'lew I!\~AA lQ.~ ~~t~ 9ft(<1'1 ~~J <f"Q1"lIt~, ~~1l~:
~HI ~~til ~'6i~J I!\~ ~ ~XR 'S ~~ttil~ ~~ f\i;~ I!\<l~~ ~'t~ ~ I
<Ut<\~tftt<f~~ttOl~ 'f'i3 I!\~~ fll~tt~~ 1lt~1}j'llt'.\i~f~~ Cil~ I ~~~~:
~til<f ~MR<1'~ I!\~~l ~II f51G W"filt~\9 ~~tt~~~ }jtfit"'1<f'tQ ~
'lJt<\~t~<1'fcI~tt"i ~~t~'tt~~ "llmt9f~~~ <e~ il1\ ~f'\\S C}j}j'llt'.\i'ltD~il ;
CDt~t~"' <\t~~ m~t~ I!\~ ~i!\t~ I 'f-Tiit'1' ~t~ ~t~ ~~~ ~t~ e~t~
~1 il~tG'\~'\t'!i "ll~:fjj~~ ~til ~t<f~ .,1 , f<\ii!$~f'tt~ 9ft'lfiCli ~ 'i1l~1 "'~,
I!\<\~f'1' <ft~t'\ ~~tt"lQ ~f'6 'f-Ttil ~D~ I <ff~~~ti5Q <\~til <\~~tfo{~~
f~il1~ ~ ~f't~ \!ilt\l~ "ll\!l:fjj~~t"! ~til Cil~ I
~t~~ ~51~' I!\~ ~~ f<I~tt~Q }jttQ\'f-Tt"l~ ~~t"' ott(<1'J I!\~~t~ I 'f4til ~~:f~~
<ff..,~~ti5Q~ ~t~tt'f~ ~tilt<1' ~il \!,;tt~ t;t~ <fQ1 ~t~~~J~ ~til COl;~' w-fc"l~ ~t~1<1' ~\l\, \2tt~J"<l'~f~~ ~llt'IJ I ~~~ ~"! W-Ttil~
~\!,;tt~ ~t"'<\t~ 9f~f\§ \!It..,~ I 'Ol1~~1<rtt'1' <\Jt<\~tfi<f'f<\~til (empirical ~ 9f~t~;ijtft~, ~~ 9ft~ C"lI~"iI5lt1l"Q1 'f~ c'4t<1'f'l~tt~ (llt\S 9ft~, <5l~9\t~
science) ~f~, ~~~ ~~tt~ ~~til~ \!it~~· 91fttD~ QIt~ \ <\Jt<l~tfi~· fJ~ c~R <5lt1l""Q1
fJ\~t~ cQ\t<l' ~~ 'Olt~ 9ft~, 1!\<1'9ft~ClI~il'f~ \9
~",\9 (empirical knowledge) ~~ ~~tt~~ '5l~'if~ II!\ Q<f~ ~til<\t~ 9f~fn f'l~~l1 }j'llC'.\iQ
\99111'Olt~tt~~ ~~t~}j1 R;§~ <1'tll, 'Ol~9ft'lfi '5lt~ttl'f~ f5'i&1-
CWolgJ~~ ell ~~tt"ll5lt~tt~~ ~t~~ ~t~~ 'l'll~ ~t~~Q C<1'till5l'l~t-t Q{~ I ~t"Qn ~9fQ ~9f1l 'f'i3 I!\<\~f1I~tt~Q }j%\9 'i~t., fo\~~i\lG'\' ~t"! W"fil:<!Ii1l-
~<1't~1 ~<1't~l ~~J (facts) ~ Q~~ ~illl f~~~~ I!\~~I!\ 'l~~ ~flI~ <\~G'\, I!\~~ C}j <!Ii~~~il C<1't~t'S<5lt~~ ~ e1l/~Cil~' ~1I ~ttil \!it~
\!If<\'ltt}j ~Q<\t1I ~9ft~ Cil~ I ~t~t~ 91'4 D"e\t~ D"lt~ e'ft~ ClI'ft'! 'ft'! I!\<t''5lt~. C<1it~t\9C<l'tilil~~ Cil~, C<1'ilil1"il1" ~~\9 '1!:"Qtt~l~ttO\Q ~t~J
"c$'lt~ ~~~-" ~t~l ~t~ t;t~~ ~~t~ I c~t..,t~ ~~~ ~t~ c~1OI"tlft( foi~\S ft~,~ \!lC~'f"lt~ }j1l~ ~t.,~ ~~, <ft~'\ ~f~9ftlf W"f", R~J
~~~1 lQ.RW.{c~CU\",I,15l~~: I!\ <1'~ 'l~J elf ~l~rn ~~ c~t..,t~ e~t~ '11 ~ }j% 'Oltf<\'<\itC~lI ~"! 'Olt1ltt'f~ ~OI:~*,t<f .,~tt~ ~~"C'! C"t~t1,{,
C<\~~ c~t<fiC<1'til~~t~~~ ilt~ ~<.\iCil~ I \!i'!. ~'4J ~.Jjtc<\~t~t~ lf1 ~~, I!\<f~'4t~ ~-Tt"illl'l\5J \9 ~IllJ1lQ.~~I!t~ <5ltt9fN<f ,
~tt<f 15l~<1'~ <f~l ~~ il1 I ~t~ ~f~~1l'StG'\Q 'Olt~~<\ fil:}jti\'f~, 'lti\'ft~~ 'f-T('",~I!\ c<lRtz~ ~~ <1'f1\~~iS'Olt"l~ "W'e' Of~~t~"il, I!t~ 1!\<1'~1I
\!l<\<ft1l/ IS~ lI~il 9J.~tt"l1 15l~~~t~ ~tG'\ 15l~"Q1 C}j I5lt~;§tt'l ~'1"l'lfi'l 1l~ I!\~tt"l ~u:I~<fll'l' f<\~ttil ClIC~~ f<t\St~~l,{, ~t~ ~tG'\9f~><>9t~
~t~t~
'Oltt~t"t <fftl, ~~ R~1I/ <f'tQ ~t~ O\tl\~~'\ <r>BtI I!\~ ~<1'~'l~~ ~lltJ (exclusive) c~'l\\~~ \9~' C<1itOl:
I!\~~ ~~ ~gtt~ ~t~ f<\f~~ ,!t~~ ~t'\~
~~ 'l1~t~'\ C<ftOl;R~1lQ ~t\l\ ~tt~~ ~<1't1I/~ <nt<\~tftt<f ~ttilQ G'\'lfiJ
I ~tt'l"t '5l'l~<{' \l-Tt"il~i!$ '§1 ~ I I'f-fc"l~C!t~~ C<{MgJ~ I!\~ C"l\c~'l\\~~
'lt~t~'\ ~\l\~fG'\f<1'i!$\!~t<f ~f~m~ ~t~il1-~tQ\HI \5"tQ ~t"Q1 R~1 f<\~~ ~t~'''3 1mt~ "il~I ~'l-~ ~~~~ ~9ff~f~ <t115l~t'l e"llf<lf~
~~1h I \!i1. ~t~J~ R~'lti\'f~ R"5~~1 I!\ }j1l~ }jt~t"Q'\ ~t~ ~t~il1- c~'l\\~~t~, I!t~~ ~t-l~~fG'\ 9f"Q><>9t~ ~tllt~, C<1'til~i!$~ ~~1I/t~ I!\<{~
~1t~t"Q'\
~\l\~~ ~~ntil~ C<1'<\"Qj1ltl!!
'l~tt~J1Il1tt~J cot~ lIt~ I ~~'S~ill!\<f}jt~ ~'t\S 9ftCQ.,1' ~~ 'f4t0l: C"l\fm<1' ~t~'\1 (concept),
~~J I!\<l~'lt~t"Q'\ ~~ 'l'llt<.\i f<\~ }jtD~il, ffl C"lIf~t~t"QtQ ~t"! l!otJ ~~~ (proposition) I!\~~ "W~(inference) I!\~ ~il \Stt~ \St~ <l'~1 ~~, I!\
}jt~t"Q'\~t\l\ ~f~~ ~~-c}j }j~ ~~il ~~~ttl\t5lt I I!\~ f6~t~t~1 f<1' ~<I f~'l\~M ~~><>9t~f~t~ ~ I I!\re\l\ ~C"l~ ~gtt~ f\!iOl:C~~~~ G'\~t'\l1
DtM~~, ~tQ ~Dn ~~ ~tt~~ ~t~, f<l~til ell 'l'llt<.\ifil'liit<f' f<1'~ '" 9ffiD~ 9ft<em~-~t"! C<t~tR<f c!t~ ~\St~ 1!\C'lfit~~~t~ <l'~1DC"!0l;11
9f~~(~ ~tt~lI ~f5 <11C<1'<\"l1l~~~t~~ ~~til (assumption) lIt~ ~ ~1I C"l\'Oltt9ff~~1 <t'f"!~~~ ~"C'!If''ft~ c~fitgJ, 1!~\9 <5l{I!\~~AA
<f~1 ~ il1 C~"" f<l~"Q \!i~J <\1 'lt~t~'\ ~~ flft~ ~tll '<1'101~t'1 9ftsit 9ft'S~1"l\t~, ~~ ,~~ ~\St~ I!\<f~ (absolute) "'~ ~~ tf-fc"l~ c'la'll
"l\t~il1 I ~~ ~~ ~~J 'Ol~~ 'l'll<.\iI!\<\~fo\"5~l!tQ 'l'liil!!~ '5lt~~ I I!~ ~ I!\'l~~~ "llt~31J}j~9 ~ \ ~1I <1'1UiI!t~ ~til ~fl! ~~ ~til
~'4J ~'ltC<\ fo\~}jti\'f~,~ ~Q\J '<ft.,f~ ~t<1' Rf"5~ ~~~1 ful! 9f~' ~l i!\tfut~ 9f~'t~ ~ I <ft~'\ ~f~ ~"L~ ~~ ~~ ~1~ ~
~'4J I!\<\~~\l\ ~~t~~ C<\iR~~ 1!\~<1''5l'4<\11!\<ft~'5l~tt'f~ fRt9f~f\!t<1' ~f!$~ ~'SttQlI ~~ '5l~~'l ~f~ ~~ \!i1 OI:~,}j~~~il:\9mt~ I ~t" ~~tOO }j\5J
Cf~t~ '5l9ftQ~ I ~)
,
""
-- ----~-----~~ --
•
'.
.,6
.,
Ql)
"'-'
6
aD
<;t
,
..