Scribd Logo
Încărcați

Bine ați venit la Scribd!

  • Giving Think Enter Which Chiefly: Will

    Încărcat de

    Jai Thakur
    16 vizualizări1 pagină
    This document discusses an appeal from the Sudder Dewanny Adawlut of Allahabad regarding a mortgage of an infant's ancestral estate by the estate's manager. The committee gives their opinion that the order upholding the protest should be reversed, with each party paying their own appeal costs. While the lower court focused on whether the parties were considered "British subjects" under earlier charters, the committee finds this suit cannot be entertained regardless. Principles for Native courts in India require trying cases on the merits, allowing issues to be amended if needed to fully address the real points of dispute.

    Descriere originală:

    Titlu original

    a

    Drepturi de autor

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Formate disponibile

    PDF, TXT sau citiți online pe Scribd

    Vi se pare util acest document?

    Este necorespunzător acest conținut?

    Raportați acest document
    This document discusses an appeal from the Sudder Dewanny Adawlut of Allahabad regarding a mortgage of an infant's ancestral estate by the estate's manager. The committee gives their opinion that the order upholding the protest should be reversed, with each party paying their own appeal costs. While the lower court focused on whether the parties were considered "British subjects" under earlier charters, the committee finds this suit cannot be entertained regardless. Principles for Native courts in India require trying cases on the merits, allowing issues to be amended if needed to fully address the real points of dispute.

    Drepturi de autor:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Descărcați ca PDF, TXT sau citiți online pe Scribd
    Indicator pentru conținut neadecvat
    16 vizualizări1 pagină

    Giving Think Enter Which Chiefly: Will

    Încărcat de

    Jai Thakur
    This document discusses an appeal from the Sudder Dewanny Adawlut of Allahabad regarding a mortgage of an infant's ancestral estate by the estate's manager. The committee gives their opinion that the order upholding the protest should be reversed, with each party paying their own appeal costs. While the lower court focused on whether the parties were considered "British subjects" under earlier charters, the committee finds this suit cannot be entertained regardless. Principles for Native courts in India require trying cases on the merits, allowing issues to be amended if needed to fully address the real points of dispute.

    Drepturi de autor:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Descărcați ca PDF, TXT sau citiți online pe Scribd
    Indicator pentru conținut neadecvat
    din 1

    t1

    la '',: .* Ir

    t: *T

    ,('i'
    Ll,

    i i ,l i

    1I; i1

    I i

    tiii

    r!

    !'i.F

    t.

    * h":,; f'
    EEr

    :r'

    1:

    8561

    H. PANDAY
    6 M.

    1850,

    M, B. M. KOONWEREE [6 M. I. A. 3e3
    ,1 .

    ;end

    I. A. BgJ.=18 W. R. 81 (Note):1 Sar. p.C.J. 552. is no such course of decision as shoulcl make us hesitate in giving offect to our own opinion.

    pon

    nay

    tbe
    )pl]'

    'be
    I, ascted
    nrge

    bof
    son-

    'han dies ; ad-

    nas
    ride,.

    protest of the Appellant was overruled, ought to be .eversed, each parby paying his and her own costs of this appeal.

    to Her Majesty as their opinion, that the ordei of the supreme court of Judicat*re at Bontbcty, of 5th Jury, 1E54, whereby the

    we think that the protest sho,rd be sustained, and judsment reversed on the grounds lve have statecl, and. rve clo not 're it deern necessary to enter upon a discussion which chiefly occupied the time of the couri below; whether the parbies to this suit *,ere or were not persons who, prior to the date of trre Letters patent estahlishing the court, were described and distinguished in the Royal charters of Justice by the appellation of " British subjects. ,, w-hatever may, in such respect, be their descriptio', our opino' s that this suit cannot be entertained. The r,ords of tlie co'rrnittee will, therefore, humbly repor.t

    ;iasrlse..

    iuch

    isht tion
    l

    6 M. I. A. S93--. lS W.

    R.8t (Note):Sevestre zj3 N..=2 Sugr. p. C. J. 29.,. I Sar. I,.g.J .552.

    [393] HUNOOMANPFRSA uD PAND Ay,-A14teilatzt.a.

    rbv eof
    )ew.
    I

    MAT BABooEtr MUTIRAJ KooNwEREnr,--Re lJuly 4,5,7 & 8, 1856.]

    Mussu-

    spottcretd"'E

    on uppetrl f'rtttr the sutlcler Dewanng Aclcucl.ut ai A11t.a, 1v-ort/t_


    W'eslertr Pt'ouinces. tlindu Larv (Debts)-Alienation-Mortgage-Manager of infant's ancestral estatc, Power of, to charge it-points to be considered-Lender, Duty of, to inquire about necessity of loan-Bona fides of lendcr and manager-onus of proving bona fides of manager-Mortgagee in possession-Accounts, Mode of taking
    of.

    nhalt
    r

    and
    ,.fi. 'i:'

    liws
    icted,

    the

    ,$,

    'ai I

    eot
    puch
    lbhat,.

    'A :t

    '*:

    u'
    '::i '

    a^

    ike a
    ases,

    .lil.
    j l:J.

    :nj

    Principles upon which the Native courts in Incl,ia are to proceed, in in suits dcirsnflln* before therl.

    tryi'g

    issues,

    rf, by inadvertence or otherwise, the recorded issues do not enabie thb court to try the whole case o' the merits, tire suit ought to be disposed ot, but an opportunity slrould be afforded by a.re'd'rent, '.t if need be, by adjou'rand,
    rnent, for decision upon the real points in dispute.

    lcl ta

    ;hink ,ofti-

    l, rhe
    ,'here

    * Present: Members of rhe ,Iud,tciat ()ontttt.ittee,-Trre ltight Ho'. the Lord Justice I(night J3ruoe, the Righc Hon. sir Eriward riyan, the Itight Hon. the Lord J'ustice Turner, and the'Right Hon. Sir John pattescn. :4ssessor',-The Right Hon. Sir Lawrence peel.
    263

    ll
    l

    i.,

    il tl' ,ii,ir
    '.1'

    ti,
    :;

    'Lri#

    "l

    S-ar putea să vă placă și