Destroying Schools: How About the Taliban’s View, Please?

Written by Bint Abu Umar

“We are Muslims. Had there not been an Islamic system of education and curriculum, then it would
have been all right to import a system of education belonging to others. But fortunately, Islam
provides its own system of education, politics, economics and justice…If Islam is a complete code of
life, then what is the need to import education from the United Kingdom?” 1 -Haji Muslim Khan
0F

(spokesman for Taliban in the Swat valley)

In the Name of Allah, we invoke peace and blessings upon His Messenger.

The past few weeks have witnessed an increasing number of slanderous remarks against the Taliban
concerning their bombing of schools in the Swat Valley, foremost originating from the mouths of
Muslims.

This article aims to underscore the importance of holding back our tongues against our Muslim
brothers and sisters when we do not know their angle of the story. The prophet ‫ﺻﻠﻰ ﷲ ﻋﻠﻳﻪ ﻭ ﺳﻠﻡ‬
informed us that "A person utters a word thoughtlessly [i.e., without thinking about its being good
or not] and, as a result of this, he will fall down into the fire of Hell deeper than the distance
between the east and the west.'' 2 [Al Bukhari and Muslim] This article also examines the reasons
1F

and justifications the Taliban have provided and whether what they have done is an action based
upon wisdom or barbarity. The analysis in this article is based solely on information that is publicly
available. Views of the Taliban that have not been reflected in public sources will consequently not
be reflected in this article.

One has to question why it is so difficult to find an honest analysis of the Taliban’s actions from the
point of view of the Taliban themselves. To add insult to injury, the ease with which ordinary
Muslims ‘issue’ fatwas, ruling the Taliban as ‘barbaric animals’ and ‘those whom we should wage
jihad against’ is abhorrent. Subhan Allah! Not only are they those who have no knowledge
concerning the reality on the ground, they do not have knowledge of the deen. The Shaykh of Islam,
Ibn Taymiyyah (‫ )ﺭﺣﻣﻪ ﷲ‬said in his Al Fatawaa Al Kubraa [4/185], “In matters of jihad one should rely
on the opinion of those who have a sound knowledge of religion and also experience of the world.
Those ulema who do not delve deep into matters of religion and examine only the surface and those
who have no experience of the world should not be consulted.” So, how can we have the audacity
to issue fatwas when even ulema who have knowledge of one type and not the other, are not to be
consulted? Who is better than those on the ground to understand what is really going on? Have we
lost the capability to understand, let alone be at ease with, the views of those who America and her
allies are not comfortable with, (even though they may be upon the haqq)?

Let’s take a look at what the Taliban have said. In an interview with Syed Saleem Shazad of Asia
Times, Haji Muslim Khan (spokesman for Maulana Fazlullah and one of the senior commanders in the

1
Syed Saleem Shahzad. "Taliban ideology echoes in the valley.” Asia Times. 3rd Feb. 2009.
<http://www.atimes.com/atimes/South_Asia/KB03Df02.html>.
2
Al Imam Abu Zakariya Yahya bin Sharaf An Nawawi Ad Dimashqi (compiler of ahadith). Riyad as Saliheen. (2/1514)
Swat Valley) was asked whether the movement is “against both men’s and women’s education” 3 to 2F

which he replied, “this is sad, that we are slaves in all sections of our society… Nobody is ready to sit
with the Taliban and ask what they want from all this. The education system and the curriculum are
both remnants of the British.”

Two important points are highlighted in this quote. Firstly, the average individual does not want to
understand the Taliban’s point of view even though as the perpetrators of this act, they should be
consulted first. Rather, we rush to form opinions that are favorable to our desires and intellect.
Secondly, the curriculums being taught in the schools were based on a non-Islamic system. Why,
when Allah ‫ ﺳﺑﺣﻧﻪ ﻭ ﺗﻌﺎﻟﻰ‬has blessed us with a complete way of life, do we then need to resort to a
system which either distorts the deen of Allah, or does not teach it, period? Any government when
designing an education policy for its citizens ensures that the fruits of its policy are loyal subjects,
who further the culture, religion, and values of the respective government using whatever resources
are available. This is why Thomas Babington Macaulay, a British Minister of Parliament who was
serving on the Supreme Council of India, (a British Colonial Institution), stated in 1835 in his
infamous Minute on Indian Education:

“It is impossible for us, with our limited means, to attempt to educate the body of the
people. We must at present do our best to form a class who may be interpreters between us
and the millions whom we govern; a class of persons, Indian in blood and colour, but English
in taste, in opinions, in morals, and in intellect. To that class we may leave it to refine the
vernacular dialects of the country, to enrich those dialects with terms of science borrowed
from the Western nomenclature, and to render them by degrees fit vehicles for conveying
knowledge to the great mass of the population.” 4 3F

This particular speech was made regarding the imposition of English as the main language of
education to be used in India. It was mandated for the purpose that it would produce “a class of
persons, Indian in blood and colour, but English in taste, in opinions, in morals, and in intellect,” and
who would further the aims of their colonial masters. Pakistani cities are abundant with the type of
people Macualay had in mind. They may wear Pakistani clothes, eat Pakistani food, look Pakistani
but when it comes to their way of thinking, their beliefs and their values, they are essentially
“English in taste.” I do not mean here those Pakistanis who have studied in the West and
subsequently returned. I mean, the home-bred Pakistanis who have spent their whole lives studying
in English-medium schools, and local universities. ‘Islam’ has become something that is limited to
saying ‘inshaAllah’ and ‘mashaAllah’ and salah has become a set of movements of going up and
down. If the class of people that the existing school system in Pakistan produces are weak Muslims
whose aim is to live a comfortable life, and not work towards establishing the laws of Allah on the
earth then it surely is not the generation of the Sahaba who we should strive to emulate. Surely
something must be wrong with the current education system!

Shouldn’t the desire of every Muslim be to worship Allah -as His Majesty deems fit- and to live under
His laws? If so, then the Shari’ah of Allah which is currently non-existent on the earth, naturally

3
Syed Saleem Shahzad. "Taliban ideology echoes in the valley.”
4
Thomas Babington Macaulay. "Minute of 2 February 1835 on Indian Education." Macaulay, Prose and Poetry,
selected by G. M. Young (Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, 1957), pp729
needs to be established in all aspects of our lives. To establish His laws, do we not then need an
education system which teaches our children from the very beginning about their duties in the
dunya and the importance of raising the banner of la ilaha illal lah? So, how is it possible to establish
an Islamic state without the proper means of education to further this aim?

The schools in Swat consist of a similar variety of those found in the rest of Pakistan. Some of these
schools are government- owned, some are missionary schools (e.g. The Missionary Girls High School
Sangota), and some are semi-government owned (e.g. Excelsior College Swat). Some of these
schools had co education in them and some taught Christianity.

As far as the two above schools are concerned (Missionary school and Excelsior College) they were
both sponsored by the British government and approximately one thousand students from all over
the province were studying in each of them. 5 Due to the popularity of these types of schools, a large
number of students were studying in establishments which were based upon Christian values and
where Christianity was taught or they were schools which were co-educational- an educational
system in which it is haram for us to educate our children due to the inherent dangers and evils that
are involved. 6 So what is the big fuss about getting rid of systems which are corrupting our youth?
Our vision should be to slowly plant the seeds for an Islamic Khilafa. In order for this to occur, we
need the ingredients that will go into achieving this goal. We have to change every aspect of our
current way of living from the root such that it is completely directed towards worshipping Allah and
establishing His laws on the earth. Our minds have to be ready to accept what an Islamic state
requires of us.

To assert that the Taliban are against education of girls or against education in general is fallacious
and unreasonable. The modern western school system has come to epitomize the meaning of what
is considered a valid education today. Thus every other system needs to be infused “with terms of
science borrowed from the Western nomenclature.” 7 The Taliban cannot be against Islamic
education of any student because if they are teaching Islam properly, it will only serve to benefit the
Islamic cause which they have sacrificed their lives for. In fact the Taliban spokesman Muslim Khan
has lucidly stated, "We are not against education, but we insist that our new generation should be
imparted with religious and then scientific and technology education... The Taliban need doctors,
engineers and scientists to strengthen our cause." 8

Even if the girls’ schools were singled out to be destroyed 9 it would still make sense. Why? Women
are the key to the establishment of khilafa. If our women are not educated in the deen but rather in
western education (alone), they will impart false information to their children, or they may raise
their children to hate jihad, to pursue an education for the sake of an education, to get a high paying
job and not have any interest with spreading the deen of Allah. If we lose our mothers, we lose the

5
Dawn Correspondent. “Mingora: Terrorists blow up historical educational institutions.” Dawn News. 8th October
2008. <http://www.dawn.com/2008/10/08/local28.htm>.
6
Islam Question and Answer. Response to “He is studying in a mixed university; how should he deal with female
teachers and students?” <http://islamqa.com/en/ref/45883/>.
7
Thomas Babington Macaulay. "Minute of 2 February 1835 on Indian Education.”
8
Fasihur Rehman Khan. “Taliban in Swat ready to reconsider women's education.” Gulf News. 28th Jan. 2009.
< http://www.gulfnews.com/world/Pakistan/10279933.html>.
9
They were not because many boys schools were bombed too.
tarbiya (Islamic) of the children, which means we have children who either do not care or are
ignorant about Islam, which means we do not have a strong generation of youth who are the fuel of
this ummah and this jihad, which means we potentially do not have an Islamic khilafa.

The issue at hand has to do with teaching a way of life (i.e. British versus Islamic curriculum) not the
imparting of skills. Those who claim that the destroying of schools means children will not be able to
acquire skills are mistaken. Acquiring a skill is not something only offered at a secular institution.
Let’s give the Taliban some breathing space. We will see what they will do after the operation is
over inshaAllah.

The prophet ‫ ﺻﻠﻰ ﷲ ﻋﻠﻴﻪ ﻭ ﺳﻠﻢ‬said ‘Seeking knowledge is obligatory upon every Muslim.’ 10 9F

According to Sheikh Muhammed Salih Al-Munajjid, “what is meant by knowledge [in the above
hadith] is knowledge of sharee’ah (Islamic knowledge). Al-Thawri said: “It is the knowledge for which
no person has any excuse for not knowing [i.e. the basic ‘ebadaat].” 11 It therefore becomes
10F

incumbent upon the Muslims to teach their children the essentials of Islam, and by inference, any
other secular education is not obligatory. This begs the question, if the Pakistani government is
really fighting for Islam as it claims, then why does it not change the educational system to an Islamic
one or help the Taliban in doing so, since they understand Islam ‘so well’? Or are they satisfied with
the existing system in which Islam is not being given the top priority?

Why is it that the government claims they are fighting for Allah ‫ﺳﺒﺤﻨﻪ ﻭ ﺗﻌﺎﻟﻰ‬yet they bombed not only
the premises, but the students of an Islamic school (Lal Masjid) to smithereens? It was especially
known to have a full Islamic curriculum (in addition to English and science being taught) 12, and 1F

enforced knowledge of the shari’ah. Oh I forgot! The government does not want Islam. Evidence for
this is when the shaheed inshaAllah, Abdur Rashid Ghazi while being interviewed by CNN for a
documentary called Pakistan: The Threat Within, said, “We have been asked by the government
many times that ‘you should stop teaching the chapter of Jihad’. So we tell them, ‘we can’t stop it
because we cannot make any amendment in Islam.’” 13 12F

If it is asked, why the Taliban had to bomb the schools in Swat, then the reply is that one has to know
the situation on the ground. Haji Muslim Khan said “Nobody can prove that we bombed any school
building during phase one of the military operations in the Swat Valley. [Sarcastically] Why did the
“well-educated” and “very qualified” Pakistan army set up military bunkers in the schools? This is my
question.” 14 In ideal circumstances, the issue of changing the curriculum could have been done
13F

through dialogue. However when you have your enemy actively fighting you for your religion,
destroying your homes, day and night then do you not retaliate? He further goes on to say, “These
are the “well educated” and “very qualified” people of our security forces who bombed our villages
and destroyed them. We have, therefore, the right to destroy those schools which brought up this
generation, sold out to foreigners and sold their own people to foreigners.”
10
A Hasan hadith narrated by Ibn Majah [1/81]
11
Islam Question and Answer. Response to ““Seek knowledge even if you have to go as far as China” is a false
hadeeth” < http://www.islamqa.com/en/ref/13637/>.
12
Wintess Special: Inside the Red Mosque. Al Jazeera English Documentary.
<http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RrKEaOeZs2o>.
13
Pakistan: The Threat Within. CNN Documentary. First aired on 7th July 2007. Quote from 9:22-9:34.
14
Syed Saleem Shahzad. "Taliban ideology echoes in the valley.”
Consequently, if for example the army was not stationed in these schools, would it still have been
legitimate for them to destroy them? Let’s think about it logically. If the schools were left in tact
with the same curriculums being applied, and producing the same weak generation of Muslims who
hate to fight for the sake of Allah, who do not want Islam to be the judge of their affairs, then we
would have to face the dire consequence a few years down the line of more and more Muslims who
are solely dunya-oriented. The alternative is that you temporarily destroy the schools so that one,
the curriculums are not being taught and therefore children are not being fed the same rhetoric as
before and two, nobody dares to even oppose the Taliban and start teaching again. They have also
promised that “we can rebuild those buildings within a month [once the military operations are
over].” 15 In most cases, the Taliban have delivered on their promises.

To those who claim that ‘violence’ is only going to breed more uneducated citizenry and peace will
never prevail as long as this is the case, I say, peace in a society is achieved when humans worship
Allah as He is supposed to be worshipped. It is when we follow His commands and stay away from
what he has prohibited or is displeased with.

Peace in a society cannot simply be achieved through “education.” Some assert, “as long as they can
read and write, they can get jobs, feed their families, thus not steal or resort to violent behavior.”
Education needs to have a purpose. If education is for the sake of the dunya, then you will never
have “peace” in the society, because living will not be for the sake of Allah. Conversely, if education
is directed for the main purpose of teaching children Islam- how to live it, sleep it, drink it, carry out
every aspect of it, solely for the purpose of Allah, then this is how peace will be achieved.

{ and keep yourself (O Muhammad ) patiently with those who call on their Lord (i.e. Your
companions who Remember their Lord with glorification, praising In prayers, etc., and other
righteous deeds, etc.) morning and afternoon, seeking his face, and let not Your eyes overlook
them, desiring the pomp and glitter of the life of the world; and obey not Him whose heart we
have made heedless of Our Remembrance, one who follows his own lusts and whose affair (deeds)
has been lost.} [Al Kahf: 28]

15
Syed Saleem Shahzad. "Taliban ideology echoes in the valley.”