Upside: Why Most Value Investors Will Burn Out - WSJ.

com

News, Quotes, Companies, Videos

SEARCH SEARCH

U.S. EDITION

Friday, February 15, 2013 As of 4:55 PM EST

Subscribe

Log In

Home

World

U.S.

New York

Business

Tech

Markets
Investing

Market Data
Stocks
3 of 12

Opinion
Bonds

Life & Culture

Commodities

Real Estate
Currencies

Careers
CFO Journal
5 of 12

Wall Street

Heard on the Street

Market Data

Personal Finance

Funds/ETFs

Wealth Mgmt

TOP STORIES IN PERSONAL FINANCE of 12 2

4 of 12

With Stock Prices Soaring, Investors Fear Another Crash

THE INTELLIGENT INVESTOR

First Homework, Then They Can Play Online

How to Get to Retirement? Practice!

A New Prescription for Taxes

February 15, 2013, 4:55 p.m. ET

Value Stocks Are HotBut Most Investors Will Burn Out

Article
Stock Quotes Comments (38)
Email Print

BY JASON ZWEIG

By JASON ZWEIG
LIKE THIS COLUMNIST Like 156

MORE IN INVESTING

"Most people aren't cut out for value investing, because human nature shrinks from pain," the money manager Jean-Marie Eveillard told me this past week. His words are a reminder that making money on cheap stocksthe goal of every value investoris harder than it sounds and can take years to play out. Lately, value investing has seemed easy. Over the past year, the Russell 1000 Value Index, a yardstick of cheap stocks with sluggish expected earnings, is up 19%, compared with 11% for pricier "growth" stocks and 15% for the full Russell 1000 index of big U.S. stocks. The public has started to notice: Mutual funds specializing in large value stocks took in $2.4 billion in January. But as Mr. Eveillard warns, the longterm rewards don't go to people who think value investing is easy. Superior returns can be earned only by those who know that it is hardand stay put. Take it from Mr. Eveillard. From 1979 through 2004, he was the lead Enlarge Image manager of the SoGen International Christophe Vorlet Fund (now First Eagle Global ). Over that period, the fund earned an average of 15.8% annually, versus 11.3% for the MSCI World Index of global stocksone of the widest and longest margins of outperformance on record. But in the late 1990s, "new economy" stocksthink Internet startupswere hot. Mr. Eveillard owned the old economy: railway, gold-mining and Japanese insurance companies. His fund trailed the index by 25 percentage points in 1998. "After one bad year investors were upset," he recalls. "After two they were mad, and after three they were gone." Between 1997 and early 2000, investors yanked out two-thirds of the fund's assetsand then missed out on its later years of

Available to WSJ.com Subscribers

The New King of Magazines

G-20 to Issue Pledge on Monetary Policy

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324432004578306153331261978.html[2013-02-19 9:52:51 AM]

Upside: Why Most Value Investors Will Burn Out - WSJ.com

superb performance. The fund industry has long marketed the chimera of "consistency," the idea that a great stock picker can always earn higher returns than the market. Investors who buy into this myth often sell in a panic as soon as the next crash proves that no stock picker can always outperform. Over the decade ended Dec. 31, value funds specializing in large stocks returned an average of 6.7% annually. But the typical investor in those funds earned just 5.5% annually, according to Russel Kinnel, director of fund research at Morningstar MORN -0.48% . That is partly because many investors bailed out after these funds lost an average of nearly 37% in 2008; the subsequent rebound was captured only by those who stuck around. "Too many investors tend to think that [value] strategies are flawless or 'bearproof,'" Mr. Kinnel saysand then sell out in shock when they realize the strategies aren't. Summit Street Capital Management, an investment partnership in New York, recently analyzed a group of value investors with long records of superior returns and found that even the best underperformed one-third to 40% of the time. "It's hard not to get shaken out unless you understand that and have conviction," says Summit Street partner Jennifer Wallace. You also should understand how the present and future might differ from the past. Since 1926, value stocks have outperformed growth stocks by an average of four percentage points annually, according to the authoritative index compiled by finance professors Eugene Fama of the University of Chicago and Kenneth French of Dartmouth College. But be warned: Today's typical value fund might not be able to deliver the superior returns generated by bargain stocks in earlier decades. Nowadays, most value managers search for stocks that are cheap relative to current or expected earnings. The bargain stocks in the best-known Fama-French index were selected on a different measure: book value, a basic yardstick of corporate net worth. Many stock pickers don't pay much attention to book value anymore. And while small-company returns accounted for much of the historical high returns on the Fama-French index, most managers today favor larger companies. Value stocks also are less of a bargain than they used to be. Historically, they averaged 54% cheaper than growth stocks, as measured by prices relative to earnings, says Eric Weigel, director of research at the Leuthold Group, an investment firm in Minneapolis. Today, value is 40% cheaper. So value might fade again before long. To be a value investor, it isn't enough to buy cheap stocks or the funds that own them. You have to stick around until the market recognizes their worth. Mr. Eveillard, now 73 years old and an adviser to his old fund, is still finding bargains in Japan and among gold-mining stocksbut he is prepared to "suffer" until the market proves him right.
intelligentinvestor@wsj.com; twitter.com/jasonzweigwsj

Global TB Fight Hits a Wall

Last Marine Standing: Tormented by Survival

Don't Miss

[?]

At Whole Foods, Low Prices Mean Trouble in Aisle 2

Opinion: The Wimpification of America

Six-Figure Salary, No Bachelor's Degree Required

Most Popular
Read Emailed Video Commented

1. 2. 3. 4. 5.

White House Immigration Plan Leaked

Opinion: Best of the Web Today: Critical Condition There's a Feeling of Instability Bubbling Up A Genetic Code for Genius? Opinion: The Minority Youth Unemployment Act

Recent Columns
Why Most Value Investors Will Burn Out A 'Bucket List' for Better Diversification It's Hard to Limit U.S. Stock Exposure

About Jason Zweig

Jason Zweig writes The Intelligent Investor every Saturday for The Wall Street Journal. He is the author of Your Money and Your Brain, on the neuroscience of investing, and the editor of the revised edition of Benjamin Graham's The Intelligent Investor, the classic text that Warren Buffett has described as "by far the best book about investing ever written." Before joining the Journal, Jason was a senior writer for Money magazine and a guest columnist for Time magazine and CNN.com, and he also spent a year studying Middle Eastern history and culture at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem.

Consumer Interest Rates

Savings Mortgage Auto Rate Last Week Chart Loan Types

Write to Jason Zweig at intelligentinvestor@wsj.com

A version of this article appeared February 16, 2013, on page B1 in the U.S. edition of The Wall Street Journal, with the headline: Value Stocks Are HotBut Most Investors Will Burn Out.

1 yr CD 6 month CD

0.65% 0.44%

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324432004578306153331261978.html[2013-02-19 9:52:51 AM]

Upside: Why Most Value Investors Will Burn Out - WSJ.com 3 month CD
JOIN THE DISCUSSION MORE IN

0.22% 0.51% 0.48%

$10K MMA MMA

Find rates:

38 Comments, add yours

Investing

Enter Zipcode

SEARCH

Email

Print

Order Reprints

The Intelligent Investor RSS Feed

More in Investing
Why Most Value Investors Will Burn Out
Hot Stock Pick OBJE Stable Growth, Diversity, Promising Outcome--Invest Today, Learn More! www.OTCStockPick.com 1000%+ Penny Stock Gains? Join our 100% Free Newsletter today and get picks that skyrocket! www.PennyStocks.com Cash Buyers Wanted Buy Wholesale Properties 20%-40% Below Market beltwaywholesaleproperties.com Florida Real Estate Great returns on your investments backed by real estate BuyRealEstateInUS.com/investor

Don't Miss
Icahn Uses Herbalife to Break Ackman Five Things Harder to Buy Than Guns

Frenzy Over New Diet Pill Stores Across Canada Selling Out of This New 'Miracle' Weight Loss Pill www.dailyweightlosscalculator.com
What it Means to be Gay in China Abby Joseph Cohen's Contrarian View on Deficits

Toronto Homesellers FREE report. Recent home sales and current listings for your area. www.EtobicokeRealEstate.net SwingTrade-Stocks-Options Real Time Stock Trading Alerts. Make Money, Learn to Beat Wall Street. JBpicks.com

You Might Like

Where the Wealthy Are Moving Assets Dakota Fanning Is A Very Good Girl. Heres Why She Was Naked at Sundance Beware the 'Great Rotation' Two-Finger Test for Rape Needs to End, Experts Say You'd Be Surprised at What's Tax Deductible

Content from our Sponsors

What's this?

Content from our Sponsors

[?]

The 15 Best Business Quotes from Warren Buffett (All Business) A Retirement-Income Strategy When Rates are Low (Citi Blog) An REIT raises its dividend a record 19.2%
(InvestorPlace.com)
CITI BLOG BRIGHTERLIFE.CA INVESTORPLACE.COM

Is the Canadian economy in trouble in 2013?

(BrighterLife.ca)

Estate Taxes: How Hard Does Your State Hit?

Is the Canadian economy in trouble?

Einhorn wants AAPL to unload its massive cash holdings

India and Vietnam: Taking the Glitter out of Gold (The Financialist)

Add a Comment
View All Comments (38) To add a comment please

JOURNAL COMMUNITY

Community rules

Log in

Create an Account
Your real name is required for commenting.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324432004578306153331261978.html[2013-02-19 9:52:51 AM]

Upside: Why Most Value Investors Will Burn Out - WSJ.com

Track replies to my comment CLEAR POST

Editors' Picks
Listening to Gun Guys
Most American gun owners don't recognize themselves in the rhetoric of the NRA or the stereotypes of gun-control advocates. Dan Baum, author of "Gun Guys: A Road Trip," offers a very different picture of American gun culture in a discussion with WSJ Weekend Review editor Gary Rosen.

Paper or Plastic? Dollar Bills, That is!

Canada's central bank has been rolling out plastic bills since 2011. But some users are complaining that the bills are sticky, don't work in all vending machine, and can even melt. WSJ's Karen Johnson reports from Toronto.

A Water Dispute Nears a Boil in Arizona

Global TB Fight Hits a Wall

And the Oscar for Top Terrorism Flick

Subscribe / Login

Back to Top

Customer Service
Customer Center New! Live Help Contact Us WSJ Weekend Contact Directory Corrections

Policy
Privacy Policy Data Policy Copyright Policy Subscriber Agreement & Terms of Use

Ads
Your Ad Choices Advertise Advertise Locally Place a Classified Ad

Tools & Features

Apps Newsletters and Alerts Graphics & Photos Columns Topics Guides Portfolio Old Portfolio

More
Register for Free Reprints E-books Content Partnerships Conferences SafeHouse Mobile Site

Jobs at WSJ

Copyright 2013 Dow Jones & Company , Inc. All Rights Reserved.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324432004578306153331261978.html[2013-02-19 9:52:51 AM]