Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The residents of Kashmir have often been called prisoners in heaven (Ganai, 2008). They are prisoners of one of the worlds longest interstate conflicts, juxtaposed to an exquisite environmental setting. The ongoing strife has cost over 70,000 Kashmiri lives and played a major role in the underdevelopment of Kashmir (Schofield, 1997). In light of this conflict between Pakistan and India, especially as compounded by the 2008 summer riots, it is now more important than ever that the turmoil surrounding Kashmir be addressed. Social services from the State, including education, have been greatly affected by this conflict (Jammu & Kashmir Development Report, 2003). It can be argued that until these issues are resolved, the politically precarious situation of Kashmir will be prolonged even further. History has shown that conflict arises when the majority in Kashmir is ignored and deprived of equal access, opportunities, or a political voice (Rai, 2004). Therefore, it is in the best interest of policy makers to ensure equal and adequate educational, political, and economic opportunities for Kashmiris. This paper provides an overview of educational development in Kashmir, both historically and currently, in the context of the political conflict. The scope of this paper has been narrowed down to the Indian State of Jammu and Kashmir, and not the Dogra Kingdom of Jammu and Kashmir, due to access to reliable data. A comprehensive examination of the entire State of Jammu and Kashmir, or the Dogra Kingdom of Jammu and Kashmir, disregarding the Line of Control between Indian and Pakistan administered Jammu and Kashmir, would be ideal. However, circumstances did not allow this research to manifest. By highlighting educational development in Indian administered Jammu and Kashmir within a historical framework, the patterns of conflict are contextualized. This paper seeks to address the lack of comprehensive and unbiased information regarding educational development in Kashmir, in hopes to begin a dialogue that centers on the people of Kashmir, rather than the political interests of the two nuclear nations of Pakistan and India. In order to address the issue of educational development in Jammu and Kashmir, it is important to define the vocabulary used in this analysis. Jammu and Kashmir (JK) is the Indian administered State of Jammu and Kashmir. Kashmir is defined as the Muslim-majority Northern valley of the Indian State of Jammu and Kashmir (Habibullah, 2008). Educational development is defined as the systematic efforts to improve the education system in Kashmir in order to support broader socio-economic development. The term Kashmiri Pandit is interchangeable for Hindu, as most Hindus in Kashmir belong to Hinduisms Pandit caste (Mir, 2003). A clarification of all of these terms is necessary, especially to aid those who are not familiar with the region.
INTRODUCTION
The beautiful landscape of this disputed State bestows an ironic backdrop on one of the longest running, unresolved, interstatearmed conflicts in the world. Kashmirs rich ethnic and religious diversity is a microcosm of India. Jammu and Kashmir is a very ethno-linguistically complex and culturally unique State, the origins of which can be traced back to its dense history (Burki, 2007). The diversity of the region has had major effects on the development of education, often determining which group receives better educational opportunities than others, a pattern which will be discussed concurrently with the conflict. History has shown that the rulers of the State have long ignored the needs of a majority of its residents (Rai, 2004). The majority of Kashmiri people have historically longed for selfdetermination, a right that has yet to be granted to them from any of its rulers in the past three centuries, including the Government of India. Currently, the State of Jammu and Kashmir in India includes three regions Jammu, Kashmir, and Ladakh (see Maps). Ladakh comprises of mountainous landscapes and forms the Eastern part of the State that shares a border with Tibet; it is also home to the Buddhist minority in JK. Jammu, which hosts the winter capital of JK, is located in the Southern part of the State that contains the Hindu minority in JK. A majority of Muslims live in the Northern valley of the State, Kashmir, which is also the location of JKs summer capital city, Srinagar. Currently, JK is the only Muslim majority State in India with over 80% of the population being Muslim. The residents of JK mostly reside in rural areas; only 20% live in urban areas (Jammu & Kashmir Development Report, 2003). The scenic State is home to the worlds largest military occupation from the worlds largest democracy, comprising an estimated 500,000 to 700,000 Indian troops (Crossette, 1997). Exploring the religious demographics of a region is also helpful in establishing a thorough overview of a region. Prior to Mughal conquest of the Kashmiri valley, most inhabitants were Kashmiri Pandits, who are classified in the highest caste of Hinduism, the Brahmin class of educators, scholars and preachers in Hinduism (Schofield, 1997). Historians dispute whether the conversion of Muslims in the valley was forced or initiated by the followers themselves (Mir, 2003). However, it is universally agreed that Muslims quickly became the majority, and belonged to a lower socioeconomic class than the Kashmiri Pandits. This division and polarization due to religion began a pattern of domination by the religious minority wealthy class, a pattern that has historically infiltrated the education systems of Kashmir (Rai, 2004).
CURRENT ANALYSIS
The current status of educational development in Kashmir is important to explore because it demonstrates how the State manages an education system after a significant amount of violence. The Board of School Education (BOSE) is the central authority regarding education in Jammu and Kashmir (J&K Board of School Education, 2008; Ganai, 2008). Currently, BOSE runs more than 10,609 schools across the State and employs 22,300 teachers (Government of Jammu & Kashmir, 2007). There are approximately 14,938 public and private schools in JK, including primary schools, elementary schools, secondary schools and senior secondary schools (J&K Board of School Education, 2008). BOSE is in charge of training and placing teachers in all schools in JK through two specific programs. In 1986, BOSE established District Institute of Education Training (DIET) and Institutes of Advanced study in Education (IASE) to standardize and improve the quality of teacher education in JK (Ganai, 2008). BOSE largely bases their policies and programs on exams conducted for students in 8th, 10th, and 12th grade. Reforms and changes are also beginning to occur for a better, well rounded, and inclusive education system (Ganai, 2008). For example, the introduction of the Kashmiri language into the secondary school curriculum is an effort to preserve the language and heritage of Kashmiris; it is now given as an optional language course up until 8th grade (J&K Board of School Education, 2008). In addition to the government schools run by BOSE, there are an abundance of private and NGO schools in Kashmir (Ganai, 2008). Regarding religious or madrassa education, which recently has been receiving negative attention due to its supposed link with terrorism, JK only has 1,729 boys and 962 girls studying in madrassas (Sachar Committee Report, 2006). In contrast to other states where numbers run to several thousands, JK has one of the lowest madrassa enrollment rates. Religious experts attribute it to the majority of residents in JK being Muslim, which causes them to be secure about their religion and identity and dismantles their need to attend madrassa for a religious identity (Ganai, 2008). Many of the students in Kashmiri madrassas are from rural areas and poor families, and new admissions are mostly orphans of violence. In order to get a clear picture of the education system, it is helpful to look at the statistics normally associated with education
CURRENT ANALYSIS
The Indian State of Jammu and Kashmir has of primary school aged children, the quality a total population of around ten million of education they receive can be understood people, with five million in Kashmir, four through an assessment of their examination million in Jammu, and less than one million performance (Seventh All India Educational in Ladakh, according to the 2001 Indian Survey, 2002). In 2006, the Annual Status Census. In 1998, the State spent 19% of its of Education Report found that 36% of 3rd overall budget towards education, a fact that to 5th grade students cannot read, and 33% shows the State is moving towards can not do simple math like addition or prioritizing education (Jammu & Kashmir subtraction (Parvaiz, 2007). These statistics Educational Facts & Figures, 1999). are representative of State that is recovering According to the 2001 Indian census, more from conflict, and moving towards than 43% of the population was under the developing their education system. age of 14, and more than one third of the Although Kashmiris follow their own Kashmiri population lived on less than a constitution and take ownership of their dollar a day. The 2001 literacy rate for the own education system, the Indian military State was 55%, with rural literacy of 48% presence in Kashmir makes and urban 72% (Jammu & 43% of the population was it difficult for the Kashmiri Kashmir Development under 14, and more than onepeople or visitors to Report, 2003). This sharp third of the Kashmiri population experience democratic contrast in comparing rural lived on less than $1 per day. freedom. According to versus urban literacy rates 2001 Census of India some, the world's largest illustrates the severe lack of democracy is currently administering the development in rural Kashmir, especially world's largest military occupation (Roy, the lack of education in villages closer to 2008). On an average day, a student has the Line of Control (J&K Board of School frequent sightings of soldiers, military Education). The historical implications of barracks, and checkpoints located all not prioritizing the education of women and around the States capital city of Srinagar. Muslims can be seen through these current Historically, development in Kashmir has statistics. In 2001, male literacy was been severely limited due to this military estimated at 66% and female at 42% presence by India (Habibullah, 2008). This (Jammu & Kashmir Development Report, occupation causes frequent harthaals 2003). Also according to the 2003 Report, (strikes) led by Kashmiri separatist parties among the rural areas Hindu-majority against the Indian military presence. Jammu tops the rural literacy rate charts Kashmiris leave their home, work, and with 72%, and Muslim-majority Kashmir is school regularly to protest in the streets, at the bottom. According to the Report, march in droves, and picket for azadi this is due to the impact of the militancy; (independence) from the Indian all of the districts affected by militancy have occupation of their homeland. This harthaal a low literacy rate, (Jammu & Kashmir is a recurring phenomenon that happens on Development Report, 2003). a monthly, sometimes weekly basis, as was These statistics are not surprising due to the experienced by the author in the summer of historic beginnings of education in Jammu 2008. Everything comes to a standstill rather than Srinagar, and the education of when these strikes take place, which in turn men as opposed to women (Mir, 2003). perpetuates the lack of socioeconomic Although JK has achieved 94% enrollment
CURRENT ANALYSIS
There is currently no contingency plan for the continuation of education and schooling for children during these periods of strikes, an issue that BOSE does not address in its current policies. The military presence and consequential insurgency is a major factor in the lack of economic development in Kashmir (Habibullah, 2008). The lack of economic development in Kashmir has a direct effect on employment opportunities for Kashmiri students when they finish school. Without a solid economy, the job market cannot adequately support the influx of educated and qualified individuals with relevant jobs. Kashmirs average per capita income is more than 100 times less than the United States, at about $324 a year (US Department of Commerce, 2007; India Economic Survey, 2007). The loss of profits from trade and tourism due to the insurgency severely effected economic development in Kashmir. As late as the early 1980s, these two activities accounted for over 17% of the GDP, and by 2001 their share declined to less than 10% of GDP (Burki, 2007). The conflict in Kashmir has crippled the economy of Kashmir. Whether measured by per capita income, aggregate growth rates, or GDP, JK ranks among the bottom one-third economically of the Indian states, and has been one of the slowest growing regional economies in South Asia (Burki, 2007). The two issues of economic and educational underdevelopment in Kashmir are interrelated, and must be addressed concurrently in order for real progress to transpire. The violence causes the people of JK to disregard progress or development, and focus on the politics of the region. In 2005,human rights groups and local NGOs put the total figure of lives lost due to the insurgency at more than 84,000, although most agree to 70,000 (Pal, 2006). Many of the lost lives have been male heads of household, who leave their family for the Kashmiri cause only to die on the battlefield. These men leave behind families, who, after the fathers death are led by illiterate mothers who cannot provide for their families (Schofield, 1997). This phenomenon is creating towns of widows and their families like Dardpora (town of pain). The number of orphans caused by the conflict is estimated to be around 100,000 (McGivering, 2000). For the countless widows of the conflict, education of their child is their top priority; irrespective of their economic status they want to provide quality education to their children (Zahoor, 2008). Yet, in order to support their household, children must leave school early to work, causing 85% of JK students to drop out after secondary school (Parvaiz, 2007). The ongoing conflict in Kashmir has caused a significant amount of human lives lost, causing a collapse of the family structure (Mir, 2003). The effects of the conflict on family structure, economy and education system has been devastating and the State must address these issues in order to begin rebuilding a stable society for generations to flourish within. Also, equitable political conditions are still nonexistent in the State. As the 2006 Sachar Committee report for the Government of India states, in Jammu and Kashmir, with a 67% Muslim population, the Muslim communitys share of the State judiciary is only 48%. Without a government that fully represents its residents, it is difficult to implement policies that are inclusive and representative of the majority in the State.
CONCLUSION
The growing frustration of the unemployed educated youth, the absence of visible economic development, and the continuing conflict are all factors to be considered when studying educational development in JK. Viewing these issues from a historic standpoint is important to understand where and why these issues began. In gathering this information, policy makers are able to design and implement a more holistic strategy in developing Kashmir. By knowing the historic information, it is easier to discover what has and has not worked, and what issues continually transpire with education in Jammu and Kashmir. The ongoing conflict is the overall hindrance to true educational development that promotes equality and opportunities for all of the residents of Jammu and Kashmir in India. In the words of Indias current President, Pratibha Patil, Education is key to Kashmirs peace and prosperity, (AOL India News, 2008).
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Biscoe, C. E. T. (1925). Kashmir in Sunlight and Shade. London: Seeley, Service. Blank, Jonah (1999). "Kashmir: Fundamentalism takes root." Foreign Affairs. Nov. 1999. <http://www.jammukashmir.com/insights/insight19991210-16.html>. Burki, Shahid Javed (2007). Kashmir: A Problem in Search of a Solution. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace. Chohan, A. (1998). Development of education in Jammu and Kashmir State, 1846-1947. New Delhi: Atlantic. Crossette, Barbara (1997). " U.S. Experts Suggest India Ease Military Presence in Kashmir ." The New York Times. 12 Oct. 1997. <http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9E06E5D6103CF931A25753C1A961958260>. "Education key to Kashmir's peace and prosperity: Patil." AOL India. 26 May 2008. <http://www.aol.in/news/story/2008052610449012000022/India/index.html>. Ganai, Nisar (2008). Personal Interview with the Chairman of JK the Board of School Education. 20 June 2008. Government of Jammu & Kashmir. (2007). Digest of Statistics, Jammu & Kashmir. Srinagar: Education Department, Jammu & Kashmir. Gupta, A. (2007). Teacher Education in Jammu & Kashmir. All India Association for Education Research. Retrieved October 1, 2008, from <http://www.aiaer.net/ejournal/vol19207/29._Gupta___Kapoor.htm>. Habibullah, W. (2008). My Kashmir: Conflict and the Prospects of Enduring Peace. Washington, DC: United States Institute Of Peace (USIP) Press. Kumar, R. (2000). The Partition Debate: Colonialism Revisited or New Policies?. Brown Journal of International Affairs, 7(1), 3-11. J&K State Board of School Education. (n.d.). Retrieved October 1, 2008, from <http://www.jkboseonline.com>. Jammu & Kashmir Development Report. Rep. Sept. 2003. State Plan Division, Government of India. <http://planningcommission.nic.in/plans/sdrbody.html>. "Jammu & Kashmir Educational Facts & Figures." Jammu and Kashmir Education. Jan. 1999. National Network of Education. <http://www.jkeducation.net/Facts/Facts&figures/> India News (2008). "Jammu and Kashmir Gets Its First Army Public School." India News. 12 Nov. 2008. <http://www.india-server.com/news/jammu-and-kashmir-gets-its-first-army-4602.html> Mcgivering, Jill (2000). "Kashmir's orphaned thousands." BBC NEWS. 7 Aug. 2000. <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/869953.stm>. Mir, Imraan (2003). A New Kashmir: Religion, Education and the Roots of Social Disintegration. New York: Valley House Books. Meyerle, G. (2008). Death by a Thousand Cuts: The Dynamics of Protracted Insurgency in Kashmir and Sri Lanka. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Dissertation. Mujoo, Ramesh-Kumar (1990). Higher Education and Social Mobility: Interdisciplinary Study of the Impact of University Education on the Career and Attitudes of Graduates in Jammu and Kashmir. Diss. The University of Poona, 1990. Pune: Indian Institute of Education. Pal, W. (2006). Kashmir: New Voices, New Approaches. Boulder: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Parvaiz, Athar (2007). "School enrolment in J&K ." Kashmir Times. 7 July 2007. <http://www.kashmirtimes.com/archive/0707/070710/news8.htm>. Peer, Basharat (2004). "The school that helped build Kashmir." The Rediff Special. 26 July 2004. <http://www.rediff.com/news/2004/jul/26spec1.htm>. Public Private Partnerships In India - Jammu & Kashmir - Introduction. (n.d.). Retrieved October 30, 2008, from <http://www.pppinindia.com/states_j&k.asp>. Rai, Mridu (2004). Hindu Rulers, Muslim Subjects: Islam, Rights, and the History of Kashmir. Princeton: Princeton University Press. Raza, Moonis (1984). School Accessibility in India : The Regional Dimension. New Delhi: NUEPA (Unpublished), 29p. Renner, M. (2007). Kashmir: Physical Tremor, but No Political Earthquake. World Watch Report, Beyond Disasters: Creating Opportunities for Peace, 32-36. Roy, Arundhati (2008). "What would independence mean to the people of Kashmir?." The Guardian Newspaper. 22 Aug. 2008. <http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2008/aug/22/kashmir.india>. Seventh All India Educational Survey. (2002). <http://7thsurvey.ncert.nic.in/1568910/secondpage.asp?code=01&name=JAMMU%20AND%20KASHMIR>. Sachar Committee Report (2006). Status of the Muslim Community in India. Rep. Nov. 2006. The Rajindar Sachar Committee. <http://www.mfsd.org/sachar/leafletEnglish.pdf>. Schofield, Victoria (1997). Kashmir in the Crossfire. New York: Viva Books Private Limited. Taseer, C. Bilqees. The Kashmir of Sheikh Abdullah. New York: Gulshan Books, 2005. The Tribune (2008). "Dropout rate down in schools - Jammu & Kashmir." The Tribune. 26 Feb. 2008. < http://www.tribuneindia.com/2008/20080227/j&k.htm#11>. Tyndale-Biscoe, E. D (1930). Fifty years against the stream: The story of a school in Kashmir, 1880-1930. India: Wesleyan Mission Press. Ul Rehman , I. (n.d.). Jammu is not Kashmir. Rising Kashmir. <http://www.risingkashmir.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=6290&Itemid=51>. Weil, F. (1985). The Variable Effects of Education on Liberal Attitudes. American Sociological Review, 50(4), 458-474. Widmalm, S. (2006). Kashmir in Comparative Perspective: Democracy and Violent Separatism in India. New York: Oxford University Press, USA. Wirsing, Robert G (1998). India, Pakistan and the Kashmir Dispute. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. Zahoor, Sheikh (2002). "Impact of Conflict Situation on Children and Women in Kashmir." Kashmir Human Rights Site. 21 Feb. 2002. <http://kashmir.ahrchk.net/mainfile.php/articles/45/>. Zutshi, U. K (1986). Emergence of Political Awakening in Kashmir. Manohar: South Asia Books.
Unlike similar yet larger organizations that charge upwards of $5,000 to volunteer abroad for seven weeks during the Summer, KashmirCorps Volunteers are assessed a fraction less than five percent of that amount. Funds for remaining expenses must be raised separately. To support volunteer work and cross-culture exchange in Kashmir, please consider sending a contribution to: KashmirCorps 14104 Tattershall Place Germantown, MD 20874 USA Any amount is greatly appreciated and goes a long way toward advancing our work.
Founded by Kashmiri-American students in 2006, KashmirCorps is an independent, nonpartisan, and nonprofit organization whose mission is to improve the welfare of Kashmiri society through service and research For more information, please visit our website at http://www.kashmircorps.org