Brevard County Solid Waste and Recycle Collection Services

RFP P-4-12-23
Ranking Sheet (Base Bid North)
IMeeting Date and Time: 10/04/12 @ 10'00 a.m. Posted Date: 10/05/12 @ gOO a.m. Through' 10/12/12 @ 5:00 O.m.
Advanced Disposal Republic Services Waste Management Waste Pro
Committee Member
Euripides Rodriguez 3 4 2 1
Mel Scott 5 3 2 1
Kathy Wall 5 4 2 1
Stockton Whitten 4 3 2 1
TOTAL 17 14 8 4
RANK 4 3 2 1
WCA
5
4
3
5
17
4
Committee Member Kelly Collins absent. Committee moved forward with quorum. Selection Committee voted unaminously to remove the following options from
consideration: Alternate 1B; Alternate 2B; and Alternate 3B. Committee proceeded with Scoring and Ranking of remaining options and voted unaminously to
short list the North Area Base Bid and South Area Base Bid options to the number 1 and 2 ranked proposers (Waste Pro and Waste Management). The
Committee then voted unaminously to short list Alternate 1A North, Alternate 2A South, and Alternate 3A North & South to the top three ranked firms (Waste Pro,
Waste Management, and WCA) . Short Listed Firms will be invited back at a later date to for presentations and Q&A sessions with the selection committee.
Brevard County Solid Waste and Recycle Collection Services
RFP P-4-12-23
Ranking Sheet (Base Bid South)
Meeting Date and Time: 10104/12 @ 10:00 a.m. Posted Date: 10105/12 @ 9:00 a.m. Through: 10/12/12 @ 5:00 Q.m.
Committee Member
Advanced Disposal Republic Services Waste Management Waste Pro WCA
Euripides Rodriguez 3 4 1 2 5
Mel Scott 5 3 1 2 4
Kathy Wall 5 4 1 2 3
Stockton Whitten 3 3 1 2 5
TOTAL 16 14 4 8 17
RANK 4 3 1 2 5
Brevard County Solid Waste and Recycle Collection Services
RFP P-4-12-23
Ranking Sheet (Alt. 1 A North - Automated, County Owns Carts)
Meeting Date and Time: 10/04/12 @ 10:00 a.m. Posted Date: 10/05/12 @ 9:00 a.m. Through: 10/12/12 @ 5:00 p.m.
Advanced Disposal Republic Services Waste Management Waste Pro
Committee Member
Euripides Rodriguez 4 5 2 1
Mel Scott 4 5 2 1
Kathy Wall 5 4 3 1
Stockton Whitten 4 5 2 1
TOTAL 17 19 9 4
RANK 4 5 2 1
WCA
3
3
2
3
11
3
Brevard County Solid Waste and Recycle Collection Services
RFP P-4-12-23
Ranking Sheet (Alt. 2A South - Automated, County Owns Carts)
Meeting Date and Time: 10104/12 @ 10:00 a.m. Posted Date: 10105/12 @ 9:00 a.m. Through 10/12/12 @ 5:00 Q.m.
Committee Member
Advanced Disposal Republic Services Waste Management Waste Pro WCA
Euripides Rodriguez 4 5 2 1 3
Mel Scott 4 5 2 1 3
Kathy Wall 5 4 2 1 3
Stockton Whitten 4 5 2 1 3
TOTAL 17 19 8 4 12
RANK 4 5 2 1 3
Brevard County Solid Waste and Recycle Collection Services
RFP P-4-12-23
Ranking Sheet (Alt. 3A North South - Automated, County Owns Carts)
Meeting Date and Time: 10104/12 @ 10:00 a.m. Posted Date: 10105/12 @ 9:00 a.m. Through : 10/12/12 @ 5:00 p.m.
Advanced Disposal Republic Services Waste Management Waste Pro
Committee Member
Euripides Rodriguez 4 5 2 1
Mel Scott 4 4 2 1
Kathy Wall 5 4 2 1
Stockton Whitten 4 5 2 1
TOTAL 17 18 8 4
RANK 4 5 2 1
WCA
3
3
2
3
11
3
Brevard County Solid Waste and Recycle Collection Services
RFP P-4-12-23
Ranking Sheet (Base Bid North)
Meeting Date and Time: 12/14/12 @ 1:00 p.m. Posted Through: /61 /;Z
Committee Member Waste Management Waste Pro
/
Euripides Rodriguez
.,;:2
Mel Scott

I
Kathy Wall
L /
Stockton Whitten
I /
i
I
TOTAL
7 If
RANK

/
Brevard County Solid Waste and Recycle Collection Services
RFP P-4-12-23
Ranking Sheet (Base Bid South)
Meeting Date and Time: 12/14/12 @ 1 :00 p.m . Posted Date: Ie< / J7!L2 Through: 1 , ~ h. ;,)IrJ.
Waste Management Waste Pro
Committee Member
~
Euripides Rodriguez
/
Mel Scott
I
t2
Kathy Wall / 2
Stockton Whitten
/
2
TOTAL
f Z
RANK
I d-
- -
Brevard County Solid Waste and Recycle Collection Services
RFP P-4-12-23
Ranking Sheet (Alt. 1A North - Automated, County Owns Carts)
Meeting Date and Time: 12/14/12 @ 1 :00 p.m. Posted Date: !:J II 7 ! /;;Z Through : J:2l9L / I ~
,
I
Waste Management Waste Pro WCA
Committee Member
Euripides Rodriguez
;;/-
! 3
Mel Scott c2 ! -3
Kathy Wall
2-
I
3
Stockton Whitten L
/
,3
TOTAL
5?
I-j /2
RANK , ~
/
-3
I
Brevard County Solid Waste and Recycle Collection Services
RFP P-4-12-23
Ranking Sheet (All. 2A South - Automated, County Owns Carts)
Meeting Date and Time: 12/14/12 @ 1:00 p.m . Posted Date: ;;2../17//2- Through: ~ ~ / a ~ / / 7
Waste Management Waste Pro WCA
Committee Member
Euripides Rodriguez
;;Z
/
:5
Mel Scott cZ /
-3
Kathy Wall L / ~ = ?
Stockton Whitten
/ I .3
TOTAL
7
t.) /2
RANK ,<
8- I
.3
I
Brevard County Solid Waste and Recycle Collection Services
RFP P-4-12-23
Ranking Sheet (Alt. 3A North South - Automated, County Owns Carts)
Meeting Date and Time: 12/14/12 @ 1 :00 p.m. Posted Date: ! 2/; 7//2- Through: /eP6/1e.
Waste Management Waste Pro WCA
Committee Member
Euripides Rodriguez d..
J
-3
Mel Scott ;Z
!
3
Kathy Wall
2-
/
~ ~
Stockton Whitten
L I
3
TOTAL
g
t?
/2
RANK
CJ- I
",":J