Tony Abela: I used discretion - timesofmalta.

com

http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20130216/local/Tony-Abel...

Saturday, February 16, 2013

Tony Abela: I used discretion

Photo: Jason Borg

Labours deputy leader for party affairs TONI ABELA tells Christian Peregin his conscience is clear and his only regret is making so many enemies because of his zeal to stamp out dishonesty. Explain in detail the case mentioned in this second recording when you found someone preparing drugs for sale in a Labour club. You have to take this in the context of a discussion I had when I met the committee of Attard. Was this the same discussion we heard in the first recording? Yes. One of my roles in the Labour Party is to oversee the 65 committees and political centres. I organised this meeting with the Attard committee to try and solve some endemic issues. There was the famous issue of the supposed break-in.... What about the drugs case? I told them we had to be serious. I did not want problems. I told them that some time ago we had a problem when, in a particular centre, I had very strong suspicions that something drug-related was going on. Where did this happen? I cannot tell you. Why not? Because I wont tell you. Im sorry. Why not? The person who approached me to regularise this very embarrassing situation and the committee bound me not to because they were so afraid. These are honest people. One of them came to tell me about the problem. He said: Ton, please get rid of him, so we can live our lives. This was the president? The president, among others, came to tell me what was happening. Once he was passing by the centre and he saw someone in the kitchen handling a white block. Was it cocaine? I dont know what it was. I never went there. All I know is what he told me. The president? Exactly. I never saw these things. I did not see this white block or anyone cutting it. I just got an honest report that they were worried that, on one occasion, not every day, they saw someone in the kitchen of this bar cutting... Did this person work there?

1 of 5

17/03/2013 11:20

Tony Abela: I used discretion - timesofmalta.com

http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20130216/local/Tony-Abel...

No. He seemed to have been a friend of the barman.

Copyright Allied Newspapers Ltd., printed on - 17-03-2013 - This article is for personal use only, and should not be distributed

Did you suspect that they were trafficking drugs? Im a lawyer, I know what it means. My first interest was the committee made up of honest people and the people who frequented the centre. So why blame the president of this club? Its not him I sacked. Unfortunately, thats how it was understood in the recording, which is very disjointed. Whom did you sack? The barman. The one who saw things? No. The one who we scolded for allowing a person to do these things in the kitchen. He said he didnt know about it and he was busy serving clients but I told him I didnt care at all and he should leave immediately. When was this? In 2009? The first part of 2010 or late 2009. But you dont want to say where? No, I wont tell you. Because of legal issues? No, because the fear was that these were honest people... I got the president to the PL headquarters and I told him to give me a statement of what he saw. I told him I want this barman removed. Why take his statement? So that I would be covered. In what sense? I had a person who gave an account of what happened. Because Ill tell you what happens... So you can fire the other man? Yes. You had it in writing that this president saw someone cutting a white block... And I took action. In fact, after he gave me this statement, I summoned the barman and told him to pack up, leave and not come back. But if the case was so serious that justified sacking the barman why didnt you inform the police? I didnt have to because... You have to be in my position to take these decisions. As the Police Commissioner told me... You had a written declaration and a founded suspicion of drug trafficking. Why didnt you tell the police to investigate him? The members of the committee were terrorised. This is a place where everyone knows everyone else. Were they afraid of the person involved? Yes. Were you afraid of him too? Not at all. I dont fear these things... I was afraid for them. When these members came to me they were almost in tears. One of the things I pointed out in the recording was that they disposed of everything... They removed all the evidence. They thanked me for removing him but they hoped things would stop here. They were terrified. Apart from all this, one of the things that dawned on me is that if I made a report... I used my discretion. You may not agree with me but I argued that if I file a report I would get these people in trouble. These, poor things, were... But isnt thats what happens when someone does something wrong and you report it? God forbid we are setting this example just because were afraid.

2 of 5

17/03/2013 11:20

Tony Abela: I used discretion - timesofmalta.com

http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20130216/local/Tony-Abel...

No, but the issue was this. At that moment in time I saw the safety of the people there. I wanted to act fast so this person does not remain there. Didnt you have faith that the police would do their work well and protect these people? The way things happened I was worried I would bring these people in a lot of trouble for being honest and approaching me immediately, when these things had already happened. So I felt I needed to be careful. Werent you covering up a case of drug trafficking? No, because I never saw the substance. I dont even know what it was and I stuck to what they told me. Youre not a normal citizen. You are a lawyer and the deputy leader of the Labour Party. Dont you think you had the duty, even politically, to report, despite these fears? My biggest duty was to see that the club is no longer occupied by people who could harm those who visit the centre and also to keep up the good name of the party. Not that justice should be carried out with these people? They reported to me and as a lawyer... Let me make it clear, there are two types of people I do not defend: drug traffickers and child abusers. I dont take on that work because I abhor drugs. When I saw this, I was alarmed because the last thing I wanted was to have a centre where this sort of activity takes place. The Police Commissioner called you in for questioning yesterday. Why? I was going out to eat with my wife for Valentines Day. As we got to the table and ordered, the Police Commissioner called me and asked me to pass by... It was the first time I heard the recording. I asked him to explain why he wanted to speak after so long. He told me he had felt there was no case but that he went through the Criminal Code and found a section on which he felt he could approach me. He said I was obliged to provide information when there was an investigation under way. But I said you have to have an investigation first, so it does not apply to me because there was no investigation... Have you offered your resignation? No because I dont have to. I have a clear conscience. If this reflects badly on the Labour Party, dont you feel you should? If it does, I know what decision I must take. I was always known for never doing anything irregular. In politics, my ticket was always fighting dishonesty, not with words but with facts. In this case, there was a lot of dishonesty: a person taking revenge, a person recording me, a person reporting me because I used to criticise them for their dishonesty and a Prime Minister who had this in his hands but did not release it until now, three years later. What discussions did you have with Labour leader Joseph Muscat? Is he backing you? Let me make it clear, Dr Muscat knew nothing about this. I do not burden him with these problems. But what did he say when the recording surfaced? Joseph is disappointed. Hes disappointed even because of how things happened. What did he say to you? Does he want you to stay? I spoke to him and so far he hasnt said anything in that sense... Do you think hes waiting to see what voters think? Whatever he does and whatever he decides, I will bow my head to his decision. If Dr Muscat feels things can be done better without me, I will not be ashamed to say so because I do not look at my personal interests, just like I didnt do in this case. Looking back, is there anything you would do differently? I think I would be more cautious... Theres one thing I did wrong in this role. I made many enemies because I was too zealous. If I do something, I like to do it properly. I dive in, headfirst. Is your advice to Dr Muscat and Labour not to make so many enemies? Joseph is full of energy and his style is different to mine. In my job Ive learnt that many times you have to be tough with the people around you. You have to take disciplinary actions and you end up having enemies and getting criticised. What is important is that the decisions are taken in good faith, not in your interest.

3 of 5

17/03/2013 11:20

Tony Abela: I used discretion - timesofmalta.com

http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20130216/local/Tony-Abel...

As a deputy leader of a party that has spent the past five years criticising ministers for not doing things perfectly, arent you doing the same thing? Is this the change in direction we are to expect? The change in direction is to have the courage I had that whenever there were people who were dishonest, I told them to leave. I did this, even with local councils. I removed mayors, including friends of mine. In fact, the joke within the party is that it is better not to be my friend because I will be even stricter with you, just to show how well I am doing things.

15 Comments

Emanuel Farrugia
Feb 17th, 18:20 Is-socjalisti warajk Toni. Ahjar GONZIPN jaghti spjegazzjoni u jghid fejn qeghdin imorru dawk il-biljuni ta' EUROS li qeghdin johorgu mill-iskandli mahmuga taht GONZIPN, dan iridu jghidu Simon u Lawrence u l-arkanglu A.G. Halluna nghixu, basta toqghodu tkomplu tghaddu z-zmien biz-zghazagh u l-istudenti issa. IPOKRITI

Emanuel Farrugia - TARXIEN

Fran Abela
Feb 17th, 16:34 Jonathan Camilleri - tell that to the parents of children who were victims of drugs. Are we now sticking up for drug traffickers. I do not mean to say that Dr. Mintoff is a drug trafficker but he refrained from reporting the incident to the police, so as not to show the PL in a bad light.

Karl Consiglio
Feb 17th, 15:37 "I used discretion" So did Lupin 3

T. Caruana
Feb 17th, 12:35 Cittadin normali kien obbligat jiehu l-kaz lill-Pulizija. Imma id-diskrezzjoni apparentament tehles lil Tony Abela milli jkun cittadin normali. KUNTRADIZZJONI. Gvern u poplu RIEQED taht muntajna paroli!

vincent Lia
Feb 17th, 17:36 Toni Abela mhux cittadin normali ghax hu avukat u deputy leader tal oppozizjoni u jist jkun ministru tal gustizja. U il partitarji laburisti akaniti jidefenduh, nispera li mhux kulhadd akanit daqshekk.

Tony Agius
Feb 17th, 11:54 Toni Abela, clearly acted in the interest of His Political Party ( MLP ) and NOT in the interest of the honest Maltese People, puting the interest of the Party and the interest of the President of the Party Club before the interest of all people in general , I am sure that this is very wrong decision by Toni Abela, and even worse decision by the committee for NOT going to the Police first thing.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Feb 17th, 10:45 Owing to the enforced succinctness on comments, my comment today 09:46, might be misunderstood as implying that it was Dr Abela himself who destroyed the drug sample. That would be incorrect.

Francis Saliba M.D.

Feb 17th, 09:46

4 of 5

17/03/2013 11:20

Tony Abela: I used discretion - timesofmalta.com

http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20130216/local/Tony-Abel...

What Dr Toni Abela describes as "his discretion" everyone else (outside the LP fold) considers as an INDISCRETION of the first magnitude covering up major drug traffic inside a Labour Party club and compounding crime by a deliberate destruction of vital evidence obstructing the course of justice. If, according to you, that is "innocence" what would you consider as stupid and guilty?

DC Agius
Feb 16th, 22:28 Kuragg Dr Abela! Qatt ma naf li kien hemm xi partit ankrat mal-poter daqs dan ta' Gonzipn. Lanqas gvernijiet nazzjonalisti ohra. Tal-ghageb ghal xiex qed jaslu biex jonfhu xi haga b'mod redikolu daqshekk. Tibzax, il-poplu illum jaf jevalwa sew minn hu tassew onest anke fl-izbalji u minn hu malinn f'ghemilu.

Victor Vella
Feb 16th, 19:59 Abela is innocent and the PN know that. But they are trying to take cheap political mileage as usual. The usual GonziPN humbug.

ALFRED BRIFFA
Feb 16th, 22:37 Mr Vella, how about asking CARITAS MALTA people like Mr Angelo Fenech and Mons. Victor Grech whether Dr Abela's action was in line with CARITAS policies. The Mons very oftenly comes out declaring that the drugs are reaching the young ones and drugs are everywhere etc etc.... I am eager to hear his condemnation or not of Dr Abela's actions!!!

p grima
Feb 16th, 23:34 Here we go again with the kettle calling the pot black. Drug trafficking is a serious crime. What if some of that stuff killed someone you love?

Jonathan Camilleri
Feb 17th, 10:18 I think Dr Abela was just trying to be discrete and avoid public embarassment.

Fran Abela
Feb 17th, 16:31 I do not think that anyone is accusing Dr. Mintoff of drug trafficking. Drug trafficking is a very serious offence and Dr. Mintoff as a lawyer knows it. In my humble opinion Dr. Mintoff made a big mistake - he should have reported the incident to the police and not kept mum so as not to embarrass his party - the PL.

vincent Lia
Feb 17th, 17:50 Billi il PL qed jiddefendi li min ghamel nuqqas kbir qed jitlef kull kredibilta. Li ma tirrapurtax kas bhal dan hu nuqqas eneromi. Ahna nistennew li kull cittadin jaqdi dmiru u jirraporta kull ma hu hazin.

5 of 5

17/03/2013 11:20