Sunteți pe pagina 1din 5

PVCOPipesSuperiorPerformance

InSeptember2012,IhadtheprivilegeofattendingtheinternationalPlasticPipesXVIConference. Theconferenceincluded465delegatesrepresenting47countries,themajoritycomingfromacross Europe.Theaimoftheconferenceandexhibitionistopresenttechnicalandmarketingissues relatingtothedesignanddevelopment,testing,installationandoperationofplasticpipessystems. OneofkeysubjectsfordiscussionattheconferencewasPVCOpipeswithsixkeypresentationson PVCOanditsadvancementasamaterialofchoiceduetoitssuperiorperformance. WhatthesepresentationagainreconfirmedisthatitisabundantlyclearthatPVCOpipe,when properlyproducedandinstalled,isunmatchedbyanyalternativepressurepipetypeinperformance, environmentalimpactand,importantly,installedcost. IhaveputtogetherasummaryofthepresentationofPVCOfromtheconferenceandincludedlocal AustralianinformationontheuseofPVCOpipes. Regards, NigelJones BusinessDevelopmentManager ThinkPipeThinkPVC

HISTORYOFPVCOPipe
ThetechnologyusedtoproducePVCOpipehascomealongwaysincethefirstprocesswas developedforcommercialproductionbyYorkshireImperialPlasticsinthe1970s.Australiawasan earlyadopterofthisprocess,withVinidexcommencingmanufactureofPVCOpipesbackin1984. Thisprocessinvolvedorientatingthepipesofflineinaseparateorientationchamber,inflatingthe pipesusingpressurisedhotwater.Theprocesswasslowandcumbersomeandproductionwasvery limited. Comethe1990s,anumberofcompaniesincludingVinidexbegantodevelopprocessesthatwould significantlyincreasetheoutputofPVCOpipe.Outofthisworkcametheinlineorientation process,whereafeedstockpipefromtheextruderisstretchedoveramandrelorplugundertightly controlledconditionstoproduceabiorientedPVCpipe.Thisconceptsubsequentlybecamethe standardprocessforproductionofPVCOpipesaroundtheworld.InAustralia,IplexinstalledWavin ApolloPVCOlines,whilstVinidexinstalledtheirpatentedCornetprocess,bothinNSW. In2006,MolecorwasformedinSpainbyformeremployeesoftheSpanishpipeproducerUralita. ThecompanywasformedtodevelopandmarketanewPVCOmanufacturingmethodutilisingan offlineorientationtechnique,basedonpressurisedhotairtoinflatefeedstockpipes.Thismethod onthesurfaceappearstoavariantoftheYorkshireprocessusingairinsteadofwater.However,by utilisingapreheatingoventobringthefeedstockpipesuptotherequiredtemperaturefor orientation,theMolecorprocessmatchestheoutputratesoftheinlineprocesses.

PVCOPipesSuperiorPerformancebyNigelJones,May2013

Page1

ThemostrecentPVCOmanufacturingtechnologycomesfromRollepaal,withtheirRBlueprocess. RollepaalhavebeeninthePVCObusinessforsometimebehindthescenes,supplyingWavinwith theequipmentfortheirApolloprocessWavinareapipeasopposedtoanequipment manufacturer.HoweverRollepaalandWavinhavenowgonetheirseparateways,leavingRollepaal todirectlymarkettheirequipment. TheRBlueprocesshaseffectivelycombinedtheinlinewiththeMolecorprocessandcomeupwitha processthatstretchesthepipeusinghotairbutnotinaseparateorientationchamber.Theairis saidtoactasthelubricantfortheorientationmandrel.Thistechniqueovercomesthesize limitationsofearlierinlineorientationprocessesduetothelargeforcesrequiredtostretchpipe overamandrel.ThisproblemhadlimitedthesizeofPVCOpipetoaround400mmmaximum diameter.TheRBlueandMolecorprocesseshaveallowedsizesabove600mmtobeproduced,with 1200mmdiameterPVCOpipenowunderinvestigation.

ADVANTAGESOFPVCOPIPE
PVChasanumberofinherentadvantagesasamaterialforwaterpipeoveralternativeproducts.In particular,resistancetocorrosionandchemicalattackincludingwaterdisinfectants,effectonwater quality,smoothbore,excellentbalancebetweenstrength,stiffnessandflexibility,easeof installation,costeffectivenessandrecyclability. TheadventofPVCOpipeenhancedtheseadvantages,butalsoimportantlyenhancedthe environmentalbenefitsofPVCpipe.ThefollowingdiagramsillustratetheadvantagesofPVCOpipe overconventionalPVCUandalternativeproducts.ItisimportanttonotethatPVCOandPVCU typicallyhaveverysimilarcompositionsthedifferenceinpropertiesisduetotheorientation process.

Source:Molecor

Figure 1. Spider diagram of key features of PVC-O vs PVC-U PVCOPipesSuperiorPerformancebyNigelJones,May2013 Page2

TheabovediagramshowsthekeypropertyadvantagesofPVCOoverPVCUpipe.The orientationprocesssignificantlyimprovestheimpactandcrackpropagationresistanceof thepipe.Thisisduetothelaminatestructureimpartedonthepipethroughtheorientation process,whichdispersestheenergyfromanimpactorcrackcircumferentiallyaroundthe piperatherthandirectlythroughthewall. ThislaminatestructuremakesPVCOpipevirtuallynotchinsensitive.PVCOpipeistherefore lesssensitivetoscratchingorothersurfacedamagethatmayhappenduringinstallation. TheimagebelowcomparesPVCOandPVCUpipesafterpressuretestinguptothepointof failure.ThelaminatestructureofPVCOcanclearlybeseen. PVCOpipeafterpressuretesting

PVCUpipeafterpressuretesting
Source:Molecor

Theorientationprocesschangesandsignificantlyincreasesthetensilestrengthofthe material.ThefollowingstressstraincurveshowsthedifferentbehaviourofPVCOcompared toPVCUandPE.

Source:Molecor

Figure 2. Stress-Strain behaviour of PVC-O

PVCOPipesSuperiorPerformancebyNigelJones,May2013

Page3

GiventhehighertensilestrengthofPVCO,itclearlywouldbeexpectedtohaveasuperiorlongterm hydrostaticresistancethanconventionalplasticpressurepipes.Thefollowingstressregressionchart confirmsthatthisisthecase.

Source:Molecor

Figure3.LongtermregressionanalysisofPVCO,PVCUandHDPEpipe Astheaboveradarplotshows,PVCOhassuperiorfatigueresistancetoPVCU.Cyclicfatiguetesting conductedbytheUniversityofQueenslanddeterminedthatPVCOhasuptofourtimesthe resistancetocyclicfatigueofPVCUpipe.

ENVIRONMENTAL
NumerousstudiesfromAustraliaandoverseashavedemonstratedthesuperiorenvironmental propertiesandbenefitsofPVCOpipecomparedtoallotherpressurepipeoptions.Comparingpipe weightsanddiameters,itisnothardtoseewhy.
PVCO

Thisimageshowsthedifferenceinwallthicknessesforpipesof identicalpressurerating.PVCOpipeofequivalentsizeand pressureratingwillbelessthanhalftheweightofPE.This representsaverylargesavinginrawmaterial.Withlessthanhalf oftherawmaterialinPVCObeingCarbonbased,its environmentalcredentialsareverystrong.


HDPE

PVCU

Onalifecycleassessmentbasis,PVCOagainratesverywell.ThefollowingchartfromEdge Environmentcomparesthedifferentpressurepipeoptionsonthebasisofecopointratings,where thehighertherating,thegreatertheenvironmentalimpact. PVCOPipesSuperiorPerformancebyNigelJones,May2013 Page4

Figure4.LCAofdifferentpressurepipes(DI=ductileiron) ThereductioninwallthicknessofPVCOmeansthepipewillhaveasignificantlylargerborefora givenexternaldiameter.ThisenablesPVCOpipetohavethehighestflowcapacityofallpressure pipes,allowingittomovemorewater,fasterthanthealternatives.Thisrepresentsapotential savinginenergyconsumptionintransportingwaterwhenusingPVCOpipe,furtherenhancingits environmentalcredentials.

SUMMARY
PVCOpipehasanumberoftechnical,performance,commercialandenvironmentaladvantages overcompetingpressurepipessuchasductileironandPE.Fromasustainabilityperspective,itisa clearwinner.ThefollowingtablesummarisesthesustainabilityadvantagesofPVCOpipecompared tothealternatives. Social Lowestfailurerates Fasterinstallation Safertoinstall Lowesteffectonwater quality BestROIforconsumers Provenlongevity Ecologic 57%byweightfromsalt NohazardousRMs Lowestembodiedenergy Conserveswater Recyclable Economic Lowestcostpipe Lowestinstalledcost Lowestoperatingcost Lowestmaintenancecost Allowscapextostretch further

PVCOpipesareavailableinAustraliafromthefollowingcompanies: IplexPipelines Pentair Promains Vinidex Page5

PVCOPipesSuperiorPerformancebyNigelJones,May2013

S-ar putea să vă placă și