The Islamic University of Gaza Department of Civil Engineering

Design of Rectangular Concrete Tanks

RECTANGULAR TANK DESIGN

The cylindrical shape is structurally best suited for tank construction, but rectangular tanks are frequently preferred for specific purposes

Easy formwork and construction process Rectangular tanks are used where partitions or tanks with more than one cell are needed.

RECTANGULAR TANK DESIGN

The behavior of rectangular tanks is different from the behavior of circular tanks

The behavior of circular tanks is axi-symmetric. That is the reason for the analysis to use only unit width of the tank The ring tension in circular tanks was uniform around the circumference

RECTANGULAR TANK DESIGN

The design of rectangular tanks is very similar in concept to the design of circular tanks

The loading combinations are the same. The modifications for the liquid pressure loading factor and the sanitary coefficient are the same. The major differences are the calculated moments, shears, and tensions in the rectangular tank walls.

RECTANGULAR TANK DESIGN

The requirements for durability are the same for rectangular and circular tanks. The requirements for reinforcement (minimum or otherwise) are very similar to those for circular tanks. The loading conditions that must be considered for the design are similar to those for circular tanks.

RECTANGULAR TANK DESIGN

The restraint condition at the base is needed to determine deflection, shears and bending moments for loading conditions.

Base restraint conditions considered in the publication include both hinged and fixed edges. However, in reality, neither of these two extremes actually exist. It is important that the designer understand the degree of restraint provided by the reinforcing bars that extends into the footing from the tank wall. If the designer is unsure, both extremes should be investigated.

RECTANGULAR TANK DESIGN

Buoyancy forces must be considered in the design process

The lifting force of the water pressure is resisted by the weight of the tank and the weight of soil on top of the slab

RECTANGULAR TANK BEHAVIOR

y

Y-axis is the horizontal axis X-axis is the vertical axis direction downward
when the plate is in the x-y plane. This moment determines the steel in the x (vertical direction).

Mx moment per unit width stretching the fibers parallel to the x direction

My moment per unit width stretching the fibers parallel to the y direction
when the plate is in the x-y plane. This moment determines the steel in the y (horizontal direction). The Subscript in Mx and My is not the axis of the moment The moments are not in a particular principal plane

Moment coefficient for Slabs with various edge Conditions

Moment coefficient for Slabs with various edge Conditions

Moment coefficient for Slabs with various edge Conditions

Moment coefficient for Slabs with various edge Conditions

Moment coefficient for Tanks with Walls Free at Top and Hinged at Bottom (Table 5)

Moment coefficient for Tanks with Walls Free at Top and Hinged at Bottom (Table 5)

Moment coefficient for Tanks with Walls Hinged at Top and Bottom (Table 6)

Moment coefficient for Tanks with Walls Hinged at Top and Bottom (Table 6)

Shear Coefficeient

Along vertical edges, shear in one wall is also used as axial tension in the adjacent wall and must be combined with bending moment to determine tensile reinforcement

Table 7. Shear at Edges of Slabs Hinged at Top and Bottom

Shear Coefficients
Notes on Tables 7

The first five lines in Table 7 are shears per linear length in terms of wa2. The remaining four lines are total shears in kN depending on how w is given. Shears per linear foot are for ratios of b/a = 1/2, 1,2, and infinity. The difference between the shear for b/a = 2 and infinity is so small that there is no necessity for computing coefficients for intermediate values. When b/a is large, a vertical strip of the slab near midpoint of the b dimension will behave essentially as a simply supported one-way slab.

Shear Coefficeient
Notes on Tables 7

Total pressure on a strip 1 m wide is 0.50wa2, of which twothirds or 0.33wa2 is the reaction at the bottom support and onethird or 0.17wa2 is the reaction at the top. The shear at midpoint of the bottom edge is 0.3290wa2 for b/a = 2.0, the coefficient being very close to that of one third for infinity. In other words, maximum bottom shear is practically constant for all values of b/a greater than 2 At the corner, shear at the bottom edge is negative and numerically greater than shear at midpoint.

Shear Coefficients

Unit shears at the fixed edge in Table 7 were used for plotting the curves in Fig. 1. Maximum value occurs at a depth below the top somewhere between 0.6a and 0.8a. Fig. 1 is useful for determination of shear or axial tension for any ratio of b/a and at any point of a fixed side edge.

Shear Coefficeient
Table 8. Shear at Edges of Slabs Free at Top and Hinged at Bottom*

For b/a = and 1 it makes little difference in total shear the area within shear curves-whether the top is supported or not. Consequently, curves for b/a = and 1 remain practically unchanged. For b/a = 2 a change in the support at the top has little effect upon shear at the bottom of the fixed edge.

Shear Coefficients

The curves in Figs. 1 and 2 are nearly identical at the bottom. As the top is approached curves for the free top deviate more and more from those for the hinged top

Shear Coefficients
Notes on Tables 8 and Figure 2

In a comparison of Figs. 1 and 2. Whereas for b/a = 2.0 and 3.0 total shear is increased 12% and 22%, respectively, when top is free instead of hinged, maximum shear is increased but slightly, 2% at most. The reason is that most of the increase in shear is near the top where shears are relatively small.

MultiCell Tank
Corner of Multicell Tank:

Moment coefficients from Tables 5 and 6, designated as L coefficients, apply to outer or L shaped corners of multi-cell tanks.

MultiCell Tank Three wall forming T-Shape:

If the continuous wall, or top of the T, is part of the long sides of two adjacent rectangular cells, the moment in the continuous wall at the intersection is maximum when both cells are filled. The intersection is then fixed and moment coefficients, designated as F coefficients, can be taken from Tables 1, 2, or 3

MultiCell Tank Three wall forming T-Shape:

If the continuous wall is part of the short sides of two adjacent rectangular cells, moment at one side of the intersection is maximum, when the cell on that side is filled while the other cell is empty. For this loading condition the magnitude of moment will be somewhere between the L coefficients and the F coefficients.

MultiCell Tank Three wall forming T-Shape:

If the unloaded third wall of the unit is disregarded, or its stiffness considered negligible, moments in the loaded walls would be the same L coefficients. If the third wall is assumed to have infinite stiffness, the corner is fixed and the F coefficients apply. The intermediate value representing more nearly the true condition can be obtained by the formula. n End Moments L L F n 2 where n: number of adjacent unloaded walls

MultiCell Tank

MultiCell Tank Intersecting Walls: If intersecting walls are the walls of square cells, moments at the intersection are maximum when any two cells are filled and the F coefficients in Tables 1, 2, or 3 apply because there is no rotation of the joint. If the cells are rectangular, moments in the longer of the intersecting walls will be maximum when two cells on the same side of the wall under consideration are filled, and again the F coefficients apply.

MultiCell Tank Intersecting Walls: Maximum moments in the shorter walls adjacent to the intersection occur when diagonally opposite cells are filled, and for this condition the L Coefficients apply.

Example 1 (Open-Top Single-Cell Tank)

The tank shown has a clear height of a = 4 m. horizontal inside dimensions are b = 10.0 m and c = 5.0 m. The tops of the walls are considered free and the bottom hinged.
A C E

Example 1 (Open-Top Single-Cell Tank)

Coefficients for moment and shear are selected from tables or diagrams for:
b/a = 10/4.0 = 2.50 and c/a =5/4 = 1.25.

Moments are in ton.m if coefficients are multiplied by wa3 = 1.0 x 64= 64 Shears are in ton if coefficients are multiplied by
wa2 = 16.

Moment coefficients taken from Table 5 for b/a = 2.5 and c/a = 1.25 are tabulated below.

Example 1 (Open-Top Single-Cell Tank)

x/a
0 1/4 1/2 3/4

y=0 Mx
0 0.026 0.045 0.044

y=b/4 My Mx
0 0.015 0.031 0.034

y=b/2 Mx
0

z=c/4 Mx
0

z=0 Mx
0 -0.002

My
0.035

My
-0.092

Mz
-0.030 -0.26

Mz
-0.010 -0.003

0.069 0.059 0.048 0.029

0.034 -0.016 -0.089 -0.006

0.031 -0.016 -0.062 0.003 -0.012 +0.008 +0.007 0.020 -0.012 -0.059 0.011 -0.002 +0.018 +0.008

Example 1 (Open-Top Single-Cell Tank)

The largest moment occurs in the horizontal direction at the top of the corner common to both walls (line AB) and equals
MAB=-0.092wa3 = -0.092 x 64 = -5.9 ton-m.

The negative sign simply indicates that tension is on the inside of the wall. Maximum horizontal moment at midpoint of the longer wall (line CD) is: MCD= +0.069wa3 = 0.069 x 64 = +4.42 ton-m. The positive sign shows that tension is in the outside of the wall. There is also some axial tension on this section that can be taken equal to end shear at the top of the shorter wall.

Example 1 (Open-Top Single-Cell Tank)

For use in connection with Fig. 2, ratio of b/a for the shorter wall is 5/4 = 1.25. The shear is 0.03wa2 = 0.03 x 16 =0.48 ton. The effect of axial tension is negligible in this case and the steel area can be determined as for simple bending. Horizontally at x = a/2 the axial tension taken from Fig. 2 for b/a = 1.25 is equal to N = -0.30wa2 = -0.30 x 16 =-4.80 ton per linear meter, which is not negligible. Moment is M = 0.048wa3 = 0.048 x 64 = 3.06 ton-m

Example 1 (Open-Top Single-Cell Tank)

In the shorter wall, positive moments are all relatively small. Maximum positive moment is vertical: 0.018wa3 = 0.018 x 64 =1.15 ton-m. Maximum Mx in the vertical strip at midpoint of longer panel 0.045wa3 = 0.045 x 64 = 2.88 ton-m.

Example 2 (Closed Single-Cell Tank)

The tank in this example differs from the preceding one only in that the tops of the walls are considered hinged rather than free. This condition exists when the tank is covered by a concrete slab with dowels extending from the wall into the slab without moment reinforcement across the bearing surface. A E
C

Example 2 (Closed Single-Cell Tank)

Coefficients for moment and shear are selected from tables or diagrams for: b/a = 10/4.0 = 2.50 and c/a =5/4 = 1.25. Moments are in ton-m if coefficients are multiplied by wa3 = 1.0 x 64= 64 Shears are in ton if coefficients are multiplied by wa2 = 16. Moment coefficients taken from Table 6 for b/a = 2.5 and c/a = 1.25 are tabulated below.

Example 2 (Closed Single-Cell Tank)

Moment coefficients taken from Table 6 are given below. All coefficients for x = 0 (top edge) and x = a (bottom edge), being equal to zero, are omitted.
x/a
1/4 1/2 3/4

y=0 Mx
0.032 0.052 0.048

y=b/4 My Mx
0.022 0.038 0.037

y=b/2 Mx My

z=c/4 Mx Mz
0.004 0.007 0.008

z=0 Mx
0.007 0.018 0.022

My

Mz
0.012 0.019 0.016

0.011 0.018 0.015

0.010 -0.006 -0.032 0.003 0.017 -0.011 -0.053 0.008 0.014 -0.010 -0.048 0.014

Example 2 (Closed Single-Cell Tank)

With a free top, maximum Mx = +0.045wa3 and maximum My = -0.092wa3. With a hinged top, maximum Mx =+0.052wa3 and maximum My=-0.053wa3. It is to be expected that a wall with hinged top will carry more load vertically and less horizontally, but it is worth noting that maximum coefficient for vertical moment is only 13% less for wall with free top than with hinged top. The maximum My coefficient at y=0 is 0.069 for a free top but 0.018 for a hinged top. Adding top support causes considerable reduction in horizontal moments, especially at y=0.

Example 2 (Closed Single-Cell Tank)

Maximum moment is My=-0.053wa3 = -0.053 x 64=-3.4 ton-m. Maximum moment in a vertical strip is Mx= 0.052wa3 = 0.052 x 64 = 3.3 ton-m. Axial compression (N) on the section subject to this moment, and loads per linear meter can be taken as follows:

4 meter high wall: 2 x 0.30 x 2.5 = 1.5 ton 30 cm. top concrete slab: 0.30x 2.5 x5/2 = 1.9 ton 1-meter fill on top of slab: 1x1.75 x 5/2 = 4.4 ton Live load on top of fill: 0.50 x 5/2 = 1.25 ton _____________ Total = 9.05 ton

Top and Base Slabs

The closed single-cell tank is covered with a concrete slab. Assume the slab is simply supported along all four sides and has a live load of 500 kg/m2 and an earthfill weighing 1.75 t/m2. Estimating slab thickness as 30 cm. gives a total design load of 0.50 + 1.75 + 2.5(0.3) = 3.0 t/m2. From Table 4, for a ratio of 10/5 = 2, select maximum coefficient of 0.100, which gives maximum M=0.100wa2 = 0.100 x 3.0 x 25 = 7.5 ton-m.

Top and Base Slabs

At the corners, a two-way slab tends to lift off the supports; and if this tendency is prevented by doweling slab to support, cracks may develop in the top of the slab across its corners. Nominal top reinforcement should therefore be supplied at the corners, say 0.005bd cm2 in each direction. Length of these bars can be taken as = a = x 5 = 1.25 m.

Top and Base Slabs

Assume the closed single-cell tank has a base slab of reinforced concrete. Weight of base slab and liquid does not create any bending or shearing stresses in concrete provided the subsoil is uniformly well compacted. Weight transferred to the base through the bottom of the wall is:

Top slab: 3.0 x 5.6 x 10.6 Walls: 4x0.3x2.5(2x10.3 +2x5.3) Total

= 178.1 ton. = 93.6 ton --------------= 271.7 ton

Top and Base Slabs

If the base slab extends 20 cm. outside the walls, its area is 11 x 6 = 66 m2. The average load of w = 271.7/66 = 4.1 t/m2 is used for design of the base slab just as w = 3.0 t/m2 was used for design of the top slab. Total average load on the subsoil is water weight (4 x 1.0) + 4.1 + weight of base slab, say 4.0 + 4.1+1 = 9.1 ton/m2, which the subsoil must be able to carry. If there is an appreciable upward hydrostatic pressure on the base slab, the slab should also be investigated for this pressure when the tank is considered empty

Two-Cell Tank, Long Center Wall

The tank in Figure consists of two adjacent cells, each with the same inside dimensions as the open-top single cell tank (a clear height of a = 4 m. Horizontal inside dimensions are b = 10.0 m and c = 5.0 m). The top is considered free.

Two-Cell Tank, Long Center Wall

The tank consists of four L-shaped and two T-shaped units. L coefficients from Table 5 for b/a = 2.50 and c/a = 1.25, and F coefficients from Table 2, for b/a = 2.50 and 1.25, are tabulated in the following tables:

Two-Cell Tank, Long Center Wall

Two-Cell Tank, Long Center Wall

Note that F coefficients in this tabulation are used only for calculation of coefficients L-(L-F)/3 that are to be used for design at the intersection of the center and outer walls as shown.

Two-Cell Tank, Long Center Wall

Coefficients for the center wall are for one cell filled, the negative sign indicating tension on the loaded side. All signs must be reversed when the other cell is filled. Shear coefficients in Tables 7 and 8 as well as in Figs. 1 and 2 (in PCA report) can be applied both to center and outer walls.

Two-Cell Tank, Short Center Wall

The tank in Figure consists of two cells with the same inside dimensions as the cells in the two-cell tank with the long center wall. The center wall is 5 m wide in this example.

Two-Cell Tank, Short Center Wall

Design procedure is identical for both two-cell tanks, but the schedule of coefficients is different because the longer side of the cell in this example is continuous instead of the shorter side. Note from the following tabulation that the long wall must be designed for a maximum My coefficient that occurs at the center wall of -0.138 instead of -0.092 at the corner in the tank in previous example. Maximum moment is My=-0.1 38wa3 = -0.138 x 64 = 8.83 ton-m.

Two-Cell Tank, Short Center Wall

Two-Cell Tank, Short Center Wall

Two-Cell Tank, Short Center Wall

6m

8m

Counterforted Tank Walls

In a tank or reservoir with large horizontal dimensions, say three or four times the height, and without a reinforced concrete cover slab, it becomes necessary to design walls as cantilevers or, when they are quite high, as counterforted walls.

The slab shown in Figure is free at the top and may be considered fixed at the bottom. If counterforts are spaced equidistantly, the slab may also be taken as fixed at counterforts. For this type of construction, coefficients in Table 3 apply.

Counterforted Tank Walls

Consider for illustration a wall panel of a counterforted wall in which spacing of counterforts is b=10m and height is a = 5 m. From Table 3, for b/a = 10/5 = 2, select the following coefficients Procedure for using these coefficients to determine moments and design of the wall is similar to that illustrated for the opentop single-cell tank.

Details at Bottom Edge

All tables except one are based on the assumption that the bottom edge is hinged. It is believed that this assumption in general is closer to the actual condition than that of a fixed edge. Consider first the detail in Fig. 9, which shows the wall supported on a relatively narrow continuous wall footing,

Details at Bottom Edge

In Fig. 9 the condition of restraint at the bottom of the footing is somewhere between hinged and fixed but much closer to hinged than to fixed. The base slab in Fig. 9 is placed on top of the wall footing and the bearing surface is brushed with a heavy coat of asphalt to break the adhesion and reduce friction between slab and footing. The vertical joint between slab and wall should be made watertight. A joint width of 2.5 cm at the bottom is considered adequate. A waterstop may not be needed in the construction joints when the vertical joint is made watertight

Details at Bottom Edge

In Fig. 10 a continuous concrete base slab is provided either for transmitting the load coming down through the wall or for upward hydrostatic pressure. In either case, the slab deflects upward in the middle and tends to rotate the wall base in Fig. 10 in a counterclockwrse direction.

Details at Bottom Edge

The wall therefore is not fixed at the bottom edge and it is difficult to predict the degree of restraint The waterstop must then be placed off center as indicated. Provision for transmitting shear through direct bearing can be made by inserting a key as in Fig. 9 or by a shear ledge as in Fig. 10. At top of wall the detail in Fig. 10 may be applied except that the waterstop and the shear key are not essential. The main thing is to prevent moments from being transmitted from the top of the slab into the wall because the wall is not designed for such moments.