Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Chromosomal polymorphism, climatic factors, and variation in population size of Drosophila willistoni i n southern
Brazil
V. L. S. Valente and A. M. Arajo
Departamento de Gentica, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Cx. Postal 1953, 90.001-Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil.
Natural populations of Drosophila willistoni collected every three months over banana baits between September, 1978 and May, 1982 at Parque de Itapui and Parque do Turvo, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil, localised in different regions in terms of climate, flora and fauna, were studied with respect to the variation of their chromosomal polymorphism associated with meteorological variables and population fluctuations.
Multiple regression applied to the variation in the population size (dependent variable), macroclimatic data and heterozygous frequency for inversions of chromosomes IlL and III showed that in
both places those parameters play very distinct roles regarding D. willistoni populations. At Parque do Turvo, where the climate is more constant, the minimum temperature of the month that pre-
ceded each month of collection explains 90 per cent of the population variation of the species, whereas at Itapu, a region presenting greater meteorological instability, intrinsic factors, such
as the inversion frequencies together with two climatic variables can account for the same proportion of the variation in population size. Significant correlations were also found between inversions and climate in both places, as well as associations
ships between the cytological data and demographic and environmental parameters, especially the effects of climatic oscillations.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
INTRODU CTIO N
Studies
by about 500 km, and in different climatic regions: Parque de Itapu (30 17' 5, 51 1' W) and Parque
in sympatry with species from temperate regions (Ehrman and Powell, 1982). Its geographic distribution ranges from central Mexico and Florida to northern Argentina. It was also found by A. R. Cordeiro (unpublished results) at the southernmost locality of Montes Tordillos, 300 km from Buenos Aires (Winge, 1971).
Florestal Estadual do Turvo (27, 21' S, 53 and 54 10' W). More details about both places are found in Valente and Morales (1985). Parque do Turvo is situated in a "hot winter" region, and Parque de Itapu is localised in a "cold winter" area (Plano Integrado para o Desenvolvimento do Litoral Norte do Rio Grande do Sul, 1976).
150
The natural populations of Drosophila willistoni were collected over conventional banana baits dur-
ing an average of 5 days (the time spent at each site was about 30 minutes) every three months
between September, 1978 and May, 1982. The baits measured about 50 cm in diameter and were made from a total of 3 kg of bananas. Nearly half of the
noticeable that, in the 19 samples studied, the frequencies of the overlapping inversions IlL D and IlL E exceed 50 per cent in 17 of them,
exhibiting extreme values, ranging from 42 to 80 per cent, being, therefore, in most cases heterotic.
samples can be considered synchronic, since they had only an interval of a week between places.
The egg samples from females captured in nature and placed individually into tubes with
culture medium were processed using Ashburner's technique (1967), during the late third larval stage. Macroclimatic data such as temperature (C), humidity, rainfall and insolation corresponding to the collecting month were obtained from meteoro-
although sporadically, for inversion B. Table 2 presents the relative frequencies of D. willistoni in the samples and its variations during
logical stations nearer the places of study: IraI Station (about 60 km from Parque do Turvo 27 il'S, 53 14' W) and Porto Alegre Station
(about 60 km from Itapu30 01' 5, 530 13' W). (Appendix 1).
where the introduced species D. simulans is the dominant one (77 per cent of total frequencies) (Valente and Arajo, submitted).
Fig. 1 represents the variation in the frequency of Drosophila willistoni (from table 2B) in parallel with total heterozygosity for chromosomes IlL and
Regression subprograms belonging to the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (Nie et al., 1975) were utilised in order to obtain correlations between heterozygous frequencies for inversions
of Drosophila willistoni and the climatic parameters considered, as well as to evaluate their effect over
rainfall and insolation in common logarithms, humidity and inversion frequencies of chromosomes IlL and III by angular transformation.
RESULTS
"B, particularly the latter, exhibit larger frequencies when the population is in expansion. Among the samples from Itapu there is also
and E (excepting those of January and April, 1981) and an inverse tendency in those of inversions IlL
The
only to chromosomes IlL and III, which are the most polymorphic in our samples among the five chromosome arms of the larval salivary glands (Dobzhansky, 1950). The chromosome arms XL, XR and hR are practically homozygous in our
samples. Table 1 shows the frequencies for the heterozy-
climatic factors on population size was made through the multiple regression technique. The
results for Parque de Itapu and Parque do Turvo are shown in tables 3 and 4, respectively. There are remarkable differences for both localities when the contribution of each variable is compared. By examining the multiple coefficient of determina-
-u
0 0
-o
:i
C/)
Table 1 Heterozygotefrequencies (%) for the most common inversions* of chromosomes IlL and III of D. willistoni collected in the two areas of study Chromosome II L Chromosome III
No. Inversions
z
0
No.
No.
Inversions Total
heterozygosis
0 -o
Ca)
of
of A
B
of
B C
Place
Month! Year
females
F 21-0
D
E 67-0 H larvae 256 20
896
Total heterozygosis
75-0 62-0 79-0
J
150 380
240
larvae
Parque
de 800
15-0
Sept. 78
68
800
15-0
660
140
7-0 212
108 558
420
4-0 46-0 36-0
10
4-0
480
46-0
258
I-.
Dec/Jan
Iapu
600
300 110 280
140
70
100
135
261
5-0 3-0
(1)
40
20
85-0
219
740 600
21 143
M.ar./Apr. 80 Jan/Feb. 81
77 80-0
4-0
509
205
13-0 19-0
50 370 290
15-0 40-0
32-0
108
80
1-0
460
500
546
137
Apr./81
116
60
260
90
420 700 630
63-0 70-0 24-0 20-0 19-0 17-0
10
4-0
48-0
260
511
July/81 78-0
820
0-4 15-0
100
320 45
60-0 68-0 75-0 77-0 79-0 50-0 60-0 70-0 9-0 9-0 8-0 6-0
460 490
240 220
23-0
206 37-0
123
40
710
8-0 12-0 7-0 16-0 16-0
Parque do Turvo
810 830
88-0 80-0
90
110
529
Mar/Apr. 80
69-0
270 265 97
7-0 2-0
800
220 200
17-0 17-0 17-0
220
220
22-0
450 460
102 10
790
170
30
670
78-0
670
780
70 90
220
460 360
28-0 76-0 78-0 72-0
39-0 24-0
920
33-0
88
30
750
79-0
840
160
17-0
127
85-0 86-0
10
0-4
6-0 20-0
264
810
130
46-0 46-0
36 386 259
564
Absence
01
C,'
of D.
Month/year July
May
80 80 80 81 81
willistoni in each sample (A) and along the collection period (B) (from Valente and Araijo, submitted)
Jan.
July Oct.
80 80
Apr./ Jan.
81
Mar./ Apr.
Apr./ May
July
Jan.
82
May
82
willis-
Place
1479 158 37 1234
15 12
1
Aug. 78 79
Sept. 78
Total
toni
Parque de Itapu
5
25 3
1
N 5 20
8297
2815
%A
2
27450
141
111
1587 56 26
272
%B
3204 157 4 3552 6245 1797
8 2
9 5
100 21
4
650 26 11
5913
257 5
1
412 2299
1107 19
2509
3148
471
107 15
1
3938 79 51 5 2765 60 14
2254 47
11
53784
20523
11
N 4
50
17
85
30 7342
1 1
%A
%B
Number of flies
(all species)
4885
4972
2191
4582
4750
44637
46
I-
rn
-I
0 >
L 0
153
0/ I0
III
80
70
II
60
J 50
40 30 20 10
0
-'I
II L
II L
01
100
90 80
.v
70 60
50
iiL
A S DJAMJ
40 30 20 10
iS
75
SO
SI
is
is
0 JMAMJ 0 JrAMJ so si
J N
$2
I TA PU
TURVO
Figure 1 Variation in population size of D. willistoni at Itapu and Turvo (thick line, below) and total frequency of heterozygotes inversions in chromosomes "L and III. Upper graphs: variation in the frequency of specific inversions in chromosomes "L and III.
variables (inversion B of the third chromosome, humidity at the collection month, inversions IlL E, III J and insolation at the collection month) can account for 90 per centof the variation in size.
This same quantitative effect is achieved at Parque do Turvo by a single variable, namely, minimum temperature in the month before collection (table
4). The contribution of inversions IlL E, IlL B, IlL F, and IlL H is negligible there. Table 5 shows the correlation matrix among 19 selected variables of the present study. Values for Parque de Itapu are placed above and those for Turvo below the diagonal. There are three types of significant associations that deserve attention
154
Table 3 Results of the stepwise multiple regression among population size (dependent variable), climatic variables and inversions (independent variables) at Parque de Itapu (B = partial regression coefficient; 13 = standardized regression coefficient; r2 = coefficient of determination; F = variance ratio)
Variable
B
1104656
8698744
/3
r
145937
F
913468891: 1258309721: 1912210541: 94382751: 98898 0721: 445489921: 35848471:
Inversion B (chromosome III) Humidity at the collection month Inversion E (chromosome II L) Inversion J (chromosome III) Insolation at the collection month Inversion H (chromosome III) Maximum temperature at the month before the collection Intercept
275940
1533116 739525
10-74973 10-27072
1i6495 032712
192376 082853
075096
1265875
0-11588
1:=P<0-00l
Table 4 Results of the stepwise multiple regression among population size (dependent variable), climatic variables and inversions (independent variables) at Parque do Turvo. (B = partial regression coefficient; /3 = standardized regression coefficient; r2 = coefficient of determination; F = variance ratio)
Variable
/3
r2
F
174579171: 7979311: 51062791: 25498491: 18786341: 10929761:
39-4581:
Minimum temperature at the month before the collection Humidity at the month before the collection Rainfall at the collection month Inversion E (chromosome II L) Inversion B (chromosome II L) Inversion F (chromosome II L) Inversion H (chromosome II L) Intercept
469060
795321 127748 17-49238 292460
118305
028224
0-68421 0-69452
090201
0-95448 0-97186
098155
0-98970
099968 099999
1:=P<0-001
here: those between chromosome inversions and climatic variables, those between inversions in the same chromosome and those between different
ones.
When correlation among inversions in the same chromosome are examined, four significant values
_0.80* and rA,B=_0.85**). At Parque do Turvo inversion A, D and E from the 2nd chromosome
are found for Itapu involving only the 2nd chromosome (rD,E = o.94**; rA,D = _0.67*; rA,E =
are related (rD,E=0.99*; rA,B _O.65* and rA,H=
0.63*), while only inversions B and C from the third chromosome are associated (rB,c = O.82**).
although with a reverse sign (the exception being inversion III B). At Turvo, inversions of the third chromosome are not correlated with climatic variables with only one exception: inversion J with InsAnt (insolation
As for association of inversions belonging to different chromosomes, at Itapu both "L D,E
correlates with II C,H,J together with "L A, III C and "L H, III B; for Parque do Turvo these are "L A with II B,C and "L H, 11 C. Tables 6 and 7 show the estimated mean num-
in the month before the collection; r=0.81**). Inversion IlL D and E are correlated, of course,
with the same climatic variables (TAntMed, TCo1-
Med, InsAnt and PCo1); it is interesting to note, however, their very different behaviour at Parque de Itapu (above diagonal). IILF is another inversion significantly correlated with climatic variables (UmiCol and UmiAnt).
ber of inversions per chromosome arm and per female in the samples from Itapu and Turvo, respectively. The left arm of chromosome II and chromosome III are the most polymorphic in the two localities. Considering the total mean per
female there are no differences between Itapu and Turvo, although the latter showed a smaller stan-
0 0
-D
(1)
I
of heterozygo te inversi ons in chromosomes IlL and III
Correlation matrix among macroclimaticvariables, population size and freque ncy (above diagonal) and Parque do Turvo (below diagonal)
t
N
0-941: 0-771:
Parque de Itapu
IlL H
C
PCol 0-18
0-851: 0-28
0
UmiCol Ant
0-01
0-921: 0-03 0-01 0-841: 0.64* 0-851: 0.70*
F
J
PAnt InsCol InsAnt
TCol Med
TAnt Med
0-21
0-35
027
0-51
032
036
0-03 0-20
0-25
041
0.73* 0-45 0-08
0-27
0-40
0.67* 0-55
0-32
0-29
TAntMed 0-871: TColMed 0-20 0-53 0-48 InsAnt 0.65* 0.73* 0-781: InsCol 0-37 0-11 UmiAnt 0-57 0-53 UmiCol
0-01
0-38 0-811:
0-06
0.79*
0-41 0-02
0.66*
0-57
0-32
0-37
0-17
0-56
0-54
0-31
0-05 0-44 0-20 0-53 0-14 0.71* 0-47 0-19 0-26 0-14 0.67* 0-811: 0.66* 0-10 0-13 0-11 0-01 0-53 0-10 055 0-43 0-02 0-64 0-62 0-50 0-821: 0-14
021 0-09 0-01 0-47 0-10 011 0-51 0-38 0-14 0-17 0-53 0-29 0-05 0-45 0-36 0.73* 0-17 0-40 094t 0-03 0-42 0-11 0-24 0-21 0-28 054 0-09 0-20 0-58 0-37 0-56 0-40 0-11 0-07 0-03 0-28 0-43 0-18 0-54 0-11 0-06 0-26
005 C
H 0-59 0-61 0.63* 0-20
0-18 0-48 0-41 0-10 0-22
0-09 0-09
0-10 041 0.57 009 0-04 0-11 0-03 0-26 0.71* 0-53 028 0-17 031 0-03 0-40 0-15 0-38 0-43 0-50 0-28 0-26 0-38 0-27 0-43 0.71* 0-16 057 015 0.79* 0.71* 0-40 0-941: 0-48 0.99*
0.74*
0-03
083t D
0-841: 0-23
E
0-20
0-26
0-18
014 0-18
0-10 0-871: 0-43
026
0-11 0-05
A
H
B
0-61 0-08 0-40 029 0-63 0-18 0-14 0-13 0-28 0-49 0-58 0-10 0-04 0-04 0-851: 0-17 002 0.63* 0-01 0-34 0-34 0-24 0-06 0-39 0-39 0.64* 030 0-05 0-05 045 0-46 0-50 049 0-54 0-50 0-29 0.68* 0-27 0-37 0-20 0-33 0-35 0-55
0-39 0-32
PCol=rainfall in the collection month; PAnt=rainfall in the month before the collection;UmiCol=humidity in the collection month; UmiAnt=humidityin the month before the collection; InsCol=insolation in the collection month; InsAnt=insolation in the month before the collection; TColMed=mean temperature in the collection month; TAntMed= mean temperaturein the month before the collection; N=population size.
1:
=P<0-01.
01 01
156 Table 6
Samples
Month/Year
Sept./78
Season
XL
XR 001
258
II L
186
256
II R
III
114
258
Spring
Summer
N N
O0O 258
001
259
Jan./79 Apr./79
000
23
014
21
170
20
009
23
088
24 125 900 125
219
Autumn
N
002
929
001
929
174
896
003
926
July/79
Oct./79 Mar./80 Jan./81
Apr./81 July/81
Winter
N
001
221
002
220
195
212
005
221
Spring
Autumn
000
N N
107
000
107
191
108
005
107
080
108
278
3.34
000
547
000
547
202
558
004
549
125
546
Summer
N
003
136
000
136
147
135
005
136
132
137
288
5.28
Autumn
N
000
139
001
139
292
139
012
139
221
138
Winter
000
511
000
511
183
509
002
511
108
511
124
292
324 063
Total
0006
002
193
005
Table 7 Mean number of inversions per chromosome and per female of Drosophila willistoni from Parque do Turvo
Chromosome
Samples
Month/Year
July/79
Oct./79
Season Season
XL
XR
II L
II R
005
205
Mean no.
III
117
206
Inv/
296 319 246 333
Winter
0004
N
Spring
001
205
172
205
205
002
N N
516
002
516
185
519
009
527
120
529
Jan./80
Apr./80
Summer
001
1289
0'OO
0004
1289
119
1265
004
1289
124
1268
Autumn
N
000
1406
211
1369
004
1413
122
1402
1407
July/80
Oct./80
Feb./81
Winter
N
000
228
000
228
003
182
228
006
228
111
228
298 293
344
337
Spring
Summer
000
N N
470
179
467
004
471
108
467
470 36 355
000
36
000 000
000
231
36
014
36
Apr./81
Autumn
N
000
355
182
383
003
384
100 36 142
386
Jan./82 May/82
Total
Summer
N
000
257
198
254
004
251
115
259
318
257
Autumn
N
0004
566
000
566
183
563
005
568
113
564
300
0004
0006
184
0'06
117
308008
DISCUSSION
ber of inversions in populations of Drosophila willistoni in Rio Grande do Sul, geographically near
tion of the populations to the environmental variations? In this State, due to its climatic characteristics, the effects of the meteorological conditions over flora, fauna and genetics of populations are probably more effective than in typically tropical Brazilian regions.
157
5) shows clearly that they play different roles. As far as populations size is concerned, the differences found in multiple regression for Itapu and Turvo
P<0.05) from Turvo, since they are sufficiently distant to allow free recombination. Asthis is not
occurring their association probably is advantageous for individuals possessing them. The same
show how much biotic and abiotic variables may act differently in both places. Thus, the populations from Parque do Turvo seem to depend much more on the macroclimatic conditions, especially on the previous minimum temperature, than on any other of the variables
for Itapu, and "L A with III B,C, and IlL H with III C for Turvo (table 5).
chromosomal constitution of the species (especially in regard to the inversions of chromosome III)
seems to be the most effective factor with humidity playing a minor role. Such results were surprising at first sight, since
Itapu was considered a marginal environment when compared to Turvo as far as lepidoptera populations are concerned (Pansera and Arauijo,
1983). It would be expected then, that biotic factors
should be more relevant at Turvo than at Itapu; this was not the case. In view of the circumstances we conjecture that at Turvo the climatic factors
Finally, the constant mean number of inversions per female (about 3) over the years and in both places leads us to suggest that probably it
reflects the action of stabilising selection, thus sup-
porting Carson's hypothesis of homoselection at the limit of the species distribution. Similar values
were reported by Da Cunha et al. (1950), Da Cunha
and Dobzhansky (1954), Cordeiro (1961), Cordeiro et aL (1960) in samples from Rio Grande do
Sul.
literature similar data in order to compare them with our data. However, it is also important to
point out that the coexistence and competition with other sympatric species (whose frequencies did not take part in the regression) must certainly play an important role in the regulation of Drosophila wil-
Findings from smaller latitudes where the mean number of inversions per female is around 9 (Da Cunha et aL, 1950) suggest that such populations
listoni populations. Pavan et al. (1957) have already suggested that when D. willistoni, D.
tropicalis and D. paulistorum are sympatric, the dominant one shows heterotic inversions. In our samples, however, sibling species of D. willistoni were not detected (in function of their own geographic distribution). A similar relationship of dominance between D. willistoni and D. simulans has been observed in the present study, although without any evident change in the frequencies of the heterotic inversions "L D, E. Heterotic inversions in Drosophila willistoni were recorded previously by many authors such
Acknowledgements Thanks are due to directors of Parque do Turvo and Parque de Itapu for allowing us to work in those
REFERENCES
ASHBURNER, M. 1967. Patterns of puffing activity in the salivary
gland chromosomes of Drosophila. I. Autosomal puffing patterns in a laboratory stock of Drosophila melanogaster.
Chromosoma, 27, 47-63.
AYALA, F. J., POWELL, J. R. AND DOBZHANSKY, T. 1971. Poly-
important those between "L A and E (r= _.0.80; P<0.05) from Itapu and "LA and H (r=0.63;
158
LEVITAN, M. 1958. Non-random associations of inversions. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 23, 251-268.
LEVITAN, M. AND SALZANO, F. M. 1959. Studies of linkage in
An interracial hybridization experiment in natural populations of Drosphila willistoni. Heredity, 15, 3545.
DA CUNHA, A. B. 1956a. Adaptation of carriers of different chromosomal types in Drosophila willistoni to a variety of environments. Rev. Bras. BioL, 16, 264-272.
DA CUNHA, A. B. 1956b. Differential viability favoring inversion
Heterosis and elimination of weak homozygotes in natural populations of three related species of Drosophila. Proc. Nati, Acad. Sci. USA, 43, 226-234. SENE, F. M. 1981. Anlise da variabilidade cromossmica de populaces naturais de Drosophila ,nercatorum pararepleta
natural populations of Drosophila willistoni and its association with the choice of feeding and breeding sites. Rev. Bras. Genet., VIII, 271284.
VALENTE, V. L. S. AND ARAUJO, A. M. (submitted). Ecological
in Southern Brazil (Diptera; Drosophilidae). I. Distribution, abundance, food preferences and breeding sites.
VALENTE, V. L. S. AND MORALES, N. B. 1985. New inversions
and qualitative description of inversion heterozygotes in natural populations of Drosophila willistoni inhabiting two different regions in the State of Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil.
Rev. Bras. Genet., VIII, 1, 167173.
VALENTE, V. L. S., SAAVEDRA, C. C. R., ARAUJO, A. M. AND
hybridization and break down of coadapted gene complexes in Drosophila willistoni. Proc. NatL Acad. Sci. USA, 44, 622-629. EHRMANN, L. AND POWELL, J. R. 1982. The Drosophila wil-
MORALES, N. B. 1981. Observations on the attraction of Drosophila species for different baits and chromosomal polymorphism in Drosophila willistoni Drosophila Informalion Service, 56, 147-149. WINGE, H. 1971. NIveis de divergncia evolutiva no grupo criptico
0 0
-U
(I,
z
0 (I) 0
Insolation (hours) Preceding Collection month month 1321
Appendix 1
Meteorologicaldata of regions near Parque de Itapu and Parque do Turvo Temperature (C) Preceding month Temperature (C) Collection month Rainfa ii (mm) Preceding Collection month month Preceding Collection month month
Relative humidity (%)
()
Max.
Med. Mm.
()
907
875
Place
Month Year
Mm. Med.
Parque
198
N N
de
Itapu
235 216
1073
80
183 586 158
259 302 186 210 208 244 124 614 1344 907 243 231
135 191 253
2002 2073
1575 1697 73
2468
1859 2541
C')
2050
1396 1322 1844 1980
293
2l65
146 1239 1082 810 2199 3346
78 70 75 79 82 78
2599 2577
1686 1618 1523 1553
282 278
22.5
186
97 110
195 239
Parque do Turvo
74
166 209 270
133 128
31i
297
221
21i
1875
249
90
321
596 1216
1738
78 78 82 79 69 75 78
2122
1633
316 300
Sept./78 Dec./Jan. 78/79 Mar./Apr. 79 July/79 Oct./79 Mar./Apr. 80 Jan./81 Apr./81 July/81 July/79 Oct./79 Jan./80 Apr./80 July/80 Oct./80 Feb./81 Apr./81 Jan./82 May/82
18i
145
79 74 73 80 74 73 76 75 81 84 71 79 79 80 71 74 71 72 73
61 77
2886
2075
01
Co