Appendices Final Mar 09 Mazars Report-Irish Government Commission To Inquire Into Child Abuse

COMMISSION TO INQUIRE INTO CHILD ABUSE
REVIEW OF FINANCIAL MATTERS

November 2007
APPENDIX I :
ADEQUACY OF FUNDING – TABULATED DATA

November 2007
Data to Support Exhibit 11

This information illustrates the rate of change in the general price level (inflation) over
the period 1939 – 69 and the rate of change in the capitation grant. For comparability
both the capitation grant and the general price level are set at 100 in 1939 to form
two equivalent indices
CPI Annual Percentage Change

(Mid-Feb to Mid-Feb)
Weekly Capitation Weekly Capitation

CPI % CPI Index Index €
Industrial Reformatory Industrial Reformatory
1939 - 100.0 100.0 100.0 0.79 0.79
1939/40 13.2 113.2 100.0 100.0 0.79 0.79
1940/41 10.7 125.3 100.0 100.0 0.79 0.79
1941/42 8.7 136.2 100.0 100.0 0.79 0.79
1942/43 15.2 156.9 120.3 144.3 0.95 1.14
1943/44 8.4 170.1 120.3 144.3 0.95 1.14
1944/45 -0.3 169.6 120.3 144.3 0.95 1.14
1945/46 -0.3 169.1 120.3 144.3 0.95 1.14
1946/47 0.3 169.6 129.1 153.2 1.02 1.21
1947/48 7.1 181.6 153.2 181.0 1.21 1.43
1948/49 0.0 181.6 153.2 181.0 1.21 1.43
1949/50 1.0 183.4 153.2 181.0 1.21 1.43
1950/51 3.0 188.9 173.4 216.5 1.37 1.71
1951/52 10.7 209.2 216.5 240.5 1.71 1.90
1952/53 7.9 225.7 216.5 265.8 1.71 2.10
1953/54 1.0 227.9 216.5 265.8 1.71 2.10
1954/55 1.8 232.1 216.5 265.8 1.71 2.10
1955/56 4.2 241.8 216.5 265.8 1.71 2.10
1956/57 2.1 246.9 216.5 265.8 1.71 2.10
1957/58 7.1 264.4 362.0 386.1 2.86 3.05
1958/59 2.0 269.7 362.0 386.1 2.86 3.05
1959/60 -2.0 264.3 362.0 386.1 2.86 3.05
1960/61 3.0 272.2 362.0 386.1 2.86 3.05
1961/62 3.7 282.3 362.0 386.1 2.86 3.05
1962/63 3.6 292.5 362.0 386.1 2.86 3.05
1963/64 3.3 302.1 401.3 425.3 3.17 3.36
1964/65 7.5 324.8 441.8 465.8 3.49 3.68
1965/66 2.2 331.9 543.0 567.1 4.29 4.48
1966/67 3.9 344.9 543.0 567.1 4.29 4.48
1967/68 4.6 360.7 602.5 626.6 4.76 4.95
1968/69 6.7 384.9 663.3 687.3 5.24 5.43
1969/70 5.9 407.6 1326.6 1374.7 10.48 10.86
November 2007
Tabulated Data to Support Exhibits 13 – 14
Exhibit 4 Exhibit 5
Household Unemployment
Income per Head Benefit
1939 €0.87 €0.95

1940 €0.90 €0.95
1941 €0.92 €0.95
1942 €0.95 €0.95
1943 €1.00 €0.95
1944 €1.08 €0.95
1945 €1.04 €0.95
1946 €1.17 €0.95
1947 €1.39 €1.43
1948 €1.53 €1.43
1949 €1.61 €1.43
1950 €1.65 €1.43
1951 €1.89 €1.43
1952 €2.06 €1.43
1953 €2.27 €1.52
1954 €2.33 €1.52
1955 €2.45 €1.52
1956 €2.57 €1.90
1957 €2.71 €1.90
1958 €3.01 €1.90
1959 €3.11 €1.90
1960 €3.33 €1.90
1961 €3.63 €2.07
1962 €3.96 €2.07
1963 €4.14 €2.39
1964 €4.53 €2.70
1965 €4.71 €2.70
1966 €5.07 €3.34
1967 €5.31 €3.34
1968 €5.84 €3.66
1969 €6.16 €3.66
November 2007
APPENDIX II :
Average Household Expenditure per Child Index 1965/66 Base &

1951/52 Base
November 2007
Supporting Data for Exhibit 15: Average Household Expenditure per Child
Index 1965/66 Base
First Child Second Third Child Average

Child per Child
1939 €1.21 €0.35 €0.30 €0.71
1940 €1.22 €0.35 €0.30 €0.72
1941 €1.40 €0.40 €0.35 €0.83
1942 €1.57 €0.45 €0.39 €0.93
1943 €1.72 €0.50 €0.42 €1.01
1944 €2.03 €0.58 €0.50 €1.20
1945 €2.22 €0.64 €0.55 €1.30
1946 €2.21 €0.64 €0.55 €1.30
1947 €2.21 €0.63 €0.54 €1.30
1948 €2.21 €0.64 €0.55 €1.30
1949 €2.38 €0.68 €0.59 €1.40
1950 €2.38 €0.68 €0.59 €1.40
1951 €2.40 €0.69 €0.59 €1.41
1952 €2.48 €0.71 €0.61 €1.46
1953 €2.78 €0.80 €0.68 €1.63
1954 €3.01 €0.87 €0.74 €1.77
1955 €3.04 €0.87 €0.75 €1.79
1956 €3.10 €0.89 €0.76 €1.82
1957 €3.24 €0.93 €0.80 €1.90
1958 €3.31 €0.95 €0.82 €1.94
1959 €3.56 €1.02 €0.88 €2.09
1960 €3.63 €1.04 €0.90 €2.14
1961 €3.56 €1.02 €0.88 €2.09
1962 €3.67 €1.05 €0.91 €2.16
1963 €3.81 €1.10 €0.94 €2.24
1964 €3.95 €1.14 €0.97 €2.33
1965 €4.09 €1.17 €1.01 €2.41
1966 €4.42 €1.27 €1.09 €2.60
1967 €4.59 €1.32 €1.13 €2.70
1968 €4.80 €1.38 €1.18 €2.83
1969 €5.13 €1.47 €1.26 €3.01
November 2007
Supporting Data for Exhibit 16: Average Household Expenditure per Person
Index 1951/52 Base
Weekly Ind. School Weekly Reformatory Avg. Expenditure per

Capitation School Capitation Person
1939 €0.79 €0.79 €0.97
1940 €0.79 €0.79 €0.97
1941 €0.79 €0.79 €1.12
1942 €0.95 €1.14 €1.26
1943 €0.95 €1.14 €1.38
1944 €0.95 €1.14 €1.62
1945 €0.95 €1.14 €1.77
1946 €1.02 €1.21 €1.77
1947 €1.21 €1.43 €1.76
1948 €1.21 €1.43 €1.77
1949 €1.21 €1.43 €1.90
1950 €1.37 €1.71 €1.90
1951 €1.71 €1.90 €1.92
1952 €1.71 €2.10 €1.98
1953 €1.71 €2.10 €2.14
1954 €1.71 €2.10 €2.16
1955 €1.71 €2.10 €2.20
1956 €1.71 €2.10 €2.29
1957 €2.86 €3.05 €2.34
1958 €2.86 €3.05 €2.50
1959 €2.86 €3.05 €2.55
1960 €2.86 €3.05 €2.50
1961 €2.86 €3.05 €2.58
1962 €2.86 €3.05 €2.67
1963 €3.17 €3.36 €2.77
1964 €3.49 €3.68 €2.86
1965 €4.29 €4.48 €3.07
1966 €4.29 €4.48 €3.14
1967 €4.76 €4.95 €3.26
1968 €5.24 €5.43 €3.41
1969 €10.48 €10.86 €3.64
November 2007
Supporting Data for Exhibit 17: Average Household Expenditure per Child
Index 1965/66 Base by Expenditure Category
Weekly Ind. Weekly Food Clothing Lodging Other Total

Capitation € Reform. Only € Only € Only € Exp € Exp €
Capitation
€
1939 €0.79 €0.79 €0.42 €0.03 €0.50 €0.26 €1.21
1940 €0.79 €0.79 €0.42 €0.03 €0.50 €0.26 €1.22
1941 €0.79 €0.79 €0.48 €0.03 €0.58 €0.30 €1.40
1942 €0.95 €1.14 €0.54 €0.04 €0.65 €0.34 €1.57
1943 €0.95 €1.14 €0.59 €0.04 €0.71 €0.37 €1.72
1944 €0.95 €1.14 €0.70 €0.05 €0.84 €0.44 €2.03
1945 €0.95 €1.14 €0.76 €0.06 €0.92 €0.48 €2.21
1946 €1.02 €1.21 €0.76 €0.06 €0.92 €0.48 €2.21
1947 €1.21 €1.43 €0.76 €0.05 €0.91 €0.47 €2.20
1948 €1.21 €1.43 €0.76 €0.06 €0.92 €0.48 €2.21
1949 €1.21 €1.43 €0.82 €0.06 €0.99 €0.51 €2.38
1950 €1.37 €1.71 €0.82 €0.06 €0.99 €0.51 €2.38
1951 €1.71 €1.90 €0.83 €0.06 €1.00 €0.52 €2.40
1952 €1.71 €2.10 €0.85 €0.06 €1.03 €0.53 €2.47
1953 €1.71 €2.10 €0.95 €0.07 €1.15 €0.60 €2.77
1954 €1.71 €2.10 €1.04 €0.08 €1.25 €0.65 €3.01
1955 €1.71 €2.10 €1.05 €0.08 €1.26 €0.65 €3.04
1956 €1.71 €2.10 €1.07 €0.08 €1.28 €0.67 €3.09
1957 €2.86 €3.05 €1.11 €0.08 €1.34 €0.70 €3.23
1958 €2.86 €3.05 €1.14 €0.08 €1.37 €0.71 €3.30
1959 €2.86 €3.05 €1.22 €0.09 €1.47 €0.76 €3.55
1960 €2.86 €3.05 €1.25 €0.09 €1.50 €0.78 €3.62
1961 €2.86 €3.05 €1.22 €0.09 €1.47 €0.77 €3.55
1962 €2.86 €3.05 €1.26 €0.09 €1.52 €0.79 €3.66
1963 €3.17 €3.36 €1.31 €0.09 €1.58 €0.82 €3.80
1964 €3.49 €3.68 €1.36 €0.10 €1.64 €0.85 €3.94
1965 €4.29 €4.48 €1.41 €0.10 €1.69 €0.88 €4.08
1966 €4.29 €4.48 €1.52 €0.11 €1.83 €0.95 €4.41
1967 €4.76 €4.95 €1.58 €0.11 €1.90 €0.99 €4.58
1968 €5.24 €5.43 €1.65 €0.12 €1.99 €1.03 €4.79
1969 €10.48 €10.86 €1.76 €0.13 €2.12 €1.10 €5.11
November 2007
Supporting Data for Exhibit 18: Average Household Expenditure per Person
Index 1951/52 Base by Expenditure Category
Weekly Weekly Food Clothing Lodging Other € Total €

Ind. Reform. Only € Only € Only €
Capitation Capitation
€ €
1939 €0.79 €0.79 €0.46 €0.14 €0.12 €0.27 €0.99
1940 €0.79 €0.79 €0.46 €0.14 €0.12 €0.27 €1.00
1941 €0.79 €0.79 €0.53 €0.16 €0.14 €0.31 €1.15
1942 €0.95 €1.14 €0.60 €0.18 €0.16 €0.35 €1.29
1943 €0.95 €1.14 €0.65 €0.20 €0.17 €0.38 €1.41
1944 €0.95 €1.14 €0.77 €0.24 €0.20 €0.45 €1.66
1945 €0.95 €1.14 €0.84 €0.26 €0.22 €0.49 €1.82
1946 €1.02 €1.21 €0.84 €0.26 €0.22 €0.49 €1.81
1947 €1.21 €1.43 €0.84 €0.26 €0.22 €0.49 €1.81
1948 €1.21 €1.43 €0.84 €0.26 €0.22 €0.49 €1.81
1949 €1.21 €1.43 €0.90 €0.28 €0.24 €0.53 €1.95
1950 €1.37 €1.71 €0.90 €0.28 €0.24 €0.53 €1.95
1951 €1.71 €1.90 €0.91 €0.28 €0.24 €0.53 €1.97
1952 €1.71 €2.10 €0.94 €0.29 €0.25 €0.55 €2.03
1953 €1.71 €2.10 €1.01 €0.31 €0.27 €0.59 €2.19
1954 €1.71 €2.10 €1.02 €0.32 €0.27 €0.60 €2.21
1955 €1.71 €2.10 €1.04 €0.32 €0.28 €0.61 €2.25
1956 €1.71 €2.10 €1.09 €0.34 €0.29 €0.64 €2.35
1957 €2.86 €3.05 €1.11 €0.34 €0.30 €0.65 €2.40
1958 €2.86 €3.05 €1.19 €0.37 €0.32 €0.70 €2.57
1959 €2.86 €3.05 €1.21 €0.37 €0.32 €0.71 €2.62
1960 €2.86 €3.05 €1.19 €0.37 €0.32 €0.69 €2.57
1961 €2.86 €3.05 €1.22 €0.38 €0.33 €0.72 €2.64
1962 €2.86 €3.05 €1.27 €0.39 €0.34 €0.74 €2.74
1963 €3.17 €3.36 €1.31 €0.41 €0.35 €0.77 €2.84
November 2007
November 2007
November 2007
November 2007
November 2007
November 2007
November 2007
November 2007
November 2007
November 2007
November 2007
November 2007
APPENDIX III :
UK Capitation Grant Data

November 2007
Supporting Data for Exhibit 19: Capitation Rates in Scotland and England and Wales
Taken from the Children and Young Persons Act 1933 and related SIs.
Scotland - Capitation England & Wales - Capitation

1939 €1.08 €1.90
1940 €1.08 €1.90
1941 €1.08 €1.90
1942 €1.08 €1.90
1943 €1.08 €1.90
1944 €1.08 €1.90
1945 €1.08 €1.90
1946 €1.08 €1.90
1947 €1.59 €2.22
1948 €2.54 €3.34
1949 €2.86 €3.56
1950 €2.86 €3.56
1951 €3.11 €4.00
1952 €3.11 €4.32
1953 €3.11 €4.32
1954 €4.19 €4.51
1955 €4.61 €5.12
1956 €4.61 €5.12
1957 €5.24 €6.45
1958 €5.33 €6.45
1959 €5.33 €5.78
1960 €5.33 €6.45
1961 €6.67 €7.44
1962 €7.55 €8.23
1963 €8.67 €8.77
1964 €9.12 €10.55
1965 €10.01 €11.88
1966 €10.89 €13.00
1967 €12.00 €14.34
1968 €12.44 €16.23
1969 €13.12 €17.78
November 2007
Scotland - Capitation
£ S D
1939 17 0
1940 17 0
1941 17 0
1942 17 0
1943 17 0
1944 17 0
1945 17 0
1946 17 0
1947 25 0
1948 40 0
1949 45 0
1950 45 0
1951 49 0
1952 49 0
1953 49 0
1954 66 0
1955 72 6
1956 72 6
1957 82 6
1958 84 0
1959 84 0
1960 84 0
1961 105 0
1962 119 0
1963 6 16 6
1964 7 3 6
1965 7 17 6
1966 8 11 6
1967 9 9 0
1968 9 16 0
1969 10 6 6
November 2007
England & Wales - Capitation

£ S D
1939 30 0
1940 30 0
1941 30 0
1942 30 0
1943 30 0
1944 30 0
1945 30 0
1946 30 0
1947 35 0
1948 52 6
1949 56 0
1950 56 0
1951 63 0
1952 68 0
1953 68 0
1954 71 0
1955 80 6
1956 80 6
1957 5 1 6
1958 5 1 6
1959 4 11 0
1960 5 1 6
1961 5 17 3
1962 6 9 6
1963 6 18 3
1964 8 6 3
1965 9 7 3
1966 10 4 9
1967 11 5 9
1968 12 15 6
1969 14 0 0
November 2007
APPENDIX IV :
Artane Industrial School
Income and Expenditure 1940 – 1969

November 2007
1940 1941 1942 1943 1944 1945 1946 1947 1948 1949 Total
Income € € € € € € € € € € €
Ministry of Education 19,685 19,863 19,863 19,863 15,350 20,335 20,336 18,227 23,814 25,760 203,095
County & Borough Councils 13,805 13,918 13,477 20,662 20,617 20,570 20,365 20,389 24,046 25,623 193,473
Capitation grants - primary
school - - - - - - - 5,081 7,697 5,029 17,808
Other 7,825 7,156 7,058 6,242 6,302 8,361 9,976 7,500 8,011 10,210 78,642
Total Income 41,315 40,936 40,398 46,767 42,268 49,266 50,678 51,198 63,568 66,623 493,018
Expenditure
Industrial Departments 13,784 7,870 6,403 8,514 5,436 8,098 9,357 8,911 11,989 10,406 90,767
Farm, Poultry and Garden 265 3,485 4,259 8,808 3,887 4,706 6,535 7,489 9,364 10,181 58,979
Salaries, Wages, insurance
stamps 15,008 14,828 14,834 14,737 12,398 13,466 13,805 14,618 14,315 14,509 142,518
Provisions Purchased 5,325 3,983 4,789 5,409 4,980 6,929 8,227 8,296 8,128 9,246 65,313
Clothing 1,747 1,115 2,305 1,185 847 1,826 1,814 729 1,341 865 13,773
Medical Expenses 152 173 149 160 88 143 254 187 163 241 1,709
Laundry and Cleansing 945 212 500 331 293 306 444 596 848 786 5,262
Ordinary Repairs and
decorations 493 527 1,015 1,081 1,580 1,211 1,922 724 820 1,731 11,103
Furniture, Library 279 517 585 946 277 359 260 447 1,006 1,070 5,747
Fuel, light, power 2,677 2,848 2,953 4,445 2,757 4,925 4,449 7,372 5,222 4,469 42,118
Rent, rates, taxes 1,674 1,726 1,788 1,337 938 1,023 909 1,077 1,121 1,379 12,972
Insurance 423 469 590 423 479 474 481 514 526 795 5,173
Stationery, telegraph,
telephone, postage 137 136 225 136 131 131 168 166 126 136 1,491
Classrooms 207 221 244 381 201 183 284 138 292 98 2,249
Band expenses 121 79 110 99 107 154 316 180 256 391 1,813
Sweet Shop & Store 528 852 881 188 373 378 306 197 185 260 4,150
Games, Awards,
Entertainment 110 89 223 245 309 348 290 215 258 236 2,322
Boys' travelling expenses 90 109 102 103 94 102 105 133 119 175 1,133
Bank Charges and Interest - - - - 25 20 27 23 20 720 835
Capital Expenditure - - - - - - - - - - -
Sundries 17 1 60 249 251 256 166 258 364 175 1,798

Transfer to Community
Account - - - - 4,845 4,845 3,596 7,720 7,720 7,479 36,205
Total Expenditure 43,982 39,239 42,016 48,776 40,294 49,884 53,716 59,990 64,184 65,348 507,429
Grant Surplus/Deficit <2,668> 1,698 <1,618> <2,009> 1,974 <618> <3,038> <8,792> <616> 1,275 <14,412>
November 2007
Artane Industrial School Income and Expenditure 1950 - 1959
1950 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 Total
Income € € € € € € € € € € €
Ministry of Education 24,553 28,460 35,332 35,909 34,914 26,132 30,432 26,353 28,488 33,271 303,844
County & Borough
Councils 24,496 27,244 33,905 34,221 38,490 46,185 33,375 30,236 32,946 40,761 341,859
Capitation grants -
primary school 5,492 5,987 6,143 6,868 6,660 6,854 6,736 5,261 4,989 4,988 59,978
Other 9,911 8,684 12,535 15,012 21,930 22,320 21,213 19,473 16,097 18,722 165,897
Total Income 64,452 70,375 87,915 92,010 101,994 101,491 91,756 81,323 82,520 97,742 871,578
Expenditure
Industrial Departments 14,465 19,765 12,556 16,102 20,689 26,645 19,954 15,623 19,026 13,707 178,532
Farm, Poultry and
Garden 11,246 10,226 9,341 14,446 13,557 10,951 6,450 6,462 11,023 5,933 99,635
Salaries, Wages,
insurance stamps 14,508 15,275 15,672 16,500 16,985 17,248 16,736 17,040 17,272 17,833 165,069
Provisions Purchased 8,185 8,208 12,796 16,005 15,302 16,604 16,423 13,539 12,931 12,904 132,897
Clothing 570 1,891 1,177 1,440 2,526 1,774 984 857 1,129 1,901 14,249
Medical Expenses 273 204 135 272 241 203 149 188 136 171 1972
Laundry and Cleansing 596 978 330 116 250 573 1,050 750 951 1,050 6,644
Ordinary Repairs and
decorations 5,380 1,708 1,006 673 1,611 1,602 799 1,418 1,957 1,435 17,589
Furniture, Library 550 349 300 965 1,337 397 190 310 1,365 331 6,094
Fuel, light, power 4,772 7,839 5,144 4,692 6,176 5,603 6,591 7,952 5,225 5,607 59,601
Rent, rates, taxes 1,360 1,181 1,186 1,300 1,117 1,180 1,286 1,241 1,498 1,362 12,711
Insurance 869 524 632 512 523 538 655 642 684 665 6244
Stationery, telegraph,
telephone, postage 119 173 146 236 338 206 179 223 225 216 2061
Classrooms 330 452 495 423 441 329 348 305 197 290 3610
Band expenses 152 476 218 574 1,512 509 627 504 1,934 1,194 7,700
Sweet Shop & Store 410 444 651 960 908 1,015 552 502 502 538 6,482
Games, Awards,
Entertainment 213 316 253 574 199 394 272 260 317 537 3335
Boys' travelling expenses 97 118 56 57 22 37 10 18 52 60 527

Bank Charges and
Interest 1,050 1,220 606 691 434 942 278 302 79 18 5,620
Capital Expenditure - - - 5,988 - - - - - 2,400 2,400
Sundries 210 1,614 288 288 1,610 1,860 2,692 895 573 842 10,872
Transfer to Community
Account 7,720 7,961 7,720 7,961 10,317 9,840 9,523 8,888 12,697 9,904 92,531
Total Expenditure 73,073 80,923 70,709 90,774 96,095 98,452 85,749 77,920 89,772 78,899 842,366
Grant Surplus/Deficit <8,622> <10,548> 17,206 1,237 5,899 3,040 6,007 3,403 <7,251> 18,843 29,212
November 2007
Artane Industrial School Income and Expenditure 1960 – 1969
1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 Total
Income € € € € € € € € € € €
Ministry of
Education
31,718 29,540 27,617 25,900 29,132 32,333 35,442 35,290 32,738 19,623 299,333
County & Borough
Councils
40,875 36,127 27,210 42,487 30,184 28,544 43,650 44,831 41,371 28,612 363,891
Capitation grants –
primary school 5,833 5,639 7,008 7,204 9,090 10,991 10,507 12,559 11,736 4,595 85,162
Other
18,488 20,515 19,640 17,792 18,875 20,655 12,349 20,356 15,234 17,291 181,195
Total Income
96,914 91,821 81,475 93,383 87,281 92,522 101,949 113,036 101,079 70,121 929,581
Expenditure
Industrial
Departments
16,095 14,392 12,390 12,822 7,466 9,933 7,127 3,446 3,064 2,320 89,055
Farm , Poultry &
Garden
5,481 10,060 7,987 7,396 6,286 7,780 8,035 11,260 6,655 1,926 72,866
Salaries, Wages,
insurance stamps 17,666 17,101 17,110 16,994 18,054 17,009 16,602 19,936 17,016 9,755 167,243
Provisions
Purchased
13,994 15,698 14,671 15,895 19,059 20,077 19,732 16,988 25,625 9,255 170,994
Clothing
2,100 1,977 3,223 2,110 2,434 3,348 9,101 13,758 7,254 312 45,617
Medical Expenses
136 174 131 150 118 75 211 131 283 88 1497
Laundry and
Cleansing
866 1,073 1,630 1,559 1,202 1,448 908 1,204 1,359 551 11,800
Ordinary Repairs
and decorations 4,341 2,867 6,143 4,727 5,617 3,435 1,427 1,789 1,439 2,974 34,759
Furniture, Library
762 265 813 3,676 2,269 489 519 480 729 36 10,038
Fuel, light, power
5,443 6,269 6,186 6,991 5,381 5,620 5,842 7,326 9,569 4,297 62,924
Rent, rates, taxes
1,475 1,527 1,449 1,228 2,632 1,460 1,516 1,554 1,727 217 14,785
Insurance
423 1,049 750 822 937 928 - 1,644 1,647 753 4,044
Stationery,
telegraph,
telephone, postage 222 244 274 270 305 380 409 711 692 333 3840
Classrooms
173 279 380 536 272 340 648 399 573 41 3641
Band Expenses
1,431 2,034 2,619 1,403 1,754 1,432 805 1,246 1,144 8,114 21,982
Sweet shop & Store
622 764 843 761 709 764 401 220 265 95 5444
Games, Awards,
Entertainment
970 750 554 782 569 828 665 753 648 226 6745
Boys' travelling
expenses
61 112 72 46 55 118 123 127 364 107 1185
Bank Charges and
Interest
11 25 24 24 23 28 13 25 18 15 206
Sundries
804 843 571 4,527 2,486 1,248 354 1,012 622 978 13,445
Capital Expenditure
24,474 8,961 13,088 22,412 40,818 13,826 17,063 3,018 564 1,778 146,002
Capital
Expenditure-
Swimming Pool - - - - - 5,079 27,555 2,348 1,114 36,096
- - - - - - - - -
November 2007
1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 Total
Income € € € € € € € € € € €
Transfer to
Community
Account 9,523 9,523 9,523 9,904 10,285 9,523 9,904 9,523 8,380 - 86,088
Total Expenditure
107,073 95,988 100,431 115,034 128,731 100,090 106,484 124,104 91,982 45,283 1,015,200
Grant
Surplus/Deficit <10,159> <4,167> <18,956> <21,652> <41,451> <7,568> <4,536> <11,068> 9,096 24,839 85,619
November 2007
APPENDIX V :
Brothers Employed in Artane Industrial School 1939 - 1969

November 2007
Total no. of Teaching

Date of Brothers Teaching Brothers Brothers - Brothers engaged in
teaching at the farm, Kitchens,
Visitation (Taken from in the Primary trade school office, aftercare,
(evening
Report visitation reports) School- taken classes) stores, infirmary
from visitation or and aged brothers
school returns (SR)
27.10 - 32 17 (SR) 1 (SR) 14

03.11.1939
16-20 11 1940 31 14 (SR) 1 (SR) 16
06-11.10.1941 31 17 (SR) 2 (SR) 12
02-04.11.1942 32 17 (SR) 2 (SR) 13
15-20.11.1943 35 16 (SR) 3 (SR) 16
30.10.1944 33 16 3 14
2-7.11.1945 34 17 4 13
15-26.10.1946 33 14 (SR) 3 (SR) 16
14-18.10.1947 36 16 (SR) 3 (SR) 17
19.11.1949 32 15 (SR) 4 (SR) 13
17-22.11.1950 34 15 (SR) 4 (SR) 15
08-13.12.1951 35 15 3 17
07-12.11.1952 34 15 5 14
12-18.03.1954 35 16 4 15
12-18.03.1955 36 14 5 17
27.01.1956 26 15 5 6
23-29.03.1957 30 12 4 14
18-25.11.1957 31 11 4 16
30.10-03.11.1958 27 12 3 12
29.11-05.12.1959 27 11 2 14
2-5.11.1960 25 10 2 13
18-25.01.1962 28 11 2 15
27.02-04.03.1963 27 11 0 16
29.10.1963 29 11 1 17
10-16.02.1965 28 11 2 15
05.11.1965 26 11 0 15
5-10.12.1966 26 12 0 14
12-23.05.1968 25 12 0 13
29.05.1969 20 9 0 11
November 2007
APPENDIX VI :
Number of Lay Staff Employed in Artane Industrial School 1939 –

1969
November 2007
Number of lay staff in Artane Industrial School at end of September each year 1939 -1969
as recorded in the Wages Book
(3 additional personnel may be added each year – the Doctor, Nurse

and Chaplain were recorded in the Cheque Payments Book rather than Wages Books)
PER RECORDS PROVIDED BY THE

CONGREGATION OF CHRISTIAN BROTHERS
YEAR Number of STAFF
September 1939 59
September 1940 56
September 1941 57
September 1942 55
September 1943 54
September 1944 54
September 1945 58
September 1946 57
September 1947 51
September 1948 51
September 1949 48
September 1950 47
September 1951 48
September 1952 49
September 1953 45
September 1954 44
September 1955 44
September 1956 42
September 1957 42
September 1958 41
September 1959 40
September 1960 39
September 1961 35
September 1962 40
September 1963 36
September 1964 36
September 1965 30
September 1966 31
September 1967 28
September 1968 24
September 1969 12
November 2007
APPENDIX VII :
Number of Brothers employed as Teachers in Artane

November 2007
YEAR No of No of Brother
Teachers (both primary
Students and trade)
1939 772 18
1940 800 15
1941 800 19
1942 800 19
1943 800 19
1944 812 19
1945 818 21
1946 794 17
1947 789 19
1948 819 19
1949 794 19
1950 762 19
1951 738 18
1952 728 20
1953 694 20
1954 737 20
1955 653 19
1956 560 20
1957 481 16
1958 422 15
1959 428 13
1960 392 12
1961 371 12
1962 353 13
1963 317 11
1964 306 11
1965 301 12
1966 327 12
1967 272 12
1968 198 12
1969 24 9
November 2007
APPENDIX VIII : ROSMINIAN FATHERS – UPTON
Income and expenditure 1952-1953

November 2007
1952 1953
Income € €
Treasury 5,764 5,872
County councils 5,929 6,193
Borough councils 6,876
Other 10,533 6,461
Total Income 22,226 25,402
Expenditure -
Medical 231 658

Wages & Social security 3,700 4,258
Provisions 3,268 3,333
Bread 1,390 1,617
Meat and fish 1,874 1,881
Clothing 1,595 1,720
Shoe shop 797
Footwear 298
Rates, rent and insurance 721 474
Fuel light water 1,350 1,171
Land commission 174
Revenue commission 24
Stamps and stationery 260 130
Farm and garden 2,924 4,093
Car and travel 279 580
Bank interest 196
Church 119 194
Boy's games 485 395
Masses given to Province 1,112 1,359
Sundries 64 65
Telephone 72 76
Community 570
Charity 14 20
Fr. Arthur’s 40
Books and papers 17
Province exchange of cheques 1,112
Special(films,entertainment,gifts) 59
Capital expenditure 1,301 1,507
Total expenditure 22,243 25,335
Surplus/ Deficit <17> 67

November 2007
APPENDIX IX : ROSMINIAN FATHERS – UPTON

November 2007
1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966

Income € € € € € € €
Government grants 14,423.46 14,253.53 13,863.64 27,104.03 27,524.11 25,972.49 21,572.85
Health Authorities 2,347.20 1,796.17 526.94
Board of assistance 3,654.65
Co and Borough Council 14,215.82 13,686.04 13,969.28
Primary schools 3,787.41 3,345.76 10,013.15 133.32
Other 10,667.27 14,585.96 15,349.49 17,360.53 13,915.06 11,979.98 14,344.22
Total Income 42,961.20 44,872.73 44,978.57 48,251.98 44,784.93 47,965.63 36,577.33
Expenditure -
School wages ( and nat insurance) 2,316.51 3,505.35 3,211.80 3,443.01 3,286.08 2,496.31 1,433.53
Bread 2,449.30 2,471.06 2,721.30 6,195.57 4,907.54 4,665.02 3,009.28
Meat and fish 2,081.56 2,344.57 2,480.94 2,787.66 3,132.44 3,076.58 2,578.84
Provisions 4,202.20 3,463.31 3,503.59
Minerals wines whiskey 264.47 231.77 183.90 249.08 232.36 190.46 227.28
Laundry 43.64
Furniture and books 250.87
Sundries 84.82
Cigarettes 440.29 496.43 629.29 643.26 595.51 537.10 519.32
Community(inc.retreat) 378.48 468.93 374.89
Medical 501.69 777.73 521.53 657.65 636.14 467.26 641.22
Shoe shop 558.00 770.38 453.41
Clothing and community footwear 3,208.07 1,437.43 2,087.51 2,101.75 1,880.48 1,778.90 864.69
Rent rates and insurance 672.92 450.82 407.29
Fuel light and heat 1,046.30 1,217.89 1,679.04 2,796.06 2,886.11 2,219.50 2,070.94
Book stationery and postage 243.76 235.04 278.10 157.45 113.01 102.85
Car and travel 638.67 1,392.55 806.33 340.24 646.30 1,184.67 458.38
Holidays 575.19 420.28 590.43
Recreation 616.42 745.34 591.70 479.96
Personal sundries 203.01
Church and mass payments 790.86 576.84 115.55 132.05 157.45
Expenditure (continues) 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966
November 2007
€ € € € € € €
Church requisites 168.15 123.63
Boy's expenses (travel and games) 434.71 398.08 582.77 161.42
Holy souls box 33.84
Mission box 18.41 10.07
Rosminians missions 19.05
Juniors 332.86 193.48 52.86
Bank fees 9.05 10.62 11.94 63.49 33.01 15.24
Telephone 52.77 66.51 83.47 164.27 135.86 121.89 151.10
Insurances and Licenses 411.93 453.30 434.25 506.63
Mass stipends 1,147.84 1,560.51 1,316.72 1,994.76
Prov contribution 1,877.90 3,249.26 2,307.11 827.87
Alms 9.37 5.08 10.16 6.35
Province and scholastics 274.73 492.38
Province (inc loan £1,500 )+£1500 3,364.81
Scholastics:medical
meals,holidays,books 219.66
University fees 402.51
Diocesan collection 44.61 22.02 43.62 71.11
Subscriptions Gratuities 66.03 195.54 45.81
Hall 222.20 118.26 148.56 40.63
Masses 724.70
Exchange cheques and guarantee
payments 3,848.39
Miscellaneous 6.37 5.57 3.52
Charity 9.59 9.97 6.29
Bal of undisbursed petty cash 41.67 29.00
Farm and garden 9,550.33 7,701.91 11,898.75 7,092.34 6,565.82 6,075.70 6,697.87
Shop supplies 675.96
Diocesan payments 36.84
Workman's compensation 279.34 298.39 299.66
Nat school supplies 205.42
Expenditure (continues) 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966
November 2007
€ € € € € € €
Investment 2,524.24
Farm capital account 9,091.32
Hall: new projects 292.04
Capital expenditure 1,600.01 6,614.09 13,049.58 10,676.34 10,013.15 12,585.64 2,119.19
35,649.64 39,684.77 46,567.08 43,449.51 42,270.85 43,651.06 34,884.78
Surplus/ Deficit 7,311.56 5,187.96 -1,588.51 4,802.47 2,514.08 4,314.57 1,692.55
November 2007
APPENDIX X : Rosminian Fathers – Ferryhouse

November 2007
1941 1947 Total

€ €
Income:
Treasury grants 4,069 4,069
Ministry of education 0
Government grants 3,948 3,948
Co and Borough council 2,594 4,171 6,765
Other 3,114 1,911
9,655 10,150 19,806
Expenditure:
Salaries and wages 2,921 2,022 4,943
Groceries 1,774 1,774
Bread 1,547 1,547
Meat 842 842
Potatoes 882 882
Vegetables 377 377
Milk 813 813
Clothing bedding 1,250 1,250
Footwear 511 511
Hardwear polish 306 306
Fuel light and heat 1,292 1,292
Laundry 188 188
Provisions 3,282 3,282
Boys clothing 142 142
Travelling 252 182 435
Medical 301 301
Interest 115 115
School books 19 19
Printing, stationery, books and newspapers 19 60 78
Postage, telegrams and telephone 34 60 94
Church expenses 63 44 107
Shop 9 9
Gratuities 19 19
Games, recreation outings 61 61
Furniture and household expenses 181 181
Washing fuel and light, turf and wood 337 337
Soap soda 57 57
Electric and engine exp 118 118
Industrial dept. tailor and housing 669 669
Bootmaker 130 130
Wine and spirits 130 130
Insurance 214 92 306
Rent rates 56 57 113
Home disposals 10 10
Sundry school expenses 26 26
Special bal on motor car 146 146
Special bal on a/c engine 104 104
Clothing (bedding) and mending 79 79
1941 1947 Total
November 2007
Expenditure cont’d € € €
Medical and dentist 108 108
Tobacco 96 96
Personal sundries 6 6
1/3 wine and spirits 65 65
Interest on bank overdraft 123 123
Interest on provincial loans 109 109
Building and repairs 791 791
Doctors salary 63 63
Nurses salary 91 91
Running cost and maintenance 89 89
Charitable contributions 20 20
Sports equipment and boys entertainment 73 73
Medicines and hospital 199 199
Capital expenditure 409 791
10,177 13,862 24,039
Surplus/Deficit -522 -3,711
November 2007
APPENDIX XI : Rosminian Fathers – Ferryhouse

November 2007
1951 1952 1953 1954 Total

Income: € € € €
Ministry of education 6794.76 8645.37 9817.79 9862.21 35120.13
Co and Borough council 6400.28 7920.78 10008.56 9688.74 34018.35
Other 2202.41 4439.69 6842.97 7559.77 21044.84
15,397.45 21,005.84 26,669.32 27,110.71 90,183.32
Expenditure:
Salaries and wages 2502.72 1413.76 1596.97 2682.35 8195.80
Farm wages 722.99 990.40 1713.38
Provisions 5931.85 3075.14 3898.39 12905.38
Travelling 106.66 145.80 358.98 312.44 923.89
Medical 343.53 178.91 231.90 141.33 895.67
Printing, stationery, books and newspapers 108.92 44.62 151.02 140.55 445.11
Postage, telegrams and telephone 53.33 57.46 139.71 77.57 328.06
Church expenses 125.98 121.54 164.66 375.92 788.10
Games, recreation outings 275.30 181.28 121.49 314.32 892.40
Furniture and household expenses 0.00
Fuel, light and power 1481.92 1157.67 318.98 2278.01 5236.59
Rent rates insurance 212.19 209.13 157.24 551.36 1129.91
Clothing (bedding) and mending 2161.64 1347.57 1881.80 1285.60 6676.61
Interest and bank charges 172.38 92.22 5.71 1702.16 1972.47
Footwear and shoe shop 723.75 175.77 434.28 1020.50 2354.30
Pension 66.03 66.03 66.03 198.08
Meat 802.26 1078.95 770.27 2651.48
Bread 1722.56 2590.65 2703.74 7016.95
Installation of ESB 815.46 385.35 1200.82
Tobacco 166.93 260.55 204.66 632.14
Farm and garden 2099.02 3398.10 3718.24 9215.35
Soap and polish 100.80 68.54 169.34
Donations 20.32 20.32
In exchange for cash 40.63 1654.57 1695.20
Buses to camps for boys 53.33 53.33
Masses 991.98 1317.34 1358.02 3667.35
Petty cash 316.16 274.26 590.43
S. Books 97.40 97.40
Whiskey and wines 91.12 280.27 371.39
Solicitor 233.63 233.63
Loan to Kilmurry house 253.95 253.95
Bakery 719.94 719.94
Architect 288.23 288.23
Fr. Provincial and Fr Egan 76.18 76.18
Gift to Omeath 12.70 12.70
Capital Expenditure 3298.47 917.39 3740.58 3973.28 11929.72
17,498.64 14,059.00 23,113.08 30,880.89 85,551.79
Surplus/Deficit -2,101.19 6,946.84 3,556.24 -3,770.18 4,631.71
November 2007
APPENDIX XII : Rosminian Fathers – Ferryhouse
Income and Expenditure 1960-1969

November 2007
1960 1961 1962 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969

€ € € € € € € € € Total
Dept of agriculture 241.25 241.25
Dept. of Education 15142.86 13528.91 12221.86 40,893.63
Local Authorities Grants 15420.37 13757.36 9389.19 25171.11 27,997.72 29,953.12 43,601.54 38,245.78 40,725.58 244,261.77
Other 10535.99 11341.26 11710.63 5906.14 9583.98 4154.58 16184.08 32757.97 16902.75 119077.40
Total 41099.22 38627.53 33321.69 31077.25 37581.71 34348.95 59785.62 71003.75 57628.33 404,474.05
Expenditure -
Groceries 3551.93 3541.77 3817.00 6,516.71 6,318.22 6,743.58 6,530.26 6,209.02 5,518.28 48,746.77
Meat 1910.70 2033.82 1789.10 2,276.01 2,822.63 2,817.55 3,548.92 4,070.78 3,052.45 24,321.95
Bread and bakery equipment 2480.65 2508.66 2481.91 7,471.22
Beers, wines and spirits 40.54 224.74 124.43 223.47 180.30 59.68 853.18
Farm (wages not included) 6011.16 4635.51 3476.71 4891.83 4,866.91 4,055.54 6,150.61 7,775.88 7,105.45 48,969.59
Garden 46.56 58.28 37.94 142.78
Poultry 371.73 253.03 173.74 1,992.22 2,790.72
House 3561.27 3,561.27
Shoe shop 931.68 1089.16 1217.74 1163.40 4,401.98
Tailoring shop 2525.79 2684.51 2574.56 2105.61 2,326.16 2,735.02 1,814.46 2,776.92 3,269.58 22,812.58
Laundry 575.53 330.13 378.38 285.69 76.18 53.33 1,699.25
Heat, light and power 281.79 284.28 833.38 1153.09 2,915.32 3,554.00 2,549.63 4,498.68 4,234.58 20,304.75
Lorry and fuel 1832.07 1895.48 2042.63 5,770.17
Rates, insurance,licences 665.14 678.10 724.51 972.25 709.78 712.32 665.34 919.29 1,031.03 7,077.77
Postage, freight and office supplies 253.19 262.37 226.00 186.33 212.05 203.16 224.74 206.97 260.30 2,035.10
November 2007
1960 1961 1962 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969

€ € € € € € € € € Total
Medical supplies 423.84 454.31 551.09 426.44 446.95 540.91 514.24 731.37 359.34 4,448.49
School supplies 253.19 275.19 411.81 128.41 1,068.60
Games, Films, Entertainment 209.95 225.61 142.85 118.48 309.82 572.65 306.01 264.11 129.51 2,278.98
Boys 222.20 234.90 457.11
Books and stationery 105.79 201.89 292.04 196.81 372.03 318.70 1,487.27
Tobacco 372.71 349.81 361.41 367.20 311.09 255.22 355.53 407.59 633.60 3,414.14
Wines and spirits 31.27 42.54 67.96 141.77
Car, travel, holidays 942.69 942.07 943.25 1,598.07 1,791.60 1,118.64 1,009.44 2,177.60 1,603.68 12,127.04
Telephone and telegrams 70.89 71.64 74.66 217.19
Alms 25.39 21.59 46.98
Prov Procurator 1585.32 1922.43 3,507.75
Fr Hickey 146.72 146.72
Fr Murray 74.60 74.60
Fr M.Reen 15.87 15.87
Fr G.Cassidy 3.83 3.83
Church and Grotto 129.58 172.05 164.63 158.56 185.38 109.20 95.23 200.62 179.03 1,394.29
Wages and soc welfare ins 2353.51 1948.45 2589.96 2279.07 2,547.09 2,568.68 3,528.60 4,519.00 5,482.73 27,817.09
Christmas fund 304.79 244.46 301.41 271.72 295.85 148.56 21.59 66.03 1,654.41
Glencomeragh 358.10 253.95 612.05
Omeath Burse 190.46 190.46 190.46 571.38
Investment in overdraft(a.c no 3) 442.67 193.64 636.30
Br. O'D's Pension to Prov Proc. 43.02 43.02
Loan 5.65 102.85 120.63 229.12
Loan repaid 2,539.48 2,539.48
Charity 62.48 62.48
Holy Fathers Jubilee Fund 12.70 12.70
Interest on overdraft 667.87 96.50 764.37
November 2007
1960 1961 1962 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969

€ € € € € € € € € Total
Reduction of overdraft 3809.21 2539.48 6348.69 1,269.74 1,269.74 2,539.48 17,776.33
Provincial contributions 2082.37 1,498.29 2,453.13 2,201.73 2,158.55 10,394.08
M McAssey fund 15.24 15.24
Carpentry 361.65 361.65
Knitting 206.66 206.66
Central heating 634.87 634.87
Laundry machine 1,128.80 1,128.80
Mission funds 78.72 78.72
Sundries 317.43 104.12 91.42 512.97
Provincial levy 1,973.17 1,973.17
Personal 19.05 82.53 101.58
Band 48.25 81.26 129.51
Transfer to No 2 account 3,809.21 3,809.21
Boys in training 133.32 133.32
Woodstown 1,230.38 1,230.38
Electrical wiring 761.84 761.84
Biafra fund 190.46 190.46
Capital expenditure 263.85 3820.30 2528.66 3235.01 4,778.02 4,018.72 18,526.75 30,678.14 3,951.42
36755.76 33820.38 34265.69 30949.01 36600.20 34955.89 53854.67 74588.22 42181.97 377,971.78
Surplus/Deficit 4343.47 4807.15 -944.00 128.23 981.51 -606.93 5930.95 -3584.47 15446.36 26502.27
November 2007
Appendix XIII :
Submissions from Rosminian Fathers

~ ~ o a q~aram~(uo~ssyomno;)
o J
a g 4 pa%w q ap)) smiqq 01(M@ ~ r m m ~sagm j o a1g ' p ~ m ay,
J O ~ pun03 aram pouad pmAalar ayt 103 svmo938~0
saldm amos a r a q ~(3v)amox
u! nelnpsox 9 q - w =qva q U! a p m oqv s e q~ m y -aJaql
~ g w ~ a mm pun03 ~ ppue (V& a - o q q y a q j o s a ~ g aqrq U! sp1-1
~ oq j3 m o q ~ u m
r w x atp as-maxa a q j o ap!s ptprrttng am spMax sv
'(vN@nay-Q'- map!=x a v
30 dcrg=m;lo aql mag llW p w q o a9 mu o p m o p ? arqrmp q9nN
.alqssod se o~ [ d u r m SE a n w 011q1o U! osp s m o s moog pump
a9 a Sml U o V o M .W W F H FPaqlrrs W 1 'WS aV1 :slW¶%
p3404 CUaM !S!3133% J-0 pU!Ul U! WOq aq w e $XLUJ 11 M ' a!AJO $yOd
w=*m B fioqjo -1 am11 h~ S! =p1 os -p
~ m a l a=p l srooy- 3yms.ppp pm s u e 103 alq!mods=
3J3M OYM SUOSlad m30 P U I ' ~ ~ ~ 0 S ' jUOo!wnm P v O M put3
p a q oqm mwad mog u o ~ amos o no ~p' s q u n m j o saldcm -a :@mpl!nq
JO s u o m p p '!x@a%~o@ 'slaponr :snaummp no A@ saga uopemojrr! a g
$emPQ+PO=P .
?s m ~ 1 1 -sroos- PWW s l ! 93adss ~ W =m ~ w ~ a 1
mn o - o ~ Am q p pm p q uo 3 ~ y o d a ~
sdnodl aqt P ~ P A O J seq
~ ( m m w 2 l ) Queq3jo atnlpq ayl ' n ~ ! V o ; )a q ¶ I F
now- mnfrum Q tr0,EFa m q .~ognl!Pq arpjo sl* =qJO '&W,
~ ~ aAq @J! ~ [ d m m
acp t p pawm pma ~ q a x d c u m q Lpo [[Fwadxa qms
jo v0da.1 dm A ~ s n o ~ q o-(s~a)@w1-0 se ]lam se) ammg p pm &uplmq
W q q W wacfxa -3 seq u o ! s q r n q q ~ , -m q ~ a q ~q ~
MOq m w Pm srooqq q 3 o slaaP!=J pa#fnmr-ou p m pn-m a q u y a p 03
FaMW &F'PIF"~Joh!@nbPm m a 9 PloV SKIP- aPn[V a s a U
=D
-! pSugumuo w a m w 013upq osp se u o p u y sy saas u o ~ s s ~ o = )
aq a)snbape m a v0 ; ~-9snoyrCuad pm u@n 9 ~ s 1u o g r q ! ~
mop^ ur pamm asngr! p1193 mtpaym a@gsav q s1q!nrar s , u o ! s s ~ o ~ jped
o
Before dealing with these specifically it may be worth saying a few words about
background The Institute of Charity is divided into Provinces and other
circumscriptions like Vice-Provinces and Regions. Provinces have their own form
of governance with a Provincial at the head. This person is appointed by the Superior
General and is accountable to him. The Irish Province of the Institute of Charity was
established in 1931 but there were communities of members in Ireland since 1866.
Before becoming a Province, the Houses of the Institute in Ireland were part of the
English Province. There were only three such houses: Upton (Co,Cork), a
Reformatory and later an Industrial School, Clonmel (Ferryhouse) (CO-Tipperary)an
Industrial School and Omeath (Co..Louth), a house of formation for students aspiring
to become members of the Institute. At the commencement of the lrish Province, the
few communities of the Institute in the United States (a few parishes and one High
School) were alsojoined to the Irish Province, which was officially know as the Irish-
American Province. This arrangement lasted until the late 1960's when America
became a separate Province. When the Irisb American Province was created it
consisted of 30 professed members in Ireland and 14 professed members in the u.s.~
In the financial context it is important to be aware of the origins and development of

the Irish Province. At its beginnings the Province did not possess nor was it later
endowed with enormous wealth. The Industrial School at Upton had a fhirly
substantial farm of over a hundred acres some of which had been purchased by the
Institute of Chariv, the School at Clonmel h i,at the outset, only a very small
amount of land (circa 9 acres)':which was part of the original endowment; the house
at Omeath had a small farm attached. The original buildings at Upton were provided
by the Cork Reformatory Society (a subsidiary of the Vincentian or St.Vincent de
Paul Society); those at Clonmel by Count Arthur Moore MP., and Omeath were the
gift of a benefactor. All subsequent development of buildings and acquisition of
lands at Upton and Clomnel were financed by the Ifi3€itute of Chari The State did
F
not provide any of the buildings for the historical Industrial Schools and from 1921
until the mid 1960's practically nothing was received by way of grants for
development or maintenance of buildings. There is some evidence that the two
Industrial Schools, Upton and Clomnel while under the aegis of the English Province
of the Institute of Charity were regarded as the 'poor relations' of the other houses in
that Province and -especially in the years prior to the establishment of the Irish
Province- were allowed to run down.' The costs of renovation and maintenance of
the Schools at Upton and Clonmel had to be borne by the fledgling Irish province6.
3 ' h f d ' members are those who b e taken vows.

'Cf. Commission ofloquj. into the Refbrmatory and hiusbid School System 1934-196 (The
Cussen Report), n. 23, p.10 and cf. also Appendbr B
'Cf. the note foJlowing
The Sormation r e g a d i the origins of the Zrish Province and its 6nancial condition at the time is
mainly derived from a IeCter of Fr-ThornasHickey (the first Provincial) to FrHugh MacFadden a later
Provincial. The letter is dated October 11" 1956. Fr.Hickey says that pn 19311 ' e r mrch ehtion
an alZoc&on off25,OOO was d e by h Enghh ProviTlce'However, f8,oOO of this was emmarked as
the cordnion of the new Province to the establishment of an iaterdonal studeut house in Rome
and the remainder was not sdlicieat to purchase and renovate the Novitiate House ofthe new Province
at Kilmurray, Co,Cork It would seem that the Province had to borrow fkom the outset. Fr-Hickeygoes
on to say re the houses at Upton and Clonmel:'llw!improvemen& lit t k C/ptort were d e e r
very strong and mtittueclprexwrefnnn he EabrdmonAuthorities. Ibe hglish P r o v i d had never
taken any interest in this School md it M Y M d owr to UY in apitiable d t i w Clonmel war
even in worse d t i o n It was a M l wirhour claw nwxru.d with only the madprimitiw toilet
l
cussen7in 1938 was well aware of the situation in Industrial Schools generally: "...It
must not be overIooked thaC the buildings,farms, plant, etc., have as a rule been
providkd by the s c b I . v thvelvc.v, without the aid of the Stale undLocaI Authorities,
and that the improvements, alterations, extensions,renewals and repairs necessury to
meet changing circwmtances have been dependent to a large extent on charitabte
contributions and on the privute resources of the imtituliom. This arrangement,
while advantageour to t k farpuyer, h v limited the activities of the M m g c ~ r and
s
hindered development in many directions" (Cussen Report,n 168, pp.43-44).
The above quotation merits careful analysis and, presumably, it will receive such from
the Ryan Commission. In the context of the developing Irish Province of the
Institute of Charity, the provision of plant, the maintenance and repair of buildings
built in the mid to late 19&century, was a heavy burden It must be kept in mind
that the two Industrial Schools were only a part of the financial burden on the
Province which also had to provide and maintain houses for students who were called
to join the Institute and who did not pay any fees for their training. From 1945
onwards, the Province had a M e r call on its limited financial resources when it was
required to provide for the travelling expenses, health care and much more, of the
members who went on mission to East Africa. The hvince, while it did receive
some financial help from the English Province in 1931, was not in receipt of ongoing
help fiom that or from any other quarter- There has never been a tradition in the
Institute of receiving any finance from what might be termed 'central funds' In fact
such funds do not exist. Any monies received by the W t u t e (including its
Provinces) by way of legacies, donations etc., if not already designated by the donor
for a particular cause or work, have to be so designated by the S-or General.
Apart from a few relatively small grants the Irish Province never received help from
any funds designated by the Superior ~ e n e d ' . As far as the Industrial Schools at
Upton and Clonrnel are concerned, the readily apparent consequence of all the above
is that the fish Province was always struggling to d n ~ annadequate standard of
living for the persons detained in the Institutions and, indeed, for those charged with
their care. While h4hagers (the Provincial Superiors) and Resident Managers might
have aimed for a standard above the mediocre, they m l y achieved anything
approaching the ideal. Government Inspectors in their Reports on these ~ c h o o l s ~
often p r e s c n i changes but they did not prescrii how these changes were to be
financed Resident hhnagers, were personalities of varying hue: some were good
fund-raisers and good at public relations; some were endowed with common
sense and business acumen; others had little of these qualities and all had no specific
training for their position. Neither did any of their staff until the late 1970's apart
from the teachers in the Primary Schools and even here one could question if anything
these had received in Training College would have prepared them for the largely
remdal type of education needed e s p e ~ d l yby the majority of the statuton'ly
committed residents of the Schools.
Another aspect to be borne in mind when considering the Accounts is the interweave
between School, Fam and Comm wWtIncome y and Expenditure. Having land was
seen as a necessity to produce food (e-gmilk,potatoes, and vegetables) for all the
accommu&ion £3,000had l0 be qwnt on clksrwm and CoSZeB. Later-more recerttfi £28,000 have
k ,%hod that it m '
been .spent on the C:/ontnelSchool to make it t
7
Cf.note 4 above
Cf.Appmdix A below: A Note on the F i AtlFairs ofthe lrish Province of the Lnstitute of
Charitv.
9
The Laffoy/Ryan C d o n wiIl, undoubtedly, have access to all these.
residents on the campus and to provide some income to the Province. The 'story' of
Upton and Clonmel does not show that the f m s there were enterprises that ever
made large profits. There are many reasons for this: the depressed economic climate
in heland especially in the 1940's, the unscientific approach to farming and h
budgeting in those years. Perhaps the greatest factor militating against good farm
management was that none of those in charge had any specific training for their task.
From the financial point of view, one has the clear impression that the management
and maintenance of the historical Industrial Schools at Upton and Clonrnel was a
constant struggle, which left those in charge with little time or energy to make the
kind of additional improvements that many of them undoubtedly would have wished
to make.
01 png o 018u?p~omr,
Xg pamolln r / n ~ p ~ a nay1 anp 1s2~atulzap pug01 snq asnoy
conjionted with a very heavyfinancial burden ". Kaving described Fr.Tom Hickey
as one who had: "carte-blanch to a good extent during thep v t 25 years in
managing the affairs ofthe Province ... " Fr. MacFadden seems to have included with
his own letter an extract from a letter that Fr.Hickey had sent to him.4
In a letter of 3 0 November
~ 1957 there is an interesting paragraph The context
surrounding ths is the proposed setting up of a Novitiate in the American part of the
Province, following Fr-Gaddo's visitation there in October of that year and the
detrimental financial consequences for Ireland, entailed by such a move. In the
course of his letter Fr.MacFadden says: " The two Indwtriul ,Cchoo/.s were undertuken
as workv of charity d thefiuits cfthe fanns go to their support with the subsit$
fiom the Government which of itselfwould be imdequute. " To be noted here,
perhaps, is that in the estimation of the Provincial the financial wntri bution by the
State to the two Lnhstrial School was only a subsidy. In the same context, the letter
of 3"' December gives some insight as to how the Industrial Schools (and even
StJoseph's Drumcondra) were regarded: It must be>ernernbered thut the two
Idustrial L k h ~and
l ~
St.Joseph *SDmrncondra are great works of charity bul ooj'nu
benefir to [he ~rde/amlikeyour great Colleges in Ita& and the two in England The
rnissionsdfor which the Province has been mainly responsible is no source of gain
We h e the Novitiute und Juniorate (...) which are not sources ofgain or profit. "
He then goes on to ask a question:" T h question is t k n how w i l l h e l d cuny on the
works of churity undertakn, andprepcrte menfor the missions with rrlI the expenses
invofved,maintain the Juniorate and Novitiate andpay oflgradua fly the huge debt
incurred? It is idle to say now that such U debt should not have been i n w e d but
A COPY ofthis extiac! is appended to these notes.

Quite obviousty 'fbxial benefit' is what is intended.
6
Here is meant the then mission territory of a region of what is now Tamaak, where persarmel from
the Irish-American Provia;e bad been worldng since 1945
the hurd fact remaim that it [is] an obligation that can't be shirked " He ends the
letter by a g a j nreferring to his distress at being: " confronted with such a debt with
1111fe or no resources to clear it. "
In the course of a letter of 6&December 1957, refemng to a report made by Fr-Torn
fickey on monies received from America, Fr Mac Fadden is making Fr.Gaddo aware
that the previous Superior General (Fr.Bozzetti) had siphoned off some h d s fiom
America and applied them to works in Italy: $ 16.000 for Domodossola College and
$15,000 for Sicily.
On the 14h December 1957, where he comments on a meeting held at Clonmel
(Ferryhouse) of the three ~ r c ~ b ~ t eresident

r . ~ ' in Ireland, he goes on to say that the
Province debt was a debt: "incurred in the name of lhe united Province [Irish-
American Province] und the overdr~fl~~permitted

by the Bunk were given on the
credt cf the Ir~vh-AmericanProvince. " The letter continues, hoping that the
brethren in Ireland will not become discouraged: "seeing t k d there iis such U h e ~ q
burden ofdebt to be cleared and the tmk seeming$~mpssibk with m)hope of
development because of ourfiruvlcial embarrassment. " There is a post-script to the
letter suggesting that the monies being contributed in America towards the formation
of the msh] students in Rome: "'should come through lreltutd us thut would help
sustain the redi it here ofthe Province before the authorities offhe Bank and would be
an affirmution of the p r a n t e e given by yourpredecessor to the B& " From
Fr.MacFaddenYsletters of this period, one can see that the Province debt weighed
heavily on hlrn personally.8 There are also some examples of how bad things were: In
November 1958, "exceptforfires in certain roorns, " there was no heating at Upton.
Presbyters in the Institute of Charity are members who have taken a fourth vow that has among its
obligations watching over tbe 'poverty' of the Institute i.e. ensuring that the income of tbe Lnstitute is
applied to works ofcharity only.
Cf. Letter of 3 l" January 1958 where he says he is suffering fiom stomach ulcers.
When Fr.Eugene Arthurs was ordained Bishop of Tanga (Tanzania) in August 2958,
the Province could not afford the expenses of the Ordination meal, which Bishop
Arthurs hmself paid for from donations received at that time. (Letter of 20" January
1959). Buttherewassomeimprovementinthesituationan~writingfiom
Ferryhouse on the 3d February 1959, Fr.MacFadden was able to tell the General:
"The Rector pr.P.Spelrnan] was able to reduce the debt [on F q h v e ] by £3,000
the pllsr yeur u p r t from minor improvements"
Bishop Arthurs made a suggestion in that same month that an extra man be assi_med
to 'mission propaganda'9 in Ireland and that the Province keep half the takings9''
Likewise in America an extra man could be put on 'propaganda' and 25% of the
income would come to Ireland. It is not clear, at the present stage of research, if any
of these suggestions were ever implemented Writing on the 21* February 1959,
Fr. MacFadden says that the: ')?inunciu/ situution seemed better hut the debts ure high
andyears will be required to clear them. " On the 28&of the same month, he refers
to the closing of Greenrnount Industrial School as "h nice bit of news " because the
influx of boys from Greenrnount to uptonu "will he a bigjhmcieI help in the
management of our SCFLOOI''
But the increase in numbers at Upton did not solve all the problems. On April 2 la
1959, Fr.MacFadden is telling the General that the Province probably would not be
justified in having the thesis of one of the members printed because it would have
limited appeal and the Province "is unable to flordsuch expense. " More expense
was incurred in January 1960 when Glencomeragh was bought for £7,000,as a
Scholasticate.
This was the term then in use for fund-raising.

'OThis has to be understood in the context of the Province having to sustain the expenditure for tbe
education, training, equipment a d travel h the missionaries.
" On the 3 l* March 1959.97 (ninety w e n ) boys fiom Greenmount School were admitted to Upton
But the 'Greenmount factor' was having some effect and Fr.MacFadden was able to
say in a letter dated l* March 1960 regarding Upton: "%rnmrhcrs in the ,School are
huppily keeping up-there i s a big reduction on the debt of the hare-less by f4.000.
AN the account.~Jiomthe various k . e . v are not in yet so thaf the Pruv.Proarafor
cun let you have U statement. "lZ
On the 17" August 1960 Fr.MacFadden reminds the General (who was about to
embark on a journey to America) that he hopes the brethren in America will be
disposed to contribute generously to the purchase of the new Scholasticate and goes
on to say: "We h e n 't the purchase mmey un1as.s by raising the overdrafl in the
Bank which m a o additional intwc?,vtto be paid and that is whut is crippling this p a ~ i
of the Province-trying tofindthe interest yeurly und not being able to reduce the
Province debt. "
On the 1 l" February 196 1(the new Scholasticate at Glencomeragh had opened the
previous October), he thanks the General for "udvuncing £-3,000

or ,so towwds the
purchase of the new Scholasticate. "'But he goes &I to express a pessimistic view
"If a r that this Province or thispurt of the Province in Ireland will never be uble to
stand alone or independent,fmrmciaflj~,in view ofthe three houses devoted to works
of ch~rity'~which
cun never be expected to carry or support the three houses of
finnation-the Schofarticate,Novifiute&~uniorate". "
However, around this time Clonturk House was purchased for circa E 8 , O . I 5 In a
letter of 1 4 February
~ 1x1,Fr.MacFadden tells the General: "There will be no
Annual Statements of Accounts were meant to be sent to the Superior General. An effort will be
made to trace extant copies &her in the IPA or the AG.
'" this time the' three houses' were: Upton, Ferrytrouse and Drurncondra.
l4 These houses w e : Glencomaagh, Kibnmay and Omeath
n the IPA, dated 18" February 1x1,fiom Fr.Gaddo to Fr.MacFaddeo, giving
l 5 There is a letter i
permission to buy Clonhrrk for Lit. 18 million
additional burden on the Province became of rhe purchs-e of the property. The
neces.vary f d v will he got from other . ~ ~ ~ ~ r c e s " ' "
There is a reference in a letter of 3* July 1961 to the fact that that the Superior
General himself gave money towards some building a t Omeath.
Omeath came into the picture again in May 1962 when there was a request from there
for permission to build a Hall. The Provincial reports that he has told the Omeath
community that they must collect (i.e. hndraise) a few thousand themselves before a
start could be made.
On the 28" September 1962, Fr.MacFadden tells Fr-Gaddothat he is: "culling a
meeting of Rectors for Ociober P here ut i@on to talk over thefimnciul stute of
each house and to see fsome ofthe houses wuld contribute to the Provincial Furui-
suy the two Sch00l.s ppton and Ferryhouse] U& Dnuncondru Hntlre. "
The meeting was held and on the 18& October Fr-MacFaddenindicates to the
Fr.Genera1 that the initiative for that particular meeting had corne fiorn Fr-O'Brien
[Provincial Procurator]. He then goes on to make a brief report on the main points
discussed, and concludes: "The Provinciul debt stunds still [sic] c ~f t 57,000-not
possible present to effect a reduction as the Provincial Procwa~orh to provide
for an extru house, the new L%hoZusticute[Glencomeragh opened in October 19601.
Thefuture is bright, h w w e r , as help wz/( beforthcomingfiom Dnmrconcfru, Upton
and the School ut CYonmel. We ure assuming that the number of boys ut both
schools is mamfained l7 There is much repair work to be dune here m Upton d a
building programme ut Drumwitdru, but ut the lutter pZuce funds are increasing with
their various appeals and means o f w - r a i s i n g . Ourfarm were ccmridered- how
16
These 'm' were made up of a grant of 33,000 fiom the Hospitals Trust aod fimd-raising efforts
directed by Fr.Con Cmrell as is evident h m a letter of Fr.Cottrell to tbe Proviocial, dated 2zd Iaouary
1960 (IPA).
" In fact, Uptw industrial School closed less than four years later.
to incrw~eproductivity and plans for developing the dairy indu~tryat Kilmt~try&
[@tonwhich w d d give a good f m i a Z return (...) Withina cmpZe of-years [@ton,
Drumcondru & Clonme1 should he able to make afairfinancial contrihtdion to the
Prov.Fd., in addition to their Mavs s t i p e d . " I S There follows this optimistic
note: Here at Cjpton the wheat crop brought in f 2,000 in spite of the had stmmer.
" "
From a letter of 30&July 1963 it is clear that Fr.Vincent K m e d y had sought
permission from the General to take out a Bank loan to build the Hall at Omeatk
On the 29' September 1963, Fr.Arthur J.O9Brienwho had been Provincial Procurator
(and Manager at Upton and then Ferryhouse) returned to America Fr. William
O'Reilly became the Manager at Ferryhouse and Provincial Procurator. According
to Fr.MacFadden7sletter of 7& Novernebr 1963, Fr.07Reilly "is concerned about the
jkncial situation as Provincial Prt~'taator."
A meeting of Rectors was held at Clonmel on November I 8&1963 with finance high
on the agenda. Suggestions were made about giving: a percenfage oftoral fukings
"
in the three uctive houses19to the 'Provincinl ~ u n k''. It was proposed that this
suggestion be followed up at the end of the year, "but in the meantime the homes of
Drumcondra and [@tonare committed through their Rectors to help ourfirtlmciailv. '"
On the 4' February 1964, Fr-MacFaddenmentions that a few donations towards the
education of students had been received but not amounting to more than £1,500.
" O£Feringsfor Masses celebrated by priests in the various communities weut (as they sfiU do) to the
Province Funds.
I 9 'Active' house.are those that generate income;houses that depend on a Province contribution are
called 'passive'
0%a m uo)cIn ~ea1y ayl ICq pasnm
n-000'9~3
a % m p a q JOJ w!ep a3uerna.q a q 1q1 sMau S! aJaq3 '9961 JaqruaAoN aql n o
,paLerap
ot aAq p p f i m u ! ~ o ~~d J WO y s g ay1 ot mueU!ruaX Ap;.rlrenb m u a w U!
P m 3 u ! W W o asntrsaq @laUa9 ayl PaUJJ0.F@SJod'ld '996 1 Apf .61 ayl W
.' ,, , 'am!AoJdJq1om-1
01 uan!3 dlay lnt~umgayjXl!mn~odurajpudms 01 hr),,~,sa~au
aq /Cntu I! , ,, :[e31~au.q1
ur rotemmu pm p t 3 u ~ o q - m m q JaUaI e ruoy
~ l 3 v -JJ wog ~ A I - 1 s ~ aq
atonb 01 no saos aH - p 3 n p aq
~ 01 a q I ~ y
Mj m u i ~01 ~ a 2 p pq u u n ayj ,, :pm
pamamur sr m r p o q a q j o uapmq pr3ueuy atp u o ~ d n j o8ursop aw t p t ~ -y)earug
%lp@a~ @ Q n 3 ! d a u m g mo!Iuam y&od'Jd '9961 Y 3 J W ,,l $0 JaUal snl ul
IZ"
.s.~rv@j/oCTIS uozr~.gs~u~uqn~
q j ucolJuralqo~d
n salnj!j.ruoD jmp pun punlaq U! ~naXs!yjuas?l o,Vn jsmajul yung ayj j m / j ajou I ,,
S
: s ~ aq S961 l a q O m .S ayl U 0 e3!J3UIV WOlJ OppE).J+JW ~ U O UO
~ U ~ U. SM I N lOJ
' ~ 9 6 jo
a3u!~oqaqjjo ved m u a q aql 01 U O ! ~ ? ? A uo 1uafi yllCsrod*~d 1 ~ l eaql
j tq
ad {O~WJ
-/Cunurl1~ q j uo auop s ~ d a q l j l o J M oj OO_Cp m j3a/oJd q j ym]s 01
00o6[Aayjoun pun sZu!plfnqay1 ~o/pasln~
unol ay1 pur$a~01 000 'z /Clawnu-h~nu~~y
~0Jppm
m ' p ,pul;{o1 p a z w a q - m mzu!=g hwa -112
uo!~uaui01 1dmn amnu$uo ymor IOU ,, :oppq-~-~d
lluys~ 01law1 v30 asno3 ay1 ul
'laqalw 47.ayl W U q
'm61 Apf U1 @f3UFo&J JaAO 3001 WWOS J d
h the ForsythfGaddo correspondence for 1967 there are some attached pages with
opinions re the proposed transfer of the Novitiate from Kilmurry to Dublin In one of
these, probably that of Fr.W.O7Reilly,the Provincial Procurator, there is a strong note
of caution: "there is still a debt of neurly f 100,000 which HAS to be puid "
On the 24' September 1968, Fr.Fors-yth makes reference to the "contract behveen
~ ~goes on: " Thefimnciirlprop',.sa/.~

Blshop Arthurs und the P r ~ v i n c e "and ure
impossible a s you b w our situation and a three year tour fmi.v.vioncaie.v returning
every three yecrrs insteud of .six originuliy] ulso impo.~.sib/eowing tof i m c i u l
implications. " Further on in the same letter he implies that the American cow is
going dry: " Ol~rfiwnciulresources depend on the cont~ibutionsfiomAmerica to cr
large extent (...). We have not received help$nancial helpfor some time.
On the 15' November 1969, Fr.Forsyth thanks the General for his "kindfimciui
help " and there is a similar reference in a previous letter.
On the 5&December 1969 Fr-Forsythwrites: " A v& mundane note hut we t h n k
God that this year the Provincial debt was reduced by f5.000 thank^ to your k i d help
and that of others i.e. for 1969. 1do not mention these matters in public for many
.I
reasons.
On the 19' February 1970 Fr-Forsythreturns to the theme of finance: "We clre not in
afinanciulposition to support a three year tow ofthe missions mui rww even more so
U we are completely on our ownfinamiully. "
On the 12& October 1970 h e tells Gaddo that Fr.Michae1 McGough, then Provincial in
l4 This was about k e s for the missionaries travelling on home leave and back to Afiica and also
about money for their holidays etc.
A decision in principle had been taken by the General to make Amerita a separate Provioce,
something that happened officially in April 1971.
England, had "agreed to give the Irish Province a loan off 5,000 to be repuid over
t ;me."
With his letter of 1 9 March

~ 1971 Fr.Forsyth seemingly included a Statement of
Province Accounts and says: "Abw f suy a word aboul the materiul s d e of things
which also m ~bet spoken d o ~ .Plea~ejindenclosed, F d k , a S t a t c m o~of '
Accounts for the Province, ending December 1970 and as you will note (with
~ r . ~ e c r e t u rthclt
y ) ~the
~ Lord has been v a y kind to us. T?te M i n g "Vuritm
Loans" f 12,I 70.00 @/us-f 600.00 and f 285.00 etc.) ure mostly Burses for the
~ , that covers @iu o m~no)~~

Education ofStuciEntsfi,r !he ~ r i e s t k x dand the present
Provinciul Overdraft o f f 14,000.00. The individual houre~'hme their debts which
can be reduced arid cleared in time with God's help. ((@tonowes also the Engksh
Province f 5,000.00 ut present on lotm). We too are very p t e f i r l f i r your kind und
generous help with tIhc Provincial Ovm&ajL "
Novitiate to Dublin, Fr.Forsyth
money for the new building.

-
On the 15& November 1971, in telling Gaddo about the decision to move the
asking advice &to where the Province would get
In a letter of 15h October 1972 he informs the General that Kilmurray was sold for
590,000 but there was a £20,000 debt to be paid off there [on the farm] and the new
Novitiate cost £ 40,000.
In a final letter mentioning finance 3 d ~ a r c h1973, Fr-Forsythtells Fr-Gaddothat the
Government is finding £70,000 for the extension at C l o n W , "we have t o w
f 5,000. "
This is Fr.Forsyth's way of making sure that Fr.Gaddo, an Italian will undmstand Irish aammts i.e,
using the help of his Secretary an Englishman.
During his tenn as Provincial Fr.Forsytb established a number of Bursa.
Italian: 'more or less'
Fr-Bernard (Brian) McNally was installed a s Provincial of the Irish Province on the
~ ~1973. His Provincialate was a short one due to ill health Writing to
1 6 July
Fr.Gaddo on the 25& July, 1973 he says regarding the proposed Secondary School at
Drumcondra: "Evendid we hcrve a suitable site our share in the comtruction of any
Secohdary School at p r e s m would cost the Province at lest £l 00,000and l Jmht f
we could carry thut burden. # 9 2 9
On the 28&October 1973 he comments that: "h ordm to save a substuntial rmunmt oj'
money-ut lemt f 2Operperson it had been decided that students from the Province
"
returning to Rome at the end of that summer would travel overland and not by air.
There are no further details re the financial situation in the McNally/Gaddo
correspondence.
In February 1974, Fr.McNaHy met with the Secretary of the Depamnerd ofEducation and rexived
of 25& February [l9741

November 2007
APPENDIX XIV :
Rosminian Fathers - Province Accounts

November 2007
Province Accounts Analysis 1952 1953 1961 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 TOTAL
€ € € € € € € € € €
Income
Masses 12,280.94 10,393.35 11,860.00 34,534.29
USA contribution 1,363.70 3,699.25 5,062.95
Contributions from sisters 634.87 72.38 707.24
Transfers 380.92 253.95 2,539.48 2,539.48 5,713.82
Refunds 933.89 467.00 171.17 18.96 123.42 1,714.44
Pensions,donations,rent,supplies, wills &
gifts 552.20 253.31 1,153.00 15.66 2,031.58 63.49 1,781.51 1,269.74 7,120.48
Unidentified income 81.11 5,979.25 6,060.36
Industrial Schools 21,543.46 253.95 21,797.40
Individuals 2,517.81 21.59 2,539.40
Sale of cottage 380.92 380.92
Rome 507.90 507.90
Glencomeragh rent 24.23 24.23
Fathers and brothers 2,901.35 380.92 312.10 162.53 3,756.90
Land Bonds 13.60 13.60
Rent 35.50 35.50
Prize Bond 63.49 63.49
Curran's Brushes Made 249.19 249.19
Cattle & Farm Produce 1,947.88 1,947.88
Provisional contributions 8,032.00 11,170.46 9,419.07 9,836.98 11,707.14 11,631.32 61,796.96
Stipendia Missarum 22,521.15 25,020.81 20,764.03 16,431.16 18,871.65 103,608.80
Stocks,Rents, Dividends 134.06 185.79 190.56 226.71 1,137.70 1,086.32 2,961.14
Funeral Expenses 190.46 190.46
Retreat - Loftus Hall 15.24 15.24
Sale of books 61.58 31.74 93.33
Bulmer's (for boys) 47.32 47.32
For African student 31.74 31.74
November 2007
Province Accounts Analysis 1952 1953 1961 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 TOTAL
€ € € € € € € € € €
Supplies 304.74 118.09 38.19 241.25 119.36 821.62
Burses 412.66 317.43 317.43 1,047.53
Sale of "Consul" 177.76 177.76
In trust 809.33 809.33
Contributions for Fr. Prov's car 380.92 380.92
Towards Glen'ragh 184.11 184.11
Sale of cattle 1,339.80 1,339.80
Sale of students car 190.46 190.46
Income tax refund 138.57 236.96 375.53
For the gen chapter from English
Provincial 253.95 253.95
Total Income 16,227.63 31,667.25 19,303.61 21,512.00 34,565.72 37,922.63 35,179.63 36,390.54 33,786.98 266,556.01
November 2007
Expenditure 1951 1953 1961 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 TOTAL
€ € € € € € € € € €
Scholastics 1,282.84 1,282.84
Novitiate 2,166.17 2,166.17
Juniorate 5,550.03 5,550.03
Missions 1,627.73 1,627.73
Dollars 3061 1,363.70 1,363.70
Individual 126.97 190.46 35.55 1,620.69 181.70 2,155.38
Medical, chemical, hospital 508.20 243.87 84.50 49.20 306.13 1,191.90
Insurance and Interests 794.27 880.54 3,288.16 2,314.00 3,132.38 2,999.44 2,784.85 3,795.95 2,151.83 22,141.42
Travelling(incl. Italy, USA and UK) 2,479.07 5,446.92 288.33 620.00 86.32 420.88 536.91 618.74 10,497.18
Province administration 241.25 253.95 495.20
Transfers 12,414.43 1,523.69 2,760.73 16,698.85
Industrial Schools 11,377.65 6,227.28 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 81.26 0.00 17,686.19
Capital Expenditure 380.92 593.34 907.86 539.64 2,421.76
Clothing 195.63 195.63
Glencomeragh 5,134.85 0.00 3,491.78 502.82 0.00 0.00 0.00 9,129.44
Car expenses 376.50 606.00 982.50
Books, fees, stationery and printing 613.39 371.08 87.61 25.39 190.97 1,288.44
Fathers and Brothers 213.43 562.79 1,118.11 533.29 1,469.72 421.55 4,318.89
Income Tax 140.17 20.00 20.00 180.16
Subscriptions Patrician Year 76.18 76.18
Mandates and subsidies 11,876.00 13,825.54 14,508.92 14,869.90 11,654.93 12,839.24 79,574.52
Transfer of Masses 2,880.00 2,880.00
U.C.C students 822.00 382.93 314.23 271.53 1,790.70
Reduction overdraft 500.00 1,269.74 1,269.74 2,539.48 3,809.21 6,348.69 15,736.86
do. Allowance 100.00 573.92 573.92 1,247.84
November 2007
Expenditure 1951 1953 1961 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 TOTAL
€ € € € € € € € € €
Insurance, Rates 184.00 244.50 335.85 277.92 163.43 292.78 1,498.47
Miscellaneous:Holidays, Medical, etc 328.00 328.00
Transfer stipendiorum 9,877.81 11,312.82 10,158.55 8,420.31 7,272.93 47,042.42
Refunds 821.84 47.32 869.16
Prize bonds 50.79 50.79
For African student 63.49 63.49
C/A fees and cheque book 2.22 3.49 5.71
supply and excess stipends 154.76 154.76
Charity 3.81 879.93 6.35 890.09
Burses 761.84 317.43 1,079.28
Courses 97.77 82.79 367.02 547.57
Basins etc K'murry 416.47 416.47
To English Provisional 253.95 253.95
To house (cattle) 389.17 389.17
Chapter expenses 640.20 634.87 1,349.73 2,624.80
Total Expenditure 16,140.24 31,193.91 16,358.29 20,230.00 34,601.85 33,179.65 38,123.97 35,786.22 33,279.52 258,893.65
Income less expenditure 87.40 473.35 2,945.32 1,282.00 -36.12 4,742.98 -2,944.34 604.32 507.46 7,662.36
November 2007
APPENDIX XV : GOLDENBRIDGE
INCOME AND EXPENDITURE 1951-1969
&
BUILDING ACCOUNT 1961-1966

November 2007
Income 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 1961
€ € € € € € € € € € €
Dublin Corporation 6,127.51 5,279.05 6,623.94 3,156.61 6,628.65 6,244.93 3,208.45 7,063.27 9,848.58 9,909.20
Treasury 5,588.79 7,053.80 7,891.60 7,746.58 7,637.89 3,648.50 9,941.77 15,977.89 5,573.22 9,226.42
Meath County
Council 35.59
Kildare Co. Council 558.14 632.62 611.38
Wicklow Co. Council 116.58 134.43 148.97
Carlow Co. Council 35.59 71.36 49.65
Dublin Co. Council 324.00 550.72 476.15
Credit Interest 11.87 21.97 26.47 20.44 6.29 12.82
Heating+Cleaning
Grant 33.01 31.30 159.61 82.67 57.14
Free Books 7.05 6.09 5.14 5.14
Unspecified 16,001.02 333.88
County Councils 1,415.66 1,210.49 697.09 1,443.27 378.13 383.41 1,930.43
Boards of
assistance 74.10 99.57 180.38
Voluntary Pupils and
other sources 513.30 173.45 486.75 219.79 25.65 139.67 210.05
Rent for St Joseph,
Rathdrum 104.75 104.75
Discounts etc.. 19.78
Cookery Grant 68.57
Rathdrum 10.64
Dept. of Education 1,115.46
Parents
Contributions 63.49
Total Income 12,786.20 13,721.98 17,032.57 16,001.02 13,042.30 15,940.71 11,099.24 15,027.13 23,979.64 15,951.17 21,430.41
November 2007
Expenditure 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 1961
€ € € € € € € € € € €
Food 4,378.91 5,681.04 7,802.54 7,427.97 4,384.63 4,563.56 1,917.60 5,487.17 4,927.46 2,945.06 6,753.35
Clothing 1,229.64 2,169.98 1,771.28 1,714.15 1,387.81 1,566.59 1,282.35 2,435.74 2,534.49 1,619.16 2,468.29
Salaries and wages 2,045.28 2,655.64 4,924.67 2,341.94 2,903.94 1,644.31 3,509.09 3,755.61 1,877.69 3,905.78
Drugs and medical
expenses 135.90 48.19 93.31 94.58 188.40 107.47 103.43 84.45 97.86 60.31 204.11
Telephone 54.88 43.26 93.55 113.24 34.84 92.88 189.44 73.62 317.31
Chapel & Rev. chaplain 170.60 144.46 269.60 211.53 169.45 257.24 396.62 300.24 320.04
Stationery and printing 5.88 5.18 7.81 77.67 33.85 99.71 163.22 26.83 116.77
Laundry and cleaning 135.09 23.30 253.95 291.60 88.07 109.77 166.34 524.30 117.76 149.89 118.47
Repairs to Buildings and
Decorations 2,805.55 65.37 724.04 610.11 2,739.84 1,089.78 1,141.53 1,919.79 4,505.65 667.36 2,635.57
Rents, Rates and Taxes 226.79 210.42 171.83 577.96 764.48 255.36 735.18 644.71 283.09 550.30
Fuel, Light and Power 360.67 1,317.32 906.47 920.41 1,243.64 990.87 1,009.42 1,254.65 1,224.70 894.40 1,852.14
Insurance 111.29 74.97 139.67 139.67
Machinery and new
equipment 226.62 0.00
Books for schoolrooms &
library 47.65 23.60
Bank charges and debit
interest 44.99 28.98 8.02 4.63 4.18 7.72 5.45 10.89 11.57 5.45 75.93
Furniture, fittings and
bed linen 560.84 231.69 304.74 345.43 800.42 399.00 539.55 577.78 837.94 115.37 798.49
Girl's travelling expenses 19.05 20.32
Cost of Band 12.70 11.43
Aftercare 12.70 15.24
Holidays 74.44 72.38
Sundries 220.11 204.69
Rent 91.42
Rates (Water) 74.79
Salaries of School Staff 944.11
Salaries of Employees 3,999.67
November 2007
Expenditure
(continued) 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 1961
€ € € € € € € € € € €
Crockery and Hardware 109.86 575.80 343.97
Allowance for sisters 361.88
Travelling and postage 238.06 165.83 102.63 416.09 292.00 212.08 347.31
Recreational expenses 23.62 39.57 26.66 168.79 40.12 13.75 221.59
Sollicitor's fees, etc.. 113.97
Swimming Pool 63.49
Garden Seeds etc. 9.52
Donations 15.74 74.77 18.03 39.43 26.73 59.65
St Joseph's Holiday's
home cottage 222.20
Petty Cash expenses 44.77
Hardware 522.84 921.91 432.17 340.92
Extraordinary expenses 134.86 9.55 38.09
Unspecified
Total Expenditure 12,540.58 12,723.40 17,439.52 16,982.60 15,063.99 14,028.56 8,776.74 18,249.48 20,710.04 9,741.29 21,086.02
November 2007
Income 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969

€ € € € € € € €
Dublin Corporation 5,281.21 15,395.60 15,059.75 4,208.28 12,219.29 4,666.66 4,228.95
Treasury 9,529.10 3,725.09 13,607.33 14,430.26 14,398.51
Credit Interest 17.97 4.69 7.91 64.10 187.83 427.39 385.92 286.26
Heating+Cleaning Grant 69.84 69.84
Free Books 5.40
Unspecified 28,245.83
County Councils 2,370.19 2,105.92 2,224.78 6,376.37 2,054.19 755.95 1,480.16
Voluntary Pupils and other
sources 123.80 166.34
Grants 205.51 22.10 430.44 45.71 1,570.67
Cookery Grant 99.04
Gifts 12.70 203.16 114.28 126.97 215.86
Dublin Health Authority 1,113.66 3,225.05 6,630.06 6,897.94 7,534.49
refund for use of telephone for
Mr Bolger 12.70 0.00
Army allowance 107.90
Children's Crafts 2,056.98 25.39
Dept. of Education 6,725.08 6,980.78
Rent for grazing 31.74
Most reverend Dr Dunne 571.38
Total Income 17,410.21 21,566.52 28,253.74 32,490.99 28,672.07 38,216.86 19,661.36 22,868.55
November 2007
Expenditure 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969

€ € € € € € € €
Food 5,143.73 7,081.40 8,128.45 7,094.64 7,884.87 6,296.16 2,648.67 3,764.17
Clothing 2,374.87 3,289.43 4,458.80 3,412.33 3,931.97 2,367.66 854.89 1,030.05
Salaries and wages 5,098.09 4,678.16 4,462.00 4,724.15 4,703.99 5,369.28 2,907.50 3,057.69
Drugs and medical expenses 269.26 867.52 1,448.19 246.20 279.94 324.10 304.50 56.99
Telephone 267.01 323.85 256.99 303.07 77.29 88.92 46.89 55.51
Chapel & Rev. chaplain 340.89 329.52 330.58 234.77 637.83 474.11 143.80 50.64
Stationery and printing 96.31 102.26 115.17 216.92 397.49 482.69 189.55 229.51
Laundry and cleaning 213.70 20.05 250.37 334.33 293.55 461.77 78.77 206.31
Repairs to Buildings and Decorations 1,734.92 1,156.21 2,675.60 2,019.39 6,365.46 12,496.04 927.12 3,915.83
Rents, Rates and Taxes 985.90 687.77 923.02 650.33 1,258.88 1,247.39 855.12 650.30
Fuel, Light and Power 2,151.99 1,657.17 983.15 1,892.58 2,775.14 2,412.87 739.30 666.17
Bank charges and debit interest 13.01 31.72 51.08 21.59 12.38 17.62 14.28 16.13
Furniture, fittings and bed linen 824.76 218.60 550.01 590.96 2,022.38 230.85 567.04 567.74
Travelling and postage 345.05 337.88 612.28 575.52 723.05 495.02 848.22 336.23
Recreational expenses 74.28 131.30 185.70 280.27 371.31 170.98 103.86 225.71
Donations 52.82 89.90 137.89 83.29 35.43 161.55 57.54 187.17
Hardware 571.26 1,043.71 772.08 253.29 246.09 252.53 156.88 694.90
Total Expenditure 20,557.85 22,046.45 26,341.36 22,933.63 32,017.05 33,349.54 11,443.93 15,711.05
Note: Only 6 months of accounts for the years 1957, 1960, 1968 and 1969.
November 2007
30-Jun- 31-Dec- 30-Jun- 31-Dec- 30-Jun- 31-Dec- 30-Jun- 31-Dec- 30-Jun- 31-Dec- 30-Jun- 30-Dec-
Building account 61 61 62 62 63 63 64 64 65 65 66 66
Income € € € € € € € € € € € €
Treasury 1,269.74 1,269.74 0.00 1,269.74 2,022.25 1,269.74 0.00 0.00 0.00 4,636.99 0.00 4,699.94
Corporation 2,590.27 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,269.74 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 7,973.57
Dublin Corporation
(Dec 66) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 3,809.21
Treasury (II) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,015.79 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Health Authority 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,189.49
Gift 0.00 126.97 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Refund board of
works 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 19,490.48 6,285.20 6,983.56 0.00
Refund of
W.J.Bolger 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,009.44 0.00 0.00
Interest on a/c 85.05 139.07 0.00 6.73 3.75 5.62 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Unidentified 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 11,120.85 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
3,945.05 1,535.79 0.00 1,276.47 4,311.52 1,275.36 0.00 11,120.85 19,490.48 11,931.64 6,983.56 17,672.21
-
In Bank 10,292.92 13,603.08 5,986.19 928.97 31.30 105.26 725.33 -5,263.12 -4,565.03 -3,300.05 7,074.92 -91.48
14,237.95 15,138.87 5,986.19 2,205.43 4,342.82 1,380.61 725.33 5,855.30 14,925.45 8,631.59 -91.36 17,580.73
Expenses 0.00 9,152.67 5,057.22 2,174.13 4,237.56 655.29 5,988.44 10,420.32 18,225.38 15,706.25 0.00 18,518.62
-
In Bank 14,237.95 5,986.19 928.97 31.30 105.26 725.33 5,263.12 -4,565.03 -3,300.05 -7,075.04 -91.36 -937.96
14,237.95 15,138.87 5,986.19 2,205.43 4,342.82 1,380.61 725.33 5,855.30 14,925.33 8,631.21 -91.36 17,580.67
Breakdown of exp 0.00 0.00 5,057.22 0.00 0.00 655.29 5,988.44 10,420.32 0.00 0.00 0.00 18,518.62
Banagher Tiles
Limited 0.00 4,571.06 0.00 1,777.63 634.87 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Banagher Tiles
Limited 0.00 4,444.08 0.00 0.00 2,212.33 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
O Connor &
Aylward 0.00 137.13 0.00 53.33 57.14 0.00 0.00 0.00 936.81 746.61 0.00 0.00
Transfer to current
a/c 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,333.22 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
November 2007
30-Jun- 31-Dec- 30-Jun- 31-Dec- 30-Jun- 31-Dec- 30-Jun- 31-Dec- 30-Jun- 31-Dec- 30-Jun- 30-Dec-
Building account 61 61 62 62 63 63 64 64 65 65 66 66
Expenses (cont.) € € € € € € € € € € € €
Mr Walsh 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 595.19 71.42 0.00 0.00
Messrs W.J Bolger 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 15,617.78 12,443.43 0.00 0.00
Forde 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 253.95 0.00 0.00
Kenny & Company 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,323.05 0.00 0.00
Varming &
Mulcachy 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 548.95 0.00 0.00
General distribution 0.00 0.00 0.00 343.17 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,066.58 0.00 0.00 0.00
Roadmakers
Limited 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 297.06 0.00 0.00
Interest 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 9.02 21.78 0.00 0.00
Cheque book 0.00 0.39 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
0.00 9,152.67 5,057.22 2,174.13 4,237.56 655.29 5,988.44 10,420.32 18,225.38 15,706.25 0.00 18,518.62
Debts owed to
industrial schools 0.00 0.00 0.00 3,809.21 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 7,618.43 0.00 0.00
Lodged to account 0.00 0.00 0.00 2,022.25 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
CLOSING BANK -
BALANCE 14,237.95 5,986.19 928.97 31.30 105.26 725.33 5,263.12 -4,565.03 -3,300.05 -7,075.04 -91.36 -937.96
DIFFERENCE 0.01 634.88 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.00 2.44 0.12 0.38 -0.12 0.19
November 2007
APPENDIX XVI : DAINGEAN
INCOME AND EXPENDITURE 1940-1969

November 2007
Income and Expenditure

1940 1941 1942 1943 1944 1945 1946 1947 1948 1949 1950 1951 1952
€ € € € € € € € € € € € €
Receipts
Government & Council Grants 5,911 12,806 12,736 13,980 14,468 13,839 12,381 10,548 13,608 13,075 14,435 16,033 18,411
Farm Sales 618 844 1,305 1,348 1,260 1,935 977 1,273 1,555 1,595 2,104 2,598 4,185
Stipends 146 309 450 422 289 429 470 415 445 535 607 751 839
Sundry Sales 38 28 21 17 0 0 12 0 0 0 0 44 0
Shop (Boys) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Other 83 295 52 4,551 149 1,237 620 233 828 99 66 89 91
6,795 14,281 14,563 20,317 16,166 17,440 14,460 12,470 16,435 15,304 17,212 19,516 23,525
Payments
Farm 812 2,148 2,247 1,868 2,579 2,963 2,039 1,611 2,093 2,523 5,833 2,214 3,455
Clothing Items (including
Repairs) 407 1,408 1,645 2,614 2,439 1,157 1,449 668 1,423 1,710 1,164 1,286 2,281
Shoe-making 313 630 462 688 655 598 867 439 560 635 496 1,068 591
Furnishing and Carpentry 130 673 622 1,385 1,256 1,309 660 964 1,489 1,624 1,395 1,877 2,378
Payments to the Province 0 1,905 2,286 3,174 2,032 2,539 2,539 1,803 2,539 1,270 952 1,270 1,905
Car, Lorry and Freight 122 296 380 205 798 278 552 376 524 669 799 676 982
Rent and Insurance 0 729 492 521 656 578 572 567 557 610 609 658 719
Rates, Taxes, and Insurance 57 168 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Dietary Expenses 1,338 3,350 2,687 2,832 3,007 3,418 3,229 2,665 2,873 2,682 3,048 4,439 5,020
Medical 251 284 305 363 374 510 277 322 373 613 661 484 805
Coal, gas, water and lighting 1,146 1,183 821 531 806 918 665 436 573 636 607 1,069 1,113
Wages 377 721 744 926 992 992 1,012 1,175 1,213 1,554 1,597 1,745 1,992
Other 384 453 699 743 6,781 1,501 1,186 1,632 1,138 1,984 873 932 2,501
5,337 13,946 13,389 15,849 22,374 16,760 15,047 12,657 15,354 16,508 18,034 17,717 23,743
Surplus/(Deficit) 1,458 335 1,174 4,468 -6,208 680 -587 -187 1,081 -1,204 -822 1,799 -218
November 2007
Income and Expenditure Continued

1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964
€ € € € € € € € € € € €
Receipts
Government & Council Grants 17,190 15,005 14,983 16,415 16,026 18,618 24,587 14,435 24,062 26,972 20,473 24,184
Farm Sales 4,705 5,049 4,846 0 4,640 0 4,319 2,104 7,215 8,606 11,242 3,686
Stipends 728 779 797 0 605 0 705 607 747 743 800 383
Sundry Sales 0 0 0 4,647 0 6,490 0 0 0 0 0 0
Shop (Boys) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Other 104 141 127 781 0 649 803 66 1,100 730 686 331
22,727 20,974 20,754 21,843 21,271 25,757 30,413 17,212 33,124 37,051 33,200 28,583
Payments
Farm 3,810 3,994 3,802 3,375 0 5,289 4,928 5,833 8,559 6,633 6,867 5,137
Repairs) 1,687 1,245 1,054 1,284 1,179 1,460 3,880 1,164 3,284 3,573 3,122 3,029
Shoe-making 677 957 0 796 1,079 1,162 0 496 0 0 0 0
Furnishing and Carpentry 2,101 1,550 1,925 1,765 2,121 2,376 3,312 1,395 3,845 4,156 2,450 0
Payments to the Province 1,270 2,539 1,905 1,270 1,270 0 1,270 952 2,539 2,539 2,539 2,539
Car, Lorry and Freight 1,969 620 920 2,144 2,057 1,740 45 799 0 11 0 3,645
Rent and Insurance 996 368 0 717 825 947 1,240 0 0 0 0 0
Rates, Taxes, and Insurance 0 422 715 0 0 0 0 609 1,305 890 1,197 1,064
Dietary Expenses 4,166 4,864 4,963 4,311 4,396 5,065 7,440 3,048 7,141 6,549 5,592 7,426
Medical 432 603 905 807 914 1,048 585 661 1,309 684 934 0
Coal, gas, water and lighting 945 961 1,058 1,391 1,540 1,855 2,751 607 3,280 3,248 3,374 7,146
Wages 2,240 2,413 2,967 1,505 2,433 2,508 2,812 1,597 4,118 4,292 830 428
Other 1,102 1,330 541 912 4,592 2,762 1,440 873 1,468 1,535 7,043 7,405
21,395 21,865 20,754 20,277 22,407 26,212 29,702 18,034 36,850 34,111 33,948 37,821
Surplus/(Deficit) 1,332 -891 0 1,566 -1,136 -455 711 -822 -3,726 2,940 -748 -9,238
November 2007
Income and Expenditure Continued

1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 TOTAL
€ € € € € €
Receipts
Government & Council Grants 23,726 26,454 24,394 27,848 26,011 533,614
Farm Sales 9,722 10,079 10,004 0 11,028 118,840
Stipends 2,318 2,347 1,382 0 0 19,049
Sundry Sales 0 0 776 0 0 12,073
Shop (Boys) 973 743 556 704 262 3,237
Other 953 1,110 1,174 15,320 7,604 40,069
37,692 40,734 38,285 43,872 44,905 726,881
Payments
Farm 9,825 7,145 7,169 12,035 13,462 140,248
Repairs) 3,572 3,596 3,086 1,896 1,207 58,969
Shoe-making 0 0 0 0 0 13,169
Furnishing and Carpentry 4,336 5,613 5,377 4,932 4,971 67,987
Payments to the Province 2,539 2,539 0 0 0 49,926
Car, Lorry and Freight 0 0 0 0 0 20,604
Rent and Insurance 1,221 1,286 0 1,828 1,607 18,301
Rates, Taxes, and Insurance 0 0 953 0 0 7,380
Dietary Expenses 6,142 6,549 8,235 10,010 10,138 146,620
Medical 2,118 2,184 1,295 992 926 22,018
Coal, gas, water and lighting 3,303 3,254 4,181 4,492 3,668 57,559
Wages 4,368 5,056 65 6,250 9,535 68,455
Other 4,918 3,787 1,677 4,077 7,082 73,351
42,341 41,009 32,038 46,512 52,596 744,587

Surplus/(Deficit) -4,649 -275 6,247 -2,640 -7,691 -17,706
November 2007
APPENDIX XVII :
NUMBERS OF CHILDREN IN
INDUSTRIAL SCHOOLS AND REFORMATORIES
1939 - 1969
November 2007
Industrial Schools Reformatory Schools

Total in % of % of % of All Sch as % Total in
Year Artane Upton % of total Ferryhouse Goldenbridge Daingean % of total
Ind Sch. total total total of total Ref Sch.
1939 6145 772 12.56% 105 1.71% 166 2.70% 139 2.26% 19.24%
1940 6180 820 13.27% 106 1.72% 159 2.57% 148 2.39% 19.95% 222
1941 6765 817 12.08% 136 2.01% 162 2.39% 142 2.10% 18.58% 221
1942 6889 817 11.86% 171 2.48% 161 2.34% 149 2.16% 18.84% 223
1943 6699 810 12.09% 217 3.24% 167 2.49% 153 2.28% 20.11% 280 240 85.71%
1944 6525 820 12.57% 207 3.17% 168 2.57% 147 2.25% 20.57% 288 236 81.94%
1945 6400 820 12.81% 213 3.33% 165 2.58% 146 2.28% 21.00% 273 224 82.05%
1946 6510 811 12.46% 211 3.24% 170 2.61% 146 2.24% 20.55% 237 199 83.76%
1947 6346 797 12.56% 189 2.98% 171 2.69% 150 2.36% 20.60% 209 178 84.93%
1948 6367 830 13.04% 177 2.78% 193 3.03% 148 2.32% 21.17% 248 206 83.06%
1949 6117 803 13.13% 142 2.32% 185 3.02% 148 2.42% 20.89% 245 201 82.04%
1950 5984 776 12.97% 136 2.27% 179 2.99% 148 2.47% 20.71% 210 175 83.21%
1951 5844 749 12.82% 129 2.21% 178 3.05% 150 2.57% 20.64% 214 178 83.18%
1952 5679 732 12.89% 115 2.03% 193 3.40% 154 2.71% 21.02% 198 177 89.27%
1953 5448 696 12.78% 121 2.22% 198 3.63% 158 2.90% 21.53% 175 152 86.86%
1954 5128 739 14.41% 114 2.22% 188 3.67% 151 2.94% 23.24% 173 142 82.08%
1955 4883 650 13.31% 128 2.62% 187 3.83% 161 3.30% 23.06% 157 130 82.59%
1956 4470 630 14.09% 181 4.05% 192 4.30% 161 3.60% 26.04% 172 166 96.51%
1957 4308 496 11.51% 124 2.88% 184 4.27% 163 3.78% 22.45% 208 163 78.25%
1958 4135 426 10.30% 130 3.14% 195 4.72% 166 4.01% 22.18% 192 154 80.21%
1959 3994 446 11.17% 216 5.41% 195 4.88% 158 3.96% 25.41% 208 172 82.81%
1960 3805 421 11.06% 190 4.99% 187 4.91% 161 4.23% 25.20% 226 187 82.52%
1961 3686 395 10.72% 195 5.29% 186 5.05% 163 4.42% 25.47% 205 181 88.29%
1962 3517 367 10.44% 190 5.40% 163 4.63% 190 5.40% 25.87% 177 146 82.34%
1963 3240 341 10.52% 169 5.22% 161 4.97% 176 5.43% 26.14% 154 117 75.76%
1964 2969 319 10.74% 148 4.98% 141 4.75% 194 6.53% 27.01% 175 129 73.57%
1965 2708 314 11.60% 126 4.65% 135 4.99% 174 6.43% 27.66% 138 108 78.02%
1966 2456 307 12.50% 85 3.46% 141 5.74% 165 6.72% 28.42% 145 119 82.24%
1967 2120 298 14.06% 0 0.00% 170 8.02% 147 6.93% 29.01% 132 107 80.68%
1968 1831 230 12.56% 0 0.00% 138 7.54% 139 7.59% 27.69% 151 104 68.54%
1969 1271 50 3.93% 0 0.00% 159 12.51% 141 11.09% 27.54% 100 92 92.00%
November 2007
APPENDIX XVIII :
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
OF
SCHOOLS EXPENDITURE
November 2007
Goldenbridge
Average Average Average Average
5 Year Intervals 1951 - 55 1956 - 60 1961 - 65 1966 - 70
% % % %
Provisions 39,328 53% 30,801 44% 54,177 48% 42,631 29%
Operational Expenses 291 0% 950 1% 2,087 2% 2,414 2%
Building Related Expenditure 13,512 18% 17,381 24% 21,562 19% 62,911 42%
Capital Expenditure 2,580 3% 5,266 7% 5,964 5% 8,741 6%
Recreational 258 0% 289 0% 912 1% 1,872 1%
Salaries 17,858 24% 15,026 21% 25,297 22% 25,413 17%
Traveling 277 1% 1,189 2% 2,218 2% 3,484 2%
Professional and Financial Related Expenses 205 0% 41 0% 193 0% 60 0%
Donations & Religious Related Expenses 16 0% 381 1% 554 1% 720 1%
Sundry Expenses 425 1% 183 0% - 0% 3 0%
Totals 74,750 71,506 112,965 148,251

November 2007
Artane
Total
Total Total Total Total Total
Average Average Average Average Average 1966 - Average
5 Year Intervals 1941 - 1946 - 1951 - 1956 - 1961 -
% % % % % 71 (5 %
45 50 55 60 65
yrs)
Provisions
35,723 16.2% 49,744 16.5% 81,023 19% 82,209 19% 106,051 20% 118,295 26%
Operational
Expenses 64,897 29.5% 96,442 32.1% 159,356 36% 123,535 28% 101,827 19% 56,129 12%
Building Related
Expenditure 33,819 15.4% 44,333 14.7% 46,888 11% 52,014 12% 67,826 13% 65,652 15%
Capital
Expenditure 2,684 1.2% 3,216 1.1% 9,336 2% 29,832 7% 106,617 20% 60,370 13%
Recreational
1,763 0.8% 2,430 0.8% 5,026 1% 8,046 2% 12,725 2% 29,055 6%
Salaries
70,263 31.9% 68,673 22.8% 81,681 19% 86,548 20% 86,269 16% 80,091 18%
Traveling
510 0.2% 608 0.2% 290 0% 201 0% 403 0% 721 0%
Professional and
Financial Related
Expenses 45 0.0% 1,617 0.5% 3,893 1% 688 0% 124 0% 83 0%
Donations &
Religious Related
Expenses 9,690 4.4% 32,595 10.8% 43,800 10% 50,536 12% 48,758 9% 27,807 6%
Sundry Expenses
817 0.4% 1,116 0.4% 5,595 1% 5,733 21% 9,618 1% 13,706 4%
Total
220,211 300,774 436,886 439,342 540,216 451,910
November 2007
An Daingean
Total
Total Average Total Average Total Average Total Average Total Average 1966- Average
5 Year Intervals 1941 - 45 % 1946 - 50 % 1951 - 55 % 1956 - 60 % 1961-1965 % 1969 %
Provisions 29,426 36% 26,180 34% 37,526 36% 40,777 35% 54,475 29% 50,114 29%
Operational
Expenses 12,581 15% 15,807 20% 21,052 19% 23,714 20% 37,021 20% 39,811 23%
Building Related
Expenditure 7,834 10% 6,878 9% 9,895 10% 14,615 12% 26,028 14% 21,269 12%
Capital Expenditure 6,445 8% 7,185 9% 9,832 9% 10,968 10% 14,787 8% 20,893 12%
Recreational 1,078 1% 1,362 2% 1,272 1% 2,009 2% - 0% - 0%
Salaries 4,373 5% 6,551 8% 11,356 10% 10,855 9% 14,036 8% 20,906 12%
Traveling 2,497 3% 3,733 5% 6,305 6% 8,006 7% 3,656 2% - 0%

Professional and
Financial Related
Expenses 63 0% - 0% - 0% - 0% - 0% - 0%
Donations &
Religious Related
Expenses 13,560 17% 9,860 13% 8,237 9% 5,358 5% 12,695 7% 2,539 2%
Sundry Expenses 4,460 5% 46 0% - 0% 330 0% 22,369 12% 16,623 10%
Totals 82,319 77,600 105,475 116,632 185,067 172,155

November 2007
Upton
Total
1952 - Total
53& Average 1962 - Average
5 Year Intervals
1960 - % 66 (5 %
61 yrs)
(4yrs)
Provisions 43,330 34% 51,193 22%
Operational Expenses 25,643 20% 40,520 17%
Building Related
7,326 6% 15,050 6%
Expenditure
Capital Expenditure 11,314 9% 60,310 26%
Recreational 2,280 2% 8,402 4%
Salaries 13,781 11% 13,871 6%
Traveling 4,604 3% 4,180 2%
Professional and
Financial Related 5,176 4% 692 0%
Expenses
Donations & Religious
4,553 3% 16,262 7%
Related Expenses
Sundry Expenses 9,604 8% 21,444 9%
Total 127,610 100% 231,925 100%
November 2007
Ferryhouse
Average Average Average
(4 yrs) (5 yrs) (4 yrs)
% % %
1951 - 1960 - 1966 -
5 Year Intervals
54 65 69
Provisions 39% 39% 27%
33,498 68,405 56,715
Operational Expenses 9,988 12% 15% 13%
26,758 27,162
Building Related
9% 12% 15%
Expenditure 7,567 19,925 31,260
Capital Expenditure 14% 7% 24%
11,930 11,452 49,123
Recreational 1% 0% 0%
892 1,007 1,402
Salaries 13% 7% 8%
11,003 11,718 16,201
Traveling 1% 4% 3%
977 6,218 5,909
Professional and
Financial Related 3% 1% 97 0%
2,494 1,304
Expenses
Donations & Religious
5% 6% 5%
Related Expenses 4,565 10,030 10,155
Sundry Expenses 3% 9% 5%
2,637 14,999 10,474
Total 85,551 100% 171,817 100% 208,498 100%
November 2007
APPENDIX XIX : STATE APPROPRIATION ACCOUNTS
VOTE ON INDUSTRIAL AND REFORMATORY SCHOOLS

November 2007
Vote on Reformatory and Industrial Schools (€)
Parental
Reformatory Industrial Places of Conveyance Moneys - Building & Appropriation
Sub Total Total
Schools Schools Dentention Expenses Collection Equipment Grant in Aid
Expenses
1939 4,726.73 134,720.99 503.62 167.30 502.84 - 140,621.48 2,554.21 138,067.27
1940 6,349.43 140,168.96 537.12 196.06 493.24 - 147,744.81 3,516.59 144,228.22
1941 10,772.27 145,236.87 603.68 364.50 37.81 - 157,015.13 3,936.99 153,078.14
1942 8,143.54 147,267.85 584.07 305.25 420.89 - 156,721.60 4,189.27 152,532.33
1943 8,339.17 148,478.73 719.56 559.23 444.04 - 158,540.73 4,734.63 153,806.10
1944 9,203.24 150,496.72 1,372.66 602.73 453.70 - 162,129.05 5,723.20 156,405.85
1945 10,093.52 157,610.86 1,680.49 530.15 551.35 - 170,466.37 7,460.80 163,005.57
1946 - - - - - - - - -
1947 8,999.84 159,838.20 1,709.38 354.66 659.88 21,479.09 193,041.05 10,836.35 182,204.70
1948 7,454.48 147,748.40 1,879.17 519.49 781.88 18,529.85 176,913.27 10,689.89 166,223.38
1949 10,732.46 199,790.72 2,190.36 357.67 941.80 11,756.00 225,769.01 12,059.63 213,709.38
1950 - - - - - - - - -
1951 9,803.06 188,350.25 2,323.49 390.61 1,005.53 5,068.20 206,941.14 12,054.24 194,886.90
1952 11,657.95 231,652.86 2,595.99 436.07 996.44 784.76 248,124.07 9,340.04 238,784.03
1953 13,829.43 284,801.11 2,661.89 439.94 910.07 - 302,642.44 8,445.03 294,197.41
1954 10,917.21 272,621.65 2,830.25 476.15 1,024.68 - 287,869.94 7,878.00 279,991.94
1955 11,529.22 257,378.45 3,301.32 570.11 996.74 - 273,775.84 6,915.00 266,860.84
1956 10,615.01 242,566.95 2,985.15 407.59 1,010.71 - 257,585.41 5,984.00 251,601.41
1957 11,082.27 229,152.17 3,679.70 384.73 912.94 - 245,211.81 5,172.00 240,039.81
1958 12,843.40 216,336.70 3,448.61 631.06 1,460.20 - 234,719.97 6,899.00 227,820.97
1959 16,570.08 283,503.31 3,753.35 523.13 998.01 - 305,347.88 4,603.00 300,744.88
1960 18,832.76 299,599.78 3,990.79 615.82 1,053.88 - 324,093.03 4,482.00 319,611.03
1961 - - - - - - - - -
1962 - - - - - - - - -
1963 17,222.73 259,486.21 6,914.99 539.64 703.43 - 284,867.00 4,979.00 279,888.00
1964 14,344.23 241,910.50 8,544.07 647.57 799.93 - 266,246.30 4,610.00 261,636.30
November 2007
Vote on Reformatory and Industrial Schools Continued (€)
Parental
Building &
Reformatory Industrial Places of Conveyance Moneys - Appropriation
Equipment Sub Total Total
Schools Schools Dentention Expenses Collection in Aid
Grant
Expenses
1965 - - - - - - - - -
1966 19,369.85 297,114.90 8,839.92 634.87 584.08 - 326,543.62 3,710.00 322,833.62
1967 21,167.80 282,653.85 8,696.44 834.22 547.26 - 313,899.57 3,514.00 310,385.57
1968 20,371.68 245,395.93 10,531.21 810.09 500.28 - 277,609.19 2,706.00 274,903.19
1969 24,036.14 246,523.46 10,590.89 954.84 432.98 - 282,538.31 2,441.00 280,097.31
Total 329,007.51 5,610,406.38 97,468.18 13,253.49 19,224.61 57,617.90 6,126,978.07 159,433.87 5,967,544.20
Note: No records were available for the years 1946, 1950, 1961 – 1962 and 1965.
November 2007
APPENDIX XX : EXPENDITURE CATEGORISATION
FOR COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS

November 2007
Expenditure Category Details
Provisions Provisions purchased, food, clothing, medical

expenses, laundry and cleaning, aftercare,
shoe making and bootshop
Operational Expenses Industrial departments, farm poultry and
garden, sweet shop and store, stationery,
telegraph, telephone, postage, books for
schoolrooms and library,
Building Related Expenditure Ordinary repairs and decorations, fuel, light,
power, rent, rates, taxes, insurance,
classrooms and payments to council
Capital Expenditure Expenditure on building works, furniture,
fittings, machinery and hardware
Recreational Band expenses, games, awards,
entertainment and holidays
Salaries Salaries, wages, insurance and stamps
Traveling Travelling expenses, car and lorry & freight.
Professional and Financial Related Expenses Bank charges, interest, solicitors fees and
valuer’s fees
Stipends & Religious Related Expenses Stipends, transfer to community account,
donations and payments to priests
Sundry Expenses Other expenses and petty cash
November 2007
APPENDIX XXI :
Provision of Accounts to the Department of Education

Appendix A
In the course of an application for financial assistance in relation to the operation of

Glencree Reformatory School, the Oblate Order submitted accounts to the Department
on 1 9 May
~ ~ 1939 for the fifteen months ended on the 31StMarch 1939.
Correspondence in relation to this application including the submitted accounts is held

on file FPl2.
On lothJuly 1945, the Minister requested the Association to provide audited accounts
to the Department. Records indicate that statements were received from twenty-one
Industrial Schools by 2oLhFebruary 1946. A list of the twenty-one schools concerned
is attached as Appendix B. The Department no longer holds copies of the statements
received. c - 4 d.,
-.F
Correspondence in relation to this application is held on file G007BVoll
On gth April 1947, the Department requested each school to submit detailed
statements of its income and expenditure for the year ending 31S'March 1947.
Records indicate that statements of Income and Expenditure were received from all
Industrial Schools by 1'' August 1947. The Department no longer holds copies of the
statements received but holds a summary financial statgrnent created at the time which
lists the schools concemed. A copy of this summary financial statement is attached as
Appendix C.
Correspondence in relation to this application is held on file G007BVoll.
On 61h July 1950, the Minister requested the Association to provide statements of
accounts from the individual schools for the periods ended 31'' December 1949 andlor
31SLMarch 1950.
On 21" July 1950, statements of accounts for the financial year 1949 in respect of
forty-two Industrial Schools and one Reformatory School (St. Conleth's, Daingean)
were submitted to the Department. The Department no longer holds copies of the
statements received but holds a summary financial statement created at the time which
lists the schools concemed. A copy of this summary financial statement is attached as
Appendix D.
Correspondence in relation to this application is held on file G007BVoll

In connection with an application made in February 1953 by the Resident Manager's
Association for an increase in the rate of grant, the Department, on 1" January 1954,
requested each Industrial School to submit detailed statements of its income and
expenditure for each of the three years ended 31S' December 1951, 1952 and 1953.
Accounts were received from nine schools on unrecorded dates in early 1954. A list
of the nine schools concerned is attached as Appendiv E. There is no record to
indicate if accounts were received from any other schools other than the .nine schools
listed. However, in a letter to the Minister dated circa loth February 1954, the
Resident Managers Association stated that "it was decided that it was impossible to
compile accounts as asked for".
Correspondence in relation to this application is held on file G007BVo12. The

accounts for the nine schools are held on file G007(C).
On 181h May 1955, the Association submitted statements of accounts for an unknown
number of schools. There is no record on file outlining a request for these accounts.
The Department no longer holds copies of the statements of accounts received.
Records indicate that the Department was unwilling to accept these statements of
account in the format presented and they were returned to the Association on 24'h
October 1955.
On 7'h November 1955, the Resident Managers Association submitted accounts for
twenty-two Lndustrial Schools. The Department no longer holds copies of the
accounts received. Following an examination of'-related records on file, the
Department is not in a position to confirm the identity of twenty-two schools for
which accounts were submitted.
Correspondence in relation to this application is held on file G007BVo12.
On 24thJanuary 1962, the Department requested the Association to submit income and
expenditure accounts for the previous year in respect of six representative but
unnamed schools. On 5thMarch 1962, the Resident Managers Association submitted
statements of account to the Department in respect of nine Industrial Schools. A list
of the nine-schools concerned is attached as Appendix F.
Correspondence in relation to this application including the statements of accounts

received is held on file G007.
On 2nd December 1964, the Resident Managers Association presented a two-page

tabular financial statement in support of an application for an increase in the rate of
grant payable. This tabular financial statement provided summary information
regarding the financial position of twenty-one schools for the years 1962 and 1963. A
copy of this tabular financial statement is attached as Appendix G.
Correspondence in relation to this application is held on file G007.

-
L
rL'
IHDDB~W. BlXML8 (8anior Bogs)

n
8 i u a t m i a l position - T e a r i/4,U - 3 / 3 / 4 7 (mm d i m ~ o e e &
i n B t a t a m a n t a or A c c o u D t s
I mtmittsd by Yanagars. ) -
Daf La l t
WO. or Bscaipta Sxpsnmom Lose POr Ponvrlcl
asha01 Oblldra~ head
Wr
Waak
a. d .
E a d e a d E . P -
Opton H6 W9.iq.3 9,696. 8 . Ic 376.17. l. - 8 Ihis m h o o l ham an o v s l d W t

ores A?2,500 a s wall m m s l o r a
f o r b u i l d i n g purposan i r u tha
Order of n a n r b E 9 , 0 0 0 .
g - - This m b o o l i s n o t oouductsd
a
Baltimore 135 5,U3. l l 5,160.16.
tb. m t l m f a o t i o m or t h e Daprt--
~ n t . I t h. a dobt o f L 3 , W
r h i o h t h e man.gumant a r e
e t v l a a r o u r i n g t o r e d u c e hY s t r i o l
s O o D 0 ~ .
Bresamonnt m 10,070.19.k 11,129.7.5 1,058.8.1 1.0 Srpondi~mLnaludemcoatof

u a F n b n m n o a Qo. o f B a h o o l B b Z i .
a n d soh001 s t a f f
of 1 6 Inooma i n o l u d a a g r s n t e r r o m
P r b ~ gBranch p a i d t o m r s b e r n
or EIO~IOO~ etarr.
I
~rtane
-- . -
m5
sod soh001 staff
- --- , & 51
42.153. 4. 3 46,612-10.10 4,459.14. 7 2. 0
l
hi;
I
9Lmnoial p o s i t i o n - Y e e r l/W - 31/3/47 ( s s disclosed i n Btatarnentu o f
Aooounta # u b m i t t e d by ~ s n a g a r a ) .
4,317.10.11 5,291.1.0 RJ.IO.I 2. 9 his s c h o o l b a g a l e 0 a d e b t or E800 for

e a h o o l r a p b l r s c a r r i e d o u t i n t h e laat
3 Years.
3,578. 0. 5 3,854. 9.tO '276. 9- 5 i. 9
2,064. 9. 3 2,549.16. 9 4a5. 7. 6 3. 6 -1
11 1/ I1 ;: II
4,22.-13. 5 4,h80.-3. 9 251.10. 4 1. 0 P a m n t t a o h s d t o C o n v a n t f r o m which i s
m a p p l i e d v a ~ t a b l e ~ . r n i l end
k ogge t o
I n d u s t r i a l Bchool s t o u r r a n t a s r k a t p r l a s m .
6,IU. 4- 9 "7-47. b. 5 l"019 8, a eI bI tLn~~acm

T t iandgont o 31/3/47
h oouon) h - 4-
e i ,641. o 1u t s t s n a i n a
4,567. 5.10 6.427. 4.11, 1,859.19. I
3,545. 5. 9 4,618.11.6 1,073. 5. 9 . 3 fnoludsd i n t h e a r p o n d l t u m for t h i n soh001
3,418.10.' 6 . 3,U0.16. 6 -
e t t h e bagtnning of t h s yaer.
Hanagemoat e t e t s t h e y bad a c o n a l d e r a b l a
stook of a-mr c l o t h i n g , b e d d i n g &c.
1
I
E x p a n s a s d o n o t i o o l u d e d e b t s or E387.5.1
for pmvisions.
P h l s e a h o o l h e a a n o u t a t s n d i n g d e b t of
E200.
T h i n soh001 . p o t approxlmetaly EJ.200 on
b u l l d i n g e n d r c p a i r a during t h e y a a r . It
b e e o o u t s t a n d i n g dabt of fi3.250.9.7.
T h i e s c h o o l had c o n ~ i d a r a b l o ~ t o c k aof
pro-rar o L o t h i n 3 m e t o r i a l o n hande w h i c h
e r e now n a a r l y s x h s u e t a d .
F i a s n c i ~ lp o a l t i o n - Yow 1/4/46 - 31/3/47 (Be d i s o l o e s d i n B t a t a m e n t s o f Accounta
e u t m i t t e d by Yenagora).
no. o r norici t
BOI1[XIL chil~ran Xmaaiptr Erpansaa Gem p a r hand Ramsrkn
par m a t .
-
E r d E a d E a d re d
Benmdn A b h y 100 L,706.11. 0 6,560. 7,[1 1,853.16. 1 7. 1. I r ~ o o d i t u r ai o a l u d a a an i t e m
of E727 f o r e l a o t r i o a l l n a t a l l -
ationa.
B l i p 199 8,952. l. 3 8,682. 2. 7 - - Phia echoal shwa a o r a d l t

b n l ~ n c aof E269.18. 8.
~emplemom 9 2,282. 9. 7 2,350. 8. 8' 67.1 7. l 5

Camha1 113 4.4~4.19.0 4,601.17. 8 116.18. 8 5
Duwata. 74 2.907.16- 4 3,455-10. 0 547.13. 0 2.10
Taterrod 160 6,992.16. 7 7,798-16. 805.19; 5 i.I+
Yoata 56 2,311 6. 4 2.6-16. 7. 1 305. -. 9 2. 1 Tbie school m b t e a that slnoa

1939 th& e x p a n d i t u r a e r a a b .
t h a i r inooma by a n era*
250 per snnum.
New Ro BB 87 3,559.1lkIO 3,355-13. 8 - - T h i n m o o 1 ahawe a o r a d l t b a l a n o a
f o r t h e p a r t o d u n d e r rariam of
E.4. 1. 2
304. 5 . 2 1. 3 T h i s school report. bhet t h a l $
lisbillttcs oxcood t h o l r a w s s t #
by E< ,265.15.7. Thsy e t e t a t h a t
t h e i r r i n a o a l a l p o s i t i o n would
bu much mare uuravourmbla wars I t
n o t f o r t h e i r f o r a a l g h t in
pumhaeing lnrm u e n t t t i a s o f
c o a l aI7d a e r a e l s ? r i o a . s s g v &c)
p r i o r t o t h a war and d u r i n g t h e
e a r l y p a r t or 1940. Large ~ t o o k u
o r c l o t t i i o & and f o o t w a s r l a m a l e 0
obtalncd during t h i e p a r i d .
T h e s e stocka, i t i s s t a t e d , e r a
now n a a r l y c x h a u a t o d .
l
0: S" ,
aim*
IOOIID* h lm~ ~ml)
'1 '0 '67 'TWL -*I 'f 'LrQ'TT 9 '5qL.6 L61
OY JO
rrnr m
P D W * mDo1oQl)
- -G -r -*n -@nz 01 -I -V(R'SI .E -v -curnc su
I
7'6I-rRL5-3
m 6 Y N U us
Bsyama- aw-a sq;
U1 .O=@I.U 7 190C I.; I
:2t:::A:Zew:; :
'
, ..lT'bP1 J0J POP (6 JO JJ-l*
. ~ . n - m 6DI ~ ~mm- ! , Toor- *.(~TO~T)
r ~ I I P P . a: . OT-S .B 7 '2- 7 h
. .oTtl'51 'E '61 -'
' L N '-. roz ~~1911.s
[.iSk*3* I
loos,. ..pllao,)
-?-v -6 '01 -rw ot .rr -*IzrSn . 7 .r -r?sSc-, 291 U00JJJ.73~ +
! '
ZI a0
u.2. pqo. PO.
- 2 , '1 '1 '6WI 'T ST
T I 'M' 'T1 'P '026'ZK / <v1 I .eTl)TJ*.C
! I
0 R ' N
t
W
r\
m
rl
I
d rl N
4 A
v
C
m 6
N
P- U d
r-
m Y)
3 f r-
fi
0
D
d
D
0 H
.
C . S 0 0
U 0- 0 m
m 0 0 0 D ' 0
C 4 3 W- m-
m l~ m w zr
OEg 4
C
.
, ocb+ TC N m
L L P - r D 0-0 o m u m c r
$zCJ Tr, "7cl FIG
Q 0
BC
3 0
S,-.&c
52
:: 0
" K !
C L
o m
c-
&+%
,,a urn
U- m zm E-
4 9
C 4
.-m
114
(lnoludlng ~ c b o o l
staff o f 6 )
79
(loolu3lng school
e t e f E of 4 )
1 127
(inolu31ng s c h o o l
a t e i f or 7)
( i n c l u d i n g echo01
etsff of 3) t h l e School h a s
outatsrding debts
o f 23143.
100
(Inolu3i o g s c h o o l
~ u r p l \ ae359.3. -.
e t e r r of 6 )
59 Hae n d e b t o f S2000
( i n c l u d i n g oohool o o n t m c t a d i n 1947
e t s f f of 6 ) tor houeehold
r s q u l a i t s s which i s
still outatending.
Thle s c h o o l hsa s I
B a t overdralt o f
,126250n n d owes
e7ooo in ru.eepact
of b u i l d i n g
lmpmvs~nenta cbrrled
o u t In 1949 and .
1950.
3 U,. U,
U ) .
\o
U) m m
I.-- I , .I- .b. L" ..( ., , ,
Schools for which accounts were received on 5' March 1962
School
I Artane Industrial School, Dublin
2 Upton Industrial School, Cork
3 Letterfrack Industrial School, Galway
4 Lakelands Industrial School. Dublin
5 Moate Industrial School, Westmeath
6 St. George's Industrial School, Limerick
7 St. Patrick's Industrial School, Kilkenny
8 Drogheda Industrial School. Louth
9 St. Kyran's lndustrial School. Rathdrurn. Wicklow
November 2007
APPENDIX XXII
Proposed 1951 Review

November 2007
Appendix XXII – Proposed Review 1951
The documents that we have identified in relation to the proposed review of the schools in
1951 are as follows:
Reference Description
CBMIN-045/1 Letter to Department which records the principle objections as

being:
• Terms of inquiry are too wide
• Objection to the organisation and conduct of the schools
being examined
Noted that there was no objection to authorised officials of the
Department visiting in their usual capacity
CBMIN-051/1 Letter from Secretary advising RMA of proposed Enquiry
CBMIN-052/1 Letter reporting consideration of the proposal – “inspection could
serve no good purpose”
CBMIN-053/2 Circular from Dept. summarising the proposal (2 March 1951)
CBMIN-054/1 Resident Managers response 7 March 1951. The letter notes:
• The RMA welcomes inspection by Department Inspectors
• The proposal is a departure from usual practice
• The terms of reference are vague
• That the RMA would like an explanation of what is meant by
“Conditions and Circumstances”
• That the RMA wish to understand whether the
recommendations of the Commission could restrict the
powers of the Resident Managers
• That the RMA wish to understand whether future grants
would be contingent on acceptance of the
recommendations of the Commission
CBMIN-056/1 Department letter in response (19 March 1951)
CBMIN-058/1 RMA letter (to members) April 1951 regarding the response from
Department. The letter notes:
• Strong opposition to the proposal
• That the inquiry would create an undesirable precedent and
tend towards an extension of State control
CBMIN-059/1 Letter to Department summarising the opposition of the RMA to the
proposal and seeking a meeting to discuss
CBMIN-064/1 Letter summarising a meeting with Minister on 23 April 1951
We also note the internal Department of Education memo dated 24th April 19511 on the
Minister’s Conference on the 23rd of April 1951 with the President and Secretary of the
Industrial and Reformatory School Managers Association.
“Br. Hurley gave as reasons for the Association’s disapproval of the proposed enquiry:-
1) that it was felt that the enquiry reflected on the management of the schools, that the
Association took particular objection to the Departments of Finance and of Social
1
Footnote 171 of the Department of Education and Science’s Statement to the Commission
November 2007
Welfare being associated with the enquiry when the Department of Education was
already fully aware of the circumstances of the schools;
2) It appeared to the Association that the proposed enquiry would be the thin end of the
wedge in an attempt by the State to impose its control on the detailed management of
the schools.
The managers were very satisfied with the present system of inspection and believed that
the present system of management was ideal.
3) They were particularly suspicious of the Department of Social Welfare appearing to

interface in the conduct of the schools and they also objected strongly to the
Department of Finance insisting on this enquiry.
4) The Minister in reply informed them –
i) that the State had no intention whatever of using this enquiry to obtain a further
footing in the schools. His policy was that the State should assist the schools and
once it is satisfied that the work is being done efficiently by the management to
interfere with them as little as possible;
ii) the Managers were mistaken in the view that the enquiry had ever insisted upon
by the Department of Finance. As a matter of fact, he himself had insisted on the
enquiry and only with the greatest reluctance did the Department of Finance
agree to it. What had happened was that the schools were being given only half
the increase they had asked for and he was not prepared to leave the matter
there. One of his objects in this was to bring the officials of the Department of
Finance face to face with the realities in the schools. It had been suggested that
the Department of Social Welfare should also be associated with the enquiry and
he had welcomed this as he regarded this as a potential help in his struggle for a
increase of grants. Fr. Reidy and Br. Hurley stated that this threw a very different
light on the proposal and in these circumstances they, personally, were quite
willing for the proposed enquiry to proceed. It would be necessary, however, for
them to hold a meeting of the managers. They hoped to do this on Friday next but
it may be taken that the managers would now accept the proposal.
Fr. Reidy then asked what would be the nature of the proposed enquiry and the
Minister said that it would cover the physical and general welfare of the pupils,
their training and aftercare subsequent to discharge and above all their food,
clothing and housing. It might be that the Department of Finance representative
would desire that the schools accounts should be available in a uniform form.
The Minister thought for his part that it would scarcely be necessary to visit all of
the schools, that visits to ten or so typical schools would be sufficient. However,
that was a matter for the Committee. The Department’s representative on the
Committee will be the Inspector.”
November 2007
APPENDIX XXIII
Balance Sheets – Upton & Ferryhouse

0 0
3 m
: :. :. : .
; .
: . . p
*e . . . . P 1 S Z
t- : , ' . m
1 e r n
2F : ::
P.
( D . . . . " a o
. .
. . . . . .P *.
. . . . F
. . . . 2
!
jj hg {I-
ll \Q II11
1
l Q
ll-.-.
.- -.. !'-.
November 2007
APPENDIX XXIV:
Documents relating to acquisition of Artane

Typed version of draft conveyance dated 18/07/1870 furnished by Maxwells under
cover of their letter of 14/05/07
This Indenture made on the 18" day of July in the year of our Lord 1870 between
Frances Mary Callaghan of Artane Castle in the county of Dublin Spinster of the one
part and James Aloysius Hoare, Richard Anthony Maxwell, John Augustine Grace,
Patrick Dominick McDonnell and Thomas Alphonsus Hoope all of North Richmond
Street in the city of Dublin hereinafter called the Purchasers of the other part.
Whereas the said Frances Mary Callaghan being seized of an estate in fee simple in
of the lands and heredits hereinafter described hath contracted with the said purchaser
for the sale thereof to them for the sum of £7000 stg. Now this Indenture witnesseth
that in consdn of said sum of £7000 paid by the said purchasers to the said Frances
Mary Callaghan on the execution of these presents the receipt of which sum she doth
hereby admit and from the same doth hereby release the said purchasers their heirs
exors and ags the said Frances Mary Callaghan doth hereby grant unto the said James
,-
Aloysius Hoare, Richard Anthony Maxwell, John Augustine Grace, Patrick Dominick
MCDonnell and Thomas Alphonsis Hoare and their heirs all that and those that part
of the lands of Artane south situated into the Barony of Coolock and County Dublin
containing 54a3r4p statute measure or thereabouts with the mansion house called
Artane Castle and all other buildings standing thereon together with all fixtures
commons waters water courses sewers privileges easements advantages and appurts
whatsoever to the said lands and heredits hereby granted belonging or with the same
or any of them heretofore enjoyed or reputed or known as part thereof or appurtenant
thereto and all the Estate rights title interest use trust property claim and demand
whatsoever of her the said Frances Mary Callaghan in to or out of the same premises.
To have and to hold the said lands heredits and premises unto the said Jarnes Aloysius
Typed version of draft conveyance dated 1810711870 furnished by Maxwells under
Hoare, Richard Anthony Maxwell, John Augustine Grace, Patrick Dominick MC
Donnell, Thomas Anthony Hoope and their heirs to the use of the said James Aloysius
Hoare: Richard Anthony Maxwell, John Augustine Grace, Patrick Dorninick MC
Donnell and Thomas Alphonsus Hoope their heirs and asigns for ever subject to a
certain Indenture of lease of a school house [This is the lease of the existing school
situate on the lands which is to be executed before this lease?] erected on a position of
said premises bearing date the day of 1870 made by the said Frances
Mary Callaghan of the one part and His Eminence Paul Cardinal Cullen and the Very
Reverend Cornelius Canon Rooney of Clontarf in the County of Dublin Roman
Catholic Parish Priest of the other part for the term of years from the
day of at the yearly rent of one shilling payable half yearly on the
day of and day of . And the said Frances Mary Callaghan

doth hereby for herself her heirs exors and admons covenant with the said James A.
Hoare, R.A Maxwell, J.A Grace, P.D McDonnell and T. A Hoope their heirs and
C-
asigns that she the said Frances Mary Callaghan now hath in herself good right, full
power and careful and absolute authority to grant the said lands heredits and premises
to their use and in manner aforesaid and that the same shall be entered upon and
enjoyed and the rents and profits thereof received and taken by the said Purchasers
their heirs and assigns without any lawful interruption by the said Frances Mary
Callaghan or any other person or persons whomsoever free from or by the said
Frances Mary Callaghan her heirs, exors or adrnons indemnified against all estates,
incurnbrances claims and demands whatsoever and further the she the said Frances
Mary Callaghan and every person rightfully claiming any estate right, title or interest
in to or out of the said lands heredits and premises will at all times hereafter at the
request and costs of the said purchasers their heirs and assigns execute and do every
Typed version of draft conveyance dated 18/07/1870 furnished by Maxwells under
such lanrful ?? and thing for the further better and more perfectly ?? the said lands
heredits and premises to the uses and in manner aforesaid as by the said purchasers
their heirs and assigns shall be reasonably required.
In witness whereof
Note: There is an illegible note on page 2 of the draft Conveyance.

Typed version of Memorial h i s h e d by Maxwells under cover of their letter dated
I .
14 May 2007
To the Registrar appointed by an act of Parliament for registering Deeds, Wills and so
forth in Ireland.
A memorial of a conveyance dated the nineteenth day of July in the year of our Lord
one thousand eight hundred and seventy between Frances Mary Callaghan of Artane
Castle in the county of Dublin Spinster of the one part and James Aloysius Hoare,
Richard Anthony Maxwell, John Augustine Grace, Patrick Dominick McDonnell and
Thomas Alphonsus Hoope all of North Richmond Street in the City of Dublin
Gentlemen hereinafter called 'the purchasers' of the other part. Reciting that the said
Frances Mary Callaghan being seized of an estate in fee simple in possession of the
lands and hereditments hereinafter described had contracted with the said purchasers
for the sale thereof to them for the sum of seven thousand pounds sterling said
Indenture witnessed that in consideration of said sum& seven thousand pounds paid
by the said purchasers to the said Frances Mary Callaghan on the execution thereof
she the said Frances Mary Callaghan granted unto the said Jarnes Aloysius Hoare,
Richard Anthony Maxwell, John Augustine Grace, Patrick Dominick McDonnell and
Thomas Alphonsus Hoope and their heirs All that and those that part of the lands of
Artane South situated in the barony of Coolock and County of Dublin containing fifty
four acres three roods and four perches Statute measure or thereabouts with the
mansion house called 'Artane Castle' and all other buildings standing thereon
together with all fixtures commons waters water courses sewars privileges easements
advantages and appurtenances whatsoever to the said lands and hereditaments thereby
granted belonging or with the same or any of them theretofore enjoyed or reputed or
trust property.. . into or out of the same premises To hold the said lands hereditments
and premises unto the said James Aloysius Hoare Richard Anthony Maxwell, John
Augustine Grace, Thomas Dominick McDonnell and Thomas Alphonsus Hoope and
their heirs to the use of the said James Aloysius Hoare, Richard Anthony Maxwell,
John Augustine Grace, Patrick Dominick McDonnell and Thomas Alphonsus Hoope
their heirs and assigns for ever subject to a certain Indenture of lease of a schoolhouse
erected on a portion of the said premises bearing date the thirteenth day of July one
thousand eight hundred and seventy made by the said Frances Mary Callaghan to His
Eminence Paul Cardinal Cullen and The Very Reverend Cornelius Cannon Rooney
of Clontarf in the County of Dublin Roman Catholic Parish Priest for the term of nine
hundred years from the thirteenth day of July one thousand and eight hundred and
seventy at the yearly rent of one shilling payable half yearly on the first day of
January and first day of July and said conveyance of which this is a memorial
contained covenants by said Frances Mary Callaghan for herself, her heirs executors
and administrators for good title quiet enjoyment freedom from incumbrances and
further assurance the execution of which said deed And this by the said Frances Mary
Callaghan By Patrick Maxwell North Great Georges Street in the city of Dublin
Solicitor And by Jarnes Hendley Quinn of Henrietta Street in said city of Cork.
Signed and sealed by the said Frances Mary Callaghan in the presence of Patrick
Maxwell and James Hendley

TYPED VERSION
13458
5 July, 1870
Sir,
With reference to your minute of the 21'' June, re the

accompanying letter, I beg to report that on the 24thultimo I
visited Artane Castle, Co. Dublin, and found it in every way, well
suited for the purposes of an Industrial School for boys. Indeed I
was consulted as to its fitness before the purchase was concluded.
The premises consists of a large dwelling house with extensive

out-offices, garden, farm-yard &c standing on 56 Statute Acres of
rich arable land, well watered, sheltered by fine trees and enclosed
on the North and East by a good wall.
The proposed school is 2 L/z miles from the General Post Office,
Dublin in the Barony of Coolock, Co. Dublin - site being a very
healthy one, not far from the sea on the road to Malahide.
The lands, which are held in fee simple have been purchased for
the purpose of an Industrial School at a cost of £7,000 and it is
proposed to erect additional buildings for Dormitories,
Classrooms, at a further outlay of £1 6,000.
The Industrial School will be managed by the Christian Brothers,

under an influential Committee which will include, amongst
others, the six Gentlemen Members of the Committee of the St.
Mary's Industrial School, Inchicore, Co. Dublin, who applied to
the Chief Secretary to withdraw the Certificate from that
Institution and which the proposed School at Artane is intended to
replace.
This establishment is well adapted for the instruction of boys in

farm-work as well as trades, and I have no doubt that it will be
efficiently carried on.
Very young boys will be cared and trained in other Schools

Managed by females and when of a sufficient age I propose that
they be transferred under 32" Section of the Act to this and
similar Institutions.
An efficient Staff has been selected.

A number of Gentlemen have consented to act as the General
Committee of Management, and from the an executive Committee
will be formed who shall have special charge of the Institution.
Having regard to these facts, I submit that a Certificate be granted.

The School being designated The Artane Industrial School for
Roman Catholic Boys, Dublin.
The Committee is so numerous that it will be unnecessary to

gazette more than the first five names on the list - . . . . . . . . . . . . ...
Cardinal Cullen
Lord 0'1-Iagan
Earl of Granard K.P.
Sir Jarnes Power Bart.
Very Rev. Doctor McCabe V.G.
I have the honour to be

Sir
Your Obt. Servant
John Lentaigne
Inspt.
TYPED VERSION
12570
1 7 Mountjoy Square,
Dublin
20 June 1870
To
The Right Hon.
Chichester Fortescue,
Chief Secretary for Ireland
Dublin Castle.
Sir,
The purchasers of Artane Castle and its Demesne of 56 statute acres of land, situated within
two miles of Dublin, are desirous that you may direct the property to be visited, and reported
upon by the Lnspector of Industrial Schools.
Should his report enable you to certify, that the property, in question, is suitable for the
establishment of an Industrial School for Roman Catholic boys, under the "Lndustrial
Schools' Act", I am to request, on the part of the proposed Committee of Management, that
you will grant the Certificate at your earliest possible convenience.
I have the honour

to remain
Sir,
Your very obt. Servant
Charles Kennedy
Mr Lentaigne

Appendices Final Mar 09 Mazars Report-Irish Government Commission To Inquire Into Child Abuse

Încărcat de

Informații document

Titlu original

Drepturi de autor

Formate disponibile

Partajați acest document

Partajați sau inserați document

Opțiuni de partajare

Vi se pare util acest document?

Este necorespunzător acest conținut?

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

Appendices Final Mar 09 Mazars Report-Irish Government Commission To Inquire Into Child Abuse

Încărcat de

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

COMMISSION TO INQUIRE INTO CHILD ABUSE

REVIEW OF FINANCIAL MATTERS

ADEQUACY OF FUNDING – TABULATED DATA

Data to Support Exhibit 11

CPI Annual Percentage Change

Weekly Capitation Weekly Capitation

Tabulated Data to Support Exhibits 13 – 14

1939 €0.87 €0.95

Average Household Expenditure per Child Index 1965/66 Base &

First Child Second Third Child Average

Weekly Ind. School Weekly Reformatory Avg. Expenditure per

Weekly Ind. Weekly Food Clothing Lodging Other Total

Weekly Weekly Food Clothing Lodging Other € Total €

UK Capitation Grant Data

Scotland - Capitation England & Wales - Capitation

England & Wales - Capitation

Artane Industrial School

Income and Expenditure 1940 – 1969

Bank Charges and Interest - - - - 25 20 27 23 20 720 835

Sundries 17 1 60 249 251 256 166 258 364 175 1,798

Artane Industrial School Income and Expenditure 1950 - 1959

Boys' travelling expenses 97 118 56 57 22 37 10 18 52 60 527

Capital Expenditure - - - 5,988 - - - - - 2,400 2,400

Artane Industrial School Income and Expenditure 1960 – 1969

Brothers Employed in Artane Industrial School 1939 - 1969

Total no. of Teaching

27.10 - 32 17 (SR) 1 (SR) 14

Number of Lay Staff Employed in Artane Industrial School 1939 –

(3 additional personnel may be added each year – the Doctor, Nurse

PER RECORDS PROVIDED BY THE

Number of Brothers employed as Teachers in Artane

APPENDIX VIII : ROSMINIAN FATHERS – UPTON

Income and expenditure 1952-1953

Medical 231 658

Surplus/ Deficit <17> 67

APPENDIX IX : ROSMINIAN FATHERS – UPTON

Income and expenditure 1960-1966

1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966

APPENDIX X : Rosminian Fathers – Ferryhouse

Income and expenditure 1940-1949

1941 1947 Total

APPENDIX XI : Rosminian Fathers – Ferryhouse

Income and expenditure 1950-1959

1951 1952 1953 1954 Total

APPENDIX XII : Rosminian Fathers – Ferryhouse

Income and Expenditure 1960-1969

1960 1961 1962 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969

1960 1961 1962 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969

1960 1961 1962 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969

Submissions from Rosminian Fathers

In the financial context it is important to be aware of the origins and development of

3 ' h f d ' members are those who b e taken vows.

as one who had: "carte-blanch to a good extent during thep v t 25 years in

detrimental financial consequences for Ireland, entailed by such a move. In the

fiom the Government which of itselfwould be imdequute. " To be noted here,

StJoseph's Drumcondra) were regarded: It must be>ernernbered thut the two

He then goes on to ask a question:" T h question is t k n how w i l l h e l d cuny on the

A COPY ofthis extiac! is appended to these notes.

1111fe or no resources to clear it. "

In the course of a letter of 6&December 1957, refemng to a report made by Fr-Torn

$15,000 for Sicily.

On the 14h December 1957, where he comments on a meeting held at Clonmel

(Ferryhouse) of the three ~ r c ~ b ~ t eresident