:

Explaining the Developmental Dynamics of East-Asian

1
Welfare Regime?: Taiwan and South-Korea Compared

[]

1.

2005 /

, 05.6-7.2004.
Kim Won Sub

NSC92-2412-H-194-007


1995
155
""2
3

Solidargemeinschaft

Risikoausgleich

aristocracy

Kwon1997

157

30%: 60%: 10%

2003
Holliday(2001)

/
facilitative
Johnson1982 (MITI and Japanese
Miracle)

(Deyo, 1992)

Haggard and
Kaufmann(2004)

Holliday(2005)

universalist

particularist(Holliday, 2000)

2003 1970

1997

80

(Hort, 2005: 15-16; Haagard

and Kaufmann, 2004)

Hort and Kuhnle (2000)

ISSA (International Social Security Association) Database

Gough(2001) Kwon(2000) 1997

Hort Kuhnle

Esping-Andersen Esping-Anderson

Polanyi

1987

(Hort,
2005)
(Kaufmann and Segura-Ubiergo, 2001)(Nelson, 2001)

(Boix, 2003)4

(Ramesh,
2003)

1986

 97 1988
1995

1964
196519771995

(Kwon, 1997; Goodman and Peng, 1996: 207)

1965 Kwon
1999:88-951965-1977
1977-1988
1978 10.49
1987 51.131988
ibid.:88 2001 12 96.9 3.1
the medical aid program

50ibid.:
89-90
1997
227
5
2000 7 1
National Health Insurance Corporation, NHIC

National Health Insurance Corporation ,NHIC


1960 1963
1975
1988

10 1992 5
1995 7
1994:143

1999 75.6
(OECD, 2000a: 80) 9
3 2005 7 9
60%

1997 1998 783.5

712.6 70.9
35.5 32.5
1999

900
1998 32.5 1999 75.66

70% 60%
(Kim,
2001: 181)
1997

1962
1995

1.36
6

2022 2031
70
60 60 65 OECD, 2000b: 124

 1.05 0.31 30
35%
50%
Kwon, 1999: 168

18 12
1998 7
7.8%

The Economist, 1998Huck-Ju kwon, 2001

1999 8.6%Kwon2001
78
910
IMF
IMF

Kwon, 2001 91

(70%)(30%) 1998 1999

0.71% 1.62%

1998 1
Tripartite Commission

1998 10 5 5 10

60 1998 50,300
1999 180,000 21
Shin, 2000: 96

50 1998 70 3.5

Shin, 2000: 94
2000 90
9

8 12 6 MOL,2002:31

1999 9 5 2000.11.24

10

 1998 2 6
Social compromise to overcome the economic crisisShin
2000:100-101
tripartite corporatism

1998 11
urgent managerial needs
12
1998
7
13

(chaebol)

14

11

1953 5

OECD, 2000:

12

61

60
30 OECD,
2000: 62

13

OECD, 2000: 64

14

Bielefeld
Kim Won-Sub


Kim(2000: 192-3)
/

1998

3
9
OECD, 2000: 100

1992
1953 15
1991 9 70

3(Ku, 1997: 58) 1958

161958 1980

1987

1980
37 8
1980 1

(Lue, 1999)1980

/
15

1988 0.1 63.1

16


1995
20032003
1990

1987
1994
971 2003 2876
18.32003 7.9
3.5

NHI 1995

4.554.55

NHI 97
GDP 5.5 NHI
OECD
NHI
2003

FFS
2000

2002 4.25 4.55

2003b

400

65
8.4 2011 102031 20
1984

1993

25 55
80

1987

1992
, 1996

3000-6000

3000

3000-8000

14625

1994

1998

2001 2000
1999
2001

1999
2000

2002 65
2001

Goodmen Peng(1996)

1997

(coverage)

Bonapartism,
Baldwin, 1990: 39-40

1995
1998

(Minimum Living Standard

Guarantee, MLSG)Kwon
(Kwon, 2003)

2004

Gough(2004)

2000

165 3000
23 3
1 50
2 503 504

 505 50

OECD
17

10000

200391-93

Birdsall Haggard (2002: 73-79)

17

1989 59.3 45.3

46.5

90

Holliday(2005)

2003
311 45
2003

31 P.189-241
(2003) <><<
>> 1-71
1999

2003
(2003)
69-94
(2001) .
263-313.
(2003)
51 51-94.
(2003)
:
92. 11/29-30

Bi
r
ds
a
l
l
,Na
nc
ya
ndSt
e
pha
nHa
g
g
a
r
d.2002.
Af
t
e
rt
heCr
i
s
i
s
:TheSoc
i
a
lCont
r
a
c
t
a
ndt
heMi
ddl
eCl
a
s
si
nEa
s
tAs
i
a
,
i
nEt
ha
nKa
ps
t
e
i
na
ndBr
a
nkoMi
l
a
novi
c
,

ed.s, When Markets Fail: Social Policy and Economic Reform. New York:
Russell Sage Foundation.
Boix, C. (2003) Democracy and Redistribution. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cameron, D. R. (1978) The Expansion of the Public Economy: A Comparative
Analysis, in: American Political Science Review 72 (Dec.) 1243-1261.
Campus, J.E. and Root, H. L. (1995) The Key to the Asian Miracle: Making Shared
Growth Credible, Washington, D. C. : Brookings Institution.
Deyo, Frederick C. 1989. Beneath the Miracle: Labour Subordination in the New
Asian Industrialism. Berkeley: University of California Press.
- (1992) The Political Economy of Social Policy Formation: East Asia
s Newly
Industrialized Countries, in: Richard P. Appelbaum and Jeffrey Henderson
(eds.) States and Development in the Asian Pacific Rim. Newbury Park: Sage,
pp. 289-306.
Goodman, R. and Peng, Ito (1996) The East Asian Welfare States: Peripatetic
Learning, and Nation-Building, in: Welfare States in Transition: National
Adaptions in Global Economies, Esping-Andersen, G. (eds.). London: Sage,
pp. 192-224.
Goug
h,I
a
n.(
2001)
Gl
oba
l
i
z
a
t
i
ona
ndr
e
g
i
ona
lwe
l
f
a
r
er
e
g
i
me
s
:t
heEa
s
tAs
i
a
nc
a
s
e
,

Global Social Policy 1(2): 163-189.

- (2004) East Asia: the limits of productivist regimes. In: I an Gough and Geof Wood
(eds.) Insecurity and Welfare Regimes in Asia, Africa and Latin America:
Social Policy in Developmental Contexts. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press, pp. 169-201.
Holliday, I. (2000)
Productivist Welfare Capitalism: Social Policy in East Asia,
Comparative Political Studies 48: 706-723.
- (2005) East-Asian social policy in the wake of the financial crisis: farewell to
productvisism, Policy and Politics 33(1): 145-62.
Holliday, Ian and Paul Wilding (2003) Welfare Capitalism in East Asia: Social Policy
in the Tiger Economies. London: Palgrave.
Hort, Sven E.O. The Geography of Comparative Welfare State Research: A Comment.
Globoal Social Policy 5(1): 14-17.
Hort, Sven E. O. and Stein Kuhnle (2000) The coming of East and South-East Asian
welfare states. Journal of European Social Policy 10 (2): 162-184.
Jayasuriya, Kanishka (2000) From the developmental state to the regulatory state in East
Asia J. Schmidt and J. Hersh (eds.) Globalization and social welfare in East and

Southeast Asia, London: Routledge.

Jones, Cathrine (1993). The pacific challenge: Confucian welfare states. In Cathrine
Jones(ed.,). New Perspectives on the Welfare State in Europe. London: Routledge.

Joo, Jaehyun (1999)

Explaining Social Policy Adoption in South-Korea: the Cases of
the Medical Insurance Law and the Minimum Wage Law,Journal of Social
Policy 28(3): 387-412.
Kang, Seoghoon (2001). Globalization and Income Inequality in Korea : An Overview.
Paper presented at the ConferenceFDI, Human Capital and Education in
Developing Countries Technical Meeting2001.12.13-14, Paris.
Korea Observer(1998). The Korean Government
s Agreement with IMF. Korea
Observer. 29(3):575-598.
Kaufman, R.R. and A. Segura-Ubiergo (2001)
Globalization, Domestic Politics, and
Social Spending in Latin America: A Time-Series Cross-Sectional Analysis,
1973-97,World Politics 53(July): 553-87.
Katzenstein, P. J. (1985) Small States in World Markets: Industrial Policy in Europe.
Ithaca/London: Cornell University Press.
Ku, Yeun-Wen (1997) Welfare Capitalism in Taiwan: State, Economy, and the Social
Pol
i
c
y
.London:Ma
Cmi
l
i
a
nPr
e
s
s
/Ne
wYor
k:St
.Ma
r
t
i
n
sPr
e
s
s
.
Ku, Yeun-Wen. (2000) Social Development in Taiwan: Upheavals in the 1990s. Pp.
39-59 in: Social Development in Asia edited by K. L. Tang. Netherland: Kluwer.
Kown, Huck-Ju. (1997) Beyond European Welfare Regimes : Comparative Perspectives
on East Asian Welfare Systems, Social Policy 26(4) : 467-84.
-

(2001) Globalization, Unemployment and Policy Responses in Korea

Repositioning the State? Global Social Policy 1(2) : 213-234.

- (2003)
Advocacy coalitions and the politics of welfare in Korea after the
economic crisis
, Policy and Politics 31(1): 69-83.
Kim, Yeon-Myung (2001)
Welfare State or Social Safety Nets?: Development of the
Social Welfare Policy of the Kim-Dae-jung AdministrationKorea Journal
(Summer): 169- 201.
Nelosn, J. M. (2001) The Politics of Pension and Health-Care Reforms in Hungary
and Poland. In: J. Kornai et al., (eds.) Reforming the State: Fiscial and Welfare
Reform in Post-Socialist Countries. P.p. 235-266. Cambridge: Cambridge UP.
OECD (2000). Pushing Ahead with Reform in Korea Labour Market and Social
Safety-net Policies. ParisOECD Publications.
Pempel, T. J. (1998) Regime Shift. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
- (ed.)(1999) The Politics of the Asian Economic Crisis. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University
Press.
Rodrik, D. (1997) Has Globalization Gone too Far? (Washington, D.C.: Institute for

International Economics.
- (1999) The New Global Economy and Developing Countries: Making Openness
Work. Washington, D.C.: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Rieger, E. And Leibfries S. (2003) Limits to Globalization: Welfare States and the
World Economy. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Rudra, N. (2002)
Globalization and the Decline of the Welfare State in
Less-Developed Countries,
International Organization 56(2): 441-445.
Shin, Dong-Myeon (2000). Financial crisis and social security: The paradox of the
Republic of Korea. International Social Security Review. 53:83-107.
Swank, D. (2002) Global Capital, Political Institutions, and Policy Change in
Developed Welfare States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tang, Kwong-leung (1996) The determinants of social security,International Social
Work 39: 377-393.
- (2000) Social Welfare and Policy Responses: Hong Kong and Korea Compared.
International Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare 20 (5/6): 49-71.
Wade, Robert and Venerso, Frank (1998) The Asian crisis: the high debt model versus
the Wall Street-Treasury-IMF complex, New Left Review 228: 1-24.
Wade R. (2000) Wheels within wheels: rethinking the Asian crisis and the Asian
Model American Review of Political Science 3: 85-115.
Weiss, Linda (2000) Developmental State in transition: adapting, dismantling, innovating,
not 'normalization'. Pacific Review 13 (1): 21-55.
- (2003) Guiding globalisation in East-Asia: new roles for old developmental states. In: L.
Weiss (ed.) States in the Global Economy: Bringing Domestic Institutions Back In.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 245-270.
World Bank (1993) The East Asian Miracle. New York: Oxford University Press for the
World Bank.