Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
CIVIL LAW
INSTRUCTIONS
GOOD LUCK!!!
____________________________________
CHAIRMAN
2005 BAR EXAMINATION COMMITTEE
-I-
- II -
- III -
- IV -
-V-
- VI -
- VII -
CIVIL LAW Page 5 of 9
b) Could Ernie close the pathway and refuse to let the buyers
pass? Give reasons. (2%)
c) What are the rights of the lot buyers, if any? Explain. (2%)
- VIII -
- IX -
-X-
- XI -
a) Who shall bear the P15,000.00 spent for the repair of the
van? Explain. (2%)
b) Who shall bear the costs for the van’s fuel, oil and other
materials while it was with Tito? Explain. (2%)
c) Does Pedro have the right to retrieve the van even before the
lapse of one year? Explain. (2%)
CIVIL LAW Page 7 of 9
- XII -
- XIII -
- XIV -
- XV -
XVI
Dr. and Mrs. Almeda are prominent citizens of the country and
are frequent travelers abroad. In 1996, they booked round-trip
business class tickets for the Manila-Hong Kong-Manila route of the
Pinoy Airlines, where they are holders of Gold Mabalos Class
Frequent Flier cards. On their return flight, Pinoy Airlines upgraded
their tickets to first class without their consent and, inspite of their
protestations to be allowed to remain in the business class so that
they could be with their friends, they were told that the business class
was already fully booked, and that they were given priority in
upgrading because they are elite members/holders of Gold Mabalos
Class cards. Since they were embarrassed at the discussions with
the flight attendants, they were forced to take the flight at the first
class section apart from their friends who were in the business class.
Upon their return to Manila, they demanded a written apology from
Pinoy Airlines. When it went unheeded, the couple sued Pinoy
Airlines for breach of contract claiming moral and exemplary
damages, as well as attorney’s fees.
NOTHING FOLLOWS