Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
P
art 1 of this series outlined recent guidance on Henderson (2007), palliative care:
demenria care and provided information on dementia • Provides relief from pain and other distressing symptoms
and its different subtypes, the assessment process • Affirms life and sees dying as a natural process
and the utility of cognitive screening tools. Part 2 • Intends neither to hasten nor postpone death
focused on cienieiitiLi management, with particular emphasis on • Integrates tbe psychological and spiritual aspects of patient
understanding and managing behavioural challenges; it described care
psychosocial interventions in dementia care in addition to • Offers a support system to belp people live as actively as
discussing current drug treatments for the condition. possible until deatb, and to families to belp cope during
This article, part 3, brietly detines palliative care and explores illness and bereavement.
issues around barriers to palliative care in advanced dementia. However, the palliative care approach to dementia does
It provides guidance on recognizing the advanced stages of not appear to be commonly adopted throughout tbe UK.
dementia, and bow nurses can care for and support people In 2002, tbe Audit Commission reported that specialist
with dementia in tbe tinal stages of their disease. Significantly, support for managing people with advanced dementia was
it also makes reference to tbe difficult decisions tacing family not available in 40% of all areas of the UK, and dementia
caregivers at this stage and the psychological impact of care specialists lack confidence in providing palliative care.
advanced dementia on caregivers. Sampson et al (2006) undertook a retrospective case-note
audit of older patients dying on an acute medical ward in
Background 2002-2003; those with dementia were much less likely to
Approximately 10000 people with dementia die eacb year in be referred to palliative care services than those without
tbe United Kingdom (UK) (Harris, 2007). Of tbi.s number, a diagnosis of dementia (9% I'i 25%), and were prescribed
over 40% die in tbe community (McCartby et al, 1997; Kay et fewer palliative medications (28% i>s 51%). A retrospective
al, 2000), and over 50% in hospital (McCarthy et al, 1997). Less study on a hospital ward for older people with mental
tban 2% of people in hospice care in tbe UK have a primary bealtb needs in the UK showed patients witb end-stage
dementia bad a number of symptoms for which they did
not receive adequate palliative care (Lloyd-WilHams and
Emma Ouldred is Deriicnti.i Niirst? Specialist and Catherine Bryant is Payne, 2002).
Consultant Physiciiin, King's College Hospitai NHS Trust, London
Guidance on end-of-llfe care for older people
Acct'picd tor pitblicalum:Jatmary 2008
Recently, attention has been tbcused on improving end-
of-life care for all older people. The Department of
I leakh (DH, 2004) document, The NHS Improvement Plan. care teams should assess the palliative needs of people close
included a commitment to develop a training programme to death and relay information to other members of health
lor staff working in primary care homes and hospitals to and social care. Specific guidance relating to nutrition, pain
ensure all people at the end of life, regardless of diagnosis, relief and resuscitation is also included.
should have the choice of deciding where to die and how NICE (2006) also recommends that practitioners discuss
they wish to be treated. In the Government white paper, certain issues with the person with dementia while he or
i)iir Health Our Care Our Say (DH, 20i)6a), a commitment she still has capacity, and to ensure people are familiar with
was expressed to extend palliative care to .ill who need it the main clauses of the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA),
regardless of terminal condition. which is initiated when a person does not have capacity.
The National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence Such areas of discussion include:
(NICE, 2004) has produced guidance on improving support • Use of advance statements (stating what is to be done if a
and palliative care for adults with cancer, and although this person loses capacity to communicate or make decisions)
work is focused on services for adult patients with cancer • Advance decisions to refuse treatment
•liid their families, it may inform the development of service • Lasting power of attorney
models for other groups of patients. The NICE (2004) • A preferred place-of-care plan.
document recommends three tools to support high-quality
end-of-life care: Barriers to providing palliative care
• The Gold Standards Framework (Thomas. 2003) There are several barriers to overcome in order to achieve
• t'he Liverpool care pathway Care of the Oyin^iA Pathway excellent end-of-hfe care for people with dementia, namely:
to Excellence (EUershaw and Wilkinson, 2(K)3) • Dementia is not recognized as terminal disease
• The "Preferred Place of Care Plati" (www. cancerlan cash ire. • There are difficulties in prognostication and difficulties in
ürg.uk/ppc.html). recognizing when somebody reaches the point at which
The NHS End of Ufe Care Programme (DH, 2005) aims to care becomes palliative
improve care at the end of life for all. and the programuîc • Problems in client communicability that impacts on
website (www.endotlifecare.nhs.uk/eoic) provides good symptom management
practice, information and resources, including links to the • A lack of skills and knowledge in providers of care regarding
three tools. palliative care for people with advanced dementia, and
a lack of access to specialist palliative care consultation
Guidance on end-of-llfe care (Shuster, 200(i)
The development of policies specifically related to end-of- • A lack of education and support about complications
life care for people with dementia has evolved slowly, but of advanced dementia, and limits to treatment options
recently a number of important documents have addressed encourages healthcare proxies to request admission to
this complex issue. Recent guidance has stipulated that hospital and aggressive interventions (Koopnians et al,
older people with mental health problems should have 2003)
equal access to the same home-based end-of-care services • A lack of advance decisions that set out the wishes of a
as others, and that a palliative care model of service person to ta-atment in advance.There is evidence to suggest
delivery should be made available for people with dementia that a person with dementia is significantly less likely than
supported with advice from general medicine physicians a person with cancer to have set up advance decisions
,uid palhative care services (Care Services Improvement (Mitchell et .i!, 2004).
Partnership, 2005).
Programmes on dignity and end of life, and mental health Advanced dementia
in old age, are included in the follow-up to the document it is not inevitable that all people with dementia will reach
A New Ambition for Old A^e: Next Steps in Impleiiiv!iliii_i; the the end stages of their disease before death. Cox and Cook
National Service Framework for Older People (DH, 2006b). (2002) describe three ways in which people with dementia
Dementia and palliative care are also included in the die, namely:
Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF) for the GP • People with dementia may die with a medical condition
contract. Under this framework, GPs must hold a register of that is unrelated to the dementia, e.g. people with tnild
patients diagnosed with dementia, and under the paUiative dementia who develop and subsequently die from cancer
care QOF GPs must hold regular review meetings of these • People with dementia may die from a complex mix of
patients (Royal College of General Practitioners, 2006). mental health and physical problems where dementia is
NICE issued guidance on dementia in 2006. which not the primary cause of death but interacts with other
specifically addressed the need for a palliative care approach conditions, such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
to dementia care to be adopted from diagnosis to death • People with dementia may die with comphcations arising
to enhance the quality of life of people with dementia advanced dementia.
and to enable them to die with dignity in an appropriate
environment. A holistic approach to care is recommended, Signs and symptoms
which encompasses the physical, psychological, social and When does a person stop living with dementia and start
spiritual needs of people with dementia, and also emphasizes dying from it? Failure to recognize when a person has
the importance of supporting families and carers. Primary entered the advanced stages of dementia has been proposed
Mrs T is a 73'year-old lady with Parkinson's disease and advanced dementia. She lives at home with her son, daughter-in-law ¡main carer) and her
two grandchildren. Mrs T is fuHy dependent for ail her activities of daily living. She is bed/chair bound and requires hoisting. She is incontinent of urine
and faeces. She has dysphagia and is at high risk of aspiration. Her pressure areas are intact (she has a pressure relieving cushion and mattress). She is
unable to communicate her wishes and has iost her grasp of English (her first language is Gujarat and she may respond to a few words spoken in her
native tongue). She loves being around her family and enjoys regular massage sessions at home, Mrs T fulfils the criteria for NHS Continuing Care.
She has a care package consisting of two carers three times a day to attend to her personal care, perform pressure area care and address toileting
needs. Mrs T's daughter-in-law. Sema, administers her medication and manages her feeding (Mrs T requires feeding and can only take fortified liquid
supplements because of her dysphagia), and also attends to her elimination and psychosocial needs at all other times. Mrs T used to attend the local
memory clinic (she presented to clinic at an advanced stage of dementia), but as her condition has progressed, the dementia nurse specialist (DNS) and
Alzheimer's support worker visited her at home on a regular basis to provide support for her and the family. On a recent visit to the family, the DNS
explored end-of-life issues with them. They expressed the wish for her to stay at home and die peacefully when the time comes. Sema and her husband
expressed concerns regarding the wish to avoid hospital admission if at all possible, the wish to avoid tube-feeding, and the need for intensive and
immediate medical support and advice when required. The fear of not knowing what to do if Mrs T started to exhibit distressing symptoms was a major
concern for the family.
Case-conference
The DNS organized a case-conference to explore and discuss the palliative care needs of Mrs T and her family. Present at the case-conñerence was:
• Sema
• DNS
• GP
• District nurse
• Community matron
• Speech and language therapist (SALT)
• Care agency manager
Professional roles
The care needs of Mrs T and her family were discussed, A written plan of care was formulated, which addressed care issues and the family's concerns,
and set out each person's professional roles and responsibiiities:
• GP - review medication and reduce amount of tablets if indicated. GP also offered to speak to Sema by telephone (and visit as necessary) whenever
any medicai concerns arose
• SALT - assess swaiiow and provide advice on reducing risk of aspiration
• District nurses/community matron - assess pressure area risk and provide equipment as appropriate
• Community matron - provide contact detaiis to Sema and coordinate care of Mrs T, including review of care pian through regular contact
• Care agency manager - provide experienced carers and ensure there is continuity of care to enabie a rapport to be estabiished between caregivers
• DNS - refer Mrs T and Sema to local hospice home-care team to review Mrs T. support her famiiy and provide contact details; refer Mrs T to a
Parkinson's nurse speciaiist for review; speak to sociai services to request respite care at home for Sema {as she did not wish for her mother-in law
to go into a care home for respite); and to maintain regular contact with Mrs T and her famiiy aiong with the Alzheimer's support worker.
Mrs T's famiiy ailowed to advocate on her behalf, and were given the opportunity and support to explore end-of-life issues
Close collaboration and understanding across heaith and social care agencies
Formulation of a written care plan that is shared across agencies
Designated case manager who will regularly review care plan