I dossier di July 2000 _ International Council of Shopping Centers A working paper prepared by ICSC Research Department TOURISM AND SHOPPING CENTERS Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 2 I dossier di Table of Contents Introduction.. 3 Tourism in a National Context... 3 The Importance of Tourism to Retail And Vice Versa... 3 The Data Dilemma. 4 Government Agencies Evidence for Shopping as a Tourist Activity. 5 Reasons Why Shopping is High on the Tourist Itinerary... 6 Tourist Purchasing... 7 How Owners Market Shopping Centers to Tourists.. 8 How Governments Market Shopping Centers to Tourists.. 10 How Other Organizations Market Shopping Centers to Tourists... 11 Latest Trends in the Shopping-Tourist Connection: Airport Retailing and Gambling.... 12 Conclusion..... 12 Appendix 1: Shopping Centers that Rank Among State and Local Top Tourist Attractions....... 13 Appendix 2: Other Examples of Tourist-Oriented Centers..... 14 Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 3 I dossier di INTRODUCTION In recent years, ICSC has compiled a resource database in response to member questions on the close and growing relationship between tourism and shopping centers. In an attempt to create a comprehensive picture from these varied materials, ICSC presents this Working Paper. It summarizes the latest available data from national, state, and local government sources, including numbers on visitor spending; explores why shopping has become such an important part of tourists travel plans; analyzes how shopping center owners, government agencies, and other organizations are marketing centers to tourists; and discusses trends that have developed over the last several years. TOURISM IN A NATIONAL CONTEXT The travel and tourism industry is a major contributor to the American economy. The Travel Industry Association of America (TIA) estimates travel expenditures of nearly $544.1 billion by domestic and international tourists in the United States in 1999. These expenditures generated nearly $92.5 billion in federal, state and local taxes. In addition, they sustained about 7.7 million jobs. Tourism can be seen as an outgrowth of the worlds interest in leisure/entertainment activities over the last decade. Several factors have influenced the growth of the industry, including increased wealth at home and abroad; a larger older population with more leisure time and money; the fall of political barriers such as Communism that once restricted the movement of people and information; and technology that has fueled air travel and new entertainment venues. These trends have strengthened the shopping-tourism connection in recent years, taking it in directions entirely unexpected as recently as a decade ago. In one way, this should not be entirely surprisingly. Shopping involves experiences as much as it does commodities and, as it has evolved in the trend toward entertainment in recent years, it shares with tourism the elements of stimulation and fantasy. THE IMPORTANCE OF TOURISM TO RETAIL AND VICE VERSA Detailing the connection between tourism and shopping centers is problematic because only recently have data been collected in depth, and these data continue to be reported in a fragmentary manner by a variety of different sources. However, information from the national government, state and local tourist agencies, and shopping centers themselves suggests that shopping is a very significant tourist activity. For example: Domestic and international travelers accounted for an estimated $35.35 billion in general retail expenditures in 1998, according to a study published by the TIA. The International Trade Administration (ITA) estimates that 24,466,000 overseas visitors spent an average of $333 each on gifts and souvenirs, for a total of $8.15 billion in 1999. In addition, these visitors spent another $281 on food and beverages for a total of $6.85 billion. Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 4 I dossier di The Mall of America annually attracts more than 42.5 million visitors. Tourism from outside a 150-mile radius accounts for more than 37 percent of all traffic. A study released in 1999 by the U.S. Department of Commerce and the Taubman Company estimated that 89% of overseas travelersthat is, visitors from countries other than Canada or Mexicoengaged in shopping during a 1997 visit to the U.S. Factory outlets, centers in which manufacturers sell goods at a discount from their normal price, function as tourist destinations even when located miles away from urban areas. In a 1997 study conducted by the Gallup Organization for ICSC, 20% of factory outlet shoppers interviewed at five outlet centers around the country said that their visit was part of a vacation. Over the years, developers have experimented with several new types of centers that have capitalized on fun and amusement, a main component of attracting tourists. Festival marketplaces, such as New Yorks South Street Seaport and Bostons Faneuil Hall, have revitalized city waterfronts even since they were first developed in the 1970s. In fact, tourists comprise 70% or more of the traffic at Faneuil Hall, Bayside Marketplace in Miami, and Riverwalk in New Orleans, according to the Rouse Company, the owner of all three centers. More recently, entertainment centers have been at the forefront of the movement toward offering shoppers the means of amusing the family inexpensively while satisfying their need for basic goods. The National Research Bureau, combining the two types, estimates that there are 147 such centers in the U.S. Shopping, therefore, is often an important segment of most travelers time away from home, whether they are taking a one-day trip or an extended vacation. THE DATA DILEMMA Among the federal, state, and local government agencies and industry consultants that still report travel statistics are ITA and the TIA. The ITA takes as its starting point for defining tourist the term visitor used by the United Nations Department for Economic and Social Information and Policy Analysis and World Tourism Organization: any person traveling to a place other than that of his/her usual environment for less than 12 months and whose main purpose of trip is other than the exercise of an activity renumerated from within the place visited. The ITA further subdivides visitors into same-day visitors and overnight visitors, or tourists. For this report ICSC also obtained data from travel and tourism offices in 42 out of 50 states and also contacted numerous city offices and individual centers. Unfortunately, the task is complicated by the fact that data collection and definitions are not uniform across these groups at the retail spending level. In part, the problem results from the fact that the travel and tourism industry is in reality a compilation of several different businesses that share a common purpose of serving the Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 5 I dossier di traveling public. Since restaurants and retailers receive only a portion of their total receipts from travelers, it is difficult to segment the portion of sales that comes from vacationers. While retail spending estimates from tourists are problematic, it is still more difficult to assess just how much shopping centers form a part of the tourist experience. Because tourism is often associated with sightseeing, shopping centers are not usually considered tourist attractions by departments or by tourists themselves, causing tourist authorities to ask few questions about them. Since, as noted, hard national statistics on retail spending by tourists are for the most part unavailable, the remainder of this report consists of information gleaned from a review of the literature and from speaking directly with state and local agencies and shopping center representatives. GOVERNMENT AGENCIES EVIDENCE FOR SHOPPING AS A TOURIST ACTIVITY According to the TIA, shopping was the most popular activity among U.S. resident travelers in 1997-1998. About 33% of person-trips activities came from shopping, while outdoor and historical activities compiled 17% and 15%, respectively. More evidence of tourists strong preference for shopping came from responses by state and metro areas to ICSCs survey, as summarized in Chart 1 below: 1 Chart 1 Tourists/Leisure Travelers Rated Shopping As The Number-One Activity In: States Maryland (source: TravelScope survey) Alabama (in 1997, source: Bureau of Tourism and Travel) New Mexico (source: 1994-1996 TravelScope survey) Oklahoma (source: 1998 Travelscope survey) Tennessee (source: Department of Tourist Development) Metro Areas Chicago, IL (source: DK Shifflet & Associates, Ltd, 1999) Houston, TX (source: Convention and Visitors Bureau) Minneapolis, MN (source: Office of Tourism, Research) Corpus Christi, TX (source: Convention and Tourism Bureau)
1 Additional details from responses to ICSCs survey can be found in Appendices 1 and 2. Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 6 I dossier di REASONS WHY SHOPPING IS HIGH ON THE TOURIST ITINERARY There are several reasons why shopping is such an integral part of the tourist experience. First, tourists shop out of necessity. Away from home, they still have a compelling need for convenience goods such as groceries that must be satisfied. This is particularly true of the segment of travelers that stay with family or friends while away. Second, tourists can find a wide array of GAFO (general merchandise, apparel, home furnishings, and other merchandise) items while still realizing significant savings. In the United States, visitors from other nations find a wealth of goods that are either unavailable in their lands or less expensive here because of the favorable exchange rates. U.S. tourists visiting other states may want to purchase an item that cant be bought back home. Savvy, cost-conscious U.S. consumers are often willing to drive far from their homes to achieve greater savings on goods. This latter factor helps explain why many consumers visit factory outlets for instance. Third, shopping is an extension of the leisure and entertainment elements that form the core of tourisms allure. Even the architecture of malls is meant to stimulate and entertain, with fountains, landscaping, high ceilings with dramatic lighting, and music. In addition, however, shopping centers have become an increasingly prominent provider of leisure-time activities. Whether through movie multiplexes, food courts, ice-skating rinks, carousels, indoor lakes, virtual-reality exhibits, or planned promotional events, Americans have discovered that shopping centers offer a low-cost way to take the family out for a day of recreation. The Mall of America, with its Knotts Camp Snoopy, nightclubs, indoor golf courses, and other amusements, and Universal City Walk, located next to adjacent to Burbanks popular Universal Studios tour, are just two of the most notable examples of this trend. Festival marketplaces, such as Baltimores Gallery at Harborplace and San Franciscos Pier 39, offer waterfront developments in which tourists can sample specialty shops, try dozens of small restaurants, or simply enjoy the passing parade of jugglers and singers. Following the opening of what is commonly accepted as the pioneering festival marketplace, Faneuil Hall, in 1976, many more centers of this type have been created. More recently, Park Meadows, a retail resort in Denver, was designed to fit into its pristine Colorado surroundings. Fourth, particularly for tourists whose major interest is sightseeing, shopping centers have become as much a touchstone of urban life as government buildings, churches, or skyscrapers that house major financial institutions. Numerous shopping centers not only represent a variety of architectural styles, but also have been designed to reflect the ambiance, culture and economic history of their local communities. Many such centers are conveniently located in downtown areas, readily accessible to major hotels and commuter hubs through which tourist will pass. Examples include: San Diegos Westfield Shoppingtown--Horton Plaza, Chicagos Water Tower Place, Houstons Galleria, San Franciscos Ghirardelli Square, Underground Atlanta and St. Louis Union Station. The recent revival of interest in downtown development holds promise for injecting further momentum in building such locations. Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 7 I dossier di Fifth, tourists simply have more time. Granted a temporary reprieve from their everyday routine of work and family commitments, tourists enjoy more unscheduled time to indulge in browsing and purchasing. TOURIST PURCHASING A number of centers contacted for this report reported that tourists spent a significantly larger amount of money than the shopper average. The increases vary widelyfrom 11% more in the case of Water Tower Place to tenfold more in the case of The Galleria at Sunset in Las Vegas. The results, limited as they are, suggest a potential avenue of new research. Several possible reasons might be proposed for why spending by tourists is greater than for non-tourists in the above instances: Chart 2 Reasons For Tourism Spending Exceeding The Shopper Norm Many tourists go to centers already intending to purchase gifts and merchandise, unlike a regular consumer who is going to assess bargains and may do comparative shopping at other centers. Tourists are on holiday and therefore more in the mood for impulse spending. Domestic and overseas tourists want to capitalize on lower sales tax rates, sales and inexpensive merchandise not found at home. Tourists have more money than the average shopper. The ITA reported that overseas leisure travelers to the U.S. had a median household income of $60,200 in 1999. In comparison, according to the Census Bureau, the median income of U.S. households was $38,885 in 1998 (the most recent year for which data are available). Retail spending also varies according to whether the traveler is a leisure visitor or business traveler. According to the ITA, leisure visitors averaged less on food and beverages than business travelers in 1999 ($268 per visitor vs. $330), but more on gifts/souvenirs ($353 vs. $299). The different spending patterns among these two groups vary because of their activities: business travelers will eat and drink as part of their normal at meetings and conferences, while leisure travelers have more time to shop for trinkets for relatives back home. Similarly, tourists who are visiting friends and relatives (the so-called VFR niche) can spend more than tourists who stay at a hotel. One type of center in which tourist spending plays a major role is the factory outlet center. Projecting from a survey of 1,200 U.S. adults conducted in December 1997, the TIA reported that 37% of U.S. travelers visited a discount outlet mall during a trip more than 100 miles away from home. The TIA estimated that one out of ten travelers who visited a factory outlet center considered discount shopping to be the primary reason for their trip. About 79% of travelers said it was a secondary reason, while 11% indicated that it was not a reason for their trip at all. Those who cited discount shopping as the primary or secondary reason for their trip spent an average of $183 at an outlet center on their most recent visit. Approximately one in five (18%) spent $250 or more. Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 8 I dossier di HOW OWNERS MARKET SHOPPING CENTERS TO TOURISTS Aside from statistics collected by state and municipal authorities, one of the best ways of measuring the importance of shopping to tourism is by looking at the broad range of highly sophisticated marketing programs undertaken to promote shopping centers to visitors, as seen in Chart 3 below. Chart 3 Marketing Programs Undertaken by Shopping Centers to Attract Tourists: Creation of Tourism Coordinator positions within the center Providing language/translation assistance at centers Advertising in visitor publications distributed at area hotels, car rental agencies Establishing links with airlines, tourist organizations, area hotels and restaurants to create incentives Providing vacation planning/tour group information on centers Web site Further details on these programs are offered in the discussion that follows. Special Positions at the Center At the simplest level, the centers management may have created special positions for targeting this particular clientele on an ongoing basis. Centers have appointed marketing or bus tour coordinators whose sole responsibility is the tourist marketing. Such coordination may involve providing special food discounts for motorcoach guest, or providing benefits for busy drivers such as a bus lounge and lunch certificates, as the Taubman Company does. Good examples of this are the Mills projects (Gurnee, Franklin, Sawgrass, Ontario, Opry, Potomac, Grapevine, and Arizona Mills), which mix outlet, off-price, and full-price retailers in large-scale developments with well over 1 million square feet of gross leasable area. Busloads of visitors have made each of these projects among the most heavily visited sites in their states. Foremost among the Mills projects as a draw for tourists is Sawgrass Mills in Florida, recording 25 million shoppers in 1998. Shopping center marketing personnel may also be employed in other ways, such as at MainPlace/Santa Ana, which features a concierge desk service. Here, visitors can obtain translation assistance in multiple languages. Advertising in Tourist Publications In addition, many tourist-oriented centers either distribute their own brochures to area hotels, car rental agencies and airports and/or advertise heavily in visitor publications found in those locations. Among centers that participate in this form of marketing are Cherry Creek Shopping Center in Denver, Great Lakes Crossing, Prime Outlets in Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 9 I dossier di Hagerstown (Maryland), Horizon Outlet Center in Somerset, PA, Dallas Galleria, Aventura Mall, Waccamaw Factory Shoppes in Myrtle Beach, SC, Biltmore Fashion Park in Phoenix, AZ, Copley Place and various Mills Corporation centers. Alliances with Area Hotels, Restaurants, Convention Centers Tourism-oriented shopping centers also link up with area hotels, motels and restaurants to create travel package deals, with such incentives as reduced room rates, free gifts, discount coupons and complimentary breakfast. Sunland Park Mall in El Paso, TX has developed a preferred-customer program aimed at Mexican natives, drawing shoppers from as far away as Mexico City, a 10-hour drive. Center personnel may also frequently attend trade shows such as Pow Wow, Vaccacoines, and La Cumbre. A number of centers are linked to downtown areas, convention centers, or hotels by shuttle bus, including Westfield Shoppingtown--Horton Plaza, Las Vegas Factory Outlet Stores, Meadowood Mall in Reno, NV, MainPlace/Santa Ana in Santa Ana, CA, and Circle Centre in Indianapolis, IN. Rehoboth Outlets, an outlet complex in Rehoboth, DL, not only offers promotions such as coupon books with the local bus company, but also with a ferry service that brings visitors from New Jersey. Links with Airlines Besides bus promotions, owners have also linked up with airlines to promote centers. Urban Retail Properties Co. has run a frequent shopper program that allows visitors who reside in Mexico, the Caribbean, Central America and South America to earn 500 Continental Airlines OnePass miles for every $500 spent at the Houston Galleria. The program enables the center to capitalize on its proximity to Mexico, the source of 20% of its shopper base. Shopping and Travel Incentive Programs Urban Retail Properties Co. has also become involved in another marketing program aimed at travelers. Spree, developed by R. Blocki & Associates, a Chicago-based marketing and advertising agency, is a free service that allows consumers to plan shopping trips through a wide range of travel venues, including hotels, restaurants, cultural attractions, museums, theater, sporting events, and sightseeing. Customers can also use Spree cards at Urban malls participating in the program. The Internet Nor have tourism-oriented centers neglected cyberspace. A number of center owners are using Web sites to serve users who wish to research centers other than the one nearest to them. Thus, a trip to the mall becomes an element of vacation planning. The sites will often detail arrangements for tour groups, such as the availability of motorcoach parking and prepaid meal vouchers, and advertise special incentives for tour group leaders and bus drivers. Some sites list nearby hotels, museums, restaurants, golf courses and other vacation travel destinations. Others may offer specific information such as prices for Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 10 I dossier di theater tickets or the admission cost of amusement parks. Among owner-developers that have added tourism information to their corporate and/or center sites are: Chart 4 Owner/Developers with Tourist Information on their Corporate or Center Web sites Chelsea GCA, Realty, Inc Forest City Enterprises Glimcher Realty Trust Kravco Co. The Mills Corp Prime Retail Tanger Factory Outlet Centers, Inc Taubman Centers The Rouse Company Urban Retail Properties Co. Westcor Partners That number will almost surely grow over time. HOW GOVERNMENTS MARKET SHOPPING CENTERS TO TOURISTS Shopping centers have also established special relationships with tourist organizations. In Cleveland, spousal programs involving shopping are offered during conventions. In addition, nontraditional non-retail tenants with particular appeal to tourists are now tenanting shopping centers. Napa Valley Conference and Visitors Bureau is a tenant at the Napa Town Center. Three of the five locations of the Shreveport-Bossier Convention & Tourist Bureau in Louisiana are area malls: Pierre Bossier Mall, South Park Mall and Mall St. Vincent. Biltmore Fashion Park hosts a Visitor Information Center in conjunction with the Greater Phoenix Convention and Visitors Bureau. Cherry Creek in Denver, features a convention bureau visitors center. Besides metro areas, states have tried innovative ways either of promoting their services to tourists in centers or of obtaining the tourist dollar. One of Californias state welcome centers is located in Beverly Center. A particularly interesting program has been implemented in Louisiana, the first state to refund sales taxes to international visitors on purchases made at participating stores. Data for 1999 indicate that the program had an economic impact of approximately $274.7 million, including 4,900 jobs and $86.4 million in earnings for Louisiana residents. The motivations for state and local organizations to ally with area shopping centers are obvious: shopping centers, because they are located in high-visibility locations, represent a vibrant part of a municipality, and they contribute significantly to the economy. ICSCs Scope USA 2000 estimated that shopping centers generated $47.5 billion in sales tax Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 11 I dossier di revenues in 1999 and directly employed 10.5 million peopleabout 8% of all nonfarm employees in the U.S. HOW OTHER ORGANIZATIONS MARKET SHOPPING CENTERS TO TOURISTS The shopping center industrys tourism efforts have reached such as level of critical mass that many centers of different types have formed a partnership. Formed in 1999, the Shop America Alliance is a tourism marketing cooperative that represents more than 300 shopping and dining destinations. It develops partnership opportunities and facilitates communications between these destinations and the media. It also provides training and partnership development for retailers, restaurants, downtown retail districts, and shopping centers of all types. Among the major shopping center companies involved with this partnership are Tanger Outlets, The Mills Corporation, Taubman World Class Shopping, Glimcher, the Rouse Company, Chelsea Premium Outlets, Urban Retail Properties and Prime Outlets. A fascinating recent outgrowth of how centers are marketing to tourists relates to Overnighters Association, a Punta Gorda, FL-based organization that is dedicated to offering its recreational vehicle (RV)-driving members an inexpensive way to travel the U.S. Permitting only stops of one night at each facility, the organization has targeted shopping centers near interstate highways and other routes to provide overnight parking for RVs. Hosting malls receive $3 out of each $5 fee charged to association members for the stay, plus any revenues generated by the tourists while they are at the mall. Overnighters claims to have 40 shopping centers now participating in its program. LATEST TRENDS IN THE SHOPPING-TOURIST CONNECTION: AIRPORT RETAILING AND GAMBLING Tourists/travelers are also spurring sales in other locations that had been relatively untapped until recently: airports. In contrast to establishments that for so long offered poor- quality products at steep prices, these new ventures offer greater convenience, broader variety, street pricing and customer servicein other words, they more closely resemble traditional malls than ever before. Airports in Portland, Pittsburgh, and Denver are among the pioneers in this rapidly evolving retail type. Several factors are fueling the rise of these new retail locations. Deregulation has increased air traffic by stimulating the growth of discount carriers, thus making travel more affordable. At the same time, a substantial portion of this traffic continues to consist of business travelers who are among the worlds most affluent consumers. In addition, these travelers are often a captive audience. With weather problems and delays, travelers can often spend a couple of hours waiting for their flights. 2 Another element of tourism as entertainment experience is the gaming industry. The issue of whether the spread of gambling is an economic plus or minus for society remains hotly debated. But indisputably, gambling venues have themselves become tourist meccas.
2 An article Airport Retailing--An Expanding Industry appeared in the Fall 1999 issue of ICSC Research Quarterly. Vol. 6, Number 3. Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 12 I dossier di But the growth of gambling can be traced in part to the same instincts for amusement and leisure that have fueled travel and tourism. In turn, partly because the most popular activity for gambling travelers after gambling is shopping, casinos have spurred retail development. Shopping centers are seen as an integral element of a complex of entertainment centers, hotels and casinos designed to make gambling part of a larger family entertainment experience. Forum Shops at Caesars may be the most prominent example of this phenomenon. The introduction of gambling in the 1990s has also spurred retail development in the Biloxi, MS area, which has seen the construction of Crossroads Shopping Center and Prime Outlets at Gulfport and the expansion of Edgewater Mall, and Shreveport, LA, which has witnessed the opening of Bayou Walk Shopping Center. CONCLUSION: A CRUCIAL ELEMENT OF THE TOURIST MIX The examples cited above demonstrate that shopper-tourists have had a major impact on the U.S. economy, particularly as they make purchases in shops and restaurants. As this report makes clear, much more research needs to be done in quantifying the relationship between tourism and shopping centers, with an emphasis on standardizing reporting categories. At the very least, however, ICSC believes that shopping centers form a major component of one of this nations most dynamic industries. As new museums, historical sites, casinos, and other establishments that cater to Americas appetite for leisure activity increase in the years ahead, that role can only grow. In some ways, this finding should surprise no one. After all, shopping centers sustain visitors with a variety of goods and services. They enable visitors to discover new fashions or other exciting new consumer products, in settings that often place a premium on convenience and value. They offer a relaxed setting for entertainment and dinner. Finally, through gift-buying, they enable tourists to present souvenirs to those at home, and to keep such reminders of the trips themselves. This report was prepared by Michael Tubridy (646-728-3671) and Bindu Nair (646- 728-3680), with additional research assistance by David Brand, based on earlier work by Diane Kutyla. Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 13 I dossier di APPENDIX 1: SHOPPING CENTERS THAT RANK AMONG STATE AND LOCAL TOP TOURIST ATTRACTIONS Despite the fact that malls often attract large amounts of tourists, many state and local tourism authorities do not include them in ranking top attractions in their areas. Part of the reason why relates to the difficulty in comparing traffic at different types of attractions, and often just obtaining accurate traffic counts to begin with. How, for instance, does one compare attendance at a museum, which charges admission, with a mall, which does not? Moreover, different shopping centers have used varying methods for determining visitor counts. Nevertheless, anecdotal evidence garnered from state and local tourism boards points to shopping centers as key points on visitors itineraries. Of the 42 states which responded to ICSCs survey, several cited specific centers as among the top attractions for either the state or metro area where they were located. These include: Circle Center Mall and Lighthouse Place (Indianapolis, Indiana) Bass Pro Outdoor World, Factory Outlet Village of Osage Beach, The Country Club Plaza and the Galleria (Missouri) West Acres (Fargo, North Dakota) Lincoln City Outlet Mall and Pioneer Place (Oregon) Empire Mall (Sioux Falls, South Dakota) San Mateo Outlet Mall (Texas) A few municipal agencies also pointed to shopping centers among their metros major attractions. Cherry Creek Shopping Center and the 16 th Street Mall rank as the top attractions for tourists in Denver. Woodfield Shopping Center in Schaumburg, IL, another mall in the Taubman portfolio, recorded 27 million visitors in 1999. The Chicago Office of Tourism reports that Navy Pier, with an attendance of 8.2 million, led all attractions in Chicago in 1998. Data di pubblicazione: Ottobre 2003 Zeta Consulting / Bologna - info@infocommercio.it pag. 14 I dossier di APPENDIX 2: OTHER EXAMPLES OF TOURIST-ORIENTED CENTERS: In Philadelphia the Franklin Mills outlet attracted over 19 million people in 1998. On their way to the Great Smoky Mountain National Park and Dollywood, created by singer Dolly Parton, approximately 12 million people visited Pigeon Forge, TN, a village with about 200 outlet shops, in 1999. Even at Niagara Falls, with its two big outlet malls, falling water often gives place to shopping. With a permanent population of only 5,000, Branson, MO would not normally have enough people to warrant much retail. But the 7 million tourists who come each year to see this country-music entertainment showcase have sparked the creation of three outlet centers in Branson and nearby Branson Meadows. Great Lakes Crossing in Michigan estimates that approximately 30% of its shoppers are visitors who have traveled 50 or more miles. Tourists account for between 40% and 50% of all visitors to Beverly Center in Los Angeles. Many of the above examples relate to urban centers. In addition, several communities feature a cluster of factory outlet centers that are known to draw many visitors. They have not so much capitalized on existing tourist traffic as become a tourist generator themselves. These include Freeport and Kittery in Maine; Boaz in Alabama; North Conway and Tilton in New Hampshire; and Flemington-Liberty Village and Secaucus in New Jersey. An especially dramatic instance of the importance of outlets is Reading, PA, often regarded as the birthplace of outlet shopping and possessing the official trademark of Outlet Capital of the World. The 300 outlet stores in the area form a shopping mecca for travelers, many of whom are one-day visitors. Several of these centers built to benefit from that tourist draw are tourist attractions in their own right, notably Belz Factory Outlet World and Belz Designer Outlet Center in Orlando, FL, with 15.3 million visitors combined annually in 1998, the last date for which figures are available.