Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
'l-Waf b. Salama the most celebrated of his anthologies, the \amsa. Some two years before his death, \asan b. Wahb found him the postmastership of Mosul. The philosopher al-Kind is supposed to have predicted an early death for him as the result of over-exertion of his intellectual faculties, iddat al-fikr (Ibn allikn, apparently after al-l, where, however, the appropriate passage is lacking, cf. Abr, 231-2). It was in Mosul that Ab Tammm died. Ab Nahal b. \umayd al-s, brother of the Muammad who fell in 214 in the campaign against Bbak, had erected over his grave a dome, visited by Ibn allikn. Ab Tammm was dark, tall, dressed in bedouin fashion, spoke extremely pure Arabic, having at the same time a most unattractive voice and suffering from a slight impediment of speech; he accordingly had his poetry recited by his rw li (Abr, 210). Ab Tammm's adas treat of important historical events, such as the conquest of Amorium, the campaign against Bbak and his execution (223/837-8), the execution of Afn (226/840), whom he himself had previously eulogised, and many others. In certain particulars the adas supplement the historians (cf. al-abar's The reign of al-Mu#taim, transl. and annot. by E. Marin, New Haven 1951, index, and M. Canard, Les allusions a la guerre byzantine chez les poetes Ab Tammm et Butur, in A. A. Vassiliev, Byzance et les Arabes, I, La dynastie d'Amorium, Bruxelles 1935, 397-403). Even in Ab Tammm's lifetime opinions were divided upon the aesthetic merit of his poetry. The poet Di#bil, held in awe by reason of his sharp tongue, asserted that one third of his poetry was plagiarized, one third bad, one third good (Abr, 244). His pupil al-Butur, who held him in the greatest respect, thought Ab Tammm's best verse better than his own best, his bad verse worse than his own bad verse (Abr, 67). The poet #Al b. al-ahm (d. 249; Abr, 61-2) was a friend and admirer of Ab Tammm. From him originates the account of Ab Tammm's first entry into the poets' hall (ubbat al-u#ar") in the mosque of Badd (Ta"r Badd, viii, 249, after al-Mu#f b. Zakariyy"; Dwn#Al b. al-ahm, intr., 6-7). Long after the poet's death writings were penned both in praise of him and against him; in these works his literary "thefts" also were discussed. Abu l-#Abbs Amad b. #Ubayd Allh al-|urabull wrote against him (al-Muwzana, 56), in his favour Ab Bakr Muammad al-l, whose Abr Ab Tammm is at once the oldest and the most circumstantial source for the life of the poet. To his defenders must be added in addition al-Marz (d. 421) who wrote a Kitb al-Intir min alamat Ab Tammm (cf. Oriens, 1949, 268). The Abu 'l-\asan #Al al-urn (d. 366/976-7) in his Wasa bayn al-Mutanabb wa umih, ayd 1331, 58 ff., and al-$mid (d. 381) in his Muwzana bayn al-"iyyayn Ab Tammm wa 'l-Butur, Istanbul 1287 (Turkish transl. by Mehmed Weled, Istanbul 1311) weigh [I 154b] up his merits and demerits. Al-Marzubn (d. 384) in al-Muwaa, Cairo 1343, 303, 329, brings into prominence rather his weak points. Al-arf al-Murta in his al-ihb fi 'l-ayb wa 'l-abb, Istanbul 1302, defends the poet against al-$mid's strictures. The modern reader will follow the judgement of the old critics. Ab Tammm's adas contain, side by side with brilliant conceits which have established the poet's fame, much that is unpleasant. He has a penchant not only for queer words but also for artificial, frequently tortuous, sentence construction, the understanding of which much exercised the Arabic commentators. Unhappy personifications of abstract ideas, affected, far-fetched and unconvincing metaphors harass the reader often for many verses at a stretch till he stumbles on an excellent poetical figure. Added to this is an unfortunate tendency towards paronomasia and subtly-reasoned antithesis, to which he all too frequently sacrifices the clarity and attractiveness of the phrase (cf. #Abd al-|hir al-urn, Asrr al-Bala, ed. Ritter, 15). The Dwn was collected by al-l (alphabetically), by #Al b. \amza al-Ifahn (under subjects), also handed on by al-Sukkar (Oriens, 1949, 268) and others. Unsatisfactory editions Cairo 1299, Beyrut 1889, 1905, 1923, 1934. Index by Margoliouth in JRAS, 1905, 763-82. No edition exists as yet of the numerous comtaries, absolutely indispensable for the understanding of his poetry, by al-l, al-Marz, al-Tibrz, Ibn al-Mustawf (Abr, intr. 8; H. Ritter, Philologika, xiii, in Oriens, 1949, 266-9; \ alfa, under Dwn Ab Tammm, and Ism#l Paa, ^ al-Maknn fi 'l-ayl #al Kaf al-unn, i, Istanbul 1945, 422). [The commentary of al-Tibrz is in course of publication in Cairo;
2001 Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, The Netherlands
vol. i, 1952.] Ab Tammm collected in addition several anthologies of poetry. The best known is a collection of fragments (mua#t) by less known poets, which he made during his involuntary halt in Haman, the \amsa. Edited with the commentary of al-Tibrz by G. Freytag, Hamasae Carmina cum Tebrisii scholiis, Bonn 1828, Latin transl. 1847-51, reprinted with all the errors Bl 1284, Cairo 1938. On the numerous commentaries see Brockelmann, i, 134 ff.; H. Ritter, Philologika, iii, in Oriens, 1949, 246-61; \ alfa, s.v. \amsa, and Ism#l Paa, ^ al-Maknn, i, 422. Of the other anthologies there are preserved in manuscript the \amsa al-ur or al-Waiyyt (see Oriens, 1949, 261-2), not to be identified with any of the Itiyrt mentioned by al-$mid; and Itiyr al-u#ar" al-Ful in Mashhad (see MMIA, xxiv, 274). We know only the names of the remainder: al-Itiyrt min i#r al-u#ar" wa Mad al-ulaf" wa A aw"izihim (Fihrist, 165, Ma#hid al-Tan, 18); al-Itiyrt min A#r al-|ab"il (Fihrist) = al-Itiyr al-|ab"il al-Akbar and al-Itiyr al-|ab"il (Muwzana, 23); Itiyr al-Mua#t, beginning with azal (ib.); al-Itiyr min A#r al-Mudan (ib.). Also the Na"iarr wa 'l-Aal, ed. Salhani, Beyrout 1922, derives from him. (H. Ritter) Ab Bakr Mu. b. Yay al-l, Abr Ab Tammm, ed. all Mamd #Askir, Mu. #Abduh #Azzm, Nar al-Islm al-Hnd, Cairo 1937 Nar al-Islm, Die Abr ber Ab Tammm von a-l, Diss. Breslau 1940 An, xv, 100-8 al-ab al-Badd, Ta"r Badd, viii, 248-63 Ibn #Askir, al-Ta"r al-Kabr (Badrn), iv, 18-26 Ibn al-Anbr [I 155a] Nuzha, 213-6 Ibn Nubta, Sar al-#Uyn, Cairo, Mab. M. #Al ubay, 205-10 al#Abbs, Ma#hid al-Tan, Cairo, 18-20 Ibn allikn, no. 146 Ysuf al-Bad#, Hibat al-Ayym fm yata#alla bi-Ab Tammm, Cairo 1934 #Abd al-|dir al-Badd, iznat al-Adab, 1347, i, 322-3 Brockelmann, I, 12, 83-5, S I, 39-40, 134-7, 940, III, 1194 O. Rescher, Abriss, Stuttgart 1933, ii, 103-81.