Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Angela M. Rovnyak
USSO 279
Holy Flying Broomsticks Batman! Harry Potter and the Exemplification of the Superhero
Archetype
us all. Then… he shoots fire from the skies and it is difficult not to think
of him as a god. How fortunate we all are that it does not occur to him.” –
Batman
Reflecting upon his friend Clark Kent, better known as Superman, Batman speaks
about the dual natures of the superhero: the extraordinary power and abilities, and the
an ideal, perfect human being who would replace God: “What is the ape to men? A
laughing stock or a painful embarrassment. And just so shall man be to the Superman: a
superhero in Western folklore, rather than subjugating man, has become mankind’s hero
and savior:
The American monomyth [the story of the Superhero] derives from tales
elements of the selfless servant who impassively gives his life for others
and the zealous crusader who destroys evil (Lawrence and Jewett, 6).
One can apply this idea of a superhero- a super-powered individual who uses these
abilities to protect mankind, while being a part of mankind himself- to British author J.K.
Rowling’s character Harry Potter. Throughout the course of the series, his powers,
Potter as a superhero.
While not required to fit the Superman archetype, conventional superheroes often
do possess powers that exceed those of normal humans. Fitting with this convention,
Harry Potter, being a Wizard, wields powerful magic. Even within the Wizarding world,
he is especially talented- in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, he discovers that he is
naturally adept at flying upon a broom (Rowling, 148-149). In the second novel in the
series, Rowling reveals that Harry is a parselmouth; he has the ability to communicate
with snakes and other reptiles (Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, 195). In
addition, a common superhero convention is that the hero does not receive powers until
young adulthood- Superman did not find out his true identity until he was eighteen and
began to exhibit Kryptonian powers such as super strength and flight (“Superman
Biography, History”), and Spider-Man developed his powers including super strength and
wall crawling while a high school student (Koepp). Similarly, Harry is eleven years old
School of Witchcraft and Wizardry (Rowling, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone,
50).
Rovnyak, 3
…always begins with a threat arising against Eden’s [the harmonious city
under siege, its citizens pressed down by alien forces too powerful for
The utopia is presented as an idyllic haven for the hero, but is constantly being attacked
by the villain, who wishes to destroy peace, or enslave the citizens. Therefore, the hero
must protect this haven at all costs. An example of the beloved utopia of the Superhero is
the dual utopias of Smallville, Kansas and Metropolis, Illinois in Superman’s universe.
Metropolis. This is the part of the job I like best. High above the city I can
The way the wheat would cut across the north field as if it were going to
roll on forever. The stillness, except for the wind. And… my Dad would
gently remind me… it was time to go to work. (Loeb and Guinness, Part 1:
World’s Finest)
Harry Potter also has a utopia similar to Metropolis: Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and
Wizardry. In Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Rowling presents the Hogwarts
not as a Paradise, but as freedom from the Muggle (non-magical) world, saying that being
away from Hogwarts is like “like having a constant stomachache” (3). When Harry is not
Rovnyak, 4
at Hogwarts, he lives with his aunt and uncle, Petunia and Vernon Dursley, who force
him to sleep in the cupboard under the stairs, (Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, 19)
and speak about Harry as if he did not exist “or, rather, as though he was something very
nasty that couldn’t understand them, like a slug” (22). This description of Harry’s home
life emphasizes how much better Harry perceives his life at Hogwarts.
Much of the evil befalling the hero’s utopia is caused by his arch nemesis, an evil
person to whom the hero has a special connection. In the1989 Tim Burton film Batman,
the hero and his arch nemesis, the Joker, are revealed to have “created” each other.
Mafioso Jack Napier pulled a hit on Thomas and Martha Wayne when he was a young
man, scarring young Bruce for life and causing him to become the Batman. Years later,
Batman pushed Napier into a vat of hazardous waste, bleaching his skin, dying his hair
green, and driving him completely insane, causing him to become the Joker (Hamm and
throughout the books as “He who must not be named” or “You-Know-Who” because of
his extreme evil. Once known as Tom Marvolo Riddle, Voldemort was a student at
Hogwarts, who committed his first murder at the age of sixteen and went on to terrorize
the wizarding and Muggle worlds. Two of his victims were Lily and James Potter,
Harry’s parents. When attempting to murder Harry, a piece of Voldemort’s soul was
trapped in Harry’s body (Rowling, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, 709),
consequently, Voldemort’s existence is based upon Harry’s survival. In Harry Potter and
the Goblet of Fire, Voldemort uses Harry’s blood to bring himself into true physical
form, therefore; he and Harry are even more intrinsically connected (642). Harry and
Voldemort’s wands are also brothers; they each contain a tail feather from the same
Rovnyak, 5
phoenix (Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, 85). Harry’s drive to defeat Voldemort
inspires heroic actions. An example in established superhero lore is the murder of Bruce
Wayne’s parents:
Martha Wayne take my hands as we leave the theater. I can only imagine
the fear that gripped them when the gunman stepped out of the shadows…
never knowing that these were their last moments alive. I will never forget
the sound of the gun firing. Tiny pieces of metal ripping through the only
two people I ever loved. The blood, the acrid smell of gunpowder. My
future going black before my eyes. My parents lay in the street, bleeding
Harry Potter lost his parents in a similar manner: Lord Voldemort murdered Lily and
James Potter in front of his intended target: the infant Harry (Rowling, Harry Potter and
the Deathly Hallows, 328). Although he was much younger than Batman had been when
his parents died, he can recall their deaths just as vividly when in the presence of their
murderer:
“Lily, take Harry and go! It’s him! Go! Run! I’ll hold him off!”…
“Avada Kedavera!”
Rovnyak, 6
The green light filled the cramped hallway… [and] James Potter
“The green light flashed around the room and she dropped like her
husband (343-344).
Tragedy is not limited to the death of parents: Harry witnesses his godfather’s murder by
Voldemort’s minion Bellatrix LeStrange in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
(805-806), his friendly rival Cedric Diggory’s murder by Wormtail in Harry Potter and
the Goblet of Fire (638), and his mentor Albus Dumbledore’s apparent murder by
Severus Snape in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (596). He also witnesses the
murder of the vindicated Snape, again by Voldemort’s hand, in Harry Potter and the
Deathly Hallows (656). Instead of crushing the superhero’s spirit, tragic life experiences
inspire greatness; for example, the death of Peter Parker’s Uncle Ben inspires Peter to
take on the persona of Spiderman (Koepp). Likewise, when Harry is reunited with his
dead friends and relatives in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, he gains the courage
must not pursue them, else risking the life of his companion. In Spider-Man, Peter lies to
Mary Jane, telling her that he does not love her, in order to protect her from being hurt or
killed by another villain, since she had already been threatened by the Green Goblin
(Koepp). Superman cannot reveal his relationship with Lois Lane or tell her his secret
identity because of similar fears (Capizzi and Timm). In Harry Potter and the Half-Blood
Rovnyak, 7
Prince, Harry breaks up with his girlfriend Ginny Weasley because of the role he would
Ginny, listen… I can’t be involved with you anymore. We’ve got to stop
enemies are close to… Think how much danger you’ll be in if we keep
this up. He’ll know, he’ll find out. He’ll try and get to me through you
This is, in fact, a common tactic of the hero’s arch nemesis. In an episode of Batman: The
Animated Series, the Joker kidnaps Batman’s girlfriend Catwoman. The Joker’s lover and
partner in crime Harley Quinn then keeps Catwoman hostage in a cat-food factory (Dini,
By fighting the villain, the hero demonstrates his superior morality which,
ironically, may require that he break the law. In the hero mythos, “the vigilante has
become a saint, not merely through superior virtue, but also through superhuman power”
(Lawrence and Jewett, 40). Harry Potter has little trouble breaking rules. In Harry Potter
and the Sorcerer’s Stone, Harry uses his Invisibility Cloak to sneak into the Restricted
section of the school library (Rowling, 205-206), and fights another student after hours
(155); in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, he uses the Marauder’s map to sneak
off school grounds (194), among other infractions. Some circumvention of established
order must be committed because the establishment itself is evil or works against good.
In Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Harry forms a group called Dumbledore’s
Army, out of respect for Hogwarts Headmaster Albus Dumbledore, and in opposition to
Ministry of Magic import High Inquisitor Dolores Umbridge (389-393). By Harry Potter
Rovnyak, 8
and the Deathly Hallows, Harry is a fugitive from Voldemort’s minions, who are the
current power in the Wizarding world: “The Ministry [of Magic] has fallen! [Minister]
Scrimgeour is dead. [Voldemort’s minions, The Death Eaters] are coming” (159). In
comparison, both Batman and Superman have been fugitives from the latter’s arch rival,
Lex Luthor, who is the current President of the United States. (Loeb and Guiness, Part
1:World’s Finest) The virtue of the superhero is such to the extent that he not only fights
against evil, but would give up his own life for those around him. In Superman:
Doomsday, Superman realizes that he and Doomsday, a powerful alien warrior, cannot
both live. Therefore, in order that the people of Metropolis would be free from harm,
Superman dies in the battle that also kills Doomsday. (Capizzi and Timm) Around the
time of Harry’s birth, Sybil Trelawney prophesied that neither Harry nor Voldemort
could “live while the other survives” (Rowling, Harry Potter and the Order of the
Phoenix, 856), and in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Harry agrees to die by
Voldemort’s hand in order to save the world from Voldemort’s evil (704).
According to a spokesperson from UCI cinemas, “Superheroes have often been favorite
characters in movies” (“Superman is ‘Greatest Superhero’”). Harry Potter has taken not
only the wizarding world by storm, but ours as well. As of July 16, 2005 Harry Potter
books 1-5 had sold over 265 million copies in 200 countries, and had been translated into
62 languages. 10 million copies of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince were sold
within the first 24 hours of release (“Potter Fans Snap Up Latest Book”). Harry Potter
and the Goblet of Fire was the best-selling item on Amazon.com for fourteen weeks prior
Rovnyak, 9
to its release in 2000 (Blake, 1). In fact, these kinds of books have always been popular
Thousands of images of heroes and heroines larger than life, with powers
“Fat Superman” and “Ugly Power Girl” waiting for a chance to see a favorite artist, or
view the preview for Dark Knight at WizardWorld 2007 in Chicago. He says that these
fans often dress as their favorite character, one that they idolize and wish to emulate.
Harry Potter is also an object of idolization by adults. Each midnight release of the
newest Harry Potter book has seen not only children, but also adults dressed as their
favorite characters, the characters that they idolize and admire most. This popularity and
idolization is due to several different factors, including the excitement of epic battles and
the hero’s humanity, which foster both reader and viewer identification with the
superhero protagonist.
Epic battles often play a major role in established superhero lore as well as the
lore of Harry Potter. Superman: Doomsday shows Superman fighting a clone of himself
in the sky above Metropolis (Capizzi and Timm); Spider-Man features a special effects-
laden battle in Times Square between the hero and the Green Goblin (Koepp). During the
Triwizard tournament in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, the champions must
retrieve a golden egg from a dragon’s nest. To achieve this end, Harry swoops down on
Rovnyak, 10
his Firebolt broom to the cheers of the audience, dizzying and confusing the dragon,
He began to fly, first this way, then the other, not near enough to make her
breathe fire to stave him off, but still posing a sufficient threat to ensure
she kept her eyes on him… He flew higher. The Horntail’s head rose with
him, her neck now stretched to its fullest extent… And then she reared,
spreading her great, black, leathery wings at last… Before the dragon
knew what he had done, or where he had disappeared to, he was speeding
toward the ground as fast as he could go… he had seized the egg
(Rowling, 355-356).
In Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Harry performed a similar heroic feat, albeit
without an audience. During an attempt to save Ron’s sister Ginny, Harry is attacked by
the same basilisk that had been terrorizing the school throughout the book and kills it
with the legendary Sword of Gryffindor (320). According to film scholar Noel Carroll,
highly charged film scenes, like a battle against a monstrous figure in a horror film, elicit
strong emotions from audience members. These emotions run parallel to the protagonist,
since they are experiencing the same emotions from the same object (Smith, 68). These
parallel emotions allow the viewer or reader to experience an emotional connection with
Another reason for the popularity of superheroes is their inherent humanity. For
college courses, and never has enough money to pay the rent in his run-down apartment
(Raimi, et al). Superman is actually a newspaper reporter named Clark Kent, who
Rovnyak, 11
struggles through everyday life and is too shy to talk to his attractive coworker Lois
(Capizzi and Timm). Harry Potter is a normal teenager who has awkward first dates
(Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, 557-563), crams for standardized tests (310-
311), and worries about his Astronomy homework (295). Also, in the epilogue of Harry
Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Rowling reveals that Harry eventually works for the
Ministry of Magic and lives a normal adult life with his wife, Ginny, and their children
(754). Average Americans are able to identify with superheroes because of these normal
human vulnerabilities.
Also accounting for the popularity of superheroes is their ability to reflect the
times and culture in which they exist. Jerry Seigel and Joe Schuster, a writer and artist
Jews to exemplify what were considered American values. Drawing upon their Jewish
background, Seigel and Schuster wrote Superman to do good for its own sake, fight the
enemies of America abroad, and fight un-American evil at home; for example, Superman
saves women from abusive husbands (Kramer). Reflecting the American hatred of
Fascism and Communism and America’s perceived role as a global enforcer of justice,
Superman single-handedly defeats Adolf Hitler, tells him he’d “like to land a strictly non-
Aryan sock on your skull!” while holding him by the throat, and drags him and Josef
Stalin to jail. (Seigel and Schuster) Also during the Second World War, Timely Comics
(later Marvel Comics) introduced Captain America, who in his first appearance is shown
punching Adolf Hitler across the jaw (Simon and Kirby, Cover). After the United States
was attacked on September 11, 2001, Marvel Comics published several books with
heroes such as Captain America and Spider-Man assisting in the rescue efforts, but
Rovnyak, 12
crumbling emotionally while New York City firefighters and police officers stand strong
(Nyman). Harry Potter, despite being the brainchild of a British author, still exemplifies
American values:
makes Harry Potter fit in so well? First, Harry Potter affirms what
America has always most believed in. It affirms our story, our values and
our truths. Americans have always loved the innocent hero who faces a
dangerous challenge with integrity and overcomes it. This is the American
story. It is the story that starts with the pilgrims and runs right up to the
(Blanchard).
Harry also fights against un-American enemies. Rowling has admitted that Lord
Voldemort is modeled after Hitler; he aims to cleanse the world of Muggles (non-magical
people) and Mudbloods (magical people of Muggle parentage), echoing the Third Reich’s
children learn moral values from watching superheroes, and associate their own morals
with those of superheroes. The effect of superheroes upon people’s thoughts has not
gone unnoticed: In 1940, Nazi propaganda magazine Das schwertze Korps published a
impressive appearance, a powerful body, and a red swim suit who enjoys
the ability to fly through the ether… The inventive Israelite named this
hate, suspicion, evil, laziness, and criminality in their young hearts. (“Jerry
Seigel Attacks!”)
Also, superheroes have been used in propaganda to support causes. For example,
Spiderman has been used to teach children and teenagers about birth control and to
upcoming Batman graphic novel, a piece which is admittedly propaganda, will depict
Batman battling al Quaeda and Osama bin Laden (Robinson). The Harry Potter novels
have also influenced children’s morality, with many children saying that Harry Potter’s
love and protectiveness of his friends, courage, and willingness to save lives are qualities
which they would like to emulate. (Vozzola) However, some American Christian groups
condemn Harry Potter because of fears that it will lead children to Witchcraft and away
from Jesus. They insist that Harry Potter is not harmless fantasy:
wizards and witches from a popular peer perspective rather than from
God's perspective. Those who sense that the occult world is evil face a
Rovnyak, 14
Harry's supernatural adventures. The second choice may quiet the nagging
doubts, but rationalizing evil and justifying sin will sear the conscience
and shift the child's perception of values from God's perspective to a more
to conform truth to multicultural ideals and turn God's values upside down
Additionally, reading Harry Potter has made British children increasingly enroll in
boarding school, and American children enroll in summer camps in a phenomenon the
Boarding School community terms the “Harry Potter Effect” (Boarding Schools Info).
In reference to superheroes, Batman and 300 graphic novelist Frank Miller once
said, “The Greeks had their gods and heroes… We have ours. What are they here for?”
(Robinson) Superman, Batman, Captain America, Spiderman, and other comic book
superheroes serve as both role models and mirrors for the time and culture in which they
are written. A far cry from the Superman of Nietzschean philosophy, the superhero of
man’s weaknesses and faults. Through their personality, morals, and experiences,
with other superheroes, Harry Potter also exemplifies this idealized version of manhood.
Harry, Superman, Batman, and other superheroes have been popular through most of the
twentieth century, and, if the first decade of the twenty-first is any indication, they will
Works Cited
Blake, Andrew. The Irresistible Rise of Harry Potter. 2002. Verso. London.
Blanchard, Tsvi. “Harry Potter and the American Philosopher’s Stone”. December 2001.
Published on The National Jewish Center for Learning and Leadership. Retrieved
Boarding Schools Info. “Harry Potter’s Strange Secret of Hogwarts: He Gets Kids to
<http://www.boardingschoolsinfo.com/harry-potter-effect.html >.
Capizzi, Duane and Bruce Timm. (screenwriters) Superman: Doomsday. (film) 2007.
Deshpande, Sudhanva. “Harry Potter and the Dilemma of the Left”. August 2005.
<http://www.zmag.org/sustainers/content/2005-08/12deshpande.cfm >.
Dini, Paul.(screenwriter) “Almost Got ‘Im”. Batman: The Animated Series. Season 4,
Animation.
Flynn, Patricia. “Comic Books: Super heroes/heroines, Domestic Scenes and Animal
<http://www.yale.edu/ynhti/curriculum/units/1980/2/80.02.03.x.html>.
Hamm, Sam and William Skaaren. (screenwriters) Batman. (film) 1989. Warner
Brothers.
Rovnyak, 16
Hayes, Bryan. “Friedrich Nietzsche and his philosophy of the Superman.” October 2000.
sage.org/philosophy/nietzsche_philosophy.html#Friedrich_Nietzsche>.
Kjos, Bert. “Twelve Reasons Not to See Harry Potter Movies.” 2001. Retrieved
Kramer, Blair. “Superman”. 2007. Published on the Jewish Virtual Library. Retrieved
<http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/biography/superman.html >.
Lawrence, John Shelton and Robert Jewett. The Myth of the American Superhero. 2002.
<http://www.superherostuff.com/Biographies/SupermanBio.html>.
their Moral Understanding” (Abstract) Journal of Moral Education. V36 n2, June
2007. pp 239-250.
Nyman, Michael. “Hero and Superhero”. Published in The Guardian. April 2004.
<http://arts.guardian.co.uk/guesteditors/story/0,,1201733,00.html >.
Rovnyak, 17
Raimi, Sam, Ivan Raimi and Alvin Sargent. (screenwriters) Spider-Man 3. (film) 2007.
Columbia Pictures.
Robinson, Ann and Ross Andru. The Amazing Spider-Man vs. The Prodigy. 1976. Marvel
Robinson, Bryan. “Batman Takes Aim at Osama”. ABC News. February 14, 2006.
<http://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/Story?id=1616836&page=1>.
Rowling, JK. Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone. 1997. Scholastic Books. New York.
--. Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. 1998. Scholastic Books. New York.
--. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. 1999. Scholastic Books. New York.
--. Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. 2000. Scholastic Books. New York.
--. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. 2003. Scholastic Books. New York.
--. Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince. 2005. Scholastic Books. New York.
--. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. 2007. Scholastic Books. New York.
Seigel, Jerry and Joe Shuster. “How Superman Would End The War”. Published in Look.
Simon, Joe and Jack Kirby. Captain America #1. March 1941. Timely Comics.
Smith, Greg M. Film Structure and the Emotion System. 2003. Cambridge University
“Potter Fans Snap Up Latest Book” BBC News. 16 July 2005. Retrieved 16 October
2007 <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/4683503.stm>.
Vozzola, Elizabeth. (Interview) MercatorNet. “What kids can learn from Harry Potter”.
<http://www.mercatornet.com/articles/what_kids_can_learn_from_harry_potter/
>.