Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ic^^
CAVE EXl'LURATIua.
BY
E. H.
IWLE31.1S.
il.A., F.G.H.,
OF
H.3I.
GEOLOGICAL SUltVEt
..x;
6'.
TIIK
H.
TIDDEMAN,
M.A., F.G.S.,
has become by
name
at least well
known
to Yorkshire-
many
outside the
Many
notices
down
interesting
work on " Cave Hunting," Prof. B. Dawkins has given a valuable resume of what has been done up to 1873. But very much has been done since that time, and some
valuable results have accrued which deserve to be put on
record in connection with what has been previously done.
it
is
only right
knowing
in
what those funds have been spent, what have far, and what may be the problems awaitwill be neces-
it
much
The
Yictoria Cave
is
range at
tlie
faces S.S.W.
feet)
and 900
feet
The southern aspect of the Cave, sheltered from the north and from the east by the cliff in which it is formed, would give it an advantage as a habitation, whether for man or Strangely enough this cavern, which has been a resort beast.
in such widely separated ages of the w^orld's history,
was on
the day of
Her Majesty's Coronation completely concealed, and unknown to any one. To Mr. Joseph Jackson, of Settle, belongs the honour of
its discover}'
still
more of the
intelligent
its
The
may
be seen
in the British
private collection.
time, as Prof.
Museum, in the Leeds Museum, and in his own The Cave furnished him from time to B. Dawkins states, wdth " a remarkable series
Fragments of
Roman
invasion.
and
and
studs.
to
and dog.
was just of
Roman
villas
is very generally found in the neighbourhood of and towns, and was doubtless formed while the
work
accomplishment.
He
late Mr. Stackhouse, and induced some of the gentry of the neighbourhood and others to form a Committee, under Sir James Kay -Shuttle worth, for
was opened, and donations Hawkins kindly undertook the Mr. John Birkbeck, Jun., scientific direction of the work.f accepted the post of Hon. Treasurer and Secretary, and the
the purpose.
subscription-list
came in
liberally.
Prof.
assist-
was resolved
to
remove the
screes
at
new
The
men
to
work
Hawkins
have been chosen by the inhabitants for kindling their fires and cooking their food. On the surface
there was a talus, 2 feet thick, of angular fragments, broken
" to
cliff
frost.
H rested
Authrop.
Inst., vol.
i.,
p. CI.
in
Dawkins was obliged by stress of work to resign this responsibility the summer of 1873, and at the request of the Committee the Author
Prof.
it.
undertook
+
Op. Cit.
less
burnt, burnt stones wbich had formed the fire places, very-
many fragments
Fires had been kindled on the spot, and the broken bones of the
relics of
the feast."
As work
continued the talus over this layer died out inwards, and
" the black layer below rose to the surface, and was continuous
and implements
The
beads,
Some
of
them are
Stevens,
much
in military dress.
The use of
by Mr.
who
now
a small
Roman
by Mr. Franks. In bronze many articles and ornaments were found, some of them beautifully enamelled in red, blue, yellow, and green, and of graceful
sword
hilt
identified
designs.
them Eoman
in form, are
Roman
type.
all
"
The
are
of the
Roman
villas.
The bones
fair
the
The
gifrons)
animal food.
The
variety
and in the
deposits around
Roman
A domestic
This
bill of fare
was varied by
To
this list
of the roedeer and the stag, but the remains of these two
Two
and a few bones of wild duck and grouse, complete the list of the animals which can with certainty be affirmed to have been eaten by the cave-dwellers." *
tino,
Prof Dawkins shows that the coins of Trajan, Constanand Tetricus, and some barbarous imitations of Roman
coins, assigned
by numismatists
of Britain by the
articles of
luxury in so rude a
"
was used in those troublous times by unfortunate provincials, who fled from their homes, with some of their cattle
that
it
to
exchange the
for a
feet
plateau
slope the
less,
covered by a
foot,
and sometimes
of
Post-Roman
it
talus,
and
as
it
came
to
the surface.
lie
at
a spot
beneath the
fragments.
Beneath the
Romano-Celtic layer
what had
together,
at
some
now bound
though
by
dripping water.
At
Op.
Cit., p. 65.
no
shaft),
a plane
through
its
axis
rectilinear ornamentation,
and three
flint flakes.
Just as the
came to the
into the
away
and run
flint
Roman
layer.
implement of lanceolate-leaf
in Mr.
side of a cutting
some figured
screes,
fallen
It
Sections across
it
would give
a
triangular,
and near
the bulb
plano-convex,
Amongst Mr.
in the
Leeds Museum,
side
by
side
So uniform
is
It
probable
layer.
also
We have now
of history.
earlier
earliest records
still
In describing these I
it
appeared
in
Chamber D, the
*
at its present
+ Cave Hunting,
p. 114.
It
Moreover, no account of
to the
Cave
and Neolithic
in one portion.
the
demands a correspondingits
formation, and
absence or thinness
its
existence
elsewhere.
importance as
eras in
which
different climatal
In
much
in
common.
Upper and Lower Cave-Earth have They both consist of large and small
stiff
buff
and
stalactite
or puddled
certainly
clay,
it
are
found
of this
finely-bedded
structure,
this
and
is
simply homogeneous.
good deal of
through
by
little
8
weatlier, althougli at present certainh' all water that drops
to be -well filtered.
chinks have
possibly of the
above
the conditions
Both these
it,
bearing
Upper and
man and
animals scattered
This
it
induced
me
to getting
it shows to them more particularly with a view the conditions under which it
was formed.
yet
so
The lamina)
as to
into
which
it
is
when
it
pulled asimder,
a
make
the digging of
work of great
fine
labour.
It is
impalpIt
able mud.
About 8 per
chambers
hitherto explored.
In the
left
hand Chamber B,
It
it
showed a
thickness of 12
feet, in
was thin
it
at the entrance,
more than 70
feet,
which
is
have
In
formation.
b-3.
9
with true glacial beds in neighbourhood.
many
At Ingleton
and
there
this
with well
The conclusion
that
alternating periods of flow and rest was prima facie not improbable, but seemed to explain the difficulties.
The great
we know
existed
We
and
still
later the
at the cave
at the
Cave Mouth.
to
As the explorations
From
year to
went on
viously,
it
results accrued.
For
fuller
disputed by Prof. Dawkius (Cave Hunting, p. 122) on the ground of 1st, laminated clay occurring in cre\ices in the Lower Cave-Earth, beneath the main mass. On this point vide supra p. 84.* 2ndly,
7
This conclusion
This seems to me beside the question, not " Can laminated clay be deposited under other than glacial conditions?" (to which I would give a decided affirmative), but "What were the
me), in pools, in the Ingleborough Cave.
which
is
prevailing conditions
when
so large a
mass of laminated
clay
was deposited iu
the Victoria Cave, contrasting so strongly with the great thickness of beds
it ?
10
year a great deposit of glacial has been uncovered
:
till
and other
glacial deposits
some
it
and some
first
still
remains.
As we
we
came upon a
Deeper
sizes,
Some
many were
is
which the
cave
formed.
when
Car-
still
ice
we must
The accumulation
do on a
are
col
no gathering grounds
mere
was
local glacier,
must be up
when
feet
below
us,
filled
with
ice
to
The ice scratches on the rocks at the base of King Scar hard by show us the direction in which it travelled across the col from Stainforth towards Long Preston
higher.
by way
of
Attermire
eviice-
sheet covered all the country visible from the cave mouth,
11
It
first
left
there
by the
ice-sheet, but
might have
fallen
cliff
subsequently.
This question
I will
is this
The boulders
lie at
the base of
all
whole thickness.
2.
The
cliff
is
The
destruction of the
must have
for
fallen subse-
quently.
cliff
it
Even now
it
the boulders
lie
that
them
to fall
from
But
if
we
cliff all
fall
The extent
now
exjDOsed
is
so
great, covering
is
boulders.
The Life of
"We
have now
briefly
we can from
the facts at
who
by these
beds.
12
Man.
Hyaena.
Rhinoceros leptorhimts.f
Hippopotamus.
Fox.
Bos primigenius.
Bear.
Bison.
Brown
Grisly Bear.
Red
Deer.
Elephas nntiquun.
The
is
a layer of
bones
Prom the characteristic gnawing and cracking of the we may conclude that to him and the other carnivores
Although a
fibula of
we
fossils.
there
is
no
evi-
dence so far
this
sufficient to justify us in
But
that he
when
roaming
"Whether
over the
can be no doubt.
him
is
it
a question
to
be thrown upon
by further
of Great Britain
when
brought piecemeal
into,
the Cavern.
marked
species,
point to a very
warm
chiefly
is founded on a misconception, and will have to give place to Prof. Owen's term leptorliinun. " Catalogue of the Pleistocene
Museum,
1874:.
only.''
\
and
as
13
to
have also
lived in
warm
countries.
The
Upon we have an assemblage of sj)ecies which live in, a tolerably warm climate. Arctic
This state of things must have
become
more
scarce, the
more
The
and the
we come upon
laminated clay, intcrbedded with an occasional layer of stalagmite, but without a trace of
way up through
it,
some wellnaturally
we
left
by a vanished
and
we
ask
Do
endurance.
roof,
and then those of greater powers of The laminated clay here fills the cave up to the
it
but
we
follow
A bed of
mud and
fallen stones
comes on above
:
it
(the
Upper Cave-
Man
Fox.
(traces
of)
as
evi-
Horse.
Pig.
denced by
hachecl bones.
Reindeer.
Grisly Bear.
Red
Deer.
Brown
Bear.
Goat or Sheep.
Badg-er.
and cold
14
conditions,
down
But
as appa-
mixed up together
at the surface.
The reindeer
ditions.
we
The reindeer
ice-sheet
waning of the
it
we have no
lived there during the cold times preceding its full develop-
talus,
20
feet
and upwards in
on Avhich
it lies
were
of
left
by the
ice-sheet.
There
tions
is
no evidence throughout
to
it
from subaerial
marine or
off,
fluviatile.
But we know
we have
some
is
six or seven
hundred
feet perhaps.
it
The
absolute depth
to
a marked absence of
district.
Still this
to
appearance of
as
shown
a
sub-
of
mergence
over large areas in the Old and the JJTew World, and in both
hemispheres, in
so
common
to
myths
in their surroundings.
The
central
dis-
figured
by the
LIST OF
...On
Victoria
i.
Cave,
5.
Collectanea
Antiqua.
Jackson, Joseph
Vol.
No,
1-860.
Denny,
On
of the Victoria
in Craven.
Proc.
Vol.
iv.
1865.
Smith, Ecroyd
of Ctaven.
Tram.
Hist.
Morrison,
Walter
On
the Exploration of the Settle Caves, Yorkshire (Abstract). Trans, of the Plymouth
Institution.
Vol.
iv.,
part
2.
1872.
Dawkins, "W.Boyd
Report of the Eesults obtained by the Settle Cave Explorations Committee out of Victoria Cave in 1870. Journ. Anthrop. Institute.
Vol.
i.,
p. 60.
TiDDEMAN, E.
Discovery of Pleistocene
toria Cave, Settle.
Mammals
in the Vicvii,
Nature.
Vol.
1873.
Settle.
Proc. Lit.
1873, p. 95.
Tiddeman, E.
Eeport on the Victoria Cave. The Physical History of the Deposits. Ibid.
in
the Victoria
Cave,
The Age
of the
North
of
England Ice-Sheet.
in
ix,,
Ibid, p. 140.
The Eelation of Man to the Ice-Sheet Nature. Vol. the North of England.
No. 210,
p. 14.
16
1874.
BcsK, Prof.
On
Human
Anthrojx
Vol.
iii.,
p. 392.
Dawkins, Prof,
516-7.
Committee for
assisting in tlie
of
and
Co.
1875.
Evans, John
Presidential Address.
TiDDEMAN, E. H.
..%
Second Eeport of the Committee appointed fur the purpose of assisting in the Exploration of the Settle Caves (Victoria Cave). Brit.
As-oc. Reports for 1S74, p. 133.
Abstract of the Third Eeport of the Settle Caves (Victoria Cave) Committee, read at
Bristol, in
EXPLAITATION OF PLATE
D. Chamber D. B. G.Birkbeck
V.
V. ^Vertical line from Cliff. X.-Z. Approximate present depth of workings (Dec, 1875). a. Eomano-Celtic layer.
Gallery.
h.
c.
Neolithic horizon.
Upper Cave
Laminated
with some layers of Stalagmite. d\ Glacial Drift. Earth with bone bed containing Hyaena, Cave e. Lower Hippopotamus, Man, &c.
d.
clay,
X
s.
I.
Position of the
Screes or Talus.
Human
Fibula.
Limestone rock.
vertical lines represent the
The numbered
1
to 40.
McCoRquoDALB &
Co.,
Printers, Leed?.