Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
A1
01-04-13
Initial Submission
MARK
DATE
DESCRIPTION
APPROVED BY (LTSE)
Project Director
Joint Project Director
SYSTEMS
Atul Jain
CheeChiak Yang
CIVIL
Prepared By
Vivek Pagnis
Checked By
DATE: 10.04.2013
DATE
CONTRACTORS DOCUMENT
No.:
DOCUMENT No.:
MM001-D-DR-VSP-LTSE-311050
REVISION
A1
10-April-2013
PRELIMINARY NOTE
This document is the exclusive property of LTSE.
It is confidential and may not be used, reproduced or communicated either in
whole or in part, in any form or manner without the prior written agreement of
LTSE.
This document shall not be distributed to third parties except under the terms of
the contract.
REVISION STATUS
A1
10-04-13
Initial Submission
AMS
VVP
ZZ
Rev.
Date
Revision Note
Designed by
Checked by
Approval by
10-April-2013
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
1.0 SUMMARY
This report contains the detailed superstructure guide-way beam design of Frame No. 17 with a curved
alignment in plan and 27+22+26m span configuration. The results are shown below:
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 1 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Fig. 3.2 : Sign convention of internal forces in the element's local coordinate system
Guideway
Piers
RC Portals
Pilecaps
Piles
60
45
45
35
35
Fcu (Mpa)
60
45
45
35
35
48
36
36
28
28
36000
32500
32500
29500
29500
B) Post-tensioning tendons: The following mechanical properties of prestressing tendon are adopted in the
design.
Nominal diameter
= 15.24 mm
= 140 mm2
LTSE
= 75% of GUTS
Class of relaxation
= Normal
Modulus of elasticity, E
= 195000 MPa
Friction coefficients, k
= .17
Wobble coefficient,
= .002
Draw-In at anchorage
= 6 mm
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 2 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 3 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
GUIDEWAY BEAMS
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 4 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
4.0 Summary
This section documents the detailed design of the Prestressed Guideway Beams. Generally, the guideway
beam consists of rectangular solid end blocks at both ends (2.2m height), and towards the mid span (2.2m
height) that is made of hollow box sections. There are three types of beams; Beam Type GB276 and GB278
at ends and GB277 at intermediate span. Fig. 4.1 shows the dimensions and locations of post-tensioned
tendons. Table 4.1 summarizes the details for post-tensioned tendons and Table 4.2 shows the summary of
main bars and torsion/shear links. Further details are contained in the construction drawings.
Mid
Section
Solid
Section
LTSE
Beam
Type
Top Bars
Bottom Bars
Side Bars
GB
269,271
9T16
9T16
GB 270
9T16
9T16
GB
269,271
18T16
4T25 + 4T25
T16
GB 270
18T16
18T16
T16
2L-T16@100c/c outer
inner links
2L-T16@100c/c outer
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 5 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
The design calculations of the precast post-tensioned guideway beams comprise of the
following:
(i) Pre-stressing design at SLS
(ii) Check Bending Capacity of Beam at ULS
(iii) Design for Shear force and Torsional Moment at ULS
(iv) Design of Beam End Block.
The mechanical properties of prestressing tendon adopted in the design are as shown below.
Nominal diameter = 15.24 mm (0.6)
Nominal tensile strength = 1860 MPa (GUTS)
Nominal strand area = 140 mm2
Specified characteristic breaking load = 260 kN
Stress at anchorage (jacking) = 75% of GUTS (1395 MPa)
Class of relaxation = very low relaxation (relaxation at 1000h =2.50 % of GUTS)
Modulus of elasticity, E = 195000 MPa
Friction coefficients, k = 0.17
Wobble coefficient, = 0.002 rad/m
Draw-In at anchorage = 6 mm
The stress limitations of prestressed concrete under serviceability loads are shown below.
a)
Transfer stage
Load Combination
All
b)
Type of stress
Compressive Stress
Tensile stress
Service stage
Load Combination
All
Type of stress
Compressive Stress
Tensile stress
S1
S2a, S2b, S3a, S3b
& S4
Tensile stress
LTSE
Allowable Stress
Lesser of
0.5 x 48 = 24 Mpa
0.4 x 60 = 24 Mpa
1.0 Mpa
Allowable Stress
0.4 x 60 = 24 Mpa
0.0 Mpa
0.36 x 60 = 2.79 Mpa
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 6 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 7 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
AT TRANSFER STAGE
Envelope Stresses Diagrams for Track 1
Top Fiber
Span 1
Span 2
Span 3
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 8 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Bottom Fiber
Span 1
Span 2
Span 3
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 9 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Envelope Stresses Diagrams for Track 2
Top Fiber
Span 1
Span2
Span 3
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 10 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Bottom Fiber
Span 1
Span 2
Span 3
Conclusion
Stresses
Compressive stress
Top Fiber
Tensile stress
Bottom
Compressive stress
Tensile stress
Fiber
LTSE
Allowable (Mpa)
-24
1
-24
1
Actual (Mpa)
-1.856
1.03
-4.892
0
Remark
OK
OK
OK
OK
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 11 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 12 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
AT SERVICE STAGE
Stresses due to service load combinations 1 (zero tension design) for both track 1 & track 2
Envelope Stresses Diagrams for Track 1 as shown as follows:
Top Fiber
SPAN 1
SPAN2
SPAN 3
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 13 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Bottom Fiber
SPAN1
SPAN2
SPAN 3
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 14 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Envelope Stresses Diagrams for Track 2 as shown as follows:
Top Fiber
SPAN 1
SPAN 2
SPAN 3
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 15 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Bottom Fiber
SPAN 1
SPAN 2
SPAN 3
Conclusion
Stresses
Compressive stress
Top Fiber
Tensile stress
Bottom
Compressive stress
Tensile stress
Fiber
LTSE
Allowable (Mpa)
-24
0
-24
0
Actual (Mpa)
-13.48
0
-12.58
0
Remark
OK
OK
OK
OK
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 16 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Stresses due to service load combinations 2 to 4 for both track 1 & track 2
Envelope Stresses Diagrams for Track 1 as shown as follows:
Top Fiber
SPAN 1
SPAN2
SPAN 3
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 17 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 18 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Bottom Fiber
SPAN1
SPAN2
SPAN 3
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 19 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
SPAN 2
SPAN 3
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 20 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Bottom Fiber
SPAN 1
SPAN 2
SPAN 3
Conclusion
Stresses
Compressive stress
Top Fiber
Tensile stress
Bottom
Compressive stress
Fiber
Tensile stress
LTSE
Allowable (Mpa)
-24
2.78
-24
2.78
Actual (Mpa)
-13.92
0.798
-13.77
0
Remark
OK
OK
OK
OK
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 21 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
LTSE
Load
Axial (kN)
U4(max)
410.35
U3b(min)
447.42
U4(min)
211.43
U4(max)
230.7
U3b(min)
169.2
U3b(max)
97.31
Moment-y Moment-z
(kNm)
(kNm)
3363.71
215.06
2490.73
138.57
4932.76
124.35
7177.02
246.24
5914.15
493.81
6225.24
529.8
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 22 of 71
Specification
General Specification
Code of Practice
Country
Bending Axes
BS5400
India
Biaxial
Section 1 Details
Definition
Name
Type
Material
Perimeter
Section Area
Reinforcement Area
Reinforcement
Mid-section
Concrete
C60
1.407E+6mm2
23710.mm2
1.685%
Section Nodes
Node
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Y
[mm]
375.0
400.0
400.0
375.0
-375.0
-400.0
-400.0
-375.0
110.0
110.0
-110.0
-110.0
Z
[mm]
1100.
1075.
-1075.
-1100.
-1100.
-1075.
1075.
1100.
850.0
-750.0
-750.0
850.0
10-April-2013
Page 23 of 71
Bars
Bar
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
[mm]
-326.0
-217.3
-108.7
0.0
108.7
217.3
326.0
-326.0
-217.3
-108.7
0.0
108.7
217.3
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-225.0
-225.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
326.0
148.0
-326.0
-148.0
0.0
326.0
148.0
-326.0
-148.0
0.0
Z
[mm]
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
-1010.
-1010.
-804.0
-804.0
872.0
872.0
1010.
1010.
0.0
-925.0
-899.0
-699.0
-499.0
-299.0
-99.00
101.0
301.0
501.0
701.0
-899.0
-699.0
-499.0
-299.0
-99.00
101.0
301.0
501.0
701.0
-691.0
-491.0
-291.0
-91.00
109.0
309.0
509.0
709.0
-788.0
-788.0
-788.0
-788.0
-788.0
888.0
888.0
888.0
888.0
888.0
Diameter
[mm]
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
42.22
42.22
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
Material
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Strands
Strands
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Type
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Pre-stress Pre-stress
Appl. loads
Force
Strain
include/exclude
pre-stress
[kN]
-1860.
-1530.
exclude
exclude
10-April-2013
Page 24 of 71
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
225.0
225.0
225.0
-225.0
-691.0
-491.0
-291.0
-91.00
109.0
309.0
509.0
709.0
0.0
-925.0
250.0
250.0
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
42.22
42.22
42.22
42.22
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
-1860.
-1530.
-1860.
-1860.
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
Elastic Properties
Properties of the untransformed section, ignoring reinforcement.
Geometric Centroid
y
z
Area
Second Moments of Area
Iyy
Izz
Iyz
0.0mm
-12.51mm
1.407E+6mm2
632.2E+9mm4
92.26E+9mm4
33.06E-6mm4
632.2E+9mm4
Torsion Constant
Section Modulus
Zy
92.26E+9mm4
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0mm4
568.2E+6mm3
Plastic Modulus
Zz
Zpy
230.6E+6mm3
825.1E+6mm3
Zpz
Ry
Rz
332.2E+6mm3
670.4mm
256.1mm
Izz
Angle
ky
kz
Radius of Gyration
y
z
EA
EI
EIyy
EIzz
EIyz
Principal EI
0.01648mm
-6.685mm
55.91E+6kN
23.64E+6kNm2
5.135E+6kNm2
-85.09kNm2
EIuu
EIzz
Angle
23.64E+6kNm2
5.135E+6kNm2
Nu
-17270.kN
0.0[-]
0.1622kNm
407.4E-6kNm
Myy
Mzz
-263.5E-6
10-April-2013
Page 25 of 71
Note: Nmax is the maximum compressive force which can be carried by the section.
This is calculated by applying a constant strain across the entire section, using
ultimate material properties.
Concrete
C60
Normal Weight
2.300t/m3
60000.kPa
3718.kPa
37.00E+6kPa
fcu
fct
E
0.2000
12.00E-6/C
mc,ULS 1.500
mc,SLS 1.000
0.003500[-]
Recto-parabolic
No-tension
Linear
No-tension
20.00mm
Reinforcement Properties
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Fe 500
500000.kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
Strands
1.857E+6kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
Loading
Reference Point
All loading acts through the Reference Point.
All strain planes are defined relative to the Reference Point.
Definition
Reference Point Coordinates
y
z
Geometric
Centroid
0.0mm
-12.51mm
10-April-2013
Page 26 of 71
Applied loads
Load Case
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
N
[kN]
410.3
447.4
211.4
230.7
169.2
97.31
1
2
3
4
5
6
Myy
[kNm]
3364.
2491.
4933.
7177.
5914.
6225.
Mzz
[kNm]
215.1
138.6
124.3
246.2
493.8
529.8
Section 1 Details
1.69% reinforcement in section 1 (Mid-section). Check this against code requirements.
Loading
Pre-stress
Factor
N
[kN]
410.3
447.4
211.4
230.7
169.2
97.31
Myy
[kNm]
3364.
2491.
4933.
7177.
5914.
6225.
Mzz
[kNm]
215.1
138.6
124.3
246.2
493.8
529.8
M
[kNm]
3371.
2495.
4934.
7181.
5935.
6248.
[]
-3.658
-3.184
-1.444
-1.965
-4.773
-4.864
Eff.
Centroid
(y)
Eff.
Centroid
(z)
[kN]
Maxima
4
-0.8899
Minima
2
-0.4688
Mu
M/Mu
Governing
Condition
[kNm] [kNm]
Neutral Neutral
Axis
Axis
Angle
Depth
[]
[mm]
From above it is observed that the Max. M/Mu ratio = 0.442 which is less than unity. Hence section is
safe.
10-April-2013
Page 27 of 71
MUMBAIMONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
4.2.2 ULTIMATE LIMIT STATE DESIGN OF MID HOLLOW SECTION
SPAN 2
The ultimate limit state analysis is carried out by the AdSEC software for bending capacity check, whereas
combined shear and torsion design is done by using a spreadsheet. The figure below shows the
arrangement of bars in the box section at the mid span after the completion of the structure.
4.2.2.1 SUMMARY OF BEAM FORCES
The summary of the maximum element forces due to various ultimate load combinations is tabulated below.
The 6 cases summarized below are
C
Case
1M
Max & Mi
Min A
Axial
i lF
Force + corresponding
di results
lt
Case 2 - Max & Min My + corresponding results
Case 3 - Max & Min Mz + corresponding results
Negative sign in axial force indicates compression and vice versa.
Table 4.3: Ultimate Load Combinations 1 - 5 (U1-U5) for span2
Moment-y Moment-z
(kNm)
(kNm)
Elem
Load
Axial (kN)
26
U4(min)
322.47
5222.48
726.05
27
U4(max)
484 61
484.61
713 76
713.76
355 32
355.32
26
U4(min)
215.35
6264.1
693.31
29
U4(max)
270.58
1948.86
29.78
34
U3b(min) 270.65
3857.16
840.28
34
U3b(max) 142.96
1550.93
997.87
LTSE
DefinitiveDesignReview
DesignCalculationforFrame17
MM002DDREPWLTSE311050Rev.A1
Page 28 of 71
Specification
General Specification
Code of Practice
Country
Bending Axes
BS5400
India
Biaxial
Section 1 Details
Definition
Name
Type
Material
Perimeter
Section Area
Reinforcement Area
Reinforcement
Mid-section
Concrete
C60
1.407E+6mm2
23710.mm2
1.685%
Section Nodes
Node
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Y
[mm]
375.0
400.0
400.0
375.0
-375.0
-400.0
-400.0
-375.0
110.0
110.0
-110.0
-110.0
Z
[mm]
1100.
1075.
-1075.
-1100.
-1100.
-1075.
1075.
1100.
850.0
-750.0
-750.0
850.0
10-April-2013
Page 29 of 71
Bars
Bar
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
[mm]
-326.0
-217.3
-108.7
0.0
108.7
217.3
326.0
-326.0
-217.3
-108.7
0.0
108.7
217.3
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-225.0
-225.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
326.0
148.0
-326.0
-148.0
0.0
326.0
148.0
-326.0
-148.0
0.0
Z
[mm]
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
-1010.
-1010.
-804.0
-804.0
872.0
872.0
1010.
1010.
-200.0
-925.0
-899.0
-699.0
-499.0
-299.0
-99.00
101.0
301.0
501.0
701.0
-899.0
-699.0
-499.0
-299.0
-99.00
101.0
301.0
501.0
701.0
-691.0
-491.0
-291.0
-91.00
109.0
309.0
509.0
709.0
-788.0
-788.0
-788.0
-788.0
-788.0
888.0
888.0
888.0
888.0
888.0
Diameter
[mm]
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
42.22
42.22
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
Material
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Strands
Strands
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Type
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Pre-stress Pre-stress
Appl. loads
Force
Strain
include/exclude
pre-stress
[kN]
-1860.
-1530.
exclude
exclude
10-April-2013
Page 30 of 71
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
225.0
225.0
225.0
-225.0
-691.0
-491.0
-291.0
-91.00
109.0
309.0
509.0
709.0
-200.0
-925.0
250.0
250.0
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
42.22
42.22
42.22
42.22
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
-1860.
-1530.
-1860.
-1860.
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
Elastic Properties
Properties of the untransformed section, ignoring reinforcement.
Geometric Centroid
y
z
Area
Second Moments of Area
Iyy
Izz
Iyz
0.0mm
-12.51mm
1.407E+6mm2
632.2E+9mm4
92.26E+9mm4
33.06E-6mm4
632.2E+9mm4
Torsion Constant
Section Modulus
Zy
92.26E+9mm4
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0mm4
568.2E+6mm3
Plastic Modulus
Zz
Zpy
230.6E+6mm3
825.1E+6mm3
Zpz
Ry
Rz
332.2E+6mm3
670.4mm
256.1mm
Izz
Angle
ky
kz
Radius of Gyration
Geometric Centroid
EA
EI
EIyy
EIzz
EIyz
Principal EI
EIuu
EIzz
Angle
Nu
Myy
Mzz
0.01648mm
-8.317mm
55.91E+6kN
23.64E+6kNm2
5.152E+6kNm2
-83.55kNm2
23.64E+6kNm2
5.152E+6kNm2
-259.0E-6
-16360.kN
0.0[-]
-0.03001kNm
-784.9E-6kNm
10-April-2013
Page 31 of 71
Note: Nmax is the maximum compressive force which can be carried by the section.
This is calculated by applying a constant strain across the entire section, using
ultimate material properties.
Concrete
C60
Normal Weight
2.300t/m3
60000.kPa
3718.kPa
37.00E+6kPa
fcu
fct
E
0.2000
12.00E-6/C
mc,ULS 1.500
mc,SLS 1.000
0.003500[-]
Recto-parabolic
No-tension
Linear
No-tension
20.00mm
Reinforcement Properties
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Fe 500
500000.kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
Strands
1.857E+6kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
Loading
Reference Point
All loading acts through the Reference Point.
All strain planes are defined relative to the Reference Point.
Definition
Reference Point Coordinates
y
z
Geometric
Centroid
0.0mm
-12.51mm
10-April-2013
Page 32 of 71
Applied loads
Load Case
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
N
[kN]
322.5
484.6
215.3
270.6
270.6
143.0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Myy
[kNm]
5222.
713.8
6264.
1949.
3857.
1551.
Mzz
[kNm]
726.0
355.3
693.3
29.78
840.3
997.9
Section 1 Details
1.69% reinforcement in section 1 (Mid-section). Check this against code requirements.
Loading
Pre-stress
Factor
N
[kN]
322.5
484.6
215.3
270.6
270.6
143.0
Myy
[kNm]
5222.
713.8
6264.
1949.
3857.
1551.
Mzz
[kNm]
726.0
355.3
693.3
29.78
840.3
997.9
[kNm]
[]
5273. -7.915
797.3 -26.46
6302. -6.316
1949. -0.8755
3948. -12.29
1844. -32.76
Eff.
Centroid
(y)
Eff.
Centroid
(z)
[kN]
Maxima
3
-0.9519
Minima
2
-0.4344
Mu
M/Mu
Governing
Condition
[kNm] [kNm]
Neutral Neutral
Axis
Axis
Angle
Depth
[]
[mm]
0.4023 B: Node 2
From above it is observed that the Max. M/Mu ratio = 0.402 which is less than unity. Hence section is
safe.
10-April-2013
Page 33 of 71
MUMBAIMONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
LTSE
DefinitiveDesignReview
DesignCalculationforFrame17
MM002DDREPWLTSE311050Rev.A1
Page 34 of 71
Specification
General Specification
Code of Practice
Country
Bending Axes
BS5400
India
Biaxial
Section 1 Details
Definition
Name
Type
Material
Perimeter
Section Area
Reinforcement Area
Reinforcement
Mid-section
Concrete
C60
1.407E+6mm2
23710.mm2
1.685%
Section Nodes
Node
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Y
[mm]
375.0
400.0
400.0
375.0
-375.0
-400.0
-400.0
-375.0
110.0
110.0
-110.0
-110.0
Z
[mm]
1100.
1075.
-1075.
-1100.
-1100.
-1075.
1075.
1100.
850.0
-750.0
-750.0
850.0
10-April-2013
Page 35 of 71
Bars
Bar
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
[mm]
-326.0
-217.3
-108.7
0.0
108.7
217.3
326.0
-326.0
-217.3
-108.7
0.0
108.7
217.3
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-326.0
326.0
-225.0
-225.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
-324.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
-148.0
326.0
148.0
-326.0
-148.0
0.0
326.0
148.0
-326.0
-148.0
0.0
Z
[mm]
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
-1010.
-1010.
-804.0
-804.0
872.0
872.0
1010.
1010.
-200.0
-925.0
-899.0
-699.0
-499.0
-299.0
-99.00
101.0
301.0
501.0
701.0
-899.0
-699.0
-499.0
-299.0
-99.00
101.0
301.0
501.0
701.0
-691.0
-491.0
-291.0
-91.00
109.0
309.0
509.0
709.0
-788.0
-788.0
-788.0
-788.0
-788.0
888.0
888.0
888.0
888.0
888.0
Diameter
[mm]
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
42.22
42.22
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
Material
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Strands
Strands
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Type
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Pre-stress Pre-stress
Appl. loads
Force
Strain
include/exclude
pre-stress
[kN]
-1860.
-1530.
exclude
exclude
10-April-2013
Page 36 of 71
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
148.0
225.0
225.0
225.0
-225.0
-691.0
-491.0
-291.0
-91.00
109.0
309.0
509.0
709.0
-200.0
-925.0
250.0
250.0
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
42.22
42.22
42.22
42.22
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
-1860.
-1530.
-1860.
-1860.
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
Elastic Properties
Properties of the untransformed section, ignoring reinforcement.
Geometric Centroid
y
z
Area
Second Moments of Area
Iyy
Izz
Iyz
0.0mm
-12.51mm
1.407E+6mm2
632.2E+9mm4
92.26E+9mm4
33.06E-6mm4
632.2E+9mm4
Torsion Constant
Section Modulus
Zy
92.26E+9mm4
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0mm4
568.2E+6mm3
Plastic Modulus
Zz
Zpy
230.6E+6mm3
825.1E+6mm3
Zpz
Ry
Rz
332.2E+6mm3
670.4mm
256.1mm
Izz
Angle
ky
kz
Radius of Gyration
y
z
EA
EI
EIyy
EIzz
EIyz
Principal EI
0.01648mm
-8.317mm
55.91E+6kN
23.64E+6kNm2
5.152E+6kNm2
-83.55kNm2
EIuu
EIzz
Angle
23.64E+6kNm2
5.152E+6kNm2
Nu
-16360.kN
0.0[-]
0.03479kNm
59.75E-6kNm
Myy
Mzz
-259.0E-6
10-April-2013
Page 37 of 71
Note: Nmax is the maximum compressive force which can be carried by the section.
This is calculated by applying a constant strain across the entire section, using
ultimate material properties.
Concrete
C60
Normal Weight
2.300t/m3
60000.kPa
3718.kPa
37.00E+6kPa
fcu
fct
E
0.2000
12.00E-6/C
mc,ULS 1.500
mc,SLS 1.000
0.003500[-]
Recto-parabolic
No-tension
Linear
No-tension
20.00mm
Reinforcement Properties
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Fe 500
500000.kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
Strands
1.857E+6kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
Loading
Reference Point
All loading acts through the Reference Point.
All strain planes are defined relative to the Reference Point.
Definition
Reference Point Coordinates
y
z
Geometric
Centroid
0.0mm
-12.51mm
10-April-2013
Page 38 of 71
Applied loads
Load Case
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
N
[kN]
310.4
397.8
83.11
35.43
37.81
270.7
1
2
3
4
5
6
Myy
[kNm]
1030.
703.1
5693.
5698.
19.89
1156.
Mzz
[kNm]
106.2
595.6
600.6
188.7
617.8
832.4
Section 1 Details
1.69% reinforcement in section 1 (Mid-section). Check this against code requirements.
Loading
Pre-stress
Factor
N
[kN]
310.4
397.8
83.11
35.43
37.81
270.7
Myy
[kNm]
1030.
703.1
5693.
5698.
19.89
1156.
Mzz
[kNm]
106.2
595.6
600.6
188.7
617.8
832.4
M
[kNm]
1035.
921.5
5725.
5701.
618.1
1425.
[]
-5.890
-40.27
-6.022
-1.897
-88.16
-35.75
Eff.
Centroid
(y)
Eff.
Centroid
(z)
[kN]
Maxima
3
-2.437
Minima
1
-0.6666
Mu
M/Mu
Governing
Condition
[kNm] [kNm]
Neutral Neutral
Axis
Axis
Angle
Depth
[]
[mm]
0.3632 B: Node 2
From above it is observed that the Max. M/Mu ratio = 0.3632 which is less than unity. Hence section is
safe.
10-April-2013
Page 39 of 71
MUMBAIMONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
4.3 ULTIMATE LIMIT STATE DESIGN OF SOLID SECTIONS
4.3.1 ULTIMATE LIMIT STATE DESIGN OF SOLID SECTION
At Pier 1
The ultimate limit state analysis is carried out by the AdSEC software for bending capacity check, whereas
combined shear and torsion design is done by using a spreadsheet. The figure below shows the
arrangement of bars in the box section at the mid span after the completion of the structure.
Elem
57
54
61
54
57
61
LTSE
Load
Axial (kN)
U3b(min) 466.14
U4(max)
428.47
220.69
U4(min)
U4(max)
298.11
U3b(min)
319.4
U3b(max) 312.71
Moment-y Moment-z
(kNm)
(kNm)
-5816.81 371.84
2251.52
399.05
-8517.12
8517.12
316.6
4147.75
72.21
-5779.38 582.54
-6508.94
610.9
DefinitiveDesignReview
DesignCalculationforFrame17
MM002DDREPWLTSE311050Rev.A1
Page 40 of 71
Specification
General Specification
Code of Practice
Country
Bending Axes
BS5400
United Kingdom
Biaxial
Section 1 Details
Definition
Name
Type
Material
Perimeter
Section Area
Reinforcement Area
Reinforcement
1C4end
Concrete
C60
1.759E+6mm2
23980.mm2
1.364%
Section Nodes
Node
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Y
[mm]
375.0
400.0
400.0
375.0
-375.0
-400.0
-400.0
-375.0
Z
[mm]
1100.
1075.
-1075.
-1100.
-1100.
-1075.
1075.
1100.
10-April-2013
Page 41 of 71
Bars
Bar
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
[mm]
-326.0
-108.7
108.7
326.0
-326.0
-244.5
-163.0
-81.50
0.0
81.50
163.0
244.5
326.0
-326.0
-244.5
-163.0
-81.50
0.0
81.50
163.0
244.5
326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
Z
[mm]
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
-907.0
-891.0
-707.2
-691.2
-507.4
-491.4
-307.7
-291.7
-107.9
-91.89
91.89
107.9
291.7
307.7
491.4
507.4
691.2
707.2
891.0
907.0
-907.0
-891.0
-707.2
-691.2
-507.4
-491.4
-307.7
-291.7
-107.9
-91.89
91.89
107.9
291.7
307.7
491.4
507.4
691.2
707.2
Diameter
[mm]
25.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
Material
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
Type
Pre-stress Pre-stress
Appl. loads
Force
Strain
include/exclude
pre-stress
[kN]
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
10-April-2013
Page 42 of 71
326.0
326.0
-165.0
165.0
-225.0
225.0
-225.0
225.0
-326.0
-108.7
108.7
326.0
891.0
907.0
-500.0
-500.0
125.0
125.0
650.0
650.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
16.00
16.00
42.22
42.22
42.20
42.20
42.20
42.20
25.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
Fe 500
Fe 500
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
-1530.
-1530.
-1860.
-1860.
-1860.
-1860.
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
Elastic Properties
Properties of the untransformed section, ignoring reinforcement.
Geometric Centroid
y
z
Area
Second Moments of Area
Iyy
Izz
Iyz
0.0mm
0.0mm
1.759E+6mm2
708.4E+9mm4
93.67E+9mm4
37.64E-6mm4
708.4E+9mm4
Torsion Constant
Section Modulus
Zy
93.67E+9mm4
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0mm4
644.0E+6mm3
Plastic Modulus
Zz
Zpy
234.2E+6mm3
966.6E+6mm3
Zpz
Ry
Rz
351.5E+6mm3
634.6mm
230.8mm
Izz
Angle
ky
kz
Radius of Gyration
y
z
EA
EI
EIyy
EIzz
EIyz
Principal EI
-189.2E-9mm
1.264mm
68.98E+6kN
26.47E+6kNm2
5.460E+6kNm2
EIuu
136.8E-6kNm2
26.47E+6kNm2
EIzz
Angle
5.460E+6kNm2
373.0E-12
Nu
44510.kN
0.0[-]
-0.04209kNm
-0.04327kNm
Myy
Mzz
10-April-2013
Page 43 of 71
Note: Nmax is the maximum compressive force which can be carried by the section.
This is calculated by applying a constant strain across the entire section, using
ultimate material properties.
Concrete
C60
Normal Weight
2.300t/m3
60000.kPa
3718.kPa
37.00E+6kPa
fcu
fct
E
0.2000
12.00E-6/C
mc,ULS 1.500
mc,SLS 1.000
0.003500[-]
Recto-parabolic
No-tension
Linear
No-tension
20.00mm
Reinforcement Properties
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Fe 500
500000.kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
Strands
1.857E+6kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
Loading
Reference Point
All loading acts through the Reference Point.
All strain planes are defined relative to the Reference Point.
Definition
Reference Point Coordinates
y
z
Geometric
Centroid
0.0mm
0.0mm
10-April-2013
Page 44 of 71
Applied loads
Load Case
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
1
2
3
4
5
6
N
[kN]
466.1
428.5
220.7
298.1
319.4
312.7
Myy
[kNm]
-5817.
2252.
-8517.
4148.
-5779.
-6509.
Mzz
[kNm]
371.8
399.0
316.6
72.21
582.5
610.9
Section 1 Details
1.36% reinforcement in section 1 (1C4end). Check this against code requirements.
Loading
Pre-stress
Factor
N
[kN]
466.1
428.5
220.7
298.1
319.4
312.7
Myy
[kNm]
-5817.
2252.
-8517.
4148.
-5779.
-6509.
Mzz
[kNm]
371.8
399.0
316.6
72.21
582.5
610.9
[kNm]
[]
5829. -176.3
2287. -10.05
8523. -177.9
4148. -0.9974
5809. -174.2
6538. -174.6
Eff.
Centroid
(y)
Eff.
Centroid
(z)
[kN]
Maxima
3 1.129E-6
Minima
2 593.7E-9
Mu
M/Mu
Governing
Condition
[kNm] [kNm]
Neutral Neutral
Axis
Axis
Angle
Depth
[]
[mm]
From above it is observed that the Max. M/Mu ratio = 0.5176 which is less than unity. Hence section is
safe.
10-April-2013
Page 45 of 71
MUMBAIMONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
At Pier 2
The ultimate limit state analysis is carried out by the AdSEC software for bending capacity check, whereas
combined shear and torsion design is done by using a spreadsheet. The figure below shows the
arrangement of bars in the box section at the mid span after the completion of the structure.
Elem
65
64
65
60
65
68
LTSE
Load
Axial (kN)
U4(min)
335.08
U4(max)
504.41
U4(min)
228.05
U4(max)
329.31
U3b(max)
7 83
7.83
U3b(max) 105.36
Moment-y
(kNm)
-7561.83
-1568.26
-9045.02
146.61
-2485.19
2485 19
-2523.84
Moment-z
(kNm)
1071.44
470.84
1000.35
123.99
1197 97
1197.97
1350.99
DefinitiveDesignReview
DesignCalculationforFrame17
MM002DDREPWLTSE311050Rev.A1
Page 46 of 71
Specification
General Specification
Code of Practice
Country
Bending Axes
BS5400
United Kingdom
Biaxial
Section 1 Details
Definition
Name
Type
Material
Perimeter
Section Area
Reinforcement Area
Reinforcement
1C4end
Concrete
C60
1.759E+6mm2
23680.mm2
1.346%
Section Nodes
Node
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Y
[mm]
375.0
400.0
400.0
375.0
-375.0
-400.0
-400.0
-375.0
Z
[mm]
1100.
1075.
-1075.
-1100.
-1100.
-1075.
1075.
1100.
10-April-2013
Page 47 of 71
Bars
Bar
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
[mm]
-326.0
-244.5
-163.0
-81.50
0.0
81.50
163.0
244.5
326.0
-326.0
-244.5
-163.0
-81.50
0.0
81.50
163.0
244.5
326.0
-326.0
-244.5
-163.0
-81.50
0.0
81.50
163.0
244.5
326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
Z
[mm]
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
-907.0
-891.0
-707.2
-691.2
-507.4
-491.4
-307.7
-291.7
-107.9
-91.89
91.89
107.9
291.7
307.7
491.4
507.4
691.2
707.2
891.0
907.0
-907.0
-891.0
-707.2
-691.2
-507.4
-491.4
-307.7
-291.7
-107.9
-91.89
91.89
107.9
291.7
Diameter
[mm]
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
Material
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
Type
Pre-stress Pre-stress
Appl. loads
Force
Strain
include/exclude
pre-stress
[kN]
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
10-April-2013
Page 48 of 71
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
-165.0
165.0
-225.0
225.0
-225.0
225.0
-326.0
-244.5
-163.0
-81.50
0.0
81.50
163.0
244.5
326.0
307.7
491.4
507.4
691.2
707.2
891.0
907.0
-500.0
-500.0
250.0
250.0
650.0
650.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
42.22
42.22
42.20
42.20
42.20
42.20
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
-1530.
-1530.
-1860.
-1860.
-1860.
-1860.
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
Elastic Properties
Properties of the untransformed section, ignoring reinforcement.
Geometric Centroid
Area
Second Moments of Area
y
z
Iyy
0.0mm
0.0mm
1.759E+6mm2
708.4E+9mm4
Izz
Iyz
93.67E+9mm4
37.64E-6mm4
708.4E+9mm4
93.67E+9mm4
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0mm4
644.0E+6mm3
Zz
Zpy
234.2E+6mm3
966.6E+6mm3
Zpz
Ry
Rz
351.5E+6mm3
634.6mm
230.8mm
y
z
EIyy
-175.9E-9mm
2.818mm
68.93E+6kN
26.46E+6kNm2
EIzz
EIyz
5.431E+6kNm2
-0.001529kNm2
10-April-2013
Page 49 of 71
EIuu
EIzz
Angle
Nu
Myy
Mzz
26.46E+6kNm2
5.431E+6kNm2
-4.167E-9
44210.kN
0.0[-]
0.08260kNm
0.09794kNm
Note: Nmax is the maximum compressive force which can be carried by the section.
This is calculated by applying a constant strain across the entire section, using
ultimate material properties.
fcu
fct
E
Concrete
C60
Normal Weight
2.300t/m3
60000.kPa
3718.kPa
37.00E+6kPa
0.2000
12.00E-6/C
mc,ULS 1.500
mc,SLS 1.000
0.003500[-]
Recto-parabolic
No-tension
Linear
No-tension
20.00mm
Reinforcement Properties
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Fe 500
500000.kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
Strands
1.857E+6kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
10-April-2013
Page 50 of 71
Loading
Applied loads
Load Case
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
1
2
3
4
5
6
N
[kN]
335.1
504.4
228.0
329.3
7.830
105.4
Myy
[kNm]
-7562.
-1568.
-9045.
146.6
-2485.
-2524.
Mzz
[kNm]
1071.
470.8
1000.
124.0
1198.
1351.
Section 1 Details
1.35% reinforcement in section 1 (1C4end). Check this against code requirements.
Loading
Pre-stress
Factor
N
[kN]
335.1
504.4
228.0
329.3
7.830
105.4
Myy
[kNm]
-7562.
-1568.
-9045.
146.6
-2485.
-2524.
Mzz
[kNm]
1071.
470.8
1000.
124.0
1198.
1351.
M
[kNm]
7637.
1637.
9100.
192.0
2759.
2863.
[]
-171.9
-163.3
-173.7
-40.22
-154.3
-151.8
Eff.
Centroid
(y)
Eff.
Centroid
(z)
[kN]
Maxima
3 -1.519E-6
Minima
4 -1.062E-6
Mu
M/Mu
Governing
Condition
[kNm] [kNm]
Neutral Neutral
Axis
Axis
Angle
Depth
[]
[mm]
0.5780 B: Node 3
From above it is observed that the Max. M/Mu ratio = 0.578 which is less than unity. Hence section is
safe.
10-April-2013
Page 51 of 71
MUMBAIMONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
At Pier 3
The ultimate limit state analysis is carried out by the AdSEC software for bending capacity check, whereas
combined shear and torsion design is done by using a spreadsheet. The figure below shows the
arrangement of bars in the box section at the mid span after the completion of the structure.
4.3.2.1 SUMMARY OF BEAM FORCES
The summary of the maximum element forces due to various ultimate load combinations is tabulated below.
The 6 cases summarized below are
Case 1 Max & Min Axial Force + corresponding results
Case 2 - Max & Min My + corresponding results
Case 3 - Max & Min Mz + corresponding results
Negative sign in axial force indicates compression and vice versa.
Table 4.6: Ultimate Load Combinations 1 - 5 (U1-U5)
Elem
71
70
67
71
67
67
LTSE
Load
Axial (kN)
U3b(min)
U3b( i )
330.6
330 6
U4(max)
419.91
U4(min)
104.75
U4(max)
35.26
U3b(min)
50.46
U3b(max)
60.32
Moment-y Moment-z
(kNm)
(kNm)
-1023.3
1023 3
229.79
229 79
-2239.07
713.1
-9219.54
831.8
2871.36
174.29
-1420.91 941.66
-8310.88 1202.5
DefinitiveDesignReview
DesignCalculationforFrame17
MM002DDREPWLTSE311050Rev.A1
Page 52 of 71
Specification
General Specification
Code of Practice
Country
Bending Axes
BS5400
United Kingdom
Biaxial
Section 1 Details
Definition
Name
Type
Material
Perimeter
Section Area
Reinforcement Area
Reinforcement
1C4end
Concrete
C60
1.759E+6mm2
23680.mm2
1.346%
Section Nodes
Node
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Y
[mm]
375.0
400.0
400.0
375.0
-375.0
-400.0
-400.0
-375.0
Z
[mm]
1100.
1075.
-1075.
-1100.
-1100.
-1075.
1075.
1100.
Bars
Definitive Design Review Design Calculations of Frame 17
MM001-D-DR-VSP-LTSE-311050 Rev A1
10-April-2013
Page 53 of 71
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
[mm]
-326.0
-244.5
-163.0
-81.50
0.0
81.50
163.0
244.5
326.0
-326.0
-244.5
-163.0
-81.50
0.0
81.50
163.0
244.5
326.0
-326.0
-244.5
-163.0
-81.50
0.0
81.50
163.0
244.5
326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
-326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
Z
[mm]
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
-1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1026.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
1010.
-907.0
-891.0
-707.2
-691.2
-507.4
-491.4
-307.7
-291.7
-107.9
-91.89
91.89
107.9
291.7
307.7
491.4
507.4
691.2
707.2
891.0
907.0
-907.0
-891.0
-707.2
-691.2
-507.4
-491.4
-307.7
-291.7
-107.9
-91.89
91.89
107.9
291.7
307.7
491.4
Diameter
[mm]
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
Material
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
Fe
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
500
Type
Pre-stress Pre-stress
Appl. loads
Force
Strain
include/exclude
pre-stress
[kN]
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
10-April-2013
Page 54 of 71
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
326.0
-165.0
165.0
-225.0
225.0
-225.0
225.0
-326.0
-244.5
-163.0
-81.50
0.0
81.50
163.0
244.5
326.0
507.4
691.2
707.2
891.0
907.0
-500.0
-500.0
550.0
550.0
850.0
850.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
-969.0
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
42.22
42.22
42.20
42.20
42.20
42.20
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
16.00
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Strands
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Fe 500
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
Steel
-1530.
-1530.
-1860.
-1860.
-1860.
-1860.
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
exclude
Elastic Properties
Properties of the untransformed section, ignoring reinforcement.
Geometric Centroid
Area
Second Moments of Area
y
z
Iyy
Izz
Iyz
Izz
Angle
ky
kz
Torsion Constant
Section Modulus
Zy
Plastic Modulus
Zz
Zpy
Radius of Gyration
Zpz
Ry
Rz
0.0mm
0.0mm
1.759E+6mm2
708.4E+9mm4
93.67E+9mm4
37.64E-6mm4
708.4E+9mm4
93.67E+9mm4
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0mm4
644.0E+6mm3
234.2E+6mm3
966.6E+6mm3
351.5E+6mm3
634.6mm
230.8mm
y
z
EIyy
EIzz
EIyz
Principal EI
EIuu
-175.9E-9mm
6.125mm
68.93E+6kN
26.46E+6kNm2
5.675E+6kNm2
-0.003643kNm2
26.46E+6kNm2
10-April-2013
Page 55 of 71
EIzz
Angle
5.675E+6kNm2
-10.04E-9
Nu
43310.kN
0.0[-]
0.02029kNm
-0.01669kNm
Myy
Mzz
Note: Nmax is the maximum compressive force which can be carried by the section.
This is calculated by applying a constant strain across the entire section, using
ultimate material properties.
fcu
fct
E
Concrete
C60
Normal Weight
2.300t/m3
60000.kPa
3718.kPa
37.00E+6kPa
0.2000
12.00E-6/C
mc,ULS 1.500
mc,SLS 1.000
0.003500[-]
Recto-parabolic
No-tension
Linear
No-tension
20.00mm
Reinforcement Properties
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Name
fy
Modulus
Partial Safety Factor
Maximum Strain
Stress/Strain Curve
Fe 500
500000.kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
Strands
1.857E+6kPa
200.0E+6kPa
ms,ULS 1.150
ms,SLS 1.000
0.05000[-]
Fig 2
10-April-2013
Page 56 of 71
Loading
Applied loads
Load Case
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Load
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
Case
1
2
3
4
5
6
N
[kN]
330.6
419.9
104.7
35.26
50.46
60.32
Myy
[kNm]
-1023.
-2239.
-9220.
2871.
-1421.
-8311.
Mzz
[kNm]
229.8
713.1
831.8
174.3
941.7
1202.
Section 1 Details
1.35% reinforcement in section 1 (1C4end). Check this against code requirements.
Loading
Pre-stress
Factor
N
[kN]
330.6
419.9
104.7
35.26
50.46
60.32
Myy
[kNm]
-1023.
-2239.
-9220.
2871.
-1421.
-8311.
Mzz
[kNm]
229.8
713.1
831.8
174.3
941.7
1202.
M
[kNm]
1049.
2350.
9257.
2877.
1705.
8397.
[]
-167.3
-162.3
-174.8
-3.474
-146.5
-171.8
Eff.
Centroid
(y)
Eff.
Centroid
(z)
[kN]
Maxima
3 -3.266E-6
Minima
1 -1.058E-6
Mu
M/Mu
Governing
Condition
[kNm] [kNm]
Neutral Neutral
Axis
Axis
Angle
Depth
[]
[mm]
0.5085 B: Node 3
From above it is observed that the Max. M/Mu ratio = 0.5085 which is less than unity. Hence section is
safe.
10-April-2013
Page 57 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
4.4 Check for Shear at Hollow section (As per IRC concrete bridge code)
The Guideway beam hollow section is checked for shear capacity at a location of max. shear & corresponding moment &
torsion and then at a location of max. torsion & corresponding shear & moment. The locations are based on sorted results
obtained from MIDAS analysis, as tabulated below:
Location
1st span
2nd span
3rd span
LTSE
Elem
88
95
83
26
34
26
35
43
40
Load
U4(max)
U3b(max)
U4(max)
U4(max)
U3b(min)
U4(min)
U4(min)
U3b(min)
U4(max)
Part
J[23]
J[24]
J[72]
J[27]
J[28]
J[27]
I[29]
I[30]
I[55]
Shear-y
Component Axial (kN) (kN)
Shear-z
129.78
-63.55
Torsion
-234.66 -115.42
Moment-y
230.73
16.45
Shear-z
-208.75
-128.5
Torsion
-268.4
142.45
Moment-y
-215.35 -125.62
Shear-z
83.01
104.35
Torsion
142.71
143.12
Moment-y
35.43
20.87
Shear-z Torsion
(kN)
(kNm)
1638.82
234.42
1013.07
419.09
-110.72
113.33
1181.73
576.27
1067.51 -854.75
1165.87
441.82
-1547.42 -789.06
-1302.33 -1102.55
-208.44 -116.89
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 58 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Element No.(refer above table & MIDAS model)
Node end
fck =
fy =
Duct diameter=
B
D
Depth of hollow box inside beam
Width of hollow box inside beam
Eff. Depth of beam
d (m)
Eff. Width of beam
b(m)
dist of T1, T2 from top(m)
dist of T3, T4(m)
dist of T5,T6(m)
Area of T1,T2(mm2)
Area of T3,T4(mm2)
Area of T5,T6(mm2)
Factored PS T1,T2(KN)
Factored PS T3,T4(KN)
Factored PS T5,T6(KN)
Area of beam in section
A (m2)
Dist. of c.g of beam from comp. fibre
y (m)
Moment of inertia of beam
I(m4)
Ecc. of tendon T1,T2
e1(T1,T2) (m)
Ecc. of tendon T3,T4
e2(T3,T4) (m)
Ecc. of tendon T5,T6
e3(T5,T6) (m)
Prestress on beam
P/A (Mpa)
Pe1*y/I (Mpa)
Pe2*y/II (Mpa)
Pe3*y/II (Mpa)
fp-comp (Mpa)
fp-tension(Mpa)
CG of Tendons (m)
Cracking Moment of beam
Mcr(KN-m)
ft(Mpa)
Vco(KN)
From above tables,
M at Max V (kNm)
Max V (kN)
Shear at Max Mn(kN)
Max M (kNm)
Governing Shear (Max V)
Shear stress (Mpa)
Vcr 1 (KN)
Vcr 2 (KN)
Min Vcr (IRC 16.4.4.3) (KN)
V limiting (KN)
Dia of stirrups
Number of stirrups
Dia of links
Number of links
Area of links provided
Asv
Dia of Longi bars
Cover (mm)
Eff.depth of beam
dt
Spacing of stirrups reqd.
Sv req(mm)
LTSE
MPa
MPa
m
m
m
m
m
88
J[23]
60
415
0.085
0.8
2.2
1.6
0.22
2.20
0.4667
1.7
0.9
0.5
1400
1680
1680
1538
1935
1910
0.280
1.1
0.63
-0.5710
0.2064
0.5728
38.5
-3.0
1.4
3.8
40.6
36.3
1.2
22611.6
1.9
5954.55
4270.00
1639.00
1471.00
4545.00
1639.00
1.6
8840.7
7479.7
795.3
5954.5
16
2
12
2
628.3
16
50
2126
450
83
J[72]
60
415
0.085
0.8
2.2
1.6
0.22
2.20
0.4667
1.7
0.9
0.5
1400
1680
1260
1538
1935
1910
0.280
1.1
0.63
-0.5710 (-ve indicates below c.g of beam)
0.2064 (+ve indicates above c.g of beam)
0.5728 (+ve indicates above c.g of beam)
38.5
-3.0
1.4
3.8
40.6
36.3
1.2
22611.6
1.9
5954.55
5852.00
563.00
111.00
7177.00
563.00
0.5
2330.8
505.1
795.3
795.3
16
2
12
2
628.3
16
50
2126
450
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 59 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
LTSE
43
1102.60
1302.30
800
2200
290
250
250
994500
1.9
0.42
Reqd.
2.7
5.80
OK
16.0
100.0
2
201.06
1.54
2.01
OK
16.0
2
402.12
1.27
315.5
200.0
OK
kNm
kN
mm
mm
mm
mm
mm
mm2
N/mm2
N/mm2
N/mm2
N/mm2
mm
mm
no.
mm2
mm
no.
mm2
mm
mm
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 60 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
4.5 Check for Shear at Solid section (As per IRC concrete bridge code)
The Guideway beam hollow section is checked for shear capacity at a location of max. shear & corresponding moment & torsion and
then at a location of max. torsion & corresponding shear & moment. The locations are based on sorted results obtained from MIDAS
analysis, as tabulated below:
Location
1st span
2nd span
3rd span
LTSE
Elem
61
57
61
65
68
65
67
70
67
Load
U4(max)
U3b(max)
U4(min)
U4(max)
U3b(min)
U4(min)
U4(min)
U4(min)
U4(min)
Part
J[18]
J[17]
J[18]
J[13]
J[14]
J[13]
I[15]
I[16]
I[15]
Shear-y
Component Axial (kN) (kN)
Shear-z
-214.78
-88.93
Torsion
17.89
-133.1
Moment-y
-220.69
-87.89
Shear-z
-222.21 -150.63
Axial
-295.85
155.33
Moment-y
-228.05 -148.11
Shear-z
108.44
112.55
Torsion
94.9
123.37
Moment-y
104.75
114.88
Shear-z
(kN)
1840.59
1347.27
1722.21
1503.23
1184.66
1436.11
-1797.62
-1362.57
-1683.88
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 61 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
Element No.(refer above table & MIDAS model)
Node end
fck =
fy =
Duct diameter=
B
D
Depth of hollow box inside beam
Width of hollow box inside beam
Eff. Depth of beam
d (m)
Eff. Width of beam
b(m)
dist of T1, T2 from top(m)
dist of T3, T4(m)
dist of T5,T6(m)
Area of T1,T2(mm2)
Area of T3,T4(mm2)
Area of T5,T6(mm2)
Factored PS T1,T2(KN)
Factored PS T3,T4(KN)
Factored PS T5,T6(KN)
Area of beam in section
A (m2)
Dist. of c.g of beam from comp. fibre
y (m)
Moment of inertia of beam
I(m4)
Ecc. of tendon T1,T2
e1(T1,T2) (m)
Ecc. of tendon T3,T4
e2(T3,T4) (m)
Ecc. of tendon T5,T6
e3(T5,T6) (m)
Prestress on beam
P/A (Mpa)
Pe1*y/I (Mpa)
Pe2*y/II (Mpa)
Pe3*y/II (Mpa)
fp-comp (Mpa)
fp-tension(Mpa)
CG of Tendons (m)
Cracking Moment of beam
Mcr(KN-m)
ft(Mpa)
Vco(KN)
From above tables,
M at Max V (kNm)
Max V (kN)
Shear at Max Mn(kN)
Max M (kNm)
Governing Shear (Max V)
Shear stress (Mpa)
Vcr 1 (KN)
Vcr 2 (KN)
Min Vcr (IRC 16.4.4.3) (KN)
V limiting (KN)
Dia of stirrups
Number of stirrups
Dia of links
Number of links
Area of links provided
Asv
Dia of Longi bars
Cover (mm)
Eff.depth of beam
dt
Spacing of stirrups reqd.
Sv req(mm)
LTSE
MPa
MPa
m
m
m
m
m
61
J[18]
60
415
0.085
0.8
2.2
0
0
2.20
0.6867
1.6
0.8
0.4
1400
1680
1680
1519
1920
1884
1.511
1.1
0.71
-0.5000
0.2506
0.6511
7.0
-2.4
1.5
3.8
10.0
4.1
1.3
4500.69
1.9
4118.46
8437.00
1841.00
1722.00
8517.00
1841.00
1.2
1232.2
1160.1
1170.2
1170.2
16
2
16
2
804.2
16
50
2126
450
67
I[15]
60
415
0.085
0.8
2.2
0
0
2.20
0.6867
1.6
0.6
0.3
1400
1680
1260
1491
1832
1848
1.511
1.1
0.71
-0.5000 (-ve indicates below c.g of beam)
0.5472 (+ve indicates above c.g of beam)
0.8478 (+ve indicates above c.g of beam)
6.8
-2.3
3.1
4.9
12.5
1.2
1.4
2620.06
1.9
4071.66
9011.00
1798.00
1684.00
9220.00
1798.00
1.2
797.7
753.4
1170.2
1170.2
16
2
16
2
804.2
16
50
2126
450
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 62 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
______________________________________________________________________________
4.5.1 Check for Max. Torsion at Hollow section
Element
Max Torsion (KN-m)
Corresponding shear (kN)
B (mm)
D (mm)
Thickness of web (mm)
Thickness of top flange (mm)
Thickness of bottom flange (mm)
Ao (mm2)
Torsional stress v (Mpa)
V min (Mpa)
Ast required
V+Vt (Mpa)
Max allowable stress (Mpa)
Status
dia of stirrups (mm)
spacing of stirrups (mm)
Number of outer legs
Ast (mm2)
T/(2*Ao*.87*fyv)
Ast/Sv
Status
Dia of longi bars
Number of bars in bundle
AsL
(Ast/Sv)*(fyv/fyL)
Minimum spacing req.(mm)
Spacing provided(mm)
Status
LTSE
70
1072.000
1363.000
800
2200
290
250
250
994500.0
1.9
0.42
Reqd.
2.6
5.80
OK
16.0
100.0
2
201.06
1.49
2.0
OK
16.0
2
402.12
1.24
324.6
200.0
OK
kNm
kN
mm
mm
mm
mm
mm
2
mm
2
N/mm
2
N/mm
2
N/mm
2
N/mm
mm
mm
no.
2
mm
mm
no.
mm2
mm
mm
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 63 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
_____________________________________________________________________________________
4.6 END BLOCK DESIGN
4.6.1 GEOMETRY AND PRESTRESS LOADS
The cross-sectional geometry at the expansion joint end of the PC Guideway beam is as
shown in the following figure. The six tendons are stressed to the following forces and the
anchorages are 265mm square
Anchorage Data
Location
Anchor
X(mm)
1
2
3
4
5
6
Anchor Size
Y(mm)
-165
-165
-165
-165
-165
-165
X Dim (mm)
550
550
975
975
1600
1600
Jacking Force(KN)
Y Dim
(mm)
275
275
275
275
275
275
Jacking
Jacking
Force per Force of
Strand
Anchor
Nos of
strands
275
275
275
275
275
275
10
10
12
12
12
12
195
195
195
195
195
195
1950
1950
2340
2340
2340
2340
Prism Dimensions
Cable
1
2
3
4
5
6
Fbst / Pk
Vertically Laterally
Vertically Laterally Vertically Laterally Vertically Laterally
425
330
0.65
0.83
0.126
0.11
1227
1073
425
330
0.65
0.83
0.126
0.11
1227
1073
675
330
0.41
0.83
0.198
0.11
2314
1287
675
330
0.41
0.83
0.198
0.11
2314
1287
675
330
0.41
0.83
0.198
0.11
2314
1287
675
330
0.41
0.83
0.198
0.11
2314
1287
Maximum reinforcement =
Provide
12 dia
nos of rounds =
LTSE
Ypo / Yo
2314 mm2
helical
upto
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 64 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
_____________________________________________________________________________________
4.6.3 SECONDARY OR EQUILIBRIUM REINFORCEMENT
As well as providing primary reinforcement in the immediate vicinity of the anchorages, it is
necessary to consider the overall equilibrium of the anchor block and to determine any outofbalance forces and moments that may be set up by the anchorages acting individually or
together. Check for the following stressing sequence.
Case
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
4
4
4
5
5
Case-2
Net
Net Vertical Due to
Vertical
Dimension
Due to
Due to
Moment
distributio Due to
Moment
from
n
anchorages (KNm)
Bottom distribution anchorages (KNm)
0
0
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
110
13.14
0.00
13.14
26.28
0.00
26.28
220
51.48
0.00
51.48
102.96
0.00
102.96
330
113.42
0.00
113.42
226.85
0.00
226.85
440
197.36
-2.68
194.68
394.71
-5.36
389.35
550
301.67
-67.03
234.64
603.35
-134.06
469.29
660
424.77 -217.18
207.59
849.54
-434.36
415.17
770
565.03 -429.00
136.03 1130.06
-858.00
272.06
880
720.86 -643.50
77.36 1441.71
-1287.00
154.71
990
890.64 -858.00
32.64 1781.28
-1716.00
65.28
1100
1072.77 -1072.50
0.27 2145.54
-2145.00
0.54
1210
1265.64 -1287.00
-21.36 2531.28
-2574.00
-42.72
1320
1467.64 -1501.50
-33.86 2935.29
-3003.00
-67.71
1430
1677.17 -1716.00
-38.83 3354.35
-3432.00
-77.65
1540
1892.63 -1930.50
-37.87 3785.25
-3861.00
-75.75
1650
2112.39 -2145.00
-32.61 4224.78
-4290.00
-65.22
1760
2334.86 -2359.50
-24.64 4669.72
-4719.00
-49.28
1870
2558.43 -2574.00
-15.57 5116.85
-5148.00
-31.15
1980
2781.48 -2788.50
-7.02 5562.97
-5577.00
-14.03
2090
3002.43 -3003.00
-0.57 6004.85
-6006.00
-1.15
2200
3219.65 -3217.50
2.15 6439.29
-6435.00
4.29
MAX
234.64
MAX
469.29
MIN
-38.83
MIN
-77.65
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 65 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Case-4
Case-5
Net
Net Vertical Due to
Vertical
Dimension
Due to
Due to
Moment
distributio Due to
Moment
from
n
anchorages (KNm)
Bottom distribution anchorages (KNm)
0
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
110
21.69
0.00
21.69
43.39
0.00
43.39
220
85.41
0.00
85.41
170.83
0.00
170.83
330
189.11
0.00
189.11
378.22
0.00
378.22
440
330.74
-2.68
328.06
661.48
-5.36
656.12
550
508.26
-67.03
441.23 1016.52
-134.06
882.46
660
719.62
-217.18
502.44 1439.25
-434.36 1004.88
770
962.78
-429.00
533.78 1925.57
-858.00 1067.57
880
1235.69
-651.18
584.51 2471.39
-1302.37 1169.02
990
1536.31
-956.94
579.37 3072.63
-1913.89 1158.74
1100
1862.59
-1365.66
496.93 3725.18
-2731.33
993.85
1210
2212.49
-1836.90
375.59 4424.97
-3673.80
751.17
1320
2583.95
-2308.80
275.15 5167.90
-4617.60
550.30
1430
2974.94
-2780.70
194.24 5949.88
-5561.40
388.48
1540
3383.41
-3252.60
130.81 6766.81
-6505.20
261.61
1650
3807.31
-3724.50
82.81 7614.62
-7449.00
165.62
1760
4244.60
-4196.40
48.20 8489.20
-8392.80
96.40
1870
4693.23
-4668.30
24.93 9386.46
-9336.60
49.86
1980
5151.16
-5140.20
10.96 10302.32 -10280.40
21.92
2090
5616.34
-5612.10
4.24 11232.68 -11224.20
8.48
2200
6086.73
-6084.00
2.73 12173.46 -12168.00
5.46
MAX
584.51
MAX
1169.02
MIN
0.00
MIN
0.00
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 66 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Case-5
Case-6
Net
Net Vertical Due to
Vertical
Dimension
Due to
Due to
Moment
distributio Due to
Moment
from
anchorages (KNm)
n
Bottom distribution anchorages (KNm)
0
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
110
19.65
0.00
19.65
39.29
0.00
39.29
220
78.39
0.00
78.39
156.78
0.00
156.78
330
175.94
0.00
175.94
351.88
0.00
351.88
440
312.00
-2.68
309.32
624.01
-5.36
618.64
550
486.29
-67.03
419.26
972.57
-134.06
838.51
660
698.50
-217.18
481.32 1397.00
-434.36
962.64
770
948.35
-429.00
519.35 1896.70
-858.00 1038.70
880
1235.54
-651.18
584.36 2471.09
-1302.37 1168.72
990
1559.79
-956.94
602.85 3119.58
-1913.89 1205.69
1100
1920.80
-1365.66
555.13 3841.60
-2731.33 1110.27
1210
2318.27
-1836.90
481.37 4636.55
-3673.80
962.75
1320
2751.92
-2308.80
443.12 5503.85
-4617.60
886.25
1430
3221.46
-2780.70
440.76 6442.92
-5561.40
881.52
1540
3726.58
-3278.15
448.43 7453.17
-6556.31
896.86
1650
4267.01
-3874.07
392.93 8534.02
-7748.15
785.87
1760
4842.44
-4570.80
271.64 9684.88
-9141.60
543.28
1870
5452.59
-5300.10
152.49 10905.17 -10600.20
304.97
1980
6097.15
-6029.40
67.75 12194.31 -12058.80
135.51
2090
6775.85
-6758.70
17.15 13551.71 -13517.40
34.31
2200
7488.39
-7488.00
0.39 14976.78 -14976.00
0.78
MAX
602.85
MAX
1205.69
MIN
0.00
MIN
0.00
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 67 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Net Transverese Moment in Vertical Plane
1400.00
1200.00
1000.00
Case1
Case2
800.00
Case3
600.00
Case4
Series5
400.00
Case5
Case6
200.00
0.00
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
-200.00
Maximum moment =
lever arm =
Fy
=
Area of steel required =
1205.69
1.1
240
4567.02285
KNm
m
Mpa
mm2
Provide
2 nos
Area provided =
LTSE
2T
8846.72 mm2
16 @
1.1 m from
face
OK
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 68 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Transverse Out-Of-balance Moments In Horizontal Plane
Transverse out-of-balance moments in vertical plane are as tabulated below
Case-1
Case-2
Net
Vertical
Net Vertical Due to
Dimension
Moment
Due to
Due to
Moment
distributio Due to
from
n
anchorages (KNm)
Bottom distribution anchorages (KNm)
0
0
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
110
11.19
0.00
11.19
22.38
0.00
22.38
220
43.88
0.00
43.88
87.75
0.00
87.75
330
96.75
0.00
96.75
193.50
0.00
193.50
440
168.49
0.00
168.49
336.99
0.00
336.99
550
257.79
-22.54
235.26
515.59
-45.08
470.51
660
363.33 -122.71
240.63
726.66
-245.41
481.25
770
483.80 -298.35
185.45
967.59
-596.70
370.89
880
617.87 -491.40
126.47 1235.74
-982.80
252.94
990
764.24 -684.45
79.79 1528.49
-1368.90
159.59
1100
921.59 -877.50
44.09 1843.19
-1755.00
88.19
1210
1088.61 -1070.55
18.06 2177.22
-2141.10
36.12
1320
1263.98 -1263.60
0.38 2527.96
-2527.20
0.76
1430
1446.38 -1456.65
-10.27 2892.77
-2913.30
-20.53
1540
1634.51 -1649.70
-15.19 3269.01
-3299.40
-30.39
1650
1827.04 -1842.75
-15.71 3654.07
-3685.50
-31.43
1760
2022.66 -2035.80
-13.14 4045.32
-4071.60
-26.28
1870
2220.06 -2228.85
-8.79 4440.11
-4457.70
-17.59
1980
2417.91 -2421.90
-3.99 4835.83
-4843.80
-7.97
2090
2614.92 -2614.95
-0.03 5229.84
-5229.90
-0.06
2200
2809.76 -2808.00
1.76 5619.51
-5616.00
3.51
MAX
240.63
MAX
481.25
MIN
-15.71
MIN
-31.43
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 69 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Case-4
Case-5
Net
Net Vertical Due to
Vertical
Dimension
Due to
Due to
Moment
distributio Due to
Moment
from
n
anchorages (KNm)
Bottom distribution anchorages (KNm)
0
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
110
15.50
0.00
15.50
31.01
0.00
31.01
220
61.43
0.00
61.43
122.85
0.00
122.85
330
136.89
0.00
136.89
273.79
0.00
273.79
440
241.03
0.00
241.03
482.06
0.00
482.06
550
372.96
-22.54
350.42
745.91
-45.08
700.84
660
531.80
-122.71
409.09 1063.59
-245.41
818.18
770
716.68
-298.35
418.33 1433.35
-596.70
836.65
880
926.71
-491.40
435.31 1853.43
-982.80
870.63
990
1161.04
-684.45
476.59 2322.08
-1368.90
953.18
1100
1418.77
-877.75
541.02 2837.54
-1755.50 1082.05
1210
1699.03
-1131.51
567.53 3398.07
-2263.01 1135.06
1320
2000.95
-1492.11
508.84 4001.91
-2984.22 1017.69
1430
2323.65
-1936.35
387.30 4647.30
-3872.70
774.60
1540
2666.25
-2386.80
279.45 5332.49
-4773.60
558.89
1650
3027.87
-2837.25
190.62 6055.74
-5674.50
381.24
1760
3407.64
-3287.70
119.94 6815.28
-6575.40
239.88
1870
3804.68
-3738.15
66.53 7609.36
-7476.30
133.06
1980
4218.12
-4188.60
29.52 8436.24
-8377.20
59.04
2090
4647.07
-4639.05
8.02 9294.15
-9278.10
16.05
2200
5090.67
-5089.50
1.17 10181.34 -10179.00
2.34
MAX
567.53
MAX
1135.06
MIN
0.00
MIN
0.00
Case-5
Case-6
Net
Net Vertical Due to
Vertical
Dimension
Due to
Due to
Moment
distributio Due to
Moment
from
anchorages (KNm)
n
Bottom distribution anchorages (KNm)
0
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
110
10.49
0.00
10.49
20.97
0.00
20.97
220
42.94
0.00
42.94
85.87
0.00
85.87
330
98.84
0.00
98.84
197.69
0.00
197.69
440
179.70
0.00
179.70
359.39
0.00
359.39
550
286.98
-22.54
264.45
573.97
-45.08
528.89
660
422.20
-122.71
299.49
844.40
-245.41
598.99
770
586.83
-298.35
288.48 1173.66
-596.70
576.96
880
782.37
-491.40
290.97 1564.74
-982.80
581.94
990
1010.30
-684.45
325.85 2020.61
-1368.90
651.71
1100
1272.13
-877.75
394.38 2544.25
-1755.50
788.76
1210
1569.33
-1131.51
437.82 3138.65
-2263.01
875.64
1320
1903.39
-1492.11
411.29 3806.79
-2984.22
822.57
1430
2275.82
-1936.35
339.47 4551.64
-3872.70
678.94
1540
2688.09
-2386.80
301.29 5376.19
-4773.60
602.59
1650
3141.71
-2837.50
304.21 6283.42
-5675.00
608.42
1760
3638.15
-3348.66
289.49 7276.30
-6697.31
578.99
1870
4178.91
-3966.66
212.25 8357.82
-7933.32
424.50
1980
4765.48
-4668.30
97.18 9530.96
-9336.60
194.36
2090
5399.35
-5376.15
23.20 10798.70 -10752.30
46.40
2200
6082.01
-6084.00
-1.99 12164.02 -12168.00
-3.98
MAX
437.82
MAX
875.64
MIN
-1.99
MIN
-3.98
LTSE
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 70 of 71
MUMBAI MONORAIL
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Maximum moment =
lever arm =
Fy
=
Area of steel required =
1135.06
1.1
200
5159.35239
KNm
m
Mpa
mm2
Provide
2 nos
Area provided =
LTSE
2T
8846.72491 mm2
16 @
OK
MM002-D-DR-EPW-LTSE-311050 Rev. A1
Page 71 of 71