A COMPENDIUM OF SOCIAL ISSUES

SHRI SAPTARSI NAG,

WBCS(EXE)

1
YASHPAL COMMITTEE REPORT ON HIGHER EDUCATION

Yashpal Committee was appointed to look into various aspects of higher

education of India and very recently the committee submitted its
recommendations. Apart from criticizing modern system of education and
mismanagement and negligence on the part of the government to promote
higher education, the committee has made a few recommendations for the
up gradation of the existing system of higher education in India. Below are
some of the recommendations

• The committee talks about the establishment of a National

Commission for Higher Education and Research which will subsume
the role of as many as 13 government bodies and councils like the
UGC,MCI or AICET which supervise higher education in India

• The committee is critical of the accreditation of granting deemed

university status to mushrooming institutes and observes that while
during the period of 1956 to 199 only 29 institutes were granted
deemed university status, in the past 15 years as many as 63
institutes were granted the same status.

• The Committee stressed on improvement of the educational

standard in the undergraduate level and recommended that the IITs
and IIMs should expand their scopes by including arts and
humanities subjects

• The committee was critical of allowing numerous foreign institutes

to open their business in India and held that while these institutes
are unheard of in their lands, they are earning a lot here and
damaging our educational system. The Committee recommended
that such institutes if want to stay in India must provide and Indian
degree of education and not foreign one.

2
 • The committee was critical of profit driven private institutions and
asked the need for "different layers of institutions", i.e. state run,
private and public -Private partnership etc.

• The committee also stressed on the integration of education and

research.

NEED FOR POLICE REFORMS IN INDIA

At present there is dire need for the police reforms in the country. The
laws related to police administration dates back to British colonial regime
and hardly reflects the present socio-economic needs. The Indian Penal
Code of 1860, the Evidence Act of 1871 or the Criminal Procedure Code
of 1898- all these bear the evidence that in India Police administration is
till governed by century old archaic laws.

Under the Indian constitution policing is a state system. Most state

governments have laws which are simple imitations of the 1861 penal
code. Since independence there have efforts from the government on
numerous occasions to introduce some changes in the police
administration. Numerous committees and commissions have been formed.
But at the end of the day it is all that same with all those voluminous,
archaic acts and laws.

3
The honorable Supreme Court of India in 2006 asked the Government of
India to ensure more accountability in police administration and to release
a draft model of a new police act. The issue till date remains unanswered.

Apart from the archaism of the laws numerous other problems exist in
police administration in India. The existing system has bred and still
breeding corruption among the policemen. The existing system hardly
provides the criminals the opportunity to correct themselves. It is still
very much a system of punishment, not correction. The police training
emphasizes on muscle power and gunmanship while very little care is
taken to imbibe endearing values among the cops. They are the protector
of human rights in the first line although they mostly remain ignorant of
what human right is.

Modernization of the police force is thus a dire need of the day

considering ever increasing cases of terrorism and violence. But more
important is the need to inculcate human values among our policemen so
that they do not behave like inhuman musclemen, but actively take part in
the socio cultural reconstruction process.

FACT SHEET ON CHILD LABOR IN INDIA

• Presently there are 20 million child labor in India, and out of this
85% belong to rural areas or unorganized sectors
• India's child labor policy is consistent with the International Labor
Conference Resolutions,1979
• It is a socio cultural menace
• Article 24 prohibits employment of children in mines or other
hazardous activities
• Child labor( Prohibition and Regulation) act, 1986 seeks to regulate
employment of children in hazardous activities
• The Directive Principles of Sate Policy also seeks to regulate Child
Labor in India
• India is signatory to 36 conventions of ILO on Child Labor

4
 • India adopted its first policy on Child Labor in 1974 in consonance
with the UN Declaration on Child Rights,1959
• To monitor the working of various rules and regulations on Child
Labor, National Authority for elimination of Child Labor was
established under the chairmanship of the Union Labor Minister
• However despite all such efforts real scenario is gloomy as there
have been hardly any efforts to regulate unorganized child labor
• Of the total workforce in India, share of child labor is 12.1%
• In the carpet industry of Mirzapur, more than 25,000 children are
employed in hazardous occupations

• In the matchstick industries of Sivakasi in TamilNadu around 40,000

children are employed
• The efforts of the girl children in hazardous occupations are rarely
counted as they are considered as mere helpers not workers

TARGETED PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM(TPDS)

The Targeted Public Distribution system was launched in 1997 by the

Government of India with the objective of providing minimum quantity of
essential commodities, i.e., food grains to the targeted people allover the

5
country. Accordingly to identify the targeted people issue of BPL card was
started and people were categorized into BPL and APL categories. Initially
10 kg of food grains per family per month was allotted at a rate much
lower than the standard market rate. At present 35 kg of food grains are
given to each family per month at a highly subsidized rate, i.e., rice @ Rs
5.65/kg and wheat @ 4.15/kg.Fair price shops have been established to
distribute the ration items to the common people.
The policies:

• Maintaining a buffer stock to meet up the rising demands during

scarcity.
• Arranging MSP for the farmers during scarcity
• Distribution of food grains from the surplus to deficit areas

Problems

• Identification of the genuine candidates. Very often deserving

candidates do not get BPL cards whereas well off people walk away
with the cards
• Political influence in the allotment of the cards
• Corruption of the government officials
• Absence of fair price shop all over the country
• Lack of supply of ration items in many fair price shops

Solutions

• Any impartial body, for example the Judiciary should be given the
task of identifying the poor people
• Criteria to identify the poor people are to be codified clearly by the
government
• More fair price shops are to be established
• Well of people with BPL cards should be given exemplary
punishment
• Grievances regarding the issue of false cards, delay in distribution
are to be heard by any impartial body

PRESSURE GROUPS

Any social group that seeks to influence the behavior of the authority
without capturing formal control of governance is known as pressure

6
group. It is a medium available for the common people to dictate the
course of affairs in the government. The political right of citizens is
limited to exercising the power of casting vote after a certain time gap.
Such democratic deficit is compensated by the existence of pressure
groups. Thus pressure groups act as medium of communication between
government and the citizens.

Lobbying is a common method to create pressure on government. Sending

representation to the legislature or any department to influence policy
making is called lobbying. Use of media, publication of books,
demonstrations, and pamphlets are the other techniques. Such groups are
broadly classified four types- institutional, associational, non
associational, anomic.

In India such groups often use techniques like candle light protests, hartal,
gherao etc. The politics of coalition has made such groups even more
prominent in India.

To sum it up, such groups accelerate social development; prevent

stagnation and increases social cohesion by providing outlet of popular
grievances.

INTEGRATED CHILD DEVELOPMENT SERVICES SCHEME (ICDS)

• India is the home to the largest child population in the world

• As per 2001 census, India has around 157.86 million children,
constituting 15.42% of India's population
• Children are the first call on agenda of human resource
development – not only because young children are the most
vulnerable, but because the foundation for life long learning and
human development is laid in these crucial early years.
• Launched on 2 nd October 1975 in 33 Community
Development Blocks , ICDS today represents one of the world’s
largest programmes for early childhood development. Presently
covers al the blocks and urban slums.
• Presently it includes Kishori Shakti Yojana

Objectives of ICDS:

7
 Lay the foundation for proper psychological development of
the child

Improve nutritional & health status of children 0-6 years

Reduce incidence of mortality, morbidity, malnutrition and

school drop-outs

Enhance the capability of the mother and family to look after

the health, nutritional and development needs of the child

Achieve effective coordination of policy and implementation

among various departments to promote child development

Services

The Scheme provides an integrated approach for converging basic

services through community-based workers and helpers. The
services are provided at a centre called the ‘Anganwadi’. The
Anganwadi, literally a courtyard play centre, is a childcare centre,
located within the village itself. A package of following six services
is provided under the ICDS Scheme:

Supplementary nutrition

Non-formal pre-school education

Immunization

Health Check-up

Referral services

Nutrition and Health Education

ISSUES INVOLVED IN IMPLEMENTING COMPULSORY PRIMARY

EDUCATION IN INDIA

Despite recent hype over the Right to Education Bill making it mandatory
for the Central, state and local bodies to provide free and compulsory
education to all the children in the 6-14 years age group, the real scenario

8
of elementary education in India is pathetic. Below are some of issues
which make free and compulsory education in India a mammoth task.

1. Inadequacy of Financial Provision: Due to over expenditure in defense,

foreign debt, meeting natural disasters among others, and the expenditure
for education in the central level comes down.

2. Poverty among Parents: Education in undeveloped areas still considered

as a luxury because of financial constraints of the parents.

3. Indifference of Parents: An illiterate parent is generally averse to

education. Again,
children from educated families climb the educational ladder more
successfully than those from uneducated families. This develops antipathy
in uneducated parents towards education.

4. Inappropriateness of Curricula: The primary school curricula vary from

State to State. The school curriculum in each of the States is almost
centrally-controlled. There are prescribed syllabi, textbooks etc.,
irrespective of diversities in languages and dialects spoken by the people
and geographical differences. Besides, such curricula do not give
independence to teachers to make variations depending on local needs,
which make them ineffective.

5. Ineffectiveness of Teachers: Lack of effectiveness among teachers

takes root at the time of teacher training. In spite of the known effects of
teacher training on efficiency of teachers, most developing countries have
poor teacher training programmes. Such training programmes in India are
also farcical in nature.

6. Inertia in Administrative and Supervisory Machinery: The inertia

prevailing among administrators and supervisors has its origin in a faulty
recruitment system. The inertia prevailing in the system is responsible for
ill-distribution of available resources. Such problems
get further accentuated because of the multitude of languages and
dialects.

Universalization of primary education is intimately connected with the

development of living conditions of the people. When a significant number
of citizens are below the poverty line, the attempts made to provide free
and compulsory education to children in the age group 6-14 cannot be

9
successful in the near future. There are, in addition, certain educational
and administrative bottlenecks that have been decelerating the process.
Efforts therefore are to be made for complete revamping of the system
both at micro and macro levels, so as to make free education a reality and
not a myth in India.

WOMEN RESERVATION BILL

The uproar over the passage of Women Reservation Bill in India presents
a gloomy scenario of the condition of women in India. While the vehement
opposition from the politicians to pass the bill for years depicts the true
picture of male chauvinism prevailing in the country, the bigger question
remains, why is such a bill important? Does not that itself tell how
miserably we have failed to secure equal rights for the women?

Ever since the Bill was introduced in the Parliament in 1996, it has
aroused wide protests from a group of politicians and every time after
much hype and public attention it goes where it was thirteen years back.
Reservation although a very favorite topic of our revered politicians, has
boomeranged in this issue to themselves as this time their personal
interest is at stake. Who would want to lose their own seats if 33% of the
seats in Lok Sabha or State Assemblies are reserved for the women?
That’s why they can even accept "death" to stop the bill from being
passed by the Parliament. It is high time that these politicians present
themselves in a responsible manner and not create any mockery of such a
serious issue. The indomitable, indefatigable, invincible (You know why I
am stressing so much) spirit that was visible when reservation of castes
was concerned, must be brought back.

Reservation itself is an indication of the failure of the state in any

particular issue. We reserve seats only for those for whom we have so far
done nothing good or who have the potentials of becoming our trump card
in the vote bank. True, by reservation we acknowledge our failure but has
this acknowledgment so far done any justice for those for whom we are
reserving. Our record answers the negative.

So, before we think about reservation for women in the constitutional

forums, we must empower women at the very grass root level. We have to
provide them proper education, at least what their male counterparts are

10
"entitled to" by virtue of their being men in the male chauvinist society.
We must protest dowry which is still widely prevalent in many parts of
this country. We must ensure social protection and safety of women.
Unless these are done, the Women Reservation Bill if passed will be
another mere hollow act, lacking any substance or relevance.

In the fight against injustice and discrimination, there need not be any
discrimination between caste and creed. Women power needs to be
viewed as a single entity and bifurcating women on the basis of caste and
class is not going to serve the purpose. It is high time that we throw away
such "Kinder, Kuche,Kirche" mentality and make women an integral part of
our nation building process.

India becomes adult... Finally!!!

Even the magic of words sometimes doesn’t convey the magic of human
spirit and the passions of a nation. But the landmark judgment by the Delhi
High Court to decriminalizing same sex-sex among the consenting adults
not only conveyed the magic of words but also the magic of human spirit
which in India has been shackled by the Section 377 of Indian Penal Code.
Though Section 377 of the Penal Code which so far had criminalized
homosexuality will continue for non consensual or vaginal sex, the path
breaking verdict marks India's forward journey from infancy caused by
age old prejudices and orthodoxies.

The first country to legalize same sex marriage was Netherlands back in
2001.Since then six countries had done so .Now with the path breaking
judgment India is also in the race to be in the elite club. Now let’s have a
look at the factors behind such a dramatic turn around. There has been
continuous international pressure on India to scrap Article 377 which
criminalizes homosexuality. Moreover, scientists and social activists have
often cursed the menacing article as the main obstacle behind India's
failure in checking the growth of HIV/AIDS patients. The efforts of Naz
Foundation, a Delhi based NGO, the Health minister Shri Ambumani
Ramadoss, celebrities especially from Bollywood along with other fields,
who have always championed the cause of the homosexuals must be
saluted for making the section of IPC a history.

Although the battle is won, the real war is yet to begin. Only when the
Parliament passes a legislature giving recognition to the landmark effort
of the Delhi High Court, the battle will be won. It is up to the civil society

11
of India to shed off age old prejudices and embrace the reality and give an
end to the long drawn battle. It is only then the likes of Harvey Milk will
be smiling from heaven, a smile which they were deprived of while they
were alive.

Ragging- an indicator of degrading values

Ragging is an act of aggression where an individual or a group of

individuals, by virtue of their being seniors get the authority and the
audacity to harass an individual or a group of individuals, who by virtue of
their being fresher in any academic or equivalent institution are always
the victims. It is a vicious cycle of degrading human values where the
students who had been ragged earlier by their seniors, find solace in
ragging their juniors. The cycle goes on, leaving the innocent newly
entrants in the receiving end, often causing their death, as recently
happened to Aman Kachroo, a first year student of Dr Rajendra Prasad
Medical College in Himachal Pradesh.

Ragging in India has been a social menace, an indicator of declining human

values. It is very often psychological, sometimes even physical, thus
leaving a permanent psychotic scar on the victims. There have been more
that thirty ragging related deaths in the past five years in India, majority
being in the campuses of medical or engineering colleges. In addition, a
number of freshmen were severely traumatized to the extent that they
were admitted to mental institutions.

12
Though ragging has ruined the lives of many, resistance against it has
grown up only recently. Several Indian states have made legislatures
banning ragging, and the Supreme Court of India has taken a strong stand
to curb ragging. Ragging has been declared a "criminal offence”. On the
orders of the Honorable Supreme Court of India, the Union Human
Resource Development Ministry set up a committee headed by Dr.
R.K.Raghavan, former Director of CBI, to look into the matter and finding
out possible means to combat the menace. The Committee recommended
ragging to be included in a section of the Indian Penal Code.

With increasing number of ragging related deaths, there has been growing
reactions against ragging in the recent past. India's first anti ragging NGO;
Society Against Violence in Education
(SAVE) has done a commendable job in this regard. The Indian media has
been playing a crucial role by exposing ragging incidents and the
indifference of many concerned institutions towards curbing the act.

However it is the civil society which can play a great role in curbing this
menace. The guardians must demand the security of their children from
the authorities while sending their children to the institutions. The
students must shed their fear and gather the courage to defend
themselves in adverse circumstances by staying united and seeking help
from the anti ragging helpline. The authorities must be proactive and
appoint full time wardens who will be accountable for any violation of laws
in the campuses. There must be anti ragging squads in every college
campus for round the clock vigilance. It is only with such awakening of the
civil society that the hydra headed monster called ragging can be put to
death.

UNORGANISED WORKERS' SOCIAL SECURITY BILL

Unorganized workers' Social Security Bill which has recently been passed
by the Parliament is an evidence of the government's concern for
unorganized workers who constitute a massive 94% of the total work
force in the country and contribute to more than 60% of the GDP of India.
According to the officials, the scheme will cover 34 crore workers in the
next five century including agricultural workers and migrant laborers. This
is being seen as one of the most important steps to alleviate the poverty
of the workers in India.
Under this scheme each worker will be identified and registered and will

13
be given a unique social security number and a social security card. All of
them will be offered a number of social security benefits like health, life
and disability insurance, old age pension, group accident scheme,
maternity benefits etc. Registration of workers will be through the Worker
Facilitation center which will work through various worker facilitation
agencies. Each worker will pay a nominal sum and will obtain a unique
social security card and number. The entire scheme will work through
Central Social Security Authority.
The Scheme promises to ameliorate the age old pangs of the unorganized
workers who even sixty years after independence continue to be
oppressed by socio-economic forces. Only time will tell whether it
remains a paper tiger or becomes the Savior of the workers.

Problems for the mentally challenged people in India

It is unfortunate that in our country very little efforts have so far been
directed towards ameliorating the pangs of the mentally challenged
persons who suffer from one or the other deficiencies of the brain or
nervous system. Despite lofty private and public promises, the real
scenario till date is bleak.
Many factors work behind the scene for such pathetic condition of these
unfortunate people. From the social point of view, first and the foremost is
of course that they are often looked at derogatorily. Very often even the
educated people rather than extending hands of support mock at them.
Lack of facilities for their cure and rehabilitation is another cause for such
sorry state of affairs. There are not enough skilled psychiatrists for their
treatment.

Lack of family support and right attitude is also an important factor. Very
often the parents or other relatives of such people deny taking
responsibilities of them and leave them in asylums or other rehabilitation
centers where facilities are inadequate and treatment is improper.
It is high time that we understand our failure in providing adequate
physical or emotional support to these special people. The NGOs must
take a positive role in this regard. Wide campaigning must be done to
make people aware that with proper care and treatment such deficiencies
can be cured. Last but not the least right use of the government funds and
proper allocation to several schemes can improve the physical
infrastructure of various asylums and rehabilitation centers.

14
http://saptarshinag1.blogspot.com/

15