2/8/2014

Articles: America's Most Important Property Rights Legislation

January 28, 2014

Home Arc hives V ideo Merc handise Donations Contac t About Searc h Login Rules/FAQ

A rchives Ho me --> A rtic les

AMERICAN THINKER VIDEOS

More Videos

Share Email | January 27, 2014

Print |

66 Comments |

Share Facebook |

Share Twitter |

Share

Kinzinger: 'Our Enemies No Longer Fear Us, And Our

W orkers Shoc ked by Sky roc keting Health Costs From

Bad Faith: Public Sc hools Protec t Ow n Rac ket At

America's Most Important Property Rights Legislation

By Mark J. Fitzgibbons

DeBlasio to Boy c ott St. Patric k's Day Parade Over Gay

United Nations Sc olds V atic an Over Child Sex

Flashbac k - Pelosi: Obamac are W ill Supply 400,000

American Thinker has covered the saga of Virginia farmer Martha Boneta, who was cited in 2012 by Fauquier County government and threatened with $5,000 per-day fines for hosting a private birthday party for eight 10-year-old girls without a permit, and advertising pumpkin carvings -- even though she had a business license. Boneta's tiny farm store where she sold organic vegetables, beeswax candles and fibers from her over-100 rescued animals was shut down as she took a principled course of action to fight the county. Every day local governments across the country abuse zoning laws to bully citizens, and violate property and other
http://www.americanthinker.com/2014/01/americas_most_important_property_rights_legislation.html

Recent Articles
The Bully-in-Chief Takes the Bully Pulpit Guns Don't Kill People, Democrats Kill People Obama Has M ade it Impossible for Israel to Strike Iran Obama's Phony Indignities Seeing What isn't There The Dark Enlightenment Hits Stage Two Scarlett Johansson's

FOLLOW US ON

1/5

2/8/2014

Articles: America's Most Important Property Rights Legislation citizens, and violate property and other Scarlett Johansson's constitutionally protected rights. Most Trouble is more than of these abuses are never known by the Oxfam general public because citizens lack the Busted! The Democratic resources to challenge these violations, Party's M oral Superiority or fear fighting back because of the America's M ost Important Property Rights Legislation well-known propensity of government Sex, Politics, Scarlett to retaliate.

Citizens often concede to these abuses, and part little by little -- or a whole lot, literally and figuratively -- with their rights. The U.S. Supreme Court recently called some local abuses of zoning or land use laws "extortive." Local governments have vast opportunity to violate rights on private property because they exercise zoning power through land use laws. Predatory local bureaucrats and anti-property rights crusaders masquerading as environmental groups figured out that it is easy to override property rights at the local government level. In Willie Sutton terms, that's where the control is. The National Association of Counties, for example, works more and more with the Obama administration to implement by executive order intrusive climate change and other invasive regulation at the local and national levels. Into this issue of local government abuses of property rights has stepped Delegate Bob Marshall, well-known as perhaps the most principled constitutional conservative in the Virginia legislature. Marshall has introduced HB 1219, a landmark remedies bill that relies on old and recent precedent to hold abusive government in check. The essence of HB 1219 is that it makes local government and even government officials subject to consequences for their abuses of rights, but in no way impedes proper uses of zoning authority. Under the bill, citizens who sue when localities violate constitutional rights through zoning abuses can be awarded damages including attorney fees. Local governments that intentionally violate rights face stiffer penalties. Local officials
http://www.americanthinker.com/2014/01/americas_most_important_property_rights_legislation.html

Johansson, and the M iddle East

Blog Posts
NBC News Poll: State of the Union - Pessimistic 19 Democratic Senators file amicus brief in Hobby Lobby case Wendy Davis: As the Soap Churns It begins: Obama to raise minimum wage for employees of federal contractors Credibility Lost: Will Obama push global warming measures in SOTU? Pete Seeger dead at 94 Credibility Lost: Bipartisan House group demands Clapper be replaced Credibility Lost: Poll reveals Americans not taking Obamacare deadlines seriously GOP Senators offer 'repeal and replace' legislation for Obamacare Congressman invites father
2/5

2/8/2014

Articles: America's Most Important Property Rights Legislation

who intentionally violate this law are subject to liability. Federal precedent includes the law codified at 42 U.S.C. 1983 and 1988, where citizens can sue for damages and attorney fees when state actors violate constitutional rights "under color of state law," meaning under the guise of state law. HB 1219 creates whistleblower protections for local officials who come forward with violations of this law, and allows the state attorney general to intervene on behalf of victims of government abuse. The bill also instructs courts to nullify local ordinances that violate constitutional rights. Localities would now have better incentive to write ordinances that comply with our supreme, fundamental and paramount law, the Constitution, in the first place. People will say that courts already have this power to nullify unconstitutional laws. True. But in the name of judicial restraint, courts too often defer to inferior laws that violate our supreme law, which allows legislative bodies to trample on our rights. Here, the inferior law eliminates that foible. Constitutionalists especially will like the next provision. It is that local ordinances do not have a presumption of constitutional validity. In a 1981 constitutional challenge to a zoning ordinance, the Virginia Supreme Court declared that local ordinances have a presumption of validity, hence a presumption of constitutionality. This presumption is not created by statute, but by the judiciary, and places the burden on citizens to prove that laws are unconstitutional rather than making government prove that their laws are constitutional, or at least start the case from a level playing field. The respective supreme courts have accorded state and federal statutes a presumption of constitutionality. Some legal scholars including Professor Randy Barnett have criticized that presumption, even calling it unconstitutional. But, state and federal laws at least go through a constitutional process of two legislative chambers and a threat of executive veto. It is that constitutional structure -checks and balances -- on which the presumption is based.
http://www.americanthinker.com/2014/01/americas_most_important_property_rights_legislation.html

Congressman invites father of SEAL killed at Benghazi to SOTU

Monthly Archives
January 2014 December 2013 November 2013 October 2013 September 2013 August 2013 July 2013 June 2013 M ay 2013 April 2013 M arch 2013 February 2013 M ore...

Sponsored Content

Newsmax Headlines

Senate GOP Firm Against Unemployment Extension Obamacare Leaves AIDS Patients in Limbo Iran Sends Warships Close to US Pat Robertson Blasts Creationist: Don't Make Us Joke
3/5

Local ordinances do not go through such a constitutional process, but may be

2/8/2014

Local ordinances do not go through such a constitutional process, but may be passed merely by a vote of three out of five elected officials in some localities. That's hardly a basis for giving ordinances a presumption of constitutional validity.

Articles: America's Most Important Property Rights Legislation

Tim Scott: Liberals Fear Young Blacks Going Conservative Bible Verse Contains Hidden Healing Code Is Obamacare Hurting Your Wallet? Vote Now Three Worst Foods That Damage Your Digestion
What's This?

In the first century of our American republic, citizens could sue and obtain damages from federal officials who exceeded their legal authority. This had the effect of making officials at least think twice before overreaching. HB 1219 includes remedies for ultra vires acts, meaning acting in excess of one's legal authority. Any good remedies law should be intended to prevent the need for litigation in the first place by creating disincentives for bad behavior. Bob Marshall's remedies bill does that by putting arrows in the quiver of any citizen bullied by local governments. It's a model that other state legislatures should replicate, and soon.
Share Email | Print | 66 Comments | Share Facebook | Share Twitter | Share

You May Like

Sponsored Content by Taboola

Infographic: This Chart Predict s A Collapse

Mon ey Mor n i n g

Warren Buffet t Indicat or Signals Collapse in St ock Market

Mon ey n ews

16 Songs Every one Over 50 Should Own

A A RP

http://www.americanthinker.com/2014/01/americas_most_important_property_rights_legislation.html

4/5

2/8/2014

Articles: America's Most Important Property Rights Legislation

Top Ten Cheap All-Inclusive Resort s

T r i pCu r a t or

7 of t he Nicest 35 MPG+ Cars of 2013

In si der Ca r News.com

5 Times Philip Sey mour Hoffman Was Bet t er Than t he Movie

PEOPLE.com

From The Web

What t he Bible Say s About Money (Shocking) (Mon ey n ew s) Homeowners Get a Bailout This Y ear
(Lifest y le Jou r n a l)

Recommended For You

8 Awesome Discont inued Cars That We Want Back (W a ll St . Ch ea t Sh eet ) VOTE: Which Movie Are Y ou Most Excit ed To See In 2014? (Hu bu b) What is MS and what are t he sy mpt oms? (Hea lt h iNa t ion ) Jenny McCart hy Bares All (Or a .T V ) 5 Foods Y ou Should Never Eat Again
(My Diet )

Wort hless Exercises Y ou Probably Do

(T h ePost Ga m e)

Surprising Abraham Lincoln Relat ives Discovered (A n cest r y .com )

7 of t he Nicest 35 MPG+ Cars of 2013

(In sider Ca r New s.com )
Sponsored Content by Taboola

View M obile Version | About Us | Contact | Privacy Policy

American Thinker 2013

http://www.americanthinker.com/2014/01/americas_most_important_property_rights_legislation.html

5/5