Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Celso D. Ratnos*, Denise E. Zantut-Wittmann,t clinical and laboratory criteria and none complained
Marcos A. Tambascia,t Ligia AssumpqBo,t of side-effects, despite significant suppression of
Elba C. S. C. Etchebehere* and TSH levels. In the patient group, thyroid uptake after
Edwaldo E. Camargo* suppression decreased in 10 patients (maximum
*Divisionof Nuclear Medicine, Department of Radiology, reduction 39%), was unchanged In 2 patients and
and t Division of Endocrinology, Department of Internal increased in the remaining 8 patients.
Medicine, School of Medical Sciences, Campinas State CONCLUSION The method described was efficient for
University, Campinas, Brazil demonstration of autonomous thyroid tissue, since
none of the patients showed significant reduction of
(Received 16 March 1999; returned for revision 3 April 1999;
finally revised 1 June 1999; accepted 28 September 1999) thyroid uptake after L-thyroxine suppression com-
pared with the control group. This test was as effec-
tive as the original T3 suppression test, but more
Summary convenient to the patient: no side-effects, ease of
hormonal intake, low dosimetry and short stay in the
OBJECTIVE The thyroid suppression test is still used nuclear medicine laboratory.
in some centres as an adjunt in the dlagnosls of
autonomous functioning thyroid nodules. With the
purpose of minimizing the disadvantages of the ori- The original thyroid suppression test consisted of a measure-
ginal T3 suppression test, we have evaluated the ment of thyroid uptake with [I3'I] iodide before and 7-10 days
efficacy of a method using L-thyroxine as TSH sup- after oral administration of 75- 100 pg of hiiodotironine (T3).
pression agent and [ss"'Tc] pertechnetate as radio- Usually, in a positive test, thyroid uptake decreased by more
pharmaceutical. than 50% of the baseline level. Initially, the most important
DESIGN Open nonrandomized prospective study
indications for this test consisted of distinguishing euthyroid
MATERIALS AND METHODS A control group of 15
from borderline hyperthyroid patients, the diagnosis of
normal volunteers (11 males, 4 females; 21-35 autonomous functioning nodules and some patients with
years, mean 26-4 years) and a patient group of 20 Graves disease. With an autonomous functioning thyroid
patients (18 females, 2 males: 27-83 years, mean 53.6 tissue there was no significant reduction of thyroid uptake
years) divided into 4 subgroups, were studied: 7 after T3 intake (Werner & Spooner, 1955; Hamburger, 1971).
patients with autonomous functioning nontoxic nod- With the ultra-sensitive tests for TSH and free T4 (fT4)
ules, 3 with autonomous functioning toxic nodules, 7 measurement to distinguish euthyroid from hyperthyroid
with Graves disease and 3 with nonautoimmune dif- individuals, the need for a thyroid suppression test declined.
fuse toxic goitre. Baseline thyroid uptake and imaging However, it is still used as an adjunct in the diagnosis of
were begun 20 minutes after an intravenous injection autonomousfunctioning thyroid nodules (Cavalieri & McDougall,
of 370 MBq (10mCi) of [""'Tc] pertechnetate. This 1996).
was followed by a single daily intake of 2pg/kg of There are two disadvantages with the original test: the use of
L-thyroxine, for 10 days. Thyroid imaging and uptake T3 as a TSH suppressor hormone, and the use of [I3'I] iodide
were then repeated. for thyroid imaging and uptake.
RESULTS In the control group [sQmTc]pertechnetate
In the past, T3 was the hormone of choice for treatment of
uptake after L-thyroxine suppression had a mean hypothyroid patients. However, because of its short biological
reduction of 75.8 ? 7.69% (5847%) in comparison to half-life (1 day) and fast absorption, its plasma concentration
the baseline level. All subjects were euthyroid by changes abruptly during the day, even when the daily dose is
fractionated into 3-4 intakes (Brent & Larsen, 1996). For some
Correspondence: Dr Celso Dario Ramos, Division of Nuclear time now, T3 has been replaced by L-thyroxine for hormonal
Medicine, Department of Radiology, School of Medical Sciences,
Campinas State University, PO Box 61 1 1 , 13083-970 Campinas-SP,
treatment, with several advantages: longer biological half-life
Brazil. Fax: + 55 19 252 6826 (7 days) which allows one single daily dose, easy intestinal
E-mail: cdramos@mn-d.com absorption, reliable serum level measurements, and very little
serum level changes between daily intakes (Kaufman et al., antithyroperoxidase antibody (TpOAb) and antithyroglobulin
1991). antibody (TgAb) (enzyme immunoassay, GenBio, San Diego,
Thyroid studies with ["'I] iodide have some disadvantages CA, USA) were also measured.
such as high radiation dose to the gland and poor quality images Among the patients, 4 were on methimazole and had normal
with conventional scintillation cameras. Thyroid studies with serum ff4levels: 1 with autonomous functioning toxic nodule,
[123X]iodide have also some disadvantages such as limited 1 with diffuse toxic goitre and 2 with Graves' disease.
availability and high cost.
On the other hand, technetium-99 m in the chemical form of
Study design
pertechnetateis consideredby many as the radiopharmaceutical
of choice for thyroid scintigraphy, due to its lower radiation For the baseline study, all subjects were placed on a diet
dose to the thyroid and good quality images. The physical without iodme-rich food for two weeks. Thyroid imaging and
half-life of only 6 h of technetium-99 m and the short stay of uptake were performed 20minutes after an intravenous
[w"'Tc] pertechnetate in the thyroid gland are factors that injection of [99mTc]pertechnetate. This was followed by the
permit sequential studies at short time intervals (Reschini et al., oral administration of 2 pgkg of L-thyroxine, as a single daily
1993). dose, in the fasting condition, for 10 days, Thyroid imaging and
With the purpose of minimizing the disadvantages of the uptake were repeated on day 11. In the control group,
original thyroid suppression test with T3, the efficacy of a L-thyroxine intake was begun 24 h after the baseline study.
method using L-thyroxine as TSH suppression agent and [" y c ] The mean time interval between the baseline and after
pertechnetate as the radiopharmaceutical, has been evaluated. suppression thyroid uptake measurements was 2.8 months in
the patient group. During this period, except for the 10days that
preceded the second test, all patients were free of medication,
Materials and methods excluding the 4 patients who needed metimazole.
Control group and patients
Method
Thuty-five subjects, 15 normal volunteers and 20 patients with
thyroid disease, divided into control group and patient group, Images were acquired 20 minutes after an intravenous injection
were studied. r9'
of 370 MBq (10 mCi) of "Tc] pertechnetate on a scintillation
The study protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee camera (Elscint SPX6) equipped with a low energy high
on Human Investigation, School of Medical Sciences, Campinas resolution collimator, using a 128 x 128 matrix and zoom 2. For
State University. All subjects gave written informed consent the uptake measurement, images of the syringe before and after
prior to the study. injection for 2 s each and an image of the anterior neck for
The control group consisted of 11 males and 4 females, with 100OOO counts, were obtained. Additional images of the neck,
ages ranging from 21 to 35 years (mean 26.4 years), all for evaluation of the gland, were obtained in the anterior and
euthyroid by clinical and laboratory criteria (Table 1). 30' anterior oblique views. These images were acquired for
The patient group consisted of 18 females and 2 males with either 180s or 200 000 counts.
autonomous thyroid disease, with ages ranging from 27 to 83 An image of the injection site was obtained to detect possible
years (mean age 53.6 years), divided into 4 subgroups: extravazation of the radiopharmaceutical, which would invalidate
0 seven patients with autonomous functioning nontoxic the thyroid uptake measurement.
nodules (AF'NTN); The method used for measuring thyroid uptake was based on
0 three patients with autonomous functioning toxic nodules the technique described by Maisey et al. (1973).Thyroid uptake
("); was calculated from the images acquired on the scintillation
0 seven patients with Graves' disease (GD), but clinically camera and processed with a dedicated nuclear medicine
euthyroid and with active disease by laboratory criteria; computer. The thyroid gland was delineated from a circular
0 three patients with nonautoimmune diffuse toxic goitre 'master' region of interest (ROI) which included the entire
(DTG). thyroid gland; then, the computer programme automatically
Laboratory assessment of thyroid function was performed in all detected the outer borders of the gland. A second ROI was
subjects by measuring serum f14 (or total T4) and TSH levels automatically drawn below the gland for calculation of the
(ultra-sensitive TSH assay) (fluorometric enzyme immune background radiation.
assay, Dade Behring Inc., Miami, FL, USA). In the control The normal range of [wmTc] pertechnetate thyroid uptake
group, additional serum f l 4 and TSH levels were obtained after previously determined in our laboratory in a group of 40 normal
L-thyroxine administration. In the patient group, serum volunteers using the same method was 0.36% to 1.6%.
0 2000 Blackwell Science Ltd, Clinical Endocrinology, 52,471-477
Thyroid suppression test 473
Table 1 Control group data before and after L-thyroxyne suppression test
*Total T4(normal range 60-154 nmoyl); Free T4 (normal range 9.5-27.0 pmoM); TSH (normal range 0.38-6-15 mUfl); [Tc-99m] pertechnetate
uptake (normal range 0.36-1.6%)
Table 2 patient group data before and after L-thyroxine suppression test
Free T4, *Total T4, TSH and [Tc-99 m] pertechnetate uptake: normal range and units as given in Table 1. A F " , autonomous functioning nontoxic
nodules; AFI",autonomous functioning toxic nodules; GD, Graves' disease; DTG, nonautoimmune diffuse toxic goitr; MMI, methimazole; TPOAb,
antithyroperoxidase antibody; TgAb, antithyroglobulin antibody. Images: MN, multinodular goitre; SN, solitary nodule; P, extra - nodular
parenchyma; DG, difuse goitre.
widely used for this purpose. However, its use has been A thyroid suppression test using T3 was described by Werner
restricted, due to undesirable pharmacological characteristics and Spooner (1953, at a time when synthetic L-thyroxine was
and some side-effects. These are caused by rapid absorption of not available. Today the test is still performed as originally
nearly 100% of the ingested hormone and peak serum described, with oral administration of T3, with undesirable
concentration in 2 - 4 h after oral administration. Thus, low T3 side-effects to the patient. Furthermore, from the theoretical
doses such as 25 pg, may lead rapidly to high serum levels, that viewpoint, pituitary TSH suppression may not be effective and
are not maintained constant. Also, the administration of 50- constant with oral T3, because its serum levels change
75 p g as a single oral dose may result in serum levels as high as significantly throughout the day.
9.2 -10-8 nmoyl, which are poorly tolerated especially by the L-thyroxine therefore could be administered in a safer
elderly (Harbert, 1996). Even if this physiological dose is manner, minimizing side-effects and resulting in a stable and
fractionated at 6 h intervals, the serum levels are widely reproducible TSH suppression. Despite these advantages, there
variable during the day (Kaufman et al., 1991). are no reports in the literature on the routine use of thyroid
Today the preferred drug for therapy of hypothyroidism is suppression test with L-thyroxine.
synthetic L-thyroxine, due to its ease of absorption, long Administration of L-thyroxine for 10 days was based on the
biological half-life and high affinity for the transporter protein fact that the peak action of this hormone occurs in
TBG, all factors that lead to a stable serum concentration and approximately 10 days (Blackbwn et al., 1954; Farwell &
consequently to normalization of TSH levels. Minor changes in Braverman, 1996). In the control group, using 2 pg/kg/day of L-
the serum concentration of thyroid hormones cause large thyroxine for 10 days, TSH suppression was demonstrated by
variations in TSH levels. Therefore, normal serum levels of laboratory data in all individuals. As described in the literature,
TSH reflect adequate hormone replacement and physiological the maintenance dose of L-thyroxine for patients with primary
action of the hormone (Atkins, 1971; Cam et al., 1988). hypothyroidism ranges from 1.6 to 1.8pgkg according to
0 2000 Blackwell Science Ltd. Clinical Endocrinology, 52, 471 -477
Thyroid suppression test 475
Maisey, M.N.,Natakarajan, T.K., Hurley, P.J. & Wagner, H.N. Jr thyroid scintiscans in thyroid disease. Journal of Nuclear Biology
(1973) Validation of a rapid computerizedmethod of mesuring -Tc and Medicine, 37, 12-17.
pertechnetate uptake for routine assessment of thyroid structure and Stock, J.M., Surks, M.I. & Oppenheimer, J.H. (1974) Replacement
function. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, 36, dosage of L-thyroxine in hypothyroidism. A re-evaluation. New
317-322. England Journal of Medicine, 290,529-533.
Parker, T.W., Mettler, F.A. Jr, Christie, J.H.& William, A.G. (1984) Toft, A.D. (1994) Thyroxine therapy. New England Journal of
Radionuclide thyroid studies: a survey of practice in the United Medicine, 331, 174-180.
States in 1981. Special Report. Radiology, 150,547-550. Werner, S.C. & Spooner, M. (1955) A new and simple test for
Reschini, E., Catania, A., Ferrari, C., Bergonzi, M., Paracchi, A. & hyperthyroidismemploying L-Triiodothyronine and the 24 hour I3'I
Raineri, P. (1993) Comparison of pertechnetate and radioiodine uptake method. Bulletin ofNew York Academy of Medicine, 31, 137.