Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
R E V I E W B Y F R A N C I S A. A N D R E W
REVIEW | FRANCIS A. ANDREW
Diseases from Space was a highly controversial book when it first came out in 1979. Its challenge to the whole concept of where diseases originate still makes it controversial in 2014. The book develops the hypothesis that many of the most common diseases which afflict mankind, such as influenza, the common cold and whooping cough, have their origins in extraterrestrial sources. The two authors argue the case for outer space being the main source for these pathogens- or at least their causative agents.
Overview
978-0060119379 ISBN Sir Fred Hoyle and Professor Nadine Chandra Wickramasinghe spent over 20 years investigating the nature and composition of interstellar dust. Though many theories regarding this dust had been postulated by various astronomers since the middle of the 19th century, all were found to be wanting as and when new data on the gas and dust clouds became available. While Hoyle and Wickramasinghe never set out to be controversial, but rather, to explain the phenomenon they were investigating within the boundaries of conventional theory, their research led them to the astonishing but inevitable conclusion that, as the spectroscopic data of the gas clouds matched those for desiccated bacteria, the core component of interstellar dust was indeed just that - desiccated bacteria. This led the two scientists in the direction of explaining the spread of diseases in ways which challenged the mainstream human-to-human transmission process of diseases, substituting it with an alternative theory which postulated that diseases such as influenza and the common cold are incident from space and fall upon the Earth in what they term "pathogenic patches." Hoyle and Wickramasinghe found themselves compelled to understand the process of evolution in a manner at variance with the standard Darwinian model. They averred that genetic material in the form of incoming pathogens from the cosmos provided the mechanism for driving the evolutionary engine.
Theory
Delivery mechanism for space incident pathogens
It is important to mention how Hoyle and Wickramasinghe describe the way pathogens are brought to Earth from out space and what happens to these pathogens when they enter the terrestrial atmosphere.
movement of people and animals (especially birds) from one pathogenic patch to another causes the illusion of diseases being spread by people. They also controversially argue that medical authorities (such as the World Health Organisation are similarly operating under an illusion in setting up projects to rid the world of various diseases. From an historical perspective, Hoyle and Wickramasinghe have observed that many diseases which exist now did not exist at various times in the past; also they have found descriptions of diseases by Thucydides which defy any kind of comparison with known diseases in the modern period. Hoyle and Wickramasinghe site Thucydides "The Peloponesian Wars."
the spread of colds and influenza. Furthermore, it would be impossible for any susceptible person to escape the disease if there were any person carrying a load of 10,000 million viral particles per cubic meter - however, most susceptible persons do escape. Yet the persistence in the common cold is shown by the high rates of infection; adults on average contract two to three colds per annum with children contracting anything from between six and twelve per annum.
Meteorological factors
Hoyle and Wickramasinghe point out that colds are more frequent when the grounds is cold and less frequent when it is warm. The temperature differences between the sea and the land are produced by the heating and cooling of the land. The coldest temperature difference between sea and land is in February. This is when a thermodynamic engine carrying heat from the sea to the land comes into operation thus bringing storms landward. These storms produce eddy transfers into the stratosphere. The electrical fields generated by these transfers pull down micro-meteorites which otherwise would take five years to reach down to the troposphere. Hoyle and Wickramasinghe explain that this process would require the particles to be of the size of around 5 millionths of a centimeter - which is about the size of viral particles.
Another experiment
Another of Sir Christopher Andrewes' experiments cited in Diseases from Space involved eight people being exposed for ten hours to others infected with the common cold virus. Between twenty four and thirty six hours later, some of those inoculated with the virus remained symptom free. Eleven other people were exposed to those with fully developed colds. Only one person, who had been exposed to the symptom free group, caught a cold. As in the case of the aforementioned experiment, there appears to be low occurrence of spread by contact. Hoyle and Wickramasinghe discount the suggestion that this
phenomenon could be explained by immunity due to the large numbers of viral types and subtypes of the common cold.
during the spring thaw. It was therefore extrapolated that the cold virus had been brought to the island by infected seamen on the boats. The authors of Diseases from Space offer an alternative explanation for this co-incidence: they argue that the melting of the ice in spring causes disturbances in the atmosphere which pull down micrometeorites to ground level. As the melting of the ice allows for open water for the entry of ships, the false impression is given that it is the ships that are responsible for the bringing of the disease into the island. The three seamen who had come down with colds were blamed for spreading the disease throughout the island. Yet their names were never released, nor was there any record of the traces of their movement. Hoyle and Wickramasinghe observe that in all cases where colds and influenza are brought to isolated communities, there are no details released of the contacts responsible for allegedly bringing the diseases. They are generally, nameless, faceless and shadowy individuals who, without trace, consistently remain in obscurity. The two authors interestingly equate this strange phenomenon with the medieval figure of death - the Grim Reaper.
aircraft have failed to function as conveyers of the disease ( p. 68 ). Once again, Hoyle and Wickramasinghe attribute this pattern of spread, which fails to accord with the human-to-human transmission concept, to theory that viruses are incident from space.
101 ). Instead the authors described the nature of the spread of the disease as "jumping about" ( p. 102 ). This "jumping about" could be explained by factors related to Meteorology.
A Historical Perspective.
By examining the historical incidences of various diseases, the authors attempt to add credibility to their theory that many diseases both emanate from outer space and fail the contagion hypothesis. In considering so-called Infectious diseases from an historical perspective, Sir Fred Hoyle and Chandra Wickramasinghe make clear that for a virus to maintain an effective human reservoir, there must be a high enough birth rate for the virus to spread itself as surviving humans who have a life-long immunity to a viral attack will no longer be able to function as reservoirs. For person to person transmission to be effective, there must be high concentrations of population. As early hunter-gatherer societies were concentrated in small groups and widely scattered ( as in the case of the Alaskan Eskimo population referred to above )diseases infecting these early human societies must therefore have originated from an outside source. In examining the disease of Poliomyelitis the authors mention the case of this disease having been discovered in an Egyptian pre-dynastic ( Pre-dynastic Egypt) mummy. Hoyle and Wickramasinghe investigate other epidemic outbreaks and notice the sporadic nature of their occurrence. Trachoma, Cholera, Measles, Mumps, Chickenpox, Bubonic plague, Smallpox, all display a mysterious coming and going. The authors are convinced that the explanation of this phenomenon lies in recognising a spacebased origin of these diseases.
Our Place in the Cosmos, The Intelligent Universe, Life on Mars, Astronomical Origins of Life. For more information on the cometary mechanism for the transportation of pathogens to planets, see Living Comets.
Publication history
First published in 1979 by J.M. Dent & Sons Ltd. Published in 1980 by Harper & Row. Published in 1981 by Sphere Books Ltd.