Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
UFO JOURNAL
OCTOBER 1997 ~f NUMBER 354 $3
O C T O B E R 1 997 N U M B E R 354
READER'S CLASSIFIEDS 21
CALENDAR 22
COVER — SR-71 and U-2 Photos courtesy of the book The World's Great Stealth and
Reconnaissance Aircraft
MUFON UFO JOURNAL Copyright 1997 by the Mutual UFO Network. All Rights Rcsen'ed.
(USPS 002-970) No part of this document may be reproduced in any form without tht' written permission of
(ISSN 0270-6822) the Copyright Owners. Permission is hereby granted to quote up to 200 words of any one arti-
103 Oldtowne Rd. cle, provided the author is credited, and the statement, "Copyright 1997 by the Mutual UFO
Seguin, TX 78155-4099 Network, 103 Oldtowne Rd., Seguin, Texas 78155," is included.
Tel: (830) 379-9216
FAX (830) 372-9439 The contents of the MUFON UFO lournal are determined by the editors and do not necessari-
ly reflect the official position of the Mutual UFO Network. Opinions expressed are solely those
EDITOR of the individual authors.
Dennis Stacy The Mutual UFO Network. Inc. is exempt from Federal Income Tax under Section 501 (c)
(3) of the Internal Rei'enue Code. MUFON is a publicly supported organization of the type
ASSOCIATE EDITOR described in Section 509 (a) (2). Donors may deduct contributions from their Federal Income
Walter H. Andrus, Jr. Tax. Bequests, legacies, devises, transfers or gifts are also deductible for estate and gift purposes,
provided they meet the applicable provisions of Sections 2055, 2106 and 2522 of the Internal
COLUMNISTS
Revenue Code. MUFON is a Texas nonprofit corporation.
Walter N. Webb
The MUFON UFO Journal is published monthly by the Mutual UFO Network, Inc., Seguin,
John S. Carpenter
Texas. Membership/Subscription rates: $30 per year in the U.S.A.; $30 foreign in U.S. funds.
T. David Spencer Second class postage paid at Seguin, TX.
ART DIRECTOR POSTMASTER: Send form 3579 to advise change of address to: MUFON UFO JOUR-
Vince Johnson NAL, 103 Oldtowne Rd., Seguin, TX 78155-4099.
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
«if^ An extraordinary 9S percent cf all Americans have at least heard or read somethinj abcvt Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs), and bV
percent believe they are real ,(l)_Fcr.ner US Paste as Cajrte: and Reagan claii'.i ID h«ve seen a UFO UFOfc'4:sts--a neologism for
UF1 j bvffs--an4 private UFC organizations aje fovnd throvghout the U rated States Many are cor^inced that the US < Tnverrjnent, aiid
paracvl»ilv CIA, axe er^sjed u a uiusire conipiracv and coveiTp of the issue The idea that •?; A his secretly co.icetJei :ts rese?i;h
uto IJF'J: has bee.i a m«jcr Aeme cf ITP~.- buffs SLice the /node^-. "JFC1 phereiiTMr-.a e/jierjed L-. the >te 19-X3s .(2)
In >w 1993, tins beLii pressv^d by ".T'JkiiTJts for -JK release of additmr.sl 7IA iiifoLT.aoc-.i or. 'JF':'S,_(3>. ZCI R James Woc^ey
ordered aiTothe» OVKV of ail Aje.icy aes on UFvs Usi-ig i.'IA records coii-.p-Jed from that reviev, tks study traces CIA interest and
irrolTemem m the UFO ccnloversy from the h»> 1 9-40i w I Q^ It chronolcjrKsJly exa/r^ves The Aiency1 s efforts t: solve the i;iys»ry
of UFOs, its projraj'ns UwthM M ijiipact on UF-r siihtmgs.Jiilits etempts »o corp^al > "!A inv.V.ve/,y>r.t in the entire UF-J usw WhM
er.isrzes froyn This examratKn is that, vhife Aje.icv conceal over "JF^'S vas svbstjiit?! «ntU the ejily 1950s, CIA has since part only
Lmfcd and peripheral anenocn to
Background
The emergence in 1Q-J7 of the CcW War ccriLcnaoun betveen the United States and the Soviet Ui-jcn also sav the fust -rsve of UFC
sifchtnjs The first report of a "Gyms sauce:" over the United Stttes carae on 2-1 Jiine 19J7, vhe.i Kenneth Arnold, a private pifct and
reputjble ivsuwssjiian, vhile tooVjnj for a dovned plsuis sighted nine disk-sh«.ped ct)ects r«eai- Kt Rainier, Wash^jvan, wveiLifc at
an estimated speed cf over 1,000 r.iph ArnoJd s report TBS folioved by a flood of additional si^har^s, inclu<lL.is reports from rndrsry
and civiliaii pifcts end an1 traffic conMiiers all ever the I Inited States (4). la 19-)C, Air Force '"Jen 1 laftan Tviiunj, head of the Aj1
Technical Service -ronj-nand, estiitshed Project SIOJl (imtnliy n-?ji«d Project SAUCER) w co^ect, colle.te, eval-jate, and distntv*
viTh^ii Th<> oTtypi^.-.i^.-it ftll info\v.'«inr;i iTpfoni'c- t.T «siirh ^iQ'hniV^*! n.'' tV nrp.'n«:p T^.^T TPi'j*! 'n^/hr hp .pal tird rf iift*v..-ift1 <y.7in*?Tv
CIA's Role in the Study of UFOs, This was the "home" of Projects SIGN, According to a
1947-90" is a recently published arti- GRUDGE and BLUE BOOK (see below). CIA historian,
cle that describes CIA involvement in the Consequently the CIA was "fed" the con- over half of all
history of UFO phenomena. The article, by ventional AF position on the subject (no ev-
UFO reports
CIA historian Gerald Haines, is published in idence of truly new technology: no evidence
the unclassified version of Studies in Intel- of a threat). In the late summer of 1952 the from the late
ligence, a twice-yearly CIA journal (Volume CIA investigated Project Blue Book and 50s through
1, 1997. pg. 67). concluded that it was satisfactory if all one the 60s were
The article presents the history of CIA wanted to do was separate explainable attributable to
involvement as determined mostly from sightings from those which were not ex- high-flying
documents released by the CIA nearly 20 plainable. However, the CIA analysts were U-2s.
years ago. There is also some updating on critical of the Air Force for not studying the
CIA activities since the documents were re- unexplained sightings to find out the under- Preposterous,
leased in December, 1978. lying causes of the reports. The CIA evalu- says Bruce
According to the CIA documents, in the ated the whole subject and concluded that Maccabee.
early days (late 40s early 50s) the CIA got there might really be something unusual go-
its UFO information from the Air Technical ing on. During the fall of 1952 at least one
Intelligence Center at the Air Materiel CIA official, Marshall Chadwick, appar- October
1997
Command headquartered at Wright- ently believed that the unexplained sight- Number 354
Patterson Air Force Base, Dayton, Ohio. ings were a real mystery. However, before Pages
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
The U-2, with carrying out an in-depth study to be autho- and reflected the rays of the sun, especially
its 80-foot rized by the National Security Council, he at sunrise and sunset. They often appeared
wingspan, flew wanted to have a panel of experts review as fiery objects to observers below. Air
the situation. This panel, which came to be Force BLUE BOOK investigators, aware of
at 60-70,000
known as the Robertson Panel after its the secret U-2 flights, tried to explain away
feet and at chairman, carried out its review in early such sightings by linking them to natural
that altitude 1953. After this review, which basically phenomena such as ice crystals and temper-
was essen- adopted the AF official position that every- ature inversions. By checking with the
tially invisible thing could be explained, the CIA appar- Agency's U-2 Project Staff in Washington,
during the ently lost interest in the subject. All of the BLUE BOOK investigators were able to at-
above has been known for years. However, tribute many UFO sightings to U-2 flights.
day. It created
the new article reveals some information They were careful, however, not to reveal
no contrail be- which was still classified Top Secret in the true cause of the sighting to the public."
cause of the December, 1978 when the FOIA documents Project BLUE BOOK was the publicly
lack of mois- were released. According to Mr. Haines 1 ar- known Air Force effort to collect and ex-
ture at that al- ticle, when the U-2 high altitude spy plane plain, if possible, UFO sightings. Any sight-
titude. began flying (first flight on August 4, ings which they could not explain were cat-
1955), CIA project directors discovered that egorized as unknown. No careful analyses
"commercial pilots and air traffic con- of the unknowns were carried out. Project
trollers began reporting a large increase in BLUE BOOK ran from early 1951 through
UFO sightings." 1969, When it closed, BLUE BOOK and its
The U-2 is the high altitude spy plane predecessors (Project SIGN, 1948,'and
made famous by the 1960 shootdown of Project GRUDGE, 1949-1951) had col-
Gary Powers as he flew over the Soviet lected about 13,000 sightings, of which
Union and by photos taken from a U-2 of about 700 were left unexplained.
Russian missile sites in Cuba during the The claim that the U-2 caused "over half
"Cuban Missile Crisis." of all UFO reports from the late 1950s
through the 1960s" is, to put it gently, pre-
cation, 1968; Bantam edition, 1969, pg. BOOK sightings and hence would not be in- In the early
514), which includes sightings by pilots and cluded in this database. On the other hand, 1960s many of
air traffic controllers as well as by military the far larger collection of non-Blue Book the U-2s were
personnel and civilians ^hows the follow- sightings in this database could include U-2
painted black
ing numbers of sighiniL's tor the six months sightings, if the CIA is correct, that were
before to the six months .itier flights began not identified by civilian investigators who or other cam-
in early August: Feb - 34, Mar-41, Apr - were unaware of the U-2's existence. Hence ouflage colors,
33, May - 54, Jun - 48, Jul - 63, Aug - 68, a comparison of the sighting statistics be- further reduc-
Sep - 57, Oct - 55, Nov - 32, Dec - 25, Jan fore and after U-2 flights started could pro- ing visibility
(1956) - 43. Notice that the August increase vide evidence that the U-2 was being re- from sun glint.
of 5 reports over the number in July may ported as a UFO. Tn this database ] find the
Hence the
have been just a continuation of the overall following:
increase that began in April, 1955. Then the probability of
number of reports per month dropped even YEAR/MONTH seeing one
though the number of U-2 flights increased. J F M A M J J A S O N D Tot. was even less
The total number of reports during the 6 1954 13 13 12 1725 28 18 14 18 4 15 10-187 than before.
months before the start of U-2 flights is 273. 1955 I I 8 9 4 12 1 I 30 29 12 13 12 6 157
The total number for the 6 months follow- 1956 10 1 1 7 5 13 20 33 43 9 6 1 2 3 174
ing the start (Aug - Jan) is 280. 1957 3 6 7 3 6 5 12 7 9 10 110 1 1 1 8 9
Thus, there was a 100 x (7/273) = 2.6% 1958 5 0 4 8 3 5 2 8 4 12 61 58
increase in the number of reports following
the start of U-2 flights using the six month As one can see from the above table,
totals. These numbers are the sum of ex- there is no evidence of an increase in
plained and unexplained sightings and so monthly sighting rales following the first
i n c l u d e U-2 sightings, if any. These statis- flight of the U-2 on Aug. 4, 1955. The
tics Miygcsi that the U-2 was causing no large increase in November, 1957 occurred
more ih.m .1 few percent of the sightings just after Sputnik 2 was launched. (This flap
(and may have caused NONE of the sight- is noted for the large number of close-range
ings!). Comparing yearly statistics in the car-stopping events. Most of the sightings
Condon Report we find: 1953 - 509, 1954 - were not sightings of Sputnik itself.)
487, 1955 - 545. Tn 1956 there was an in- An even more telling set of statistics uses
crease during the summer months with 72 in the sightings which occurred near sunrise or
July, 123 in August and 71 in September sunset when, according to Mr. Haines, the
which, when added to the nominal rate for U-2 would have appeared as a shiny or fiery
the other months (40 to 50 per month) re- bright spot in the sky.
sulted in a total of 670 for the year. The
year 1957 had 1005 reports, mostly as a re- TIME 0400 to 0700 (which encompasses
sult of the "Sputnik Flap" (103 in October, the time before sunrise) (With a time win-
361 in November and 136 in December; dow this wide we get an overestimate of the
other months were in the range of 40 - 70 number of sightings just before sunrise; the
reports). Although the number of U-2 air- time of sunrise varies during the year.)
craft and the number of flights increased August 1955 is noted by *2*.
during the following years the number of
sightings showed no correlation: 1958 - YEAR/MONTH
627, 1959-390, 1960-557, 1961 -591, J F M A M J J A S O N D Tot.
1962-474, etc. 1953 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 O i l ] 5
Statistics based on a different set of data 1954 0 0 1 0 0 2 1 I 2 0 0 0 7
are contained within the "U Database" of 1955 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 *2* 1 1 I 0 7
over 14^000 sightings by Larry Hatch (Larry 1956 0 1 0 1 1 2 6 2 1 0 1 0 15
Hatch Software, 142 Jeter St., Redwood 1957 1 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 13 I 19
City, CA 94025-1957). This excellent PC- 1958 O O O J O O O O O O O O I
based software provides statistics that are
based on unexplained sightings recorded by TIME 1700 to 2100 (which encompasses
Project BLUE BOOK and by other organi- the time after sunset) (With a time window
zations (civilian UFO groups). If Project this wide we get an overestimate of the
BLUE BOOK investigators explained some number of sightings just after sunset; local October
1997
sightings as the U-2, these sightings would sunset time varies during the year.) Number 354
not appear in the list of unexplained BLUE PageS
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
1 f; §c ientfsts; to,
cfjsfiKintJc .space
marketing campaign aimed at grabbing at- NOUNCEMENTS BY THE ARMY ON AND AFTER Above. You
tention and increasing the company's com- JULY 7TH OF 1947 REGARDING AN ALLEGED
MISHAP INVOLVING SOME FORM OF AIRBORNE may not find
puter sales? The interested are invited to CRAFT OUTSIDE OF ROSWELL, NEW MEXICO, the answers
visit ACC's web site at http://www.amen- AND SINCE THAT TIME, REGARDING A LARGE
can-computer.com. The following is repro- NUMBER OF OTHER ALLEGED, SO-CALLED to all of
"UNIDENTIFIED FLYING OBJECT" INCIDENTS. Corso's ques-
duced verbatim from the company's web
page. THE MOST COMMON EXPLANATIONS. SEEM- tionable
INGLY NUMEROUS, OFTEN FAR-FETCHED MANY
TEXT OF THE INVITATION TO SHADOWLAKE IS- TIMES VERY CONTRADICTORY, AND GENERALLY
claims here,
SUED BY AMERICAN COMPUTER COMPANY: NOT WIDELY BELIEVED, HAS CAUSED TO COME but the com-
INTO BEING, A 'SITUATION' THAT SORELY
AMERICAN COMPUTER COMPANY NEEDS ADDRESSING, IN KEEPING WITH OUR puter prices
(• COMMERCE DRIVE CRAWFORD. AMERICAN HERITAGE - THAT OF A PEOPLE AND aren't half
NEW JERSEY 07016 A COUNTRY FOUNDED FOR ONE OVER-RIDING
PURPOSE: OUR EMINENT AND MUTUAL FREEDOM. bad.
22-SEPT-1997
IT HAS BEEN THAT, FOR SOME TIME. MEM-
A COMMUNIQUE ADDRESSED TO THE SECRE- BERS OF THE AMERICAN PUBLIC HAVE EX-
TARY OF DEFENSE, VARIOUS SENIOR PENTAGON PRESSED' FAIRLY WIDESPREAD OUTRAGE OVER A
OFFICIALS OF THE UNITED STATES ARMY AND WIDELY HELD BELIEF THAT OUR GOVERNMENT
AIR FORCE. AND THE JOINT CHIEFS OF HAS HELD BACK SECRETS THAT, WERE THEY
STAFF. WAS ISSUED AS OF 18:00 HOURS BY REVEALED, WOULD ALLEGEDLY REVEAL A LONG
AMERICAN COMPUTER COMPANY, SET FORTH AS PRACTICE OF CONCEALMENT CONNECTED WITH
FOLLOWS- VISITS TO OUR PLANET BY OTHERWORLDLY
SPECIES, CONCEALMENT OF THE TRUTH FROM
RE: A MATTER OF CONSIDERABLE URGENCY THE AMERICAN PEOPLE AND ALL OF HUMANITY.
were at the corners of each side and at the 00:10-1:10 GMT, for 1 minute. Then they saw
front apex. On the sides, smaller red lights Investigator: John Thompson an oblong,
were to the inside of each white light, and a smaller craft,
blue light was at the center. They estimated On three separate occasions, the witness
having a gray-
the object to be about 100 feet long and 20- saw an object in the vicinity of highway 27
30 feet tall. between LaGrange and Franklin, Georgia. ish color and
By the time the couple had driven a few The first two occurred on two nights in a traveling
blocks and reached University Avenue, they row, and one two days before the third. The about the
had lost sight of the vehicle. They attempted first, which he observed for about 15 sec- speed of a
to locate it again but were unsuccessful. onds as he drove on, was about a half mile propeller
The investigator contacted the FAA, Des away, hovering over a ridge line. The sec-
plane, almost
Moine's Police, the Polk County Sheriff, ond was moving from the southwest to the
and the Drake Observatory without finding northeast very slowly, and he watched it for on a collision
corroborating reports. about 30 seconds. Both were at treetop alti- course with
tude. During the third sighting — which in- the oddity. As
LOG # 970303E: FB-1, 03/03/97, Franklin, volved an object he thought was the same as the oblong
GA, at 14:00 hours EST, 19:00 GMT, for the two earlier sightings, but four miles far- craft passed
0.2 minutes. Investigator: Tracy Hardy, ther south — the witness watched the tree-
the object,
John Thompson top-level, huge craft fly directly overhead,
coming within 100 feet. both of them
Three young men were driving south on The witness was driving south on high- vanished.
highway 27 about one mile south of way 27 and saw multicolored lights flicker-
Franklin on a bright, sunny day when the ing through the trees to his right. He looped
driver noticed a "shiny blob" hovering at the car around to face the lights and stopped
about 25,000 feet a mile away in the east- at the intersection with the entrance to
northeast. He lost sight of the object, then Grayson's Landing to watch it approach.
saw its reflection of sunlight again three Moving at a speed less than 20 mph, a 250-
miles later, after alerting his two passengers. 300 foot long cigar-shaped vehicle loomed
Farther away and to the east of their posi- over him, blinking some of its 10 white,
tion, the craft could only be seen for a few green and red lights as it passed. Both ends
seconds. Two miles past highway 100, all of the shape were rounded. The witness
three in the car saw the object for about five made out a several-foot-wide indentation in
seconds. During this short time, they saw an the dark, non-metallic surface. The recess
oblong, smaller craft, having a grayish was across its flat, 100-foot width, at its
color, possibly having wings, and travelling middle and gave him the impression of a
about the speed of a conventional propeller doorway that "could open up."
plane, almost on a collision course with the The object continued its journey to the
oddity. As the oblong craft passed the ob- northeast and went out of sight behind the
ject, both of them vanished. trees.
The investigator contacted the county
Sheriff's Department and was told there had At about 09:00 hours on February 17, 1997
been a UFO report on their recorder, and an area near LaGrange, Georgia experi-
there had also been a white helicopter in the enced a small earth tremor having a magni-
area about the same time. The witnesses tude of 2.0 on the Richter scale, which was
said what they saw was not a helicopter. A apparently accompanied by a "loud sonic
person living near where the sighting was boom, " according to one witness. Later that
made was contacted, but the person had not day and the next, three sightings of anom-
seen either an anomalous object or a heli- alous objects occurred, which makes one
copter. wonder if the sightings and the tremor were
somehow related. The airport, police, and
The investigator claims that many reports of Atlanta FAA all indicated they had not re-
unexplained, anomalous objects seen in this ceived any cal/s regarding unusual aircraft
area have been made in the past, including that evening.
April 1995.
LOG # 970610E: FB-1, 02/17/97,
LOG # 970901SE: CE-1, 04/xx/95, LaGrange, GA, at 21:00 hours, for 1 October
1997
LaGrange, GA, at 22:10 hours EST/EDT, minute. Investigator: John Thompson Number 354
Page 9
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
The USAF In the wooded and hilly suburbs of Also on February 17, about 300 miles
dentist fo- LaGrange, the witness was outside saying from LaGrange, Georgia, a sighting was
cused his farewell to her son-in-law when she noticed made in Mississippi. This sighting occurred
binoculars on a glowing object in the south approaching. about six hours after the tremor and six
When it was closer, three soft-white lights hours before any of the sightings in
one of the ob-
about the size of a golf ball at arm's length Georgia.
jects and and in a triangular formation were seen
studied it "floating" in the sky and moving in unison. LOG # 970514bC: FB-1, 02/17/97, Biloxi,
closely, find- Two of the lights led the third, passing by at MS, at 14:30 hours, for 7 minutes.
ing it to be less than 1,000 feet altitude, and silently go- Investigators: J.R. Gillis and Don Hirth
shaped like a ing out of sight.
The witness used the 800 number to call
disc. Six lights LOG#970217E: CE-1, 02/17/97, MUFON headquarters, which resulted in his
were on the Franklin, GA, at 21:10 hours, for 2 minutes. being put in direct contact with one of the
bottom, one in Investigator: John Thompson investigators.
the center A middle-aged USAF dentist was clean-
and the others In the country near Franklin, two middle- ing his carport when he heard jet aircraft
around the aged and one young lady were outside when and looked up to watch them cross over-
they saw a glowing, multi-colored object head. At the same time, he glimpsed some-
bottom edge.
approach at a low altitude and at a rapid but thing shiny to the northwest and turned to
not incredible speed ("faster than a prop but see a bright object at a distance. Realizing
slower than a jet"). The red, blue, white, this was not a typical aircraft, he rushed into
and yellow lights were in a group like a tri- the house to get his binoculars. When he
angle, but no triangular object's surface was came back out to look, the single object was
seen. The assembly of lights passed on by now four bright lights.
them, then out of sight, without a sound. He focused his 7x35 binoculars on one of
the objects and studied it closely, finding it
LOG # 970218E: FB-1, 02/18/97, Glenn, to be shaped like a disc. Six lights were on
GA, at 06:45 hours, for 2 minutes. the bottom, one in the center and the others
Investigator: John Thompson around the bottom edge. Bright white, the
object switched to red, then back to white
Watching television and sipping a cup of before it was out of sight.
coffee in her country abode outside of The investigators talked to the local po-
Glenn, Georgia, a middle-aged insurance lice and Keesler AFB trying to find corrob-
agent looked out her window to see a group orating information, but without luck.
of about 15 white lights in a row, in the
southwest and moving slowly eastward. The
anomaly was at a low (treetop) altitude, and PROJECT 1947
the assemblage was about the size of a base- MUFON has a limited supply of
ball at arm's length. Each light appeared to Jan Aldrich's 209 page book titled
be square, like a window possibly "six feet A Preliminary Report On The 1947
square." They were each bright, but the col- UFO Sighting Wave
lection did not illuminate ground surfaces. published by the UFO Research Coalition.
The string of lights appeared to curve to the Price: $20 plus $2 for postage and handling
rear at each end, suggesting they were on in the U.S.A. and $5 for foreign.
the outside of a circular object "at least 90
feet" in diameter, according to the witness,
but no object surface was seen.
Keying on the estimated size of the ob- MUFON 1997
ject, the investigator first suspected a blimp SYMPOSIUM PROCEEDINGS
and called the LaGrange-Calloway airport, "Fiftieth Anniversary of Ufology"
but they were not aware of anything that
Thirteen papers — 300 pages
could produce such a sighting. Additionally, Price: $25 plus $1.75
neither the owners of a nearby store nor a for postage and handling, in U.S. funds
neighbor to the witness had seen anything
October ORDER FROM:
unusual that evening; they had not had the MUFON, 103 Oldtowne Road
1997
Number 354 opportunity. Seguin, TX 78155-4099
Page 10
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
"About the Stanton T. Friedman, who contacted garding the dates of the recoveries. If I had I
only thing I re- Sarbacher. would send it to you.
member at A review of the contact is best described 2. Regarding verification that persons
by Jerome Clark, editor of the International you list were involved, I can only say this:
this time is
UFO Reporter, in his authoritative book, John von Neuman was definitely involved.
that certain UFOs in the 1980s: The UFO Dr. Vannever Bush was definitely involved,
materials re- Encyclopedia, Volume 1. Clark writes: and I think Dr. Robert Oppenheimer also.
ported to have "When he spoke with him over the My association with the Research and
come from fly- phone, Friedman .learned immediately that Development Board under Doctor Compton
ing saucer Sarbacher had not been, Bray to the con- during the Eisenhower administration was
trary, "deeply involved in UFO research for rather limited so that although I had been
crashes were
the U.S. government." He did confirm the invited to participate in several discussions
extremely essentials of the Smith account but said his associated with the reported recoveries, I
light and very knowledge of the UFO project was based could not personally attend the meetings. I
tough. I am only on what he had heard from other scien- am sure that they would have asked Dr. von
sure our labo- tists who were involved. At one point, he Braun, and the others that you listed were
ratories ana- said, he had been invited to Wright- probably asked and may or may not have at-
Patterson Air Force Base to hear a presenta- tended. This is all I know for sure.
lyzed them
tion by scientists and military men who 3.1 did receive some official reports
very closely." were studying UFO remains, but other when I was in my office at the Pentagon but
pressing business had kept him from attend- all of these were left there as at the time we
ing. Sarbacher said his colleagues had told were never supposed to take them out of the
of wreckage and bodies, but with the pas- office.
sage of years his memory had grown hazy 4.1 do not recall receiving any photo-
about the specifics. He said he did not know graphs such as you request so I am not in a
why the matter had been covered up all position to answer.
these years." 5. I have to make the same reply as on
Friedman met Sarbacher in early 1983, No. 4.
but little more was learned that had not al- I recall the interview with Dr. Brenner of
ready been discussed on the phone. the Canadian Embassy. I think the answers I
Friedman mentioned his conversation with gave him were the ones you listed.
Sarbacher to a colleague of his, UFO writer Naturally, I was more familiar with the sub-
William L. Moore, who later relayed the de- ject matter under discussion, at that time.
tails to UFO enthusiast William S. Actually, I would have been able to give
Steinman. Steinman wrote Sarbacher sev- more specific answers had I attended the
eral letters, and finally received a response meetings concerning the subject. You must
from Sarbacher, dated November 29, 1983. understand that I took this assignment as a
The contents were quite revealing. private contribution. We were called "dol-
Sarbacher writes: lar-a-year men." My first responsibility was
the maintenance of my own business activ-
I am sorry I have taken so long in an- ity so that my participation was limited.
swering your letters. However, I have About the only thing I remember at this
moved my office and have had to make a time is that certain materials reported to
number of extended trips. have come from flying saucer crashes were
To answer your last question in your let- extremely light and very tough. I am sure
ter of October 14, 1983, there is no particu- our laboratories analyzed them very care-
lar reason I feel I shouldn't or couldn't an- fully.
swer any or all of your questions. I am de- There were reports that instruments or
lighted to answer all of them to the best of people operating these machines were also
my ability. of very light weight, sufficient to withstand
You listed some of your questions in your the tremendous deceleration and accelera-
letter of September 12th. I will attempt to tion associated with their machinery. I re-
answer them as you had listed them. member in talking with some of the people
1. Relating to my own expexience re- at the office that I got the impression these
garding recovered flying saucers, I had no "aliens" were constructed like certain in-
October
association with any of the people involved sects we have.observed on earth, wherein
1997
Number 354 in the recovery and have no knowledge re- because of the low mass the inertia! forces
Page 12
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
involved in operation of these instruments there is no corroboration for it. But there are Sarbacher's
would be quite low. problems in the story that go deeper than no job on the R
I still do not know why the high order of confirmation. & D Board
classification has been given and why the According to an article in the September would defi-
denial of the existence of these devices. 1985 issue of Just Cause, editor Barry
I am sorry it has taken me so long to re- Greenwood explained that Sarbacher be- nitely put him
ply but I suggest you get in touch with the came involved with the UFO evidence due in a position
others who may be directly involved in this to his connection with the Research and to have ac-
program. [End quote] Development Board. Greenwood writes: cess to sen-
"Sarbacher's role with the R&DB was as sitive high-
BACKGROUND & ANALYSIS Chairman of the Guidance and Control level informa-
Even skeptics would agree that Dr. Panel of the Guided Missile Committee of
Sarbacher's background is exceptional. In the R&DB." tion, and he
our book, UFOs, MJ-12 & The "The R&DB meetings were not necessar- may have
Government, Canadian UFO researcher ily UFO meetings per se but were part of been privy to
Grant Cameron and I reported on some of their regular schedule and UFOs came up details about
Sarbacher's past accomplishments. among other subjects under discussion. UFO re-
Dr. Sarbacher's credentials are impres- Sarbacher told me that since he did not at- trievals, if
sive: he was a graduate of the University of tend the meetings, he had only heard snip-
Florida (B.S., 1933), Princeton University pets of stories which others more closely in- they existed.
(M.S., 1934), Harvard University (Sc.D., volved in the meetings had heard. This in-
1939). He served as a Harvard instructor in cluded the information in his 11/29/83 letter
physics and communications engineering to Steinman. The crash/retrieval data origi-
(1936-40) and was a professor of electrical nally came from Wright Field, as Sarbacher
engineering at the Illinois Institute of recalls."
Technology (1940-42). Sarbacher was a A contrasting version of the R & D Board
professor at Harvard in 1941, a wartime sci- meetings comes from Fred A. Darwin, who
ence consultant for the U.S. Navy from was the Executive Director of the Guided
1942-45, and dean of the graduate school of Missile Committee for the R & D Board
the Georgia Institute of Technology from from 1949-54. Darwin was a good friend of
1945-49. He was an inventor and helped au- Sarbacher's. He met him while at Harvard
thor such technical works as Hyper and University where he, William Edson and
Ultra-High Frequency Engineering (1944). Sarbacher studied a lot together. In a letter to
In the 1980s he was President of the me in August, 1988, Darwin writes:
Washington Institute of Technology. "I wish that I could give you news more
Sarbacher's job on the R & D Board likely to be welcome: The RDB took a
would definitely put him in a position to rather dim view of UFO's. Not that UFO's
have access to sensitive high-level informa- do not exist; they have existed, probably
tion, and may have been privy to details since the beginning of time. Vehicles from
about UFO retrievals, if they existed. All of outer space are, however, another proposi-
those who contacted Sarbacher, including tion."
William Steinman, author of UFO Crash At The Public Affairs Division of Wright-
Aztec, Jerome Clark, who interviewed Patterson Air Force Base also takes a dim
Sarbacher for an OMNI article, Bruce view of Sarbacher's assertion that the
Maccabee, of the Fund for UFO Research crash/retrieval data originated from their lo-
and Barry Greenwood, for an article in Just cation. In a fact sheet, dated January 1985, it
Cause, a UFO newsletter, were impressed states:
with Sarbacher's seeming sincerity, and his "Periodically, it is erroneously stated that
willingness to answer questions as best he the remains of extraterrestrial visitors are or
could. His story is fairly consistent with have been stored at Wright-Patterson AFB.
these UFO researchers who interviewed There are not now, nor ever have been, any
him, and sounds like the truth as he may extraterrestrial visitors or equipment on
have understood it. Wright-Patterson Air Force Base."
CREDIBILITY QUESTIONS
The story sounds so credible on the sur- October
1997
face, most UFO researchers assume Robert Number 354
Sarbacher's testimony is valid, even though Page 13
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
Strieber said SARBACHER & THE MISSILE knowledge of UFO retrievals and who were
that COMMITTEE "definitely involved" were John von
Sarbacher in- Just how involved was Dr. Sarbacher on Neuman and Vannevar Bush, "and I think
the Missile Committee? First let's examine Dr. Robert Oppenheimer also." Again, I
dicated the
Sarbacher's recollection of those days on questioned Darwin about some of the names
analysis of the the R&D Board. In a telephone interview Sarbacher offered along with a few others,
debris was with Stan Friedman, Sarbacher states: and he responded:
helpful in S: And ah, Fred came to me and asked me "Of the people listed on page 2 of your
making seam- if I would help him on the guidance and letter, I knew pretty well Johnny von
less coatings control. Neuman, Wernher von Braun, Robert
F: I see. Oppenheimer, Vannevar Bush, Detlev
that would
S: For the missiles? Bronk, and Lloyd Berkner. None of those
cover "radar- F: Ya he was chairman for that subcom- was ever convinced that vehicles from outer
proof aircraft mittee. space even existed."
which eventu- S: Ya that's right. One would think that the Director of the
ally evolved F: Or went on to be anyway. Missile Committee would have had some
into the S: That's right and I came down and I knowledge of a UFO retrieval or a meeting
was in that, and worked on it, for a long about crash hardware and aliens at Wright-
Stealth."
time and I guess it was over a year, Patterson AFB if it happened as Sarbacher
maybe a couple of years, I don't know, I claims. Darwin makes no mention in his let-
don't remember. But I know it was dur- ter to me that any such discussions took
ing that time we had an office there that place.
we all went to. You know. Another, source I contacted who knew
F: The Research and Development Board? Sarbacher well, and was in close contact
S: Ya the Research and Development Board. with him from 1935 to 1950, recalled hav-
It was sorta like a little cabinet post. ing no conversations with him about UFO
F: OK so the guys there told you about the research. He described Bob as "brillant" and
UFO's? "charming," but doubted whether some of
S: Ya it was among those fellows in conver- the statements Sarbacher makes are entirely
sation. truthful.
F: Remember any of those guys? Sarbacher told Friedman he had a prob-
S: Not a one. Not a one. Fred would lem remembering the names of those men
know them all. I should think that some- serving on the R&D Board. For the record,
where among his files he would have a the United States Government Organization
list of all the men that worked there. Manual 1951-52 indicates the following list
F: Oh ya. He did. As a matter of fact he had of names serving as the R&D Board mem-
names at his fingertips so to speak. bers during this period: Chairman, William
S: Ya I know, Fred was right in the middle Webster; Deputy Chairman, James A.
of it. Perkins; Army members Archibald S.
Sarbacher stated he worked on the R&D Alexander and Major General Ward S.
Board for a long time, perhaps a year or Maris; Navy members Dan A. Kimball and
two. However, Darwin provided me with a Rear Admiral M. E. Curtis; and Air Force
different perspective of Sarbacher's partici- members John A. McCone and Major
pation on the Missile Committee. Darwin General Gordon P. Seville. Dr. Eric A.
writes: Walker served as Executive Secretary. The
"Bob Sarbacher (originally known as R&D Board was established by the National
Irving) had virtually no connection with the Security Act of 1947, and was set up to ad-
activities of the Research and Development vise the Secretary of Defense on trends of
Board. (More's the pity.) I got Bob ap- scientific research affecting national secu-
pointed to membership on the Guidance and rity, and to promote research and develop-
Control Panel. After a couple of months, the ment among the services involving security-
Chairman requested his replacement; he type scientific problems.
never came to the meetings. Bob had talents
that could have been valuable." STRIEBER S TALE
Earlier versions of Sarbacher's story
October
OTHER SCIENTISTS INVOLVED? were fairly consistent. But in 1986, shortly
1997
Number 354 In Sarbacher's 1983 letter to William before he died, it is alleged his story became
Page 14 Steinman, he writes that those having more elaborate and detailed. According to
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
science fiction writer Whitley Strieber in his sulting in the development of lasers, fiber Sarbacher
1995 book Breakthrough, Sarbacher told optics, integrated circuit chips and super openly admit-
him on the phone the UFO debris had some tenacity fibers by some of the nation's ted he had no
unusual properties. "That fabric we ob- largest companies. The companies have
firsthand
tained at Roswell had molecular welds so publicly admitted on nationwide television
small you couldn't even identify what they they have no knowledge of this, but Corso knowledge of
were until the sixties, when the microscopes says it was meant to be that way. It all the UFO
to do it became available." Strieber said that sounds a little too easy, and until Corso crashes, did
Sarbacher indicated the analysis of the de- coughs up supporting documents and de- not attend the
bris was helpful in making seamless coat- tailed notes supporting his claims, these al- R & D Board
ings that would cover "radar-proof aircraft, legations cannot be taken seriously.
meetings
which eventually evolved into the Stealth."
Strieber said he asked Sarbacher if he had CONCLUSIONS where they
seen the material and he reportedly replied All the allegations Sarbacher reported may have
that he had not only seen it, but examined could still be true, but there are inconsisten- been dis-
and studied it. Asked if the material was of cies as well as Darwin's remarks that cast a cussed ... and
a non-human origin, Strieber said he an- shadow of doubt over Sarbacher's testi- didn't show up
swered, "What I can be certain about is that mony. I discussed some of these discrepan-
at too many
it was not produced by any technology that cies with an associate, Grant Cameron, who
we were aware of in 1947. Or now." suggested that Darwin could have been left Missile Com-
In all fairness, Sarbacher was getting up out of the loop, and that Sarbacher was mittee meet-
in age, and perhaps his memory was not asked to attend UFO meetings because of ings either.
what it used to be. Strieber's account is also his technical expertise. The alleged group
suspect, because it seems to contradict one asked to attend meetings at Wright-
of his earlier books, Communion, where he Patterson AFB may have been on a need to
indicates he only learned of Steinman's let- know basis, and Darwin didn't need to
ter after Sarbacher's death, and "...was un- know. When researcher Bruce Maccabee in-
able to interview him ..." I wrote to Strieber terviewed Sarbacher on August 5, 1985,
on April 13, 1997, for clarification, and in Sarbacher explained it "... as something I
mid-May he sent me a two-page form letter should have done but didn't do. I had had a
explaining, "I wish that I could reply to request to visit a site...(either the site was
each of you individually, but the volume of Wright Field or the request came from
mail prevents me from doing this." there)... regarding a fallen... UFO and at
that time could not go...tied up with per-
CORSO'S TALE sonal business." He went on to tell
Support for Sarbacher's claims have re- Maccabee that, "Some of the men went. I
cently been reported in the 1997 book, The went to the office some time after they got
Day After Roswell, by Col. Philip J. Corso back and talked to some of the guys who
(ret.). Corso, who served as the Chief of the saw it. I wish I could have gone."
Army's Foreign Technology Division in Looking at this situation another way,
1961, says Sarbacher was a valuable player, one could say Sarbacher simply overheard
was in close touch with the U.S. Govern- some of the guys talking around the water
ment's UFO working group, and was instru- cooler about alleged UFO crashes and bod-
mental in helping General Nathan F. ies that were discussed at the meeting,
Twining decide to move the Roswell crash mayjje even the situation at Roswell came
saucer debris to Wright-Field for a prelimi- up, and Sarbacher began to fill in the
nary examination. blanks. Sarbacher openly admitted he had
Although this all sounds very interesting, no first-hand knowledge of the UFO
there was no evidence that I could see to crashes, did not attend the R&D meetings
support these points. Corso could very well where they may have been discussed, and
say Sarbacher was involved based on according to Darwin, didn't show up at too
Sarbacher's own remarks regarding his in- many Missile Committee meetings either. It
volvement, and created a story using seems very odd that Sarbacher would pass
Sarbacher based on previous research al- up an opportunity to attend an event this ex-
ready found in the literature. traordinary because of personal business.
October
Corso also reported in his book that alien Dr. Sarbacher did identify to researcher 1997
artifacts that have been recovered have been William Steinman a member of the R&D Number 354
reverse engineered by earthly scientists, re- Board who he said attended all the UFO Page 15
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
Reading of meetings. His name is Dr. Eric A. Walker, appearing in the July 29, 1986 issue of The
Kent Jeffrey's who served as Executive Secretary of the Palm Beach Post.
conversion is R&D Board between 1950-51, and later be- There was no boating accident. Sarbacher
came President of the Pennsylvania State was 79 years old.
reminiscent of
University. Cameron and I investigated Sarbacher leaves behind an extraordinary
Robert Mac- Walker for several years, but we could file of possible government involvement
Namara's mea never get Walker to admit to us that he par- and cover-up of a retrieved UFO and its pi-
culpa after he ticipated in UFO retrieval discussions while lots. But lacking corraborating evidence to
sent 58,000 at the R&D Board. However, Steinman support these claims, it remains one of
Americans to claims he had a telephone interview with many reports that remains unverified.
Walker in which he admitted attending UFO
their deaths in
meetings at Wright-Patterson AFB and was
VietNam, only familiar with a group known as "MJ-12," an
to state last alleged group of military and government Letters to Mufon UFO Journal
year that he officials brought together under President
had made a Truman to oversee UFO recovery opera- DISGRUNTLED
mistake! tions. Since that interview with Steinman on
August 30, 1987, in all follow-up interviews
with us and others, Walker has proved elu-
S peaking as a MUFON Consultant and
a Psychotherapist-Hypnotherapist with
many years of research and work with ab-
sive in answering direct questions about ductees, 1 do not believe that my Journal
UFO retrievals. Walker died on February should be used to debunk the UFO phenom-
17, 1995. enon generally nor the Roswell crash specif-
ically. I was astounded and irate that the edi-
RUMORS TO THE END tor would give Kent Jeffrey fifteen pages out
Dr. Sarbacher died on July 26, 1986, in of a total of eighteen pages to expound his
West Palm Beach, Florida. Hints of a con- negative views about the Roswell incident.
spiracy concerning Dr. Sarbacher's death Whether he has been co-opted or he has sim-
appeared on the internet. One notebook file ply had a change of heart is not relevant.
SX112 dated September 21, 1996 re- This is not the first time you have given over
ported..."Why did Dr. Sarbacher 'drown in my journal to debunkers, but if it is not the
a boating accident' only TWO DAYS after last, you no longer represent my thinking
his third interview in 1983 or so in which he and have no further need of my membership
really began naming more names and talk- dues or my services.
ing more?" Reading of Kent Jeffrey's conversion is
The source of that comment originated reminiscent of Robert MacNamara's mea
with writer Whitley Strieber. In his book, culpa after he sent 58,000 Americans to their
Breakthrough, Strieber indicated after hav- deaths in VietNam, only to state last year
ing a telephone conversation with Sarbacher that he had made a mistake!
in 1986, he forwarded a letter to him via Moreover, Jeffrey's apologia is replete
United Parcel Service outlining some expe- with contradictions. To begin with, he uses
riences he had had. Strieber writes, "I didn't the film Roswell as an example of exagger-
hear anything for a while, then received a ated statements. No one familiar with the
telephone call from UPS. They could not Roswell affair believed the film was any-
deliver because the recipient was deceased. thing other than a popularized and fictional-
The UPS driver had been told that he had ized version of events. Jeffrey is disingenu-
fallen off his boat and drowned." An Alexa ous when he cites the film as a factual expli-
Cameron questioned Strieber by E-Mail cation of events in New Mexico in 1947, and
about the admission, and he replied on then proceeds to point out its exaggerations
September 22, 1996. Strieber repeated the and shortcomings.
UPS story he said he was told, and wrote, "I When he writes of the discredited MU-
never researched this any further. The fact is FON Board Member and author, once again
that he died at a very inopportune time for he sets up a straw man in order to destroy
me, and that was where my interest in the him.
matter ended." He embarks on pseudo-philosophical
If Strieber had followed up, he would musings concerning the relationship of ad-
October
1997
have discovered that Sarbacher died of heart vanced technology to reliability, using mod-
Number 354 failure according to the newspaper account ern airliners as his medium. Modern airliners
Page 16 are wondrous examples of 1990s state of the
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
art aircraft technology, but they do crash on supposed crashed-saucer incident until years And of course
occasion with terrible loss of life. Many later, after all the publicity started." Are we Jeffrey's
such crashes are due to pilot error, others to to believe that these "elite" intelligent offi- Walter
weather conditions such as icing, lightning, cers had their heads in the sand and were not
Klimkowski is
and wind shear. Is it too much to expect that aware of the Roswell news release, the
even the most advanced space-craft may queries from all over the world, the fuss in unimpeach-
similarly be subject to these same vagaries Roswell, and learned about a possible saucer able as a wit-
of wind shear, lightning and pilot error? crash only years later? Absurd! Jeffrey ac- ness. After all,
Jeffrey sarcastically refutes the notion that knowledges that "the word was already out - he comes
there are secret hangars at Wright-Patterson, the story had been published in afternoon highly recom-
and throughout his article asks us to use our newspapers all over the Western United
mended. He
common sense and be logical. I believe I am States!"
being logical when I ask Mr. Jeffrey to con- It is interesting how Jeffrey treats the tes- played the pi-
sider the response of Air Force General timony and recollections of the witnesses he ano for strip-
Curtis LeMay to Senator Barry Goldwater chooses to mention. When the pilots and per Gypsy
when he asked LeMay if he could have ac- bombardiers he interviews profess to know Rose Lee!
cess to these secret hangars where alien bod- nothing about a UFO crash, he accepts their
ies and space-craft were reported to be statements without question. However, he
housed: LeMay is alleged to have retorted casually dismisses out of hand the testimony
"Hell no, and don't ask again." A strange re- of other witnesses whose testimony would
sponse to make to a United States Senator, apparently refute Jeffrey's theory.
Air Force General and Presidential candi- "...Because the debris recovered outside of
date, particularly if there were no alien bod- Roswell in 1947 was not extraterrestrial,"
ies or artifacts hidden. Wouldn't a more logi- Jeffrey states, "none of the other witness tes-
cal response have been, "there is nothing to timony really matters." In one fell swoop,
see, Barry. The whole thing is a myth. We Jeffrey simply declares the testimony of
have no alien bodies or space-craft?" dozens, perhaps hundreds of witnesses, to be
Concerning the 509th Bomb Group, unimportant. Jeffrey similarly dismisses the
Jeffrey states that a "very elite group of indi- testimony of Henderson's family. Their
viduals" comprised the 509th, yet he obvi- memories are faulty and they got it mixed
ously believes that the Intelligence Officer up, he says, with something they read. Sure,
for that elite outfit, the only atomic bomb Mr. Jeffrey, but the testimony of
wing in the entire world, could not tell the Henderson's friend Jesse Mitchell is "incon-
difference between a weather balloon and trovertible." He no doubt remembers every-
what he believed to be extraterrestrial debris. thing very clearly and correctly, Jeffrey asks
Abandoning his own logical stance, Jeffrey us to believe. It's only the memories of those
rather illogically asks us to believe that a ju- who recall seeing alien bodies that have
nior level weather officer easily identified eroded over time. And of course Walter
the debris that Colonel Blanchard, Lt. Haul Klimkowski is unimpeachable as a witness.
and Major Marcel, who all saw and handled After all, he comes highly recommended. He
the wreckage, obviously could not identify. played the piano for stripper Gypsy Rose
Would they have issued the flying saucer Lee!
news release had they recognized the debris? Jeffrey concludes his incredible recanta-
Obviously not. tion by stating "...we don't yet have tangible
Mr. Jeffrey places great importance on the evidence that alien spacecraft exist..."
fact that Jack Ingham had no knowledge of Mr. Jeffrey is quite free of course to as-
anything unusual occurring at Roswell in sess the evidence and to arrive at any judg-
1947. He tells us that Ingham retired as a Lt. ment he wishes concerning the existence of
Colonel in 1971.1 mean no disrespect to UFOs. He is certainly free to change his
Col. Ingham when I state that Lt. Colonel is mind about an alien spacecraft crash at
not a very exalted rank to attain after at least Roswell. What he does not have is the right
25 years in the service. In 1946, he very to a fifteen page essay in the journal of an
probably was a 2nd Lieutenant. Is it logical organization devoted to demonstrating that
for us to believe that a mere second lieu- UFOs and aliens are real. MUFON is not a
tenant should have been privy to top level debating society which presents both sides
secrets in 1946? I think not. Jeffrey also asks of the question of UFOs and aliens. MU- October
1997
us to believe that the pilots and bombardiers FON is an advocacy organization whose ac- Number 354
he interviewed "heard nothing about the tivities are supported primarily by the dues Page 17
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
Interestingly of people who believe aliens have visited ROSWELL & REALITY
enough, I and are visiting earth, that citizens of the
know for a earth are being abducted, and that the gov- My name is Chris Brethwaite and I'm a
ernments of the world, particularly our own, MUFON member here in Kansas City,
fact that we
are not telling the truth to their citizens. By Missouri. I'm writing to commend you on
have been vis- devoting any space whatsoever to Jeffrey, let the job you've done as editor of MUFON's
ited by ex- alone just about the entire issue, you have "UFO Journal." As a professional writer
traterrestrials. placed our organization in the position of and adjunct college professor, I appreciate
And ironically, having pulled the rug out from under the your efforts at trying to inject some level of
it happened in countless abductees who, rebuffed at so scholarship into the UFO debate.
many turns, found solace in knowing one Judging by some of the things I read in
New Mexico
important organization supported them. I , the August issue of the Journal, it appears
exactly twenty want to see articles in our journal which sup- that the UFO faithful are somewhat dis-
years after port those abductees. Do Phil Klass and oth- pleased with you because of your refusal to
•Roswell. ers of his ilk at CSICOP provide a platform go along with every new claim and unsub-
for MUFON members? Why should we pro- stantiated story that comes down the ex-
vide space for those who oppose our beliefs? traterrestrial highway. I know that your edi-
Don't the editors and leaders of our organi- torship is on shaky ground, but I implore
zation understand the joy Mr. Jeffrey's arti- you not to give in to those who would have
cle provided our critics, and the consterna- the Journal become a printed version of
tion he caused our allies? "The Art Bell Show." Though there may be
What is at stake here is not some theoreti- some ways to improve the Journal, such as
cal issue of freedom of the press. Mr. Jeffrey by publishing a list each month of places
is entitled to his opinions, but he is not enti- currently experiencing UFO activity, the
tled to have them printed in our Journal. By bottom line is that we need a publication
publishing this article, the officers of MU- that addresses the subject in a serious man-
FON have called into question their judg- ner, and which isn't afraid to police its own
ment and their commitment. By their ac- by pointing out dubious claims, shoddy re-
tions, they have also called into question search and selective reporting.
their fitness to continue to serve as the lead- I was also displeased to learn that you re-
ers of the Mutual U.F.O. Network. They ceived a lot of criticism for printing Kent
have driven a stake into the heart of our or- Jeffrey's Roswell article in the June issue. I
ganization. The implications for their ill- thought his piece was well reasoned, well
conceived actions are so terrible and serious researched and well written. Though I'm
I tremble for the continued vitality of our or- still at a loss to explain how an Air Force
ganization in the months ahead. Major, who was an intelligence officer,
Resignations are in order for all those in- could have mistaken balloon debris for an
volved in this meretricious exercise. The alien spacecraft, I am nonetheless forced to
Editors also owe an apology to all MUFON agree with Kent that maybe that's exactly
members and particularly to the countless what happened. I first started thinking that
number of abductees who by the thoughtless Roswell might be a myth when I visited
actions of Jeffrey and those Editors now find Walter Haul's UFO museum and noticed the
themselves adrift without the support of the similarity between Jessie Marcel Jr.'s I-
one international organization which hereto- beam and Project Mogul debris. Many of
fore provided them with the support they the concerns that Kent raised in his article
need so badly. are things that I have wondered about over
— Dr. Walter T. Schoen, Ph.D. the years also. For example, why wasn't
there a greater variety of debris? Questions
Editor's Note: Dr. Schoen is speaking for like these need to be addressed. It's just un- ^
himself, just like Kent Jeffrey has done. fortunate that so many MUFON members
However, the statements made in the last two are so desperate to believe in aliens that any
paragraphs, where he condemns the editors negative information is viewed as heresy.
and officers of the Mutual UFO Network are Interestingly enough, I know for a fact
entirely unwarranted. The MUFON Board of that we have been visited by extraterrestri-
Directors determines the policies of MU- als. And ironically, it happened in New
October
1997
FON, not Dr. Schoen. Mexico exactly twenty years after Roswell.
Number 354 — Walt Andrus This is the Reader's Digest version of my
Page 18
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
close encounter. I was twelve years-old at name who endeavor to promote ufology in There is no
the time, living with my family in the an intellectually honest manner. need to fear
Sandia Foothills on the northeast side of Well, that's all I wanted to say. I hope ideas that dis-
Albuquerque. One night during the summer you get to stay on as editor of the Journal. agree with our
of 1967,1 went to go next door to return a You have done a great job, and you can
own provided
basketball to my best friend, Scott Everett, count on me for my support.
and noticed an unusual light in the sky —Chris Brethwaite that a mecha-
southwest of my house. Together, Scott and Kansas City, MO nism is in
I watched this light travel north, turn to the place to en-
northeast, perform a series of zigzag moves Actually, Walter Haut recently resigned sure fair com-
and then disappear over Sandia Peak. The from the International UFO Museum ment. A jour-
object returned the next two nights. On the and Research Center in Roswell. Glenn
nal of, by, and
third night, the object stopped dead in the Dennis is the current president of
air after performing the zigzag moves. same. for "believers"
Shortly thereafter, Scott walked over to me will remain
and said, "Chris, I just saw an orange man CIVILIZED DISCOURSE just that and,
on the school roof." A reference to the at best, will be
Hoover Elementary School that was directly The sorry state of ufology never ceases to a poor imita-
across the street from us, probably about a depress me. As someone who has devoted
tion of a sci-
hunderd feet away. I walked over to the most of his adult life to trying to bring san-
curb and had Scott show me exactly where ity and science to bear on UFOs, I am ap- entific journal.
he had seen this "man." All I could see was palled by the notion that you should be
the black of night, and I was just getting drawn and quartered for publishing seeming
ready to turn away, when all of a sudden, a "anti-UFO" articles (or should we say
seven-foot tall, luminous orange man ap- 'questioning ufological orthodoxy'). Since
peared right where I was looking. Less than we have an excess of sloppy investigation
two seconds later he was gone, but I have and wild speculation that is making a mock-
absolutely no doubt as to what I saw. ery of science, you are entirely correct to
As for his appearance, I was quite sur- publish thoughtful skeptical pieces like that
prised at how human he looked. He had two of Kent Jeffrey.
arms, two legs, a torso, and a slightly elon- The only genuine editorial issues are the
gated head. He stood very erect and looked overall balance of material presented, and
to be quite muscular. Because of the glow the credibility and credentials of contribu-
and a black speckling that also covered him, tors. But editorial decisions are not easy; for
I was not able to make out any facial fea- example, both James Moseley and Karl
tures. Shortly after he disappeared, the UFO Pflock have certain legitimate credentials,
resumed its flight and was not seen again. but—in my estimation—seriously lack
The only thing I have to add is that one of credibility. Track records of game-playing
the members of our group saw an orange and manipulation are not conducive to cred-
light come on [on] the UFO during the time ibility. Still, if you—as editor—choose to
period that Scott and I saw the alien. publish some of their writings, that is your
Needless to say, it was an experience that prerogative, subject to peer review and cri-
changed my life. I think one of the ways tique.
that it benefitted me is that I know for a fact There is no need to fear ideas that dis-
that we have been visited by a being not of agree with our own provided that a mecha-
this world. Consequently, I could care less if nism is in place to ensure fair comment. A
a sacred UFO case gets debunked. If other journal of, by, and for "believers" will re-
sightings are misidentifications or hoaxes main just that and, at best, will be a poor
(Ed Walters), I want to know about it. It re- imitation of a scientific journal. In that con-
ally bothers me to see ufology become so text, I agree wholeheartedly with Jerome
uncritical in its thinking. Most of the UFO Clark's letter (Journal, August 1997) that
literature that's available on the book tables whether or not we agree with Jeffrey, he has
at UFO conferences belongs in a landfill, set a good example of civilized discourse
yet people snatch the stuff up left and right. that is all too lacking in the UFO field.
It's very disheartening. What we need are My personal view is that Jeffrey is quite
October
more people like you, and Jerome Clark and sincere and made some cogent arguments, 1997
George Wingfield and a few others I could but he lacks the experience and detachment Number 354
to recognize the flaws—or omissions—in Page 19
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
The Stars:
The NIGH SKY
. - • , - . . . ' - . • - - « . - -- '....-jj-» At 9 PM the Summer Triangle nears the W horizon, while the
Walter N.Webb ° "0 ° bright patterns of winter appear in the E—Orion, Taurus,
Auriga, and Gemini. The dim autumn constellations of "The
November 1997 Sea" and the season's sky symbol Pegasus occupy the middle
sky. Be sure to observe the Andromeda spiral galaxy with
Bright Planets (Evening Sky): naked eye, binoculars, or telescope. This system of billions of
From about mid-November through early December, it is stars, visible to the unaided eye as an oval patch, lies right on
possible to view all five naked-eye planets at the same time the N-S meridian almost directly overhead at 9 PM in mid-
during evening twilight. Mercury will be the hardest to see November.
from northern latitudes. (Both it and Venus are higher from
the southern states.) The parade of planets can be seen at
dusk as follows, from W to E: Mercury (magnitude -0.4), low
in the WSW (early twilight): Mars (1.1), Sagittarius, SW;
Venus (-4.5), Sagittarius, SW; Jupiter (-2.3), Capricornus,
S; Saturn (0.5-), Pisces, ESE.
Both Venus and Mars set around 7 PM. The two planets and
the lunar crescent form a nice triangle on November 3. On the October 11 & 12 — 'The UFO Experience" at Holiday Inn in North
7th, Jupiter lies near the quarter Moon, while on the 11th Haven. Connecticut. Contact Omega Communications, P.O. Box
Saturn is near the gibbous Moon. In fact, on the latter date 2051, Cheshire, CT 06410.
states in the Southeast will see the Moon hide the ringed October 17-19 — Australian International UFO Symposium 1997 at
planet for up to an hour starting at 6:25 PM (Miami) or 6:52 Carlton Crest Hotel, Brisbane, Australia. For further information
write to Glennys Mackay, P.O. Box 2183, Mansfield MC, Brisbane,
(Atlanta), for example. Jupiter sets in the W about 10 PM in QLD 4122, Australia.
midmonth.
October 18 — Second Annual Corpus Christi MUFON Mini-
In addition to seeing all the bright planets at once, Uranus and Conference, Skywatch and Camp Out on the Reeves Ranch, start-
Neptune may be visible in binoculars or a telescope as well. ing at 1:00 p.m., between Goliad and Victoria, Texas on U.S.
The former is a 6th-magnitude object in Capricornus; the Highway 59. For information contact Doris Upchurch (512) 937-
2381 or Sue Taylor (512) 785-4010.
latter, an 8th-magnitude object in Sagittarius. (For finder
charts or coordinates, consult such publications as Observer's October 24 & 25 — Australian International UFO Symposium 1997
at Carlton Crest Hotel in Melbourne, Australia. For further informa-
Handbook 1997, The Astronomical Almanac 1997. or Sky & tion write to MUFON (QLD), P. O. Box 2183 Mansfield, Brisbane
Telescope magazine.) 4122 Australia.
October 31 - November 2 — 4th Annual Tampa UFO Conference.
Camberly Plaza Hotel, Tampa, Florida. For information write Project
Bright Planets (Morning Sky): Awareness, P.O. Box 730, Gulf Breeze, FL 32562 or call (904) 432-
Saturn sets in the W about 3 AM in mid-November. 8888.
November 2 — First Annual Long Island UFO Conference at
Levittown Hall, Levittown Parkway, Hicksville, New York. For infor-
Meteor Showers: mation contact Joanne Steele (516) 386-1493 or Janet Russell
The South Taurid meteors peak during the first week of (516)654-3353.
November at about 10-15 per hour before dawn. Though few November 15 — Second Annual UFO/Alien Abduction Seminar
in number, the reddish meteors of the Taurids do create some featuring John Carpenter at the Holiday Inn Convention Center, Eau
Claire, Wisconsin. For tickets and/or information call (715) 833-
bright fireballs. 4639.
The "Leonid watch" continues as we head toward a possibly November 22 & 23 — 5th Symposium on Ufology and Exobiology.
spectacular meteor display in 1998 or 1999. Last November Sindipetro, Santos, SP Brasil. For further information call 55 (043)
observers reported an exceptional number of Leonid fire- 336.3719 or 55 (011) 5513.7107.
balls and an above-average per-hour rate. Though this year's December 4-7 — Second World UFO Congress Acapulco 1997 in
bright gibbous Moon severely hampers viewing, it still may be Acapulco, Mexico. For information contact Pasquale Lopresti, Fax
worth watching the sky during the predawn hours of the 17th (525) 589-33-43.
for an increase in bright meteors which will emanate from the December 7-14 — First World UFO Forum, Brasilia, D.F. Brazil at
constellation Leo in the southern sky. Some predictions favor Parlamundi Convention Center. Sponsor is Legiao da Boa Vontade
(LBV) and Coalition of Leading Brazilian UFO researchers. For
western North America and/or the Pacific for the best chance information write to Caixa Postal 2182, 79008-970 Campo Grande
of seeing a decent show. (MS) Brazil.
February 1-7,1998 — The 7th Annual International UFO Congress
Moon Phases: Convention and Film Festival. To be held at the Gold River Resort
First quarter—November 7 c in Laughlin, Nevada. For information contact the UFO Congress,
9975 Wadsworth Pkwy. #K2-274, Westminster, CO 80020.
Phone/Fax (303) 543-9443.
Full moon-November 14 O June 26, 27 & 28,1998 — MUFON 1998 International UFO
Symposium, Renaissance Denver Hotel, Denver, Colorado.
Last quarter—November 21 July 3-5 — Roswell Days, Roswell, New Mexico. For information
contact International UFO Museum & Research Center, P.O. Box
New moon-November 29 2221, Roswell, NM 88202 or call (505) 625-9495.
October 1997 Number 354 Page 22
MUFON UFO JOURNAL
DIRECTOR'S MESSAGE - Continued from Page 24 possible for them to possess every answer to the test.
Obviously, we would not like for them to share their an-
We have found it necessary to revise our mission swers with colleagues, therefore we have been reluctant
statement three times since founding MUFON in 1969 to do so. Since a large number of the questions are mul-
in order to reflect our goals and objectives without al- tiple choice, Mrs. Marden would be willing to advise
lowing theories and philosophic trends to influence our the examinee which of these questions that was incor-
thrust in resolving the phenomenon. Our new mission is rectly answered by question number only, upon written
not only a challenge in broad terms, but an unlimited request.
vision for the future. We are indebted to MUFON's A study is being conducted, based upon questions
Treasurer and Bexar County State Section Director, consistently answered incorrectly, to revise the exam.
Thomas M. Whitmore for proposing this mission Some of the true-false questions need rewording or
statement. eliminated as an example. A few questions are a mea-
sure of the overall knowledge of ufology of the exami-
MOTTO CONTEST nee, based upon reading the literature. These answers
Nearly nine hundred mottos were submitted in the con- are obviously not in the MUFON Field Investigator's
test, a record surpassing all previous programs of this Manual. For current members, the new manual may be
nature. In their original form, the judges could not find purchased for $25.00 plus $3.50 for postage and han-
one that literally "rang the bell," that is, catchy, unique, dling from MUFON in Seguin.
eye appealing and exemplified MUFON's goals and Congratulations to the people who have recently
objectives. As previously announced, the judges will be taken the Field Investigator's Exam and received a
sorting through the entries looking for one or more that passing grade. Kathleen Marden now grades the exams
is compatible to our new mission statement. Even and forwards the name and score to MUFON
though this may require making slight wording revi- Headquarters, where Ann Knovvles records the grade
sions in the motto originally submitted, one or more on your membership application, revises the applica-
contestants will be awarded or share $100 in MUFON tion, and mails the new Field Investigator their new I.D.
publications of their choice. card.
As a further incentive to the Field Investigator
MUFON LAPEL PINS Trainee to successfully pass the examination, some
The one-inch long oval-shaped lapel pin has the State Directors are making this a condition before a per-
MUFON logo in blue on a white background outlined son is promoted to State Section Director. This is a pos-
in gold with a pin clasp on the back suitable for fasten- itive means of upgrading the caliber of the MUFON
ing to clothing. You may order yours from MUFON in field organization. Obviously, anyone teaching a Field
Seguin, TX for $5 plus $1 for P&H. This is an opportu- Investigator's Training Class must be a qualified Field
nity to let people know that you are a MUFON member Investigator.
by proudly wearing our new lapel pin. The lapel pins
are being mailed in a special bubblepack envelope to
protect them from damage. MUFON COMMUNICATION
NUMBERS
FIELD INVESTIGATOR'S EXAM
Anyone who has purchased and studied the 4th edi- MUFON Headquarters: Seguin, TX
tion of the MUFON Field Investigator's Manual is eli- Telephone: (830)379-9216
gible to take the exam via mail when they feel quali- Fax: (830)372-9439
fied. The 100-question test may be secured from MU-
FON headquarters in Seguin and returned to Kathleen MUFON UFO HOT LINE 1-800-UFO-2166
F. Marden, 103 Willow Road, East Kingston, NH THE INTERNET - mufon.com
03827, for grading. In localities where field investigator
training classes are conducted, the instructor may order MUFON e-mail address -- mufonhq@aol.com
sufficient quantities of the test and administer the exam
at the conclusion of the training classes. However, the MUFONET-BBS (901)327-1008
majority of people will study the manual, like a corre-
spondence course, before taking the exam. It is an open MUFON On CompuServe - "Go MUFON"
book test and other references may be utilized to to access the Forum
broaden the scope of your knowledge.
A passing grade is 75%. A few individuals have re- MUFON Amateur Radio Net
quested that they want to know which questions they 40 meters - 7.237 MHz - Saturday, 8 a.m.
missed. To supply the correct answers would make it Eastern Time
aiRECTOR'S MESSAG'
O o
Walter Andrus
NEWS FROM AROUND THE NETWORK several small town newspapers after leaving Quincy, IL
in the late I970's. Mr. Connelly is eminently qualified
JOURNAL EDITOR RESIGNS for this important position based upon his prior journal-
A Membership Journal Survey was enclosed within istic and publishing experience.
the September 1997 issue of the MUFON UFO Journal The MUFON Executive Committee has recom-
to solicit each readers opinion on how we can improve mended that Walter H. Andrus, Jr. become the Editor
the Journal to meet the members/subscribers desires. If in Chief as well as publisher of the MUFON UFO
you have not returned your pink survey form, please do Journal.
so immediately, because we want to know what evolu-
tionary changes should be incorporated into your maga- NEW DIRECTORS
zine. Cesar Remus, State Director for Puerto Rico, has
An evaluation of the editor was point number two on selected Mrs. Luz B. Guzman de Pla (San Juan) to be
the survey. On August 28, 1997, Dennis Stacy offi- the Assistant State Director. James E. Delehanty
cially resigned as Editor of the MUFON UFO Journal (Jeffersonville) was appointed Assistant State Director
effective after the November 1997 issue. Starting with for Indiana by Jerry L. Sievers. Four new State
the October 1984 issue, Mr. Stacy has performed meri- Section Directors were appointed this month. They are
torious service to the Mutual UFO Network as editor of Leslie G. Salvato, B.A. (Silverdale, WA) for Kitsap
our monthly magazine for over thirteen years, longer County; James G. Bouck, Jr. (Schenectady, NY) for
than any previous editor. He must be highly com- the additional Counties of Albany, Schenectady,
mended for being responsible for the overall improve- Saratoga and Rensselaer; William M. Dungan, Jr.
ment of our magazine during this period. As a freelance (Crystal Springs, MS) for Copiah, Simpson and
writer, photojournalism and publisher, this will give Lawrence Counties: and Connie Churchill (Three
Dennis an opportunity to explore other exciting fields Rivers, TX) for Live Oak County. Gayle Treadwell,
besides UFOs. B.S. (Beeville, TX) was reassigned to Bee County. Mrs.
Mr. Stacy was originally elected to the MUFON Treadwell joined MUFON in 1983.
Board of Directors as Director of Publications in 1980
and coedited the Annual MUFON Symposium NEW CONSULTANTS AND RESEARCH
Proceedings from 1980 through 1984. Walt Andrus is SPECIALISTS
proud to have introduced Dennis to Japanese magazine The following new Consultants volunteered their ex-
publishers prior to this time, giving him his first oppor- pertise this past month: Charles Albano, Ed.D. (Point
tunity to write professionally in the UFO field. The Pleasant, NJ) in Education; William H. Hardy, Jr. J.D.
MUFON 1993 International UFO Symposium (Ada, MI) in Law; and Thomas E. Simpson, Ph.D.
Proceedings were respectfully dedicated to Dennis (Dublin, OH) in Industrial Design. A new Research
Stacy in recognition of his editorial services to MU- Specialist is Philip A. Bayly, M.S. (Largo, FL) in
FON. We all extend our best wishes to Dennis in his Education.
new endeavors.
MUFON MISSION STATEMENT
NEW JOURNAL EDITOR SELECTED At the MUFON Board of Director's Meeting in
Effective with the December 1997 issue, Dwight Grand Rapids, Michigan, each Director was requested
Connelly will take over the reins as Editor of the MU- to submit a MUFON Mission Statement to identify our
FON UFO Journal for a second time. Mr. Connelly goals and objectives. Some very good statements were
edited our monthly magazine from February 1974 submitted, however, most were more detailed in scope
through May 1976 when it was known as SKYLOOK, and some were very specific providing insufficient lati-
succeeding the founder in 1967. Mrs. Norma E. Short. tude for the future. At the Executive Committee
Dwight's wife, Carolyn, formerly the business man- Meeting in Seguin on September 13th, the five officers
ager of SKYLOOK is anxiously anticipating a role in selected a brief statement that summarizes MUFON's
the future of the Journal. mission for the future without being confining in this
Dwight previously taught Journalism at Quincy very controversial field of study. As one might say, "it
Senior High School in Quincy, Illinois and is now is short and sweet." MUFON's Mission is the system-
teaching in the school system in Marshall, IL. He is atic collection and analysis of UFO data with the ul-
also a part owner of the newspaper Shoreline Reporter timate goal of learning the origin and nature of the
in Treasure Island. Florida and has owned and operated UFO phenomena.
October 1997 Number 354 Page 24 Continued on Page 23