Platinum Overdraft (POD) 15 months following implementation 1.
the client achieved: Signicantly improved revenue Control of principal charge-offs to within 1% of revenue Consistent application of payment rules to all accounts Improved overdraft decision process Greater operational efciency with a centralized decision and communication process Deposit Score 2. (DS) upgrade nine months following implementation the client achieved: 18% improvement in Paid Items per Account 29% improvement of Waived Fees Consistently managed risk at the account level The Washington Trust Company Background Like many community banks, The Washington Trust Company (WTC) was looking for new ways to increase its fee income and provide improved customer service. WTC was initially hesitant to change its systems due to the regulatory landscape and the negative public perception of poorly run overdraft programs. Prior to the banks implementation of SMS Platinum Overdraft solution (POD), multiple WTC departments managed customers overdraft items, the process was subjective and inconsistent across its multiple branches. The challenges that WTC faced are common among the many banks that offer an overdraft service on a large scale: compliance, charge-offs, management of communication, customer service, and public policy, all of which must be done at the highest levels of efciency, professionalism, and customer satisfaction. Due Diligence Washington Trust was looking for the right solution to appropriately manage risk, comply with regulations, provide excellent customer service, and enable the bank to efciently manage public policy. WTC chose the Platinum Overdraft solution from Sheshunoff Management Services due to several key criteria that separate Platinum Overdraft from other vendors. CASE STUDY Financial Institution The Washington Trust Company Westerly, RI www.washtrust.com Asset Size: $2.4 billion Implemented Solutions Platinum Overdraft (March 2003) Deposit Score (November 2005) Client Objectives Enhance customer service Increase revenue Consistent service to all account holders Improve Risk Management and Compliance Core Vendor Open Solutions Inc. Our greatest concern was risk management and compliance with regulations. We feel strongly that SMS understands risk and that the SMS program has been designed to comply with the regulations more than any other program that we evaluated. Michael Rauh Jr. Senior Vice President The Washington Trust Company At A Glance A No marketing approach; SMS recommended WTC not mass market the program. SMSs best practices and the fact that the Ofce of Trust Services (OTS) recommends SMS best practices in their ofcial guidance. PODs ability to communicate the right message at the right time to the right customer. The ability to manage risk on each individual account and react accordingly. Robust reporting that allows WTC to manage the program from the perspectives of compliance, public policy, and line of business. A Perfect Fit WTC discovered that the benets offered by the POD program went beyond the banks initial expectations. The ultimate driver in implementing a program was revenue, says Rauh. But we did not envision a program so robust and easy to use. With the POD solution, the bank was now able to automatically pay items up to a determined overdraft tolerance and centrally generate all communications to account holders that used the service. Branch Managers were only responsible for the decision to pay or return items above the overdraft threshold and no longer responsible for monitoring these overdrawn accounts, resulting in greater staff efciency. Implementing the program improved risk management, and WTC found that the return on the investment for this solution paid off. Customer satisfaction increased, thanks to the consistency in payment of items when presented against insufcient funds, and branch employees were freed to serve other customers needs. The service addressed the immediate needs of the bank, and after experiencing the value of the centralized POD process rst hand, both nancially and operationally, it sought to expand the service. WTC implemented SMS POD program in 2003, and since that time the program has enabled the bank to better serve its customers, manage risk, increase revenue, and streamline the process. Initially the bank only offered the service to personal checking account customers. But due to the success of the program and the high level of customer satisfaction it generated, the bank extended the service to its business customers. The widespread success that WTC experienced after implementing POD is clearly seen in the nancial results of the program. In just the 15 months following its implementation for personal checking accounts, the bank experienced signicant revenue improvements. Principal charge off activity during this timeframe was held to within 1% of net overdraft revenue. While the service aspect is not as easy to quantify, overall improvements were apparent in customer satisfaction and operational efciencies. Customer Service and Communication The manual system the bank previously used to manage overdrafts consumed valuable employee time and since it was subjective in its nature, the application was also inefcient. After implementing POD, WTC discovered the benets of a structured, objective procedure for processing NSF items and communicating with account holders regarding NSF matters. Overall, our customers who enrolled in and use the program like the fact that they know their items will be paid, says Rauh. Understandably, people sometimes make errors in their checkbooks. They know they can count on us. The program provides for consistency in application of best practices for all types of checking accounts. It also helps WTC identify troubled customers in order to mitigate potential negative consequences for the customer and any nancial losses for the institution. SMS trained our staff to clearly communicate the program policies to customers. By empowering the customers, they are able to make informed decisions about their nances, and we are able to better manage risk and the customer relationship, adds Rauh. Targeted, specic, and direct communication is critical in managing a successful overdraft program. With a detailed communication strategy like that offered by POD, the bank can communicate the right message at the right time to customers. Typically, 90% of all overdrawn accounts will be brought positive within the rst 10 days following the overdraft event. But now at WTC, according to Rauh, 90% of overdrafts are collected within ve days, proving that the effective customer communication system offered by the POD solution has had a measurable and signicant impact on repayment times at WTC. Risk Management and Public Policy With increased scrutiny from the OTS and other regulatory agencies, banks that offer overdraft protection services must be above reproach in the manner in which these types of programs are offered to customers. Banks have a duciary responsibility to provide services that are sound for both their customers and the institution, its employees and its shareholders. This was a central concern for Washington Trust and a key factor in selecting SMS POD program. Our goal clearly is to help those who have good intentions but have had something go wrong. The system helps us make better decisions. We have a high degree of condence in the program, explains Rauh. POD offers prudent management of an overdraft service through daily monitoring of each individual accounts behavior patterns and reacting to negative changes in those patterns by reducing or removing the overdraft tolerance. This management addresses public policy and minimizes the possibility of the customer getting into overdraft trouble while also controlling risk exposure for the bank. Continuous Improvement Bolstered by the success of Platinum Overdraft, WTC decided to further enhance the existing program by extending it to business accounts, including additional delivery channels, and implementing a new sophisticated tool called Deposit Score
. As Rauh explains, Deposit Score
has given our overdraft program a dramatic boost. Not only
are we able to further enhance customer service by paying more items, but we are able to mitigate principal losses by decreasing or eliminating overdraft limits when such risk factors as negative deposit trends are present. Without Deposit Score
, we would not have been able to take our service to the next level. With the implementation of Deposit Score
, overdraft thresholds are now automatically calculated on a daily basis.
If risk factors are detected, the thresholds are reduced or removed, thus controlling potential principal losses. When those risk factors improve, the customers overdraft threshold is automatically reestablished. The scoring process is based on objective account characteristics and applied to all accounts, both personal and business, ensuring fair treatment of all deposit accounts. In the nine months following the Deposit Score
implementation, WTC has
experienced an 18.2% improvement in items per account and waived fees have decreased by 29.4%. By utilizing sophisticated analytics Deposit Score
has the ability to score customers based on unique characteristics
and automatically increase or decrease overdraft limits based on any changes in those characteristics. Traditional scoring models use factors such as average collected balance, number of overdraft items, and age of account to determine the appropriate overdraft limit. The typical model tends to only allow limited tiers for an overdraft threshold, such as $250 or $500. What makes Deposit Score
different from other programs is that it goes beyond
the stagnant traditional approach and dynamically evaluates the individual account holders setting on an ongoing basis and adjust the overdraft threshold to an appropriate level. Unlike other models on the market that use only industry standards to score an account, Deposit Score
starts with SMS best practice recommendations for the
scoring criteria and enhances the calculation with individual account deposit and overdraft trends. Using the unique behavior of each account provides the ability to establish the right overdraft threshold at the right time for each account holder. The analytics enable an institution to balance the objectives of controlling loss and increasing revenue, thus maximizing overall protability. A Great Partnership Washington Trust Company ultimately found that SMS offered the best and most efcient program for its overdraft protection needs with positive results across the board. We have done a number of projects with Sheshunoff over the years. SMS is a professional organization with good values. This program exemplies these qualities, concludes Rauh. Sheshunoff Management Services 2801 Via Fortuna, Suite 600 | Austin, Texas 78746 | 1.800.477.1772 | www.smslp.com