BEN 610 PROJECT MANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES ANDREW WILLIAMSON By BEN 610 Project Management Principle Assignment Malkeet Singh (n8991294) 1 INTRODUCTION E-courier, founded in 2003 provides courier services with a focus on delivery transparency and automated costumer interaction. A highly advanced system called Advanced information Based Allocation (AIBA) is responsible for managing the overall delivery system of the company. The services provided to the costumer includes: Real time tracking of the parcel. Providing shortest route for the parcel delivery. Door to door service from pick-up to dispatch. Email confirmation within after the parcel is arrived. Online booking and costumer queries. The company started a new project to introduce new technology in the services. They faced a number of problems during the overall implementation of the project. The issues were mainly related to, technology issue, project management, risk management, stakeholder management. The problems and their impacts are discussed in the following sections. PROBLEMS AND CHALLENGES [1]. The companys position in the market was not good in the starting years. Companys policies were unattractive for both employees and customers. There were stories of fraud and breaches in trust in the media including security issues. Company, in the beginning was using traditional ways of delivery system which was unreliable and untrusted. There were cases where loss of packages, delays in delivery time, and even damaged packages were reported.
[2]. The IT solutions that company adopted were difficult to implement because of the following reasons: Technology issue: According to research from Royal Academy of Engineering and the British Computer Society (2004), only 16% of IT projects are considered truly successful. Technical issues give rise to uncertainty in IT projects, especially those utilizing innovative technology and practices using technology. This happened because technology and its use changes rapidly, BEN 610 Project Management Principle Assignment Malkeet Singh (n8991294) 2 and a technical and competitive mistake can produce severe financial loses. E-Courier during the project phase, faced continuing complexity and uncertainty, as they wanted to be innovative and adaptive towards new technologies and their possible applications, in order to ensure that this advantage can be sustained. Project environment: Problems occurred because there were conflicts between the organization environment and the project environment. Within the organization, IT projects find it more difficult to gain support, either financial or other resources from the senior management team as they were making extensive use of technology to manage the entire process of delivery.
[3]. The company had a manual system for costumer service which was inefficient and a lot of time was spent to done task manually. It was difficult to respond to millions of customers queries by limited number of employees. A ticket was generated for each costumers request and a copy was saved in system. As millions of complaints were registered and cleared every day, hundreds of old files, created for each request logs were floating in the system. This not only took up the space but also slow down the entire system, a cost of 10 cents per MB. The company wanted to reduce its dependence on manual processes to enable employees to focus on critical business priorities, as well as to realize time and cost savings.
IMPACTS 1) As the companys reputation was not good, competition started to grow up and number of new small companies started giving competition to them. It affected the status of the company; customers and clients started walking away as new companies were providing better and secured services for the delivery. The costumer services that were being provided were not appreciated by the costumers. Because of the very few employees meant for the management purpose, the records were BEN 610 Project Management Principle Assignment Malkeet Singh (n8991294) 3 generally misplaced and hence costumers were unhappy with the information that was provided to them.
2) As there was uncertainty with the IT solutions, the complexity increased as a result of which project and the project team needed to cope with changing client requirements, because of the lack of awareness of technology and its novel applications. Thus, the scope of project changed frequently as client requirements emerges and changes. The cost and risk of technology used was the varying factors. Because of the nature of IT project, there was no accurate or reliable prediction of return on investment. Thus, it was more difficult to obtain outside (venture capital) funding when compared to a more tangible investment option.
3) The manual system of customer service was too slow and there was no proper way to keep the records of the customers. No specific software was installed because of which the overall support system was lacking perfection. The employees doesnt have administrative rights on their computers, thus were unable to make any system-wide changes Such as routine clean-ups or maintenance tasks to enhance system performance. The manual cleaning process also meant that human errors were introduced, which affects the accuracy and thoroughness of the cleaning process. Thus long manual processes were affecting the services provided to the customers, The company was not getting any positive feedbacks from the customers.
RECOMMENDATIONS & SOLUTIONS Even though the company was focusing on IT solutions, there was strong need to work in various areas of management sectors which are given below: I. Change Management: Correct change management procedures, undertaken at the right can help prevent IT project failures. This would be prevalent in projects that succeeded based on non-IT related factors, BEN 610 Project Management Principle Assignment Malkeet Singh (n8991294) 4 for example complete requirements specifications and avoiding of late changes in specifications. E-Courier had done some accurate and timely market research and recognize a need of change in industry. The company founders assigned the help of an academic one of the worlds top IT experts, to help with the business startup, thereby identifying a new business mentor.
1.1 People: (Hagel and Brown 2005) stated that the teams should be assembled with people who have different perspective, presumably to gain a wider range of opinions and resources, thereby offering a better chance of success. E-Courier took extreme measures to assemble a team with people they believe would bring the most business and technical benefits to the projects. They hired people with complementary skills so that there was no duplication of role within the organization which may have brought potential issues and conflicts. This was managed by building a corporate culture that is focused on providing a good services to the employees that will allow them to provide good services to the costumers. (Beer, Eisenstat et al. 1990) indicated that successful IT projects are one that focus on the employee first and foremost. E-courier focused on employees, acknowledging them to be a service resource and this has created seemingly never-ending possibilities for improved customer service.
1.2 Technology: Software requirements go through a series of changes before the final version of the project. E-courier continuously updated their system as areas for improvements were identified, often by costumers request. Company implemented technological improvements like real-time tracked maps, placing real time traffic information onto the map. For the purpose to accomplish, a software team was hired which was flexible and open to change having extensive relevant experience and tacit knowledge which could be applied to the specific project. (Justin 2006) suggested that IT employees should be a part of body of knowledge to promote best services and BEN 610 Project Management Principle Assignment Malkeet Singh (n8991294) 5 to ensure they are as skilled and as experienced as the management team in driving business change.
II. Stake Holder Management: Stakeholders played significant role in any project because their satisfaction indicated how successful a project is. (Hartman and Books24x 2000) claims that a successful project is one that makes all stakeholders happy. E-courier measures its project success based on end users feedback about their product. Stakeholder management was essential factor for the project, as with the cooperation of stakeholders, project objectives can be achieved (Cleland and King 1988). Communication was the key factor for the better stakeholder management. Managers communicated with their project teams to ensure the positive growth of project. E-courier managed external stakeholders by letting them know the importance of the project and the progress of the project.
III. Risk Management: Risk management is important in overall project management and helps to improve project performance, reduce threats and increase successful outcomes and the exploitation of opportunities and possibilities. E-courier in the initial stage defined the scope of project, its limitations, challenging improved technologies which reduces the risk to great extent. Project managers carried out risk assessment every quarter, helping them to refine existing responses and prompt the development of new responses based on new situations. They had done contingency planning in order to avoid risks. They created backups of their backups, considering scenarios such as power outages by installing backup generators.
IV. Communication Management: Companys communication management had two goals; first to inform stakeholder about their tasks, plan and information about the project and second to create supportive and cooperative culture within the project (Project Management 2013) Communication with the costumers to deal with their complaints and queries was also an essential part of the project. BEN 610 Project Management Principle Assignment Malkeet Singh (n8991294) 6 CONCLUSION The report is designed to highlight the key problems in courier industry. E- Courier, one the biggest courier industry in UK started a project and number of factor influenced the scope of project. Because of the IT nature of the project, it was more uncertain and complex as compared to other project because of the changing technology issue. Based on the research it is concluded that critical success factors (Butler and Fitzgerald 1999) for IT projects include: project plan, technical issues, change management, stakeholder management, risk management and communication management. These factors are important during the whole project cycle, but may have differing implication during different stages of the project cycle. If these areas are managed properly, the complexity will be reduced and the chances of success rates will increase.
(2004). ROYAL ACADEMY OF ENGINEERING: UK wasting billions on IT projects.
Beer, M., et al. (1990). Why change programs don't produce change. UNITED STATES, Harvard Business Review. 68: 158.
Butler, T. and B. Fitzgerald (1999). "Unpacking the systems development process: an empirical application of the CSF concept in a research context." Journal of Strategic Information Systems 8(4): 351-371.
Cleland, D. I. and W. R. King (1988). Project Management handbook. New York, Van Nostrand Reinhold.
Hagel, r. J. and J. S. Brown (2005). Productive friction: how difficult business partnerships can accelerate innovation. United States, Harvard Business Review. 83: 82.
Hartman, F. T. and I. Books24x (2000). Don't park your brain outside: a practical guide to improving shareholder value with SMART management. Newtown Square, Pa, Project Management Institute.
Justin, R. (2006). BCS debate identifies change management as key to the progression of the IT industry. Sutton, Reed Business Information UK: 58.
Project Management, I. (2013). A guide to the project management body of knowledge (PMBOK guide). Newtown Square, Pa, Project Management Institute.