Formwork shall consist of shores, bracings, sides of beams & slabs, bottoms of slabs etc. Including, anchors, hangers, inserts etc. and shall be designed & planned for the work by contractor. Formwork shall be so constructed that vertical adjustments can be made to compensate for settlement using M.S. props only. The contractor shall indicate in his tender the minimum quantity of formwork, staging & scaffolding materials he proposes to mobilize for the work. Fabricated structure steel staging & steel pipe scaffolding shall be used (wood & bamboo staging is not permitted)
(a) Design The design of formwork & its construction & erection is the sole responsibility of contractor. The design shall consider all the loads (vertical & lateral) including live & vibration loadings. Horizontal tubes will not be permitted to carry loads. They shall be used as bracings only & only the vertical tubes will carry the load.
(b) Tolerances for Reinforced concrete Buildings Variation from the plumb. o In the lines & surfaces of columns, piers, walls 5mm per 2.5m, whichever is less. o For exposed corner columns - In any bay or 5 m maximum: 5 mm - In 10 m or more: 10 mm Variation from the level or from the grids indicated on drawings. o In 5 m: 15 mm o In 10 m or more: 25 mm o In buried construction: Twice the above amounts Variation in cross sectional dimensions of columns, beams, piers & similar members. o Minus: 5 mm o Plus: 10 mm Variation in thickness of slabs, walls & similar members o Minus: 5 mm o Plus: 10 mm Footing for columns, walls & similar members. o Variation of dimension in plan - Minus: 10 mm & plus: 50 mm o Misplacement or Eccentricity - 2% of footing width in direction of misplacement not more than 50mm o Reduction in Thickness - 5% of specified thickness subject to maximum of 50 mm 77
Tolerance in other structures shall conform to those given in ACI 347 clause 2.4 of Recommended practice for concrete formwork. Tolerances in fixing anchor bolts shall be as follows : o Anchor bolts without sleeves : + 1.5 mm in plan o Anchor bolts with sleeves : + 5 mm in elevation o Embedded parts : + 5 mm in all directions o For bolts 32 mm dia & above : + 3 mm in all directions o For bolts through 28 mm dia : + 5 mm in all directions
(c) Formwork Requirements Formwork shall be conform to the shapes, lines & dimensions including cambers of concrete as required by design. Ample struts, walers, shores etc. of MS shall be used to hold the formwork in proper position. Formwork shall be strong enough to permit the use of immersion vibrators. Faces coming into contact with concrete shall be free from adhesive grout, plaster, paint or other defeats. All new and used ACROW props and shuttering material shall be maintained in good condition with respect to shape, strength, smoothness of surfaces. Shores supporting successive storage shall be placed directly over those below or be so designed and placed that loads will be transmitted directly to them. Excessive construction camber to compensate for shrinkage, settlement etc. That impair strength of members will not be permitted. Formwork for substructure concrete may be omitted when the given excavation is firm enough to act as formwork. Formwork during any stage of construction showing sign of distortion to such an extent that it does not conform to exact contours as indicated on drawing shall be repositioned and strengthened. Formwork to beams & slabs shall be so erected that the formwork on sides of beams and under the soffits of slabs can be removed without disturbing beam bottoms. Re-propping of beams shall not be done except when props have to be reinstalled to bear construction loads anticipated in excess of design loads. Vertical props shall be supported on wedges or other measures shall be taken whereby props can be gently lowered vertically while striking formwork. If formwork of columns is erected to full height, one side shall be left open & built up in sections as concrete pouring proceeds. Windows may be left for pouring concrete from sides to limit drop of concrete to 1m.
(d) Mould Oil It shall be ensured that faces coming into contact with concrete are perfectly cleaned & two coats of mould oil applied. It shall not become flaky or removed by rain or wash. All corners exposed in finished structure shall be formed with moldings to form chamfers or fillets. The standard dimensions shall be 20mm x 20mm. Vertical construction joins on faces shall be chamfered. Wire ties passing through walls are not allowed, bolts posing through shall be used.
78
(e) Removal of formwork In normal circumstances (when temperatures are above 20C) following striking period shall be used Table 2.2.1 Formwork stripping period for various elements Elements For OPC Walls, columns & vertical side of beams Slabs (props left under) Beam soffits (props left under) Removal of props to slab Span up to 4.5m Span above 4.5m Removal of props to beams Span up to 6m Span above 6m 24 to 48 hrs. 3 days 7 days
7 days 14 days
14 days 21 days
After removing the formwork, if it is found that timber has been embedded in concrete, it shall be removed. Reinforced temporary openings shall be provided to facilitate removal of formwork. Tie rods, clamps which must be removed entirely shall be loosened not earlier than 24 hrs. nor later than 40 hrs. after concrete has been poured. Cutting ties back from faces of walls is not permitted.
2.3.2 MATERIAL SPECIFICATIONS 1. Peri liwa shutter plates
Material- Steel fame and plywood Source/company- PERI Rate- Rs 8000/m 2
Specifications- o The LIWA has been designed for a fresh concrete pressure of 50 kN/m 2
o Total thickness 100mm (85mm steel frame + 15mm ply wood)
2. Plastic shutter plates
Material- Plastic Source/make- NOVA Rate- Rs. 5000/m 2
Specifications- o Can bear loads up to 60 kN/m 2
o Total thickness of 80mm (5mm plastic plate + 75mm plastic projection)
3. Shuttering Oil
Material- Mould Oil Source/make - CERA Chemical Rate- Rs. 78/ lit Coverage- 35 m 2 /lit. 79
Company- ACROW Rate- Rs. 1555/Nos. Specifications- o Closed height: 2300 mm o Open height (max.): 4230 mm o 29 kN safe working load
10. Clamps
(a) Wedge clamp LIWA Used to connect two plates when no filler material is there between two adjacent plates. Company : PERI
(b) Wedge clamp compensation LIWA Company : PERI Used to connect two adjacent plates when filler of max. 5cm size is used in-between two plates.
80
(c) DOMINO Alignment coupler Company : PERI It fastens, aligns and tightens in a single operation. Used for standard panel connections or with fillers up to 120mm wide.
2.3.3 TOOLS & EQUIPMENT USED
Bar bending machine: SPARTAN SBM 42 Bar cutting machine: SPARTAN SCM 42 Transit mixer: SCHWING STETTER Needle vibrator: WACKER NEUSON Plumb Bob Line - Dori Hooked rod for binding wires (Aakdi) Hammer Measure tape Concrete Boom Placer o Model: S 36X (4 section roll and fold system, height 36m) o Specifications :
Table 2.2.2 Boom Placer (S 36X) and Portable pump specifications Concrete Pump Type P1800 Max. Pumping output (m 3 /4) 96 Max. number of strokes / min 19 Max. concrete Pump (bear) 85
Placing Boom S 36X Pumping line diameter (mm) 125 Length of end hoes (m) 4 Reaching height (m) 35.2 Hori. Reach from Centre of slewing axis (m) 31.25 Lifting angle 96 1 st folding angle 180 2 nd folding angle 180 3 rd folding angle 238 Slewing range 2 x 360
2.3.4 ENABLING WORKS Ramp construction House keeping 81
Safety Harness provision Diesel Generator provision (for keeping up vibration during power cutoff )
2.3.5 CONCRETE POUR CARD (FOR TOWER 32 SHEAR WALLS) Table 2.2.3 Concrete Pour card (Shear walls) Date 25/01/2014 Grade of concrete M40 Quantity of concrete 5.4 m 3 Location Tower 32 Are shuttering, Reinf. & Services completed Yes Starting time 4 pm Completion time 4:30 pm Number of cubes taken for testing -- Slump value 120 mm
2.3.6 CONSTRUCTION PROCEDURE Observations for shear walls 4SW12 (plastic formwork) and 4SW22 (PERI formwork) of certain tower (Tower 32) starting from the starter construction till deshuttering have been made. 1. Starter construction In starter construction, one carpenter and 2 helpers have been deployed. It took 2 hours to finish the starters of both the walls. Wooden runners of 50mm (width) x 70mm (depth) are used for fabricating starter. Before fixing the starter, reinforcement is fixed into place which is preceded by removal of wooden pieces used for making shear keys beneath the shear walls. Shear keys are approximately 150mm (length) x 30mm (depth) spaced at 450mm clear spacing (and parallel to length of wall). The wooden runners are cut into required lengths so that the internal corners of starter coincide with the corners of walls as marked on the raft top by surveyors. The alignment of starter is ensured by means of line-dori tied at the ends of walls through rods secured to the reinforcement of wall. Line-dori is tied along one face of the wall. To prevent inward or outward tilting of starter, rods (tied to reinforcement) and wooden strips (nailed to runners) are used. The grade of concrete used for starter has to be one grade higher than grade used for shear wall. Thus M45 grade of concrete is used for starter. Once it is concreted, it is compacted by rodding it through a rod at several locations. 82
This is followed by placing of wooden pieces parallel to length of wall so as to have shear keys with dimensions as mentioned before. These wooden pieces are removed at a later stage.
Figure 2.2.1 Starter arrangement 2. Shuttering The plan (or drawings) of panels to be used for a particular shear wall is rendered to the carpenter so that he becomes aware regarding the panel lengths, numbers and their arrangement. As per the requirement, the PVC pipes are cut down by the labor. The shutter plates are cleaned and formwork releasing agent is applied (2 coats). In case of PERI formwork, the shutter plates are held at the position and are tied to the reinforcement of wall through binding wire (for this purpose, a hole is provided at the top PERI plates). Two such adjacent plates are clamped at three locations by standard wedge clamp (height of each plate=3m). In case of plastic formwork, connections are secured by insertion of plastic handle locks in the slots and rotating them 90 through steel spigot. The connections are secured between 2 adjacent vertical and 2 adjacent horizontal panels (height of each panel=1.24m). The tie rods are provided at the junctions of plates in both formwork systems. These tie rods are put into the sleeves (PVC tube and cone) and are tightened by wingnuts/griplocks. In PERI formwork, wherever the fillers are encountered, the wedge compensation clamp or domino alignment couplers are used (depending upon the filler thickness) to secure connection. Moreover, for the insertion of tie rods, walers are put into place at such locations. Wooden spreaders are placed at about 400mm clear spacing near the top of formwork to prevent inward tilting of formwork. Once erection of formwork is done, they are aligned 83
by placing adjustable props. For checking the plumb, a plumb bob is provided on two perpendicular faces at the ends of wall. To bring the wall into plumb, the props are adjusted accordingly (before concreting and just after concreting). To ensure the horizontality, a line dori is also tied at the top of the wall along one face.
Table 2.2.4 Comparison between PERI and Plastic formworks Sr.no. PERI formwork PLASTIC formwork 1 Difficult to handle since it is heavy (35 kg/m 2 ) Easy to handle since it is light-weight. 2 Productivity is more since number of connections is less. Productivity is less since number of connections are more. 3 Number of lateral props required is less. Number of lateral props required is more. 4 Cost incurred for material and labour is less. Cost incurred for material and labour is more.
3. Concreting and Deshuttering Concreting in shear walls is carried out by Boom placer. Five unskilled labors were deployed for concreting in following manner. o 2 labors- for compaction/vibration of concrete o 1 labor- for delivering concrete through hose. o 2 labors- for adjusting props and tamping at the bottom (to prevent honeycombing)
It took about 30 minutes to concrete both the walls. The concrete pour height was 3 m (opposed to 1.5m as prescribed by IS code). The concrete is poured into 2 layers and each layer compacted by needle vibrator at four locations (2-at boundary elements and 2-in between). The concrete which gets deposited on formwork top is removed by trowel. Once the top layer of concrete is vibrated, shear keys as mentioned before are placed over it (which are removed later on). After about 16 hours of concreting, deshuttering is carried out. Number of labors involved in deshuttering is 3. It takes about 4 hours to deshutter PERI formwork whereas 7 hours for PLASTIC formwork. The pipe use as sleeve was just 1mm thick (instead of 3mm stipulated value) because of which it got broken by concrete pressure thereby leading to sticking up of tie rods inside 84
the wall. Hence, the only resort was to cut off the projecting tie rods (which is not permitted as per contract specifications). After deshuttering, the shear walls are cured through water sprinkling and hessian cloth coverings for 14 days. Also, the verticality and cover adequacy are checked by clients quality department.
2.3.7 MANPOWER EMPLOYED, PRODUCTIVITY AND COST ASPECT 1. Labor wages & Productivity Table 2.2.5 Labor wages and productivity for both formworks Sr. Item Peri Liwa Plastic 1 Labour (nos.) Skilled Helper
2 3
1 2 2 Labour wages (paid by labour contractor) Skilled Helper
230/8 hrs. 200/8 hrs.
250/8 hrs. 180/8 hrs. 3 SPCL pays to labour contractor 110/m 130/m 4 Quantity of formwork payable 25.27 m 21.05 m 5 SPCL paid for labour Rs.2779.7 Rs.2763.5 6 Time taken 10 hrs 21 hrs 7 Productivity (actual) (estimated) 0.525 m/lab/hr 0.375m/lab/hr 0.358/m/lab/hr 0.375m/lab/hr 8 Labour contractor pays to labour Rs.1450 Rs.1601.5 9 Profit of labour contractor Rs.1329.7 Rs.52.69/m Rs.1135.5 Rs.53.94/m 85
10 If SPCL had their own labour then, Profit + overheads/m (Wages: Skilled-300/8 hrs Unskilled-250/8 hrs) [2779.7-1687.5] =Rs.1092.2 =Rs.45.22/m 2736.5-2100 =Rs.636.5 =Rs.30.24/m
2. Rate analysis for Plastic formwork (Shear wall 4SW12) Table 2.2.6 Rate analysis for Plastic formwork Sr.no. Item description Unit Quantity Rate (Rs./Unit) Amount (Rs.) (1) Materials
m 21.05 130 2736.5 Total cost incurred for 22.59 m m 244.75/m 5328.8 Rate quoted in BOQ 567/m (Profit margin + over heads) /m
322.24/m (131.66%)
86
3. Rate analysis for PERI formwork(Shear wall 4SW22) Table 2.2.7 Rate analysis for PERI formwork Sr. No Item Description Unit Quantity Rate (Rs.) Amount (Rs) (1) Materials
-PERI shutter plate & wedge clamps (19 nos.
m
25.8
8000/120
1720 Shuttering oil (2 coats) lit 1.5 78/lit 117 Tie rods (1m) (0.5m) nos. nos. 27 9 83/200 47/200 11.2 2.11 Props nos. 29 1555/100 450.95 Walers (1.98m) (1.2m) kg kg 32.96x5 22.43x7 48/250 48/250 35.48 30.14 Edge walers kg 2.75x7 48/250 3.7 PVC tube m 7.32 14 102.48 PVC cone nos. 48 2.5 120 Wingnut nos. 60 48/100 28.8 (2) Labors m 25.26 110 2778.6 Total cost incurred for 26.25m 211.65/m 5400.46 Rate quoted in BOQ 567/m (Profit margin + over heads) / m 567-211.65. = 366.27/m (175.6%)
4. Rate analysis & Productivity for Concreting Grade of concrete used for shear walls- M 40 Mix design proportion- 1 : 1.9 : 2.47 : 0.36
Here, 320 kg is cement and 100 kg is GGBS. Chemical admixture (ECMAS HP-900): 250 ml per 50 kg of cementitious material.
Cost per m 3 = 320x5.2 + 100x3.128 + 798x0.67 + 622.44x0.6 + 414.96x0.53 + 2.1x54 87
= 3218.2528 Rs/m 3
Concrete volume for 4SW12 o Concrete level up to 2.45 height o Concrete volume= plan area x height = (1.015) x 2.45 = 2.487 m 3 Concrete volume for 4SW22 o Concrete level up to 2.99 m height o Concrete volume= plan area x height = 0.965 x 2.99 = 2.885 m 3
Concrete productivity = 10.59 m 3 /hour
(a) Labor cost
Time taken for concrete for both shear walls is 30 minutes. o No. of labors= 5 o Wages (Rs) = 200/8 hrs. o Labor cost incurred= Rs. 62.5 = Rs. 11.63 / m 3
Total cost / m 3 = Rs. 3229.88/ m 3
Rate quoted in BOQ = Rs. 5456/m 3
(Profit + Overheads) per m 3 = Rs. 2226.12 /m 3 (68.92 %)
5. Rate Analysis for Reinforcement
For Shear wall 4SW12 o Quantity of reinforcement in kg from BBS= 413.91 Kg o Total cost of material= 43 x 413.91= Rs. 17798.13 o Labor cost= Rs. 4.5/kg x 413.91= Rs. 1862.59 o Total cost incurred= Rs. 19660.725 o Now cost per kg= 47.5 Rs/kg o Cost quoted in BOQ= 60.645 Rs./kg o (Profit + Overheads)/kg = 13.145 Rs./kg (27.67 %)
For Shear wall 4SW22 o Reinforcement in kg from BBS = 389.31 kg o Total cost of material= 389.31 kg x 43 Rs/kg= 16740.33 Rs. o Labor cost = Rs. 4.5/kg x 389.31= 1751.89 Rs o Total cost incurred= 18492.22 Rs o (Profit + Overheads)/kg= 13.145 Rs/kg (27.67%)
88
6. Analysis of Total Cost & Profit + Overheads
Table 2.2.8 Analysis of Total Cost & Profit + Overheads for Shear walls Sr. No. Activity Price as per BOQ (Rs.)
2.3.8 INSPECTION AND QUALITY CHECKS 1. Checklist for shuttering
Are all the safety norms being covered as per HSEM process? Check for shuttering for availability and arrangement. Are all the plates / plywood cleaned and polished properly. Type of oil / polish used on the surface of shuttering. Check for suitability, stability, safety & rigidity of assembled forms. Check for provision for service piping. Vertical members-Shear walls o Checking alignment of all vertical members at floor level with respect to grid lines. o Check plumb for vertical members (minimum 2 sides) o Check right angle and diagonals of the vertical members from the top. o Check for alignment with respect to adjacent vertical members. o Check for adequate support as per shattering design o Check for adequate of cover block.