KORAC74 TOO MUCH RIGHTNESS CAN KILL YOU BY RABBI JACK RIEMER I want to study with you today one aspect o the story o Korach and Moses which I must te!! you I ne"er rea!!y appreciated unti! now# Two peop!e ena$!ed me to see this o!d story in a way that I ne"er rea!!y understood it $eore# One was the great Israe!i poet% &ehuda Amichai% and the other was my mentor and riend% Ra$$i 'o!e Ke!man# Amichai has a poem ca!!ed( )*ama+om ,he$o Anu Tsod+im-% .rom the /!ace 'here 'e Are Right% and this is what it says( ).rom the p!ace where we are right .!owers wi!! ne"er grow In the spring# The p!ace where we are right Is hard and tramp!ed 0i+e a yard# 1ut dou$ts and !o"es 2ig up the wor!d 0i+e a mo!e% a p!ow% And a whisper wi!! $e heard in the p!ace 'here the ruined *ouse once stood#-
2o you understand what the poet is saying here3 ).rom the p!ace where we are right% !owers wi!! ne"er grow#- The !and o those who are sure that they are right is hard and unyie!ding# It is more !i+e a stony courtyard than it is !i+e a erti!e ie!d# There are no dou$t in the hearts and minds o those who are certain that they are a!ways right# And there is no !o"e in the hearts o those who are sure that they are comp!ete!y right and that those who disagree with them are comp!ete!y wrong# 1ut things on!y grow where there are dou$ts# 2ou$ts ena$!e us to see what we $e!ie"e Too Much RightnessKorac74 Riemer 4 rom a dierent perspecti"e% and sometimes the interchange $etween what I $e!ie"e and what you $e!ie"e !eads to the $irth o a new idea% that is $etter than either my origina! idea or your origina! idea# And i there is !o"e $etween two peop!e who disagree% that !o"e ena$!es them to !isten to each other5s ideas and to grow rom the interchange# That is what I thin+ the poet means when he says( ).rom the p!ace where we are right% !owers wi!! ne"er grow-# The p!ace where we are sure that we are right% and that on!y we are right% is a co!d and stony ground% a ground on which nothing can e"er grow# Ra$$i 'o!e Ke!man% 6ichrono !i"racha% e7pressed the same truth% not in poetry% $ut in this story% which his daughter% Ra$$i 8aamah Ke!man% reca!!ed to me recent!y# )There was once a young discip!e o a great ra$$inic master who wanted to marry the daughter o a "ery wea!thy $usinessman# The $usinessman agreed to the match% and he agreed to support the young man or a certain num$er o years whi!e he studied% $ut he set down one condition# The young man must study on his own% and not spend any time studying with his ormer teacher# The reason the ather9in9!aw set this condition was that he wanted his son9in9!aw to $e an origina! scho!ar and not :ust a discip!e o some$ody e!se# The young man accepted the condition% $ut o"er time% he ound that he cou!d not a$ide $y it# *e missed his o!d teacher# *e yearned to $e with him and to !earn rom his wisdom# And so% e"ery so oten% when his ather9in9!aw was not around% he wou!d s!ip o to study with his ormer teacher# Too Much RightnessKorac74 Riemer ; 'hen his ather9in9!aw ound out what his son9in9!aw was doing% he was urious# *e said to him% )&ou made an agreement< &ou signed a contract that you wou!d not do this< It was on this condition that I !et you marry my daughter% and it was on this condition that I ha"e supported you a!! these years# &ou $ro+e your word< And thereore% I am no !onger going to support you<- Ra$$i Ke!man said( 'as the ather9in9!aw not right3 The young man had $ro+en his word# 'as his ather9in9!aw not entit!ed to cance! his agreement to support him3 There is no =uestion that the ather9in9!aw was !ega!!y right# Any court that read the agreement wou!d ha"e ound or him# 'as the son9in9!aw not right too3 *e yearned to ha"e the $eneit o his teacher5s wisdom% and so he s!ipped away in secret in order to study with him# Can you $!ame anyone or wanting to study Torah3 'as he not right to do what he did3 The answer is( no# A dea! is a dea!# I you sign an agreement% you ha"e no right to $rea+ it# /eriod# And what a$out the young man5s ormer teacher3 Can you $!ame him or wanting to teach his discip!e3 Can you $!ame him or wanting to he!p this young man deepen his +now!edge o Torah3 Can you $!ame him or wanting to teach his a"orite student% e"en i it had to $e in secret3 'as he not right too3 The answer is( no# The teacher had no !ega! right to encourage his student to $rea+ his contract# That5s c!ear# Ra$$i Ke!man used to say( the ather9in9!aw was right# There is no =uestion a$out that# A dea! is a dea!# The son9in9!aw was wrong> he shou!d not ha"e signed an agreement% and then gone $ac+ on it# ,tudying with a great master may $e a good deed% $ut sti!!% it does not :ustiy $rea+ing your !ega! agreement# And the ormer master that the young man went $ac+ to was wrong too# ?"en though it is hard to Too Much RightnessKorac74 Riemer 4 turn down a student who wants to study with you% you are not supposed to encourage someone to $rea+ his word# 1ut do you +now what3 Ra$$i Ke!man said% )The ather9in9!aw was right% and the son9in9!aw was wrong% and his teacher was wrong% there is no =uestion a$out that# 1ut the Mashiach wi!! on!y come or those who are not right#- I !o"e that answer% don5t you3 1ecause% !i+e &ehudah Amichai5s poem% it warns against the danger o a!ways $eing right# It teaches us that there is a "a!ue in $eing open to the possi$i!ity that the other person may a!so $e right% or at !east part!y right% and that% i you want to grow in understanding and wisdom% you ha"e to $e open to the possi$i!ity that you are on!y part!y right% and that your opponent may a!so $e part!y right# I must te!! you that I ne"er understood one dimension o the story o Korach and Moses unti! I read this poem and this story# ,o% !et me go o"er the story again% e"en though we are a!! ami!iar with it% and thin+ that we understand it% and !et me read it again% this time as a =uarre! $etween two peop!e( one o whom is a$so!ute!y certain that he is comp!ete!y right% and one o whom is open to the possi$i!ity that he :ust might not $e entire!y right# The story $egins with Korach ma+ing an accusation# *e says that a!! the peop!e are e=ua!!y ho!y% and that thereore Moses has no right to ru!e o"er them# *e accuses Moses o arrogance in setting himse! up a$o"e the peop!e# And e"en though the traditiona! commentators a!! agree that this was :ust demagoguery% and that he did not mean what he was saying@that it was :ust a way to ire up the peop!e and get them to $e on his side 9 !et us grant or a moment that Korach :ust might ha"e $een sincere% and that he might ha"e meant what he was saying# Too Much RightnessKorac74 Riemer A 'hat is Moses5s reaction to this accusation3 The Torah says% )Bayishma Moshe% "ayipo! a! pana"-@that when Moses heard this accusation% he e!! upon his ace# 'hat does that mean3 I used to thin+ that Moses e!! upon his ace in e7haustion or in disappointment# Ater a!! he has done or this peop!e 9 this is the way they treat him3 I a!ways thought that he e!! upon his ace in e7haustion and in despair# That is what I thought the passage meant# 1ut one o the commentators@orgi"e me $ut at the moment I don5t remem$er which one@one o the commentators says that )Moses e!! upon his ace- means that Moses went into himse!# *e c!osed his eyes to what was going on around him or a ew moments% and !oo+ed $ac+ o"er his !ie to see i there was any truth to this accusation# *ad he perhaps !orded o"er the peop!e more than he shou!d ha"e3 *ad he perhaps raised himse! o"er the peop!e improper!y3 And on!y then% on!y ater he had e7amined his conscience% and con"inced himse! that he had not done any o the things o which he was $eing accused% on!y then did he stand up and answer the accusations o Korach# Korach may ha"e $een sure that he was right# Moses was not so sure# Moses in"ites Korach and his cohorts to come orward and :oin in a test# *e says% )&ou each ta+e pans and put ire and incense in them% and Aaron wi!! do the same thing% and !et us see which pan Cod wi!! respond to#- I a!ways assumed that Moses was sure that Cod wou!d respond to Aaron5s pan% and that is why he oered this test# 1ut the story does not necessari!y ha"e to $e read that way# /erhaps what it means is that Moses meant it to $e a rea! test% that Moses was content to !et Cod decide who was the rightu! !eader% and that i the test had come out in a"or o Korach and his cohorts% he wou!d ha"e $een a$!e to accept that# Then% urther on in the story% Moses sends a message to the re$e!s who ha"e risen up against him# *e says to them% )Come up and !et us ta!+# /erhaps we can arri"e Too Much RightnessKorac74 Riemer D at some +ind o a compromise#- And they answer% )'e wi!! not go up< 'e ha"e nothing to say to you# 'e are right and you are wrong# That5s it# ,ett!ed#- Rashi puts it "ery we!!# *e says that $ecause they wou!d not go up% thereore they went down# Their sin was not so much re$e!!ing against Moses# Their sin was reusing to e"en ta!+ to him to see i their dispute cou!d somehow $e reso!"ed# And it was or this 9 or their certainty that they and on!y they were right 9 that Korach and his a!!ies were destroyed# Rightness can +i!! you% i you thin+ it is a!! on your side# 0et me spe!! this !esson out% irst as it app!ies to the peop!e who !i"e in Israe!% and then as it app!ies to each one o us who are here today# Israe! is terri$!y di"ided and the di"ision is $etween peop!e on $oth sides who are sure that a!! the right is on their side# The secu!ar Eews are right> they rea!!y are% when they say that the charedim shou!d carry their air share o the $urdens o citi6enship# They are right when they say that our $!ood is not cheaper than yours% and that i you are citi6ens% you must $ear the $urdens o citi6enship% :ust as we do# They are right# There is no =uestion a$out that# 1ut they are not entire!y right# They need to rea!i6e that i it were not or those who studied the Torah down through the centuries% there wou!d $e no state o Israe! today# They need to +now that i it were not or the pious peop!e who wrote their =uestions in *e$rew and who recei"ed their answers in *e$rew% there wou!d $e no *e$rew or the modern Eews to re"i"e# They need to +now that they are right% $ut not comp!ete!y right# Too Much RightnessKorac74 Riemer 7 And the *aredim must ee! the same way# In what other state in the wor!d cou!d they ee! ree to pic+et and to protest on $eha! o their right to o$ser"e the Torah as they understand it% as they are in Israe!3 In what other state in the wor!d cou!d they demand and recei"e the +ind o support that their schoo!s and their students recei"e in Israe!3 ,hou!d not a measure o gratitude come with this support that they recei"e3 And do they not ha"e an o$!igation to respect the rights and the needs o those who do not see things the way they do3 They may $e right% $ut as 'o!e Ke!man said( The mashiach wi!! on!y come or the sa+e o those who are not right% or at !east or the sa+e o those who do not c!aim that a!! the right is on their side% and none is on the side o the other# .or nothing grows in a society that thin+s that way# And so it is with the haw+s in Israe! who sincere!y $e!ie"e that the do"es are endangering the security o the state% and so it is with the do"es in Israe! who sincere!y $e!ie"e that the haw+s are endangering the security o the state# 1oth sides need to !isten to the partia! truth o the other side% and $oth sides need to grant the partia! truth o the other side% or i they cannot !isten to each other% the state wi!! $e undermined more $y that than $y their dierent points o "iew< 0isten to how the 'omen o the 'a!! ight or their right to pray their way at the 'a!! and how they ca!! those who o$:ect names% and !isten to how those who ha"e a!ways prayed at the wa!! their way and who are oended $y these women ca!!ing them names# I you do% you wi!! understand why one wise charedi ra$$i whom I +now says that Cod% who dwe!!s on the other side o the 'a!!% must $e groaning at the $ad $eha"ior o them $oth# 0et us mo"e rom ta!+ing a$out Israe!% or I ne"er ee! "ery comorta$!e :udging Israe! rom here# 0et us mo"e rom :udging Israe! and !et us !oo+ at ourse!"es# Too Much RightnessKorac74 Riemer F 0isten to the ierce de$ate that goes on within our own community# 0isten to the name9ca!!ing that goes on $etween the groups in Eewish !ie# 0isten to how one side says that E ,treet is a traitorous organi6ation and shou!d not $e a!!owed to spea+ to our young peop!e% and !isten to how the other side says that AI/AC is a puppet o the Israe!i go"ernment that shou!d not $e a!!owed to spea+ to our youth# 0isten to how $oth groups on so many issues insist that a!! the right is on their side% and that their opponents are comp!ete!y wrong# And remem$er &ehudah Amicha5s warning( 8othing grows in soi! !i+e this# 8othing grows in a p!ace where we are comp!ete!y right and our opponents are comp!ete!y wrong# It is easy to critici6e the name9ca!!ing and the di"isi"eness that goes on in Israe!# It is easy to denounce the ways in which the do"es and the haw+s% the secu!arists and the charedim% the !i$era!s and the conser"ati"es treat each other there# 1ut that is a cheap shot% or those o us who do not !i"e there# Instead o doing that% !et us !oo+ into our own $eha"ior here at home# *ow many o us !i"e in ami!ies in which parents and chi!dren dismiss each other% or denigrate each other% or ca!! each other names% instead o !istening to each other and !earning rom each other3 *ow many o us $e!ong to organi6ations that dup!icate each other% and that ought to merge with each other% $ut are una$!e to do so% $ecause each $e!ie"es that a!! right is with them% and none is with the other side3 The story o Korach "ersus Moses is a story that is a!! too re!e"ant% that is painu!!y re!e"ant% in our time# I gi"e Korach the $eneit o the dou$t and $e!ie"e that he rea!!y $e!ie"ed he was right# 1ut I ho!d him responsi$!e or $e!ie"ing that on!y he was right# That was his sin% and it is oten ours# ,o !et us !earn today the art o compromise# 0et us !earn today the art o !istening to those with whom we disagree to see i we can ind the +erne! o truth within Too Much RightnessKorac74 Riemer G their arguments# .or i we can !earn to do that% our arguments with each other wi!! $e more persuasi"e% and the resu!ts o our disputes wi!! $e more producti"e# 0et me te!! you one more word which I !earned rom Ra$$i 'o!e Ke!man# I remem$er how once he was arguing on $eha! o the concepts o p!ura!ism and mutua! respect% and someone cha!!enged him# ,omeone stood up and said( )Can you p!ease te!! me where the idea o p!ura!ism is ound in the c!assic Eewish sources3 'here does it say that we shou!d $e respectu! to those who are against the "a!ues that we $e!ie"e in3- I cou!d ha"e answered that =uestion with ha! a do6en sources% and I am sure that 'o!e cou!d ha"e too# 1ut this what he said( )The act that you can stand up and as+ that =uestion% and that no$ody says( 'ho are you to $e so presumptuous as to spea+ in the name o the tradition3 And the act that I can answer this =uestion% and no$ody says( 'ho are you to $e so presumptuous as to answer in the name o the tradition is in itse! the answer to your =uestion#- And he was right# It is good to tra"e! through !ie in the company o those who see+ the truth% or you can !earn rom $eing with them# It is hard to tra"e! through !ie in the company o those who possess@or who thin+ that they possess a!! the truth% or they are not open to !earning and thereore they cannot teach# 0et me remind you o what we say and what we do e"ery time we inish a $oo+ o the Torah# 'e stand or the !ast words% and we wish each other we!!# 'e say to each other( )*a6a+% ha6a+% "initcha6e+-# And this is what I $e!ie"e that $!essing rea!!y means# It means -May you $e strong% and may I $e strong% and may we strengthen each other-# That is true p!ura!ism# Too Much RightnessKorac74 Riemer 1H And thereore% this is my prayer on the ,a$$ath when we read the archetypa! story o what happens when peop!e ight o"er who is right in the Torah( the story o Korach and Moses# May the $!essing that we say each time we inish a $oo+ o the Torah come true in our organi6ations% in our synagogues% in our homes% and in our !i"es# May we not $e so sure that we% and on!y we% possess a!! the right and that those we disagree with possess none o the right% or as Korach and his cohorts !earned( $eing too right can $e !etha!# And to this% !et us a!! say( Amen#